Boycotts and Backlash: Canadian Opposition to Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) Movements from South Africa to Israel
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
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`F>0)3!()*!8&62-()06![6",()%3!('! H6,,!('!4#))(!/#F-0,,3!&-6!(*70)0'&=(&#=!#<!&-6!@)'&0&>&6!#<!D#,0&0%(,!\%#)#7$P!?)*!#<! %#>='63!7$!(%(*670%!6M26=06)%6!H#>,*!)#&!-(56!A66)!&-6!'(76!H0&-#>&!&-6!%=0&0%(,! (*5#%(%$!#<!&-6!C=(*>(&6!8&>*6)&'U!?''#%0(&0#)!()*!/GD\!ab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cd! 8()%&0#)'!PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP!ab! B0)()%0(,!8()%&0#)'!()*!&-6!Yefg!/=0'0'!PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP!gg! 40*!8()%&0#)'!\)*!?2(=&-60*h!PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP!bY! 4A&:$.%(M?(NA&$(G+.#(EG@(!'$>&--<(G+O(555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555(PL! 40'=>2&0)F!&-6!/0=%>,(&0#)!#<!/(20&(,!PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP!bg! <%+5+=$%'>+-%+**)'999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999'?@! A$/.)*=.5*'999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999'?;! B"5%*$+5)'999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999';C! 8-(20)F!N/#77#)!86)'6O!PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP!fY! >AB'"5#'D+==+5'B.5).'999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999';?! "48!()*!\%#)#70%!86,<R@)&6=6'&!PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP!ea! 9&%$(2,+?(@+>$A(!3%6'&(4&#.(@$>/<(5555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555(QR! 4A&:$.%(H?(2A.(!S4F(@!42TF(&*/($A.(4&*&/6&*(U+7.1.*$(&0&6*#$(@+>$A(!3%6'&*( !:&%$A.6/(55555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555(QV! L-6!?W/!('!Z6<6=6)%6!D#0)&!<#=!&-6!?)&0R?2(=&-60*!;#5676)&!PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP!ee! 8?/LG!()*!&-6![(A#>=!;#5676)&!PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP!YKd! 40'%02,0)0)F!&-6!?)&0R?2(=&-60*!;#5676)&!PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP!YYY! 4A&:$.%(I?(2A.(@+>$A(!3%6'&(8+""<(6*(4&*&/&(555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555(BBQ!