DOCSLIB.ORG

A Comparative Theological Reflection on Dalit Theology's Service And

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Comparative Theological Reflection on Dalit Theology's Service And Liberative Service: A Comparative Theological Reflection on Dalit Theology's Service and Swami Vivekananda's Seva Author: Christopher Robert Conway Persistent link: http://hdl.handle.net/2345/bc-ir:103548 This work is posted on eScholarship@BC, Boston College University Libraries. Boston College Electronic Thesis or Dissertation, 2014 Copyright is held by the author, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise noted. Boston College The Graduate School of Arts and Sciences Department of Theology LIBERATIVE SERVICE: A COMPARATIVE THEOLOGICAL REFLECTION ON DALIT THEOLOGY’S SERVICE AND SWAMI VIVEKANANDA’S SEVA a dissertation by CHRISTOPHER ROBERT CONWAY submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy August 2014 © Copyright by Christopher Robert Conway 2014 ii Liberative Service: A Comparative Theological Reflection on Dalit Theology’s Service and Swami Vivekananda’s Seva Christopher Robert Conway Dr. Catherine Cornille Abstract: This dissertation offers a comparative theological reflection on Dalit Christian theology—a contextual, liberation theology rooted in the Dalit communities’ experiences of caste-based oppression—and Swami Vivekananda—the late 19th c. Neo-Vedantin and founder of the Ramkrishna Math and Mission. It seeks to provide a model of Dalit liberative service that attends to the theology’s objectives—identity affirmation and a liberative social vision—works to foster liberative partnerships beyond the Dalit Christian community, and responds to the critical, but constructive assessment of Dalit theology offered by its present generation of theologians. As a work in comparative theology, it does so through a close, reflective reading of Swami Vivekananda, his Practical Vedanta, and his own reworking of sevā (devotional service). The intent is not to present Vivekananda as a corrective, but rather to see newly and understand differently the dimensions of liberative service that are made manifest by seeing and understanding how sevā performs in Vivekananda’s thought and how it there leads to spiritual and social liberation. These dimensions include recovering by uncovering the imago Dei in Dalit theology, re-presenting liberative service as representing the Kingdom of God, and service understood as doubly and mutually liberating. While Chapter Five presents the fruits of this comparative theological reflection on Dalit Christian theology and Swami Vivekananda, the preceding four chapters provide the necessary foundation for this engagement. The first and second chapters address the iii historical and theological development of Dalit Christian theology presenting its origins in the Modern Maharashtran Dalit Movement and the Indian Christian context, respectively. The third and fourth examine Vivekananda’s development of Practical Vedanta and sevā. Together they provide the content from which and through which this comparative theological reflection occurs. iv Acknowledgements I have had the good fortune to have been accompanied by so many fine folks throughout this dissertation. Their guidance and support sustained me during the tough times, and their humor and joy provided me with many good times as well. As a collective they have seen me through to this point, and I so am grateful. As individuals the have shaped, challenged, and comforted me, and so am I am blessed to have had them alongside of me. Let me begin by thanking my committee without whom this dissertation would not have been possible: my director Dr. Catherine Cornille and my readers Drs. Francis X. Clooney, S.J. and Roberto Goizueta. Their support for and insight into this project has been immense as has their patience and kindness been towards me. I was fortunate to have such a distinguished class of scholars serving on my committee, but even more fortunate to have such a remarkable class of persons. Thank you also to my CT professors and classmates at Boston College for great conversations and friendships: Professors Ruth Langer, John Makransky, and Jim Morris; my current classmates Gregory Baker, Tim Carey, Stephanie Corigliano, Won-Jae Hur, Neil Hutton, Kevin Johnson, Emma O’Donnell, Jillian Stout Maxey, Glenn Willis, and Jen Wade; and those who have gone on Bede Bidlack, Karen Enriquez, and Bagus Laksana, S.J. The BC CT area also provided funding for my research in India for which I am most grateful. A special thanks to Erik Ranstrom with whom I entered this program and who has been a great friend ever since. Thank you to my many wonderful professors and classmates in the BC Theology department, and especially Professors M. Shawn Copeland, Mary Ann Hinsdale, Fred Lawrence, Jim Kennan, S. J., John McDargh, Erik Owens, Steve Pope, and Margaret Schatkin; and classmates Kim Bauser, Tom Fraatz, Daryn Henry, Megan McCabe, Autumn Ridenour, and Bobby Rivera. Thank you also to all the members of my cohort. Thank you to my current flatmates: Kirstin Farchaus, Aaron Fix, Amanda Gallinat, and our Boston Terrier Maebe. One could not ask for better persons to live with. Thank you to my former Newman Housemates: Kevin Ahearn, Rob Broderick, Megan Courtney, John Edwards, Nichole Flores-Henry, Meghan Lovett, Stephen Okey, Amanda Osheim, Nicole Reibe, and Aaron Taylor. It was a joy to live in community with you. Thank you to my friends in the wider Boston College community including my regular noontime basketball group, Dr. Craig Burns, and members of BC Econ Department: Samson Alva, Rosella Calvi, Farooq Pasha, Geoff Sanzenbacher, and Meg Skira. And to my friends in the Great Boston Area: Doug Ballas, Alex Daigle, John Henderson, Ann and Justin Palmer, Iyar Mazar, Liz Shea, and V. Lee Stephenson. v Thank you to my professors and classmates from Princeton Theological Seminary: Professors Luis Rivera-Pagan, Herman Tull, and Richard Fox Young, and my classmates Jessica Bratt, Jamey Heit, Scott Haile, Amanda Ihan Joe Kramp, Larry Stratton, and Clay Stauffer. A special thanks to Jeff Meyers, my pastor and friend, and Pangernungba and his family, who first introduced to me to Dalit theology and hosted me in Nagaland. Thank you as well to all those from Georgetown University. Thank you to the faculty and staff at United Theological College in Bangalore: Professors Peniel Rajkumar and Joseph Dayam Prabhakar both of whom were very generous with their time; Jai Singh and Balakrishnan Kathamuthu and his family for their hospitality and prayers. They all made my time in India productive and transformative. Thank you also to Chinna Devaraj and Swami Tyagananda both who from Boston provided me with many contacts in India. Thank you to all my friends from Louisville, KY: Joseph Ardery, Omar Kahn, Chris Kosfled, Greg May, Chris Stege, Greg Wirtzberger and Andrew Wobbee. A special thanks the Agrawal family: Arpit, Nirmesh, Nirmala, and Mahesh who first introduced me to the beauty and truth in Hinduism. Thank you to Margaret Nuzzolese whose support and encouragement saw me through to the end and for whom I am ever thankful. To the many others I have forgotten, my thanks and my apologies. Finally, thank you to my family whose love made this all possible. My sister Margaret, my brother-in-law Jack, my niece Eleanor, my nephew John, and my grandmother Ruth. To my father, Peter, who has been my rock, and to my mother, Lorrie, a fount of love, I dedicate this dissertation: non potest ut filius istarum lacrimarum pereat. vi vii Table of Contents Abstract . iii Acknowledgements . v Introduction Dalit Theology: Then and Now . 1 Why Swami Vivekananda? . 6 Swami Vivekananda, Dalit Theology, Comparative Theology . 8 Swami Vivekananda, Dalit Theology, and I . 9 Conclusion the Road Ahead . 13 Chapter One In the Beginning: The Origins of Dalit Theology and the ‘Dalit’ of Dalit Christianity Introduction . 17 Towards the Beginning of ‘a’ Theology . 18 From Whence Dalit Theology: The History of a Beginning . 20 The Maharashtran Influence: The ‘Dalit’ of Dalit Christianity Jyotiba Phule: Recovering a History . 30 Dr. B. R. Ambedkar: Raising a Conscious . 40 Dalit Sahitya: Making a Name . 55 The Dalit Panthers: Taking it to the Streets . 65 Dalit Christian Theology: Taking a Historical Consciousness and a Name to the Church . 72 Conclusion . 73 ix Chapter Two Dalit Christian Theology and Pathos: The Painful Need for a Pain-filled Theology Introduction . 75 Looking Back and Looking Ahead . 76 A New Way of Doing Indian Christian Theology The Mass Movement of Dalit Conversion . 79 The Rise of (Traditional) Indian Christian Theology . 85 Dalit Theology: A Response to Indian Christian Theology and ‘Other Theologies’ . 92 Dalit Theology and Dalit Identity . 101 A Suffering Identity . 107 The Problem with the Pathos Paradigm . 118 Moving Forward Dalit Theology in a Comparative Key . 131 Conclusion . 136 Chapter Three Swami Vivekananda’s Practical and Synthetic Vedanta Introduction . 139 Swami Vivekananda: Biographical Sketch . 144 Family and Schooling (1863- 1881) . 145 With the Brāhmos and Sri Ramakrishna (1881 – 1886) . 151 After Ramakrishna: The Math and Travels through India (1886 – 1892) . 160 Swami Vivekananda Abroad: The United States and England (1893 – 1897) . 167 x Swami Vivekananda and Vedānta: Synthetic Vedānta and Practical Vedānta as Synthetic Vedānta . 170 Vedānta as Practical Vedanta . 178 Practical Vedanta and Ethics . 182 Practical Vedanta and Adhikāra . 197 Conclusion . 209 Chapter Four Jīva Sevā: Swami Vivekananda’s Program of Social and Spiritual Uplift Introduction . 213 The Origins of Jīva Sevā . 214 Jīva Sevā: The Development of an Idea . 234 Jīva Sevā: A Reworking of Sevā in Theory and Practice . 252 Vivekananda’s Sevā and Vaiṣṇavism . 257 Jīva Sevā: Identity Affirmation and Liberative Social Vision Identity Affirmation . 270 Liberative Social Vision . 277 Conclusion . 285 Chapter Five Dalit Liberative Service and Swami Vivekananda’s Sevā: A Comparative Theological Reflection Introduction . 287 Dalit Theology in the Twenty-first Century . 288 In The Beginning: Dalit Theology and the Modern Dalit Movement . 292 Rethinking Dalit Theology in and for the Twenty-first Century: Identity and Exclusivism . 299 xi Dalit Theology and Strategic Essentialism . 308 Dalit Theology and Methodological Exclusivism .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Portland Daily Press: January 25,1886
    ...— -______-—■ — ■■ ....... L I THE 1 BY A SNOW SLIDE. OHIO LEGISLATURE. FOREIGN. FROZEN SOUTH. FROM incorporation of unions requires State action. BURIED RPECIAL NOTICES. THE PORTLAND DAILY PRESS, WASHINGTON. favor this in connection with laws compelling em- the ployers and organizations to arbitrate their differ- Over the to the Florida Fruit Crop Published every day (Sundays excepted) by A Division of the Senate the of Damage ences as strikes are ruinous to all concerned.” lik Three Men Found Dead in a Wrecked Cermany Agitating Question INSURANCE. conclusion he “do not too conclude Cases. Will Not Exceed Two Millions. PORTLAND PUBLISHING COMPANY, Maine Postmasters Appointed, says, hastily Hamilton County Silver that all public men are enemies. You make Cabin in Colorado. Coinage. At 97 Exchange Street, Portland, Me. your the Senate Jacksonville, Fla., Jan. Washington, Jan. 23.—These postmasters It hard to serve you when you us all under Cincinnati, O., Jan. 23.-In 23.—Referring Year. To mall sub- place W.D. LITTLE & Terms—Eight Dollars a have been appointed for Maine offices to- suspicion.” much excitement prevailed over to the damages by the recent freezing in CO., scribers, Seven Dollars a Year, II paid in advance. Mitchell favors the first six meas- yesterday, Demonstrations Held in Athens Congressman Presented by Their of the Florida, the Times-Union tomorrow morn- Rates of Advertising—One inch of space day: ures. opposes the seventh and Is doubtful of the Sickening Sights the majority and minority reports 31 EXCHANGE STREET, have the of column, or twelve lines nonpareil Rome-E. S. Phillips. eighth.
    [Show full text]
  • THE DEVADASI SYSTEM: Temple Prostitution in India
    UCLA UCLA Women's Law Journal Title THE DEVADASI SYSTEM: Temple Prostitution in India Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/37z853br Journal UCLA Women's Law Journal, 22(1) Author Shingal, Ankur Publication Date 2015 DOI 10.5070/L3221026367 Peer reviewed eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California THE DEVADASI SYSTEM: Temple Prostitution in India Ankur Shingal* Introduction Sexual exploitation, especially of children, is an internation- al epidemic.1 While it is difficult, given how underreported such crimes are, to arrive at accurate statistics regarding the problem, “it is estimated that approximately one million children (mainly girls) enter the multi-billion dollar commercial sex trade every year.”2 Although child exploitation continues to persist, and in many in- stances thrive, the international community has, in recent decades, become increasingly aware of and reactive to the issue.3 Thanks in large part to that increased focus, the root causes of sexual exploita- tion, especially of children, have become better understood.4 While the issue is certainly an international one, spanning nearly every country on the globe5 and is one that transcends “cul- tures, geography, and time,” sexual exploitation of minors is perhaps * J.D., Class of 2014, University of Chicago Law School; B.A. in Political Science with minor in South Asian Studies, Class of 2011, University of Califor- nia, Los Angeles. Currently an Associate at Quinn Emanuel Urquhart and Sul- livan, LLP. I would like to thank Misoo Moon, J.D. 2014, University of Chicago Law School, for her editing and support. 1 Press Release, UNICEF, UNICEF calls for eradication of commercial sexual exploitation of children (Dec.
    [Show full text]
  • Vol 11, Issue 1 December 2018 Complete Book Reviews
    Vol 11, Issue 1 December 2018 Complete Book Reviews Editor: Sean Haylock Contents Peter Beaglehole What Matters?: Talking Value in Australian Culture by Julian Meyrick, Robert Phiddian and Tully Barnett Arpita Chakrabarti and Inter/Nationalism: Decolonizing Native America and Anindya Sekhar Purakayastha Palestine by Steven Salaita Melinda Graefe Poetry of the Earth: Mapuche Trilingual Anthology, edited by Jaime Luis Huenún Villa, Spanish into Mapudungun translation by Víctor Cifuentes Palacios, Spanish into English Translation by Juan Garrido Salgado, Steve Brock and Sergio Holas Saba Idris Biopolitics and Memory in Postcolonial Literature and Culture by Michael R. Griffiths Sirsha Nandi Africa’s Narrative Geographies: Charting the Intersections of Geocrticism and Postcolonial Studies by Dustin Crowley Jaydeep Sarangi Four Gardens and Other Poems by Malsawmi Jacob Mandy Treagus Georges Baudoux’s Jean M’Barai: The Trepang Fisherman, translated and with a critical introduction by Karin Speedy Amelia Walker Dalit Voice: Literature and Revolt by Sharankumar Limbale and Jaydeep Sarangi Amelia Walker Faithfully, I Wait by Jaydeep Sarangi Complete Book Reviews. Transnational Literature Vol. 11 no. 1, December 2018. http://fhrc.flinders.edu.au/transnational/home.html Julian Meyrick, Robert Phiddian and Tully Barnett, What Matters?: Talking Value in Australian Culture (Monash University Publishing, 2018) What Matters? is a product of the Laboratory Adelaide, a research project that began with the task of finding better ways to communicate the experience of culture (attending/curating/making an exhibition/concert/library/performance/museum/etc.) to policy makers in Australia (deciding how to, how much, and why?). The authors respond to the rise of ‘metric power’ (vi), where cultural experiences are measured quantitatively, or ‘datafied’ (viii).
    [Show full text]
  • LCSH Section K
    K., Rupert (Fictitious character) Motion of K stars in line of sight Ka-đai language USE Rupert (Fictitious character : Laporte) Radial velocity of K stars USE Kadai languages K-4 PRR 1361 (Steam locomotive) — Orbits Ka’do Herdé language USE 1361 K4 (Steam locomotive) UF Galactic orbits of K stars USE Herdé language K-9 (Fictitious character) (Not Subd Geog) K stars—Galactic orbits Ka’do Pévé language UF K-Nine (Fictitious character) BT Orbits USE Pévé language K9 (Fictitious character) — Radial velocity Ka Dwo (Asian people) K 37 (Military aircraft) USE K stars—Motion in line of sight USE Kadu (Asian people) USE Junkers K 37 (Military aircraft) — Spectra Ka-Ga-Nga script (May Subd Geog) K 98 k (Rifle) K Street (Sacramento, Calif.) UF Script, Ka-Ga-Nga USE Mauser K98k rifle This heading is not valid for use as a geographic BT Inscriptions, Malayan K.A.L. Flight 007 Incident, 1983 subdivision. Ka-houk (Wash.) USE Korean Air Lines Incident, 1983 BT Streets—California USE Ozette Lake (Wash.) K.A. Lind Honorary Award K-T boundary Ka Iwi National Scenic Shoreline (Hawaii) USE Moderna museets vänners skulpturpris USE Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary UF Ka Iwi Scenic Shoreline Park (Hawaii) K.A. Linds hederspris K-T Extinction Ka Iwi Shoreline (Hawaii) USE Moderna museets vänners skulpturpris USE Cretaceous-Paleogene Extinction BT National parks and reserves—Hawaii K-ABC (Intelligence test) K-T Mass Extinction Ka Iwi Scenic Shoreline Park (Hawaii) USE Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children USE Cretaceous-Paleogene Extinction USE Ka Iwi National Scenic Shoreline (Hawaii) K-B Bridge (Palau) K-TEA (Achievement test) Ka Iwi Shoreline (Hawaii) USE Koro-Babeldaod Bridge (Palau) USE Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement USE Ka Iwi National Scenic Shoreline (Hawaii) K-BIT (Intelligence test) K-theory Ka-ju-ken-bo USE Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test [QA612.33] USE Kajukenbo K.
    [Show full text]
  • Book Review: "Dalit Theology and Dalit Liberation: Problems, Paradigms and Possibilities" by Peniel Rajkumar
    Journal of Hindu-Christian Studies Volume 25 Article 13 November 2012 Book Review: "Dalit Theology and Dalit Liberation: Problems, Paradigms and Possibilities" by Peniel Rajkumar Sathianathan Clarke Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.butler.edu/jhcs Part of the Religion Commons Recommended Citation Clarke, Sathianathan (2012) "Book Review: "Dalit Theology and Dalit Liberation: Problems, Paradigms and Possibilities" by Peniel Rajkumar," Journal of Hindu-Christian Studies: Vol. 25, Article 13. Available at: https://doi.org/10.7825/2164-6279.1519 The Journal of Hindu-Christian Studies is a publication of the Society for Hindu-Christian Studies. The digital version is made available by Digital Commons @ Butler University. For questions about the Journal or the Society, please contact [email protected]. For more information about Digital Commons @ Butler University, please contact [email protected]. Clarke: Book Review: "Dalit Theology and Dalit Liberation: Problems, Paradigms and Possibilities" by Peniel Rajkumar BOOK REVIEWS Dalit Theology and Dalit Liberation: Problems, Paradigms and Possibilities. Peniel Rajkumar. Farnham, UK: Ashgate, 2010, 224 + xi pages. DALIT theology is a context-specific the “purity and pollution theory.” (pp. 7-19). expression of people’s God-talk that has real One needs to wait for his constructive consequences for the lives of marginalized contribution to detect the similarities between communities in India. Founded in the good the Indian ritually-based social division and the news that a new world order has been fractured socio-religious context of first announced and initiated by Jesus Christ, century Palestine. The healing dimensions of ‘broken’ men and women, who were ‘crushed’ Jesus’ work in the bible stories thus readily and and ‘rent asunder’ by the caste system (These fittingly become relevant in addressing the three terms are most commonly used as English present day caste-divide in the Indian situation.
    [Show full text]
  • The Grace of God and the Travails of Contemporary Indian Catholicism Kerry P
    Journal of Global Catholicism Volume 1 Issue 1 Indian Catholicism: Interventions & Article 3 Imaginings September 2016 The Grace of God and the Travails of Contemporary Indian Catholicism Kerry P. C. San Chirico Villanova University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://crossworks.holycross.edu/jgc Part of the Asian History Commons, Asian Studies Commons, Catholic Studies Commons, Christian Denominations and Sects Commons, Christianity Commons, Comparative Methodologies and Theories Commons, Comparative Philosophy Commons, Cultural History Commons, Digital Humanities Commons, Hindu Studies Commons, History of Christianity Commons, History of Religion Commons, History of Religions of Eastern Origins Commons, History of Religions of Western Origin Commons, Inequality and Stratification Commons, Intellectual History Commons, Liturgy and Worship Commons, Missions and World Christianity Commons, Oral History Commons, Other Anthropology Commons, Place and Environment Commons, Politics and Social Change Commons, Practical Theology Commons, Quantitative, Qualitative, Comparative, and Historical Methodologies Commons, Race and Ethnicity Commons, Race, Ethnicity and Post-Colonial Studies Commons, Regional Sociology Commons, Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion Commons, Rural Sociology Commons, Social and Cultural Anthropology Commons, Social History Commons, Sociology of Culture Commons, Sociology of Religion Commons, and the South and Southeast Asian Languages and Societies Commons Recommended Citation San Chirico, Kerry P. C. (2016) "The Grace of God and the Travails of Contemporary Indian Catholicism," Journal of Global Catholicism: Vol. 1: Iss. 1, Article 3. p.56-84. DOI: 10.32436/2475-6423.1001 Available at: https://crossworks.holycross.edu/jgc/vol1/iss1/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by CrossWorks.
    [Show full text]
  • Dalit Theology and Indian Christian History in Dialogue: Constructive and Practical Possibilities
    religions Article Dalit Theology and Indian Christian History in Dialogue: Constructive and Practical Possibilities Andrew Ronnevik Department of Religion, Baylor University, Waco, TX 76706, USA; [email protected] Abstract: In this article, I consider how an integration of Dalit theology and Indian Christian history could help Dalit theologians in their efforts to connect more deeply with the lived realities of today’s Dalit Christians. Drawing from the foundational work of such scholars as James Massey and John C. B. Webster, I argue for and begin a deeper and more comprehensive Dalit reading and theological analysis of the history of Christianity and mission in India. My explorations—touching on India’s Thomas/Syrian, Catholic, Protestant, and Pentecostal traditions—reveal the persistence and complexity of caste oppression throughout Christian history in India, and they simultaneously draw attention to over-looked, empowering, and liberative resources that are bound to Dalit Christians lives, both past and present. More broadly, I suggest that historians and theologians in a variety of contexts—not just in India—can benefit from blurring the lines between their disciplines. Keywords: Dalit theology; history of Indian Christianity; caste; liberation 1. Introduction In the early 1980s, Christian scholars in India began to articulate a new form of Citation: Ronnevik, Andrew. 2021. theology, one tethered to the lives of a particular group of Indian people. Related to libera- Dalit Theology and Indian Christian tion theology, postcolonialism, and Subaltern Studies, Dalit theology concentrates on the History in Dialogue: Constructive voices, experiences, and aspirations of India’s so-called “untouchables”, who constitute the and Practical Possibilities.
    [Show full text]
  • THE CLASS of of the City University of New York May 28, 2020 2020 1
    Herbert H. Lehman College THE CLASS OF of The City University of New York May 28, 2020 2020 1 Dear Class of 2020: As I write this, I am reflecting on the 2018 Winter Olympics. I remember being impressed by the vignettes highlighting the personal sacrifice and commitment that led some of the most admired and talented athletes in the world to the medal stand. Those traits – sacrifice and commitment – came to mind when I thought about your graduating class of more than 3500 students. Though you did not have the privilege those Olympic athletes enjoyed to devote themselves completely to just one thing, you have shown, especially in the months leading up to this moment, that you share the same kind of commitment and sacrifices needed to help you take your place among champions. While studying, many of you have worked several part-time jobs, caring for children and relatives, commuting many hours to and from classes. Without the benefit of a financial safety net, you have also now managed to complete the disrupted term of spring term, often with inadequate internet access and with multiple challenges compounded by stay-at-home restrictions. What you have achieved would be admirable in any context but in the context of 2020, it is phenomenal. Nearly 40 percent of you have lost your jobs and critical income this spring. Some of you have battled COVID-19 yourselves, and far too many of you have friends and loved ones coping with COVID-19. It grieves me to say that at least two of your peers lost the fight with coronavirus, with the Bronx being one of the counties hardest-hit by the pandemic in the country.
    [Show full text]
  • Interreligious Dialogue, Comparative Theology and the Alterity of Hindu
    Interreligious Dialogue, Comparative Theology and the Alterity of Hindu Thought Abstract A key question at the heart of contemporary debates over interreligious dialogue is whether the Christian partner in such conversations should view her interlocutors through the lens of Christian descriptions or whether any such imaging amounts to a form of Christian imperialism. We look at the responses to this question from certain contemporary forms of ‘particularism’ which regard religious universes as densely knit, and sometimes incommensurable, systems of meanings, so that they usually deny the significance, or even the possibility, of modes of Bible preaching such as apologetics. While these concerns over the alterity of other religious traditions are often viewed as specifically postmodern, two Scotsmen in British India, J.N. Farquhar (1861–1929) and A.G. Hogg (1875–1954), struggled exactly a hundred years ago with a version of this question vis-à-vis the religious universe of Vedāntic Hinduism and responded to it in a manner that has striking resemblances to ‘particularism’. We shall argue that Hogg can be seen as an early practitioner of a form of ‘comparative theology’ which emerges in his case, on the one hand, through a textual engagement with specific problems thrown up in interreligious spaces but, on the other hand, also seeks to present a reasoned defence of Christian doctrinal statements. We shall note a crucial difference between his comparative theological encounters and contemporary practitioners of the same – while the latter are usually wary of speaking of any ‘common ground’ in interreligious encounters, Hogg regarded the presuppositions of the Christian faith as the basis of such encounters.
    [Show full text]
  • Multiple Religious Belonging and Christian Identity - 2012 Catherine Cornille Boston College
    Santa Clara University Scholar Commons Santa Clara Lectures Lectures 2-14-2012 Multiple Religious Belonging and Christian Identity - 2012 Catherine Cornille Boston College Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.scu.edu/sc_lectures Recommended Citation Cornille, Catherine, "Multiple Religious Belonging and Christian Identity - 2012" (2012). Santa Clara Lectures. 1. https://scholarcommons.scu.edu/sc_lectures/1 This Lecture is brought to you for free and open access by the Lectures at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Santa Clara Lectures by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 2012 SANTA CLARA LECTURE CATHERINE CORNILLE SANTA CLARA UNIVERSITY FEBRUARY 14, 2012 2012 Santa Clara Lecture Multiple Religious Belonging and Christian Identity Catherine Cornille, Boston College Santa Clara University, February 14, 2012 In the context of burgeoning religious plurality, experiences of multiple religious belonging or hybrid religious identities have become increasingly reported and noted. Throughout the Western world, pockets of people have come to cheerfully claim to being both Christian and Hindu, or Buddhist and Jewish, or any combination of two and sometimes more religious identities. A classical example of this may be found in the figure of the Christian theologian, Raimon Panikkar, who, returning from a visit to India, famously claimed that: “I ‘left’ a Christian, ‘discovered’ myself a Hindu, ‘returned’ a Buddhist, all the while remaining a ‘Christian.’”1 This enigmatic statement encapsulates a world of meaning which gradually comes to light in reading his oeuvre. Another Christian theologian, Paul Knitter, recently published a book titled Without the Buddha, I Could Not Be a Christian (London: Oneworld, 2009).
    [Show full text]
  • Devotional Practices (Part -1)
    Devotional Practices (Part -1) Hare Krishna Sunday School International Society for Krishna Consciousness Founder Acarya : His Divine Grace AC. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada Price : $4 Name _ Class _ Devotional Practices ( Part - 1) Compiled By : Tapasvini devi dasi Vasantaranjani devi dasi Vishnu das Art Work By: Mahahari das & Jay Baldeva das Hare Krishna Sunday School , , ,-:: . :', . • '> ,'';- ',' "j",.v'. "'.~~ " ""'... ,. A." \'" , ."" ~ .. This book is dedicated to His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, the founder acarya ofthe Hare Krishna Movement. He taught /IS how to perform pure devotional service unto the lotus feet of Sri Sri Radha & Krishna. Contents Lesson Page No. l. Chanting Hare Krishna 1 2. Wearing Tilak 13 3. Vaisnava Dress and Appearance 28 4. Deity Worship 32 5. Offering Arati 41 6. Offering Obeisances 46 Lesson 1 Chanting Hare Krishna A. Introduction Lord Caitanya Mahaprabhu, an incarnation ofKrishna who appeared 500 years ago, taught the easiest method for self-realization - chanting the Hare Krishna Maha-mantra. Hare Krishna Hare Krishna '. Krishna Krishna Hare Hare Hare Rama Hare Rams Rams Rama Hare Hare if' ,. These sixteen words make up the Maha-mantra. Maha means "great." Mantra means "a sound vibration that relieves the mind of all anxieties". We chant this mantra every day, but why? B. Chanting is the recommended process for this age. As you know, there are four different ages: Satya-yuga, Treta-yuga, Dvapara-yuga and Kali-yuga. People in Satya­ yuga lived for almost 100,000 years whereas in Kali-yuga they live for 100 years at best. In each age there is a different process for self­ realization or understanding God .
    [Show full text]
  • Recasting Caste: Histories of Dalit Transnationalism and the Internationalization of Caste Discrimination
    Recasting Caste: Histories of Dalit Transnationalism and the Internationalization of Caste Discrimination by Purvi Mehta A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Anthropology and History) in the University of Michigan 2013 Doctoral Committee: Associate Professor Farina Mir, Chair Professor Pamela Ballinger Emeritus Professor David W. Cohen Associate Professor Matthew Hull Professor Mrinalini Sinha Dedication For my sister, Prapti Mehta ii Acknowledgements I thank the dalit activists that generously shared their work with me. These activists – including those at the National Campaign for Dalit Human Rights, Navsarjan Trust, and the National Federation of Dalit Women – gave time and energy to support me and my research in India. Thank you. The research for this dissertation was conducting with funding from Rackham Graduate School, the Eisenberg Center for Historical Studies, the Institute for Research on Women and Gender, the Center for Comparative and International Studies, and the Nonprofit and Public Management Center. I thank these institutions for their support. I thank my dissertation committee at the University of Michigan for their years of guidance. My adviser, Farina Mir, supported every step of the process leading up to and including this dissertation. I thank her for her years of dedication and mentorship. Pamela Ballinger, David Cohen, Fernando Coronil, Matthew Hull, and Mrinalini Sinha posed challenging questions, offered analytical and conceptual clarity, and encouraged me to find my voice. I thank them for their intellectual generosity and commitment to me and my project. Diana Denney, Kathleen King, and Lorna Altstetter helped me navigate through graduate training.
    [Show full text]