The Year in Review the Proposed CHUM Tower

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Year in Review the Proposed CHUM Tower Established in 1967 Winter 1999 Celebrating our 30th year Volume 25, No. 4 Dedicated to Preserving Our Built Heritage CHUM now has City support to The President’s Report — erect its enormous tower in the Bytown Market. Visually offensive, The Year in Review monstrously out of scale, destruc- tive of the heritage integrity of this By Carolyn Quinn designated Heritage District, and, we now know, unnecessary for its This past year has been a busy one for sector company Eau Vive, who provided stated broadcast purposes. both canoe and boatman. Six other Heritage Ottawa. The organization has Byward Market resident John informative and unique tours kept partici- successfully fulfilled its mandate to edu- Edwards has been following the pants returning for more! cate and inform residents and visitors of curious twisted story and submits A special thank you goes out to all the city’s valuable heritage buildings and this probe of the strange goings-on. districts. The armchair and walking tours the intrepid volunteer guides who con- exposed many to the benefits of heritage tribute so much to the success of these conservation practice, however, our valuable tours: John Leaning, Terry advocacy work has been arguably less deMarsh, Fern Graham, Judy Deegan, The Proposed successful in meeting our preservation Glenn Lockwood, Louisa Coates and goals. Mark Brandt. Thank you one and all!! February and March saw the pre- Heritage Ottawa was also an active CHUM Tower participant in several events celebrating sentation of five instructive and entertain- If Moses Znaimer and CHUM, his the city’s history and heritage including ing slide-shows where topics ranged Toronto-based radio and television con- Heritage Day ceremonies hosted at All from the fascinating landscape history of glomerate, have their way, a 127-foot Saints’ Church in Sandy Hill, Colonel By the Central Experimental Farm by histori- tower, equivalent in height to a 10-storey Day activities and more recently Bytown an Edwinna von Baeyer, to a highly infor- building, will be erected on a squat 2- Days in the Byward Market. Heritage mative evening with architect Lyette storey structure in the historic Byward Ottawa will be represented in the Local Fortin who spoke on the restoration of Market along with a considerable number Architectural Conservation Advisory the Parliamentary Precinct. In between, of 13-foot wide dishes on the roof. Committee’s Quarter Century Report, we enjoyed the architecture of Werner From public records, from scrutiniz- due to be released in the new year, with Noffke with Gordon Cullingham; we visit- ing City files, from discussion with a vari- articles contributed by several members ed the Art Deco hotels and theatres of ety of experts and lawyers, and from an of the Board. Miami with Paul Stumes; and architect October meeting with Moses Znaimer These successes were accompa- Richard Limmert shared his restoration and some of his staff, an interesting tale nied by serious losses for Ottawa’s her- and adaptive re-use of the old Fraser emerges of an enterprise determined to itage. Over the summer City Council Schoolhouse at 62 John Street. get its way, an out-played city administra- approved the construction of a 45-metre Our walking tour season was a great tion, and a community fighting an tower in the heart of the Byward Market success again this year beginning with eleventh-hour action. and the demolition of two buildings on architect John Leaning leading the way CHUM is on track to pull off a Bank Street in the soon-to-be-designated through the back alleys of the Glebe and remarkable public relations coup — the Heritage District. In both cases the vote ending with architect Mark Brandt’s capti- creation of an attention-demanding bea- was a six-to-five split against heritage vating visit, via canoe, to historic Victoria con for their new premises, a signpost preservation. Island and Chaudière Falls. This latter visible from Confederation Square and tour involved partnering with the private Heritage Ottawa, among other Continued page 2 Continued page 3 1 President’s Report… preservation of the commercial function of Bank Street for the last century and longer. The LACAC voted unanimously groups, lobbied against the proposed against the demolition and pressed for STAY transmission tower at 87 George Street their preservation alongside Heritage as inappropriate for Ottawa’s most Ottawa at the Planning and Economic ALERT!!! historic heritage designated district in Development Committee. The City of terms of its size, scale, materials and Ottawa Official Plan states the block in Shocking as it may seem, the NCC detailing. Unfortunately, the majority question is the most significant heritage have not given up plans for the widen- of city councillors were blinded by area on Bank Street. Further backing ing of Metcalfe Street. The fixation Nokomis, the Algonquin goddess came from the City Centre Coalition with “la grande allée” or boulevard to weathervane that will sit atop the and the Heritage Canada Foundation. meet the Peace Tower of the Centre structure. So they gave CHUM Media But this support was not enough. Block at huge cost to the heritage the unfair advantage of having what The preservation of our historic building fabric of the city is still being amounts to oversized signage. (See urban fabric is not about being anti- considered. As the NCC celebrates it John Edwards’ report on page...) development. Providing designated 100th anniversary it is surprising that City Council also voted to give protection to important heritage more attention has not been paid to Standard Life the go-ahead to demolish resources in the community does not one of the first reports prepared for the two buildings at 142-148 Bank Street preclude redevelopment of the site. then Ottawa Improvement Commission that comprise one-third of the buildings Many examples of creative, award- by landscape architect Frederick Todd. on the west side of the block. This will winning solutions involving the He advises against approaching the result in the loss of a critical mass of adaptive re-use of heritage buildings city as a “Washington of the north.” its heritage building stock and destroy exist in our city. Mr. Gréber certainly recognized this the historic commercial streetscape. On a happier note, the Central when he proposed the widening of Combined the buildings of the block cre- Experimental Farm, recently given a Elgin Street, a boulevard that culmi- ate a high concentration of old National Historic Site designation, has nates with Confederation Square structures that have contributed to the seen a real commitment on the part of before curving westward to reveal the the department of Agriculture and Agri- city’s magnificent Gothic Revival pile. Foods Canada with the appointment of Heritage Ottawa will need all the sup- an official advisory council on heritage port we can muster to prevent the matters and the commitment of some butchering of centretown so some $250,000 to the restoration of the Booth politician or bureaucrat can leave their Barn. (Please see “Central Experimental mark, or in this case scar, on the city. Farm” on page...) As the NCC considers spending The year 2000 will bring new chal- untold sums on this misguided concept lenges for the organization. We must other heritage property under its stew- consider certain inevitable changes if our ardship, namely the modest but impor- preservation goals are to remain relevant tant houses on the Nicholas/Waller tri- within the expanding regional political angle, heritage resources that mark a structure. Our education mandate gateway to the central area, are left to deteriorate. It would seem that money Heritage Ottawa is a non-profit becomes more urgent within the wider context of the digital revolution’s launch for a basic maintenance programme organisation dedicated to advocating cannot be found. Andrex Holdings the preservation, restoration, and into a futuristic cyberspace. How will the Inc., which have successfully restored adaptive re-use of the National survival of the artifacts of our collective Capital’s built and natural heritage. past measure up against the kinds of many heritage sites in this city, includ- technological changes that discard as ing Wallis House, is waiting on the Membership fees: Individual $25 obsolete that which was deemed state- sidelines with a restoration/adaptive re- Family $30; Student/Senior $15 of-the-art little more than a decade ago. use proposal should the NCC be will- Patron $50; Corporation $75 These are issues that must be tackled as ing to negotiate. Stay tuned... Heritage Ottawa, 2 Daly Avenue, the new millennium approaches. Ottawa, ON, K1N 6E2, Tel. 230- 8841 1SSN 1483-9032 Guest Editor: Gordon Cullingham Layout: Tyrell Reproductions Ltd. 2 CHUM Tower… them any indication of the controversial tower record comments from Industry Canada offi- to come? cials from many of the approaches to the Market, City officials claim to have heard of a and a clearly unambiguous open letter from ironically because of past enforcement of tower only in March 1999. What powers did Dr. Peter Strickland, a specialist height restrictions in this heritage area. Their the City have over the erection of the tower in antenna technology associated with arguments go something like this: at that time? There would seem to have Carleton University, confirmed that • Technology is beautiful; a nest of giant been two: alternative ways of sending and receiving satellite dishes on a roof is attractive. A 1. The Ontario Heritage Act. To quote a signals at that location did indeed exist. 127-foot broadcasting tower, tarted up a senior City planner in early March: “I am Despite many presentations against the little with ornamentation, gets compared expecting an Application to Alter this proper- tower before Ottawa’s Planning Committee to the Eiffel Tower.
Recommended publications
  • The Rideau Canal
    City History Hunt: The Rideau Canal ENTRANCE BAY OTTAWA LOCKS RIDEAU CANAL LEBRETON FLATS LeBreton Flats This area was the second choice for the start of the Rideau Canal due to its flat landscape. The first choice was the parcel of land we know of as LeBreton Flats. However, Captain LeBreton, who had previously purchased the land for £499, tried selling the land to Lieutenant Colonel John By for £3000. John By decided this was too much money to spend on a plot of land and decided to look elsewhere. Entrance Bay John By ended up purchasing this plot of land for the beginning of the Rideau Canal. There have been many names for this part of the Ottawa River, but it is now referred to as Entrance Bay due to its location at the entrance of the Rideau Canal. It has also been named Sleigh’s Bay after the wedding of Philemon Wright’s son, during which guests watched the ceremony from their sleighs on the frozen Ottawa River. Philemon Wright was the founder of Wrightsville, now Gatineau. Rideau Canal The Rideau Canal was built between 1826 and 1832. It was intended to be a secure military route to the Great Lakes that bypassed the St Lawrence River. It is now simply used for pleasure. The Rideau Canal is a total of 202 kilometers between Ottawa and Kingston and uses both man-made canals and natural waterways. Ottawa Locks The locks along the Rideau Canal use four different mechanisms to control them. All except three locks are operated solely by man-power.
    [Show full text]
  • Urban and Historic Context
    Architectural Rejuvenation Project URBAN AND HISTORIC CONTEXT Barry Padolsky Associates Inc., Architects, Urban Design and Heritage Consultants February 13, 2015 Aerial view of National Arts Centre (2010) TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction..................................................................................................................................2 Urban and Historic Context........................................................................................................2 . The Holt/Bennett Plan ................................................................................................................4 The Gréber Plan .........................................................................................................................6 The Parkin Plan ...........................................................................................................................8 Architecture and National Identity: the Centennial Projects .......................................................9 NAC: The Architectural Challenge ............................................................................................10 The Architectural Response .....................................................................................................13 Architectural Style: Polite “Brutalism” ......................................................................................16 Re-inventing “Brutalism”..........................................................................................................17 NCC Canada’s
    [Show full text]
  • Byward Market Annual Report
    ByWard Market Annual 2017 Report Introduction: Administration & Financial ByWard Market BIA Mandate To support and promote the health and vitality of the ByWard Market as a unique business district and meeting place for residents as well as visitors. The ByWard Market is characterized by a wide variety of owner-operated businesses and a farmers’ market that make the Market rich in heritage, activity and animation. Financial Breakdown Revenues & Expenses Property Taxes vs Levies Commercial properties in the ByWard Market BIA pay millions of dollars in property taxes annually to the City of Ottawa. Property taxes DO NOT fund the BIA. 100% of property taxes go directly to the City of Ottawa paying for many City services such as: emergency services (police, fire, ambulance), road maintenance, snow removal, water service and sewers, City parks, and facilities etc… In contrast, the BIA is primarily funded through the BIA levy collected from commercial property owners. It is very important to note that the ByWard Market BIA has one of the lowest levies of all of Ottawa’s urban BIAs. This commitment to keep the levy cost minimal for business members means BIA staff need to find alternative sources of revenue to supplement the overall budget. These include sponsorships, grants, sales, and partnerships. In 2017, the ByWard Market BIA supplemented 35% of the overall operating budget through other sources of revenue (sponsorships, sales, and grants). The Board has always been committed to responsible fiscal management. Even though we are one of the busiest BIAs in the City, the ByWard Market BIA levy remains one of the lowest in the downtown core.
    [Show full text]
  • A History of Commissions: Threads of an Ottawa Planning History
    Document generated on 09/24/2021 11:42 p.m. Urban History Review Revue d'histoire urbaine A History of Commissions Threads of An Ottawa Planning History Ken Hillis Volume 21, Number 1, October 1992 Article abstract Early planning in Ottawa takes the form of a piece-meal architectural URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/1019246ar admixture. On paper there remains a series of largely unrealized proposals DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/1019246ar designed to promote an image symbolic of national identity. Successive federal and municipal agencies worked to various degrees of success to augment See table of contents Ottawa's appearance and amenity. British planner Thomas Adams' departure from, and the subsequent demise of the Federal Commission of Conservation in the early 1920's marked a low point in efforts to evolve comprehensive Publisher(s) planning strategies. The career of Noulan Cauchon, first head of the Ottawa Town Planning Commission, aimed to keep the notion of planning alive in the Urban History Review / Revue d'histoire urbaine city. Certain of his little-acknowledged proposals bear remarkable similarity to the pre-W.W. II planning efforts of MacKenzie King and Jacques Greber. ISSN Cauchon's legacy endures in proposals which appear to have been incorporated into federal planning activities during the post-war era. 0703-0428 (print) 1918-5138 (digital) Explore this journal Cite this article Hillis, K. (1992). A History of Commissions: Threads of An Ottawa Planning History. Urban History Review / Revue d'histoire urbaine, 21(1), 46–60. https://doi.org/10.7202/1019246ar All Rights Reserved © Urban History Review / Revue d'histoire urbaine, 1992 This document is protected by copyright law.
    [Show full text]
  • Perth's Built Heritage
    PERTH’S BUILT HERITAGE Anderson-Foss Law Building (1856) – 10 Market Square Asbury Free Methodist Church (1884) – 144 Gore Street East Bain House (1847) – 4 South Street Band Stand (1931) – Market Square Bank of Montreal (1884) - 30 Gore Street East Bridgemaster’s House (1889) – Beckwith Street & Riverside Drive Carnegie Library / McMillan Building (1907) – 77 Gore Street East Code’s Mill (1842-1902) & Kininvie House (1907) – 50/53 Herriott Street Courthouse (1843) - 41 Drummond Street East Craig Street Cemetery / Old Burying Ground (1818) – 21 Brock Street South Daly-Reid Building (1880) - 13 Gore Street West Doctor’s House (1840s) – 22 Wilson Street West Firehall (1855 & 1883) – 34 Herriott Street Grant Building (1860s) – 89-91 Gore Street East Haggart House (1837), Haggart Mill and Dam (1840) - 41 Mill Street Inge-Va (1824) - 66 Craig Street Hart / O’Donnell House (1842) – 37 Herriott Street Hope Building (1886) – 69-71 Foster Street Jail / Gaol (1863) – 62 Beckwith Street Kellock Block (1848) - 39-43 Gore Street East Lillie House (1863) – 43-45 North Street Maple Drop Building / Butler Building (1884) – 2-6 Wilson Street East Matheson House (1840) – 11 Gore Street East Matthews Building (1846) – 55 Gore Street East McKay House (c1820) - 9 Mill Street McLaren Building (1874) – 85-87 Gore Street East McMartin House (1830) – 125 Gore Street East Methodist Robinson Street Cemetery (1841) – 1 Robinson Street Nevis Estate (1842) – 61 Drummond Street West Perkins Building (1947) – 2 Wilson Street West Red House (1816) - 55 Craig Street Registry
    [Show full text]
  • Uptown Rideau STREET COMMUNITY DESIGN PLAN Draft V2 - November 2015
    UPTOWN RIDEAU STREET COMMUNITY DESIGN PLAN Draft v2 - November 2015 City of Ottawa Planning and Growth Management Ottawa.ca/planning Ottawa.ca/urbanisme CONTENTS 1.0 Introduction ............................................................... 5 4.0 The Plan .................................................................... 51 1.1 What is a Community Design Plan? ....................................................... 7 4.1 General Approach ................................................................................ 52 1.2 2005 Uptown Rideau CDP ...................................................................... 7 4.2 Vision, Core Principles and Key Directions ............................................. 52 1.3 How to Use This CDP ............................................................................. 7 4.3 Built Form ............................................................................................ 54 1.4 The CDP Area ......................................................................................... 8 4.4 Open Space .......................................................................................... 68 1.5 Study Process ......................................................................................... 8 4.5 Mobility .............................................................................................. 74 1.6 As We Heard It .................................................................................... 10 4.6 Heritage ..............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Architecture of Ottawa's Central Union Station
    Heritage Ottawa NEWSLETTER Dedicated to Preserving Our Built Heritage Summer 2002 Volume 29, No. 1 Heritage Ottawa Addresses the NCC’s Board of Directors. President’s Report Carolyn Quinn he National Capital Mayors of Ottawa and Gatineau is The City of Ottawa has designated Commission invited local essential. When communicating the parts of Sparks Street a Heritage Tinterest groups to present capital to Canadians, it is the actual Conservation District under the Ontario nature and history of the capital that ideas to assist the commission in Heritage Act to preserve its history. What must be the focus. The city is the you propose is to transform Sparks Street, fulfilling its three-part national product of the life of the local citizens, a weasel word used in describing your mandate: Communicating the capital the Ontario-Quebec bilingual character, plans for LeBreton Flats. to Canadians; safeguarding and the cosmopolitan lifestyle of immigrant Similarly, the creation of a public preserving national symbols and and diplomatic communities and square runs contrary to the design of treasures; and creating a meeting the political climate as the seat of Parliament Hill. The High-Victorian government. place for all Canadians. The following Gothic Revival design of our Parliament Your mandate must balance the Buildings was chosen over the Neo- is a modified version of our response civic realm and the capital realm more Classical style because it reflected our presented to the Board of Directors of effectively. The ‘town versus crown’ non-revolutionary past and our feeling the NCC by President Carolyn Quinn dichotomy has tended to work against for the picturesque.
    [Show full text]
  • Monuments and Memories in Ontario, 1850-2001
    FORGING ICONOGRAPHIES AND CASTING COLONIALISM: MONUMENTS AND MEMORIES IN ONTARIO, 1850-2001 By Brittney Anne Bos A thesis submitted to the Department of History In conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Queen’s University Kingston, Ontario, Canada (September 2016) Copyright ©Brittney Anne Bos, 2016 ii Abstract Commemorations are a critical window for exploring the social, political, and cultural trends of a specific time period. Over the past two centuries, the commemorative landscape of Ontario reaffirmed the inclusion/exclusion of particular racial groups. Intended as static markers to the past, monuments in particular visually demonstrated the boundaries of a community and acted as ongoing memorials to existing social structures. Using a specific type of iconography and visual language, the creators of monuments imbued the physical markers of stone and bronze with racialized meanings. As builders were connected with their own time periods and social contexts, the ideas behind these commemorations shifted. Nonetheless, creators were intent on producing a memorial that educated present and future generations on the boundaries of their “imagined communities.” This dissertation considers the carefully chosen iconographies of Ontario’s monuments and how visual symbolism was attached to historical memory. Through the examination of five case studies, this dissertation examines the shifting commemorative landscape of Ontario and how memorials were used to mark the boundaries of communities. By integrating the visual analysis of monuments and related images, it bridges a methodological and theoretical gap between history and art history. This dissertation opens an important dialogue between these fields of study and demonstrates how monuments themselves are critical “documents” of the past.
    [Show full text]
  • Alexandra Bridge Replacement Project
    Alexandra Bridge Replacement Project PUBLIC CONSULTATION REPORT OCTOBER TO DECEMBE R , 2 0 2 0 Table of Contents I. Project description .................................................................................................................................... 3 A. Background ........................................................................................................................................ 3 B. Project requirements ..................................................................................................................... 3 C. Project timeline ................................................................................................................................ 4 D. Project impacts ............................................................................................................................. 4 II. Public consultation process............................................................................................................ 5 A. Overview .............................................................................................................................................. 5 a. Consultation objectives ............................................................................................................ 5 b. Dates and times ............................................................................................................................ 5 B. Consultation procedure and tools ..........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • To Download the PDF File
    Paraxial Architecture + Hypodigital Space : Exploring the relationship between the Physical and the Digital in Architecture by Andre L. Ottley, B.A.S. A thesis submitted to, The Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARCHITECTURE (M. Arch Professional) Carleton University, Azrieli School of Architecture and Urbanism Ottawa, Ontario August, 2011 © Copyright 2011 Andre L. Ottley i Library and Archives Bibliotheque et 1*1 Canada Archives Canada Published Heritage Direction du Branch Patrimoine de I'edition 395 Wellington Street 395, rue Wellington Ottawa ON MAOISM OttawaONK1A0N4 Canada Canada Your file Votre reference ISBN: 978-0-494-83204-2 Our file Notre r6f4rence ISBN: 978-0-494-83204-2 NOTICE: AVIS: The author has granted a non­ L'auteur a accorde une licence non exclusive exclusive license allowing Library and permettant a la Bibliotheque et Archives Archives Canada to reproduce, Canada de reproduire, publier, archiver, publish, archive, preserve, conserve, sauvegarder, conserver, transmettre au public communicate to the public by par telecommunication ou par I'lnternet, preter, telecommunication or on the Internet, distribuer et vendre des theses partout dans le loan, distribute and sell theses monde, a des fins commerciales ou autres, sur worldwide, for commercial or non­ support microforme, papier, electronique et/ou commercial purposes, in microform, autres formats. paper, electronic and/or any other formats. The author retains copyright L'auteur conserve la propriete du droit d'auteur ownership and moral rights in this et des droits moraux qui protege cette these. Ni thesis. Neither the thesis nor la these ni des extraits substantiels de celle-ci substantial extracts from it may be ne doivent etre imprimes ou autrement printed or otherwise reproduced reproduits sans son autorisation.
    [Show full text]
  • Illumination Lebreton, by Rendezvous Lebreton Group, All Incomes, All Abilities
    LEBRETON BY RENDEZVOUS LEBRETON GROUP A Powerful Expression of Capital City Building and National Identity BY RENDEZVOUS LEBRETON GROUP Linking, Connecting, Completing. IllumiNATION LeBreton, by RendezVous LeBreton Group, all incomes, all abilities. As it once was, it will be a will be many things. It will be a place that celebrates its past nexus point through which people, ideas and creativity while inspiring a bright future. It will be a place where First will move—both physically via multi-modal means and Nations culture and spirituality are key—embraced, shared creatively through innovative experiences, businesses and and celebrated. It will be a place where the traditions of places. It will once again take its place among the diverse innovation that once energized LeBreton Flats will once neighbourhoods of the National Capital—the final piece of a again fuel the future of Canada. Like the LeBreton Flats of great puzzle, linking, connecting, completing. old, it will be a place where all are welcome—all peoples, IllumiNATION LeBreton design Our vision, harkening back to LeBreton Flats’ entrepreneurial spirit, introduces and manages a world-class anchor institution in principles the form of a Major Event Centre, which will be the new home of the Ottawa Senators of the National Hockey League. The massive IllumiNATION LeBreton is poised to become a signature roundhouse, which was located on the western edge of the destination for visitors to Canada’s Capital and a point of civic Option Lands, partly inspires the form and scale of the proposed pride for its residents. In striving to fulfill this potential, RLG is Major Event Centre as does its prominent location.
    [Show full text]
  • Gloucester Street Names Including Vanier, Rockcliffe, and East and South Ottawa
    Gloucester Street Names Including Vanier, Rockcliffe, and East and South Ottawa Updated March 8, 2021 Do you know the history behind a street name not on the list? Please contact us at [email protected] with the details. • - The Gloucester Historical Society wishes to thank others for sharing their research on street names including: o Société franco-ontarienne du patrimoine et de l’histoire d’Orléans for Orléans street names https://www.sfopho.com o The Hunt Club Community Association for Hunt Club street names https://hunt-club.ca/ and particularly John Sankey http://johnsankey.ca/name.html o Vanier Museoparc and Léo Paquette for Vanier street names https://museoparc.ca/en/ Neighbourhood Street Name Themes Neighbourhood Theme Details Examples Alta Vista American States The portion of Connecticut, Michigan, Urbandale Acres Illinois, Virginia, others closest to Heron Road Blackburn Hamlet Streets named with Eastpark, Southpark, ‘Park’ Glen Park, many others Blossom Park National Research Queensdale Village Maass, Parkin, Council scientists (Queensdale and Stedman Albion) on former Metcalfe Road Field Station site (Radar research) Eastway Gardens Alphabeted streets Avenue K, L, N to U Hunt Club Castles The Chateaus of Hunt Buckingham, Club near Riverside Chatsworth, Drive Cheltenham, Chambord, Cardiff, Versailles Hunt Club Entertainers West part of Hunt Club Paul Anka, Rich Little, Dean Martin, Boone Hunt Club Finnish Municipalities The first section of Tapiola, Tammela, Greenboro built near Rastila, Somero, Johnston Road.
    [Show full text]