DOCSLIB.ORG

“21St Century Sewer Socialism”: Sanitation and Venezuela's

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
“21St Century Sewer Socialism”: Sanitation and Venezuela's Building “21st Century Sewer Socialism”: Sanitation and Venezuela’s Technical Water Committees Rebecca McMillan A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies in partial fulfillment of the MA degree in International Development and Globalization Under the Supervision of Dr. Susan J. Spronk School of International Development and Global Studies Faculty of Social Sciences University of Ottawa © Rebecca McMillan, Ottawa, Canada 2013 McMillan, Building “21st Century Sewer Socialism” ii Table of Contents List of Tables ..........................................................................................................................iv Legend ......................................................................................................................................v Abstract...................................................................................................................................vi Acknowledgements............................................................................................................... vii Chapter 1: Towards A Political Geographic Understanding of Citizen Participation in Water and Sanitation Service Provision ...............................................................................8 Research Context ................................................................................................................9 Caracas: A Tale of Two Cities..........................................................................................9 Mapping “Alternatives to Privatization”.........................................................................10 Research Questions ...........................................................................................................12 Methodology and Research Methods ..............................................................................12 Literature Review and Conceptual Framework ............................................................17 Situating Participation in the Planning and Delivery of Sanitation Services..................18 Defining Coproduction....................................................................................................19 Comparing Technocratic and Radical Approaches to Coproduction..............................20 Assessing Transformative Participation: A Framework .................................................28 Structure of the Thesis......................................................................................................30 Chapter 2: Venezuela’s Radical Political Project – The Bolivarian Process and Contemporary State-Society Relations ...............................................................................31 Understanding the rise of Hugo Chávez .........................................................................31 The Bolivarian Process (1999-Present) ...........................................................................33 Who are the Chavistas? The State-Society Dialectic......................................................34 From Reformism to Radicalization: A Brief History of the Bolivarian Process ............36 Conclusions ........................................................................................................................40 Chapter 3: “From Technical to Social Logic” – The MTAs’ Engagement with Underlying Processes of Development ................................................................................41 Informal Development and Urban Water and Sanitation Services in Caracas ..........41 History of the Technical Water Committees (MTAs)....................................................43 Early Origins: From Protest to Parish Government (1993-1996) ...................................43 Scaling Up: The MTAs Reborn (1999-Present)..............................................................45 The MTA Methodology: Census, Sketch, Diagnosis, and Project Execution..............47 State Investment in Water and Sanitation......................................................................49 Conclusions ........................................................................................................................51 Chapter 4: “We are Building Urbanismos”: Water and Sanitation, Popular Power, and Citizenship in Antímano, Caracas.......................................................................................52 Participation as Citizenship .............................................................................................53 Radical Citizenship and Immanent Development...........................................................53 Citizenship and Poder Popular: Towards a New Geography of Power in Venezuela ....54 Introduction to the Case study: The MTAs in Antímano, Caracas .............................56 Geography and Socioeconomic Status............................................................................56 McMillan, Building “21st Century Sewer Socialism” iii Profile of Water and Sanitation Services ........................................................................57 History of Water and Sanitation Struggles in Antímano ................................................58 I. The “Material Emblems of Citizenship”: Service Improvements in Antímano......60 Water Service Improvements..........................................................................................61 Sanitation Service Improvements ...................................................................................66 II. Redefining Spaces of Citizenship: Improved Barrio-State Relations .....................69 III. Beyond Citizenship as Inclusion: Self-management and the Creation of New Political Subjects ...............................................................................................................70 Communities as Sites of Conflict: The Question of Elite Capture ...............................75 Conclusions ........................................................................................................................77 Chapter 5: “The Water that Buys Votes is the Water that I drink”: Challenges for Improving Sanitation and Building Popular Power in a ‘Hybrid’ State .........................78 The Finance Gap and the Limitations of the Local Scale..............................................78 The Contradictions of Insurgent Planning from Above................................................83 Bureaucracy and Politicization: Constraints to Autonomous Action? ........................86 Scale, Institutional Overlap, and the Brown and Green Agendas................................92 Participation, Community Labour, and Invited and Invented Spaces ........................95 Conclusions ........................................................................................................................98 Conclusion..............................................................................................................................99 Areas for Future Research .............................................................................................103 Learning Across Sectors: Comparative Work on the MTAs ........................................103 Sustainable “Alternatives” to Conventional Sanitation?...............................................104 Appendix A: Bibliography of Works Published on Venezuela’s Technical Water Committees ..........................................................................................................................107 Appendix B: Map of Caracas.............................................................................................109 Appendix C: List of Interviews and Events Attended .....................................................110 Appendix D: Interview Schedule .......................................................................................115 Appendix E: Survey Guide (Spanish) ...............................................................................116 Appendix F: Results of Venezuelan Electoral Competitions and Popular Referenda, 1998-Present.........................................................................................................................119 Appendix G: Structure of the Technical Water Committees in Urban Areas ..............122 Appendix I: Investment in Water and Sanitation in Select Latin American Countries (2010) ....................................................................................................................................124 Appendix J: Photographs...................................................................................................125 Appendix K: Ethics Certificate..........................................................................................131 Bibliography ........................................................................................................................132 McMillan, Building “21st Century Sewer Socialism” iv List of Tables Table 4.1 Official Poverty Statistics for the Parish of Antímano, 2001 and 2011 McMillan, Building “21st Century Sewer Socialism” v Legend AD Acción Democrática (Democratic Action, a Venezuelan political party) CCA Consejo comunitario de agua (Community water council) CMA Caracas Metropolitan Area COPEI Comité de Organización Política Electoral Independiente (Committee of Independent Political Organization, a Venezuelan political party) FUNDACOMUNAL Fundación para el Desarrollo de la Comunidad y Promoción del Poder Comunal (Foundation for Community Development and the Promotion
Load more

Recommended publications
  • SEWER SYNDICALISM: WORKER SELF- MANAGEMENT in PUBLIC SERVICES Eric M
    \\jciprod01\productn\N\NVJ\14-2\NVJ208.txt unknown Seq: 1 30-APR-14 10:47 SEWER SYNDICALISM: WORKER SELF- MANAGEMENT IN PUBLIC SERVICES Eric M. Fink* Staat ist ein Verh¨altnis, ist eine Beziehung zwischen den Menschen, ist eine Art, wie die Menschen sich zu einander verhalten; und man zerst¨ort ihn, indem man andere Beziehungen eingeht, indem man sich anders zu einander verh¨alt.1 I. INTRODUCTION In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, municipal govern- ments in various US cities assumed responsibility for utilities and other ser- vices that previously had been privately operated. In the late twentieth century, prompted by fiscal crisis and encouraged by neo-liberal ideology, governments embraced the concept of “privatization,” shifting management and control over public services2 to private entities. Despite disagreements over the merits of privatization, both proponents and opponents accept the premise of a fundamental distinction between the “public” and “private” sectors, and between “state” and “market” institutions. A more skeptical view questions the analytical soundness and practical signifi- cance of these dichotomies. In this view, “privatization” is best understood as a rhetorical strategy, part of a broader neo-liberal ideology that relies on putative antinomies of “public” v. “private” and “state” v. “market” to obscure and rein- force social and economic power relations. While “privatization” may be an ideological definition of the situation, for public service workers the difference between employment in the “public” and “private” sectors can be real in its consequences3 for job security, compensa- * Associate Professor of Law, Elon University School of Law, Greensboro, North Carolina.
    [Show full text]
  • Libertarian Municipalism: an Overview
    Murray Bookchin Libertarian Municipalism: An Overview 1991 The Anarchist Library Contents A Civic Ethics............................. 3 Means and Ends ........................... 4 Confederalism............................. 5 Municipalizing the Economy .................... 7 Addendum ............................... 9 2 Perhaps the greatest single failing of movements for social recon- struction — I refer particularly to the Left, to radical ecology groups, and to organizations that profess to speak for the oppressed — is their lack of a politics that will carry people beyond the limits es- tablished by the status quo. Politics today means duels between top-down bureaucratic parties for elec- toral office, that offer vacuous programs for “social justice” to attract a nonde- script “electorate.” Once in office, their programs usually turn into a bouquet of “compromises.” In this respect, many Green parties in Europe have been only marginally different from conventional parliamentary parties. Nor have so- cialist parties, with all their various labels, exhibited any basic differences from their capitalist counter parts. To be sure, the indifference of the Euro-American public — its “apoliticism” — is understandably depressing. Given their low expectations, when people do vote, they normally turn to established parties if only because, as centers of power, they cart produce results of sorts in practical matters. If one bothers to vote, most people reason, why waste a vote on a new marginal organization that has all the characteristics of the major ones and that will eventually become corrupted if it succeeds? Witness the German Greens, whose internal and public life increasingly approximates that of other parties in the new Reich. That this “political process” has lingered on with almost no basic alteration for decades now is due in great part to the inertia of the process itself.
    [Show full text]
  • Socialism, the IWW, and Communism on the Cuyuna Iron Range, 1912-1933 by John Anthony Byczynski
    Rethinking Radicalism: Socialism, the IWW, and Communism on the Cuyuna Iron Range, 1912-1933 By John Anthony Byczynski n 1933, the twenty-five-year-old mayor of Crosby, Minnesota, the largest city on the Cuyuna Iron Range, Emil Nygard, was on a nationwide tour, the highlight of which was a speech at Web- ster IHall in New York City. On October 19, 1933, the young mayor declared in front of a packed house: “We should not think that it is im- possible to elect Communists to office in the United States of America.” Many in Crosby Minnesota thought “I could not be elected as a Com- munist Mayor. But because I led them in militant demonstrations . a Communist Mayor was elected.” Nygard continued: “In the city of Crosby the working men have begun to realize that they cannot any lon- ger depend on demagogues,” the working-class understood “they must support the Communist Party.” The crowd cheered its approval when Nygard added: “They are beginning to realize also that the Communist Party will not betray the working class!”1 If one looks at miners of the region with only a passing glance, Ny- gard’s election, and a series of Progressive Era strikes led by socialists and a radical union, the Industrial Workers of the World, might lead one to conclude, as one historian suggests of Nygard’s election, that it is was “the culmination of years of radical activity on the iron range.”2 How- ever, connections with the Socialist Party and the IWW give the false impression that the miners were more radical than they really were.
    [Show full text]
  • View Latest Version Here. SOCIALISM
    This transcript was exported on Apr 27, 2019 - view latest version here. Speaker 1: Major funds for BackStory is provided by an anonymous donor, the National Endowment for the Humanities, and the Joseph and Robert Cornell Memorial Foundation. Brian Balogh: From Virginia Humanities, this is BackStory. Brian Balogh: Welcome to BackStory, the show that explains the history behind today's headlines. I'm Brian Balogh. Nathan Connolly: And, I'm Nathan Connolly. If you're new to the podcast, we're all historians, and each week, along with our colleagues, Joanne Freeman and Ed Ayers, we explore the history of one topic that's been in the news. Brian Balogh: We're going to start today's show just outside of Chicago in the town of Pullman. Founded in 1880 by George Pullman, owner of the Pullman Car Company, the town was developed exclusively for laborers. It was an experiment in social reform providing workers a community free from poverty and crime. But, according to historian Nicholas Salvatore, Pullman's motivations were, in reality, much less altruistic. Nicholas S.: That model town was actually a way of controlling the workforce, because if the worker ... Let's say a family is there with a husband, wife, and two kids, and if the husband was the one who was working on the line, if he raised any issues about conditions, wages, dissent concerning the way the company was run, et cetera, et cetera, they get thrown out. And, it happened all the time. Brian Balogh: In 1893, the railroad industry was hit hard by a financial panic.
    [Show full text]
  • Prepared for LSC Madison Trip in March 2016 Version 02262016 This Is Supplemental This Year to the Paper Handout
    Jay Moynihan Community Resource Development Room 101 Shawano County Courthouse 311 N. Main street Shawano, Wisconsin 54166 U.S.A. (715) 526 – 6136 [email protected] Prepared for LSC Madison Trip in March 2016 Version 02262016 This is supplemental this year to the paper handout. Shoreline land Use Contents: Issues as viewed by…. page 1 Science Meets Policy….page 1 The Basic Science….page 2 State government systemic diagrams page 7 Jay’s Three Rules of Understanding What Politicians Do, …. page 8 A brief, 100,000 foot View of Shoreline Zoning and Riparian Rights in Wisconsin…. page 9 Power of Words page 11 A Sketch of a Viewpoint Tendency Continuum …. Page 13 Two important factors in any political debate: Economic Interest and Ideology Page 14 ___________________________________ Issues as viewed by: Wisconsin League of Conservation Voters http://conservationvoters.org/issues/oppose-the-kneecapping-local-communities-bill/ http://conservationvoters.org/issues/special-interest-grab-bag/ Wisconsin Realtors Association The link on their site re The Environment & Land Use has been down for a awhile. Here are PDF legislative reports, that contain some entries re zoning/shoreline issues. https://www.wra.org/Priorities/ A news release from WRA on Act 55 (the 2015-2017 budget) impact on shoreline zoning https://www.wra.org/WREM/July15/Shoreland/ Science Meets Policy Material on the issue from the Wisconsin Lakes Association http://www.wisconsinlakes.org/index.php/shoreland-and-waterways http://www.wisconsinlakes.org/index.php/shorelands-a-shallows 1 The Basic Science: The really basic science: 1. Water runs down hill 2. Water is a “universal” solvent.
    [Show full text]
  • Historic Resources Study of Pullman National Monument, Illinois
    Michigan Technological University Digital Commons @ Michigan Tech Michigan Tech Publications 12-2019 Historic Resources Study of Pullman National Monument, Illinois Laura Walikainen Rouleau Michigan Technological University, [email protected] Sarah Fayen Scarlett Michigan Technological University, [email protected] Steven A. Walton Michigan Technological University, [email protected] Timothy Scarlett Michigan Technological University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.mtu.edu/michigantech-p Part of the Archaeological Anthropology Commons, Other Anthropology Commons, Social and Cultural Anthropology Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Walikainen Rouleau, L., Scarlett, S. F., Walton, S. A., & Scarlett, T. (2019). Historic Resources Study of Pullman National Monument, Illinois. Report for the National Park Service. Retrieved from: https://digitalcommons.mtu.edu/michigantech-p/14692 Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.mtu.edu/michigantech-p Part of the Archaeological Anthropology Commons, Other Anthropology Commons, Social and Cultural Anthropology Commons, and the United States History Commons National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior Midwest Archeological Center Lincoln, Nebraska Historic Resource Survey PULLMAN NATIONAL HISTORICAL MONUMENT Town of Pullman, Chicago, Illinois Dr. Laura Walikainen Rouleau Dr. Sarah Fayen Scarlett Dr. Steven A. Walton and Dr. Timothy J. Scarlett Michigan Technological University 31 December 2019 HISTORIC RESOURCE STUDY OF PULLMAN NATIONAL MONUMENT, Illinois Dr. Laura Walikainen Rouleau Dr. Sarah Fayen Scarlett Dr. Steven A. Walton and Dr. Timothy J. Scarlett Department of Social Sciences Michigan Technological University Houghton, MI 49931 Submitted to: Dr. Timothy M. Schilling Midwest Archeological Center, National Park Service 100 Centennial Mall North, Room 44 7 Lincoln, NE 68508 31 December 2019 Historic Resource Study of Pullman National Monument, Illinois by Laura Walikinen Rouleau Sarah F.
    [Show full text]
  • A Case of American Exceptionalism: ______
    A case of American exceptionalism: _________________________________________ Why is there no socialist tradition in the United States? Master thesis Constança Soares Correia de Matos MA in Governance, Leadership and Democracy Studies Supervisor: Prof. Dr. João Carlos Espada Instituto de Estudos Políticos Universidade Católica Portuguesa Lisbon, May 2020 Acknowledgements I would like to thank all of the people who have both direct and indirectly helped me in the past months, during which I was devoted to completing this project. In particular, I must express my deepest gratitude for my supervisor, Professor João Carlos Espada. I thank him for his committed involvement, his sage advice, his disciplined method of working and his ever-present words of encouragement. I feel very humbled to have been your student and to have had the privilege of working closely with you on this project. I would also like to acknowledge the support that I received from the Instituto de Estudos Políticos’ professors, colleagues and staff, who have, in more ways than one, helped me accomplish my goal. Finally, a special recognition goes to my family, who have been beside me every step of the way. A particular word of thanks goes to my mother, whose infinite wisdom has never ceased to surprise me. Thank you for your endless support and for always believing in me. You are my greatest inspiration. 2 Abstract Unlike other major developed nations, the United States has never witnessed the development of a broad socialist-inspired movement, nor have its most prominent socialist party organizations ever achieved electoral success at the national level.
    [Show full text]
  • Remapping the American Left: a History of Radical Discontinuity
    Remapping the American Left: A History of Radical Discontinuity James N. Gregory Is the American Left reemerging as a political force? Suddenly there are socialists in Congress, socialists on city councils, socialists in the Democratic Party, and much of the media has taken up the question of whether the Democratic Party is swinging to the left. If we are indeed seeing a new surge to the left and new phase of Ameri- can radicalism, it would not be the first time. This is something that has happened repeatedly in the past century. The particulars are new, but the cycles of movement reinvention appear to be a feature of American politics, one that historians have not adequately explored. American radicalism has been a vexing subject for many years. It was not long ago that historians could do little more than grieve, framing the subject as a story of failures and asking why- not questions. Why was there no revolution? Why wasn’t the US Left more like the European Left or the Canadian Left? Why did the Socialist Party fall apart? Why did the New Left fade?1 No longer. Books by Paul Buhle, Richard Flacks, Michael Kazin, Doug Rossinow, Howard Brick, Christopher Phelps, Rhodri Jeffrey- Jones, and Dawson Barrett have changed the tone, examining accomplishments as well as limitations, arguing that the Left has initiated significant transformations, especially involving the rights of previously excluded populations, while a century of radical action has also changed the dimensions of the civic sphere and democratic practice by fostering a culture of activism. The newer books do so in This article began as my presidential address at the Labor and Working- Class History Association banquet at the 2018 Organization of American Historians conference in Sacramento.
    [Show full text]
  • Inventory of the Hal Draper Papers Is Licensed Under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
    UC Davis Special Collections This document represents a preliminary list of the contents of the boxes of this collection. The preliminary list was created for the most part by listing the creators' folder headings. At this time researchers should be aware that we cannot verify exact contents of this collection, but provide this information to assist your research. D-373 Hal Draper Papers BOX 1 Folder 1: Heinrich Heine: A Selected Critical Bibliography, 1956-1980 Folder 2: Heinrich Heine: A Modern Biography Folder 3: M-E NYT 1852 Folder 4: Jan 1931- June 1933 Folder 5: Communist Publications- 1918-1938 Folder 6: Feb 1936- Aug 1938 Folder 7: Nov. 1938- June 1940 (Part 1 of 2) Folder 8: Nov. 1938- June 1940 (Part 2 of 2) Folder 9: 1923- April 1929 Folder 10: May 1929- 1930 Folder 11: July 1933- Dec 1935 Folder 12: Reference Center for Marxist Studies Folder 13: Independent Socialist Reports- March 1969 Folder 14: Independent Social Bulletin- May 1969 Folder 15: ISCA Reports- March 1969 D-373 1 Inventory of the Hal Draper Papers is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Folder 16: ISCA Reports- Part II- July 1969 Folder 17: Independent Socialist Reports- Jan. 1969 Folder 18: Independent Socialist Reports- July 1969 Folder 19: Misc. Socialist Papers Folder 20: Misc. ISC Papers Folder 21: Independent Socialist Reports- Jan. 1969 Folder 22: Misc. ISC Papers and Resolutions (Part 1 of 2) Folder 23: Misc. ISC Papers and Resolutions (Part 2 of 2) Folder 24: IS- Internal Dimension Folder 25: Misc. Radical Rags Folder 26: Correspondence Folder 27: Socialist Handouts Folder 28: Elliot Folder 29: Carlton(?) Folder 30: Logan Folder 31: Derron Folder 32: Jose Folder 33: Sam Folder 34: John Folder 35: Sophia Folder 36: Kevin BOX 2 Folder 1: D-H-S (Part 1 of 2) D-373 2 Inventory of the Hal Draper Papers is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
    [Show full text]
  • A Democracy of Its Own: Milwaukee's Socialisms, Difference
    A DEMOCRACY OF ITS OWN: MILWAUKEE’S SOCIALISMS, DIFFERENCE AND PRAGMATISM by Edward A. Benoit, III A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in History at The University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee August 2009 © Copyright by Edward A. Benoit, III, 2009 All Rights Reserved iv To my mother and father, for all of your support v TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 1 Chapter One: Victor L. Berger 26 Chapter Two: Emil Seidel 61 Chapter Three: Daniel W. Hoan 87 Conclusion 115 Bibliography 118 vi LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1, Unknown, Populistic Boarding House, Victor Berger Papers, Wisconsin Historical Society, Madison, Wisconsin 35 Figure 2, Unknown, Emil Seidel and Victor Berger, Victor Berger Papers, Wisconsin Historical Society, Madison, Wisconsin 45 Figure 3, Unknown, Eugene Debs and Victor Berger, Victor Berger Papers, Wisconsin Historical Society, Madison, Wisconsin 47 Figure 4, Unknown, The Track is Cleared, Victor Berger Papers, Wisconsin Historical Society, Madison, Wisconsin 53 Figure 5, Unknown, Victor L. Berger for U.S. Senator, Victor Berger Papers, Wisconsin Historical Society, Madison, Wisconsin 57 Figure 6, Unknown, Solidartät, Emil Seidel Papers, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee Archive, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 67 Figure 7, Unknown, Come to Hear Emil Seidel, History of Socialism Visual Materials, Wisconsin Historical Society, Madison, Wisconsin 79 vii INSERTED PAGE Notice: Figures are redacted from this version for copyright and licensing protection. Some of the images are available from the Wisconsin Historical Society online (listed below). For the remaining figures, a print copy of the thesis is available through the University of Wisconsin- Milwaukee Golda Meir Library.
    [Show full text]
  • Planned Communities and Pullman
    CHAPTER 4 PLANNED COMMUNITIES AND PULLMAN 4.A A General History of Planned Communities Pullman, Illinois is among the most influential planned company towns in the United States, but it was not the first or the last. A planned community features a spatial arrangement and other characteristics both physical and social that were calculated and designed in advance for a particular intended outcome. The first planned community in the US was New Haven, Connecticut, whose nine-square layout defined the independent colony starting in 1638. Throughout the nineteenth century, planned communities included utopian communities separated both for practical and philosophical ideals. Currently, the New Urbanism movement has created planned communities whose dense residential units interspersed with grocery stores, schools, and other amenities challenge the unplanned nature of suburban sprawl. The first of these was Seaside, Florida (1981) and examples more recently, like Atlantic Station, Georgia (2005), often reclaim brownfield sites and include conscious efforts at environmental remediation and improvement. A company town is a special kind of planned community specifically designed by an employer to house and provide services for employees. The idea has ancient roots but gained significant followers wherever industrial production spread in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.339 Some companies created model villages or model industrial towns intended to demonstrate the perceived advantages of paternalistic planning for ameliorating the overcrowding and inequality being caused by new industrial systems. Pullman stands out among American company towns as being perhaps the most thoroughly planned and comprehensively integrated with company agendas, both of which contributed to the ultimate downfall of George Pullman’s vision and served as cautionary lessons to companies building towns in later years.
    [Show full text]
  • The City Sanders and Ocasio-Cortez Would Have Loved to Live In
    The City Sanders and Ocasio-Cortez Would Have Loved to Live In When “sewer socialism” ruled during the first half of the 20th century, Milwaukee flourished. By Dan Kaufman / The New York Times / 19 October, 2019 Mr. Kaufman is a writer and musician who grew up in Wisconsin.’ A poster for the socialist presidential ticket of 1904, Eugene V. Debs and his running mate, Ben Hanford.CreditCreditVCG Wilson/Corbis, via Getty Images Since the presidential campaign began, the prospect that socialism would seize the Democratic Party has animated Republicans and created anxiety for many Democrats. Last Tuesday, hours before the Democratic debate, President Trump’s campaign flew a 105-foot-long banner reading “Socialism Destroys Ohio Jobs: Vote Trump” over the debate site in Westerville, Ohio. At the same time, some progressives, including Senator Elizabeth Warren, have rejected any association with the socialist label. Warren has called herself a “capitalist to my bones” and stood up to applaud Mr. Trump’s declaration that “America will never be a socialist country” during this year’s State of the Union address. (Senator Bernie Sanders, the only major presidential candidate who identifies as a democratic socialist, remained seated.) Mr. Sanders, who just received the endorsement of the country’s second-most prominent democratic socialist, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York, has fended off Republican attacks by tying his economic ideology to Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal. Mr. Sanders should also consider another remarkable American legacy: the one provided by the socialists who once ruled Milwaukee, the city that will host the 2020 Democratic National Convention and the only large American city that has ever been governed for a significant period of time by socialists.
    [Show full text]