Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

Contents

Page No. 1. Introduction 2

2. The LDP Strategic Housing Objective and Policy 2

3. Supply of Housing Land 3

4. The Vale of Glamorgan Housing Supply Calculation 7

5. Other Sources of Housing 8

6. Managing Housing Land Supply 9

7. Settlement Boundary Review 11

8. Relationship between the distribution of housing allocations and the 12 LDP Settlement Hierarchy

Appendices

Appendix 1 - Unallocated Windfall Developments in the Vale of Glamorgan 16 2001-2011

Appendix 2 - Planning Application History for the Demolition or Replacement 18 of Existing Residential Dwellings

Housing Supply Background Paper

1

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

1. Introduction

1.1. This topic paper is one of a series produced by the Vale of Glamorgan as part of the evidence base for the Deposit Local Development Plan (LDP). Each topic paper can be read in isolation or together to gain a wider understanding of how the policies and/or allocations in the LDP have been developed to address issues facing the Vale of Glamorgan. It considers the requirements for the Vale of Glamorgan LDP in respect of the housing land supply needed to address the population forecasts during the Plan period. Further details on the Council’s population projections for the Vale of Glamorgan are set out in a separate background paper entitled ‘Population and Housing Projections’ (2011)

2. The Vale of Glamorgan LDP Strategic Housing Objective and Policy

2.1. The LDP recognises that one of the greatest demands for development land during the Plan period will come from the provision of housing to meet future changes in population growth. The importance of providing for a balanced range of housing is reflected in the LDP’s housing objective “To provide the opportunity for people in the Vale of Glamorgan to meet their housing needs”.

POLICY SP 3 – RESIDENTIAL REQUIREMENT

IN ORDER TO MEET THE IDENTIFIED RESIDENTIAL REQUIREMENT, LAND IS MADE AVAILABLE IN SUSTAINABLE LOCATIONS FOR THE PROVISION OF 9950 NEW RESIDENTIAL UNITS UP TO 2026.

TO ENSURE A SUFFICIENT SUPPLY OF HOUSING LAND IS MAINTAINED DURING THE PLAN PERIOD, THE RELEASE OF HOUSING LAND WILL BE PHASED IN FIVE YEAR PERIODS WITH PRIORITY BEING GIVEN TO BROWNFIELD AND COMMITTED SITES.

2.2. Policy SP 3 identifies a housing requirement of 9,950 dwellings for the Plan period. The requirement figure is based on Welsh Government population projections for the Vale of Glamorgan. To accommodate this level of growth the LDP has identified a range of development opportunities throughout the Vale of Glamorgan. Further information on how the LDP housing requirement has been derived is set out in the Council’s Population and Housing Projections Background Topic Paper.

Housing Supply Background Paper

2

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

3. Supply of Housing Land

3.1. The supply of new residential development in the Vale of Glamorgan will be provided in accordance with Policy MG 1 which states:

POLICY MG 1 - HOUSING SUPPLY IN THE VALE GLAMORGAN

IN ORDER TO MEET THE HOUSING LAND REQUIREMENT OF 9,950 NEW DWELLINGS PROVISION WILL BE MADE FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF UP TO 10,945 NEW DWELLINGS DURING THE PLAN PERIOD. THIS WILL BE MET THROUGH:

1. ALLOCATIONS WITHIN THE PLAN (INCLUDING 10% FLEXIBILITY); 2. DEVELOPMENT SITES WITH EXTANT PLANNING PERMISSIONS; 3. DEVELOPMENT OF UNALLOCATED WINDFALL SITES IN SUSTAINABLE LOCATIONS AND 4. SMALL SITES, INCLUDING INFILL, THE CONVERSION OF SUITABLE BUILDINGS AND SUBDIVISION OF EXISTING DWELLINGS.

TO ENSURE AN ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF HOUSING LAND IS MAINTAINED DURING THE PLAN PERIOD, THE RELEASE OF HOUSING LAND WILL BE PHASED IN FIVE YEAR PERIODS WITH PRIORITY BEING GIVEN TO BROWNFIELD AND COMMITTED SITES.

3.2. Policy MG 1 of the LDP indicates that the housing requirement for 9950 dwellings will be provided through a number of sources namely:

(i) Allocations within the Plan; (ii) Development of sites with extant planning permissions as at April 2011; (iii) Development of unallocated windfall sites and (iv) Development of unallocated small sites.

3.3. Additionally Policy MG 1 indicates that the Plan includes a 10% margin for flexibility. This is achieved by the provision of an additional 995 dwellings which can be released if required. These sites are marked as “reserve sites” in the supply list and will only be released if other allocated sites do not come forward as planned or if there is an increase in the need for additional housing sites in the Plan period. The provision of these reserve sites will ensure the availability of a range and choice of housing land throughout the Plan period. As a consequence, if necessary, these reserve sites will be developed during the latter part of the plan period or carried forward to the next plan period as appropriate. Further information in respect of each component of the housing supply is outlined below.

(i) Allocations within the Plan – land for new residential development is allocated in accordance with Policies SP3 and MG2 for 7721 dwellings. This has been derived by assessing the anticipated contribution from other sources of housing identified in Policy MG 1, which is discussed below.

Housing Supply Background Paper

3

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

3.4. In determining the contribution of each site towards meeting the LDP’s housing requirements, the Council have used an indicative capacity of 25 to 30 net dwellings per hectare. The densities for each site have been applied to take account of site mitigation measures, densities of existing developments locally and where appropriate current planning permissions. It is acknowledged that when detailed planning applications are submitted, the number of dwellings proposed on each site may be higher or lower than this estimate. However, the Council considers that on the basis of past developments, the densities of between 25 and 30 net dwellings per hectare reflects development patterns in the Vale of Glamorgan.

3.5. Table 1 provides a list of the sites allocated for housing development in Policy MG 2.

Table 1: LDP Housing Site Allocations Site Number 1 Phase 2 Barry Waterfront, Barry 2000 2 Land at Higher End, St. Athan (part of St. Athan SOA) 280 3 Land at Church Farm, St. Athan (part of St. Athan SOA) 250 4 Land to the North of Waycock Cross, Barry 500 5 Barry Island Pleasure Park, Barry Island 115 6 White Farm, Barry 130 7 Land south west of, Waycock Cross, Barry 210 8 Land to east of Pencoedtre Lane, North East Barry 67 9 Land to west of Pencoedtre Lane, North East Barry 30 10 Comprehensive Lower School, Cowbridge 27 11 Cowbridge Cattle Market, Cowbridge 45 12 Cowbridge Comprehensive Sixth Form Block, Road, Cowbridge 15 13 Land adjoining St. Athan Road, Cowbridge 100 14 Plasnewydd Farm, 120 15* Land to the rear of Heol-y-Felin Estate, Llantwit Major (*reserve site) 345 16 Land at Fort Road, , 450 17 Land adjoining St. Josephs School, Sully Road, Penarth 70 18 Headlands School, St. Augustines Road, Penarth 80 19 Land at and adjoining St. Cyres School, Murch Road, 340 20 Land off Caerleon Road, Dinas Powys 60 21 Land south of Hill/Penarth Road, Llandough 150 22 Land north & south of Leckwith Road, Llandough 20 23 Land north of the Railway Line, 680 24 Land south of the Railway Line, Rhoose Point 50 25* Land West of Swanbridge, Sully (* reserve site) 650 26 Land to the West of Port Road, 150 27 Land adjoining Court Close, Aberthin 20

Housing Supply Background Paper

4

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

Site Number 28 Land to the rear of St. Davids Church in Wales Primary School, 60 29 ITV Wales Site, 40 30 The Garden Emporium, Fferm Goch 220 31 Ogmore Residential Centre, Ogmore by Sea 70 32 Ogmore Caravan Park, Ogmore by Sea 82 33 Land to the East of St. Nicholas 50 34 Land off St. Brides Road, Wick 150 35 Land to the North of Sandy Lane, 45 36 Land off Badgers Brook Rise, Ystradowen 50 *Reserve Total Units 7721* sites (*includes reserve sites to be brought forward if necessary)

(ii) Development of Sites with extant planning permission (10 or more dwellings)

3.6. As of April 2011, the five year land bank in the Vale of Glamorgan has land for the development of 1297units. This figure excludes the allowance for small site completions of 287 dwellings.

3.7. Excluding land which has been allocated in the LDP for residential development and units which are agreed by the Study Group to be built outside the five year supply, the agreed land bank contains 175 dwellings made up of the following sites:

Table 2: Large Sites (10 or more dwellings) in the 5 year supply available as contained within the April 2011 JHLAS

Reference Address Units 2009/00879/FUL Custom House Dock View 16 units under construction Road, Barry 2010/01355/FUL 68-84 Merthyr Street, Barry 12 units due for completion 2013 2007/00751/FUL 67-79 Dochdwy Road, 12 units due for completion 2014 Llandough 2008/01413/OUT Former Church in Wales, 25 units due for completion 2013 2010/01144/RES Plassey Street, Penarth 2007/00295/FUL Penarth Heights, off Harbour 48 units (net gain) under construction Road, Penarth 2007/00722/FUL Llantwit Major Social Club, 16 units under construction Beach Rd, Llantwit Major 2007/00107/FUL The Coal Yard, Le Pouliguen 14 units under construction Way, Llantwit Major 2009/00965/FUL , Hensol 32 units remaining of which 20 units under construction and 12 units due for completion 2014 Total 175 units available

Housing Supply Background Paper

5

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

(iii) Development of unallocated windfall sites (10 or more dwellings) and small sites(less than 10 dwellings)

3.8. The contribution of both windfall development (sites of 10 or more units) and small sites (9 units or less) to the overall housing supply in the Vale of Glamorgan has in the past been significant. Between 2001 and 2010, 1939 dwellings were granted planning permission on windfall development sites of 10 or more units. For the purposes of this Plan and to ensure there is no double counting the calculation of the number of Windfall sites that came forward over the period 2001 to 2010 (Table 3) excludes sites allocated for residential development within the Adopted Vale of Glamorgan Unitary Development Plan.

3.9. Table 3, below, illustrates the pattern of approvals over the 10 year period. This information has been derived from the annual Joint Housing Land Availability Schedules. Further detail on the windfall sites included in Table 3 is provided at Appendix 1.

Table 3: Large Windfall Sites Contribution Trend 2001-2010

Joint Housing land Availability Study Year Number of dwellings 2001 451 2002 220 2003 36 2004 243 2005 44 2006 156 2007 107 2008 601 2009 44 2010 37 Total 1939

Annual average 194

3.10. During the same period 772 dwellings were completed on small sites1. Table 4 illustrates the contribution to dwelling completions within the Vale of Glamorgan of sites on less than 10 dwellings. This information is derived from the Joint Housing Land Availability Schedules.

1 Housing Background Paper (Vale of Glamorgan Council)

Housing Supply Background Paper

6

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

Table 4: Small Sites Contribution- Past completions2 (2001-2010)

Joint Housing land Availability Period Number of dwellings 2001 70 2002 144 2003 78 2004 40 2005 153 2006 110 2007 77 2008 30 2009 47 2010 23 Total 772

Annual average 77

3.11. Together, the average contribution from windfall (over 10 units) and small sites (under 10 units) over the last 10 years has been 271 dwellings per annum. Rolled forward over the Plan period this could equate to a contribution to the housing supply for the LDP of such sites of 4065 (Annual total of 271 multiplied by 15 (plan period in years)). 3.12. The Council recognises that in the current economic climate the contribution from windfall and small sites to the housing supply is likely to be reduced. However, over a 15 year period and with greater flexibility within settlements for development opportunities to come forward in the LDP, it is likely that this figure will be similar for the LDP Plan period. 3.13. To reflect the current climate but to also be realistic about the long term opportunities over the Plan period it is proposed to discount the average windfall and small site figure obtained over the past 10 years by 25%. The windfall (over 10 units) and small site figure (under 10 units) for the LDP will therefore be 3049 or approximately 203 units per annum. This comprises of a total of 866 small (under 10 unit sites) and 2183 windfall (over 10 unit sites).

4. The Vale of Glamorgan Housing Supply Calculation

4.1. Taking into account all the above factors it is anticipated that the LDP will provide for 9950 dwellings. Of the allocations within the plan, which amount to 7721 in total, 995 sites are classed as reserve sites and have been identified to come forward as appropriate and in accordance with the phasing of sites in Table 6.

2 Annual Joint Housing Land Availability Studies 2001-2011.

Housing Supply Background Paper

7

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

Table 5: LDP Housing Supply Calculation 1. Allocations within the Plan (of which 995 units are 7721 identified on reserve sites for flexibility) 2. Development of Sites with extant planning permissions 175 (10 or more dwellings) 3. Development of unallocated windfall sites (10 or more 2183 dwellings)

4. Development of small sites (less than 10 dwellings) 866

Total Housing Provision (including 10% flexibility) 10,945

5. Other Sources of Housing

5.1. Consideration has been given to the provision of additional housing through the reinstatement of empty properties and loss of housing stock as a result of the demolition. However a review of these as detailed below indicates that this is unlikely to have a significant impact on the provision of new housing in the Vale of Glamorgan.

(a) Reinstatement of Empty dwellings

5.2. The Council’s Outcome Agreement with the Welsh Government addresses particular strategic themes, objectives and improvement targets, including a number in relation to empty homes. This agreement sets a target for the Council to reinstate 8 dwellings during 2010-13 (of which 7 fall within the LDP period). Theoretically, this could contribute 39 dwellings over the Plan period. However, the reinstatement of empty properties is dependent of the actual circumstances for the property to become vacant, and in the case of the Council using its statutory powers these apply where the condition of properties is such that they pose a threat to public health. Therefore it is difficult for the Council to predict accurately the total contribution and for this reason the 39 units identified have been excluded from being a source for meeting the LDP housing requirement.

(b) Loss of housing supply as a result of demolition

5.3. Local experience suggests that demolition occurs primarily where this is involves a replacement dwelling (zero loss) or the redevelopment of a site for more than one dwelling producing a net gain in housing stock. To support this assumption Appendix 2 provides a record of the number of applications received by the Council for either the replacement or demolition of existing dwellings for the Vale of Glamorgan between 2000 and 2010. Accordingly the Council considers that loss of housing stock as a result of demolition would be nil over the LDP period and where demolition would result in a net housing gain, this has been taken into account within the small site windfall allowances.

Housing Supply Background Paper

8

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

6. Managing Housing Land Supply

6.1. National Planning Policy places a requirement on local planning authorities to ensure that a minimum 5 year supply of housing land is available, and where land supply falls below this, take appropriate steps to increase supply. In preparing LDPs, TAN 1 advises that local planning authorities should seek to integrate the LDP and JHLAS processes in developing the evidence base for future housing requirements and for the annual monitoring of housing development and land supply.

6.2. In order to ensure a continued supply of land over the Plan period, the Council proposes to release housing allocations over 3 successive 5 year periods. In addition to ensuring that housing land supply in the Vale is broadly in line with the housing land requirements of TAN 1, phasing will allow the Council to ensure that sites are prioritised assisting the delivery of the aims and objectives underpinning the Plan. The anticipated schedule for the phasing of allocations within the LDP is shown in Table 6 and gives priority to committed sites with extant permissions and brownfield sites.

Table 6: Proposed Schedule of the Release of Land Allocation Period 2011-16 2016-21 2021-26 Strategic Housing Sites 1 Phase 2 Barry Waterfront (B1) 650 650 700 2 Land at Higher End, St. Athan (part of St. Athan 280 SOA) 3 Land at Church Farm, St. Athan (part of St. 250 Athan SOA)

Allocation Period 2011-16 2016-21 2021-26 Key Settlement: Barry 4 Land to the North of Waycock Cross, Barry 250 250

5 Barry Island Pleasure Park, Barry Island 115

6 White Farm, Barry 130 7 Land to the south west of Weycock Cross, 210 Barry 8 Land to east of Pencoedtre Lane, North East 30 Barry 9 Land to west of Pencoedtre Lane North East 67 Barry

Housing Supply Background Paper

9

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

Allocation Period 2011-16 2016-21 2021-26 Service Centre Settlements Cowbridge 10 Cowbridge Comprehensive Lower School 27

11 Cowbridge Cattle Market 45 12 Cowbridge Comprehensive Sixth Form Block, 15 Aberthin Road 13 Land adjoining St. Athan Road 100 Llantwit Major 14 Plasnewydd Farm, Llantwit Major 120 15 Land to the rear of Heol-y-Felin Estate, Llantwit 345 Major (*reserve site) Penarth 16 Land at Fort Road, Lavernock 200 250

17 Land adjoining St. Josephs School, Sully Road 70

18 Headlands School, St. Augustines Road 80

Allocation Period 2011-16 2016-21 2021-26 Primary Settlements Dinas Powys 19 Land at and adjoining St. Cyres School, Murch 160 180 Road, Dinas Powys 20 Land off Caerleon Road, Dinas Powys 60 Llandough (Penarth) 21 Land south of Llandough Hill/Penarth Road 150

22 Land north & south of Leckwith Road 20

Allocation Period 2011-16 2016-21 2021-26 Primary Settlements Rhoose 23 Land north of the Railway Line, Rhoose 300 380

24 Land south of the Railway Line, Rhoose Point 50 Sully 25 Land West of Swanbridge, Sully (*reserve site) 650 Wenvoe 26 Land to the West of Port Road, Wenvoe 150

Housing Supply Background Paper

10

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

Allocation Period 2011-16 2016-21 2021-26 Minor Rural Settlements Aberthin 27 Land adjoining Court Close, Aberthin 20 Colwinston 28 Land to the rear of St. Davids Church in Wales 60 Primary School, Colwinston Culverhouse Cross 29 ITV Wales and Land adjacent to Old Port Road 110 110 Fferm Goch 30 The Garden Emporium 40 Ogmore-by-Sea 31 Ogmore Residential Centre 70

32 Ogmore Caravan Park 82 St.Nicholas 33 Land to the East of St. Nicholas 50 Wick 34 Land off St. Brides Road, Wick 150 Ystradowen 35 Land to the North of Sandy Lane 45

36 Land off Badgers Brook Rise 50

Total Units Per Period (needs updating) 2041 2715 2965

6.3. Information on the availability and capacity of existing infrastructure such as main line sewage including the programmed provision of new or upgraded services by statutory undertakers has also informed the phasing of sites.

7. Settlement Boundary Review

7.1. As part of the process of formulating the LDP the Council has identified settlement boundaries for the Key Settlement of Barry, the Service Centres of Cowbridge, Llantwit Major and Penarth and the Primary Settlements of Dinas Powys, Llandough (Penarth), Rhoose, Sully and Wenvoe.

Housing Supply Background Paper

11

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

7.2. In order to identify settlement boundaries the Council has:

• Reviewed the current relevant settlement boundaries contained in the Adopted Vale of Glamorgan Unitary Development Plan; • Identified proposed new allocations; • Identified areas of change, e.g. new road layouts etc; • Identified relevant planning approvals on the urban fringe and • Reviewed pre application enquiries to identify appropriate areas for inclusion.

8. Relationship between the distribution of housing allocations and the LDP Settlement Hierarchy

8.1. The LDP Strategy sets out the framework for positively managing change up to 2026 to achieve a balance between environmental protections, improving quality of life and ensuring sustainable development. The LDP Strategy seeks to direct housing in the Vale of Glamorgan to the most sustainable locations in accordance with the LDP Settlement Hierarchy. This hierarchy provides the planning framework for the sustainable distribution and direction of development across the Vale and has been used by the Council in the identification of sites for housing development within the LDP:

LDP SUSTAINABLE SETTLEMENT HIERARCHY

• KEY SETTLEMENT: BARRY

• SERVICE CENTRE SETTLEMENTS: COWBRIDGE, LLANTWIT MAJOR, PENARTH

• PRIMARY SETTLEMENTS: DINAS POWYS, LLANDOUGH (PENARTH), RHOOSE, ST. ATHAN, SULLY, & WENVOE

• MINOR RURAL SETTLEMENTS: ABERTHIN, , COLWINSTON, , CULVERHOUSE CROSS, EAST , , FFERM GOCH, GRAIG PENLLYN, , , , , OGMORE BY SEA, , PENLLYN, PETERSTON SUPER ELY, SIGINSTONE, , , ST NICHOLAS, TREOES, WICK, YSTRADOWEN.

8.2. Table 7 below compares the distribution of the housing numbers within the Deposit LDP with the above settlement hierarchy. This reveals that housing site allocations within the settlement of Barry will accommodate 39.5% of housing; with Service and Primary Settlements accommodating higher levels of development than Minor Rural Settlements. Strategic allocations at St. Athan will provide 6.9% of the total requirement, which for a single settlement is proportionate to the total level of housing within the 3 service centre settlements and is a reflection of its strategic importance.

Housing Supply Background Paper

12

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

Table 7 – Distribution of Housing Allocations by Settlement Category Barry Number of Dwellings Proposed Phase 2 Barry Waterfront, Barry 2000 Land at Walters Farm, Weycock Road, Barry 500 Barry Island Pleasure Park, Barry Island 115 White Farm, Barry 130 Land south west of, Weycock Cross, Barry 210 Land to east of Pencoedtre Lane, North East Barry 67 Land to west of Pencoedtre Lane, North East Barry 30 Hierarchy Category Sub Total 3052 As a Percent of Total Allocations 39.5%

St. Athan Land at Higher End, St. Athan (part of St. Athan SOA) 280 Land at Church Farm, St. Athan (part of St. Athan SOA) 250 Hierarchy Category Sub Total 530 As a Percent of Total Allocations 6.9%

Service Centre Settlements Cowbridge Comprehensive Lower School, Cowbridge 27 Cowbridge Cattle Market, Cowbridge 45 Cowbridge Comprehensive Sixth Form Block, Aberthin Road, 15 Cowbridge Land adjoining St. Athan Road, Cowbridge 100 Plasnewydd Farm, Llantwit Major 120 Land to the rear of Heol-y-Felin Estate, Llantwit Major 345 Land at Fort Road, Lavernock, Penarth 450 Land adjoining St. Josephs School, Sully Road, Penarth 70 Headlands School, St. Augustines Road, Penarth 80 Hierarchy Category Sub Total 1252 As a Percent of Total Allocations 16.2%

Housing Supply Background Paper

13

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

Primary Settlements Land south of Llandough Hill/Penarth Road, Llandough 150 Land north & south of Leckwith Road, Llandough 20 Land north of the Railway Line, Rhoose 680 Land south of the Railway Line, Rhoose Point 50 Land West of Swanbridge, Sully 650 Land to the West of Port Road, Wenvoe 150 Land at and adjoining St.Cyres School, Murch Road, Dinas Powys 340 Land off Caerleon Road, Dinas Powys 60 Hierarchy Category Sub Total 2100 As a Percent of Total Allocations 27.2%

Minor Rural Settlements Land adjoining Court Close, Aberthin 20 Land to the rear of St.Davids Church in Wales Primary School, 60 Colwinston ITV Wales and Land adjacent to Old Port Road, Culverhouse Cross 220 The Garden Emporium, Fferm Goch 40 Ogmore Residential Centre, Ogmore by Sea 70 Ogmore Caravan Park, Ogmore by Sea 82 Land to the East of St.Nicholas 50 Land off St.Brides Road, Wick 150 Land North of Sandy Land, Ystradowen 45 Land off Badgers Brook Rise, Ystradowen 50 Hierarchy Category Sub Total 787 As a Percent of Total Allocations 10.2%

Total Dwellings 7721 Percent 100%

Housing Supply Background Paper

14

Vale of Glamorgan Local Development Plan 2011 - 2026

Appendices

Housing Supply Background Paper

15 Appendix 1 Unallocated Windfall Development Trend in the Vale of Glamorgan 2001-2010

Joint Housing Land Study Year No. dwellings Site Name JHLA 2010 Site north west of Bendrick Rd, via Wimbourne Rd, Barry 12 Former Church in Wales Primary School, Plassey Street. 25 JHLA 2009 St. Athan Methodist Church 16 Llantwit Major Social Club 16 Bethan Chapel, Corner of Court Road Barry 12 JHLA 2008 11 Paget Road , Barry 11 Beach Way, The Knap, Barry 26 Custom House, Dock View Road, Barry 16 Land at Suran-y-Gog, Pencoedtre Barry 50 Barry Hotel, Barry 28 The Royal Hotel, Barry 18 67-69 Dochdwy Road, LLandough 12 Bron-y-Glyn, Marine Parade, Penarth 27 Former Penarth Baths, Penarth 19 Penarth Heights, Penarth (net gain) 48 Sully Hospital, Hayes Road, Sully 234 Cowbridge Grammar School 19 Hensol Castle 58 St. Athan 12 63-73 Main Street, Barry 12 Land at Robbins Lane, Barry 11 JHLA 2007 1a Rock Café , Pagent Road, Barry 12 2c Nells Point, Barry 51 Hazelhurst, Sully Road, Penarth 11 Heritage Coast House, Main Road Ogmore 15 Land at Robins Road/ Glenbrook Drive 18 JHLA 2006 Former Holiday Camp, Phase 2 143 YMCA, Woodlands road, Barry 13 JHLA 2005 Bindles, Barry 20 Lakin Drive, Barry 13 48 Elmgrove Road, Dinas Powys 11 JHLA 2004 Former Holiday Camp, Phase 1 88 Woodfield Heights, Gibbonsdown 30 Plymouth House 44 Craig Yr Eos, Ogmore 12 Land off Marine Drive, Ogmore by Sea 69 JHLA 2003 Williams Garage, Colhugh Street, Llantwit Major 10 Coleridge Crescent, Barry 26 JHLA 2002

Westward Rise, Marine Drive 114 The Lindens, Bradford Place 11

16 Part of Gibbonsdown estate, off Skomer Rd. 95

JHLA 2001

Winchester Close, Barry 145 Upper Cosmeston farm 22 Llantwit Major and Llanmaes Road 91 Walston Road, Wenvoe 12 Polytechnic Campus, Barry 171 West Terrace, Penarth 10

Total 1939 (194 per annum)

17

Appendix 2 Applications for Demolition and Replacement of Existing Dwelling 2000-2010

Application Location existing units Description Reference units proposed 2007/00847/FUL 1 and 2, Wern Fawr Bungalows, Sandy 2 2 Replacement of Nos. 1 and 2 Wern Fawr Bungalows with 2 no. detached Lane, Ystradowen dwellings 2002/00870/FUL 10, Ash Grove, Barry 1 4 Demolition of an existing bungalow and the construction of four new houses with associated site access 2001/00987/FUL 114, Dobbins Road, Barry 1 1 Demolish existing house & garage & construct replacement dwelling 2007/010135?FUL 14, Smithies Avenue, Sully 1 2 Demolish existing cottage, garage and outbuildings and build two detached houses. 2009/01212/FUL 143, Pontypridd Road, Barry 1 1 Demolition of existing sub-standard cottage and replacement with new dwelling and garage 2003/00325/FUL 25 & 27, Station Road, Dinas Powys 1 1 Proposed demolition of existing unoccupied house and outbuildings construction of replacement single dwelling 2000/01215/FUL 48, Elm Grove Road, Dinas Powys 1 11 Demolition of existing premises and redevelopment as 11 no. 2 bedroom flats. 2003/01201/FUL Normandy (Oakhurst), Bridgeman 3 9 Demolish and rebuild main house into 3 no. apartments. Build side and rear Road, Penarth extensions for a further 6 no. apartments 2007/01205/FUL 8, Stanton Way, Penarth 1 4 Demolition of existing bungalow and erection of 4 no. new dwelling houses 2010/00820/FUL 9, Church Hill Close, 1 1 Replacement of an existing 3 bedroom dwelling 2006/01189/FUL 9, Smithies Avenue, Sully 1 1 Demolition of existing buildings and construction of 1 dwelling 2006/01000/OUT 90, Fontygary Road, Rhoose 1 2 Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of two bungalows of the same design on the site 2005/01870/FUL Ashlea, Cross Common Road, Dinas 1 1 Proposed replacement dwelling Powys 2002/01006/OUT Baltimore House, 1 & 2, Park Road, 1 1 Demolish existing dormer bungalow, construct new dormer bungalow Barry 2000/00107/OUT Barkways Cottage, Grants Field, The 1 1 Erection of a replacement dwelling Downs 2000/00107/OUT Barns adjacent Caerau Lane, 1 3 Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of three dwellings

18 Barkways, Wenvoe 2001/01510/FUL Broomwell, Llancarfan 1 1 Proposed replacement dwelling 2009/00834/FUL Brynheulog Farm, St. Andrews Road, 1 1 Replacement dwelling on grounds of existing nursery Wenvoe 2006/01033/FUL Brynhyfryd, Bonvilston 1 1 Replacement dwelling 2009/01294/FUL Caradoc Cottage, Llancarfan 1 1 Demolition of existing sub-standard cottage and replacement with new dwelling and garage 2010/00172/FUL Castle Lodge, St. Georges-Super-Ely 1 5 Demolition of existing building (retail ground floor and flat to first floor) and construction of five two bedroom apartments. 2000/00523/FUL Channel View, Wick Road, Llantwit 1 1 Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of new detached dwelling Major 2000/00783/FUL Cottage Farm, Michaelston-Le-Pit, 1 1 Demolition of existing bungalow and the construction of a new bungalow Dinas Powys 2009/01011/FUL Glendon, Argae Lane, Dinas Powys 1 1 Replacement dwelling 2008/01028/FUL Golygfa, Colwinston 1 1 Proposed replacement dwelling 2009/00423/FUL Green Meadow, Penllyn 1 2 Demolition of single residential dwelling and replacement with 2 no. 4-bedroom detached houses. 2010/00812/FUL Gwynfa, David Street, Wick 1 1 Demolition of existing bungalow and construction of new dormer bungalow. 2010/01127/FUL Heathcliffe, Clive Crescent, Penarth 1 1 Replacement dwelling and landscape works 2005/01164/FUL Heathfield House, St. Brides Super Ely 1 1 Demolition of structurally unsound dwelling and erection of new replacement dwelling 2008/00093/FUL Hendre Wen (Plot Two), Rock Road, 1 1 Proposed replacement dwelling - (existing bungalow structurally defective and St. Athan dilapidated) 2008/00817/FUL High Peak, Pen Y Lan, Cowbridge 1 1 Demolition of existing bungalow and garage and construction of replacement dwelling. 2001/01307/FUL Hill Cottage, Church Road, 1 1 Demolish existing house & garage & construct replacement dwelling Llanblethian 2010/00873/FUL Holm View Cottage, Pen y Turnpike 1 2 Demolition of existing bungalow and re-develop for 2 No. Plots Road, Dinas Powys 2010/00400/FUL Land adjacent to Anwylfan, St. 1 1 Construction of a new six bedroom house and demolition of the existing two Nicholas bedroom house

19 2001/01305/FUL Land at 42, Fontygary Road, Rhoose 1 1 Demolition of existing bungalow and construction of house 2007/00215/FUL Land at rear of 31-32, Station Road, 1 1 Demolition of existing residential buildings and construction of replacement Penarth single dwelling 2008/01209/FUL Lane End (formerly Stuart Memorial 1 1 Renewal of planning permission 03/00973/FUL - Proposed replacement dwelling Cottage), Michaelston-Le-Pit 2010/01038/FUL Llwyn Draen, Ystradowen, Cowbridge 1 1 Replacement dwelling. 2010/00808/FUL Meliden, Sunnycroft Lane, Dinas 1 1 Replacement of derelict house with three storey five bedroom house. Powys 2003/01278/FUL Mon Repose, Pleasant Harbour, East 1 1 Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of replacement dwelling Aberthaw 2005/01880/FUL New dwelling at White Wells Farm, 1 2 Demolition of existing bungalow and erection of 2 no. semi-detached dwellings Peterston Super Ely 2010/01090/FUL Pant Y Groes, B4265, Vale of 1 1 Replacement dormer bungalow dwelling in place of existing bungalow. Glamorgan 2000/00338/FUL Parc Newydd Cottage, Welsh St. 1 1 Demolish existing house and erect new house Donats 2007/00295/FUL Penarth Heights, off Harbour View 329 377 To demolish the existing flats and construct 377 residential units and associated Road, Penarth highway infrastructure and open space 2006/00090/FUL Pencarreg, Bonvilston 1 1 Renewal of application 01/00072/FUL for a replacement dwelling 2004/01515/FUL Plot of land between Frampton and 1 1 Demolish existing bungalow to floor slab level, construct new two storey four Hallowdene, St. Athan Road, bedroom dwelling. Cowbridge 2005/01388/FUL Raycroft, Cross Common Road, Dinas 1 1 Proposed replacement dwelling to include self-contained granny annex Powys 2010/01104/FUL Sant Y Nyll Guest House, Heol Sant y 1 1 Demolition of existing residential buildings and construction of replacement Nyll, St. Brides Super Ely single dwelling 2010/00523/FUL Southmead, Wick Road, Llandow 1 1 Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of new replacement dwelling (outline) 2007/01623/FUL Springside, Pen-y-Turnpike Road, 1 1 Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of replacement dwelling. Dinas Powys 2001/01246/FUL St. Helens Church Hall, Maesycwm 1 2 Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of 2 No. dwellings

20 Street, Barry 2001/00291/RES St. Mary's Well Bay Road, Lavernock, 1 1 Replacement and resisting of existing dwelling Sully 2001/01489/FUL Sutton Farm, Fort Road, Lavernock 1 1 Replacement dwelling 2007/01641/FUL The Cot, Farm, Gileston 1 1 Replacement of run down farm workers cottage 2010/01243/FUL The Rickyard, Upper Farm Court, 1 1 Construction of replacement dwelling, including conversion of existing barn Rhoose Road, Rhoose 2004/00964/OUT The Stables, St. Brides Road, Wick 1 2 Demolition of existing bungalow and replacement with pair of semi-detached houses 2007/00422/FUL Three Oaks, Church Road, 1 2 Demolition of single terrace house and construction of 2 new three storey terrace Llanblethian houses. 2009/01006/FUL Trem-y-Glyn, 8, Windmill Lane, 1 2 Demolish existing house on site. Erect two new two-storey detached dwellings. Cowbridge 2006/01403/OUT Ty Buwch, Bute Lane, Penarth 1 1 Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of replacement dwelling 2006/00967/OUT Ty Canol, Craig Penllyn 1 1 Demolish existing bungalow and replace with new dormer type four bedroom bungalow 2004/00973/FUL Walden, Highlight Lane, Barry 1 1 Replacement dwelling 2009/01028/FUL Waun View, Burdons Hill, Wenvoe 1 1 Demolition of Existing Bungalow and Construction of New Dwelling 2010/00159/FUL White Bungalow, Barry Road, Dinas 1 2 Demolition of single residential dwelling house and replacement with 2 no. 4- Powys bedroom detached houses. Total 394 480

21