EXAMINER Issue 1.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ripper Morganstone, Geography THE CASEBOOK Elizabeth & Victorian Phoenix English & Culture issue one Mrs Carthy David M. Gates April 2010 Neal Shelden JACK THE RIPPER STUDIES, TRUE CRIME & L.V.P. SOCIAL HISTORY R. J. Palmer Examines OF THERWALTERISE ANDREWS MICHAEL KIDneY IS INNOCENT! Tom Wescott Takes A Fresh Look At Some Old Myths THE CASEBOOK The contents of Casebook Examiner No. 1 April 2010 are copyright © 2010 Casebook.org. The authors of signed issue one articles, essays, letters, reviews and April 2010 other items retain the copyright of their respective contributions. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. No part of this publication, except for brief quotations where credit is given, may be repro- CONTENTS: duced, stored in a retrieval system, transmitted or otherwise circulated in Greetings! pg 3 Collectors Corner any form or by any means, including Subscription Information pg 5 Expert Advice pg 86 digital, electronic, printed, mechani- Exonerating Michael Kidney On The Case cal, photocopying, recording or any Tom Wescott pg 6 News From Ripper World pg 88 other, without the express written per- mission of Casebook.org. The unau- The Rise of Walter Andrews On The Case Extra thorized reproduction or circulation of R. J. Palmer pg 30 Feature Story pg 90 this publication or any part thereof, Reconsidering Ripper Geography Ultimate Ripperologist’s Tour Explore Leicester pg 92 whether for monetary gain or not, is & Victorian English Culture strictly prohibited and may constitute D. M . Gates pg 55 CSI: Whitechapel copyright infringement as defined in Mary Ann Nichols pg 102 Morganstone, Elizabeth Phoenix domestic laws and international agree- & Mrs Carthy From the Casebook Archives ments and give rise to civil liability and Neal Shelden pg 62 Emma Smith pg 108 criminal prosecution. Undercover Investigations Scenes of Crime Book Reviews pg 73 Christ Church pg 108 The views, conclusions and opinions expressed in articles, essays, letters and other items published in Casebook Editor in Chief Don Souden Acknowledgements: Examiner are those of the authors and Publisher Stephen P. Ryder Suzi Hanney & Rob Clack do not necessarily reflect the views, for Casebook.org for use of images. conclusions and opinions of Casebook. Features Editor Jennifer Shelden org, Casebook Examiner or its editors. Design David Pegg GREETINGS! WELCOME TO CAseBOOK EXAMINER… DON SOUDEN … the newest publication in the field. magazine and that we do not intend to barker’s shout “Folks, you ain’t seen And, like most proud parents, we at be, as borne out by this first issue with nothing yet!” because there are many the Examiner already see a wonder- articles on a variety of subjects as well more exciting articles coming in future ful future for our progeny and hope as a number of interesting features issues by both old hands and newcom- that this and subsequent issues will and columns. ers in the field. have you, our readers, agreeing that In this initial issue, Tom Wescott In the same way, the features our initial pride is more than justified. provides a strong case for the exonera- in this issue are just the beginning Indeed, we recognize that any publica- tion of Michael Kidney for the murder of what promises to be an innovative tion’s success depends on its ability to of Liz Stride while Roger J. Palmer and entertaining section. There will satisfy its audience and we pledge to begins his examination of Walter always be reviews of the latest books, keep that simple truth forever in mind Andrews’ “Mission to Montreal.” In films and stage performances relating — this magazine is for our readers and addition, Jennifer and Neal Shelden to Ripperology as well as other regular not for ourselves. provide new genealogical insights features like the column on collecting The Examiner is still growing and on a few of the peripheral — but fas- by Stewart P. Evans, Robert Clack’s evolving, but there are two things we cinating — players in the Mary Jane photo column and The Ultimate Ripper will promise our readers and they are Kelly murder and David Gates offers Tour that will take readers down high- that we will inform and we will enter- a thought-provoking essay on Ripper ways and byways everywhere in the tain. In fact, one without the other research. Yet, even with that strong world to places that have ties to the would make for a rather pointless opening lineup we echo the carnival Whitechapel Murders. And again, THE CASEBOOK Examiner Issue 1 April 2010 3 there are many, many more fascinat- will be signed. In theory, at least, an this is a labor of love, what is earned ing features set for subsequent issues. unsigned review allows the reviewer will be donated annually to a suitable Finally, there are a few things to be more honest, especially in a field charity. Finally, although we are finan- that should be said about our purpose like Ripperology that is so small and cially independent from Casebook, in and policies. The first is that while we where feelings are so easily hurt. In return for server space and sponsor- are sponsored by Casebook, and are practice, however, anonymous reviews ship, a subscription to our magazine obviously bound by that organization’s sometimes allow a reviewer to perpet- will be included with all Casebook high standards for comity and fairness, uate petty animosities and pursue a Premium Memberships. If you would we are quite independent in outlook personal agenda beyond simply inform- like to purchase a no advertisements and operation. First and foremost, that ing readers about a book. Conversely, account on Casebook in addition to means we welcome submissions, let- unsigned reviews also can lead to a receiving a bonus subscription to the ters and comments from EVERYONE. painting of the lily because of friend- Examiner, please click HER E. Submissions will be judged solely on ship or other close association with the That is our story for today: the merit and not the name at the top of author. We will strive to assure neither newest and best magazine in the field the page. If a point is arguable — and happens, but in any case our reviewers has arrived with a pledge to inform rationally argued — it is worthy of pub- will be fully accountable for what they and entertain now and in the future. lication in the Examiner. Indeed, lively write. And opposing views will always We intend to be around a long while but informed controversy is one of our be welcome. and we hope you will join us for that goals and intend to make that happen. This issue has been supplied free long and adventuresome journey as we Nor will personal animus by anyone to all so that everyone could get a real explore not only the evergreen realm at the Examiner toward an individual sense of just what the Examiner will of Ripperology but the related fields of or theory be tolerated or will that ever bring both to the field and to them per- LVP crime and social history. It prom- influence what a contributor may write sonally. Subsequent issues, however, ises to be one heck of a ride in the years — short, of course, of the laws of libel will be available by subscription at a ahead and we urge you to book passage and physics. rate of $9 a year — six big issues for now so you won’t miss a single thrill on In the same vein, all reviews only a dollar fifty each. Moreover, as the Casebook Examiner Express. Welcome to Casebook Examiner Don’T Miss A SingLE GreAT IssUE OF CASEBOOK EXAMINER SUBSCRIBE NOW FOR A WHOLE YEAR SIX BIG ISSUES! FOR ONLY For less than a night at the movies or a And remember, you will not$9 only be Go to WWW .CASEBOOK .ORG /EXAMINE R dyspeptic dinner for two at a fast-food getting the best in JtR fact and fiction, for full subscription details. restaurant you will get a year’s worth along with LVP true crime and social of informative articles, entertaining history articles, but the money will be features and all the exciting news in going to a suitable charity. A winning the field. combination that can’t be beat. THE CASEBOOK Examiner Issue 1 April 2010 5 Exonerating Michael Tom Wescott A Fresh Look At Kidney Some Old Myths While there is not a shred of evidence to support the belief that Elizabeth Stride was murdered by the Ripper this murder is included, for, like that of Martha Tabram, no account of the East End murders would be complete without it. The murder of Stride was a coincidence and, merely because her body was found in a yard, both Press and public jumped to the conclusion that both this murder and that of Eddows [sic] which took place an hour later, was the work of the Ripper… William Stewart, Jack the Ripper: A New Theory, 1939 THE CASEBOOK Examiner Issue 1 April 2010 6 nd such is the genesis of a The Final Solution. But 37 years is a qualifications that the knife used on perspective that not only con- long time; far more than enough for Stride was dull or blunted at the tip, Atinues to this day, but thrives the idea of ‘Stride out’ to settle into or that the doctors said she was killed and multiplies along with the number the back of the minds of researchers with a much shorter knife than that of publications that appear each year coming to the case in the interim. used on Eddowes. None of this is true. dissecting the Ripper’s crimes – that Once an idea takes hold in your The confusion arises over a knife found Elizabeth Stride’s murder is not to be mind, it is not always an easy thing to a street away a full day following the counted among them.