Portrait Medals of Pope Julius II a Dissertation Submitte
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Los Angeles Casting an Ecclesiastical Prince: Portrait Medals of Pope Julius II A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Art History by James Eynon Fishburne 2014 © Copyright by James Eynon Fishburne 2014 ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION Casting an Ecclesiastical Prince: Portrait Medals of Pope Julius II by James Eynon Fishburne Doctor of Philosophy in Art History University of California, Los Angeles, 2014 Professor Joanna Woods-Marsden, Chair The portrait medal was arguably the preeminent humanist genre in the Renaissance, yet the medallic commissions of one of the era’s most important patrons remain largely unexplored. Pope Julius II Della Rovere (born 1445, reigned 1503-13) commissioned more than two dozen medals, the earliest of which date from his cardinalate. Using semiotics and social art history, I place the medals in their appropriate political and art historical contexts while investigating the various sign systems employed in these complex works of art. Portrait medals are double-sided objects inspired by ancient Roman coins. They allowed patrons to fashion personae using words and images with references to antiquity and princely authority. The reproducible format was distributed to nobles and diplomats, often with propagandistic intentions. Ruling during an exceptionally turbulent period in which the papacy was threatened by internal and external forces, Julius and his advisors shrewdly exploited portrait medals in order to project an image of strength and reassert Petrine authority. ii As the temporal ruler of the Papal States and spiritual leader of Western Christianity, the pontiff was unlike any other sovereign figure in Europe. The unique nature of the position, which encompassed both secular and ecclesiastical roles, was reflected in the medals’ inscriptions and iconography. I examine how the medals were used to construct various personae for the controversial cleric who spent much of his pontificate at war. The works of art combined biblical and classical content, thereby presenting the pontiff with a balance of piety and imperial strength. I argue that some medals cast Julius as a pastoral and priestly figure, while others compared him, both implicitly and explicitly, to the emperors of ancient Rome. A thorough study of the medals will provide a greater understanding of the pope’s endeavors, including his attempted reorganization of Roman government, the rebuilding of St. Peter’s Basilica, and the battle for control over the Papal States. iii The dissertation of James Eynon Fishburne is approved. Peter Stacey Charlene Villaseñor Black Robert Gurval Joanna Woods-Marsden, Committee Chair University of California, Los Angeles 2014 iv For Professor Joanna Woods-Marsden v TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................................................... vii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ........................................................................................................................................ xvi VITA ............................................................................................................................................................................. xix INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................................................ 1 I. SETTING THE STAGE: THE PATRONAGE OF POPE JULIUS II AND THE CHRONOLOGY OF HIS MEDALS ......................................................................................................... 14 II. THE PERSONAE OF POPE JULIUS II ................................................................................................ 65 III. FORGING AND EMPIRE: ARCHITECTURAL MEDALS OF POPE JULIUS II ..................... 120 IV. TEXT AND IMAGE: AN IMPERFECT UNION .............................................................................. 161 CONCLUSION ......................................................................................................................................................... 197 APPENDIX: TWO ARTISTS, ONE MEDAL ................................................................................................... 200 FIGURES .................................................................................................................................................................. 205 BIBLIOGRAPHY .................................................................................................................................................... 270 vi LIST OF FIGURES Figure Number Page 1 Caradosso Foppa, Pope Julius II (reverse: St. Peter’s Basilica), 1506, 205 cast bronze, 57 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 2 Pisanello, Emperor John VIII Palaeologus, 1438-1439, cast bronze, 205 102 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 3 Roman Sesterius, AD 74, bronze, 32 mm diameter, 26.16 g, 206 American Numismatic Society, New York. 4 Andrea Guacialoti, Pope Nicholas V, 1455, cast bronze, 78 mm 206 diameter, Vatican Medagliere. 5 Hegesandros, Athenodoros, and Polydoros of Rhodes, The Laocoön, 207 c. First century BC, rediscovered on Esquiline Hill in 1506, Vatican Museums. 6 Pinturicchio, Music, Borgia Apartments, 1492-94, fresco, Vatican 207 Palace. 7 Raphael, Stanza della Segnatura (view of School of Athens and 208 Poetry), 1508-11, fresco, Vatican Palace. 8 Raphael, Stanza della Segnatura (view of Disputa and Law), 1508- 208 11, fresco, Vatican Palace. 9 Raphael, Theology (Disputa), 1508-11, fresco, Vatican Palace. 209 10 Raphael, Philosophy (School of Athens), 1508-11, fresco, Vatican 209 Palace. 11 Raphael, Law (Justice), 1508-11, fresco, Vatican Palace. 210 12 Raphael, Poetry (Parnassus), 1508-11, fresco, Vatican Palace. 210 13 Raphael, Stanza di Eliodoro (view of The Expulsion of Heliodorus 211 and The Mass of Bolsena), 1512-14, fresco, Vatican Palace. 14 Raphael, Stanza di Eliodoro (view of The Repulse of Attila and The 211 Liberation of St. Peter), 1512-14, fresco, Vatican Palace. 15 Raphael, The Liberation of St. Peter, 1512-14, fresco, Vatican 212 Palace. vii 16 Raphael, The Expulsion of Heliodorus, 1512-14, fresco, Vatican 212 Palace. 17 Raphael, The Mass of Bolsena, 1512-14, fresco, Vatican Palace. 213 18 Hartt’s Reconstruction of 1505 design of Michelangelo’s Tomb of 213 Pope Julius II. 19 Michelangelo, Sistine Chapel Ceiling, 1508-1512, fresco, Vatican. 214 20 Sandro Botticelli and assistants, Gallery of Popes (detail), 1482-83, 214 fresco, Vatican (Sistine Chapel). 21 Diagram of Sistine Chapel ceiling showing locations of figures. 215 22 Michelangelo, Ignudo, 1508-1512, fresco, Vatican (Sistine Chapel). 215 23 Della Rovere Stemma, stucco, 1511, Stanza della Segnatura. 216 24 Giovanni Antonio Dosio, View of the Cortile del Belvedere from the 216 Vatican Palace, pen and brown ink with traces of black chalk on paper, 1558-61, Uffizi 2559A, Florence. 25 Donato Bramante, St. Peter’s Basilica (floor plan), c. 1506, Vatican. 217 26 Apollonius of Athens, Belvedere Torso, First century BC, Vatican 217 Museums. 27 Pantheon (cross section), 123-125 AD, Rome. 218 28 Unknown artist from Roman school, Cardinal Giuliano Della Rovere 218 (reverse: Fortress of Ostia), February-November 1483, cast bronze, 34 mm diameter, Museo Nazionale del Bargello, Florence. 29 Unknown artist from Roman School, Pope Sixtus IV (reverse: 219 Fortress of Ostia), February-November 1483, cast bronze, 39 mm diameter, Museo Nazionale del Bargello, Florence. 30 Sperandio of Mantua, Cardinal Giuliano Della Rovere (reverse: ship 219 with allegorical figures), c. 1488, cast bronze, 76 mm diameter, Museo Nazionale del Bargello, Florence. 31 Giovanni Candida, Cardinal Giuliano Della Rovere (reverse: 220 Clemente Della Rovere), March 1495, cast bronze, 62 mm diameter, National Gallery of Art, Washington. viii 32 Unknown artist from Roman School, Cardinal Pietro Barbo, c. 1455, 220 cast bronze, 34 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 33 Unknown artist from Roman School, Cardinal Pietro Barbo, c. 1455, 221 cast bronze, 34 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 34 Adriano Fiorentino (attributed), Cardinal Raffaele Riario, c. 1483, 221 cast bronze, 80 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 35 Lysippus the Younger (attributed), Cardinal Raffaele Riario, 1478, 222 cast bronze, 34 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 36 Unknown artist from Ferrarese School, Cardinal Bartolommeo 222 Roverella, c. 1470, cast bronze, 67 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 37 Unknown artist from Ferrarese School, Cardinal Bartolommeo 223 Roverella, c. 1470, cast bronze, 44 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 38 Unknown artist from Roman school, Pope Julius II (reverse: Cortile 223 del Belvedere), c. 1504, cast bronze, 45 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 39 Portrait of Pope Julius II in illuminated manuscript, Vatican, MS. 224 Vat. lat. 1682, fol. gr (Weiss, 33, cat. e). 40 Caradosso Foppa, Pope Julius II (reverse: St. Peter’s Basilica), 1506, 224 cast bronze, 57 mm diameter, National Gallery of Art, Washington. 41 Donato Bramante, Plan for St. Peter’s Basilica, Gabinetto Disegni e 225 Stampe degli Uffizi (U 1A), Florence. 42 Donato Bramante (attributed), Plan for St. Peter’s Basilica, 1505, 225 Gabinetto Disegni e Stampe degli Uffizi (U 8Av), Florence. 43 Caradosso Foppa, Pope Julius II (reverse: shepherd), 1506, cast 226 bronze, 57 mm diameter, British Museum, London. 44 Camelio, Pope Julius II (reverse: Christ,