Anniversary Issue
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Princeton ToryMay 2009 25th Anniversary Also: THE IssuE March 2008 AND P W THE PRINCETON OINT HAT /C ’S OUNTER WP RONG PRINCETON OINT WITH : G W LOBALOODY W W OO TORY TORYMay 2008 ARMING McCoshed: A special investigation reveals incompetence and ethical lapses at Princeton’s health center Hypocrisy Also Inside: at the LGBT Center The untold story of the Nava response A TORY Exclusive Princeton’s Preacher Sex Jeopardy! & Whit Stillman to Princeton INSIDE: Special ALSO: Stem25th CellAnniversary Research Section! Comes The Princeton Letter from the Publisher The Importance Of Tory Tradition May 2009 eing publisher of this magazine doesn’t afford Volume XXVI - Issue II Bmuch time for reflection on its tradition. One must live from deadline to deadline, handling the idiosyncratic problems that arise, working all the Publisher while with the silent hope that he is “making his Robert Day ’10 mark” on the publication, that he will leave it better Editor-in-Chief Managing Editors off than where he found it. These publisher’s notes Brandon McGinley ’10 Andrew Saraf ’11 – which I affectionately call “my complimentary Aaron Smargon ’11 soap box” – are perfect example of this. Each issue provides me a new opportunity to express my own Copy Editors opinions, a new chance to assert my individuality. Shivani Radhakrishnan ’11 Production Manager I even get my own photo. Ameena Schelling ’12 Alfred Miller ’11 And yet, as I sorted through the 25 years of Tory issues with Brandon David Schuster ’12 McGinley looking for articles to publish in this one, I was hit with a sense of Production Assisstants the tradition I was a part of. I saw quite clearly that I was part of a progression Financial Manager Joelle Birge ’11 of people who had done the same. I was part of a history of publishers, all Steve Lindsay ’12 Christine Bokman ’11 using this space as their own “soap box” - individual photo and all. Indeed, in one year’s time, I too shall join these publishers as part of that history. I will become some future publisher’s past. Publisher Emeritus Operations Manager What I felt in this sudden consciousness of tradition as I waded through Joel Alicea ’10 William Herlands ’12 the archives was not a belittling of my sense of self – this is still my soap box, thank you very much – but in fact a profoundly comforting feeling of Editor-in-Chief Emeritus continuity with my predecessors. And it occurred to me that this feeling ought Leon Furchtgott’09 to extend through the entire Tory community. For we all have played equal Staff Writers parts in a history that we helped write, and that bit we wrote was fundamentally dependent on what had already been written. It is only because of this history, Douglas Lavanture ’09 Matthew Sanyour ’11 for example, that I can intelligibly call this my “soap box” at all. Clint Montague ’09 Aaron Smargon ’11 What I mean to say is that as we move forward, we constantly look to Emely Peña ’09 Emma Yates ’11 our past, whether we are aware of it or not. This maxim is nothing new for Kyle Smith ’09 Kerry Brodie ’12 conservatives of course, and it is for this reason we find something quite perverse Katie Fletcher ’10 Stuart Chessman ’12 in the incautious tirade of our liberal counterparts against the historical and Amy Osterman ’10 William Herlands ’12 social traditions– be it marriage, faith, gender or otherwise – that have played Joelle Birge ’11 Steven Lindsay ’12 such a foundational role in not only sculpting our acts, but our very identity. For this 25th Anniversary Issue, we thought it appropriate to make our Christine Bokman 11 Raphael Murillo 12 ’ ’ backward glance more explicit by publishing a few articles from the past. By Nicholas Elan ’11 Sam Norton ’12 doing so, we honor the Tory’s past, to which we – as Tories – are forever in Bobby Marsland ’11 Ameena Schelling ’12 debt. We first offer you a revealing interview with President Tilghman just three Jeffery Mensch ’11 David Schuster ’12 months after she was elected president, in which she discusses her academic Alfred Miller ’11 Shivani Sud ’12 philosophy, her vision for Princeton, and the question of stem cell research. The Shivani Radhakrishnan ’11 second two articles, one written for Volume One of the Tory in 1985 and the Board of Trustees other for the publication’s 10th anniversary, are themselves reflective pieces. Peter Heinecke ’87 Timothy Webster ’99 The first is a fascinating examination of the state of campus conservatism; the Anna Bray Duff ’92 Peter Hegseth ’03 second, an in depth look at the Tory’s history and influence: a project whose importance I have already provided the reasons for. Brian Tvenstrup 95 Ira Leeds 06 ’ ’ We have not, however, abandoned our tradition in our reflection in it. To Wickham Schmidt ’99 do so would in fact be a most serious affront rather than homage. And so to that The Princeton Tory is a journal of conservative and moderate political thought end, we have three new articles on campus issues and political commentary: written, edited and produced by Princeton University students and delivered free of charge to all Princeton students and faculty. The Princeton Tory is a publication of an examination of the planned budget cuts in light of economic downturns, a The Princeton Tory, Inc. Opinions expressed herein are those of the authors and not look at the prospects of embryonic stem cell research occurring on our very necessarily those of the editors, trustees, Princeton University, or The Princeton Tory, campus, and a comment on the future of the social conservative movement in Inc. The Princeton Tory accepts letters to the editor. Direct correspondence to: such unsure times for the Republican party. Brandon’s Last Word offers his P.O. Box 1499, Princeton, NJ 08542; or by e-mail: [email protected]. Advertise- reflections on the current conservative movement - a piece which should serve ment rates for The Princeton Tory can be found on the magazine’s website at www. our future as well as the past has served us. princetontory.com. Donations to The Princeton Tory are fully tax-deductible. Please mail donations to: P.O. Box 1499, Princeton, NJ 08542. We Tories have much to be thankful to the Tory for, and we have each The Princeton Tory is a member of the Collegiate Network. The Princeton other to thank for it. And so here’s to the Tory on its 25th Anniversary. May Tory gives special thanks to the Intercollegiate Studies Institute, Princeton Alumni Viewpoints, and The Bachman Foundation. she always stand athwart history, yelling “Halt,” so long as that history is not The Princeton Tory, Inc. is a non-profit corporation registered in New Jersey. her own. No part of this publication should be construed to promote any pending legislation or to support any candidate for office. No part of this publication may be reproduced without express written consent of the Publisher. Sincerely, Copyright © 2009 The Princeton Tory Rob Day ‘10 2 The Princeton Tory May 2009 the princeton tory May 2009 - Volume XXVI - Issue II www.princeton.edu/~tory Table of Contents CAMPUS 4 Budget Cuts Reveal University’s Priorities by Nick Elan ’11 Is sustainability or diversity more important to the university? 6 Stem Cell Research Comes to Princeton? by Shivani Sud ’12 Will embryo-destructive research find a home in the Orange Bubble? COMMENTARY 9 The Importance of Social Conservatism by Bobby Marsland ’11 While the Republican Party rebuilds, it must not forget two key social issues. SPE C IA L 25TH ANNIVERSARY SE C TION 11 An Interview with President Shirley Tilghman by Peter Hegseth ‘03 Just three months after being elected president in 2001, the Tory held an interview with Princeton’s first female president. 13 Why is Junior Conservative? by Daniel Polisar ‘87 Written during the its founding year, the Tory published a piece taking an in-depth look at the collegiate conservative immediately following Reagan’s re-election. 16 The First Decade of the Tory: 1984-1994 by Alexander G. Sherman ‘97 For the 10th Anniversary Issue, the Tory dug into its archives and wrote a brief history. LAST WORD 18 The Silver Anniversary by Brandon McGinley ’10 Why morality has always mattered (and always will). May 2009 The Princeton Tory 3 CAMPUS Budget Cuts Reveal University’s Priorities Sustainability Initiative Is Big Winner, While Diversity Loses its Luster Nicholas Elan ’11 were revolutionized in the 1960s? The newly created Office of Sustainability. university administration has often Thus, nearly 60 percent of additions to With the precipitous decline of its readily accepted a range of fashionable, program funding fell under the category of endowment, Princeton was forced to make “progressive” academic and administrative sustainability. a broad set of budget cuts. An investigation initiatives as they emerged. And as each Meanwhile, PriCom declined to fund of these cuts will illuminate the university’s earned its place on the growing list of requests from the Carl Fields Center, priorities. The university’s recent spending the university’s professed imperatives, the Office of Human Resources, and the decisions paint a telling portrait of the the bureaucracy flourished. How would a Office of the Vice Provost for Institutional varied ideological demands faced by the nascent movement, e.g., the sustainability Equity, all of which had asked PriCom to modern academy and outline a hierarchy effort, fare in comparison with the older pay for a Diversity-related bureaucratic among its ideological initiatives, with emphasis on “diversity,” and how would position. For example, the Office of Human newer, more marketable initiatives taking each fare in comparison to less politically Resources wanted permanent funding for priority.