Oslerlibrary Newsletter
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
L OSLER LIBRARY NEWSLETTER McGILL UNIVERSITY, MONTREAL, CANADA No. 23 - OCTOBER 1976 One of the treasured possessions of the Osler Library is the set of portraits of Linacre, Harvey, and Syden- THE LINACRE, HARVEY, AND ham which once adorned William Osler's library first SYDENHAM TRIPTYCH in Baltimore and later in Oxford. At the request of the Editorial Committee Dr. A.H.T. Robb-Smith has traced the history of this triptych and the results of his research are published in this Newsletter. N THE OSLER LIBRARY AT McGill University portraits of Thomas Linacre, William Harvey, they might be copied as a birthday present tor her husband. and Thomas Sydenham hang in So it was that the 'triptych' came to adorn Osler's libraries a triple frame. Their history goes in Baltimore and Oxford, "for though his teacher Burdon back a century to December 19, 1876 when Dr. Samuel W. Gross, Sanderson came between, it would almost seem as though son of Dr. S.D. Gross the doyen Acland had knowingly handed on an emblem of the Regius of American surgeons, married Professorship to the man destined, in the whirligig of time and place, to become his successor"3. These are the por- Miss Grace Revere. Five years later the young couple repre- sented the elder Dr. Gross at the Seventh International traits that hang in the Osler Library at McGill University and we can only add a little to their history and that of the Medical Congress in London and were feted everywhere, staying in London with the President, Sir James Paget, in originals from which they were derived. his Regent's Park house, and attending a dinner at which It has been suggested that the idea of this triumvirate came were present the Prince and Princess of Wales and their .from Dr. Richard Quain's proposal that three niches in the nephew, the future German Emperor. After the Congress portico of the Pall Mall building of the Royal College of was over they were received in Oxford by the Regius Pro- Physicians of London should be filled with statues of Linacre, fessor, Dr. Henry Acland, and in later years, when Mrs. Harvey, and Sydenham. These were carved by Henry Weekes Gross had become Mrs. Osler, she would recall the Acland and put in position in 1876, but the evidence would suggest home at 39 Broad Street (the New Bodleian Library now that Acland's portraits preceded this and were more likely occupies the site) with its long entrance passage, cluttered an act of filial piety to the college which had elected him a with statues and knick-knacks, leading to the dining room fellow in 1842, for Linacre and. Sydenham had both been and the two libraries. Benjamin Woodward, the architect of fellows of All Souls, while Harvey had been Warden of Mer- the Oxford Museum, had designed the larger library with its ton College, to which the Linacre lecturers were attached. gasoliers and tall bookcases up to the beamed ceiling. Pic- It would take too long in this article to describe in detail tures, plaster casts, curios and papers were scattered every- the originals from which Acland's portraits were derived where so that it was hard to find anywhere to sit down. but a full account has been deposited in the Osler Library. There was a massive fireplace devised by Ruskin and carved It must suffice here to state that the Linacre is a copy of a by Jack O'Shea, Woodward's artistic Irish mason, while high portrait in Windsor Castle which has been in the Royal above it hung the portraits of Linacre, S'ydenham, and Collection since early in the seventeenth century, but it was Harvey in a triple frame with their names and dates below not until 1734 that it was acclaimed .lSa representation by and on the frame above "Literae, Praxis, Scientia." There is Quentin Matsys of Thomas Linacre, though modern art a photograph of the Library in J.B. Atlay's memoir of critics question both attributions. The portrait of Thomas Henry Aclandl and of the portraits in A.W. Franklin's Sydenham is based on an engraving by Jakob Houbraken "Osler transmitted - A study in humanism"2 . of a lost painting said to have been by Sir Peter Lely and formerly in the possession of John Sydenham, the physi- In 1894 it was young Professor Osler from Johns Hopkins cian's grandson. The Harvey is certainly derived from the and his wife who were calling on Sir Henry Acland, now so-called official portrait in the Royal College of Physicians nearly 80. It was Osler'sJirst visit to Oxford. He had come which was formerly attributed to Cornelius Johnson (jans- to England to attend the Bristol meeting of the British Medical Association as well as that of the British Association sen) but is now considered to be by some unknown artist and perhaps painted posthumously. It will be convenient to for the Advancement of Science. On entering Sir Henry trace the history of the Acland portraits first and then turn Acland's library he looked up at the portraits in the triple to the copies made for the Osiers. frame that his wife had seen about a dozen years before and exclaimed with delight. Indeed he made such a to-do Sir Henry Acland died on October 16th, 1900, at the age about them that Mrs. Osler subsequently asked Sir Henry if of 85, but his affairs had long been in order and in a codicil The historiated letter on this page is from Realdo Colombo, De re anatomica libri XV (Venetiis: Ex typographia Nicolai Brevilacquae, 1559; BibL Oslo 897). ;- 2 to his will, dated March 14th,. 1893, he bequeathed to the Pepper, as Osler recalled, had been well grounded in morbid University of Oxford, an astronomical clock, John Hunter's anatomy in which he made some important contributions chair, and "The portraits of Sydenham, Linacre and Harvey but initially he had little interest in clinical pathology, in one frame to be kept in the room at the Museum of the though he did provide two small laboratories, primarily in- Regius Professor of Medicine." Osler, as the RegiusProfes- tended for chemical tests, under the new lecture theatre sor, inherited this room. He wrote in 1905 "I have very which was built in 1872 for the Philadelphia University nice official rooms at the Museum, with two laboratory Hospital. It was Osler's arrival in 1884 that turned one of rooms attached, ... .4 It was there that he found the three these rooms into a clinical research laboratory with "an portraits which had thrilled him on his fIrst visit to Oxford atmosphere so encouraging and helpful that young fellows eleven years before. Appropriately Dr. T.D. Acland, Sir trooped to his side"? Ten years later Dr. Pepper, now Henry's son, in his contribution on "The Oxford University Provost of the University, proposed the creation of a Lab- Museum" in the Festschrift for Osler's 70th birthday wrote oratory of Clinical Medicine - in fact clinical research - in "Literae - Scientia - Praxis. So runs the legend inscribed memory of his father and to the design of Dr. John Shaw beneath the portraits of three distinguished sons of Oxford Billings, at that time Director of the Hospital as well as in the Regius professor's room at the University Museum. Professor of Hygiene. The portraits were a legacy from Sir Henry Acland ... ."5 Osler would certainly have heard of these proposals when But it is curious that neither Sir Henry in his will nor Dr. Acland in this article were concerned as to the correct order he delivered his address 'The Leaven of Science' at the open- ing of the Wistar Institute of Anatomy in Philadelphia on in which the portraits were arranged in the frame. May 21, 1894, and so it is not surprising that when he saw, In 1954 the Regius Professor relinquished the last of his only two months later, Sir Henry Acland's triptych of the rooms in the Museum for which Sir Henry Acland had three physicians - scholar, clinician, and experimentalist - fought so hard a century before. Two years later Sir George he felt it would form an ideal emblem for what was to be Pickering became the fIrst Regius, since Osler, to reside in the first clinical research laboratory to be built in the United 13 Norham Gardens. Acland's triptych was moved to 13 States; so it was that two copies of the Acland triptych Norham Gardens where it now hangs in the Regius Profes- were made, one for Osler himself and one for the Pepper sor's offIce over the maple wood mantelpiece made from Laboratory. doors in Dr. S.D. Gross' home in Philadelphia and brought by the OsIers to Baltimore and thence to Oxford. This Despite a thorough search of the Pepper manuscripts, it has office was formerly Lady Osler's drawing room and her not been possible to determine when the portraits were re- carpet is still on the floor. ceived in Philadelphia, but it must have been sometime in 1896, as on January 13th, 1897, Osler was answering Reverting to Osler's visit to Oxford in 1894, he and his Pepper's enquiry as to their provenance. He wrote "Drum- wife were back in Baltimore by October 1st and on Novem- mond has sent me word with reference to the pictures. The ber 14th, Osler was writing to Sir Henry Acland "If the Linacre was copied from the painting by Holbein; Sydenham Artist has finished copying the portraits would you kindly from the one by Sir Peter Lely; Harvey from the painting ask him to have them framed and lettered and then care- by Cornelius Jansen [Janssen] in the C~llege ofPhysicians"g.