Baseline Survey for Farmers Organizations of Mirwal and Shahpur Small Dams, Punjab, Pakistan
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Report NO. R-38 SOCIAL ORGANIZATION FOR IMPROVED SYSTEM MANAGEMENT AND SUSTAINABLE IRRIGATED AGRICULTURE IN SMALL DAMS BASELINE SURVEY FOR FARMERS ORGANIZATIONS OF MIRWAL AND SHAHPUR SMALL DAMS, PUNJAB, PAKISTAN MUHAMMADASGHARCHEEMA DON JAYATISSA BANDARAGODA DECEMBER 1997 PAKISTAN NATIONAL PROGRAM INTERNATIONAL IRRIGATION MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE. PAKISTAN CONTENTS Contents ...................................................... i Annexes ...................................................... iii Tables ....................................................... iv Figures ....................................................... vi Foreword ..................................................... vii Acknowledgements .............................................. viii Chapter-I INTRODUCTION ....................................... 1 1.1 Background ........................................... 1 1.2 Objectives of the Study .................................. 2 1.3 Methodology .......................................... 2 1.4 Organization of the Report ............................... 7 Chapter-2 CHARACTERISTICS OF THE COMMUNITY AND THERESPONDENTS ................................... 8 2.1 Community Characteristics ................................ 8 2.1.1 Mirwal Small Dam ................................. 8 2.1.2 Shahpur Small Dam ................................ 9 2.2 Residential Status of the Respondents ...................... 10 2.3 Caste Structure of the Respondents ........................ 11 2.4 Father's Occupation .................................... 13 2.5 Educational Level of the Respondents ....................... 13 2.6 Household Size of the Respondents ........................ 15 2.7 Working Family Members ................................ 16 2.8 Tenurial Status of the Respondents ........................ 17 2.9 Size of Landholding .................................... 18 2.10 Machinery ........................................... 22 Chapter-3 IRRIGATION PRACTICES. WAl-ER MANAGEMENT AND IRRIGATION SYSTEM PERFORMANCE ..................... 23 3.1 Irrigation Practices ..................................... 23 3.1.1 Sources of Irrigation ............................... 23 3.1.2 Extent of Satisfaction .............................. 23 3.1.3 Methods Used to Overcome Deficiency .................25 i 3.2 Irrigation System Performance ............................ 26 3.2.1 Equity in Water Distribution .......................... 26 3.2.2 Adequacy of Irrigation Water from Small Dams ........... 29 3.3 Functional Condition of Dam. Water Channels and Watercourses ..................................... 32 Chapter-4 INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT ......................... 35 4.1 Water Users Association ................................ 35 4.1.1 Existence of WUA ................................ 35 4.1.2 Membership of WUA .............................. 35 4.2 Organizational Behavior ................................. 36 4.3 Willingness to Work with Other People ...................... 37 4.4 Type of Organization Initiated ............................. 38 4.5 Advantages of Farmers Organizations at Small Dam Level ........39 4.6 Land Levelling ........................................ 40 4.7 Benefits from Representatives of Government Agencies ................................. 41 Chapter-5 AGRONOMIC PRACTICES. CROPPING INTENSITY. FARM OUTPUT AND INCOME .......................... 43 5.1 Cropping Pattern ...................................... 43 j1 5.2 Agronomic Practices in Irrigated Area ....................... 44 5.2.1 Seed Rate Used ................................. 44 5.2.2 Fertilizer Used ................................... 50 5.2.3 Production of Various Crops ......................... 51 5.2.4 Prices of Various Crops Received by the Farmers .........52 5.2.5 Crop Expenditures ................................ 54 5.3 Agronomic Practices in Barani Area ........................ 54 5.3.1 Seed Rates Used ................................. 55 5.3.2 Fertilizer Used ................................... 55 5.3.3 Production of Various Crops ......................... 56 5.3.4 Crop Expenditures ................................ 57 5.4 Cropping Intensity ..................................... 59 5.5 Land Use Intensity ..................................... 60 5.6 Livestock ............................................ 63 5.7 Household Income ..................................... 64 5.8 Ranking of Factors Responsible for Crop Production Increases ............................... 65 ii Chapter-6 ISSUES ............................................ 69 6.1 Ensured Dam Water Supply .............................. 69 6.2 Water Rights ......................................... 69 6.3 Water Conveyance Network .............................. 69 6.4 Land Levelling ........................................ 70. 6.5 Farm Productivity ....................................... 70 I REFERENCES ................................................. 71 i ANNEXES Annex-I Questionnaire ........................................ 73 Annex-2 Basic Information on Three Selected Small Dam Systems ........ 86 iii ! TABLES 1.1 Distribution of Respondents According to their Village . 6 1.2 Distribution of Respondents by Irrigated and Barani Land . 7 2.1 Characteristics of Communities in Mirwal Small Dam Area . 9 2.2 Characteristics of Communities in Shahpur Small Dam Area . 10 2.3 Distribution of Respondents with Regard to Their Residential Status . 11 2.4 Caste Structure of the Respondents . 11 2.5 Distribution of Respondents with Regard to Father's Occupation . 13 2.6 Distribution of Respondents with Regard to Educational Attainment ....................................... 15 2.7 Mean Number of Family Members by Age, Schooling Status and Literacy Rate . 16 2.8 Mean Number of Working Family Members and Their Enterprise 17 2.9 Tenurial Classification of the Respondents . 17 2.10 Classification of the Respondents with Respect to Size of Holding (Percentage) . 18 2.1 1 Area Owned Operated, Levelled and Potential for Levelling by type of Irrigation . 21 2.12 Percentage of Respondents Owning Tractors and other Implements ....................................... 22 3.1 Sources of Irrigation . 23 'I 3.2 Extent of Satisfaction from Sources of Irrigation . 25 3.3 Methods Used for Overcoming Deficiency of in Meeting Water Requirements . , . 25 3.4 Irrigation Methods Practiced by the Water Users . 26 3.5 Perceptions About Equity in Distribution of Water . , . 28 3.6 Perceptions for Inequitable Water Distribution . , . 28 3.7 Sufficiency of Irrigation Water During Kharif 1996 . 29 3.8 Sufficiency of Irrigation Water During Rabi 1995-96 . 31 3.9 Extent of Satisfaction from Small Dam Water Supply . 31 3.10 Perceptions of Farmers Regarding Improvement I of Water Distribution . 32 3.1 1 Present Functional Condition of Dams, Water Channels and Watercourses as Compared to 5 Years Earlier . 33 4.1 Existence of Water Users Association . 35 4.2 Member of Water Users Association . 36 4.3 Current Level of Organized Behavior of the Respondents . 36 I 4.4 Respondents' Willingness to Work with other People of the Area . 37 4.5 How Farmers Perceive Their Contribution in Working with Other People . 38 iv 4.6 Farmers who Initiated any Kind of Organization ............. 38 4.7 Type of Organization Initiated .......................... 38 4.8 Distribution of Respondents Who Agreed with "Organized People Work Effectively" ..................... 38 4.9 Advantages of Farmers Organizations at Small Dam Level ..... 39 4.10 Distribution of Respondents Who had Their Land Levelled ..... 40 4.11 Reasons for not Getting Land Levelled ................... 40 4.12 Distribution of Respondents who Heard About Precision Land Levelling ............................. 41 4.13 Source of Information About Precision Land Levelling ........ 41 4.14 Benefits from Representatives of Various Government Agencies ............................... 42 5.1 Cropping Pattern in Irrigated and Barani Areas ............. '43 5.2 Mean Seed Rates Used per Kanal for Various Crops (Irrigated) . 49 5.3 Mean Fertilizer Used per Kanal for Various Crops (Irrigated) in Kilograms ............................... 50 5.4 Mean Production of Various Crops Per Kanal (Irrigated) ....... 51 5.5 Mean Price (in Rs.) of Various Crops per 40 Kg (Irrigated) ..... 52 5.6 Mean Expenditures (in Rs.) per Kanal for Various Crops (Irrigated) ........................................ 54 5.7 Mean Seed Rates Used per Kanal for Various Crops (Barani) .................................... 55 5.8 Mean Fertilizer Used per Kanal for Various Crops (Barani) in Kilograms ........................... 56 5.9 Mean Production of Various Crops per Kanal (Barani) ........ 57 5.10 Mean Price (in Rs.) of Various Crops per 40 Kg (Barani) ...... 59 5.1 1 Mean Expenditures (in Rs.) per Kanal of Various Crops (Barani) 59 5.12 Cropping Intensities for Mirwal and Shahpur Small Dams ...... 60 5.13 Land Used Intensity for Mirwal and Shahpur Small Dams ..... 60 5.14 Mean Number of Livestock in the Project Areas ............. 63 5.15 Mean Income from Various Sources (in Rs.) of the Respondents Under Mirwal and Shahpur Small Dams .................. 64 5.16 Average Income from Various Sources (in Rs.) of the Respondents (Farmers having Land 1600 kanals and Above are not Included) 65 5.17 Ranking of Factors Associated with Increase in Crop Production . 68 V FIGURES 1 .I Location Map of Mirwal and Shahpur Small Dams ............ 3 1.2 Irrigation System Network of the Mirwal Dam ............... 4 1.3 Irrigation System Network of Shahpur Dam ................