Cliff Notes: Text and Image at Baodingshan
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS As with any extended research project, there are many who have helped to see this dissertation through to fruition. Dr. Hu Wenhe of the Sichuan Provincial Research Institute was extremely gracious in helping me clarify issues related to the Great Buddha Bend grotto, especially with regard to their underlying Chinese themes. I would also like to thank Dr. Lothar Ledderose for his willingness to provide me with materials related to the sutra-carving tradition in China, and Dr. Henrik Sørenson for pointing out the relatedness of the sutra carvings at Baodingshan to inscribed texts found elsewhere in Sichuan. Grants from the Samuel Kress Foundation, the Asian Cultural Council and the Metropolitan Center for Far Eastern Studies aided me in my research in China in 1999 and 2000. I would also like to take this opportunity to thank the Morris family for their continuing support of art history at the University of Kansas, and the University of Oregon Department of Art History for providing me with the initial funding in 1993 to return to China for my first foray into on- site work at Baodingshan. Lastly, I would especially like to thank the members of my committee: Drs. Amy McNair, Marsha Haufler, Sherry Fowler, Daniel Stevenson, and Charles Lachman. Amy must be recognized for the expert advice and guidance she has given me, helping me through not only the mound of material that was my original research project on Baodingshan, but also through the maze of academia. Her self-discipline and clarity of purpose are something I shall always aspire to. Dr. Stevenson expertly overcame my ignorance of the nuances of vi Chinese Buddhism with a true bodhisattva-like attitude for which I will forever be grateful. Drs. Haufler and Fowler must be acknowledged for being willing and more than able to serve on my committee, providing positive and productive feedback from which this work has most certainly benefited. And finally, I must thank the last member of my committee, Dr. Charles Lachman, for without his quest for a taste of tea-smoked duck, this dissertation would never have even been dreamed of. viii ILLUSTRATIONS Figure Page 1. Schematic drawing of Great Buddha Bend at Baodingshan, Dazu County, Sichuan. 243 2. Aerial view of the Baodingshan monastic complex, with plan of site. 244 3. Schematic drawing of Beishan cave site, Dazu County, Sichuan. 245 4. Sculptural grouping from the Scripture on Skillful Means of the Buddha’s Repayment of Kindness tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 246 5. Rubbing of Yuwen Ji stele inscription, Great Buddha Bend. 246 6. Photo of ‘fu’ and ‘shou’ characters at Great Buddha Bend 247 7. Detail from tableau number 21. 247 8. View of the Scripture on the Kindness of Parents tableau. 248 9. View of the Scripture on Skillful Means of the Buddha’s Repayment of Kindness tableau. 249 10. View of the Amitayus-dhyana Scripture. 250 11. View of Dizang Bodhisattva with the Ten Kings of Hell and the Eighteen Hell scenes. 250 12. View of Tableau number 21, the ‘Asceticism of Master Liu’. 251 13. View of the Taming of the Wild Buffalo tableau. 251 14. Diagram of Great Buddha Bend narrative tableaux showing large textual blocks. 252 15. a.table showing imagery within Dunhuang caves and b.table of bian wen texts found at Dunhuang related to Baodingshan’s Great Buddha Bend imagery. 253-4 ix 16. Wall painting from Kizil depicting bian xiang in use. 254 17. Drawing of east end of Great Buddha Bend grotto. 255 18. Wei Liaoweng inscribed placard from pagoda at Great Buddha Bend. 256 19. Wei Liaoweng inscribed placard from Vairocana cave at Great Buddha Bend. 256 20. Du Xiaoyan inscribed placard from Great Buddha Bend. 257 21. Overview of Scripture on the Kindness of Parents tableau. 258 22. Overview of The Buddha Preaches the Mahayana Scripture on the Skillful Means for Repaying Kindness. 259 23. a. Father and mother figures central to the Kindness of Parents tableau, and b. diagram of the tableau. 260-1 24. First of the 10 Kindnesses in the Kindness of Parents tableau. 262 25. Second of the 10 Kindnesses in the tableau. 262 26. Third of the 10 Kindnesses in the tableau. 263 27. Fourth and sixth of the 10 Kindnesses in the tableau. 263 28. Fifth of the 10 Kindnesses in the tableau. 264 29. Seventh of the 10 Kindnesses in the tableau. 264 30. Eighth of the 10 Kindnesses in the tableau. 265 31. Ninth of the 10 Kindnesses in the tableau. 265 32. Tenth of the 10 Kindnesses in the tableau. 266 33. Depiction of the lowest level of the tableau. 266 34. Detail of hell demon in lowest level of the Kindness of Parents tableau. 267 35. a. Central Buddha figure in the Repayment of Kindness tableau, and b. diagram of the tableau. 267-8 x 36. First vignette of the Repayment of Kindness tableau. 269 37. Detail of Ananda and the inscribed text from the first vignette of the Repayment of Kindness tableau. 269 38. a. detail of son shouldering his parents from the first vignette of the Repayment of Kindness tableau, and b. six heretics in Repayment of Kindness tableau. 270 39. Detail of six realms of being portrayed in central Buddha figure’s nimbus in the Repayment of Kindness tableau. 271 40. Lowest level of the left side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau. 271 41. Second level of the left side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the Buddha at his father’s deathbed. 272 42. Second level of the left side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the “sacrifice for a stanza”. 272 43. Second level of the right side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau. 273 44. Second level of the right side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the parents mourning their son in a scene from the Hungry Tigress jataka. 273 45. Second level of the right side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the prince Jati offering up his flesh to feed his parents. 274 46. Inscription carved above the Repayment of Kindness tableau. 274 47. Third level of the right side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the 32 Filial Characteristics of the Buddha. 275 48. Third level of the right side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the prince offering up his eyes for his father. 275 49. Third level of the left side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the blind parents grieving over the body of Prince Samaka. 276 xi 50. Third level of the left side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the king cutting his own flesh. 276 51. Third level of the left side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the filial prince and the goose. 277 52. Third level of the right side of the Repayment of Kindness tableau showing the story of the filial parrot. 277 53. Diagram of the Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 278 54. The Six Vices tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 279 55. Diagram of the Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 280 56. Overview of the Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 281 57. Overview of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 282 58. Detail of the central Buddha pentad in the Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 283 59 Detail of a newborn soul in the Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 283 60. Pure Land image from niche number 245 at Beishan, Dazu County. 284 61. Detail of monk figure in 16 Visualizations, Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 285 62. Detail of military figure in 16 Visualizations, Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 285 63. Detail of young woman figure in 16 Visualizations, Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 286 64. Detail of scholar figure in 16 Visualizations, Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 286 65. Detail of a second monk figure in 16 Visualizations, Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 287 66. Looking over to hell from the Pure Land tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 288 xii 67. Buddhas of the 10 Directions above Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 288 68. Dizang Bodhisattva figure in Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 289 69. Two figures flanking Dizang Bodhisattva figure in Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 289 70. Image of Zhao Zhifeng as monk in Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 290 71. Officer of Immediate Retribution on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 291 72. King Guang of Qin on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 291 73. King of the First River on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 292 74. Bathing of Buddha tableau from Great Buddha Bend showing channeling of water runoff. 292 75. Sovereign King of Song on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 293 76. King of the Five Offices on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 293 77. King Yama on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 294 78. King of Transformations on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 294 79. King of Mt. Tai on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 295 80. Impartial King on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 295 81. King of the Capital on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend. 296 xiii 82. King who Turns the Wheel on second tier of Hell tableau at Great Buddha Bend.