DOCSLIB.ORG

The Ethics of Meta-Witnessing in Yannick Haenel's Jan Karski

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Ethics of Meta-Witnessing in Yannick Haenel's Jan Karski The Ethics of Meta-Witnessing in Yannick Haenel’s Jan Karski Helena Duffy Royal Holloway, University of London The research leading to these results has received funding from the Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (MSCA) of the European Union’s research and innovation program Horizon 2020, under grant agreement number 654786. This is a Pre-Print of an article published by Taylor & Francis [Dapim: Studies on the Holocaust 32.1 (2018)], https://doi.org/10.1080/23256249.2018.1432254. 1 We move now to outside a German wood. Three men are there commanded to dig a hole In which the two Jews are ordered to lie down And be buried alive by the third who is a Pole. Not light from the shrine at Weimar beyond the hill Nor light from heaven appeared. But he did refuse. A Lüger settled back deeply in its glove. He was ordered to change places with the Jews. Much causal death had drained away their souls. The thick dirt mounted towards the quivering chin. When only the head was exposed the order came To dig him out again and to get back in. No light, no light in the blue Polish eye. When he finished a riding boot packed down the earth. The Lüger hovered lightly in its glove. He was shot in the belly and in three hours bled to death. Anthony Hecht, ‘More Light! More Light!’ A ‘false novel’ or a ‘false testimony’? Published in September 2009 as part of Gallimard’s prestigious L’Infini series, Jan Karski narrates the life of Jan Romuald Kozielewski (Karski’s real name), a key figure of the Polish Resistance who during World War II acted as one of the couriers ensuring communication between the Underground and the Polish government in exile, residing first in Paris and then, after the Germans invaded France, in London. Yet, rather than for his perilous missions, one of which ended in Karski’s capture by the Gestapo, the Polish courier is best known for his efforts to persuade the Western Allies to act upon the extermination of the Jews carried out by the Nazis in German-occupied Poland. Indeed, Haenel’s key objective is to pay tribute1 to ‘the man who tried to stop the Holocaust’,2 an ambition confirmed by the fact that all the three parts making up this self-consciously hybrid text speak of Karski’s clandestine visits to the Warsaw Ghetto and the transit camp of Izbica Lubelska. Otherwise the book’s three parts, which greatly vary in length and texture, focus on different stages of Karski’s life and career. Part I offers an ekphratic description of the Polish courier’s testimony in Claude Lanzmann’s documentary Shoah (1985) in which he recounts his meeting with two Jewish leaders who entrusted him with the task of communicating the Jews’ tragedy to the world, and his 1 ‘Entretien avec Yannick Haenel: Précisions sur Jan Karski’, Mémoires occupées: Fictions françaises et Seconde Guerre mondiale, ed. by Marc Dambre (Paris: Presses Sorbonne Nouvelle, 2013), 233-47 (p. 235). 2 This is how Karski has often been referred to since the publication of E. Thomas Wood’s and Stanisław M. Jankowski’s authorised biography, Karski: How One Man Who Tried to Stop the Holocaust (New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1994). 2 traumatic visits to the ghetto and the camp he infiltrated on their recommendation. Part II then summarizes the Polish courier’s own memoirs, Story of the Secret State (1944), which relate Karski’s work for the Polish resistance and his diplomatic missions to London and Washington. Much longer than Parts I and II and strikingly different in tone, Part III concentrates on the Polish hero’s postwar life in America and is narrated by an imaginary Jan Karski who is speaking to us from beyond the grave. As if trying to forestall any misunderstandings or criticism provoked by this daring mix of fact and fiction, in the author’s note Haenel scrupulously distinguishes between the first two parts, which are documentary, and Part III that is fictional.3 It seems that by staging a highly positive hero, whose commitment to the Jewish cause has been officially acknowledged by both Israel and America, 4 and by displaying a truly reverential attitude towards his courageous and righteous protagonist, Haenel should have been spared the sort of criticism that Jonathan Littell faced on publishing Les Bienveillantes four years earlier. Indeed, having been awarded two important French literary prizes,5 Jan Karski became an overnight critical and commercial success, and earned its hitherto relatively unknown author many honours.6 In this context, the accusations that Claude Lanzmann levelled at Haenel in January 2010 came as a surprise; the author of Shoah criticised the novelist for having plagiarised his documentary and, worse still, for having written a ‘false novel’ and falsified history, as well as for lacking imagination and talent. Lanzmann also claimed that Haenel had misrepresented Karski by showing him in a simplistic way as a ‘pleurnichard et véhément procureur qui met le monde entier en accusation pour n’avoir pas sauvé les Juifs’.7 Around the same time, prominent Holocaust historian, Annette Wieviorka, launched her crusade against Haenel’s book, calling it a ‘false testimony’ and thus implicitly equating it with Jerzy Kosiński’s or Binjamin Wilkomirski’s faked accounts of their 3 In interviews Haenel redefined the third past as ‘fiction intuitive’ and highlighted the fictionality of Parts I and II. This is because these offer a subjective representation of the documentary texts that in themselves are partial in both senses of the word. See ‘Entretien avec Yannick Haenel’, 237. 4 In 1982, Yad Vashem recognised Karski as Righteous Among the Nations, in 1994 he was made an honorary citizen of Israel, and in 2012 Barack Obama awarded Karski the Presidential Medal for Freedom. 5 The Prix Interallié and Prix du roman FNAC. 6 Haenel was made Chevalier de l’Ordre des Arts et des Lettres and received the Order of Merit of the Republic of Poland. 7 Claude Lanzmann, ‘Jan Karski de Yannick Haenel: un faux roman’, Les Temps modernes 657 (January-March 2010), online. 3 childhood survival of the Holocaust. 8 Wieviorka also condemned the anachronism of Haenel’s conception of World War II politics consisting in the book’s resolute anti-American stance. Finally, she took exception to Haenel’s alleged relativisation of Polish anti-Semitism and, agreeing with Lanzmann, reproached him for having taken inadmissible liberties with historical truth, which the novelist reportedly replaced with ‘un certain nombre de ‘vérités’ qui sont les siennes dans une totale désinvolture à l’égard de l’histoire’.9 It is noteworthy that the afore-cited accusations were quickly taken up and repeated in Karski’s homeland, a fact that seems puzzling given Haenel’s adulatory attitude towards the Polish hero and his romanticised image of Poland itself.10 The debate then moved from the pages of newspapers and magazines to scholarly journals where, once again, Haenel found his supporters and detractors. 11 Rather than trying to re-evaluate the novel’s historical veracity or further discuss the ethics of its marriage of fact and fiction but nevertheless polemicising with certain points of 8 Published in 1965 as an autobiographical novel, Kosinski’s The Painted Bird was later denounced as fiction. See Eliot Weinberger, Karmic Traces 1993–1995 (New York: New Directions, 2000), 56. Likewise, Wilkomirski’s Fragments: Memories of a Wartime Childhood were exposed as a fake and its author as an impostor. See, for example, Andrea Reiter, ‘Memory and Authenticity: The Case of Binjamin Wilkomirski’, The Memory of Catastrophe, ed. by Peter Grey and Kendrick Oliver (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2004), 132-45. 9 Annette Wieviorka, ‘Karski témoigne: La réponse d’Annette Wieviorka’, L’Histoire 379 (March 2014), online. For more details on the acrimonious exchanges between Haenel and his critics, see Richard J. Golsan, ‘L’“Affaire Jan Karski”: Réflexions sur un scandale littéraire et historique’, Mémoires occupées, pp. 183-90. 10 Among the critics who reacted to Jan Karski were the journalist Leopold Unger, the President of the Jan Karski Society, Kazimierz Pawełek, and a score of prominent journalists such as Aleksandra Klich or Jarosław Kurski. See, for example, Leopold Unger, ‘On ne touche pas à Jan Karski’, Courrier international, 15.02.2010, online; Aleksandra Klich, ‘Ksero z życia Karskiego’ [‘A Photocopy of Karski’s Life’], Gazeta Wyborcza, 28.09.2010, online; Jarosław Kurski, ‘Karykatury Jana Karskiego’ [‘Caricatures of Jan Karski’], Gazeta Wyborcza, 22.03.2010, online; Kazimierz Pawełek, ‘Karski n’a jamais soupçonné les États-Unis de trahison’, Le Point, 04.02.2010. 11 Among Haenel’s most severe critics is Golsan who has endorsed Lanzmann’s and Wieviorka’s judgment of the novel, adding further arguments against Haenel’s writing. He described Jan Karski as a novel where ‘distortion bleeds into scandalous revisionism’ and its protagonist as ‘a problematic and dubious witness’, as well as ‘a falsifier of history’. See Richard J. Golsan, ‘The Poetics and Perils of Faction: Contemporary French Fiction and the Memory of World War II’, The Romanic Review 105.1- 2 (2014), 53–68 (p. 63 and p. 65). More positive have been Philippe Carrard, Manuel Braganca, Pavel Hladki, and Evelyne Ledoux-Beaugrand. See Philippe Carrard, ‘Historiographic Metafiction, French Style’, Style 48.2 (Summer 2014), 181-202, Manuel Braganca, ‘Faire parler les morts: Sur Jan Karski et la controverse Lanzmann-Haenel’, Modern and Contemporary France 23.1 (2015), 35-46, Pawel Hladki, ‘“Qui témoigne pour le témoin?” Question de la liberté littéraire à l’exemple de Jan Karski de Yannick Haenel’, Études romanes de Brno 33.1 (2012), 57-67, Evelyne Ledoux-Beaugrand, ‘Les restes d’Auschwitz: Intertextualité et postmémoire dans Jan Karski de Yannick Haenel et C’est maintenant du passé de Marianne Rubinstein’, Études françaises 49.2 (2013), 14562, and ‘Emprunt et bricolage: Traces mémorielles de la Shoah dans Drancy Avenir et Jan Karski’, French Forum 39.1 (Winter 2014), 143-57.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Surv Surv Script
    Surviving Survival 9/2/09 p.1 SURVIVING SURVIVAL ** Bach Morimur I’ve been thinking about survivors: survivors of holocaust, of genocide, survivors of terrorist attacks. and survivors of illness, of epidemic . survivors of domestic violence, of poverty, of deprivation. My question is not – how do you survive? My question is – how do you survive your own survival? Because it’s a blessing to live through something, to escape the body’s or the spirit’s destruction. But what about those you left behind – the ones who didn’t make it? the other patient, the war buddy, the little sister; the fireman, the rescue worker… the ones who did not survive? You don’t forget them. You can’t. I’M EK. THIS TIME ON S&S – SURVIVING SURVIVAL. What is the way to healing? Some survivors say you must forget the past, bury the loss, put it behind you as quickly as possible. Others need to mourn, to memorialize; they tell their stories over and over to anyone who will listen. It is important to have a purpose, a goal, a reason that’s it’s all right for you to have been the one who was saved. You dedicate your life to something: to raising children, to bearing witness, to making music, to saving others. CAMBODIA Start with mood music – melancholy – for Cambodia: *** NEW INTERNATIONAL TRIO (something sad-sounding) OR *** Rak Smey Khemera: "Light From Heaven" TK. 5? 6? It’s almost impossible to comprehend what happened in Cambodia during Pol Pot’s regime, beginning in 1975: an entire population uprooted, deliberately murdered by the HUDNREDS of thousands in the killing fields .
    [Show full text]
  • Il Ruolo E La Funzione Del Falso Nella Storia Della Shoah
    IL RUOLO E LA FUNZIONE DEL FALSO NELLA STORIA DELLA SHOAH. STORICI, AFFAIRES E OPINIONE PUBBLICA Thèse en cotutelle entre l’Université de Bologne Alma Mater Studiorum et l’Université Paris X Nanterre (Ed 395 École Doctorale Milieux, Cultures et Sociétés du Passé et du Présent, Doc Histoire du monde contemporain). Membres du jury: Prof. Henry Rousso (rapporteur), Prof. Luciano Casali (rapporteur), Prof. Marie Anne Matard Bonucci (rapporteur), Prof. Alfonso Botti (Président du jury). «Citai di nuovo, per non diventare idillico in prima persona, il poeta che dice: “Quanto hai vissuto, nessuna potenza del mondo può togliertelo”. Ciò che abbiamo realizzato nella pienezza della nostra vita passata, nella sua ricchezza d’esperienza, questa ricchezza interiore, nessuno può sottrarcela. Ma non solo ciò che abbiamo vissuto, anche ciò che abbiamo fatto, ciò che di grande abbiamo pensato e ciò che abbiamo sofferto... Tutto ciò l’abbiamo salvato rendendolo reale, una volta per sempre. E se pure si tratta di un passato, è assicurato per l’eternità! Perché essere passato è ancora un modo di essere, forse, anzi, il più sicuro». Viktor E. Frankl - Uno psicologo nei Lager INDICE INTRODUZIONE p. 4 PREMESSA p. 15 CAPITOLO I QUESTIONI DI METODO STORICO p. 32 1. La dimensione di massa della storia contemporanea. p. 33 2. La storia del tempo presente. p. 37 3. Della difficile coesistenza di storia e memoria. p. 42 4. Il dovere di storia. p. 46 5. Sulla testimonianza. p. 51 6. Le testimonianze della Shoah. p. 56 CAPITOLO II FALSI TESTIMONI, ALCUNI CASI DI STUDIO p. 67 1. I primi falsari.
    [Show full text]
  • Lessons from the Treblinka Archive: Transnational Collections and Their Implications for Historical Research Chad S.A
    Journal of Contemporary Archival Studies Volume 5 Article 14 2018 Lessons from the Treblinka Archive: Transnational Collections and their Implications for Historical Research Chad S.A. Gibbs University of Wisconsin-Madison, cgibbs4@wisc.edu Follow this and additional works at: https://elischolar.library.yale.edu/jcas Part of the Archival Science Commons, European History Commons, and the Jewish Studies Commons Recommended Citation Gibbs, Chad S.A. (2018) "Lessons from the Treblinka Archive: Transnational Collections and their Implications for Historical Research," Journal of Contemporary Archival Studies: Vol. 5 , Article 14. Available at: https://elischolar.library.yale.edu/jcas/vol5/iss1/14 This Case Study is brought to you for free and open access by EliScholar – A Digital Platform for Scholarly Publishing at Yale. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Contemporary Archival Studies by an authorized editor of EliScholar – A Digital Platform for Scholarly Publishing at Yale. For more information, please contact elischolar@yale.edu. Lessons from the Treblinka Archive: Transnational Collections and their Implications for Historical Research Cover Page Footnote No one works alone. True to this statement, I owe thanks to many for their assistance in the completion of this work. This article began as a seminar paper in Professor Kathryn Ciancia's course "Transnational Histories of Modern Europe." I thank her and my classmates for many enlightening discussions and the opportunity to challenge my ongoing research in new ways. As always, I thank my advisor at the University of Wisconsin- Madison, Professor Amos Bitzan. His guidance and example are always greatly appreciated. In completing this work, I also had the support of my colleague Brian North and Professors Christopher Simer of the University of Wisconsin-River Falls and Connie Harris of Dickinson State University.
    [Show full text]
  • Apocalypse and Australian Speculative Fiction Roslyn Weaver University of Wollongong
    University of Wollongong Research Online University of Wollongong Thesis Collection University of Wollongong Thesis Collections 2007 At the ends of the world: apocalypse and Australian speculative fiction Roslyn Weaver University of Wollongong Recommended Citation Weaver, Roslyn, At the ends of the world: apocalypse and Australian speculative fiction, Doctor of Philosophy thesis, Faculty of Arts, University of Wollongong, 2007. http://ro.uow.edu.au/theses/1733 Research Online is the open access institutional repository for the University of Wollongong. For further information contact the UOW Library: research-pubs@uow.edu.au AT THE ENDS OF THE WORLD: APOCALYPSE AND AUSTRALIAN SPECULATIVE FICTION A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY from UNIVERSITY OF WOLLONGONG by ROSLYN WEAVER, BA (HONS) FACULTY OF ARTS 2007 CERTIFICATION I, Roslyn Weaver, declare that this thesis, submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the award of Doctor of Philosophy, in the Faculty of Arts, University of Wollongong, is wholly my own work unless otherwise referenced or acknowledged. The document has not been submitted for qualifications at any other academic institution. Roslyn Weaver 21 September 2007 Contents List of Illustrations ii Abstract iii Acknowledgments v Chapter One 1 Introduction Chapter Two 44 The Apocalyptic Map Chapter Three 81 The Edge of the World: Australian Apocalypse After 1945 Chapter Four 115 Exile in “The Nothing”: Land as Apocalypse in the Mad Max films Chapter Five 147 Children of the Apocalypse: Australian Adolescent Literature Chapter Six 181 The “Sacred Heart”: Indigenous Apocalypse Chapter Seven 215 “Slipstreaming the End of the World”: Australian Apocalypse and Cyberpunk Conclusion 249 Bibliography 253 i List of Illustrations Figure 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Treblinka Camp, Located in Eastern Poland, Between the Summers of 1942 and 1943
    CCarloarlo MMattogno,attogno, JJürgenürgen GGrafraf Holocaust survivors report that at least 700,000, if not as many as three million people primarily of Jewish faith were murdered in the Treblinka camp, located in eastern Poland, between the summers of 1942 and 1943. Various murder weapons are claimed to have been used: mobile or stationary gas chambers; poison gas with delayed or immediate effect; unslaked lime; hot steam; high voltage; machine guns; vacuum chambers; chlorine Camp? Transit or gas; Zyklon B; diesel exhaust gas. According to the witnesses, Extermination Camp TTreblinkareblinka the corpses of the victims were fi nally incinerated on pyres as high as a multi-story building without leaving any traces. • EExterminationxtermination CampCamp In the fi rst part of this book, the offi cial image portrait of Treblinka is subjected to a thorough critique regarding its oorr TTransitransit CCamp?amp? historical genesis, inner logic, and technical feasibility. The result of this analysis is essentially that the historical picture, which is prescribed by penal law in many European countries, is untenable, because it is nothing more than an uninterrupted chain of absurdities. In the second part of this book, the authors attempt to deter- mine the real function of the Treblinka camp with the help of witness statements, documents, and forensic fi ndings. Through their analysis, they conclude that Treblinka was a transit camp, through which Jews from Warsaw and other areas were led on their way either to occupied Soviet territories in the east or to Treblinka the Majdanek camp and other labor camps in the area south of Treblinka.
    [Show full text]
  • Wartime Hiding Places of Jews in Occupied Poland
    11 This book is an anthropological essay which aims to capture the elu- sive phenomenon of hideouts employed by Jews persecuted during Marta Cobel-Tokarska the Second World War. Oscillating between life and death, the Jewish hideouts were a space of the most diverse and extremely complex hu- man relations – a specific realm of everyday life, with its own inherent logic. Based on different literary sources, especially wartime and post- war testimonies of Jewish escapees, the author seeks to examine the realm of hideouts to develop a novel, interdisciplinary perspective on this often neglected aspect of the 20th-century history. Desert Island, Burrow, Grave Wartime Hiding Places of Jews in Occupied Poland Marta Cobel-Tokarska is a Polish sociologist working at the intersection Hiding Places of Jews in Occupied Poland Wartime of sociology of culture, anthropology, literature, and recent history. · Studies in Jewish History and Memory Marta Cobel-Tokarska ISBN 978-3-631-67438-3 www.peterlang.com SJHM_011 267438_Cobel-Tokarska_TL_A5HC 151x214 globalL.indd 1 04.10.18 01:44 11 This book is an anthropological essay which aims to capture the elu- sive phenomenon of hideouts employed by Jews persecuted during Marta Cobel-Tokarska the Second World War. Oscillating between life and death, the Jewish hideouts were a space of the most diverse and extremely complex hu- man relations – a specific realm of everyday life, with its own inherent logic. Based on different literary sources, especially wartime and post- war testimonies of Jewish escapees, the author seeks to examine the realm of hideouts to develop a novel, interdisciplinary perspective on this often neglected aspect of the 20th-century history.
    [Show full text]
  • Genocide Genres: Reading Atrocity Testimonies Katherine Wilson University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
    University of Wisconsin Milwaukee UWM Digital Commons Theses and Dissertations May 2013 Genocide Genres: Reading Atrocity Testimonies Katherine Wilson University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee Follow this and additional works at: https://dc.uwm.edu/etd Part of the Comparative Literature Commons Recommended Citation Wilson, Katherine, "Genocide Genres: Reading Atrocity Testimonies" (2013). Theses and Dissertations. 326. https://dc.uwm.edu/etd/326 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by UWM Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of UWM Digital Commons. For more information, please contact open-access@uwm.edu. GENOCIDE GENRES: READING ATROCITY TESTIMONIES by Katherine Wilson A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in English at The University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee May 2013 ABSTRACT GENOCIDE GENRES: READING ATROCITY TESTIMONIES by Katherine Wilson The University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, 2013 Under the Supervision of Professor Jane Gallop “Genocide Genres” investigates the transnational circulation of atrocity testimony, writing which describes the most spectacularly failed of human encounters. In particular, my project compares the production and reception of atrocity narratives across three distinct, post-WWII discourses: 1) Holocaust studies, 2) the modern human rights movement, and 3) international criminal law. Each discourse, I argue, sets formal limits on individual testimonies in order to regulate their function institutionally, directing not only which testimonies are read but how those accounts should be read. As a result, testimonies become generic. We see this demonstrated by the emergence of identifiable genres such as Holocaust literature and human rights literature, and the successful “passing” of faked accounts in each discourse.
    [Show full text]
  • Holocaust Book Collection
    Lawrence Seeborg 3076 Finlandia Court Sandy, UT 84093 801 942-5235 There are approximately 463 books in this collection. These were collected over a period of 30 years. All titles are in fine or near-fine condition. All but three titles are in their original publisher’s dust jackets. All but 32 titles are 1st printings. All titles are enclosed, with their dust jackets, in clear, polyester library jacket covers. Emphasis was placed on first-person accounts of holocaust survivors when forming this collection. This collection offered en bloc only. Holocaust Book Collection As of January 22, 2018 Note: Unless otherwise noted, all titles listed below are hardbound 1st printings with their original dust jackets. • indicates a copy that is not a 1st printing •• indicates a hardbound copy missing dust jacket ••• indicates a copy published only in the softbound format •••• indicates hardbound copy published without dust jacket Abrams, Alan. Special Treatment Ackerman, Diane. The Zookeeper’s Wife (300 jews are hidden during holocaust in Warsaw zoo) Adachi, Agnes. Child of the Winds – My Mission with Raoul Wallenberg Adelsberger, Lucie. A Doctor's Story (a Jewish female physician's memoir of Auschwitz) Adelson, Alan (editor). The Diary of David Sierakowiak Adelson, Alan & Lapides, Robert (ed). Lodz Ghetto Adler, Alice Dunn. Boriska’s Prophecy (owner of fashion boutique in Budapest survives Auschwitz) Alpert, Nachum. The Destruction of Slonim Jewry (destruction of the Jews in the city of Slonim, Poland) Aly, Götz. Into The Tunnel (story of brief life of Jewish girl killed in Auschwitz at the age of 11) Anger, Per. With Raoul Wallenberg in Budapest (small library stamp on title page) Anne Frank House (compiler).
    [Show full text]
  • False Memoir Syndrome Sue Vice
    False Memoir Syndrome Sue Vice In this paper, I will consider what seems to be a recent plethora of false Holocaust testimonies. These are of two different kinds: entirely fictional, and partially embellished. Under the former heading fall Binjamin Wilkomirski’s Fragments (1995), Bernard Holstein’s Stolen Soul (2004) and Misha Defonseca’s Surviving with Wolves (2004); under the latter Deli Strummer’s A Personal Reflection of the Holocaust (1988) and Herman Rosenblat’s Angel at the Fence (which was scheduled for publication in 2009 but withdrawn), as well as Martin Gray’s earlier augmented work, For Those I Loved (1971). I will ask whether these texts should be considered as part of a general cultural study of false memoirs (such as James Frey’s A Million Little Pieces and Margaret Jones’s Love and Consequences) but will argue that false and embellished Holocaust testimony does fall into a separate category. While it may be true that Holocaust fakes are created by a particular climate of publication and marketing, these inauthentic works also cast light on Holocaust literature and testimony in general, in terms of what readers expect of such works and whether Holocaust testimony is a literary genre which can be imitated like any other. I will conclude by arguing that these false memoirs are in fact very useful texts which allow us to consider what happens as the Holocaust passes from an event in living memory to one that is in the past. Sue Vice is Professor of English Literature at the University of Sheffield, UK. Her recent publications include Holocaust Fiction (2000) and Children Writing the Holocaust (2004).
    [Show full text]
  • The Politics of the Second World War in Communist Poland
    Studies in Contemporary History 4 4 Studies in Contemporary History 4 Joanna Wawrzyniak Joanna Wawrzyniak Veterans, Victims, and Memory Wawrzyniak Joanna In the vast literature on how the Second The Author Veterans, Victims, World War has been remembered in Joanna Wawrzyniak is Deputy Director of Europe, research into what happened the Institute of Sociology at the University in communist Poland, a country most of Warsaw, where she also heads the Social and Memory affected by the war, is surprisingly scarce. Memory Laboratory. She has published The long gestation of Polish narratives extensively on the relationship between of heroism and sacrifice, explored in history and memory in Poland, the uses The Politics of the Second World War this book, might help to understand of oral history, and the current state why the country still finds itself in a of memory studies in Central-Eastern in Communist Poland ‘mnemonic standoff’ with Western Europe. Recently she was a visiting Europe, which tends to favour imagining fellow at Freiburg Institute for Advanced the war in a civil, post-Holocaust, human Studies and at Imre Kertész Kolleg in Jena rights-oriented way. The specific focus of (Germany). this book is the organized movement of war veterans and former prisoners of Nazi camps from the 1940s until the end of the 1960s, when the core narratives of war became well established. Veterans, VictimsVeterans, and Memory ISBN 978-3-631-64049-4 Joanna Wawrzyniak - 978-3-653-99681-4 Downloaded from PubFactory at 01/11/2019 11:05:35AM via free access
    [Show full text]
  • REVIEWS • Robert Enrico's Au Nom De Tous Les Miens
    • REVIEWS • Robert Enrico's Au nom de tous les miens For those who lived through the real Holocaust, watching the 1979 television miniseries Holocaust was nonetheless traumatic. In once-occupied countries like France, the showing of the series became a subject for furious debate, vociferous denials that the Holocaust had ever taken place and a resurgence of anti-Semitism. Some film producers felt there was a need for more films about the terrible wartime martyrdom of the Jews of Europe, and began cast­ ing about for stories. The France-Canada coproduction Au nom de tous les miens, which recently had its world.premiere in Montreal, is one of these films. Martin Gray IMajcek Grayewski) is a 58-year-old Warsavian, and a survivor of the Warsaw Ghetto, the Treblinka death camp, the Polish underground, the Soviet Red Army, and various business endeavors in the U.S. and France. In 1970, while living in the south of France, Gray's wife and family were killed in a forest fire, and Gray, after contempla­ ting suicide, turned instead to writing. His 1971 autobiography, "Au nom de tous les miens" ghostwritten by French novelist and presidential cultural advisor Max Gallo, would sell 35 million copies worldwide and be translated into 19 languages. Gray held onto the film rights for 10 years, until Frenchl producers Andre Djaoui and Jacques­ • Descent into the Nazi inferno: Au nom de tous les miens' Michael York and Macha Meril arriving in the Warsaw Ghetto Eric Strauss and Franco-Italian film director Robert Enrico persuaded him actor, 24-year-old Jacques Penot, who can be played with Canada's not espe­ film home, so to speak, to recoup some they could make a film that would be plays the young Martin Gray, struggles cially am using official coproductions of the $2 million Canadian that went faithful to the book's message of life.
    [Show full text]
  • Treblinka: Extermination Camp Or Transit Camp?
    Treblinka Extermination Camp or Transit Camp? CAVEAT: The first two editions of the present book appeared in 2004 and 2005. Since that time, the authors have found a wealth of additional documents and testimonies. Most of them are discussed in the two-volume, 1396-page study of 2013 titled The “Extermination Camps” of “Aktion Rein- hardt”: An Analysis and Refutation of Factitious “Evidence,” Deceptions and Flawed Argumentation of the “Holocaust Controversies” Bloggers, and au- thored by Carlo Mattogno, Jürgen Graf and Thomas Kues. It deals with all three “Aktion Reinhardt” camps (Belzec, Sobibor and Treblinka). Readers in- terested in a more-thorough study of the present topic are advised to also consult this study, which can be downloaded as a PDF file free of charge at www.HolocaustHandbooks.com (Volume 28). Most of the new insights pre- sented in that voluminous study were not included in the present slightly ex- panded edition. However, we have included an update on “Modern Forensics at Treblinka” starting on page 311. Castle Hill Publishers Treblinka Extermination Camp or Transit Camp? Carlo Mattogno and Jürgen Graf Castle Hill Publishers P.O. Box 243, Uckfield, TN22 9AW, UK 3rd edition, May 2020 HOLOCAUST HANDBOOKS, Volume 8: Carlo Mattogno, Jürgen Graf: Treblinka: Extermination Camp or Transit Camp? Slightly expanded 3rd edition With an epilogue by Germar Rudolf and a supplement by Thomas Kues Uckfield, East Sussex: CASTLE HILL PUBLISHERS P.O. Box 243, Uckfield, TN22 9AW, UK May 2020 ISBN13: 978-1-59148-252-9 (print edition) ISBN10: 1-59148-252-6 (print edition) ISSN: 1529-7748 Published by CASTLE HILL PUBLISHERS Manufactured worldwide © 2002, 2004, 2005, 2020 by Carlo Mattogno, Jürgen Graf Distribution: Castle Hill Publishers PO Box 243, Uckfield, TN22 9AW, UK https://shop.codoh.com Set in Times New Roman.
    [Show full text]