Sustainable Energy Access in Eastern Indonesia Power Generation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Sustainable Energy Access in Eastern Indonesia—Power Generation Sector Project (RRP INO 49203) Environmental Impact Assessment Project Number: 49203-002 March 2018 INO: Sustainable Energy Access in Eastern Indonesia─Power Generation Sector Project Kaltim Peaker 2 Core Subproject Prepared by Fichtner for the Asian Development Bank. This environmental impact assessment is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area. Final Version March 2018 CONSULTING SERVICES FOR "TA-9082 INO: Preparing the Eastern Indonesia Sustainable Energy Access Sector Project“ KALTIM PEAKER 2 Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (Final Report) 7203F96/FICHT-19631702-v1 Sarweystrasse 3 ● 70191 Stuttgart P.O. 10 14 54 ● 70013 Stuttgart Germany Phone: +49 711 8995-0 Fax: +49 711 8995-459 www.fichtner.de Please contact: Dr. Werner Miller Extension: 418 E-mail: [email protected] 7203F96/FICHT-19631702-v1 Rev Checked/releas Rev-date Contents /amendments Prepared/revised No. ed 0 27.04.2017 ESIA - Draft Zajac / Ningtyas Miller 1 28.06.2017 ESIA - Draft revised Sousa Miller 2 14.08.2017 ESIA - Draft final Zajac Sousa 3 06.10.2017 ESIA - Final Zajac Miller 7203F96/FICHT-19631702-v1 Disclaimer The content of this document is intended for the exclusive use of Fichtner’s client and other contractually agreed recipients. It may only be made available in whole or in part to third parties with the client’s consent and on a non-reliance basis. Fichtner is not liable to third parties for the completeness and accuracy of the information provided therein. 7203F96/FICHT-19631702-v1 Table of Contents I. Executive Summary I-1 A. The project I-1 B. Legal requirements I-3 C. Project categorization I-4 D. Environmental and social baseline conditions I-4 E. Impact assessment I-6 F. Environmental Management and Monitoring Plan I-10 G. Public participation I-11 H. Overall Findings and Recommendations I-11 II. Introduction II-14 A. Project Background and Objective II-14 B. Project need II-14 C. Scope of the Study II-14 D. Data sources II-15 E. Project categorization II-15 F. Project area of influence II-16 III. Institutional and Legislative Framework III-1 A. National Legal and Institutional Framework III-1 1. National Legal and Institutional Framwework III-4 2. Indonesian Law III-6 3. Indonesian Government Regulations III-6 4. Indonesian Minister Decrees III-7 B. International Guidelines and Standards III-13 1. International Agreements III-13 2. ADB Safeguards Error! Bookmark not defined. C. Gaps between national requirements and international standards III-14 IV. Description of the Project IV-16 A. Project setting IV-16 1. Project location IV-16 2. The project site IV-17 3. Access to the project site IV-18 B. Technical Description IV-20 1. Existing Tanjung Batu and Kaltim 1 Power Station Complex IV-20 2. Planned Technical Infrastructure for Kaltim Peaker 2 IV-22 C. Project Associated facilities IV-24 D. Project variants IV-29 E. No-Project option IV-30 V. Description of the Environment V-31 A. Physical environment V-31 B. Natural environment V-42 7203F96/FICHT-19631702-v1 I C. Human environment V-51 1. Kutai Kartanegara District V-51 Cultural heritage V-53 2. Project site V-53 VI. Environmental Impact Assessment and Mitigation Measures VI-1 A. Methodology VI-1 1. Scoping VI-1 2. Assessment criteria VI-2 3. Cumulative impacts VI-3 B. Design Phase and Pre-Construction Impacts VI-4 C. Construction Phase Impacts VI-5 1. Physical Environment VI-5 2. Natural Environment VI-9 3. Human Environment VI-12 D. Operation Phase Impacts VI-15 1. Physical Environment VI-15 Mitigation and Monitoring Error! Bookmark not defined. 2. Natural Environment VI-33 3. Human Environment VI-35 Mitigation and Monitoring VI-36 E. Cumulative impacts VI-37 VII. Public participation VII-38 VIII. Grievance Redress Mechanism VIII-39 IX. Environmental Management and Monitoring Plan IX-41 A. Institutional Framework and Procedural Arrangements for Environmental Compliance IX-42 B. Self-monitoring and external auditing IX-42 X. Costs of EMP Implementation X-1 XI. Overall Findings and Recommendations XI-2 A. Kaltim Peaker 2 Error! Bookmark not defined. B. Mitigation Error! Bookmark not defined. C. Cumulative Impacts Error! Bookmark not defined. XII. References XII-5 Annexes XII-7 A. Maps of the project site and the investigation area XII-7 B. Public Participation and Meetings XII-7 C. Air Emission Expert Study XII-7 7203F96/FICHT-19631702-v1 II D. Noise Emission Expert Study XII-7 E. Land Certificate XII-7 F. Hazardous Waste Permits XII-7 G. Noise control for power plants, Short overview of basic principles and examples XII-7 H. Biodiversity Study XII-7 7203F96/FICHT-19631702-v1 III List of Tables Table 1: Summary of the main project facilities .................................................... IV-29 Table 2: Various Types of Geological Formations (Source: Agriculture and Horticulture Agency Kutai Kartanegara, 2010) ........................................ V-32 Table 3: Various Types of Soil (Source: Agriculture and Horticulture Agency Kutai Kartanegara, 2010) .......................................................................... V-32 Table 4: Summary of water quality measurements from the semi-annual monitoring Reports for the Tanjung Batu Power plant complex (average values). ....................................................................................... V-36 Table 5: Water quality data from the semi-annual monitoring Reports for the Tanjung Batu Power plant complex. ......................................................... V-37 Table 6: Rainfall and Rainy Day by Month (Source: District of Tenggarong Seberang in Figures, 2016) ....................................................................... V-38 Table 7: Multiplying factor to convert 24 hour concentrations to 1 hr concentrations (adapted from EPA, 1992) ................................................ V-39 Table 8: Multiplying factors for point sources to convert 1 hour concentrations to other averaging periods (*OME, 2008, and **EPA, 1992) ............................................................................................ V-40 Table 9: Air Quality measured and converted data in the project area (adapted from data directly received) ....................................................... V-40 Table 10: Results of the semi-annual noise measurements in the years 2014, 2015, and 2016 .......................................................................................... V-41 Table 11: Maximum calculated 10 minutes SO2 concentrations and comparison with the air quality standards ................................................ VI-21 Table 12: equations and parameters used to calculate the Project GHG emissions .................................................................................................. VI-27 Table 13: worst case scenario when all three power plants are operational 24 hours a day and both Kaltim 1 and Kaltim 2 Peakers use HSD as a primary fuel. ................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined. Table 14: Calculated A-weighted downwind sound pressure level LA(DW) at the POIs for operation of the existing power plants Tanjung Batu and Kaltim 1 and level increase L caused by the additional contribution from Kaltim Peaker 2. ......................................................... VI-32 Table 15: Suggestion of an External Auditing Plan for the Kaltim Peaker 2 .......... IX-43 Table 16: Outline of an Environmental Management and Monitoring Plan for Kaltim Peaker 2 - Pre-Construction and Construction phase................... IX-44 Table 17: Outline of an Environmental Management and Monitoring Plan for Kaltim Peaker 2 - Operation phase .......................................................... IX-55 7203F96/FICHT-19631702-v1 IV List of Figures Figure 1: Location of the planned project site Kaltim Peaker 2 (marked in yellow), bordering the existing Kaltim 1 Peaker site and the Tanjung Batu Power Station Complex area in the North. ........................ IV-16 Figure 2: Location of the planned project site Kaltim Peaker 2 (marked in yellow), bordering the existing Kaltim 1 Peaker site and the Tanjung Batu Power Station Complex area in the North ....................................... IV-17 Figure 3: View from the top of the Diesel tank within the Kaltim Peaker 1 site to the neighbouring Kaltim Peaker 2 site. At the left side of the picture, at the other side of the fence, the abandoned office buildings can be seen and in the far background the school building. ..................... IV-18 Figure 4: Access from/to Sultan Aji Muhammad Sulaiman Airport, Balikpapan................................................................................................ IV-19 Figure 5: Murinin road from/to Temindung Airport, Samarinda, to/from the Tanjung Batu complex. ............................................................................ IV-20 Figure 6: Tanjung Batu Power Plant (Gas Turbines, 60 MW) ................................ IV-21 Figure 7: Kaltim Peaker 1 Power Plant (Gas Turbines, 100 MW) .......................... IV-21 Figure 8: Layout plan of the planned