14Th Annual Peggy Glanville-Hicks Address 2012
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
australian societa y fo r s music educationm e What Would Peggy Do? i ncorporated 14th Annual Peggy Glanville-Hicks Address 2012 Michael Kieran Harvey The New Music Network established the Peggy Glanville-Hicks Address in 1999 in honour of one of Australia’s great international composers. It is an annual forum for ideas relating to the creation and performance of Australian music. In the spirit of the great Australian composer Peggy Glanville-Hicks, an outstanding advocate of Australian music delivers the address each year, challenging the status quo and raising issues of importance in new music. In 2012, Michael Kieran Harvey was guest speaker presenting his Address entitled What Would Peggy Do? at the Sydney Conservatorium on 22 October and BMW Edge Fed Square in Melbourne on 2 November 2012. The transcripts are reproduced with permission by Michael Kieran Harvey and the New Music Network. http://www.newmusicnetwork.com.au/index.html Australian Journal of Music Education 2012:2,59-70 Just in case some of you are wondering about I did read an absolutely awe-inspiring Peggy what to expect from the original blurb for this Glanville-Hicks Address by Jon Rose however, address: the pie-graphs didn’t quite work out, and and I guess my views are known to the address powerpoint is so boring, don’t you agree? organisers, so, therefore, I will proceed, certain For reasons of a rare dysfunctional condition in the knowledge that I will offend many and I have called (quote) “industry allergy”, and for encourage, I hope, a valuable few. everyone’s sanity, I promise I will mention only In preparing this address I would like to one statistic, one… HORRIFYING …statistic, acknowledge the indispensable help of the during this entire speech. eminent poet and psychiatrist Professor Saxby Pridmore, the composer and my inspiring What would Peggy do? friend Dr Nigel Westlake, the imperturbable and dignified Sally Howland of APRA, the phenomenal Before I properly begin, I must admit that I am at CEO of the AMC John Davis and the virtuosic odds with many of my artmusic colleagues on musicologist/mandolinist Dr Michael Hooper. I a range of issues. I note also that many of them would like to especially thank the AMC Advisory have far too much “common-sense” to agree to Committee for putting up with my outrageous give this address, apart from those squealing for outbursts of outrage at their various meetings... yet more cash for their grand opera of course, but when I found out the truth about AMC funding. that’s hardly surprising. One need only read their Now, what would Peggy say about the state of opera plot summaries. [Circular finger-motion at classical music in Australia? (Here I am referring temple]. Australian Journal of Music Education 59 Harvey to notated music primarily, but the definition I’m is based in Melbourne. Astra has managed sure can embrace all artmusic). for over 60 years to present new Australian 1. I think she would notice immediately how compositions and nurture new performers well women are doing as performers and despite capricious and insufficient funding, composers - a quick glance through a which recently has been cut to zero, I’m wonderful recent publication, Women of ashamed to say! In my reckoning, Astra’s work Note, by Rosalind Appleby confirms this under the extraordinary John McCaughey (and I strongly recommend this publication has premiered more Australian compositions to you all); Peggy would then wryly observe than any other group, and many performers, how women are now just as equally ignored myself included, continue to be developed by and discriminated against by our taxpayer- this wonderful, cash-strapped organisation. I subsidised orchestras and opera companies would like to know who it was at the Australia as their male counterparts WARNING: Council who knocked back their meagre STATISTIC ALERT!!! - only 7 percent – 7 percent funding this year, and for what reason? - [show 7 fingers for photo opportunity!] of This is especially galling in the light of the our orchestral programs and even less of gluttonous triennial funding of the orchestras our opera season is Australian music; (this and opera which together produce the includes old music by wannabe Poms such as pathetic aforementioned statistic of Australian Percy Grainger and wannabe Elgars, wannabe work. [Again show 7 fingers]. Ravels, wannabe Brahms, Poots and Parrys 4. Peggy Glanville-Hicks would be astonished etc etc). at the diversity of recordings of Australian 2. Peggy would rejoice that there is still an art music by self-funded, independent labels Australian Music Centre representing like Tall Poppies and Move despite the unfair Australian composers, and performers, to the advantage of extravagantly taxpayer-funded world. This, in spite of the efforts of certain labels which produce mainly old-fashioned hostile funding bodies to starve it of funds. pap in comparison; do we really need obscure Why, she would ask, is this amazing resource, French operas, another boxed set of dreary under the dogged and inspired leadership and expensive Mahler symphonies? Is this the of John Davis, not directly federally funded apex of Australian culture? Or Wagner Spin like the National Film and Sound Archives cycles?? Gimme a break! or indeed the National Library, such that its 5. Peggy would be outraged that no Australian important work is not constantly impeded by conductor laureates are leading our endless funding applications and mystifying orchestras, or championing our composers, movements of the goalposts? Why is the AMC as Challender and Patrick Thomas briefly did at a crisis point and facingeviction?! Peggy with the SSO, giving left-field composers like would wonder, as do I. Carl Vine an opportunity to develop their skills 3. She would marvel at how well groups like with orchestral music. In the case of Carl, I ASTRA have done (a group I mention simply must also mention the support he received because I can speak from long experience from the wonderful Graeme Murphy and with them; I know there are many others the Sydney Dance Company, and ASTRA, struggling to survive). The Astra Chamber particularly John McCaughey without whose music society, for those of you unfamiliar with house and bathroom accessories Carl’s string our musical equivalent of La Mama Theatre, quartet, the “Brunswick”, would not have been written. 60 2012, No. 2 14th Annual Peggy Glanville-Hicks Address 6. Peggy would be further outraged that the 9. Peggy would wonder why there is not a very same operas by Bellini, Mozart, Verdi magnificent Stuart and Sons piano in every and Wagner which she heard as a girl are concert hall and school in Australia - and still being presented now at Australian bemoan the fact that once again Australian taxpayer’s expense, while her own operas and ingenuity and superior design, such as that of symphonic works are ignored. As are most these NSW instrument makers are struggling other Australian composers. As an aside, to survive against the cultural cringe, and these ancient Bellinis, Mozarts, Verdis and against monopolistic and reactionary foreign Wagners must inevitably be pale imitations brands. And no, I am not a Stuart and Sons of superior overseas productions. We could artist (although I wish I was, Wayne if you’re never hope to match overseas cultural listening!). budgets, and neither should we try. Personally 10. Despite the lack of funding encouragement, I think the money’s better spent on original Peggy would be delighted at the emergence work. Instead of spending 10 million on an of young Australian advocates of new individual sporting gold medal why not music such as Zubin Kanga, Clare Edwardes, create a decent Australian opera or symphony Anthony Pateras, Aura Go, James Nightingale with this amount? It would provide jobs for and all the folk at the New Music Network, untold numbers of Australian musicians into Eugene Ughetti, Genevieve Lacey, Ian the distant future, and maybe even give Grandage, Vanessa Tomlinson, Ekki Waldheim, audiences some pleasure and self-respect. It The Australian Art Orchestra, Kate Neal, Ashley would certainly justify the existence of these Smith, Natsuko Yoshimoto, Elliott Gyger, my “gas-guzzling” organisations to the taxpayer siblings Dom, Bern and Rowan, Peter DeJager, more than their current programming. the astonishing brothers Dean and Grigoryan, 7. Peggy would be deeply distressed at the Annie Hsieh, Mathew Hindson, Jane Stanley Foxification (pron. Fuxification) of our and Damian Barbeler, to name but a few of culture, I refer here to the monopolisation the many who have flown through my narrow of entertainment. I believe this would make orbit. Peggyeven more determined to produce 11. Peggy would be frustrated by the failure of independent work, more determined to classical music around the globe to adapt to resist the awful competition philosophy this new world full of technology. Everything triumphantly promoted by certain powerful is miniaturizing, and being made more local individuals. efficient, smarter, doing more with less. And 8. Peggy would note that in the area of classical I believe it is in this light that she would music the Australian cultural cringe definitely carefully examine the current persisting remains. There is no problem with the arrangement of opera companies, orchestras number or quality of Australian composers or and the conservatoria. I do not think she performers; we punch well above our weight would be desperate to preserve the “golden for such a population. There is a problem, age” of classical music, at least I don’t believe however, and it is that Australian classical she would want to preserve the “golden music audiences still regard Australian music age” of classical music, AT ANY COST. There and performers as inferior.