Implications for China's Tourist Attractions
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Article Meta-Understanding of Environmental Perception in Tourism: Implications for China’s Tourist Attractions Jinlian Shi 1 and Jing Sun 2,* 1 Business School, Beijing Technology and Business University, Beijing 100048, China; [email protected] 2 Institute of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing 100081, China * Correspondence: [email protected] Received: 10 January 2020; Accepted: 17 February 2020; Published: date Supplementary Materials Sustainability 2020, 12, x; doi: FOR PEER REVIEW www.mdpi.com/journal/sustainability Table S1. Literature used in meta-analysis with detailed information, including name of tourist attraction, province, tourist or resident, ticket price, attraction type, environmental perception, reference, page number of notes, and notes. ID Name of Provinc Tourist Ticke Attractio Attractio Environmental References Notes Notes tourist e or t n rating n type perception (Positive: 1; on attraction Residen price Negative: 0) page t 1 Ba Tscu Fujian Tourist 95 5 Natural 0 CHEN Zaifu. 113- In this paper, a 5-point Likert Scale is Ueung attraction Analysis on the 114 adopted to investigate the Park & Service Quality of “environmental health services brought Baishuiyan Fujian Baishuiyang by residents to tourism”. The results g Park Scenic Spot. showed that the average performance Management and of “environmental health services” was Administration, 2011, 2.20, which is unsatisfactory and the (11) :112-114. problems of "disorder and dirty" are prominent. The number of Tourist cannot be well controlled and the Tourist can be properly arranged in the peak season. There is always a phenomenon of mass Tourist stay at the entrance of the scenic area in large quantities. That is, Tourist are negative. 2 Fujian Fujian Tourist 100 5 Man- 1 CHEN Zaifu. 56 This paper constructs the IPA four- Earthen made Analysis of Service quadrant diagram by using the average Structures attraction Quality of Fujian value of the importance factor score Nanjiang Earth and the average value of the Building Based on performance factor score as the IPA Method. coordinate origin, and studies the Contemporary individual evaluation of the importance Economics, 2011, (18): and performance of different factors by 55-57. Tourist. The results show that the tourism factors of A10 "environmental improvement", A11 "toilet setting", A 16 "natural ecological landscape", A17 "original appearance protection of earth buildings" and A28 "public security environment" fall in the first quadrant, indicating that Tourist consider the above environmental factors very important and have high satisfaction. That is, Tourist are positive. 3 Fujian Fujian Tourist 100 5 Man- 1 ZHUANG Xiaojing. A 103 In this paper, a 5-point Likert Scale is Earthen made Study on the Tourism adopted to investigate Tourist' Structures attraction Attractiveness of the evaluation of the attractiveness value of South Fujian Earth mountains, water and air of Fujian Building. Rural Earthen Structures. The research results Economy and show that various environmental Science-Technology, factors score relatively high, among 2016, (23): 102-104. which the average air quality is 3.99, which reflects that Tourist are relatively satisfied with the environment of Fujian Earthen Structures. That is, Tourist are positive. 4 Youxi Fujian Tourist 0 0 Man- 1 ZHAN Jiwen, 148 The survey results of Tourist' Terraced made HUANG Lihong, YE satisfaction with the natural landscape Fields in attraction Lina, WANG of Youxi Terraced Fields in Fujian Fujian Qiaoyan, YAN Siyu.A Province show that Tourist' satisfaction Province Study on the with the natural landscape is relatively Evaluation of high, among which the majority of Tourism Experience Tourist' evaluation of traffic facilities Quality of and environmental sanitation is "good". Agricultural Cultural For the "tourism resource richness", Heritage Sites—A "ecological value", "cultural landscape Case Study of Youxi value", and the three secondary Union Terrace in indicators, the Tourist were assessed as Fujian Province. "good", while most people rated as Journal of Inner "excellent" for the "beautiful natural Mongolia scenery". That is, Tourist are positive. Agricultural University (Social Science Edrion), 2016, (06):145-150. 5 TaiMu Fujian Tourist 115 5 Natural 0 BIAN Lili. Study on 45 By randomly distributing Mountains attraction the Eco-tourism questionnaires to the residents around Comprehensive Taimu Mountain Scenic Spot, Evaluation and investigating residents' perceptions of Exploitation in environmental impacts of tourism Taimushan Scenery waste and noise. The results showed District. Fujian that 79.25% of the residents thought Agriculture and traveling garbage was obvious, 73.58% Forestyr UniVersity, thought traveling had brought noise 2008. Master Thesis pollution, 69.81% thought that the development of tourism had caused certain negative effects on the natural environment. Loud, negative attitude 30.19%. That is, Tourist are positive. 6 Yongding Fujian Tourist 50 5 Man- 1 CAI Caiyun. 62 In this paper, a 5-point Likert Scale was Earth made Evaluation Research used to study Tourist' evaluation of Building attraction of Tourist Satisfaction their satisfaction with Yongding Earth Degree in Yongding Building, and the results showed that Earth Building the average value of Tourist for Tourism Destination. "landscape protection of Yongding Fujian Normal Earth Building", "scenic beauty degree University, 2010. of scenic spots" and tourism service Master Thesis quality was above 4 points. That is, Tourist are positive. 7 Youxi Fujian Tourist 0 3 Natural 1 HUANG Yu. The 48 By using the 5-point Likert scale, this Pillow attraction Recreational Function paper investigates Tourist’ satisfaction Mountain Assessment on with the natural environment of Youxi in the Zhentoushan Forest Pillow Mountain in the Forest Park. The Forest Park Park Based on the results show that the average values of Tourist Feeling. climate, air quality, biodiversity and Fujian Forestry, 2016, sound conditions are all above 3.6. That (4): 45-48. is, Tourist are positive. 8 Shaowu Fujian Tourist 40 0 Natural 1 YU Mingtong, LIN 106 According to the survey of the Tiancheng attraction Youhong. Behavior reclamation groups in scenic spots, the Rock Features of Tour- results show that the overall Pioneer: As the Case satisfaction of the reclamation groups is of Tianchenyan Scenic relatively high, 61% of them thought of Shaowu City, that the scenery was good and they are Fujian Province. in high spirits; 18% thought that the Economic Geography, scenery was still good, but lack of 2006, (S2):105-107. cultural landscape activities; 6% thought that the scenery was general and the consumption was too high; 5% thought that the traffic was inconvenient and there were many difficulties. That is, Tourist are positive. 9 Fuzhou Fujian Tourist 0 4 Natural 0 YE Ping.Study on the 43-45 According to the survey on the Tourist' National attraction cultura environmental satisfaction, the result Forest Park advaneement1n the shows that the Tourist' environmental urban forest Parks at satisfaction is relatively low, among the baekground of which more than 80% of the Tourist are tourism Experienee. extremely dissatisfied with this Fujian Agrieulture phenomenon, believing that the driving and Forestry of vehicles in the scenic area destroys the tranquil atmosphere of the University, 2008. countryside and pollutes the fresh air. Master Thesis 62.59% of the surveyed Tourist think that the ecological and environmental protection service is average or even very poor; The Tourist' impression of forest park is not as good as expected. 57.91% of the Tourist have an average or poor impression of the current fuzhou national forest park, with a very satisfied minority, only 7.61%. That is, Tourist are negative. 10 Meizhou Fujian Tourist 65 4 Natural 1 LIN Cuisheng. Study 34 Based on religious pilgrimage tourism Island attraction on Driving Factors of scenic environment satisfaction survey, Tourist' Loyalty in the result shows: the pilgrims and Religious Pilgrimige Tourist to the scenic area retains a Site—based on the strong religious pilgrimage atmosphere Contrast Analysis of "mean value is 4.09 and 4.16, Pilgrims and respectively," scenic area maintained a Sightseers in Meizhou beautiful seaside tourism environment island ,Putian .Fujian "average 3.88 and 4.07, the overall Normal University, environment clean" mean value is 3.69 2014. Master Thesis and 3.85 respectively, pilgrims and Tourist to the scenic spot environment relatively happy with the performance. That is, Tourist are positive. 11 Meizhou Fujian Tourist 65 4 Natural 1 GAO Dexing. A 39 This paper investigates Tourist' Island attraction Study on Place perception of Meizhou Island's tourism Attachment of environment by using Level 5 Likert Tourist—A Case Scale, and ticks out "very opposed", Study on Mazu "opposed", "neutral", "agree" and Halidome Meizhou "strongly disagree" for each question. Island. Fujian Normal Each question is given 1 (very University, 2008. opposed), 2 (opposed), 3 (neutral), 4 Master Thesis (agreed), 5 (strongly agree). The results showed that the average perception of the tourist environment on Meizhou Island is 3.14, neutral but to satisfaction. That is, Tourist are positive. 12 Longjia Fujian Tourist 25 4 Man- 1 HUANG Yuancai. 39 Article take five point Likert scale Ecological made Study Evaluation of research tourist area of the scenic spot Hot Spring attraction Ecological humanistic