Bees, Brains and Behaviour: a Philosophical Essay in Theoretical Biology

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Bees, Brains and Behaviour: a Philosophical Essay in Theoretical Biology Bees, Brains and Behaviour: A Philosophical Essay In Theoretical Biology Phiilip A Veldhuis A thesis submiaed to the Fucully of Graduate Studies in parLial Fulflment of the requirementsfor the dcgree of Miasters of Arts Department of Phcüoophy Unntetssiry of Manit00 Wh@%, Manitoba National Library Bibliothèque nationale u*u of Canada du Canada Acquisitions and Acquisitions et Bibliogmphic Services services bibliographiques 395 Wellingtûn Street 395, rue Weilington Ottawa ON KiA ON4 OnawaON K1AW canada Canada The author has granted a non- L'auteur a accordé une licence non exclusive licence allowing the exclusive permettant à la National Library of Canada to Bibliothèque nationale du Canada de reproduce, loan, distribute or sell reproduire, prêter, distribuer ou copies of ttus thesis in microform, vendre des copies de cette thèse sous paper or electronic formats. la forme de microfiche/nlm, de reproduction sur papier ou sur format électronique. The author retains ownership of the L'auteur conserve la propnéte du copyright in this thesis. Neither the droit d'auteur qui protège cette thèse. thesis nor substantial extracts fkom it Ni la thèse ni des extraits substantiels may be printed or otherwise de celle-ci ne doivent être imprimés reproduced without the author's ou autrement reproduits sans son permission. autorisation. THE UNIVERSITY OF MANITOBA FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES ***** COPYRIGHT PERMISSION PAGE Bees, Bths and Bebaviow: A PMiosophicd Essay in Theoreoeil Biology PhUp A Veldhuis A Thtsio/Pncticum rubmitteà to the Ficulty of Graduate Studies of The University of Manitoba in partial MfWment of the requirements of the dcgm of Master of Arts Permission bu ben grrnted to the Libnry of Tk Univeriity of Manitoba to lend or aell copier of thb thcdilpncticum, to the National Lmriry of Canada to microfilm this thcris and to lend or cdl copies of the lilm, and to Disaertidons Abstractr International to pubürh an abstnct of this thaidpridcpm. The iuthor rtaervea othw puMication ri@@rad neither thia tbddpncticum nor estensive i Abstract: In the introduction to the second edition of Karl von Frisch's popular monograph [1950] on honeybee behaviour, Donald Griffin concludes: a reluctance to become embroiled in rnetaphysics should not anesthetize our perceptions. Heretical as it may seem to many behavioral scientists, I am willing to entertain the thought that perhaps the bees know what they are dohg [ûriffin 197 1, p. xiii]. In this thesis I will not be daunted by metaphysics. Rathei, I will attempt to establish whether honeybee behaviour is best described by Griffin's cognitive theory, and whether this implies that it is reesonable to think 'Wie bees know what they are doing". Griffin has argued extensively that it is possible to leam whether non-human anirnals think consciously. He has founded and defended the recent and controversial scientific discipline of cognitive ethology, which attempts to make a scientific "analysis of the cognitive processes of non-human animals7' [Griffin 1992, p. vii]. Cognitive Ethology seeks to combine and apply theory and method from biology, neuro- physiology, and cognitive psychology to animal ethology. My analysis of bee behaviour will be made within the fiamework of cognitive ethology. I will conclude that the dance Ianguage of the honeybees is intentional. 1 reject Griffui's strategy of conflating cognition wit h consciousness and sel f-consciousness. Therefore, aithough I think the best explanation of honeybee behaviour is a cognitive explanation, I do not conclude that honeybees are conscious or self-conscious. Introduction Introductory Remarks in the introduction to the second edition of Karl von Frisch's popular monograph [1950] on honeybee behaviour, Donald Gnfin concludes: a reluctance to become embroiled in metaphysics should not anesthetue ouperceptions. Heretical as it may seem to many behanoral scientists, 1 am willing to entertain the thought that perhaps the bees know what they are doing [Grifin 197 1, p. xiü]. In this thesis I will not be daunted by metaphysics. Rather, this thesis will be an attempt to establish whaher honeybee behaviour is best described by Grifin's cognitive theory, and whether this implies that it is reasonable to think 'Yhe bees how what they are doing". affin, best known for his discovery that bats navigate by echolocation (sonar), has argued extensively for the view that it is possible to lem whether non-human animals think consciously. He has founded and defended the recent and controversial scientific discipline of cognitive ethology, which attempts to make a scientific "analysis of the cognitive processes of non-human animalsy' [Gritnn 1992, p. vii]. My adysis of bee behaviour will be made within the framework of cognitive ethology. Cognitive ethology saks to combine and apply theory and method Rom biology, muro-physiology, and cognitive psychology to animal ethology. As part of my evaluation of the claim that honeybees 'bow what they are dohg'l, 1 dlargue thet there are some serious dificulties in any attempt to make a systematic study of animal psychology, but that the obstacles are sufmountable if confionteci. However, there will be a methodologicaî and philosophical cost for this success. 1 wiil conclude that a philosophical study of the minds of humans and animals is best conducteci within the framework of evolutioaary theory of Darwin, and not the dominant philosophical framework provided by Descartes. 1 will argue that the various considerations taken by Griffin and his colleagues to support the view that animais have important cognitive experiences codict and so seriously undetmine the prospects for cognitive ethology. Tbuis Structure In making a case for cognitive ethology, Griffin takes on two largely sepmte tasks. Firstly, he must reject the idea that non-human animals differ in kind and not just in degree fkom humans; 1 cal1 this idea the apartness thesis and consider the case against it in chapter one. Secondly, a positive case is required which makes arguments for the primafacie plausibility of cognitive ethology. One main problem is that this second task is actually made more dificult once the apartness thesis is rejected. 1 consider the general case for the plausibility of cognitive ethology in chapter two. In chapter three 1 consider the case of honeybee behaviour within the program of cognitive ethology as developed in the first two chapters. I wish to acknowledge the unwavering support ofmy de,Vona, my parents and family, and fnends Pierre LeMorvan and Dennis Foerster. 1 also want to express my gratitude to Jack Bailey and Martin Gerwin for their support of my academic endeavours. I wish to dedicate this effort to my Grandmother, Ruth Vane, whose started me on my beekeeping career, and whose knowledge and curiosity inspire us dl. Contents . uitroductory Remarks ........................................................................................ ...11 Thesis Structure .................................................................................................. 111 Ac know ledgements ............................................................................................ iv Chapter Onewwmm~ommm~~~w~~~~~~~~~~m~~wwww~~mmwwmmwmwwwwwoow~~~~~wwwm~~~~~~mm~mw~m~~~~wwwwawwwwwwwwwwwwowwmwswwwwowwwl Rejecting The Apartness Thesis ........................................................................... 1 Introduction to the Apariness Thesis .................................................................... I History of the Apariness Thesis ....................................................................... 2 Descartes Versus Animal Cognitivism ........................................................... 3 Afker Descartes ................................................................................................ -6 Darwin and Animal Cognitiwsm ......................................................................... -7 Behaviourism. and the Apartness Thesis ......................................................... 8 Rejecting the Apartness Thesis ....................................................................... 8 Discussion of Particular Versions of the Apartness Thesis ................................... 8 Animai Language.......................................................................................... 8 Higher Order Cognition ................................................................................. 8 Reasun ....................................................................................................*...... 8 Abstraction .................................................................................................... 8 Adaptability and Flexibility as Marks of Intelligence ..................................... 8 Learning ........................................................................................................ 8 Tool Use ........................................................................................................ 8 Consciousness ................ .. .............................................................................. 8 Conclusion to Chapter One ................................................................................ 8 Chapter TWOwowomwwwwwmwwwwwmwmwmmwwwwwmwwwwwwwwwwmsowmwmwwwwwwwwowwwww.wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwmwwmmmwwwwwoowwwmwwmwwwwoww~w0 A Brief History of Cognitive Psychology .......................................................... 8 Methodological Behaviourisrn ............................................................................ 8 The Problem
Recommended publications
  • Animal Welfare and the Paradox of Animal Consciousness
    ARTICLE IN PRESS Animal Welfare and the Paradox of Animal Consciousness Marian Dawkins1 Department of Zoology, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK 1Corresponding author: e-mail address: [email protected] Contents 1. Introduction 1 2. Animal Consciousness: The Heart of the Paradox 2 2.1 Behaviorism Applies to Other People Too 5 3. Human Emotions and Animals Emotions 7 3.1 Physiological Indicators of Emotion 7 3.2 Behavioral Components of Emotion 8 3.2.1 Vacuum Behavior 10 3.2.2 Rebound 10 3.2.3 “Abnormal” Behavior 10 3.2.4 The Animal’s Point of View 11 3.2.5 Cognitive Bias 15 3.2.6 Expressions of the Emotions 15 3.3 The Third Component of Emotion: Consciousness 16 4. Definitions of Animal Welfare 24 5. Conclusions 26 References 27 1. INTRODUCTION Consciousness has always been both central to and a stumbling block for animal welfare. On the one hand, the belief that nonhuman animals suffer and feel pain is what draws many people to want to study animal welfare in the first place. Animal welfare is seen as fundamentally different from plant “welfare” or the welfare of works of art precisely because of the widely held belief that animals have feelings and experience emotions in ways that plants or inanimate objectsdhowever valuableddo not (Midgley, 1983; Regan, 1984; Rollin, 1989; Singer, 1975). On the other hand, consciousness is also the most elusive and difficult to study of any biological phenomenon (Blackmore, 2012; Koch, 2004). Even with our own human consciousness, we are still baffled as to how Advances in the Study of Behavior, Volume 47 ISSN 0065-3454 © 2014 Elsevier Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Mental States in Animals: Cognitive Ethology Jacques Vauclair
    Mental states in animals: cognitive ethology Jacques Vauclair This artHe addresses the quegtion of mentaJ states in animak as viewed in ‘cognitive ethology”. In effect, thk field of research aims at studying naturally occurring behaviours such as food caching, individual recognition, imitation, tool use and communication in wild animals, in order to seek for evidence of mental experiences, self-aw&&reness and intentional@. Cognitive ethologists use some philosophical cencepts (e.g., the ‘intentional stance’) to carry out their programme of the investigation of natural behaviours. A comparison between cognitive ethology and other approaches to the investigation of cognitive processes in animals (e.g., experimental animal psychology) helps to point out the strengths and weaknesses of cognitive ethology. Moreover, laboratory attempts to analyse experimentally Mentional behaviours such as deception, the relationship between seeing and knowing, as well as the ability of animals to monitor their own states of knowing, suggest that cognitive ethology could benefit significantly from the conceptual frameworks and methods of animal cognitive psychology. Both disciplines could, in fact, co&ribute to the understanding of which cognitive abilities are evolutionary adaptations. T he term ‘cognirive ethology’ (CE) was comed by that it advances a purposive or Intentional interpretation Griffin in The Question ofAnimd Au~aarmess’ and later de- for activities which are a mixture of some fixed genetically veloped in other publications’ ‘_ Although Griffin‘s IS’6 transmitred elements with more hexible behaviour?. book was first a strong (and certainly salutary) reacrion (Cognitive ethologists USC conceptual frameworks against the inhibitions imposed by strict behaviourism in provided by philosophers (such as rhe ‘intentional stance’)“.
    [Show full text]
  • Intentional Systems in Cognitive Ethology: the "Panglossian Paradigm" Defended
    THE BEHAVIORAL AND BRAIN SCIENCES (1983) 6, 343-390 Printed in the United States of America Intentional systems in cognitive ethology: The "Panglossian paradigm" defended Daniel C. Dennett Department of Philosophy, Tufts University, Medford, Mass. 02155 Abstract: Ethologists and others studying animal behavior in a "cognitive" spirit are in need of a descriptive language and method that are neither anachronistically bound by behaviorist scruples nor prematurely committed to particular "information-processing models. "Just such an interim descriptive method can be found in intentional system theory. The use of intentional system theory is illustrated with the case of the apparently communicative behavior of vervet monkeys. A way of using the theory to generate data - including usable, testable "anecdotal" data - is sketched. The underlying assumptions of this approach can be seen to ally it directly with "adaptationist' theorizing in evolutionary biology, which has recently come under attack from Stephen Gould and Richard Lewontin, who castigate it as the "Panglossian paradigm." Their arguments, which are strongly analogous to B. F. Skinner's arguments against "mentalism," point to certain pitfalls that attend the careless exercise of such "Panglossian" thinking (and rival varieties of thinking as well), but do not constitute a fundamental objection to either adaptationist theorizing or its cousin, intentional system theory. Keywords: adaptation; animal cognition; behaviorism; cognitive ethology; communication; comparative psychology; consciousness;
    [Show full text]
  • The Cognitive Animal Empirical and Theoretical Perspectives on Animal Cognition
    This PDF includes a chapter from the following book: The Cognitive Animal Empirical and Theoretical Perspectives on Animal Cognition © 2002 Massachusetts Institute of Technology License Terms: Made available under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International Public License https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ OA Funding Provided By: The open access edition of this book was made possible by generous funding from Arcadia—a charitable fund of Lisbet Rausing and Peter Baldwin. The title-level DOI for this work is: doi:10.7551/mitpress/1885.001.0001 Downloaded from http://direct.mit.edu/books/edited-volume/chapter-pdf/677472/9780262268028_f000000.pdf by guest on 29 September 2021 Introduction There are as many approaches to studying ani- and The Expression of the Emotions in Man and mal cognition as there are definitions of cogni- Animals (1872). Consequently, both disciplines tion itself. This diversity is reflected in the essays are almost inextricably linked to the concept of that follow, to a degree that we believe is un- instinct. Darwin viewed instinct primarily in be- paralleled in any other volume that has been havioral terms and considered his ability to ex- produced on this subject. This diversity is philo- plain instinct through natural selection to be one sophical and methodological, with contributors of the most critical tests of his theories. Thus he demonstrating various degrees of acceptance or compared closely related species of bees to ex- disdain for terms such as ‘‘consciousness’’ and plain the evolution of hive building and closely various degrees of concern for the rigors of lab- related species of ants to explain the origins of oratory experimentation versus the validity of slave making.
    [Show full text]
  • "DO DOGS APE?" OR "DO APES DOG?" and DOES Rr MATTER? BROADENING and DEEPENING COGNITIVE ETHOLOGY
    "DO DOGS APE?" OR "DO APES DOG?" AND DOES rr MATTER? BROADENING AND DEEPENING COGNITIVE ETHOLOGY By MA~c BEKOFF4' "Certainlyit seems like a dirty double-cross to enter into a relationshipof trust and affection with any creaturethat can enter into such a relationship, and then to be a party to'its premeditated and premature destruction."1 I. RAiN WrrHouT TmmDER, ANimAS Wrrour MINDS In Rain Without Thunder, Gary Francione raises numerous impor- tant issues and takes on many important people.2 The phrase "rain with- out thunder" made me think about the notion of animals without minds- animals without thoughts or feelings. This idea is troublesome for the nonhuman animals (hereafter animals) to whom it is attributed because it is much easier for humans to exploit animals when we believe that they don't have thoughts or feelings. I have been privileged to study various aspects of animal behavior for over 25 years, including animal cognition3 (cognitive ethology), and have attempted to learn more about how the study of animal cognition can aid discussions of animal protection. 4 As a * Professor of Biology, University of Colorado, Boulder;, A.B. and PILD., Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri; Guggenheim Fellow and Fellow of the Animal Behavior Soci- ety; Correspondence: Marc Bekoff, 296 Canyonside Drive, Boulder, Colorado 80302; Emaih [email protected] 1 LAWRENCE E. JoHNsoN, A MORALLY DEEP WoRLD: AN E.sxe*ON MORAL SIGNIFICANCE AND ENvmonwNAL ETmcs 122 (1991). 2 GARY L. FPNtcioNE, RAiN WmoUr TnuDER TIE IDEOLOGY OF mm.EAn,,AL RPiurrs MovmiErr (1996). 3 INTERPRrrATION AND EXPLANATION IN T-E STUDY OF Amm- Bcsxion (Marc Bekoff & Dale Jamieson eds., 1990); READINGS 1N AmAL COGNMON (Marc Bekoff & Dale Jamieson eds., 1996); Marc Bekoff & Colin Allen, Cognitive Ethology: Slayers, Skeptics, and Propo- nents, in ANmRoPoiORPmS.e ANscDoTE, ANzmms: TuE EMpERiO's NEW CLOTnts? 313 (Rob- ert W.
    [Show full text]
  • Cognitive Ethology Ádám Miklósi Dept
    Introduction to Cognitive ethology Ádám Miklósi Dept. of Ethology Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest [email protected] 2018 Literature This lecture series is based on Shettleworth, S. J. 2010 Cognition, evolution and behaviour (2nd edition) Oxford University Press Pages where you find background information to these topics: •CH 1, 2: 1-53 Introduction •CH 4: 96-119 Learning •CH 8: 261-283; 296-310 Spatial Cognition •CH 12: 417-455 Social cognition •CH 13: 466-497 Social learning •CH 14: 508-546 Communication You DON NOT have to know/learn all of this, check by means of the ppt files which parts of the chapters are relevant Ethology is the biological study of animal and human behaviour in the natural environment (Tinbergen 1953) Why do we study animals? 1. Understanding the biology of animal behaviour (evolution, genetics, physiology, cognition) 2. Understanding human behaviour 3. Practical reasons (welfare, agriculture) Ethological research has significant effect on people’s perceptions of animals Movies, television, shows, books, magazines Concept 1: Darwinian Evolution Natural selection: Change in the characteristics of organisms over time („continuity”) 1. Large reproductive potential in populations 2. Fixed amount of resources 3. Individuals compete for resources (fitness = offspring) 4. There is an individual variation 5. Individual traits can be inherited (Darwin: Origin of the species) Levels (unit) of selection: gene, individual, kin Concept 1: Darwinian Evolution Sources of variation: Mutation and recombination Adaptation: Is it a circular argument? Just so stories? Can we detect and measure adaptation? Distinguishing „adaptation” from „adaptive” Gould and Vrba (1982): Adaptation: specific evolutionary change as a response to a specific environmental parameter Exaptation: earlier adaptation new function non-adaptation („by product”) new function Adaptation has a function Exaptation has an effect E.g.
    [Show full text]
  • Aquatic Animals, Cognitive Ethology, and Ethics: Questions About Sentience and Other Troubling Issues That Lurk in Turbid Water
    DISEASES OF AQUATIC ORGANISMS Vol. 75: 87–98, 2007 Published May 4 Dis Aquat Org OPEN ACCESS Aquatic animals, cognitive ethology, and ethics: questions about sentience and other troubling issues that lurk in turbid water Marc Bekoff* Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado 80309-0334, USA ABSTRACT: In this general, strongly pro-animal, and somewhat utopian and personal essay, I argue that we owe aquatic animals respect and moral consideration just as we owe respect and moral con- sideration to all other animal beings, regardless of the taxonomic group to which they belong. In many ways it is more difficult to convince some people of our ethical obligations to numerous aquatic animals because we do not identify or empathize with them as we do with animals with whom we are more familiar or to whom we are more closely related, including those species (usually terrestrial) to whom we refer as charismatic megafauna. Many of my examples come from animals that are more well studied but they can be used as models for aquatic animals. I follow Darwinian notions of evolu- tionary continuity to argue that if we feel pain, then so too do many other animals, including those that live in aquatic environs. Recent scientific data (‘science sense’) show clearly that many aquatic organisms, much to some people’s surprise, likely suffer at our hands and feel their own sorts of pain. Throughout I discuss how cognitive ethology (the study of animal minds) is the unifying science for understanding the subjective, emotional, empathic, and moral lives of animals because it is essential to know what animals do, think, and feel as they go about their daily routines.
    [Show full text]
  • Animal Umwelten in a Changing World
    Tartu Semiotics Library 18 Tartu Tartu Semiotics Library 18 Animal umwelten in a changing world: Zoosemiotic perspectives represents a clear and concise review of zoosemiotics, present- ing theories, models and methods, and providing interesting examples of human–animal interactions. The reader is invited to explore the umwelten of animals in a successful attempt to retrieve the relationship of people with animals: a cornerstone of the past common evolutionary processes. The twelve chapters, which cover recent developments in zoosemiotics and much more, inspire the reader to think about the human condition and about ways to recover our lost contact with the animal world. Written in a clear, concise style, this collection of articles creates a wonderful bridge between Timo Maran, Morten Tønnessen, human and animal worlds. It represents a holistic approach Kristin Armstrong Oma, rich with suggestions for how to educate people to face the dynamic relationships with nature within the conceptual Laura Kiiroja, Riin Magnus, framework of the umwelt, providing stimulus and opportuni- Nelly Mäekivi, Silver Rattasepp, ties to develop new studies in zoosemiotics. Professor Almo Farina, CHANGING WORLD A IN UMWELTEN ANIMAL Paul Thibault, Kadri Tüür University of Urbino “Carlo Bo” This important book offers the first coherent gathering of perspectives on the way animals are communicating with each ANIMAL UMWELTEN other and with us as environmental change requires increasing adaptation. Produced by a young generation of zoosemiotics scholars engaged in international research programs at Tartu, IN A CHANGING this work introduces an exciting research field linking the biological sciences with the humanities. Its key premises are that all animals participate in a dynamic web of meanings WORLD: and signs in their own distinctive styles, and all animal spe- cies have distinctive cultures.
    [Show full text]
  • Anthrozoology
    28 ANTHROZOOLOGY theory, has come a renewed acceptance of anthropomorphism. prehistory to the present, including archaeozoology, anthro Ethologists have been joined by psychologists and philosophers pology and sociology; (ii) the effects of associations with in research into the minds of animals. This multidisciplinary animal companions on the development of personality, field of research, known as cognitive ethology, has resulted attitudes and other traits in humans, encompassing psychology in a multitude of investigations into consciousness, cogni and psychiatry; (iii) the therapeutic effects of companion tion, self-awareness and intelligence, as well as on whether animals; and (iv) the ethology of human—animal interactions. animals feel pain, anger, fear, love and have a theory of mind. A further two decades on, knowledge has increased in all of With the expanding research into animal minds has come these areas, and there have also been attempts to forge links the general realization that anthropomorphism does not between them to develop underlying theories of the human— disrupt scientific observation but supports the continuity animal ‘bond’, which will be covered in the latter part of this between humans and animals. A strong supporter of this view entry. is Frans de Waal who, in writing about attitudes to anthro— The roles of animals in human cultures have often been pomorphism, cites the example of his chimpanzee, Georgia, studied from an anthropocentric viewpoint and so fall who regularly ‘plays a trick’ on visitors by taking a drink of outside the scope of this volume. Archaeozoology has made a water and then spraying them with it from her cheek pouches valuable contribution towards our understanding of the (Waal, 2001).
    [Show full text]
  • 1995 – Volume 10 Issue 2
    Human Ethology Bulletin Editor: Glenn Weisfeld Department of Psychology, Wayne State University, Detroit, MI 48202 USA 1-313-577-2835 (office) 577-8596 (lab), 577-2801 (messages), 577-7636 (Fax), 393-2403 (home) VOLUME 10, ISSUE 2 ISSN 0739-2036 JUNE 1995 © 1995 The International Society for Human Ethology SOCIETY NEWS membership form. Events: Here we provide information on ISHE World-Wide-Web Server Is upcoming and past conferences. If you wish to have something posted, you will have to e- On-Line mail it to us. Full information on ISHE conferences will, of course, be provided, By Karl Grammer, ISHE Secretary including abstracts of past meetings. I began this ISHE electronic bulletin Electronic Publications: This is my personal board in March as a sl,lpplement to the Bulletin. experimental page. There is also a link to In the test phase which lasted a week, the Psycholoquy, the first electronic scientific server had more than 300 visitors. journal. My idea is to publish posters (which have been prepared in electronic form) as The server can be reached under this pictures, and also figures to accompany journal URL: hUp:llevolution.humb.unvie.ac.at. For articles, such as videoclips, 3-D graphs, color access you need a direct Internet connection and pictures, and sounds. These things have been one of the following programs: Mosaic or difficult or impossible to publish previously. Netscape; both come in versions for either If there is enough interest, we will provide an Windows, MacOs or Unix. You can get both electronic journal for behavioural analysis. programs for free on the net.
    [Show full text]
  • Where Is Ethology Heading? an Invitation for Collective Metadisciplinary Discussion
    animals Article Where Is Ethology Heading? An Invitation for Collective Metadisciplinary Discussion Nereida Bueno-Guerra Department of Psychology, Pontifical Comillas University, 28049 Madrid, Spain; [email protected] Simple Summary: I analyzed the current state of Ethology (i.e., the study of animal behavior and cognition) from the researchers’ perspective through an online questionnaire that was responded to by almost a hundred participants. Despite that the number of the respondents was small, it is interesting to highlight some of the results, since they align with some published analyses. First, not many basic concepts of the discipline, nor its denomination, reached homogeneous consensus. This is alarming because researchers need common vocabulary to communicate effectively between them. Second, despite the enormous biodiversity existent, the researchers seem to be biased towards studying primates, our own family species. Also, the apparatuses employed in the studies are not always adapted to the species’ specific characteristics, so our conclusions about their behavior or cognition might be biased. Fortunately, the technology needed to conduct further studies already exists. However, there is not enough funding or collaboration with engineers to make it real. Establishing big scale networking, adopting some research principles such as transparency, and broadening gender and ethnic diversity in research teams may help in adopting new endeavors. Abstract: Many factors can impact the advancement of scientific disciplines. In the study of animal behavior and cognition (i.e., Ethology), a lack of consensus about definitions or the emergence of some current events and inventions, among other aspects, may challenge the discipline’s grounds Citation: Bueno-Guerra, N. Where Is within the next decades.
    [Show full text]
  • Cognitive Ethology Carolyn A
    Advanced Review Cognitive ethology Carolyn A. Ristau∗ Cognitive Ethology, the field initiated by Donald R Griffin, was defined by him as the study of the mental experiences of animals as they behave in their natural environment in the course of their normal lives. It encompasses both the problems defined by Chalmers as the ‘hard’ problem of consciousness, phenomenological experience, and the ‘easy’ problems, the phenomena that appear to be explicable (someday) in terms of computational or neural mechanisms. Sources for evidence of consciousness and other mental experiences that Griffin suggested and are updated here include (1) possible neural correlates of consciousness, (2) versatility in meeting novel challenges, and (3) animal communication which he saw as a potential ‘window’ into their mental experiences. Also included is a very brief discussion of pertinent philosophical and conceptual issues; cross-species neural substrates underlying selected cognitive abilities; memory capacities especially as related to remembering the past and planning for the future; problem solving, tool use and strategic behavioral sequences such as those needed in anti-predator behaviors. The capacity for mirror self-recognition is examined as a means to investigate higher levels of consciousness. The evolutionary basis for morality is discussed. Throughout are noted the admonitions of von Uexkull¨ to the scientist to attempt to understand the Umwelt of each animal. The evolutionary and ecological impacts and constraints on animal capacity and behavior are examined as possible. © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. How to cite this article: WIREs Cogn Sci 2013, 4:493–509. doi: 10.1002/wcs.1239 INTRODUCTION they behave in their natural environments in the course of their normal lives.
    [Show full text]