Human Ethology Bulletin

Editor: Glenn Weisfeld Department of Psychology, Wayne State University, Detroit, MI 48202 USA 1-313-577-2835 (office) 577-8596 (lab), 577-2801 (messages), 577-7636 (Fax), 393-2403 (home)

VOLUME 10, ISSUE 2 ISSN 0739-2036 JUNE 1995

© 1995 The International Society for Human Ethology

SOCIETY NEWS membership form. Events: Here we provide information on ISHE World-Wide-Web Server Is upcoming and past conferences. If you wish to have something posted, you will have to e- On-Line mail it to us. Full information on ISHE conferences will, of course, be provided, By Karl Grammer, ISHE Secretary including abstracts of past meetings.

I began this ISHE electronic bulletin Electronic Publications: This is my personal board in March as a sl,lpplement to the Bulletin. experimental page. There is also a link to In the test phase which lasted a week, the Psycholoquy, the first electronic scientific server had more than 300 visitors. journal. My idea is to publish posters (which have been prepared in electronic form) as The server can be reached under this pictures, and also figures to accompany journal URL: hUp:llevolution.humb.unvie.ac.at. For articles, such as videoclips, 3-D graphs, color access you need a direct Internet connection and pictures, and sounds. These things have been one of the following programs: Mosaic or difficult or impossible to publish previously. Netscape; both come in versions for either If there is enough interest, we will provide an Windows, MacOs or Unix. You can get both electronic journal for behavioural analysis. programs for free on the net. We prefer Have a look at our supplements and videoclips

Netscapei because it performs much better than for the digital page image analysis of human Mosaic. Please set the program up corectly so courtship. You will also be allowed to you will have access to the full service of our download some of the pictures and use them for server. If you have installed the program, use teaching, etc. "open location" and type in the URL above. Access to some pages will be exclusive to ISHE ISHE Archives: The ISHE archives will hold members. book reviews which have been published in the Bulletin. You will be able to search this page, The server will provide the following as soon as the search engine is working. pages: Multimedia: This is a "toy page"; look for ISHE Information: Here you will find a surprises. At the moment, the page provides description of ISHE: its history and information on research material we are using, information on the people running it. From this videoclips on morphs, and a list of the 100 point you can e-mail to the officers directly, if scientific films of the Human Ethological Film you have installed your client program Archive in Andechs (Germany), with correctly. This makes communication with information on how to get them. We will ISHE much easier. We also provide a expand the film service with a list of 2

auiovisual materials available to the North !Thl' dates tor thl' 1996 ISm congress in Vil'nna, I American market. IAustria have bl'en set: 5-10 AUlus" i

Research and Teaching Tools: This is a Symposium on collection of commercial, free, and shareware programs for behavioural analysis. On this Ideology, Warfare and page ISHE will try to help you in finding the Indoctrinability right technical and statitstical programs for behavioural analysis. It provides direct e- mail or FTP links to the- sites, programmers or This symposium was held at Ringsberg companies that will provide the software. The Castle, Germany, 9-13 January 1995. The idea second half of the page will provide pictures, for the symposium carne from Irenaus Eibl- graphs, and experiment descriptions for Eibesfeldt, ISHE past president. The behavioural research courses, and so on. symposium was sponsored by the Max Planck Society and was organized by Frank Salter, Jumping Stations: This page provides Wulf Schiefenhovel, and Karl Grammer. As a connections to the Animal Behavior Society, special event, a winter tour in the hills of and to Newsgroups, and other useful links in southern Bavaria was conducted. behavioural research. If you know of a link, send the URL to us and we will publish it. Sessions were held on these topiCS: Evolutionary Precursors and Models (chairs: Behavior Research: This is our self- Detlev Ploog and Lionel Tiger); Institutions, presentation page. You will fmd addresses and Authority, and Media (chairs: Carinen descriptions of research institutes in our field Strungaru and Roger Masters); Individual (up to now only in Austria). If you want to see Behavioural Mechanisms (chairs: Frank Salter your research institute published here, either and Linnda Caporea!); Group Formation, provide us with the link to your server or send Dynamics and Strategies (chairs: Al Somit and us some photos and a one-page description with Karl Grammer); and Indoctrination and Ethics your research activities, publications, address, (chair: Hiram Caton). Forty-five minutes were and e-mail. We established this service allotted for presentation and discussion of each mainly for students in our field, who often paper. In addition, Hiram Caton led a phone us to ask, "Where in the world can I roundtable discussion of the topic "Knowledge study human behaviour?" There is also an of indoctrinability: implications for politics, interesting link to our Institute of Human education and media. A list of papers Biology in Vienna. Get news from the "Ice presented follows: Man" or see the results of new CT methods in research on the evolution of the human skull. Byrne, Richard W., University of St. Andrews, Scotland, Imagination and indoctrination: At this point, we do not plan to evolutionary origins. establish discussion groups, etc. If you are interested in hosting one, please tell us. Caporeal, Linnda R. , Dept. of Science & Technology Studies, Rennselaer Polytechnic I am looking forward to your visits and Institute, Troy, NY 12180 USA, Why the your contributions! If you have anything you Lysistrata strategy fails: gender identity, want to publish, contact us: E-Mail to group identity and indoctrinability. [email protected] and attach your text, pictures, etc. Alternatively, you can Caton, Hiram, Dept. of Political Science, upload directly to our FTP Server: Griffith University, Kessels Road, Brisbaine, evolution.humb.univie.ac.at. The directory is Queensland 4111, Australia, Self- "PubliC/Anonymous". Text should be either indoctrinating groups. plain (no carriage returns) or RTF format (use Save as.. in yom writing program to create such Dennen, Johan van der, Center for Peace and a document). Pictures should be in GIF or JPEG Conflict Studies, University of Groningert, Oude format. Ifyou cannot do it yourself, simply send Kijk in 't Jatstraat 5/9, 9712 EA Groninge, The the text and pictures to us and we will scan it Netherlands, The ethics and politics of peace for you. in preindustrial societies. 3

Deutsch, Robert, 6092 Old Landing Way, Burke, Box 103, University of Colorado, Denver, CO VA 22015 USA, The primal screen: 800217 USA, The fight to keep cigarette international relations and indoctrination in smokers lighting ("US Tareyton smokers would the age of TV. rather light than fight").

Eibl-Eibesfeldt, Ireni:ius, Max-Planck-Institut, Richerson, Peter, & Boyd, Robert, The cultural Von-der-Tann-Strasse 3-5, 0-8138 Andechs, evolution of group-"beneficial" traits. Germany, We and the others: familial roots of ethno-nationalism. Salter, Frank, Max-Planck-Institute, Von-der- Tann-Strasse 3-5, 0-8138 Andechs, Germany, Freedman, Daniel G., Committee on Human Indoctrination as institutionalized persuasion: Development, University of Chicago, 5730 S. further evidence that political ideologies are Woodlawn, Chicago, IL 60637 USA, Inter- constrained by species-typical behaviour. ethnic misunderstanding and the Internal Working Model. Schiefenhovel, Wulf, Forschungsstelle fur Humanethologie in der Max-Planck- Frey, Siegfried, The formation of prejudice: new Gesellschaft, D-8138 Andechs, Germany, facts about an old problem. Principles of indoctrination among the Eipo, highlands of West New Guinea. Geiger, Gebhard, Institut fUr Philosophie, Technische Universita.t Miinchen, Lothstrasse 17, D-80290 Miinchen, Germany, Ideology, indoctrination and the non-cognitive foundation of beliefs of legitimacy: a biobehavioural Schubert, James N., Dept. of Political Science, analysis of legitimate violent social action. Northern Illinois University, OeKalb, IL 60115 USA, The role of sex and emotional response in Grammer, Karl, Ludwig-Boltzmann-Institute indoctrinability: experimental evidence on the for Urban Ethology, Althanstrasse 14, A-1090 "rally-round-the-flag" effect. Vienna, Austria, Gender advertisement: Erving GoHman revisited. Shnirelman, Victor, Institute of Ethnology & Anthropology, Leninskiy Prospekt 32-A, MacDonald, Kevin, Dept. of Psychology, Moscow 117334, Russia, Who has priority: on California State University, Long Beach, CA the ideology of confrontation. 90840 USA, Indoctrination and group evolutionary strategies. Somit, Albert, & Peterson, Steven R, Southern Illinois University, Room 256, Lesar Law Bldg., Masters, Roger, Dept. of Government, Carbondale, IL 62901 USA (Somit), Dartmouth College, Silsby Hall, Hanover, NH Indoctrinability as a precondition for 03755 USA, On the evolution of political democracy. communities. Siitterin, Christa, Forschungsstelle fUr McGuire, Michael, Neuropsychiatric Institute Humanethologie in der Max-Planck- and Hospital for the Health Sciences, 760 Gesellschaft, Von-der-Tann-Strasse 3-5, 0-8138 Westwood Plaza, Los Angeles, CA 90024 USA, Andechs, Germany, Art and indoctrination. Uncertainty and neurophysiological vulnerability to indoctrination. Tiger, Lionel, 4th floor, 248 W. 23rd St., New York, NY 10011 USA, The interaction of nature Ploog, Detlev, Katharinenweg 5, West 0-8044 and culture and human indoctrinability. U. Schleissheim, Germany, War and peace- making: the fusion of two neighboring captive Wiessner, Polly, Forschungsstelle fUr monkey colonies. Humanethologie in der Max-Planck- Gesellschaft, Von-der-Tann-Strasse 3-5, D-8138 Quiatt, Duane; Schneider, Shari; & Corbett, Andechs, Germany, Indoctrinability and the Kitty King, Dept. of Anthropology, Campus two axes of kinship. 4

German anatomist, Ernst Schwarz, was ARTICLE scrutinizing a skull that had been ascribed to a juvenile chimpanzee because of its small size, Bonobo Sex and Society: when he realized that it belonged to an adult. Schwarz declared that he had stumbled on a The behavior ofa close relative new subspecies of chimpanzee. But soon the challenges assumptions about animal was assigned the status of an entirely male supremacy in human distinct species within the same genus as the chimpanzee, Pan. evolution 1 The bonobo was officially classified as By Frans B. M. de Waal, Yerkes Regional Pan paniscus, or the diminutive Pan. But I Primate Center, Emory University, Atlanta, believe a different label might have been GA 30322 USA.2 selected had the discoverers known then what we know now. The old taxonomic name of the At a juncture in history during which chimpanzee, P. satyrus--which refers to the women are seeking equality with men, science myth of apes as lustful satyrs--would have arrives with a belated gift to the feminist been perfect for the bonobo. movement. Male-biased evolutionary scenarios--Man the Hunter, Man the Toolmaker The species is best characterized as and so on--are being challenged by the female-centered and egalitarian and as one discovery that females playa central, perhaps that substitutes sex for aggression. Whereas in even dominant, role in the social life of one of most other species sexual behavior is a fairly our nearest relatives. In the past few years distinct category, in the bonobo it is part and many strands of knowledge have come together parcel of social relations--and not just between concerning a relatively unknown ape with an males and females. Bonobos engage in sex in unorthodox repertoire of behavior: the bonobo. virtually every partner combination (although such contact among close family members may The bonobo is one of the last large be suppressed). And sexual interactions occur mammals to be found by science. The creature more often among bonobos than among other was discovered in 1929 in a Belgian colonial primates. Despite the frequency of sex, the museum, far from its lush Africiill habitat. A bonobo's rate of reproduction in the wild is about the same as that of the chimpanzee. A 1 The editors of the Human Ethology Bulletin female gives birth to a single infant at requested permission to reprint "Bonobo Sex and intervals of between five and six years. So Society," by Frans B. M. de Waal, from bonobos share at least one very important characteristic with our own species, namely, a Scientific American, March 1995, Vol. 272, No. partial separation between sex and 3, pp. 82-88. The text is reprinted with reproduction. permission from FransB. M. de Waal and Scientific American, Inc. All rights reserved. A Near Relative The Bulletin wishes to thank Frans, an ISHE This finding commands attention member, and Scientific American for allOWing because the bonobo shares more than 98 percent us to reprint this important article without of our genetic profile, making it as close to a charge. The original article includes some human as, say, a fox is to a dog. The split illustrations. To subscribe to Scientific between the human line of ancestry and the line American, send $36 per year ($47 non-US) to 415 of the chimpanzee and the bonobo is believed to Madison Ave., New York, NY 10017 USA. have occurred a mere eight million years ago. The subsequent divergence of the chimpanzee 2 The author and renowned wildlife and the bonobo lines came much later, perhaps photographer Frans Lanting are currently prompted by the chimpanzee's need to adapt to working on a richly illustrated book treating relatively open, dry habitats [see "East Side the significance of the bonobo for models of Story: The Origin of Humankind," by Yves human evolution. Coppens; Scientific American, May 1994]. 5

In contrast, bonobos probably never left Enter the bonobo. Despite their common the protection of the trees. Their present range name--the pygmy chimpanzee--bonobos cannot lies in humid forests south of the Zaire River, be distinguished from the chimpanzee by size. where perhaps fewer than 10,000 bonobos Adult males of the smallest subspecies of survive. (Given the species' slow rate of chimpanzee weigh some 43 kilograms (95 reproduction, the rapid destruction of its pounds) and females 33 kilograms (73 pounds), tropical habitat and the political instability about the same as bonobos. Although female of central Africa, there is reason for much bonobos are much smaller than the males, they concern about its future.) seem to rule.

If this evolutionary scenario of Graceful Apes ecological continuity is true, the bonobo may have undergone less transformation than either In physique, a bonobo is as different humans or chimpanzees. It could most closely from a chimpanzee as a Concorde is from a resemble the common ancestor of all three Boeing 747. I do not wish to offend any modem species. Indeed, in the 1930s Harold J. chimpanzees, but bonobos have more style. The Coolidge--the American anatomist who gave bonobo, with its long legs and small head atop the bonobo its eventual taxonomic status-- narrow shoulders, has a more gracile build than suggested that the animal might be most does a chimpanzee. Bonobo lips are reddish in similar to the primogenitor, since its anatomy a black face, the ears small and the nostrils is less specialized than is the chimpanzee's. almost as wide as a gorilla's. These primates Bonobo body proportions have been compared also have a flatter, more open face with a with those of the australopithecines, a form of higher forehead than the chimpanzee's and-- prehuman. When the apes stand or walk to top it all off--an attractive coiffure with upright, they look as if they stepped straight long, fine, black hair neatly parted in the out of an artist's impression of early hominids. middle.

Not too long ago the savanna baboon Like chimpanzees, female bonobos nurse was regarded as the best living model of the and carry around their young for up to five human ancestor. That primate is adapted to years. By the age of seven the offspring reach the kinds of ecological conditions that adolescence. Wild females give birth for the prehumans may have faced after descending first time at 13 or 14 years of age, becoming full from the trees. But in the late 1970s, grown by about 15. A bonobo's longevity is chimpanzees, which are much more closely imknown, but judging by the chimpanzee it may related to humans, became the model of choice. be older than 40 in the wild and close to 60 in Traits that are observed in chimpanzees-- captivity. including cooperative hunting, food sharing, tool use, power politics and primitive warfare- Fruit is central to the diets of both wild -were absent or not as developed in baboons. In bonobos and chimpanzees. The former the laboratory the apes have been able to learn supplement with more pith from herbaceous sign language and to recognize themselves in a plants, and the latter add meat. Although mirror, a sign of self-awareness not yet bonobos do eat invertebrates and occasionally demonstrated in monkeys. capture and eat small vertebrates, including mammals, their diet seems to contain Although selecting the chimpanzee as relatively little animal protein. Unlike the touchstone of hominid evolution chimpanzees, they have not been observed to represented a great improvement, at least one hunt monkeys. aspect of the former model did not need to be revised: male superiority remained the natural Whereas chimpanzees use a rich array state of affairs. In both baboons and of strategies to obtain foods--from cracking nuts chimpanzees, males are conspicuously dominant with stone tools to fishing for ants and termites over females; they reign supremely and often with sticks--tool use in wild bonobos seems brutally. It is highly unusual for a fully grown undeveloped. (Captive bonobos use tools male chimpanzee to be dominated by any skillfully.) Apparently as intelligent as female. chimpanzees, bonobos have, however, a far 6 more sensitive temperament. During World the aftermath of conflict. After two War II bombing of Hellabrun, Germany, the chimpanzees have fought, for instance, they bonobos in a nearby zoo all died of fright from may come together for a hug and mouth-to- the noise; the chimpanzees were unaffected. mouth kiss. Assuming that such reunions serve to restore peace and harmony, I labeled them Bonobos are also imaginative in play. I reconciliations. have watched captive bonobos engage in "blindman's buff." A bonobo covers her eyes Any species that combines close bonds with a banana leaf or an arm or by sticking two with a potential for conflict needs such fingers in her eyes. Thus handicapped, she conciliatory mechanisms. Thinking how much stumbles around on a climbing frame, bumping faster marriages would break up if people had into others or almost falling. She seems to be no way of compensating for hurting each other, imposing a rule on herself: "I cannot look until I I set out to investigate such mechanisms in lose my balance." Other apes and monkeys also several primates, including bonobos. Although indulge in this game, but I have never seen it I expected to see peacemaking in these apes, performed with such dedication and too, I was little prepared for the form it would concentration as by bonobos. take.

Juvenile bonobos are incurably playful For my study, which began in 1983, I and like to make funny faces, sometimes in long chose the San Diego Zoo. At the time, it solitary pantomimes and at other times while housed the world's largest captive bonobo tickling one another. Bonobos are, however, colony--10 members divided into three groups. I more controlled in expressing their emotions-- spent entire days in front of the enclosure with whether it be joy, sorrow, excitement or anger-- a video camera, which was switched on at than are the extroverted chimpanzees. Male feeding time. As soon as a caretaker chimpanzees often engage in spectacular approached the enclosure with food, the males charging displays in which they show off their would develop erections. Even before the food strength: throwing rocks, breaking branches and was thrown into the area, the bonobos would be uprooting small trees in the process. They keep inviting each other for sex: males would invite up these noisy performances for many minutes, females, and females would invite males and during which most other members of the group other females. wisely stay out of their way. Male bonobos, on the other hand, usually limit displays to a Sex, it turned out, is the key to the brief run while dragging a few branches behind social life of the bonobo. The first suggestion them. that the sexual behavior of bonobos is different had come from observations at European zoos. Both primates signal emotions and Wrapping their findings in Latin, intentions through facial expressions and hand primatologists Eduard Tratz and Heinz Heck gestures, many of which are also present in the reported in 1954 that the chimpanzees at nonverbal communication of humans. For Hellabrun mated more canum (like dogs) and example, bonobos will beg by stretching out an bonobos more hominum (like people). In those open hand (or, sometimes, a foot) to a possessor days, face-to-face copulation was considered of food and will pout their lips and make uniquely human, a cultural innovation that whimpering sounds if the effort is unsuccessful. needed to be taught to preliterate people But bonobos make different sounds than (hence the term "missionary position"). These chimpanzees do. The renowned low-pitched, early studies, written in German, were ignored extended "huuu-huuu" pant-hooting of the by the international scientific establishment. latter contrasts with the rather sharp, high- The bonobo's humanlike sexuality needed to be pitched barking sounds of the bonobo. rediscovered in the 19 70s before it became accepted as characteristic of the species. Love, Not War Bonobos become sexually aroused My own interest in bonobos came not remarkably easily, and they express this from an inherent fascination with their charms excitement in a variety of mounting positions but from research on aggressive behavior in and genital contacts. Although chimpanzees primates. I was particularly intrigued with virtually never adopt face-to-face positions, 7 bonobos do so in one out of three copulations in even appears to make food sharing possible, the wild. Furthermore, the frontal orientation has been observed not only in zoos but also in of the bonobo vulva and clitoris strongly suggest the wild. Nancy Thompson-Handler, then at that the female genitalia are adapted for this the State University of New York at Stony position. Brook, saw bonobos in Zaire's Lomako Forest engage in sex after they had entered trees Another similarity with humans is loaded with ripe figs or when one among them increased female sexual· receptivity. The had captured a prey animal, such as a small tumescent phase of the female's genitals, forest duiker. The flurry of sexual contacts resulting in a pink swelling that signals would last for five to 10 minutes, after which willingness to mate, covers a much longer part the apes would settle down to consume the food. of estrus in bonobos than in chimpanzees. Instead of a few days out of her cycle, the One explanation for the sexual activity female bonobo is almost continuously sexually at feeding time could be that excitement over attractive and active [see "Sex food translates into sexual arousal. This idea Receptivity.GIF" in the Image File Library]. may be partly true. Yet another motivation is probably the real cause: competition. There are Perhaps the bonobo's most typical two reasons to believe sexual activity is the sexual pattern, undocumented in any other bonobo's answer to avoiding conflict. primate, is genito-genital rubbing (or GG rubbing) between adult females. One female First, anything, not just food, that facing another clings with arms and legs to a arouses the interest of more than one bonobo at a partner that, standing on both hands and feet, time tends to result in sexual contact. If two lifts her off the ground. The two females then bonobos approach a cardboard box thrown into rub their genital swellings laterally together, their enclosure, they will briefly mount each emitting grins and squeals that probably reflect other before playing with the box. Such orgasmic experiences. (Laboratory experiments situations lead to squabbles in most other on stump-tailed macaques have demonstrated species. But bonobos are quite tolerant, perhaps that women are not the only female primates because they use sex to divert attention and to capable of phySiological orgasm.) diffuse tension.

Male bonobos, too, may engage in Second, bonobo sex often occurs in pseudocopulation but generally perform a aggressive contexts totally unrelated to food. A variation. Standing back to back, one male jealous male might chase another away from a briefly rubs his scrotum against the buttocks of female, after which the two males reunite and another. They also practice so-called penis- engage in scrotal rubbing. Or after a female fencing, in which two males hang face to face hits a juvenile, the latter's mother may lunge from a branch while rubbing their erect penises at the aggressor, an action that is immediately together. followed by genital rubbing between the two adults. The diversity of erotic contacts in bonobos includes sporadic oral sex, massage of another individual's genitals and intense lance observed a young male, Kako, tongue-kissing. Lest this leave the impression inadvertently blocking an older, female of a pathologically oversexed species, I must juvenile, Leslie, from moving along a branch. add, based on hundreds of hours of watching First, Leslie pushed him; Kako, who was not bonobos, that their sexual activity is rather very confident in trees, tightened his grip, casual and relaxed. It appears to be a grinning nervously. Next Leslie gnawed on one completely natural part of their group life. of his hands, presumably to loosen his grasp. Like people, bonobos engage in sex only Kako uttered a sharp peep and stayed put. occasionally, not continuously. Furthermore, Then Leslie rubbed her vulva against his with the average copulation lasting 13 seconds, shoulder. This gesture calmed Kako, and he sexual contact in bonobos is rather quick by moved along the branch. It seemed that Leslie human standards. had been very close to using force but instead had reassured both herself and Kako with That sex is connected to feeding, and sexual contact. 8

During reconciliations, bonobos use the travels of chimpanzees in the Mahale same sexual repertoire as they do during Mountains, Nishida first reported that they feeding time. Based on an analysis of many form large communities all members of one such incidents, my study yielded the first solid community mix freely in ever changing parties, evidence for sexual behavior as a mechanism to but members of different communities never overcome aggression. Not that this function is gather. Later, Goodall added territoriality to absent in other animals--or in humans, for that this picture. That is, not only do communities matter-but the art of sexual reconciliation not mix, but males of different chimpanzee may well have reached its evolutionary peak communities engage in lethal battles. in the bonobo. For these animals, sexual behavior is indistinguishable from social In both bonobos and chimpanzees, males behavior. Given its peacemaking and stay in their natal group, whereas females tend appeasement functions, it is not surprising that to migrate during adolescence. As a result, the sex among bonobos occurs in so many different senior males of a chimpanzee or bonobo group partner combinations, including between have known all junior males since birth, and all juveniles and adults. The need for peaceful junior males have grown up together. Females, coexistence is obviously not restricted to adult on the other hand, transfer to an unfamiliar heterosexual pairs. and often hostile group where they may know no one. A chief difference between chimpanzee Female Alliance and bonobo societies is the way in which young females integrate into their new community. Apart from maintaining harmony, sex is also involved in creating the singular social On arrival in another community, young structure of the bonobo. This use of sex becomes bonobo females at Wamba single out one or two clear when studying bonobos in the wild. Field senior resident females for special attention, research on bonobos started only in the mid- using frequent GG rubbing and grooming to 1970s, more than a decade after the most establish a relation. If the residents important studies on wild chimpanzees had reciprocate, close associations are set up, and been initiated. In terms of continuity and the younger female gradually becomes accepted invested (wo)manpower, the chimpanzee into the group. After producing her first projects of Jane Goodall and Toshisada offspring, the young female's position becomes Nishida, both in Tanzania, are unparalleled. more stable and central. Eventually the cycle But bonobo research by Takayoshi Kano and repeats with younger immigrants, in turn, others of Kyoto University is now two decades seeking a good relation with the now under way at Wamba in Zaire and is beginning established female. Sex thus smooths the to show the same payoffs. migrant's entrance into the community of females, which is much more dose-knit in the Both bonobos arid chimpanzees live in bonobo than in the chimpanzee. so-called fission-fusion sbcieties. The apes move alone or in small parties of a few Bonobo males remain attached to their individuals at a time, the composition of mothers all their lives, following them which changes constantly. Several bonobos through the forest and being dependent on them traveling together in the morning might meet for protection in aggressive encounters with another group in the forest, whereupon one other males. As a result, the highest-ranking individual from the first group wanders off males of a bonobo community tend to be sons of with others from the second group, while those important females. left behind forage together. All associations, except the one between mother and dependent What a contrast with chimpanzees! offspring, are of a temporary character. Male chimpanzees fight their own battles, often relying on the support of other males. Initially this flexibility baffled Furthermore, adult male chimpanzees travel investigators, making them wonder if these together in same-sex parties, grooming each apes formed any social groups with stable other frequently. Males form a distinct social membership. After years of documenting the hierarchy with high levels of both 9 competition and association. Given the need to make the controversial claim. But in 1992, at stick together against males of neighboring the 14th Congress of the International communities, their bonding is not surprising: Primatological Society in Strasbourg, failure to form a united front might result in the investigators of both captive and wild bonobos loss of lives and territory. The danger of being presented data that left little doubt about the male is reflected in the adult sex ratio of issue. chimpanzee populations, with considerably fewer males than females. Amy R. Parish of the University of California at Davis reported on food Serious conflict between bonobo groups competition in identical groups (one adult male has been witnessed in the field, but it seems and two adult females) of chimpanzees and quite rare. On the contrary, reports exist of bonobos at the Stuttgart Zoo. Honey was peaceable mingling, including mutual sex and provided in a "termite hill" from which it grooming, between what appear to be different could be extracted by dipping sticks into a small communities. If intergroup combat is indeed hole. As soon as honey was made available, unusual, it may explain the lower rate of all- the male chimpanzee would make a charging male associations. Rather than being male- display through the enclosure and claim bonded, bonobo society gives the impression of everything for himself. Only when his being female-bonded, with even adult males appetite was satisfied would he let the relying on their mothers instead of on other females fish for honey. males. No wonder Kano calls mothers the "core" of bonobo society. In the bonobo group, it was the females that approached the honey first. After having The bonding among female bonobos engaged in some GG rubbing, they would feed violates a fairly general rule, outlined by together, taking turns with virtually no Harvard University anthropologist Richard competition between them. The male might W. Wrangham, that the sex that stays in the make as many charging displays as he wanted; natal group develops the strongest mutual the females were not intimidated and ignored bonds. Bonding among male chimpanzees the commotion. follows naturally because they remain in the community of their birth. The same is true for Observers at the Belgian animal park female kinship bonding in Old World monkeys, of Planckendael, which currently has the most such as macaques and baboons, where males are naturalistic bonobo colony, reported similar the migratory sex. findings. If a male bonobo tried to harass a female, all females would band together to Bonobos are unique in that the chase him off. Because females appeared more migratory sex, females, strongly bond with successful in dominating males when they were same-sex strangers later in life. In setting up an together than on their own, their close artificial sisterhood, bonobos can be said to be association and frequent genital rubbing may secondarily bonded. (Kinship bonds are said to represent an alliance. Females may bond so as be primary.) Although we now know how this to outcompete members of the individually happens-through the use of sexual contact and stronger sex. grooming--we do not yet know why bonobos and chimpanzees differ in this respect. The answer The fact that they manage to do so not may lie in the different ecological only in captivity is evident from zoologist environments of bonobos and chimpanzees--such Takeshi Furuichi's summary of the relation as the abundance and quality of food in the between the sexes at Wamba, where bonobos forest. But it is uncertain if such explanations are enticed out of the forest with sugarcane. will suffice. "Males usually appeared at the feeding site first, but they surrendered preferred positions Bonobo society is, however, not only when the females appeared. It seemed that female-centered but also appears to be female- males appeared first not because they were dominated. Bonobo specialists, while long dominant, but because they had to feed before suspecting such a reality, have been reluctant to the arrival of females," Furuichi reported at 10

Strasbourg. to food is taken one step further, bringing Sex for Food bonobos very dose to humans in their behavior. It has been speculated by anthropologists-- Occasionally, the role of sex in relation including C. Owen Lovejoy of Kent State University and Helen Fisher of Rutgers University--that sex is partially separated from reproduction in our species because it Social Organization among Various serves to cement mutually profitable Primates relationships between men and women. The human female's capacity to mate throughout BONOBO her cycle and her strong sex drive allow her to Bonobo communities are and exchange sex for male commitment and paternal generally egalitarian. The strongest social care, thus giving rise to the nuclear family. bonds are those among females, although females also bond with males. The status of a This arrangement is thought to be male depends on the position of his mother, to favored by natural selection because it allows whom he remains closely bonded for her entire women to raise more offspring than they could life. if they were on their own. Although bonobos clearly do not establish the exclusive CHIMPANZEE heterOSexual bonds characteristic of our species, In chimpanzee groups the strongest bonds are their behavior does fit important elements of established between the males in order to hunt this model. A female bonobo shows extended and to protect their shared territory. The receptivity and uses sex to obtain a male's females live in overlapping home ranges favors when--usual1y because of youth--she is within this territory but are not strongly too low in social status to dominate him. bonded to other females or to anyone male. At the San Diego Zoo, I observed that GIBBON if Loretta was in a sexually attractive state, Gibbons establish monogamous, egalitarian she would not hesitate to approach the adult relations, and one couple will maintain a male, Vernon, if he had food. Presenting territory to the exclusion of other pairs. herself to Vernon, she would mate with him and make high-pitched food calls while HUMAN taking over his entire bundle of branches and Human society is the most diverse among the leaves. When Loretta had no genital swelling" primates. Males unite for cooperative ventures, she would wait until Vernon was ready to whereas females also bond with those of their share. Primatologist Suehisa Kuroda reports own sex. Monogamy, polygamy and polyandry similar exchanges at Wamba: "A young female are all in evidence. approached a male, who was eating sugarcane. They copulated in short order, whereupon she GORILLA took one of the two canes held by him and left." The social organization of gorillas provides a clear example of polygamy. Usually a single Despite such quid pro quo between the male maintains a range for his family unit, sexes, there are no indications that bonobos which contains several females. The strongest form humanlike nuclear families. The burden bonds are those between the male and his of raising offspring appears to rest entirely on females. the female's shoulders. In fact, nuclear families are probably incompatible with the ORANGUTAN diverse use of sex found in bonobos. If our Orangutans live solitary lives with little ancestors started out with a sex life similar to bonding in evidence. Male orangutans are that of bonobos, the evolution of the family intolerant of one another. In his prime, a single would have required dramatic change. male establishes a large within which live several females. Each female has Human family life implies paternal her own, separate home range. investment, which is unlikely to develop unless males can be reasonably certain that they are 11 caring for their own, not someone else's, the most successful reconstruction of our past offspring. Bonobo society lacks any such will be based not on chimpanzees or even on guarantee, but humans protect the integrity of bonobos but on a three way comparison of their family units through all kinds of moral chimpanzees, bonobos and humans. restrictions and taboos. Thus, although our species is characterized by an extraordinary FRANS B. M. de WAAL was trained as an interest in sex, there are no societies in which ethologist in the European tradition, receiving people engage in it at the drop of a hat (or a his Ph.D. from the University of Utrecht in cardboard box, as the case may be). A sense of 1977. After a six-year study of the chimpanzee shame and a desire for domestic privacy are colony at the Arnhem Zoo, he moved to the typical human concepts related to the evolution U.S. in 1981 to work on other primate species, and cultural bolstering of the family. including bonobos. He is now a research professor at the Yerkes H.egional Primate Yet no degree of moralizing can make Research Center in Atlanta and professor of sex disappear from every realm of human life lpsychology at Emory University. that does not relate to the nuclear family. The bonobo's behavioral peculiarities may help us understand the role of sex and may have serious implications for models of human society. Response to the Review by James H. Fetzer of Animal Minds Just imagine that we had never heard by Donald Griffin (Sept. 1994 of chimpanzees or baboons and had known bonobos first. We would at present most likely Newsletter) believe that early hominids lived in £emale- centered societies, in which sex served By Nancy .E. Aiken, P. O. Box 27, Guysville, OH important social functions and in which 45735 USA. warfare was rare or absent. In the end, perhaps If it is, indeed, the case that cognitive FURTHER READING ethology is built upon two opposing views of behavior--the "common-sense" view that THE PYGMY CHIMPANZEE: animals make deliberate choices, and the EVOLUTIONARY BIOLOGY AND "behavioristic" view that cognitive processes BEHAVIOR. Edited by Randall L. Susman. have no effect on behavior--then it seems that Plenum Press, 1984. cognitive ethology is built upon two not only opposing, but very simplistic, views. THE COMMUNICATIVE REPERTOIRE OF Ethological literature certainly does not CAPTIVE BONOBOS (PAN PANISCUS) support the notion that these are the only COMPARED TO THAT OF CHIMPANZEES. possible views of animal and human behavior. F.B.M. de Waal in "Behaviour," Vol. 106, Nos. Griffin, of course, wisely suggests alternatives. 34, pages 183-251; September 1988. One of these possibilities is that cognition can occur without consciousness of that cognition. PEACEMAKING AMONG PRIMATES. F.B.M. Studies of the operations of the emotions and de Waal. Harvard University Press, 1989. other behaviors associated with precortical brain activities certainly support this UNDERSTANDING CHIMPANZEES. Edited alternative. by Paul Heltne and Linda A. Marquardt. Harvard University Press, 1989. Griffin goes further to suggest that animals also possess different lewds of THE LAST APE: PYGMY CHIMPANZEE consciousness: perceptual and reflective. Of BEHAVIOR AND ECOLOGY. Takayoshi course, humans experience reflective Kano. Stanford University Press, 1992. consciousness, but Griffin suggests that some other animals do too. A nicely developed CHIMPANZEE CULTURES. R. Wrangham, W. cortex would provide the physical structure for C. McGrew, F.B.M. de Waal and P. Heltne. reflective consciousness--just how much Harvard University Press, 1994. development is needed for reflective 12 consciousness is probably the question. true enough, but not knowing God in the perceptual sense does not preclude our knowing Fetzer suggests that cognition is built other things in the perceptual sense. upon signs and that various behaviors are Furthermore, Hume added that since we do not activated by the presence of different kinds of perceive cause and effect, we cannot know the signs. For example, an alarm call will cause cause and effect relationship. Kant reacted to other animals of the group to seek safety. Hume's conclusion by proposing that synthetic a Fetzer further suggests that distinctions can be priori knowledge answers the question of how drawn among different types of "minds" by people can "know" cause and effect. However, their reactions to different kinds of signs. Type his suggestion and explanation of synthetic a I minds can process signs that look like what priori knowledge has never been completely they stand for, e.g., light and dark. Type II understood. Perhaps he could have explained it minds can process and make uSe of signs that are causes or effects for the things for which they more dearly if he had had ethological studies stand, e.g., a fly will help satisfy a toad's to use as examples. hunger. Type III minds can process signs that are conventions associated with that for which This last notion has already been they stand, such as (and this Fetzer's example) explored by Michael Ruse (1985) in a book words in a language. edited by Fetzer, Sociobiology and Epistemology. In his chapter, Ruse suggests Perhaps I have misunderstood but it looking at synthetic a priori knowlege in light seems a large jump from type II minds to type III of E. O. Wilson's description of epigenetic rules. minds. Reducing cognition to types I-III is too Whereas Kant might say that synthetic a limiting. Using Fetzer's sign model to study priori knowledge makes cause and effect cognition has possiblities, however, and can (as necessary, Wilson would probably argue that Fetzer suggests) be superimposed on Griffin's knowing cause and effect is adaptive. Ruse ideas about types of consciousness. points out that the key difference in the Kantian and Wilsonian viewpoints is that The philosopher David Hume wrote Kant would find cause and effect "immutable" that all we know is what we know from our but Wilson would see other possibilities senses; we can only assume cause and effect. depending on the evolution of the species in Thus, if Hume was right, we human beings question. Philosophical epistemology might have type I minds. However, when Hume explore this notion of knowledge relative to discussed "knowing" he did not mean simple species as a means of darifing what we, as perceptual awareness as Griffin and Fetzer human beings, know. (This idea is being mean, but knowing in the sense of knowing explored in a paper currently being prepared for things such as how God works, what is the publication by myself and two others.) This universe, and what is justice, love, etc. Hume notion might also open the field of cognitive thought big. Much confusion results, however, ethology to a comparative approach realizing from different meanings of words. Knowing is the possibility that knowledge is relative to such a word, and consciousness is such a word. the evolutionary forces which have developed As Fetzer points out, saying an animal is the creature under study whether it be man, conscious of its behavior does not necessarily goldfish, spider, or worm. mean that the animal is reflecting upon its behavior, but only that it realizes that it is While Fetzer's sign model may work as behaving. Other terms such as mind, a means of forming a comparative approach to awareness, cognition, mentality, and thinking cognitive ethology, it is important· to avoid need to be clarifed if substantial progress is to anthropomorphising the knowledge of be made in the area of animal cognition. nonhuman creatures. We need to somehow place ourselves in their positions in order to Another concern that should be arrive at a viewpoint of their worlds as addressed relates to Hume's assessment that we objectively as it is possible. In the same way; it (human beings) can never "know" anything is important to differentiate spider knowledge because we have only our senses to provide us from cat knowledge, etc. That is, it seems with information. He meant that since we important to not only differentiate by types of cannot hear God, see God, taste God, feel God, "minds" but to remember to look at the- or smell God, we cannot know Him. That seems evolutionary forces behind those "minds." 13 Getting back to the issue of types of work stands for something that is neither signs and minds, an investigation of cognitive conventional nor biological but a subtle mixture ethology (and epistemology) should consider of both. The kind of mind that can utilize this the effects of "sign stimuli," or "releasers." The type of sign must be able to make metaphorical releaser concept has changed since the days of leaps. LQrenz and Tinbergen. [I outline these changes in my dissertation, A Biological Basis for the Fetzer's reView of Griffin's book was Emotional Impact of Art (Ohio University, quite interesting. Perhaps the suggestions 1992).] This type of sign is not alluded to by offered above will be of some value; it seems Fetzer but is similar to the type III sign. that we all need to look around at other However, the association is not through disciplines in order to broaden our views of our convention but through biology. The releaser's own specialities. An evolutionary viewpoint effect on behavior is to cause the behavior applied to any discipline seems to open many without the animal's awareness. The doors to a global perspective capable of solving importance of this type of sign cannot be and resolving many heretofore vexing problems. underestimated, especially for us human beings who are apt to think that we are aware of Reference every cause and every effect. Ruse, M. (1985). Evolutionary epistemology: Another type of sign that may have Can sociobiology help? In J.H. Fetzer importance only for human beings is the artistic (Ed.), Sociobiology and Epistemology, "sign" which can probably best be explained as pp. 249-265. D. Reidel Publishing.

Newsletter Submissions Festschrift for Dan Anything that might be of interest to ISH Freedman members is welcome: Society matters; articles; replies to articles; suggestions; announcements of meetings, journals or professional societies; The American Psychological etc. These sorts of submission should be sent to Association will sponsor a Festschrift to honor the editor. Book review inquiries should go to Daniel G. Freedman. Dan is retiring from his the appropriate book review editor (the British professorship at the Committee on Human editor covers English-language books published Development of the University of Chicago, but in Europe). Submission should be in English, continues to conduct research. The conference is on paper and, if possible, also on diskette entitled "Genetic, Ethological and (WordPerfect preferred). Shorter reviews are Evolutionary Perspectives on Human preferred (less than 1000 words). Please include Development." complete references for all publications cited. For book reviews, please include publisher's The event will take place from 7PM mailing address and the price of hardback and Fri., 27 October to 1 PM Sun., 29 October 1995 at paperback editions. There usually is not time to the University of Chicago. It should be of consult with reviewers about editorial changes, interest to a wide range of human ethologists. but most of these are minor. The scheduled speakers are: J. Michael Bailey, Newsletter submissions are usually reviewec Jerome H. Barkow, Nicholas G. Blurton Jones, only by the editorial staff. However, some Irenaus Eibl-Eibesfeldt, Paul Ekman, Irving I. submissions are rejected. Political censorship is Gottesman, Roger Levesque, Robert LeVine, avoided, so as to foster free and creative Robert Marvin, Ritch Savin-Williams, J. Paul exchange of (even outrageous) ideas among Scott, Nancy L. Segal, Robert trivers, Carol scholars. The fact that material appears in the Weisfeld, Glenn Weisfeld, and Peter Wolff. newsletter never implies the truth of those ideas, Nancy, our Membership Chair, is principal ISHE's endorsement of them, or support for any organizer of the conference. The conference will policy implications that may be inferred from them. include film presentations, a reception the first evening, time allotted for audience 14

a flyer suitable for posting, contact Nancy Segal at 1-714-773, 2142, fax 1-714-449-7134, E- Membership Renewals for 1995 mail [email protected] or Glenn Weisfeld. Dan is currently at P. O. Box 959, Las Vegas, It is time to renew your membership for 1995 if NM 87701, tel. 1-505-421-2715. you have not already done so. Membership is by calendar year, so dties are to be paid by the first of the year. If the date on your mailing label is earlier than the current year, it is time to renew your membership. For financial reasons, renewal notices are not usually sent. Those who do not renew their memberships will be removed from the membership list. Please BOOK REVIEWS report errors, changes of address, etc. to the treasurer. Current dues and directions for payment are given on the last page. Please allow four weeks for recording changes of The Bell Curve address or payment of dues. By Richard J. Herrnstein and Charles Murray. The Free Press, 866 Third Ave., New York, NY 1994. Pp. 845; $30.00 (hdbk). participation, a session for graduate students and post-doctoral fellows at which the Reviewed by Barbara Hollar, Dept. oJ 'Biology, participants will have reprints available and University of Detroit Mercy, Detroit, MI 48219 will be present to discuss their work USA. informally, and a concluding round-table discussion on fu ture research possibilities and The Bell Curve is thought provoking career opportunities. but ultimately flawed. Its errors invalidate the sweeping conclusions claimed for it by its Registration (preferably by 15 Oct.) is authors, but other facets of the book are $25 ($15 for students and post-doctoral provocative and deserve public discussion. fellows). Please send registration to Betty Cawelti (ATTN: FEST), University of Chicago, In brief, Herrnstein and Murray contend Committee on Human Development, 5730 that having a high IQ enables one to obtain S.Woodlawn, Chicago, IL 60637 USA, fax 1- education and employment in a highly 312-702-0320. Credit card payment is technological society, while having a low IQ acceptable (but not by fax). Include address, predisposes one to unemployment, poverty, phone, fax, and E-mail numbers. welfare dependency and crime. They support their hypothesis with data showing the Please make your own hotel distribution of IQ scores among various arrangements. The conference hotel is the socioeconomic, racial and ethnic groups. They Ramada Lake Shore, 4900 S. Lake Shore Dr., then argue that since the IQ distributions are Chicago, IL 60615, tel. 1-312-288-5800, fax 1- genetically 312-288-5745. Ask for Bette Hunt and the rooms determined and are resistant to environmental reserved for the "Freedman Conference". Single change, the gap between the affluent cognitive rooms are $73 per night, doubles $83. Some elite and the intellectually and economically dormitory rooms on campus may be available impoverished will grow. In a chapter entitled for about $35 at International House, 1414 E. "The Way We Are Headed", they predict a 59th St., Chicago, IL 60637 USA, tel. 1-312-753- caste system in Americawith the federal 2270, fax 1-312-753-2310. government running a "custodial state" in which the underclass is kept out of sight and out of mind. According to Murray and For additional information or to receive Herrnstein, "we have in mind a high-tech and 15 more lavish version of the Indian reservation example. But this time, when you do the for sorne substantial minority of the nation's heritability calculations, you find that population, while the rest of America tries to heritability is low. The variation in height is go about its business" (p. 526). due more to the differing microenvironments than it is to genes. But the genes in the seeds While one might think that the whole are exactly the same in the two examples. idea might be inflammatoryenough to start several advocacy groups afire, in fact public Murray and Herrnstein's error is to discussion thus far has seemed to focus on the have assumed that heritability is a fixed part of the book that deals with genetics, IQ, value. Even worse, they have arrived at the and race (Chapter 13). Not only is this the heritability estimate that they use throughout most politically volatile issue in the book, it the book by determining a "middle-ground highlights the weakest link in their argument. estimate" taken from many different studies of Herrnstein and Murray misunderstand the heritability. This is roughly akin to a concept of heritability. They have committed climatologist averaging today's temperatures a fundamental error in the use of heritability in London, New Delhi, and Melbourne measures that anyone who has taken a college and declaring 60 degrees to be the world level course in genetics would recognize temperature useful in any climate model. immediately. Since many otherwise well informed readers know little about genetics, Even the reasons for pursuing the public reaction in the media has been to discuss analysis of heritability are unclear. If the ethics of broaching the topic rather than to Herrnstein and Murray had data to show that analyze the argument itself. the heritability of IQ in both blacks and whites were La, the differences in the IQ Let me illustrate why their analysis is distributions between the races could still be incorrect. Heritability is defined as the envirorunentai. Furthermore, heritability proportion of the total variance in a trait measurements do not enable one to predict what (phenotypic variance) that is due to would happen in an entirely new environment. variance. It ranges from zero (no genetlc The heritability of stature in people has been influence) to one (all of the variation in the high in every study done, but over the last trait is due to genetics). Heritabilities century average height has increased measured in one place at One point in time are dramatically. It is possible for heritability to valid only for that set of conditions and cannot be high in the old environment and in the new be extrapolated from one population to another. environment while the trait still changes An example will serve to demonstrate the substantially. In short, the prediction that we rationale behind this "rule". Suppose you take will have a heritable caste system based on the a handful of genetically similar com seeds and genetics of IQ is unsubstantiated. plant them in a greenhouse under carefully controlled conditions. When the plants mature, If the analysis of heritability is there will be variation in height which you incorrect, are there any other reasons for can graph as a bell curve. If you measure recommending the book? This certainly is not a heritability in this population, you will find it book that I would recommend to the casual to be very high, meaning that the. environment reader. The prose is dense, and the text is thick (which was held constant) had little to do with data even for readers in the "cognitive with plant height and genetics accounts for elite" who are accustomed to journal reading. most of the variation. Now suppose you could However, if you are willing to persevere, there take the very same com and plant it outdoors. is a great deal of data that is relevant to Some seeds will have optimum growth current political discussions of education, conditions but others will fall in a shady spot welfare and affirmative action. or on rocky soil. When you measure the variation in height of the mature plants, you Part I of the book is an examination of will get a bell curve again, albeit probably one the group of people Herrnstein and Murray term with a larger variance than in the greenhouse the "cognitive elite". (Those of you reading 16 this are certainly members of this group.) equal job opportunities regardless of their People with high cognitive abilities, ethnic group. regardless of socioeconomic status, will attend college and become employed in a relatively Taken as a whole, this is not a book small number of professional occupations which that I can recommend. While individual pay well in comparison to the average job. The chapters have merit (particularly those authors argue that this partitioning by IQ and showing links between low intelligence and the occupation will continue and that the tendency to drop out of school or to end up on "cognitive elite" will become increasing public assistance), the overall argument that a isolated from other Americans. The assumption hereditary underclass is forming does not hold is that this group is likely to become richer and up. While few would dispute the claim that more powerful as others struggle to make ends genes ha:ve an effect on nervous system meet. How convincing this argument is depends development, no one knows which genes are upon whether or not you believe that recent involved, how many genes are involved, or how trends in employment are likely to continue. those genes are distributed in the population. Derek Bok's book, The Cost of Talent (1993), Given that, it is presumptuous in the extreme to analyzes this issue in detail and would be a suggest that class structure in America is a valuable supplement while reading result of the genetics of IQ. Herrnstein and Murray. While I agree with those who say that The analyses of social concerns such as Herrnstein and Murray's ideas should be poverty, crime, unemployment, and welfare within the the realm of public debate, I hope dependency with regard to IQ are enlightening. that while we are debating we do not lose The unspoken assumption in our culture is that sight of the measures such as prenatal care and these problems are in large part due to a infant nutrition that we know to be effective in background of low socioeconomic status. preventing some cases of subnormal intelligence. Herrnstein and Murray show that low IQ is a much stronger predictor of poverty and Reference unemployment than is socioeconomic background. Their analysis of the National Bok, D. The Cost of Talent. New York: The Free Longitudinal Study of Youth showed that Press, 1993. three-fourths of the white women on welfare after the birth of their first child came from the bottom quartile of IQ. This has profound public policy implications. Proponents of welfare reform are proposing mandatory job Nature's Mind: The Biological training for welfare recipients. Job training Roots Thinking, Emotions, programs involve teaching skills that of employers find desirable. If, in fact, many of Sexuality, Language, and the people on welfare are incapable of Intelligence attaining this level of competence, reform could be an expensive mistake. By Michael S. Gazzaniga. Basic Books, 10 E. 53rd St., New York, NY 10022, USA, 1992, $25 Finally, the authors tackle the issue of (hdbk.). affirmative action. Regardless of your opinion on the matter, you will find their analysis Reviewed by Linda Mealey, Psychology interesting. The authors clearly trace the Department, College of St. Benedict, history of affirmative action from its Collegeville, MN 56321 USA. legislative beginnings through subsequent court and executive decisions to its present form, and This is a book that, in my estimation, is then analyze whether or not present policies mistitled. I'm guessing that the title was have had the desired effect. Not surprisingly, designed to appeal to a broad, lay audience, but they favor reforming affirmative action so that I expect the result is that it will not be read by people with equal intellectual abilities have as many academics as it should. Gazzaniga's 17 book is not just any other pop psych or pop bio definitely worth reading. book. In fact, despite the subtitle, there is nothing in the book on emotion or sexuality. On the other hand, I am not as The book is really about the role of selection in enthusiastic about the rest of the book. the ultimate expression of mind--not just the Subsequent chapters--on the development of role of natural selection in designing our species' cognition, language, intelligence, consciousness, brain, but selection at the level of cells and addictions and compulsions, psychoanalysis, neural circuits whose tailoring can give rise to and health care--are increasingly distant from hundreds of thousands of different phenotypes, the thesis, and increasingly disjointed in style. expressed as individual minds. As such, it is Only if one is already familiar with the basic the first of what will likely be a stream of research of a given chapter will the connection popular books on this subject. to the selection model be at all evident. There is, however, no need to read all of the chapters The introduction, entitled "Selection nor to read them sequentially. I would suggest versus Instruction," puts proposes that the brain reading only the one or two most relevant to is not plastic in any of the ways previously one's own field, to get an idea of how selection thought. It is not a tabula rasa, nor clay to be theory may affect that field in the next few molded, nor even a profusion of neurons decades. awaiting environmental input in order to form their eventual adult circuitry. Rather, it I might also mention that the book consists of a plethora of pre-wired circuits utilizes what is becoming an increasingly available to respond to a variety of common form of referencing that r am very environmental contingencies. Through cell unhappy with: The text contains vague death and the selective retention of certain references to particular authors, without a circuits over others, an individual's particular reference number or a date. Instead, the brain and mind is selected from the many numbers refer to footnotes at the back of the possible minds encoded in the original genotype book which point the reader to "suggested and phenotype. readings". Not only is it impossible to know which original works were actually utilized in Although we have known abo ut the writing of the text, but I find this format perinatal neuronal death for decades, the much more prone to error than formal citation. interpretation of this phenomenon as a The footnotes mention articles or books that selection process is fairly new and has many may have influenced the author, but may not profound implications. Theoretically, this have been cited in context or cited at all. view allows a reconciliation of the functionalist view of the brain as a set of pre- All in all, I find Gazzaniga to be an determined and independent cognitive modules enthusiastic spokesperson trying to fill a (Fodor, 1981) with the interactionist view that serio!ls gap in the current literature. Still, I acknowledges the apparent role of "learning" look forward to an accessible text by an expert in development. It is also compatible with (but who can focus on the selection model and not identical to) the "Neural Darwinism" of explain it with patience rather than with the Gerald Edelman (1987, 1992). Practically unfocussed energy of the recently converted. speaking, this view leads to a change in our conception of the mechanics of learning and the References role of environmental input in that process. Edelman, G.M (1987). Neural Darwinism: The Chapter 1 and 2 are, respectively, an Theory of Neuronal Group Selection. New explanation of the model based on an analogy York: Basic Books. to the immune system, and an application of the model to the well-known work on the --- (1992). Bright Air, Brilliant Fire: On the plasticity of the visual system. These two Matter of the Mind. New York: Basic Books. chapters are accessible (I was unable to get through the Edelman .books because of their Fodor, 1.A. (1981). The Modularity of the Mind. technical q.ifficulty).. and fundamental-- Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. 18 Politics ofEthnic Nepotism: India because, despite being a highly developed democracy, competing ethnic groups in the US as an Example are finding it increasingly difficult to agree on institutional structures that would adequately By Tatu Vanhanen. Sterling Publishers Pvt. satisfy their individual needs. His third Ltd., New Delhi, India 110016, LlO, Green Park agenda is a proposal for reforms that could Extension, 1991,200 Rupees (ca.$12). mitigate ethnic conflict if political structures were built upon biological realties. Reviewed by William R. Charlesworth, Institute of Child Development, University of The starting point of his effort is the Minnesota, 51 E. River Road, Minneapolis, .MN fact that ethnic conflicts are very common 55455 USA. today. Drawing on Horowitz (1985) (a recommended companion to the present This is an interesting book. As noted on volume), Vanhanen reports that ethnic the book jacket, it "traces the origin of ethnic conflicts have claimed ten million lives since conflicts, not only in India but in all ethnically the end of WWII--even in "modernized" divided societies, to our assumed universal countries. According to Vanhanen, no theory behavioural predispositions, shared by natural (including Marx's) has adequately accounted selection, to favour kin over non-kin." for these conflicts. In his estimation, the only theory that can do this job is Darwin's theory Tatu Vanhanen, Associate Professor of of evolution by natural selection. As Vanhanen Science at the University of Tampere, Finland, informs us in his introduction, .... I have tried to has written numerous books on power, formulate a theory of ethnic nepotism derived militarism and military rule, as well as on from the socio-biological theory of kin political and social strllctures in various selection, according to which the ultimate aim countries. His interest in "how ethnic of human beings is to reproduce their own genes cleavages affect the nature of political through their own offspring and relatives" (pp. institutions and the process of democratic 1£). He also notes that" ethnic loyalties have politics .. (p. vii) took him to India1. As the so often proved more important and stronger largest, mO$t ethnically, religiously, and than ideological or class interests" (p. 2). culturally diverse democracy in the world, India consists of numerous opposing, self-serving Chapter 2 contains a synopsis of groups of citizens, each struggling against the biological thinking that concludes that conflict other and at the same collaborating in order to over scarce resources is a fact of all life and obtain vital resources. that those who cooperate do so because they are genetic relatives. Even in large, modern Vanharten has several agendas. The societies genetic nepotism, Vanhanen asserts, is fitst is to describe the current ethno-political the rule. "Communalism, casteism, scene in India using the resulting picture as a nationalism, patriotism, racism, and regional basis to test the hypothesis of ethnic nepotism solidarity are forms of nepotism." (p.ll). deduced from kin selection theory. His second While many proximate explanations can be agenda is to illustrate the persistence of ethnic evoked to account for nepotistic conflict over nepotism outside of India, such persistence resources, Darwin's theory of ultimate suggesting that its origin resides in human causation provides the most convincing nature rather thim in socio-economic conditions. explanation: individuals have been selected to He chooses the US as a comparison country maximize their inclusive fitness. All else follows from this. 1Acaveat is in order here. The reviewer is only somewhat familiar with India, having Vanhanen then applies his theory to been there briefly to do research with young India which, despite its democratic structures, children and having read only a modest amount is plagued by serious ethnic conflicts. Reasons about modern India and its socio/political for this include "traditionalism" (old conflicts problems. Hopefully, these insufficiencies will are not forgotten) as well as "modernization" not detract from a fair and useful review of this (it creates or sustain such conflicts since the book. economic gains of modernization are not equally 19 shared). Dispensing with these reasons as historically has had a large, dominant inadequate, Vanha.nen evokes traditional majority (whites), but, unlike India, only two socio/psychological concepts such as in- major mirtorities--blacks and Native Americans group/ out-group distinctions, xenophobia, and (Hispanics were probably excluded because ethnocentrism and connects them with the they are relative latecomers). The long history concepts of inclusive fitness, kin selection and of whites encountering Native Americans began nepotism. Drawing on van den Berghe (1981) in the early 17th Century and resulted in and Vine (1987), Vanhanen makes a theoretical numerous major and minor conflicts that ended a case for why individuals show discriminatory little more than a century ago. Enslavement of preference for individuals most like the blacks by whites, also beginning in the themselves. Ergo, members of the same ethnic early 17th Century, was accompanied by long, group will avoid social conflict with each systematic repression lasting well into the 20th other and engage in such conflict with others. Century. Vanhanen ends this chapter with the Given that our behavioral predisposition to conclusion that US social conflicts support his ethnic nepotism is rooted in evolution, he hypothesis that "the more ethnic groups differ proposes two universal hypotheses--first, from each other genetically, the more probable "ethnic cleavages always lead to ethnic are violent conflicts between them" (p. 159). interest conflicts", and second, "the mote a That he does not in this, or in other parts of the society is ethnically divided, the more book, deal with intra-ethnic conflicts, is an political and other interest conflicts tend to obvious omission. become canalized along ethnic lines" (pp. 13f). In the final chapter, Vanhanen In his third and longest chapter expands on his idea that ethnic conflicts can be Vanhanen presents historical, geographic, accommodated by certain political reforms. demographic, and political information on While democratic governments have means of ethnicity in India and the pressures it puts on abolishing rank based on ethnicity (as in India Indian unity. Diverse linguistic and religious and the US), thereby theoretically ensuring a groups (four of the former and seven of the fairer distribution of opportunity, education, latter) intersect or underlie "scheduled castes" and wealth, a plurality electoral system (as in and "scheduled tribes" to produce a "vast both systems) "is not well suited to plural ethnic mosaic" dominated by a Hindu majority societies because it produces highly unequal (ca. 83%) which itself is also a mosaic of castes representation of politkal parties and and languages. The all-India mosaic consists of discriminates against minority groups geographically (and not so geographically) systematically and may deprive them of discrete political groups (more than 80 representation" (p. 169). To rectify this, participated in elections between 1952 and Vanha.nen suggests the implementation of three 1984) each attempting to establish its own "institutional techniques" --federalism, political power base. proportional (instead of electoral) representation, and parliamentarism. These Giyen persistent shortages of resources, te.:hniques would mean fitting political systems competition and conflict are bound to occur in to the facts of ethnic nepotism rather than such diverse country. Of 293 violent social living with nepotism and the endless conflicts conflicts reported in India between 1980-1988, generated by it when resources are in short 25 (ca. 9%) were non-ethnic in character. By supply. Vanhanen's definition of ethnic, the 268 remaining were ethnic--Hindu-Muslim, Hindu- As already noted, Vanhanen is cautious Harijan, tribal-non-tribat Hindu-Sikh, and about drawing firm conclusions in favor of his other. In light of these data, Vanhanen hypothesis. I would also be cautious. His cautiously concludes that "nearly all violent efforts leave open various questions of social conflicts have taken place between definition and methodology. But there is a clearly different ethnic groups and that ... the bigger question still to be asked. Given the genetic distance between conflicting groups has nature of his theoretical leanings, what kind of increased the probability of violence" (p. 133). data are (can ever be) available that would lead to a convincing test of his hypotheses? As Chapter 5 deals with an historical with all other human research aimed at analysis of ethnic conflicts in the US. Similar examining genetic and environmental causes, to the Hindu majority in India, the os the causes in reality are always conflated and 20 can only, at best, be statistically References Where the "dependent variable" is so global a concept as social conflict and the "independent" Hermstein, R.J. & Murray, C. (1994). The bell variable of ethnicity so vague and so removed curve: Intelligence and class structure In from hard genetic evidence, historical accident, American life. New York: The Free Press. and daily experience, it takes a daring scholar to bring the variables together to test for their Horowitz, D.L. (1985). Ethnic groups in conflict. causal connection. Berkeley, University of California Press.

Despite these shortcomings, Vanhanen, MacDonald, K. (1994). A people that shall in my estimation, is on the right track in taking dwell alone: Judaism as a group evolutionary on the problem of nepotistic conflict. The strategy. Westport, CT: Praeger Publishers. question is whether at present the track is scientifically strong enough to carry the freight Rushton, J.P. (1989). Genetic similarity, human of explanation required to account for one of the altruism, and group selection. Behavioral and most dangerous social problems facing us today. Brain Sciences,13, 503-559. Rushton's (1989) work on genetic similarity and altruism and the recent volumes by Hermstein van der Berghe, P.L. (1981). The ethnic & Murray (1994) on the contribution of phenomenon. New York: Elsevier. intelligence to social stratification and by MacDonald (1994) on Judaism as a group Vine, 1. (1987). Inclusive fitness and the self evolutionary strategy are current examples of system: The roles of human nature and socio- this. Does social stratification begin, persist, cultural processes in intergroup discrimination. and end with genetic disparities in those In V. Reynolds et al.(Eds.) (pp.60- cognitive skills that contribute to economic and 80),Sociobiology of Ethnocentrism. London: social success? If so, what should policy makers Groom Helms. and citizens in a democracy do with such knowledge? If social conflict truly is based on ethnic nepotism, and ethnic groups differ in cognitive skills, and all individuals are ANNOUNCEMENTS genetically programmed to maximize their fitness, what steps should reasonable people Gruter Institute Seminars take to avoid social conflict? Or should any steps be taken at all? These are not strictly The third annual faculty seminar on scientific questions, but scientists are going to be "Biological Perspectives in the Social asked them anyway. Sciences" will take place at Dartmouth College 5-11 August 1995. Directed by ISHE If there is a more exciting combination of variables to get the adrenaline of cultural members Roger D. Masters and Michael T. relativists and evolutionary determinists McGuire, visiting lecturers will represent flOWing, I would like to hear about it. diverse fields in the biological and social Vanhanen's effort is an introduction to this sciences. Invited lecturers are Miguel Marin- combination that needs careful consideration. Padilla, Robert Trivers, Lionel Tiger, Helen Cultural relativists who hope their Fisher, Robert Frank, E. Donald Elliott, and formulations will help resolve social conflicts ought to turn to Vanhanen and broaden their Edward Berger. A limited number of grants perspective to include inclusive fitness. covering expenses exclusive of travel Evolutionists ought to examine how far the (estimated at $300) are available to scholars logic of their position can justifiably extend or graduate students. For information or into such a complex phenomenon as human applications write: Ms. Kimberly Watson, survival politics. Future generations have a lot Nelson A. Rockefeller Center for the Social of stake in this. Sciences, 6082 Rockefeller Hall, Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH 03755-3514 USA, tel. 603-646-3874, fax 1-603-646-1329. 21

A similar seminar is being orgartized at the Squaw Valley Inn, Squaw Valley, Editorial Staff California24-29 June 1995. For details contact Ms. Gerti Dieker, Gruter Institute for Law and Assodate Editor Behavioural Research, 158 Goya Rd., Portola Laurence J. Stettner Valley, CA 94028 USA. Department of Psychology Wayne State University Detroit, MI 48202 USA Requestfor Research Assistance: a tel. 1-313-577-2866 Prepucition Current Literature Editor Any information on foreskins of the great apes, Robert M. Adams Department of Psychology sexually transmitted diseases in feral Eastern Kentucky University primates, or the pheromonic qualities of Richmond, KY 40475-0937 USA smegma is being solicited by two of our members. Contact Wade C. Mackey, Dept. of American Book Review Editor Psychology, Southeastern Community College, Linda Mealey West Burlington, Iowa 52655 USA or Ron Department of Psychology St. John's University Immerman, E-mail Collegeville, MN 56321 USA [email protected]. tel. 1-612-363-3135 fax 1-612-363-3202 American Anthropological E-mail [email protected] Association Panel British Book Review Editor The Gruter Institute sponsored a panel on A. Stuart Laws "Where in human nature do human rights come Department of Psychology The University from?" at the AAA convention in Atlanta, Newcastle upon Tyne Georgia 1 Dec. 1994. The program was NE1 7RU, England organized by Oliver Goodenough and Lionel tel. 44-91-222-6000 Tiger. Speakers included Frans de Waal, fax 44-91-261-1182 Robert Wright, Ward Goodenough, Roger Telex 53654 (UNINEW G) Masters, Laura Betzig, and Beth Stevens. Jane French Book Review Editor Lancaster was the discussant. Peter LaFreniere Universite de Montreal C. P. 6128, succursale A, Association for the Study of Animal Montreal, Quebec H3C 3J7, Canada Behaviour German Book Review Editor Karl Grammer The summer meeting of the Associaton for the Ludwig Boltzmann Institute for Study of Animal Behaviour will tClke place 12- Urban Ethology/Human Biology 14 It,lly 1995 in Leiden, The Netherlands. The Althanstrasse 14 main theme will be 'Behavioural Mechanisms A-1090 Vienna, Austria and Evolution." For information contact Carel Spanish and Portuguese Book Review Editor ten Cate, Institute of Evolutionary and Eduardo Gudynas Ecological Sciences, Faculty of Mathematics c/o ASMER Regional Office and Natural Sciences, Kaiserstraat 63, P. O. Casilla Correo 13125 Box 9516, NL-2300, RA Leiden, The Montevideo, Uruguay Netherlands; fax 31-71-274900. 22

Calafate, L.C (1994). Etologiae Educa<;ao: CURRENT Contribui<;ao para uma discussao da "funi;ao do LITERATURE comportamento de ensina, segundo uma perspectiva biol6gica. 0 Professor, 41: 65-72. June 1995 (Instituto de Botanica "Dr. Gon<;alo Sampaio", Universidade do Porto, Rua do Campo Alegre Interested in possibly reviewing one of the 1191,4150 Porto, Portugal). books below or some other suitable book? Please contact the appropriate book review Calafate, L. C. (1994). Vers une approche editor (see Editorial Staff box). biologique de la socialisation. Revista Portuguesa de Educa(:iio, 7, 27-36. (see supra). Submit items for Current Literature to Bob Adams (see box). Please be sure that the item Caro, TM.. (1995). Short-term costs and has not yet appeared. correlates of play in cheetahs. Ani maI Behaviour, 49, 333-345. (Dept. of Wildlife, Agoramoorthy, G. & Rudran R. (1995). Fish & Conservation BioI and Ctr. For Infanticide by adult and subadult males in free- Population Biology, Univ. of California, ranging red howler monkeys, Alouatta Davis, CA 95616, USA). seniculus, in Venezuela. Ethology, 99, 75. (Natl. Sun Yat Sen Univ., Dept. Biol., Carroll, J. (1995). Evolution and Literary Kaohsiung 80424, Taiwan). Theory. Univ. of Missouri Press, 2910 LeMone blvd., Columbia, MO 65201 USA, $44.95 Alexander, J.P. (1994). Sexual dimorphism in (hdbk.). Needs Reviewer. Nothactid primates. Folia Primatologica, 63, 59. (Amer. Museum Nat. Hist., Dept. Chiarello, AG. (1995). Grooming in brown Vertebrate Paleontol., Cent. Pk. W. & 79th St., howler monkeys, Alouatta fusca. American New York, NY 10024, USA). Journal of Primatology, 35, 73. (Univ. Cambridge, Dept. Anat. Wildlife Res. Grop., Allman, W. F.(1994). The Stone Age Present. Downing St., Cambridge CB2 3DY, England). Simon & Schuster, 200 Old Tappan Rd., Old Tappan, NJ 07675 USA, $23. Needs Reviewer. Cohen, D. B. (1993). Development of Play. Routledge, 29 W. 35th St., New York, NY 10001 Almada, V., & Oliveira, R. (Eds.) (1994). USA. Biologia e Comportamento. Lisboa, Portugal: Instituto Superior de Cohen, D. B. (1994). Out of the Blue:

.- Depression and human nature. W.W. Norton, B-arnerr;"&A.---(1994). Humanity as Homo 500 Fifth Ave., New York, NY 10110 USA docens:: the teaching species. Interdisciplinary Science Reviews, 19, 166-174. (Australian National University, Canberra, ACT, Australia). Cormor, R.c. & Curry, R.L. (1995). Helping non- relatives: A role for deceit? Ani mal Bauman, M. L., & Kemper, T. L. (1994). Behaviour, 49, 389-393. (Div. of BioI. Sci. & Neurobiology of Autism. Johns Hopkins Univ. Michigan Society of Fellows, Museum of Press, 701 W. 40th St., Baltimore, MD 21211 Zoology, Univ. Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA. USA).

Boinski, S. (1994). Affiliation patterns among Cooper, R. (Ed.) (1994). Sleep. Routledge, male Costa Rican squirrel monkeys. Behaviour, Chapman & Hall, 29 W. 35th St., New York, 130, 191-210. (Univ. Florida, Dept. Anthropol., NY 10001 USA 1350 Turlington, Gainesville, FL, 32611, USA). Cooper, S. J., & Hendrie, C.A (Eds.). (1995). Buss, D.M. (1995). The Evolution of Desire: Ethology and Psychopharmacology.. John Strategies of human mating. New York: Basic Wiley, Dept. 063, 1 Wiley Dr., Somerset, NJ Books [just out in paperback; $13.]10 E. 53rd St., 08875 USA, $20. Needs Reviewer. NY, NY 10022-5299USA 23 Dawkins, R. (1995). River out of Eden: A Foley, R A. (Ed.) (1991). Origins of Human Darwinian view of life. Basic Books, 10 E. 53rd Behaviour. London: Unwin Hyman. St., New York, NY 10022 USA, $20 (hdbk). Furuichi, T., Thobe, H. (1994). Variation in Dawson, G., & Fischer, K. W. (Eds.) (1994). male relationships in bonobos and Human Behavior and the Developing Brain. Behaviour, 130(3-4), 211-228. Guilford, 72 Spring St., New York, NY 10012 (Meiji Gakuin Univ., BioI. Lab, 1518 USA. Kamikurata, Yokohama, Kanagawa 244, Japan). DeFries, J. c., Plomin, R., & Fulker, D. W. (1994). Nature and Nurture During Middle Gable, R K. (1993). Instrument Development in Childhood. Blackwell, 3 Cambridge Center, the Affective Domain. Kluwer, 101 Philip Dr., Cambridge, MA 02142 USA. Norwell, MA 02061 USA

Dennett, D. C. (1995). Darwin's Dangerou$ Gardner, R. A, Gardner, B. T., Chiarelli, B., & Idea: Evolution and the meanings of life. Simon Plooij, F. X. (Eds.). (1994). Ethological Roots of & Schuster, 200 Old Tappan Rd., Old Tappan, Culture. Kluwer Academic Publishers, 101 NJ 07675 USA, $30 (hdbk). Philip Dr., Norwell, MA 02061 USA. Needs Reviewer. Depew, D.J., & Weber, B. H. (1995). Darwinism Evolving: Systems dynamics and Gilette, D. M. (1995). Primal Love: Reclaiming the of natural selection. MIT Press, our instincts for lasting passion. St. Martin's 55 Hayward St., Cambridge, MA 02142 USA, Press, 175 Fifth Ave., New York, NY 10010 $49.95 (hdbk). USA, $21.95 (hdbk). Needs Reviewer.

Deputte, B.L. (1994). Ethological study of Goldberg, T.L. (1995). Altruism towards yawning in primates .1. Quantitative analysis pandhandlers: Who gives? Human Nature, 6, and study of causation in two species of Old 79-90. (Harvard Univ., Peabody Museum, World monkeys (Cercocebus albigena and Dept. Anthropol., 11 Divinity Ave., Macaca fascicularis). Ethology, 98(3&4), 221- Cambridge, MA, 02138, USA). 245. (Lab Primatol. BioI. Evolut., CNRS, URA 373, BioI. Stn. F-35380 Paimpont, France). Goozen, S. H. M. van, Poll, N. E. Van de, & Sergeant, J. A. (Eds.). (1994). Emotions: Essays Dunbar, RI.M. & Dunbar, P. (1995). Mother- on emotion theory.. L. Erlbaum, 365 Broadway, infant contact as contingent behaviour in gelada Hillsdale, NJ 07642 USA baboons. Animal Behaviour, 49, 805-810. (Dept. Anthropology, Univ. ColI. London, Harrison, P.J., Everall, J.P., & Catalan, J. Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, u.K.) (1994). Is homosexual behaviour hard-wired? Sexual orientation and brain structure. Dunbar, R. I. M., Duncan, N. D. c., & Nettle, D. Psychological Medicine, 24, 811-816. (1995). Size and structure of freely forming (Warneford Hosp., Dept. Psychiat., Oxford conversational groups. Human Nature, 6, 67-78. OX3 7JX, England), (See supra). Hill, D.A. (1994). Affiliative behaviour Fay, J.M., Carroll RW. (1994). Chimpanzee between adult males of the genus Macaca. tool use for honey and termite extraction in Behaviour, 130(3-4), 293-308. (Univ. Hong Central Africa. American Journal of Kong, Dept. Anat., Li Shu Fan Bldg., 5 Sassoon Primatology, 34, 309-319. (New York Zool. Rd., Hong Kong, Hong Kong). Soc., Wildlife Conservation Soc, Bronx, NY 10460, USA). Feierman, J.R (1994). A testable hypothesis about schizophrenia generated by evolutionary Hill, D.A. & van Hooff, J.AR.A.M. (1994). theory. Ethology & Sociobiology, 15, 263-282. Affiliative relationships between males in (Presbyterian Behav. Med. Ctr., 1325 Wyoming groups of nonhuman primates: A summary. Blvd. NE, Albuquerque, NM, 87112, USA). Behaviour, 130, 143-150. (see supra). 24

Hill, E.M., Young, J.P. & Nord, J.L. (1994). L'Heureux, N., Lucherini, M., Festa-Bianchet, Childhood adversity, attachment security, and M. & Jorgenson, J. T. (1995). Density-dependent adult relationships: A preliminary study. mother-yearling association in bighorn sheep. Ethology & Sociobiology, 15, 323-338. (Univ. Animal Behaviour, 49, 901-910. (Groupe de Michigan, Alcohol Res. Ctr., Dept. Psychiat., recherches en ecologie, nutrition et energetique, 400 E. Eisenhower, Ann Arbor, MI, 48104, USA). Departement de biologie, Universite de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, Quebec, J1K 2R1 Huesmann, L. R (1994). Aggressive Behavior: Canada). Curren t perspectives. Plenum, 233 Srpng St., New York, NY 1013 USA. Lichtenberg, K. E. (1994). Research Guide to Human Sexuality. Garland, 717 Fifth Ave., Judge, P.G., & deWaal, F.B.M. (1994). New York, NY 10022 USA. Intergroup grooming relations between alpha females in a population of free-ranging rhesus Lintl, G.5., Mase, D., Lafrancois, D., Okeeffe, macaques. Folia Primatologica, 63, 63-70. RT., & Lifshitz, K. (1995). Social and (Yerkes Reg. Primate Res. Or., Field Stn., 2409 menstrual cycle phase influences on the Taylor Rd., Lawrenceville, GA, 30243, USA). behavior of group-housed Cebus apella. American Journal of Primatology, 35, 41-58. Karen, R. (1994). Becoming Attached: (Nathan S. Kline Inst. Psychiat. Res. Unfolding the mystery of the infant-mother Orangeburg, NY, 10962, USA). bond and its impact on later life. Warner, 666 Fifth Ave., New York, NY 10103 USA. Macedonia, J.M. & Stamps, J.A. (1994). Species recognition in Anolis grahami (Sauria, Kerasote, T. (1993). Bloodties: Nature, culture Iguanidae): Evidence from responses to video and the hunt. Random House, 201 E. 50th St., playbacks of conspecific and heterospecific New York, NY 10022 USA. displays. Ethology, 98(3-4), 246-264. (Alma CoIl., Dept. Bio!., Alma, MI, 48801, USA). Kerber, K.B. (1994). The marital balance of power and quid pro quo: An evolutionary Maestripieri, D. (1994). Mother-infant perspective. Ethology & Sociobiology, IS, 283- relationships in three species of macaques 298. (Univ. Michigan, Dept. Psychiat., 400 E. (Macaca mulatta, M. nemestrina, M. Eisenhower Pkwy., Bldg. 2, Suite A, Ann Arbor, arctoides).l.Development of the mother-infant MI, 48104, USA). relationship in the first three months. Behaviour, 131(1-2), 75-96. (Emory Univ., Kohl, J. V., & Francoeur, R. T. (1995). Scent of Dept. Psycho!., 2409 Taylor Lane, Eros: Mysteries of odor in human sexuality. Lawrenceville, GA, 30243, USA). Continuum Publishing, 370 Lexington Ave., New York, NY 10017 USA, $24.95 (hdbk.). Needs Marks, I.M. & Neese, R.M. (1994). Fear and Reviewer. fitness: An evolutionary analysis of anxiety disorders. Ethology & Sociobiology, 15, 247- Kuhn, S. L. (1995). Mousterian Lithic 262. (Inst. Psychiat., London, SE5 8AF, U.K.). Technology: An ecological perspective. Princeton Univ. Press, 41 William St., McGuire, M.T., Fawzy, F.L, Spar, J.E., Weigel, Princeton, NJ 08540 USA, $49.50 (hdbk.). KM., & Troisi, A. (1994). Altruism and mental disorders. Ethology & Sociobiology, 15, 299- Laland, K.N., Jumm, J. & Feldman, M.W. 322. (Univ. Calif. Los Angeles, Inst. (1995). Gene-culture coevolutionary theory: A Neuropsychiat., Sch. Med., Dept. Psychiat. & test case. Current Anthropology, 36, 131. Biobehav. Sci., Los Angeles, CA 90024, USA). (Univ. Cambridge, Subdept. Anim. Behav. Cambridge CB3 8AA, England). McKinney, W.T., Gardner, K, Barlow, G.W., & McGuire, M.T. (1994). Conceptual basis of Laska, M., Hudson, R (1995). Ability of female animal models in psychiatry: A conference squirrel monkeys (Saimiri sciureus) to summary. Ethology &- Sociobiology, IS, 369- discriminate between conspecific urine odours. 382. (Univ. Wisconsin, Sch. Med., Dept. Ethology, 99, 39-53. (Univ. Munich, Inst. Med. Psychiat., Harlow Primate Lab., 22 N. Charter Psychology, Goethestr. 31, D-80336 Munich, St., Madison, WI, 53715, USA). Germany). 25

McGuire, M.T., McKinney, W.T., Nesse, RM., & Plomin, R. (1994). Genetics and Experience: The Troisi, A. (1994). Special issue introduction. interplay between nature and nurture. Sage, Ethology & Sociobiology, 15, 245-246. (Univ. 2455 Teller Rd., Newbury Park, CA 91320 USA. Calif. Los Angeles, Inst. Neuropsychiat., Sch. Med., Dept. Psychiat. & Biobehav. Sci., Los Pool, R E. (1994). Eve's Rib: Searching for the Angeles, CA 90024, USA). biological roots of sex differences. Crown Publishers, New York, NY, USA. Mehler, J., & Dupoux, E. (1994). What Infants Know: The new cognitive science of early Pope, S. (1994). Evolution of Altruism and the development. Blackwell, 3 Cambridge Center, Ordering of Love. Georgetown Univ. Press, Cambridge, MA 02142 USA. Georgetown Univ., Washington, DC 20057-1079 USA. Needs Reviewer. Mitchell, c.L. (1994). Migration alliances and coalitions among adult male South American Relethford, J.H., & Harpending H.C., (1994). squirrel monkeys (Saimiri sciureus). Behaviour, Craniometric variation, genetic theory, and 130(3-4), 169-190. (Duke Univ., Or. Trop modern human origins. American Journal of Conservat., Amazon Biodivers. Project, POB Physical Anthropology, 95, 249-271. (Suny 821, Cuzco, Peru). ColI. Oneonta, Dept. Anthropol., Oneonta, NY 13820, USA). Messer, S.c. & Gross, A.M. (1995). Childhood depression and family interaction: A Rogers, L.J., & Kaplan, G. (1994). A new form of naturalistic observation study. Journal of tool use by orang-utans in Sabah, East Clinical Child Psychology, 24, 71-76. (Duke Malaysia. Folia Primatologica, 63, 50-52. Univ., Med. Or., Dept. Psychiatry & Behavior (Univ. New England, Dept. Physiol., Med., Dev. Epidemiol Program, Box 3454, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia). Durham, NC, 27710, USA). Ron, T. (1994). An ambitious baboon: Money, J. (1994). Reinterpreting the Independent rise in rank by a single female. Unspeakable: Human sexuality 2000. New Folia Primatologica, 63, 71-74. (Nat. Reserves York: Continuum. Author. Israel, 78 Yirmeyahu St., IL-94467 Jerusalem, Israel.) Nesse, R.M. (1994). An evolutionary perspective on substance abuse. Ethology & Rowe, D. C. (1994). The Limits of Family Sociobiology, 15, (Uillv. Michigan, Influence: Genes, experience, and behavior. Dept. Psychiat., Med. Inn Bldg., Room C440, Guilford, 72 Spring St., New York, NY 10012 Ann Arbor, MI, 48109, USA). USA.

Nicholson, J. (1993). Men and Women: How different are they? Oxford Univ. Press, Walton St., Oxford OX 2 6DP, u.K. Rushton, J. P. (1994). The egalitarian dogma NiedenthaC P. M., & Kitayama, S. (Eds.) revisited. Intelligence, 19, 263-280. (Dept. (1994). Heart's Eye: Emotional influences in Psych., Univ. Western Ontario, London, perception and attention. Academic Press, 1250 Ontario N6A 5C2, Canada. Sixth Ave., San Diego, CA 92101 USA. Rushton, J. P. (1994). Sex and race differences in Parker, S. T, Mitchell, R. W., & Boccia, M. L. cranial capacity from International Labour (1994). Self-awareness in Animals and Office data. Intelligence, 19, 281-294. (see Humans: Developmental perspectives. supra). Cambridge Univ. Press, Pitt Bldg., Trumpington St., CB2 lRP, U.K. Rushton, J. P. (1995). Construct validity, censorship, and the genetics of race. American Percivat R.5. (1994). Dawkins and incurable Psychologist, 50, 40f. (see supra). mind viruses?: Memes, rationality and evolution. Journal of Social a&Evolutionary Rushton, J. P. (1995). Race and crime: An Systems, 17, 243-286. (70 Hillview Court, international dilemma. Society, 32, 37-41 (see Astley Bridge, Bolton BLl 8NU, U.K.). supra). 26 Santangelo, A. (1993). Beginning and Stanford, CB., Wallis, J., Mpongo, E., & MeanIng of cultgure: The cerebral activity Goodall, J. (1994). Hunting decisions in wild underlying it. La Pietra, via Cino da Pistoia 10, chimpanzees. Behaviour, 131(1-2), 1-18. Milano, Italy. (Univ. So. Calif., Dept. Anthropol., Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA). Schelde, T. (1994). Ethological research in psychiatry. Ethology & Sociobiology, 15, 349- Starin, E. (1994). Philopatry and affiliation 368. (Frederiksberg Univ. Hosp., Dept. among red colobus. Behaviour, 130(3-4), 253- Psychiat., Nordre Fasanvej 57, KD-2000 270. (Univ. London Univ. ColI., Dept. Frederiksberg, Denmark). Anthropol., Gower St. London WC1E 6BT, England). Schelde, T. & Hertz, M. (1994). Ethology and psychotherapy. Ethology and Sociobiology, 15, Strier, K.B. (1994). Brotherhoods among 383. (see supra). atelins: Kinship, affiliation, and competition. Behaviour, 130(3-4), 151-168. (Univ. Schoe, A. N. (1995). Affect Regulation and the Wisconsin., Dept. Anthropol., Madison, WI, Origin of the Self: The neurobiology of 53706, USA). emotional development. L. Erlbaum, 365 Broadway, Hillsdale, NJ 07642 USA, $135 TeBoekhorst, I.J. A. , & Hogeweg, P. (1994). (hdbk.). Self-structuring in artificial "chimps" offers new hypotheses for male grouping in Silk, J.B. (1994). Social relationships of male chimpanzees. Behaviour, 130(3-4), 229-252. bonnet macaques: Male' bonding in a (Univ. Zurich, Inst. InformaL, Winterthurerstr. matrilineal society. Behaviour, 130(3-4), 271- 190, DH-8032 Zurich, Switzerland). 292. (Univ. Calif. Los Angeles, Dept. Anthropol., Los Angeles, CA, Templer, D. I., Spencer, D. A., & Hartlage, L. C (1993). Biosocial Psychopathology: Singh, D. & Luis, S. (1995). Ethnic and gender Epidemiologic perspectives. Springer consensus for the effect of waist-ta-hip ratio on Publishing, 536 Broadway, New York, NY judgement of women's attractiveness. Human 10012 USA. Nature, 6, 51.....{'j6. (Univ. Texas, Dept. Psychol., Austin, TX, 78712, USA)._ VanHooff, }.A.R.A.M., & VanSchaik, CP. (1994). Male bonds: Affiliative relationships Smith, D.G. (1995). Avoidance of close among nonhuman primate males. Behaviour, consanguineous inbreeding in captive groups of 130(3-4), 309. (Univ. Utrecht., Ethol. & rhesus macaques. American Journal of Socioecol. Grp., Utrecht, Netherlands). Primatology, 35, 31-40. (Univ. Calfi. Davis, Dept. Anthropol., Davis, CA 95616, USA). Visalberghi, E. & Fragaszy, D. (1995). The behaviour of capuchin monkeys, Cebus apeIla, with novel food: The role of social context. Smuts, B. (1995). The evolutionary origins of Animal Behaviour, 49, 1089-1095. (Istituto di patriarchy. Human Nature, 6, 1-32. (Univ. Psicologia, Consiglio Nazionale delle Michigan, Dept. Psy., 580 Union Dr., Ann Arbor, Ricerche, Via Aldrovandi 168, Rome 00197, Ml, 48109, USA). Italy).

Sperling, M. B., & Berman, W. H. (Eds.) (1994). Voland, E. & Dunbar, R.I.M., (1995). Resource Attachment in Adults: Clinical and competition and reproduction: The relationship developmental perspectives. Guilford, 72 between economic and parental strategies in the Spring St., New York, NY 10012 USA. Krummhorn population (1720-1874). Human Nature, 6, 33-50. (Univ. Giessen, Zentrum Stanford, C B., & Salmon, P. (1993). Stress: Philosophie & Grundlagen Wissensch, Otto From synapse to syndrome. Academic Press, Behaghel Str. 10-C II, 0-35394 Giessen, 1250 Sixth Ave., San Diego, CA 92101 USA. Gennany). 27

Vygotskii, L.S., & Luria, A. R. (1993). Winegar, L. T., & Valsiner, J. (Eds.) (1992). Studies on the History of BehavIOr: Ape, Children's Development within Social primitive, and child. L. Erlbaum, 365 Context. Erlbaum, 365 Broadway, Hillsdale, Broadway, Hillsdale, NJ 07642 USA, $59.95 NJ 07642 USA. (hdbk.). iayan, R. (1994). Editor's preface. Walker, M.L. (1995). Menopause in female Behavioural Processes, 1-2. (Preface to a rhesus monkeys. American Journal of special edition containing 13 papers on Primatology, 35, 59-72. (Towson State Univ., individual and social recognition, including Dept. Psychol., Towson, MD 21204, USA). kinship recognition.)

Walsh, A., & Walsh, G. J. (1993). Vive la Difference: A celebration of the sexes. Prometheus, 700 E. Amherst St., Buffalo, NY Officers of the Society 14215 USA. President Walters, S. (1994). Algorithms and William R. Charlesworth archetypes: Evolutionary psychology and Carl Institute of Child Development Jung theory of the collective unconscious. 51 East River Road Journal of Social and Evolutionary Systems, 17, University of Minnesota 287-306. (Simon Fraser Univ., Dept. Psycho!., Minneapolis, MN 55455 USA Burnaby, BC V5A 1S6, Canada). Vice-President/ President-Elect Wasser, L.M. & Wasser, S.K. (1995). Charles B. Crawford Environmental variation and developmental Department of Psychology rate among free ranging yellow baboons (Papio SitnonFraser University cyn 0 c ep haIus). American Journal of Burnaby, B. C. V5A 1S6 Canada Prima tology, 35, 15- 30. Vice-President for Information Weitekamp, E. G. M., & Kerner, H.-J. (1994). Glenn Weisfeld Cross-National Longitudmal 'Research and Its Department of Psychology Impact on Human Development and Criminal Wayne State University Behavior. Kluwer, 101 Philip Dr., Norwell, Detroit, MI 48202 USA MA 02061 USA. Secretary West, M. L., & Sheldon-Keller, A. E. (1994). Karl Grammer Patterns of Relating: An adult attachment Ludwig-Boltzmann-Institute far perspective. Guiltord, 72 Spring St., New Yark, Urban Ethology/Human Biology NY 10012 USA. Althanstrasse 14 A·1090 Vienna, Austria

Westergaard, G.c., & Suomi, S.J. (1994). Treasurer Asymmetrical manipulation in the use of tools Barbara F. Fuller by tufted capuchin monkeys (Cebus apella). School of Nursing Folia Primatologica, 63, 96-98. (Natl. Inst. University of Colorado Health. Anim. Ctr., Comparat. Ethol. Lab., 4200 E. Ninth Ave. POB 529, Poolesville, MD, 20837, USA). Denver, CO 80262 USA

Wilson, OS., & Sober, E. (1994). Reintroducing Membership Chair group selection to the human behavioral Nancy L. Segal sciences (with comerttary). Behavioral & Department of Psychology Brain Sciences, 17, 585-607. (SUNY California State University Binghamton, Dept. Biol. ScL, Binghamton, NY, Fullerton, CA 92634 USA 13902, USA).