Multiculturalism as Transformative? Paul Gingrich Department of Sociology and Social Studies University of Regina
[email protected] Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Canadian Sociology and Anthropology Association, York University, Toronto, May 30, 2006 Abstract The practice of multiculturalism can be a way for a diverse society to transform itself. By providing opportunities for all members of society to participate in social life and employing principles of multiculturalism such as equality, respect, and harmony, a society can become more socially just. Multiculturalism is not always thought of this way, and is often considered a means of preserving cultures, emphasizing difference, and separating people from each other. In this paper, I explore the possibility that multiculturalism provides a means of social transformation in a more socially just direction and provide evidence that some Canadians think of multiculturalism this way. That is, some consider it as a framework for working together to create a society that reduces barriers to participation by ending discriminatory treatment of some members and providing an opportunity for all members of the society to participate more fully in social life. The data I employ come from analysis of a student survey I conducted, from some national surveys, and from official statements about multiculturalism. The frameworks I use for organizing these data are those provided by Nancy Fraser and Cecil Foster. Fraser focuses on the dual issues of redistribution and recognition as distinct, but interlocking, dimensions of social justice. For Fraser, the criterion for a socially just transformation is parity of participation. Cecil Foster explores the possibility that multiculturalism has presented Canada with an opportunity that it should not ignore.