The Future of Physical Education in Higher Education: a Delphi Investigation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Future of Physical Education in Higher Education: A Delphi Investigation Jenna Lorusso, B.PhEd. (Hons.), B.Ed. Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Applied Health Sciences (Health and Physical Education) Under the supervision of Nancy Francis, EdD Faculty of Applied Health Sciences, Brock University St. Catharines, Ontario Jenna Lorusso © January 2013 Abstract Despite the profound and widespread concern for the future of higher education physical education, there has been little systematic study on the topic. This research investigated the future by utilizing a two-round interview Delphi method. Five international experts were asked to project possible, probable, preferable and undesirable futures of the academic discipline in fifteen years time; specifically in regards to issues within the undergraduate degree programs, and the research sub-disciplines. The results of quantitative descriptive statistics and qualitative content analysis reveal an ever- changing higher education environment in the postmodern information age, which presents a complicating future for the academic discipline. The experts expressed concern that some disciplinarians will be a-futuristic and unable to operationalize the vast potential of the discipline at the institutional level, by continuing to use outdated and inappropriate frameworks of a modern era gone by. ii Acknowledgements To the five experts who so graciously participated in this research, I wish to express my sincere gratitude. This research would not have been possible without your unparalleled insight on the future of physical education in higher education. To my supervisor, Dr. Nancy Francis, thank you for your unwavering support throughout this process. To my supervisory committee, Dr.’s Anna Lathrop, Murray Knuttila, and Lori Livingston, thank you for the invaluable contributions your insights have made to this research. To my family, boyfriend, and friends, your support made it possible for me to pursue, and achieve, this master’s degree. This research was supported by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council. iii Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................................................ ii Acknowledgements ......................................................................................................................... iii List of Tables .................................................................................................................................. vi List of Figures ............................................................................................................................... viii CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION ................................................................................. 1 Physical Education in Context: K-12 and Higher Education .................................................. 1 Purpose and Research Questions ............................................................................................. 6 Rationale.................................................................................................................................. 7 Significance of the Study ........................................................................................................ 8 Tone and Context of the Research .......................................................................................... 9 CHAPTER TWO: DEFINITIONS ................................................................................... 11 Definitional Issues ................................................................................................................. 11 Field ....................................................................................................................................... 13 Academic Discipline ............................................................................................................. 16 Profession .............................................................................................................................. 18 K-12 School Physical Education ........................................................................................... 19 Higher Education Physical Education ................................................................................... 20 Higher Education Kinesiology .............................................................................................. 22 Relevant Organizations and Acronyms ................................................................................. 24 CHAPTER THREE: OVERVIEW OF LITERATURE ................................................... 26 Content and Methods ............................................................................................................ 26 Geographical Context ............................................................................................................ 30 Authorship ............................................................................................................................. 33 Publication Criteria ............................................................................................................... 35 Tone and Modus Operandi .................................................................................................... 36 Important Considerations for the Reader .............................................................................. 38 CHAPTER FOUR: REVIEW OF LITERATURE ........................................................... 40 The Past ................................................................................................................................. 41 The Present ............................................................................................................................ 69 The Future ........................................................................................................................... 135 iv CHAPTER FIVE – METHODOLOGY AND METHODS ........................................... 147 Methodology ....................................................................................................................... 149 Methods ............................................................................................................................... 151 Research Design and Protocol ............................................................................................. 153 Quality of Research ............................................................................................................. 178 CHAPTER SIX: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION ........................................................ 182 Layer 1 Making the Obvious Obvious ................................................................................ 184 Layer 2 Making the Obvious Dubious ................................................................................ 215 Layer 3 Making the Hidden Obvious .................................................................................. 249 Concluding Statements ........................................................................................................ 252 References .................................................................................................................................... 260 APPENDIX A ................................................................................................................. 271 APPENDIX B ................................................................................................................. 273 APPENDIX C ................................................................................................................. 275 APPENDIX D ................................................................................................................. 278 APPENDIX E ................................................................................................................. 281 v List of Tables 1. NAKHE Conference Themes for the Past Five Years .................................................. 28 2. Examples of NAKHE Commemorative Lecture Topics............................................... 29 3. Themes of NAK Meetings for the Past Five Years ...................................................... 29 4. Examples of NAK Academy Paper Titles .................................................................... 30 5. Historical Events in the Development of the Academic Discipline's Issues ................ 42 6. Two Perspectives of the Curriculum Conflict............................................................... 81 7. Melnychuk et al. (2011) Current and Believed Focus of Curricula .............................. 90 8. CCUPEKA Curriculum Standards ................................................................................ 92 9. Physical Education/Kinesiology Academic Units in Canada 2011 .............................. 99 10. Names of Physical Education/Kinesiology Academic Units in Canada 2012 .......... 108 11. Most Frequently Used Terms in Academic Unit Titles ............................................ 115 12. Inter-Disciplinary versus Cross-Disciplinary Organizational Frameworks .............. 120 13. Ishee (2003) Future Changes in Higher Education Physical Education ................... 136 14. Ishee (2003) Desirable Changes in Higher Education Physical Education .............. 137 15. Ishee (2003) Undesirable Changes in Higher Education Physical