Of the PETRALE SOLE
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Bulletin No. 153 POPULATION DYNAMICS· of the PETRALE SOLE, Eopsetta jordani, in waters off western Canada by K. S. Ketchen and C. R. Forrester Fisheries Research Board of Canada. Ottawa.,1966 POPULATION DYNAMICS OF THE PETRALE SOLE, EOPSETTA JORDAN!, IN WATERS OFF WESTERN CANADA Bulletins of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada are designed to assess and interpret current knowledge in scientific fields pertinent to Canadian fisheries. Recent numbers in this series are listed at the back of this Bulletin. Editor: J. C. STEVENSON Associate Editor: G. 1. PRITCHARD Assis tant Editor: R. H. WIGMORE Production: R. L. MacIntyre Fisheries Research Board of Canada Sir Charles Tupper Building Ottawa 8, Ontario, Canada The Board also publishes the Journal of the Fisheries Research Board of CalZada in annual volumes of monthly issues, and an Anllual Report. Fisheries Research Board of Canada publications are for sale by the Queen's Printer, Ottawa. Remittances must be in advance, payable in Canadian funds to the order of the Receiver General of Canada. Publications may be consulted at Board establishments located at Ottawa ; Nanaimo and Vancouver, B.C. ; Sault Ste. Marie and London, Ont. ; Ste. Anne de Bellevue and Grande-Riviere, Que. ; St. Andrews, N.B. ; Halifax and Dartmouth, N.S. ; Ellerslie, P.E.I. ; and st. John's, Nfld. BULLETIN No. 153 Population dynamics of the petrale sale, Eopsetta jordani, in waters off western Canada By K. S. Ketchen and C. R. Forrester Fisheries Research Board of Canada Biological Station, Nanaimo, B. C. FISHERIES RESEARCH BOARD OF CANADA Ottawa, 1966 © Crown Copyrights reserved Available by mail from the Queen's Printer, Ottawa, and at the following Canadian Government bookshops: OTTAWA Daly Building, Corner Mackenzie and Rideau TORONTO Mackenzie Building, 36 Adelaide St. East MONTREAL Alterna-Vie Building, ]]82 St. Catherine St. West WINNIPEG Mall Center Bldg., 499 Portage Avenue VANCOUVER 657 Granville Street or through your bookseller A deposit copy of this publication is also available for reference in public libraries across Canada Price $3.75 Catalogue No. Fs 94-153 Price subject to change without notice ROGER DUHAMEL, F.R.S.C. Queen's Printer and Controller of Stationery Ottawa, Canada 1966 iv Contents ABSTRACT, vii CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION, Acknowledgments, 3 CHAPTER II. HISTORY OF THE PETRALE SOLE FISHERY, 4 1. The United States fishery, 4 2. The Canadian fishery, 9 CHAPTER III. DEFINITION OF STOCKS, 13 1. Results of inshore tagging, 16 2. Results of deep-water tagging, 36 3. Boundaries of stocks, 42 CHAPTER IV. STATISTICS OF CATCH AND CATCH PER UNIT OF EFFORT, 43 1. General statistics of catch, 43 2. Statistics of catch per unit of effort, 53 CHAPTER V. CHANGES IN LENGTH AND AGE COMPOSITION OF CANADIAN PETRALE SOLE STOCKS, 79 1. Method of sampling, 79 2. Changes in length composition, 80 3. Changes in age composition, 86 CHAPTER VI. MEASURES OF RECRUITMENT, 94 1. Length-weight relationship, 94 2. Conversion to numbers of fish per unit of effort, 95 3. Variations in year-class strength in the southern stock, 99 4. Variations in year-class strength in the northern stock, 105 5. Summary, 107 CHAPTER VII. GROWTH OF THE PETRALE SOLE, 108 CHAPTER VIII. FOOD HABITS OF THE PETRALE SOLE, 114 CHAPTER IX. SIZE AND AGE AT MATURITY, 116 CHAPTER X. MORTALITY RATES, 118 1. Estimates of total mortality rate, 118 2. Estimates of natural mortality rate, 122 3. Estimates of fishing mortality rate, 126 4. Summary, 129 v Contents - Concluded CHAPTER XI. PATTERN OF RECRUITMENT TO THE FISHERY, 130 1. Size and age of recruitment to the fishing grounds, 130 2. Entry to the exploited phase, 135 CHAPTER XII. YIELD PER RECRUITMENT, 145 1. Introduction, 145 2. Choice of population model, 146 3. Results, 148 4. Conclusions, 150 CHAPTER XIII. FACTORS INFLUENCING RECRUITMENT, 153 1. The critical stage, 154 2. Transport mechanism, 155 3. Variability of survival, 155 4. The petrale sole and its environment, 157 5. Hypotheses regarding survival, 163 6. Prediction of petrale sole abundance, 164 CHAPTER XIV. REGULATION OF THE PETRALE SOLE FISHERY, 166 1. The question of optimum fishing, 166 2. Consequences of a spawning ground fishery, 169 3. Future outlook, 172 4. Research programs past and future, 175 CHAPTER XV. SUMMARY, 177 REFERENCES, 182 ApPENDICES, 185 I. Scientific and common names of species, 187 II. Agreement between Canada and the United States to restrict winter fishing for petrale sole, 187 III. Estimation of Washington catch of petrale sole by area in the years 1939-47, inclusive, 188 IV. Monthly landings of petrale sole from Area 3C, 190 V. Observed relationship between total length and mean weight of petrale sole, 191 VI. Average length by age of male and female petrale sole contained in Canadian landings from Area 3C, 192 VII. Back-calculation of lengths of petrale sole at ages I-IV, 194 vi ABSTRACT The petrale sole is an important contributor to the trawl fishery along the west coast of North America. Results of tagging suggest that there are two main units of stock in British Columbia waters, one offsou thern Vancouver Island and the other to the northward, mainly in Queen Charlotte Sound and Hecate Strait. Sharp reduc tion in abundance occurred in both stocks after the inception of fishing. Paralleling classical examples, average size and age decreased in catches from the southern stock until 1947, but this trend was reversed between 1948 and 1955 and accompanied a continued decline in abundance. Timing of the rising trend in size and age composi tion was the same in both the southern and northern stocks, though the histories of exploitation were different, thus indicating trends in recruitment. Year-classes of 1940-1943 contributed strongly to the fishery, but succeeding year-classes to 1949 were progressively weaker. Thereafter, there was some recovery, and early perform ance of the 1958 year-class suggests that it is of about the same size as those of the early 1940s. Growth of petrale sole, for practical purposes, conforms with the von Berta lanffy growth equation, the growth coefficient, K, being 0.160 for males and 0.167 for females, with corresponding asymptotic lengths, Leo, being 49.0 cm and 58.6 cm. Fifty percent of male fishmature at a length of 38 cm or age VII, while corresponding figures for females are 44 cm and VIII years. A verage instantaneous total mortality rate Z of the strong year-classes 1940-43 is estimated as 0.70 for males and 0.45 for females. Best estimate of instantaneous natural mortality rate (M) is 0.25 and 0.20 for the two sexes respectively, whence average instantaneous rate of fishing (F) is 0.45 for males and 0.25 for females. Alternatively, consideration is also given to the possibility that the indicated sex difference in Z is due largely to a differencein M, namely, M is 0.45 for males and 0.20 for females, whence F is 0.25 for both sexes. These two possibilities, when incorporated in models of yield per recruitment, lead to essentially the same conclu sion, viz. a modest increase in yield (2-12%) theoretically could be achieved by reduction in the minimum size of fishretained for market, and/or by more intensive fishing. However, the models are of restricted usefulness because of the observed trends in recruitment, possible trends in effective fishing effort (lack of equilibrium conditions), and because they do not permit prediction of effects of fishing on highly vulnerable spawning concentrations. Variations in year-class strength appear to be correlated with variations in the environment at the time of the pelagic egg and larval stages, as indicated by seawater temperatures and geostrophic wind patterns. Discussion is provided on the consequences of unrestricted fishing of spawning concentrations and on prospects for future regulation of the fishery. vii Chapter I INTRODUCTION During World War II, exploitation of demersal fishes by means of otter trawling underwent rapid development in the northeastern Pacific Ocean, particu larly in waters adjacent to Canada and the northwestern United States. Stimulation for expansion of this industry, which for nearly three decades had been confined largely to sheltered inshore waters, was gained from the sharp increase in demand for foodfishto offset war-time meat shortages and for supplies of vitamin A (prin cipally from dogfish liver) . Among the numerous species which contributed heavily FIG. 1. The petrale sole, Eopsetta jordani (Lockington) . to the offshore fishery in its initial stages was the petrale sole, or brill, Eopsetta jordani (Lockington) .l This is a relatively large member of the family Pleuronectidae (Fig. 1), closely related to the genus Hippoglossoides and restricted in its distribu tion to the northeastern Pacific between the Gulf of Alaska and lower California. One other member of the genus (E. grigOljewi) occurs in the western Pacificbetween Japan and Formosa (Norman, 1934, p. 309). IThe name petrale sole is used throughout because of its more general acceptance by industry and international scientific circles. "Brill" is in common usage among Canadian fishermen and is the name accepted by Clemens and Wilby (1961). The latter name presumably can be traced to fishermen from Great Britain where "brill" refers to Scophthalmus rhombus which resembles the petrale sole only vaguely and belongs to a different family (Bothidae). Because of its large size and excellent quality as a fresh or frozen fillet product, the petrale sole has commanded the highest price among the various species of flatfish landed for market, with the exception of halibut which is landed exclu sively by the long-established and well-known setline fishery. Until about 1949, product ion of petrale sole kept pace with the general ex pansion of the trawl fisheryof f the Canadian coast, but thereafter declined steadily in spite of continued high demand and improvement in fishing techniques.