DOCSLIB.ORG

Philosophies of Technology Intersections Yearbook for Early Modern Studies

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Philosophies of Technology Intersections Yearbook for Early Modern Studies Philosophies of Technology Intersections Yearbook for Early Modern Studies General Editor Karl A.E. Enenkel Chair of Neo-Latin Literature Faculty of Arts, University of Leiden P.O. Box 9515, 2300 RA Leiden-NL e-mail: [email protected] Editorial Board W. van Anrooij (University of Leiden) B. Blondé (University of Antwerp) K.A.E. Enenkel (University of Leiden) R.L. Falkenburg (University of Leiden) J.L. de Jong (University of Groningen) E.E.P. Kolfi n (University of Amsterdam) W. Neuber (Free University of Berlin) H. Roodenburg (P.J. Meertens Institute) P.J. Smith (University of Leiden) R.K. Todd (University of Leiden) C. Zittel (Kunsthistorisches Institut/Max Planck Institut, Florence) Advisory Board K. VAN BERKEL (University of Groningen) – F. EGMOND A. GRAFTON (Princeton University) – A. HAMILTON (Warburg Institute) C.L. HEESAKKERS – H.A. HENDRIX (Utrecht University) – F.J. VAN INGEN J.I. ISRAEL (Institute for Advanced Studies, Princeton, N.J.) – M. JACOBS (Free University of Brussels) K.A. OTTENHEYM (Utrecht University) – K. PORTEMAN E.J. SLUIJTER (University of Amsterdam) VOLUME 11 – 2008 Philosophies of Technology Francis Bacon and his Contemporaries Edited by Claus Zittel, Gisela Engel, Romano Nanni, and Nicole C. Karafyllis LEIDEN • BOSTON 2008 Illustration on the cover: Salomon de Caus, Von gewaltsamen bewegungen. Beschreibung etlicher, so wol nützlichen alß lustigen Maschinen, Erstes Buch, Problema XII: “Wie durchs Wasser eines Vogels natürlicher Gesang nach zu pfeiffen” (copperplate engraving), Frankfurt 1615. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Philosophies of technology : Francis Bacon and his contemporaries / edited by Claus Zittel . [et al.]. p. cm. — (Intersections ; 11) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-90-04-17050-6 (hardback : alk. paper) 1. Technology—Philosophy. 2. Technology—History—17th century. 3. Science—History—17th century. 4. Bacon, Francis, 1561–1626. I. Zittel, Claus. II. Title. III. Series. T14.P48 2008 601—dc22 2008032054 ISSN 1568-1181 ISBN 978 90 04 17050 6 Copyright 2008 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands. Koninklijke Brill NV incorporates the imprints Brill, Hotei Publishing, IDC Publishers, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers and VSP. Brill has made all reasonable efforts to trace all right holders to any copyrighted material used in this work. In cases where these efforts have not been successful the publisher welcomes communications from copyright holders, so that the appropriate acknowledgements can be made in future editions, and to settle other permission matters. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Koninklijke Brill NV provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change. printed in the netherlands CONTENTS VOLUME ONE Notes on the Editors of this Volume ......................................... ix List of Contributors .................................................................... xi List of Illustrations ...................................................................... xv Introduction ................................................................................ xix Claus Zittel PART I BEGINNINGS “Industrious Observations, Grounded Conclusions, and Profi table Inventions and Discoveries; the Best State of That Province”: Technology and Culture during Francis Bacon’s Stay in France ........................................................... 3 Luisa Dolza Francis Bacon’s Scientia Operativa, The Tradition of the Workshops, and The Secrets of Nature ................................. 21 Jürgen Klein Technical Knowledge and the Advancement of Learning: Some Questions about ‘Perfectibility’ and ‘Invention’ .......... 51 Romano Nanni The Weatherglass and its Observers in the Early Seventeenth Century .............................................................. 67 Arianna Borrelli vi contents PART II BACON: MECHANICS, INSTRUMENTS AND UTOPIAS The Role of Mechanics in Francis Bacon’s Great Instauration .... 133 Sophie Weeks Bacon’s Brotherhood and its Classical Sources: Producing and Communicating Knowledge in the Project of the Great Instauration .................................................................. 197 Dana Jalobeanu The Whale under the Microscope: Technology and Objectivity in Two Renaissance Utopias ............................... 231 Todd Andrew Borlik VOLUME TWO PART III METAPHORIC MODELS The Role of Metaphors in William Harvey’s Thought ............ 253 Jarmo Pulkkinen Legitimating the Machine: The Epistemological Foundation of Technological Metaphor in the Natural Philosophy of René Descartes ....................................................................... 287 Andrés Vaccari Descartes as Bricoleur ................................................................ 337 Claus Zittel contents vii PART IV BACON’S LEGACY: THE IMPACT FOR THE ARTS AND SCIENCES The Poet and the Philosopher: Francis Bacon and Georg Philipp Harsdörffer ...................................................... 375 Berthold Heinecke Formal Causes and Mechanical Causes: The Analogy of the Musical Instrument in Late Seventeenth-Century Natural Philosophy ................................................................. 411 Benjamin Wardhaugh The Modern Wonder and its Enemies: Courtly Innovations in the Spanish Renaissance .................................................... 429 Daniel Damler The Gap between Theory and Practice: Hydrodynamical and Hydraulical Utopias in the 18th Century ...................... 457 Moritz Epple Sentimental Hydraulics: Utopia and Technology in 18th-Century France .............................................................. 495 Thomas Brandstetter History Redoubled: The Synthesis of Facts in Linnaean Natural History ....................................................................... 513 Staffan Müller-Wille Rescue Attempts: Scientifi c Images and the Mysteries of Power in the Era of Louis XIV ............................................. 539 Pablo Schneider Index Nominum ......................................................................... 573 NOTES ON THE EDITORS OF THIS VOLUME Gisela Engel works as a researcher and organizer at Zentrum zur Erforschung der Frühen Neuzeit/Center for Research in Early Modern History, Culture and Science (Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main). Main interests: history of political theories, Gender Studies, early modern cultural and social history. She is editor of the series Salecina- Beiträge zur Gesellschafts- und Kulturkritik, co-editor of Frankfurter Kulturwis- senschaftliche Beiträge and co- editor of the journal Zeitsprünge. Forschungen zur Frühen Neuzeit and Eigene und fremde Frühe Neuzeiten. Genese und Geltung eines Epochenbegrieffs (2003); Technik in der Frühen Neuzeit – Schrittmacher der europäischen Moderne (2004); Expansionen in der Frühen Neuzeit (2004); Fallstudien: Theorie—Geschichte—Methode (2007). Nicole C. Karafyllis is Professor of Philosophy at the College of Humanities and Social Sciences, United Arab Emirates University (UAEU). Her main interests of research are philosophy of nature and technology, theory of life sciences, cultural philosophy of plants, anthropology, history of botany and technology, theory of biofacts, Arabic Philosophy. Selected publications: Biologisch, Natürlich, Nachhaltig. Philosophische Aspekte des Naturzugangs im 21. Jahrhundert (2001); Die Phänomenologie des Wachstums (forthcoming 2008); (as editor) Biofakte – Versuch über den Men- schen zwischen Artefakt und Lebewesen (2003); Technik in der Frühen Neuzeit – Schrittmacher der europäischen Moderne (co-ed.) (2004). Romano Nanni graduated at the University of Florence in Moral Philosophy, with a dissertation on “Il pensiero di Croce e il problema del fascismo nel primo Carlo Antoni” (published in 1987). For some years he has been director of the Biblioteca Leonardiana & Museo Leonardiano in Vinci (Florence). He established (2006), with the Uni- versity of Florence, the Vinci Summer School on Renaissance, and projected (2007) e-Leo—Archiv for the history of technics and science (www .leonardodigitale.com). He is the author of Ovidio metamorfoseos, Letteratura Italiana Antica (2001), and has co-edited Leonardo e il mito di Leda. Modelli, memorie e metamorfosi di un’invenzione (2001); Nello specchio del genio. Studi storici, cultura urbana e genius loci tra Otto e Novecento nel segno di Leonardo (2001). x notes on the editors of this volume Leda: storia di un mito dalle origini a Leonardo (2008). Forthcoming: Leonardo e le arti meccaniche (2009). Claus Zittel works at the Kunsthistorisches Institut / Max Planck Institut in Florence and teaches Philosophy and German Literature at the Universities of Frankfurt am Main and Olsztyn (Poland). He is doing research on “Forms and Functions of aesthetic knowledge generation in Early Modern Europe”, and is inter alia the author of: Selbstaufhe- bungsfi guren bei Nietzsche (1995); Das ästhetische Kalkül von Friedrich Nietzsches ‘Also sprach Zarathustra’ (2000); Theatrum philosophicum. Descartes und die Rolle ästhetischer Formen in der Wissenschaft (forthcoming 2009); Editor
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The ”EXPERIMENTAL PHILOSOPHY”: Francis Bacon (1561-1626 AD)
    1 The "EXPERIMENTAL PHILOSOPHY": Francis Bacon (1561-1626 AD) One of the most remarkable products of the reaction against Aristotelian philosophy, in the form that was handed down by late Mediaeval philosophers, was the rise of an entirely new philosophical system which came to be called 'Empiricism". This was particularly associated with British philosophers, and was both instrumental in the rise of modern science, and a by-product of it. Its ¯rst major exponent was Francis Bacon - although he was certainly influenced by earlier ideas (for example, from Roger Bacon) his ideas were very new in many cases, and had a very large influence on later work by British scientists. Later on Locke (a friend of Newton's) took it much further, and subsequently Berkeley and Hume took the whole idea of empiricism to an extreme. Although Bacon's contribution was the earliest and in some respects the crudest approach, in some ways it was the most durable, and certainly it had the largest impact on the development of science. LIFE of FRANCIS BACON Francis Bacon was born in London on January 22, 1561, at York House o® the Strand. He was the younger of two sons of Sir Nicholas Bacon, a successful lawyer and Lord Keeper of the Great Seal under Queen Elisabeth I. His mother Anne was a scholar, daughter of Sir Anthony Cooke, who translated ecclesiastical material from Italian and Latin into English; she was also a zealous Puritan. Bacon's father hoped Francis would become a diplomat and taught him the ways of a courtier. His aunt was married to William Cecil, later to become Lord Burghley, the most important ¯gure in Elisabeth's government.
    [Show full text]
  • “Cornelis Drebbel (Alkmaar 1572 – Londen 1633): Kloeck Verstant, Een Pronck Der Wereldt”
    Histechnica – Vereniging Vrienden van KIVI – het Academisch Erfgoed van de TU Delft Afdeling Geschiedenis der Techniek Programma commissaris: dr.ir. P.Th.L.M. van Woerkom, tel. 070 – 30 70 275, e-mail [email protected] Secretaris Histechnica: ir. H. Boonstra, tel. 070 – 38 73 808, e-mail [email protected] Secretaris KIVI afd. Geschiedenis der Techniek: ir. A. de Liefde, tel. 070 – 39 66 999, e-mail [email protected] Delft, 10 maart 2019 Geachte leden, De besturen van de vereniging Histechnica en van de KIVI afdeling Geschiedenis der Techniek hebben het genoegen u uit te nodigen tot het bijwonen van een voordracht te houden door de heer H. van Onna, met titel: “Cornelis Drebbel (Alkmaar 1572 – Londen 1633): Kloeck Verstant, een pronck der Wereldt” > Datum: zaterdag 13 april 2019. > Plaats: Science Centre van de TU Delft, Mijnbouwstraat 120, 2628 RX Delft. > Programma: 10.00 uur: Gebouw open; ontvangst met koffie 10.10 uur: Algemene Leden Vergadering van leden van de vereniging Histechnica gevolgd door: 11:00 uur: Voordracht door de heer H. van Onna (Tweede Drebbel Genootschap). 11:45 uur: Pauze. 12:15 uur: Vervolg van voordracht / afsluitende discussie. 12:45 uur: Einde bijeenkomst. U bent met uw introducé’s van harte welkom. Aan het bijwonen van de voordracht zijn geen kosten verbonden. U wordt vriendelijk verzocht zich tevoren aan te melden, uiterlijk zaterdag 6 april 2019. > Hoe aanmelden: - leden van KIVI : aanmelden via de KIVI website (www.kivi.nl) - leden van Histechnica : aanmelden via [email protected] Zaterdag 13 april 2019 > Samenvatting van de voordracht Vandaag vertel ik u over het Cornelis Drebbel, natuurfilosoof en inventor, ‘de Edison in zijn tijd’.
    [Show full text]
  • Francis Bacon and the Late Renaissance Politics of Learning
    chapter 12 Francis Bacon and the Late Renaissance Politics of Learning Richard Serjeantson Anthony Grafton’s contributions to our knowledge and understanding of the long European Renaissance are numerous and varied. But one that is espe- cially significant is his demonstration of the role played by humanistic learn- ing in the transformation of natural knowledge across the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. No longer do we see this period as witnessing the sepa- ration of two increasingly opposed cultures of scholarship and of science. On the contrary: the history and philology of the Renaissance had far-reaching consequences for the natural sciences.1 Indeed, some of the most cherished aspects of this era’s revolution in the sciences can now be seen to have had their origins in humanistic scholarly practices. We now know, for instance, that Francis Bacon’s epochal insistence that research into nature should be the work of collaborative research groups, rather than the preserve of solitary savants, had its roots in the collaborative labors of the team of Protestant ecclesiastical historians led at Magdeburg by Matthias Flacius Illyricus.2 Francis Bacon is also the subject of this contribution. One of the great mod- ern questions in the interpretation of his life and writings has concerned the relationship between his politics and his science. According to one perspec- tive, Bacon was a proponent of a “politics of science,” in which natural philoso- phy would support a powerful and well-governed British state.3 An opposite 1 Anthony Grafton, “Humanism, Magic and Science,” in The Impact of Humanism on Western Europe, ed.
    [Show full text]
  • Francis Bacon: of Law, Science, and Philosophy Laurel Davis Boston College Law School, [email protected]
    Boston College Law School Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School Rare Book Room Exhibition Programs Daniel R. Coquillette Rare Book Room Fall 9-1-2013 Francis Bacon: Of Law, Science, and Philosophy Laurel Davis Boston College Law School, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/rbr_exhibit_programs Part of the Archival Science Commons, European History Commons, and the Legal History Commons Digital Commons Citation Davis, Laurel, "Francis Bacon: Of Law, Science, and Philosophy" (2013). Rare Book Room Exhibition Programs. Paper 20. http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/rbr_exhibit_programs/20 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Daniel R. Coquillette Rare Book Room at Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School. It has been accepted for inclusion in Rare Book Room Exhibition Programs by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Boston College Law School. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 1 Francis Bacon: Of Law, Science, and Philosophy Boston College Law Library Daniel R. Coquillette Rare Book Room Fall 2013 This exhibit was curated by Laurel Davis and features a selection of books from a beautiful and generous gift to us from J. Donald Monan Professor of Law Daniel R. Coquillette The catalog cover was created by Lily Olson, Law Library Assistant, from the frontispiece portrait in Bacon’s Of the Advancement and Proficiencie of Learn- ing: Or the Partitions of Sciences Nine Books. London: Printed for Thomas Williams at the Golden Ball in Osier Lane, 1674. The caption of the original image gives Bacon’s official title and states that he died in April 1626 at age 66.
    [Show full text]
  • EXPLORE the DEEP Submersibles Product Overview When Your Dive Commencesyou Willbecompletely Most Private Andluxuriousplacesintheworld
    EXPLORE THE DEEP submersibles product overview A NEW HORIZON For centuries mankind has explored and conquered the surrounded by the ocean while enjoying the luxury and surface of our oceans. More recently we have begun safety of a one-atmospheric environment, making you want doing the same in the wondrous world beneath the waves. to stay submerged for hours. Then out of the shimmering Owning a U-Boat Worx submersible makes exploring the depths shapes start to appear. The pilot hands you the depths of the uncharted subsea realm an effortless pleasure. MANTA controller allowing you to set a course to the contours on the horizon. With 90% of the oceans still When boarding our submersibles you step into one of the unexplored, you have embarked on a voyage of discovery to most private and luxurious places in the world. find reefs, drop-offs to the dark depths, unique marine life, When your dive commences you will be completely shipwrecks and underwater hills and valleys. © Cosimo Malesci - www.cosimomalesci.com A HERITAGE INSPIRED ABOUT BY EXPLORERS U-BOAT WORX IIt’s human nature to satisfy our curiosity even at 1,700 meters At U-Boat Worx we do everything possible to give you the best and safest below the surface. Since time immemorial, mankind has attempted diving experience possible. Since our start in 2005 we have grown to to discover and conquer the underwater world. The first records of become the largest private submersible builder in the world. Our large these attempts date back before the time of Christ, to the time of fleet consists of nine different models, and has changed the standards for the Assyrian.
    [Show full text]
  • Enlightenment Philosophers:Locke, Voltaire, and Montesquieu
    Massachusetts State Standards WHI.33 Summarize how the Scientific Revolution and the scientific method led to new theories of the universe and describe the accomplishments of leading figures of the Scientific Revolution, including Bacon, Copernicus, Descartes, Galileo, Kepler, and Newton. (H) WHI.34 Describe the concept of Enlightenment in European history and describe the accomplishments of major Enlightenment thinkers, including Diderot, Kant, Locke, Montesquieu, Rousseau, and Voltaire. (H) WHI.35 Explain how the Enlightenment contributed to the growth of democratic principles of government, a stress on reason and progress, and the replacement of a theocentric interpretation of the universe with a secular interpretation. (H) ELA 2.4 Integrate relevant information gathered from group discussions or interviews for reports. ELA 3.12 Give oral presentations to different audiences for various purposes showing appropriate changes in delivery VA 5.7 Demonstrate a fundamental awareness of architectural styles and the ways that these have influenced painting and sculpture Bacon and Descartes “Fathers of the Enlightenment” Insert United Streaming Video Segment The Scientific Method: Francis Bacon and René Descartes (02:24) Many historians consider Francis Bacon and René descartes to be the "Fathers of the Enlightenment". Their ideas proved to be extremely important because they led to the development of the scientific method, a series of simple steps that can be followed to help solve even the most complicated scientific problems.Grade(s) : 6-8 © 2004 United Learning 18th Century Europe What is “The Enlightenment Era” or “Age of Reason” ? (A Time of Illumination) (Rational Thought) During the 1800’s a group of new age thinkers known as philosophers began exploring new ways of thinking and understanding the world.
    [Show full text]
  • Re-Entangling the Thermometer: Cornelis Drebbel's Description Of
    Nuncius 28 (2013) 243–275 brill.com/nun Re-entangling the Thermometer: Cornelis Drebbel’s Description of his Self-regulating Oven, the Regiment of Fire, and the Early History of Temperature Vera Keller Robert D. Clark Honors College, University of Oregon, USA [email protected] Abstract A new, illustrated source, “Drebbel’s Description of his Circulating Oven,” sheds light on the thermostatic oven of Cornelis Drebbel (1572-1633), a Dutch alchemist, engineer, and philosopher active in Holland, Zeeland, London and Prague. The “Description” survives in two German copies. It describes two new inventions, a “Judicium” (which we might call a thermometer) and a “Regimen” (which we might call a feedback control mechanism). It thus engages longstanding debates concerning the invention of the thermometer. More fundamentally, it engages the relationship of artisanality and philosophy. The “Description” highlights the entangled origins of both instruments, which emerged through combined concerns of alchemy, engineering, philosophy, and natural magic. In the early seventeenth century, the term “thermometer” indicated an object with a more expansive role than it later would. The later emergence of a distinct scientific instrument industry, separating previously entangled roles, has colored subsequent views of such instruments and their makers. Keywords thermometer, Cornelis Drebbel, feedback control, instrument 1. Introduction: The Self-regulating Oven between Theory and Practice Much ink has been spilled over the early history of the thermometer. A never before studied text describing the self-regulating oven of Cornelis Drebbel (1572-1633) has the potential to shed new light on that history. Cornelis Drebbel of Alkmaar in North Holland trained as an engraver with his brother-in-law, the famed artist Hendrick Goltzius.
    [Show full text]
  • The Mechanics of Modernity in Europe and East Asia
    The Mechanics of Modernity in Europe and East Asia This book provides a new answer to the old question of the 'rise of the west.' Why, from the eighteenth century onwards, did some countries embark on a path of sustained economic growth while others stagnated? For instance, Euro­ pean powers such as Great Britain and Germany emerged, whilst the likes of China failed to fulfil their potential. Ringmar concludes that, for sustained development to be possible, change must be institutionalised. The implications of this are brought to bear on issues facing the developing world today - with particular emphasis on Asia. Erik Ringmar teaches in the government department at the London School of Economics. He is the author of How We Survived Capitalism and Remained Almost Human (Anthem Books, 2005). Routledge explorations in economic history 1 Economic Ideas and Government Policy Contributions to contemporary economic history Sir Alec Caimcross 2 The Organization of Labour Markets Moderniry, culture and governance in Germany, Sweden, Britain and Japan Bo Strath 3 Currency Convertibility The gold standard and beyond Edited by Jorge Braga de Macedo, Barry Eichengreen and Jaime Reis 4 Britain's Place in the World A historical enquiry into import controls 1945-1960 Alan S. Milward and George Brennan 5 France and the International Economy From Vichy to the Treaty of Rome Frances M. B. Lynch 6 Monetary Standards and Exchange Rates M. C. Marcuzzo, L. Officer and A. Rosselli 7 Production Efficiency in Domesday England, 1086 John McDonal.d 8 Free Trade and its Reception 1815-1960 Freedom and trade: volume I Edited by Andrew Marrison 9 Conceiving Companies Joint-stock politics in Victorian England Timothy L.
    [Show full text]
  • Bodies of Knowledge: the Presentation of Personified Figures in Engraved Allegorical Series Produced in the Netherlands, 1548-1600
    University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations 2015 Bodies of Knowledge: The Presentation of Personified Figures in Engraved Allegorical Series Produced in the Netherlands, 1548-1600 Geoffrey Shamos University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations Part of the History of Art, Architecture, and Archaeology Commons Recommended Citation Shamos, Geoffrey, "Bodies of Knowledge: The Presentation of Personified Figures in Engraved Allegorical Series Produced in the Netherlands, 1548-1600" (2015). Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations. 1128. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/1128 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/1128 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Bodies of Knowledge: The Presentation of Personified Figures in Engraved Allegorical Series Produced in the Netherlands, 1548-1600 Abstract During the second half of the sixteenth century, engraved series of allegorical subjects featuring personified figures flourished for several decades in the Low Countries before falling into disfavor. Designed by the Netherlandsâ?? leading artists and cut by professional engravers, such series were collected primarily by the urban intelligentsia, who appreciated the use of personification for the representation of immaterial concepts and for the transmission of knowledge, both in prints and in public spectacles. The pairing of embodied forms and serial format was particularly well suited to the portrayal of abstract themes with multiple components, such as the Four Elements, Four Seasons, Seven Planets, Five Senses, or Seven Virtues and Seven Vices. While many of the themes had existed prior to their adoption in Netherlandish graphics, their pictorial rendering had rarely been so pervasive or systematic.
    [Show full text]
  • John Stuart Mill's (1806–1873) Methods with His Methods Of
    John Stuart Mill’s (1806‒1873) Methods With his methods of experimental inquiry, it was J. S. Mill’s (1806‒1873) aim to develop means of induction that would promote a search for causes (Flew, 1984). Mill recognized induction as a process whereby one generalizes from experience but it was his belief, beyond that, that all induction involves a search for causes, and that his methods were intended to support this (Day, 1964). Furthermore, the methods, he thought, would contribute to a definition of “cause.” To Mill, causal law meant “uniformity of succession” which, presumably, is consistent with Hume’s constant conjunction, and refers to events that are invariable antecedents, i.e., when the antecedent occurs it is always followed by the consequent. Mill went further, however, in proposing that causal laws are proved upon the basis of the law of universal causation, the idea that each event has its cause (Newton’s determinism). This would be bolstered when supported by experimental methods. The Method of Agreement According to the method of agreement, if two or more examples of a phenomenon only share in a single antecedent condition, that single condition is the cause of the examples of the phenomena (Hung, 1997). By such reasoning, if, in all cases of tree rot, I identify a type of tick to be present, I conclude the tick to have caused the tree rot. The tick, however, may be ubiquitous and found in trees that are not rotting; there could be an unobservable virus. As Hung points out, the method is open to difficulties in interpretation.
    [Show full text]
  • Constructing Natural Historical Facts BACONIAN NATURAL HISTORY in NEWTON’S FIRST PAPER on LIGHT and COLORS
    OUP UNCORRECTED PROOF – FIRSTPROOFS, Mon Feb 10 2014, NEWGEN 2 Constructing Natural Historical Facts BACONIAN NATURAL HISTORY IN NEWTON’S FIRST PAPER ON LIGHT AND COLORS Dana Jalobeanu* The peculiar structure of Newton’s first published paper on light and colors has been the subject of an astonishing diversity of readings: to date, scholars still do not agree as to what Newton wanted to prove in this paper or how he proved it.1 The structure of the paper is far from transparent. It consists of two very different parts: a historical account of what Newton called his “crucial experiment,” and a “doctrine of colors” consisting of thirteen propositions and an illustrative experiment. Equally debated has been the “style” of Newton’s demonstration.2 Newton begins the first part with an extensive his- torical account of how he became interested in the “celebrated phenomena of colors” and later reached one of its major results: that the shape of the spectrum refracted * Research for this paper has been supported by the grant PN-II-ID-PCE-2011-3-0719, “From Natural History to Science,” awarded by the CNCS. 1 The paper has been read, in turns, as a formal blunder of a young upstart who dared to make a clear break with the mitigated skepticism and anti-dogmatism of the Royal Society, and as a brilliant exercise of rhetoric aiming to rewrite in the “scientific style of the day” the results of six long years of optical research. The reason for the exercise of rhetoric has also been the subject of fierce debates.
    [Show full text]
  • Department of Philosophy Eighteenth-Century Philosophy/107
    Department of Philosophy Eighteenth-Century Philosophy/107-361B 2018 Professor Alison Laywine Leacock 918, [email protected] (514-398-1671) Office hours: Tuesdays 17:40-19:00 No use of laptops in class The purpose of this course is to introduce students to philosophy of the eighteenth century in Europe. The focus of our readings and discussion will be a claim associated with the English philosopher Francis Bacon (1561-1626): philosophy (broadly construed) can make progress, but not if it proceeds by conjecture or hypothesis; progress is possible only by proceeding ‘experimentally’, i.e., by observation, by conducting experiments or even collecting reports of received wisdom (‘old wives’ tales’). The virtue of proceeding this way is supposed to be that we do not prejudge what our conclusions should be; we allow ourselves to be guided to the truth by the facts and not by our expectations. One reason for taking Bacon’s claim very seriously is that it seems to pass the most important test: it yields fruit – perhaps even the most and the best. Or so its ablest proponents argued. We will critically examine the claim by tasting the fruit of the experimental philosophy and comparing it to the fruit of hypothesis – in two different areas of enquiry: the investigation of material nature – ‘natural philosophy’, as it was known at the time – and the investigation of human nature. We will proceed by case- study (there is no other way). Our case study for the investigation of material nature will be two different attempts to explain the nature of colour: that of Descartes, which rests on a certain hypothesis (namely that light is a pressure of the etherial medium that fills space) and that of Newton, which purports to proceed experimentally.
    [Show full text]