Mysteries of Abraham's Four Altars and of King Solomon's Four Temples
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ap. 4-A ABRAHAM'S 4 ALTARS & SOLOMON'S 4 TEMPLES Yitzhaq Hayut-Man, Ph.D 20.06.2010 The account of Abraham's four altars (with some Pagan associations) can explain King Solomon's seeming fault. In turn, Solomon's Temple begot its offspring, the Dome of the Rock. These cases give insights how to manage the Temple Mount in our time. Re-Genesis, Chapter four (Vayera portion), Appendix 4-A: Mysteries of Abraham’s four altars and of King Solomon’s four Temples The quest of Abraham, which started at Ur and arrived “on the third day” (22:4) to Mount Moriah, took place at the dawn of the third millennium (related to the Third Day of Genesis) when there starts the Age of the Torah (“Two thousand years Torah”),1 and fixed the place from which there would issue Torah in/of the future, as stated “for out of Ẓiyyon shall go forth Torah” (Isaiah 2:3). As related in chapter 3 (section 9), Abraham has built four altars in the Land of Kena’ạn, thereby marking clues to the riddle of the future Temple(s) in Jerusalem. The first three altars (which are listed in the former Parashah – Lekh Lekha) were built when he was still called “Abram”, without the letter H’e of the Name of YHWH, and those altars seem to have already been sacred sites of the pagan religions of the time. The mention of Oak and Terebinth trees in two of the altar sites points to a sacred grove dedicated to a terrestrial god, even if YHWH appeared there or Abraham evoked His Name. The last, and different, altar was the altar that Abraham and Isaac built together at Mount Moriah. It appears as if the Torah gives us in this story a key to the riddle of the four Temples of King Solomon. For while everybody speaks of “Solomon’s Temple” as singular, it is more exact to speak of “Solomon’s Temples” in the plural: "Then did Shelomoh build a high place for Kemosh, the abomination of Moav, in the hill that is before Yerushalayim, and for Molekh, the abomination of the children of Ammon. And likewise did he 1 Sanhedrin 97a, Avodah Zara 9a for all his foreign wives…" (I Kings 11:7-8). These shrines did function in Jerusalem until the time of the kings Ḥezqiyah and Josiah: “And the high places that were before Yerushalayim, which were on the right hand of the mount of corruption, which Shelomo the king of Yisra’el had built for Ạshtoret the abomination of the Ẓidonim, and for Kemosh the abomination of Mo’av, and for Milkom the abomination of the children of ‘Ammon, did the king defile” (II Kings, 23:13). Does this mean that Shelomoh-Solomon, the builder of the Temple of Jerusalem, did not limit himself to the exclusive worship of YHWH? Did he become feeble-minded at his old age, as the scribes of the later kings claim? Are his women to blame (as Eve was in the garden)? But it could however be that Solomon’s cult was not that different from the popular religion in Israel at the time, as evident from the archeological find of shards of that period dedicated “To YHWH and His Asherah”.2 This might have been the popular cult for another 300 years till the time of kings Ḥezeqiah and Josiah. It can also be that Shelomoh, widely considered “the wisest of men”, had a long-range vision, and had reproduced the pattern that Abraham fixed by building altars over the whole land, and concentrated the pattern in the new capital, to make Jerusalem a place of pilgrimage - binding the newly conquered people of Ammon and Mo'av to Jerusalem through the altars of Milkom and Kemosh, and his recent allies of Phoenicia through the altar of Ashtoreth. The likely plan was that once they’d do pilgrimage to Jerusalem; they would eventually come to worship the (multifaced) God of Abraham, of Yitzḥaq and of Israel. We can guess that, in the spirit of the sacred architecture of the times, the shrines and altars were orientated between them, in ways that would enable rituals of relation and conjunction between the gods, or guardian angels of the people who comprise the growing Israelite nation. Had Solomon’s Israelite mini-empire survived, this might have worked. But after Solomon’s death his kingdom got divided, the people of Ammon and Mo’av got released from the Israelite kingdoms and the Phoenicians distanced themselves. By the time of Josiah these altars were no longer places of added pilgrimage to Jerusalem, but places of diverting the people of Judea from the monotheistic cult, and thus had better to be destroyed. Where were these shrines or altars that Solomon built, and in what pattern? The scriptures say that they were on the hills surrounding the Temple Mount. We shall presently discuss the legacy of Solomon’s main Temple and how it led to the still present Dome of the Rock, but it is also possible that his pluralistic design influenced later generations through the following millennia. According to the studies of the architect Tuviah Sagiv, there were three high places at Mount Moriah, which apparently served for the ancient rituals (we count them from North to South, as did Abraham): (1) at the site of “the 2 These shrines were have discussed more extensively, including the national considerations for building them, in the article “Four Temples and One Belief – What was the Religion of King Solomon?” in theHOPE.org website (being re-constructed). Dome of the Spirits” (or “Dome of the Tablets”) 120 yards north of the Dome of the Rock, (2) at the Dome of the Rock; and Sagiv further proposes (3) that the site of the present Al-Aqsa Mosque, at the southern end of the precinct, was a higher place at the time of the kings. Sagiv claims, however, that the site of the Jewish Temple was not at the Dome of the Rock or at a high place at all.3 This fourth place in time order and the third on the north-south axis could have been a place that had not served as a prior sanctuary of idol worship because it was a lower place. The site of this “Hidden Temple”, claims Sagiv, is opposite the Wailing Wall and level with its present paving, under El-Kas fountain at the Temple Mount. If we regard the Temple Mount precinct as a kind of map of the whole land of Israel, then these marked places at the Temple Mount – which form a rough north-south alignment – map the four altars that Abraham built along the north-south axis of the land. This scheme thus suggests that the place of the current El- Aqsa Mosque is related to a still fifth shrine of Abraham. The Fifth Temple of Abraham In the vaYera portion, we learn about the fourth altar that Abraham built, together with Yitzhaq, at mount Moriah. Later on, in history, when the Qur’an would be written, it will hint at a fifth altar, the one at Mecca, which, the Qur’an claims, was built by Abraham and Ishmael together. The casting away of Ishmael to the desert therefore connects between the Moriah of “vaYera” to the Ka'ba in Mecca. One, hinted in va’yera (“would be seen”) is characterized by sight and vision, the other – as indicated by the name of Yishma’el, ("the one who will hear") is characterized by hearing - Shemi’ạh - and by discipline – Mishma'ạt. Discipline is yielding, which is what the very word “Islam” means. Thus there formed an axis of tension – and of binding – between the two shrines, between Mecca and Jerusalem (which we shall discuss below), between the children of Ishmael and the children of Isaac. The relations between the children of Abraham are aligned and measured upon this axis (which is perpendicular to the Axis between the Pyramid of Gizeh and Mount Moriah, as we have discussed earlier regarding “The Abraham Triangle). More than two billion people, Jews Christians and Moslems, accept the Biblical stories about Abraham and are likely to regard the places consecrated by Abraham as veritable holy places. About half of them, the Qur’an believing Moslems, also believe in what is written in the second Surah of the Qur’an – that Abraham built, with the help of his son Ishmael, a shrine for God (Allah) also in Mecca, a shrine that stands there in glory till this day and serves as the chief place of worship for Islam, a place that every Moslem wants to visit at least once in his lifetime. 3 Sagiv gives half a dozen independent arguments for his unconventional claim (see http://www.templemount.org/theories.html). The scriptural source that he quotes is the blessing of Moses to Benjamin, in whose domain Solomon’s Temple was sited, “The beloved of the Lord, he shall dwell in safety by him, he shall cover him all the day long, and he shall dwell between his shoulders (Deut. 33:12). # North City Local deity Solomonic Likely location on to shrine Temple Mount South 1 Elon Shekhe ? Milkom? Rock at North-west Moré m 2 East of Bet-El ? Kemosh? Dome of the Spirits Bet-El 4 Mount Jerusale Shalem / Ashtoret Dome of the Rock Moriah m Ashtoret 3 Alonei Ḥebron Tombs of YHWH “Hidden Temple” Mamre Patriarchs site opposite Wailing Wall under El-Kas fountain 5 The Mecca Ishmael Allah Way down South Ka’ba Domicile Due to very special circumstances in the first century of Islam this axis became marked by the building of the Dome of the Rock and soon later the early El-Aqsa Mosque.