Cultural Identity in the West
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
16538_intro.qxp 4/21/06 10:04 AM Page 1 culturalidentity westin the SYMPOSIUM PROCEEDINGS LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA NOVEMBER 11-13, 2004 PRESENTED BY THE WESTERN STATES ARTS FEDERATION 16538_intro.qxp 4/21/06 10:04 AM Page 3 culturalidentity westin the SYMPOSIUM DIRECTOR: ANTHONY RADICH PROCEEDINGS EDITOR: MARY HEADRICK CONTRIBUTING EDITORS: SONJA K. FOSS ANTHONY RADICH LISA BOYD LAUREL SHERMAN PAUL MINICUCCI GRAPHIC DESIGN: DAVID BAKER COVER IMAGE: DETAIL OF CROW AND FALCON BY GLORIA EMERSON THE WESTERN STATES ARTS FEDERATION 1743 WAZEE ST.,SUITE 300 DENVER, COLORADO 80202 TEL. 303-629-1166 TTY: 303-607-9019 FAX: 303-629-9717 WWW.WESTAF.ORG 16538_intro.qxp 4/21/06 10:04 AM Page 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS ABOUT THE PROJECT SPONSOR i INTRODUCTION BY SUZANNE BENALLY iii LIST OF SYMPOSIUM PARTICIPANTS v KEYNOTE ADDRESS: CITIZEN-ARTIST: IMAGINING THE FUTURE POSSIBLE BY JAMES EARLY 1 QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS 6 TOPIC I: THE NEXT GENERATION OF LEADERS: STRATEGIES TO INCLUDE NEW YOUNG VOICES IN BROADER CULTURAL DISCUSSIONS INTRODUCTION BY JUAN CARRILLO 13 PRESENTERS: LESLIE ITO 13 RICARDO FRAZER 19 DEBORA IYALL 21 RESPONDENTS: MARGO ARAGON 24 JAMES EARLY 25 TOPIC II: ISSUES OF INCLUSION AND ECONOMICS PRESENTERS: TONY GARCIA 33 SABRINA LYNNMOTLEY 39 JUDITH LUTHER WILDER 43 RESPONDENTS: MICHAEL ALEXANDER 45 SUSAN BOSKOFF 46 ANNE HUANG 47 SELECTION OF COLOR IMAGES FROM PRESENTATIONS 53 TOPIC III: THE RELATIONSHIP OF THE LAND TO CULTURAL IDENTITY PRESENTERS: GLORIA EMERSON 61 NEIL HANNAHS 65 PATTY ORTIZ 71 RON SENUNGETUK 77 RESPONDENT: PRAVINA GONDOLIA 79 16538_intro.qxp 4/21/06 10:04 AM Page 6 TABLE OF CONTENTS BREAKOUT SESSIONS AND REPORTS 83 FINAL COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS 95 APPENDIX LIST OF PRELIMINARY READINGS 105 REFERENCES AND WORKS CITED 107 SYMPOSIUM PROCESS AND AGENDA 109 PARTICIPANT BIOGRAPHIES WITH INTRODUCTORY REMARKS 111 LIST OF SYMPOSIUM OBSERVERS 121 16538_intro.qxp 4/21/06 10:04 AM Page i ABOUT THE PROJECT SPONSOR WESTAF Board of Trustees, who adopted the recommendations with the stated intent of infusing WESTAF with multicultural values The Western States Arts Federation (WESTAF) and placing it on a path to evolve into a truly multicultural organization. The trustees then WESTAF is a nonprofit arts service organiza- institutionalized the work of the task force and tion dedicated to the creative advancement and transformed the group into a permanent adviso- preservation of the arts. Founded in 1974, the ry committee. The Multicultural Advisory organization fulfills its mission to strengthen Committee now regularly meets and advises the financial, organizational, and policy infra- WESTAF on a wide variety of issues. Cultural structure of the arts in the West by providing Identity in the West was the first in a series of innovative programs and services. WESTAF is planned convenings on topics related to multi- located in Denver, Colorado, and is governed culturalism and the arts in the West. by a 22-member board of trustees drawn largely from arts leaders in the West. The organization WESTAF is funded in part by the National serves the largest geographical area and number Endowment for the Arts. of states of the six mainland regional arts organ- izations. WESTAF's constituents include the state arts agencies, artists, and arts organizations of Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Washington, and Wyoming. WESTAF is engaged in information-systems development, arts-policy research, state-arts- agency development, and the convening of arts experts and leaders to address critical issues in the arts. In addition, the organization is com- mitted to programmatic work in the areas of performing arts presenting, visual arts, litera- ture, and folk arts. Programs in these areas include activities such as the convening of lead- ers from an arts discipline; the development of model programs; and the sponsorship of long- term, region-wide programs that fill a gap in the arts infrastructure of the West. WESTAF has also developed a number of Web-based pro- grams designed to benefit the future well-being of the arts communities of the West. In 2000, WESTAF created a multicultural task force to provide inspiration and guidance for the organization’s commitment to multicultural policies and values. After eight meetings in locations across the West, the task force present- ed a report and recommendations to the i 16538_intro.qxp 4/21/06 10:04 AM Page iii INTRODUCTION by Suzanne Benally This symposium grew out of conversations, dis- effectively with issues of inclusion and econom- cussions, questions, experiences and cultural ics for arts organizations of color and indige- histories of a group of people committed to the nous arts organizations in a way that builds cul- accurate representation and the voice of and for tural capacity in our communities? cultural arts of people of color, communities of color, and indigenous people. In 2000, WEST- These are the concerns that shaped the three AF convened a multicultural task force to guide topics that were thoughtfully discussed during its development toward becoming a multicul- WESTAF’s 2004 symposium. tural arts organization and to assert multicultur- al arts leadership in the West. The task force met over a year and a half, evolving values and principles and advancing recommendations to the WESTAF Board of Trustees that were fully adopted by the Board. The dialogue among the task-force members was a thick text of America’s personal history, collective experiences, collisions, and intersec- tions that reflected the complexity of the issue at hand. Unable to lock down a definition of diversity that would satisfy those who were seeking definition, the task force evolved a dynamic understanding of diversity that some- times was a suitable container for the concept and sometimes not. Nevertheless, a document evolved that recognized, listened to, and includ- ed a diversity of cultures in the arts. Specifically, the focus was on those who have been margin- alized throughout history and those who con- tinue to be marginalized today. A major concern of the task force was the iden- tification of and contact with emerging cultural leaders and voices among youth. The task force wanted to engage future generations in a dia- logue around the following questions: What are the issues of cultural assimilation to people? What are our rights of identity? How can we prevent cultural genocide? How do we bring forward authentic cultural voice and place, which are critical to the survival of an indige- nous people? And, finally, how can we deal iii 16538_intro.qxp 4/21/06 10:04 AM Page v LIST OF SYMPOSIUM PARTICIPANTS Anthony (Tony) J. Garcia Director Co-Facilitators El Centro Su Teatro Denver, CO Suzanne Benally Chair Pravina Gondalia Environmental Studies Program Visual Artist and Art Consultant Naropa University Cheyenne, WY Boulder, CO Neil Hannahs Juan Carrillo Director Former Interim Director Land Assets Division California Arts Council Kamehameha Schools Sacramento, CA Honolulu, HI Anne Huang Participants Executive Director Oakland Asian Cultural Center Michael Alexander Oakland, CA Executive Director Grand Performances Leslie Ito Los Angeles, CA Executive Director Visual Communications Margo Aragon Los Angeles, CA Public Affairs Director KLEW-TV Debora Iyall Lewiston, ID Artist and Educator Twenty-Nine Palms, CA Susan Boskoff Executive Director Judith Luther Wilder Nevada Arts Council President Carson City, NV Center for Cultural Innovation Culver City, CA James Early Director Sabrina Lynn Motley Center for Folklife and Director of Public Programs Cultural Heritage Japanese American National Museum Smithsonian Institution Los Angeles, CA Washington, D.C. Patty Ortiz Gloria Emerson Director of Programs Visual Artist, Poet, and Consultant Museum of Contemporary Art/Denver Shiprock, NM Denver, CO Estelle Enoki Michael Schuster Administrative Services Assistant Curator Hawaii State Foundation on Culture and the Arts East-West Center Gallery Honolulu, HI Oahu, HI Rose Fosdick Ron Senungetuk Program Director Artist Kawerak Reindeer Herders Association Homer, AK Nome, AK Mayumi Tsutakawa Ricardo Frazer Independent Editor and Curator President Seattle, WA Hardroad.com Seattle, WA v 16538_pgs1_122.qxd 4/21/06 9:57 AM Page 1 KEYNOTE ADDRESS: sion"—invitation and acceptance—would CITIZEN-ARTIST: IMAGINING THE FUTURE POSSIBLE reflect well, if not the best, on his generational values and professional ways and on my genera- by James Early tional values and evolving new professional ways. I am pleased to be back at the Japanese American National Museum. This institution I arrived at the Japanese American National provided a watershed experience for me on the Museum with many preconceptions. Despite eve of the decision of the Rodney King trial, the positive valence many, including me, have which, many of you will remember, was very attached to the term people of color (predicated much an explicit issue about diversity and dis- in large measure on generalized distinctions parities among races in America. The Secretary from White Americans and presumed unity of the Smithsonian Institution, Bob Adams, based on common marginalization in the dis- asked me to speak in his stead at the opening of criminatory practice of U.S. democracy), the this museum. "You will likely be the only term is often used idealistically and fails to pro- African American there," he said to me. duce expected positive outcomes. I certainly came to the opening of this museum with a I think back on that important occasion in my positive sense about who Japanese Americans personal and professional development for rea- were and what I would expect at the opening of sons related to the objectives of the 2004 the museum. But I soon learned that my think- WESTAF symposium: Acting on the nexus ing about Japanese Americans was (to be lenient between generational transition and multicul- on myself) rather uncomplicated. To my pleas- turalism. ant surprise and learning, the museum opened with a tri-lingual exhibition—English, Japanese, Bob Adams was and is the kind of person who and Spanish.