Annual Report 2017-18

Home , DHA Suffa University, Forman Christian College, HITEC University, Qarshi University, University of Wah

National Computing Education Accreditation Council Islamabad

Established by Higher Education Commission Pakistan

Table of Contents

Chairman’s Message 1 Members ( May 2013- May 2021 ) 2 NCEAC Secretariat 3 Introduction 3 Governing Council of NCEAC 4 Executive Summary 5 Accreditation 6 Importance of Accreditation 6 Scope & Accreditation Procedure 6 Online Accreditation Process Framework 7 Achievements 8 Program Accredited 8 Accreditation Inspection Committee Visits 8 Annual Program Accreditations 8 Programs Accredited Between July 1, 2017-June 30, 2018 9 Accreditation Inspection Committee 11 Accreditation Inspection Visits to Institutes 12 Program Evaluators 14 Meetings and Workshops 16 General Council and Accreditation Standard Committee Meetings 16 Region Wise Training Workshops of Program Evaluators 17 Region Wise Training Seminars on Computer Technologies 20 Meeting of HEC Councils about Online Registration System for students, 21 Alumni and Qualiﬁed Professionals Upcoming Measures in 2019 21 Annex A 22 Inclusive Accredited Batches of Institutes 22 Annex B 38 NCEAC BUGET UTILIZATION REPORT FY 2017-18 38 Picture Gallery 46 Press Release 50

National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Chairman’s Message

It is my pleasure to present the Annual Report of NCEAC for the ﬁnancial year 2017 – 18. I thank all the (current and previous members) of NCEAC for their contribution and support in helping NCEAC improve the quality of computing education imparted by universities of Pakistan. I also acknowledge the guidance provided by the Quality Assurance Division (HEC), cooperation of the accredited universities, and the commitment of NCEAC secretariat staff.

I hope that universities offering computing programs shall continue to improve their standards with the assistance of NCEAC. Our next challenge is to move towards OBE (Outcome Based Education). This requires deciding PLOs (Program Learning Outcomes) and CLOs (Course Learning Objectives). It also requires continuous monitoring and documentation of all educational and student evaluation activities. The process does not end with graduation of students, but also extends to seeking feedback from alumni and their employers. All this requires a robust and extensive IT system to support all stages of OBE.

Dr. Mohammad Ayub Alvi Chairman, NCEAC

Annual Report 2017-18 | 1 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Members ( May 2017 - May 2021 ) NCEAC Secretariat

Muhammad Jawad Hussain Hafiza Sumaira Hafeez Adnan Mansha Arslan Butt Program Coordinator Deputy Program Coordinator Software Engineer Software Engineer

Dr. Ayub Alvi Dr. Shoab A Khan Dr. Faisal Ahmad Khan Kakar Chairman NCEAC Vice Chairman NCEAC Member NCEAC (March 2016-) (May 2017- ) (May 2013- )

Mahnoor Fatima Adeel Aftab Syed Usama Ali Muhammad Tanveer Business Analyst Technical Intern Technical Intern Ofﬁce Attendant

Introduction

Dr. Muhammad Ali Maud Dr. Zartash Afzal Uzmi Dr. Jamil Ahmad Member NCEAC Member NCEAC Member NCEAC NCEAC, established by HEC (Higher Education Commission) Pakistan, accredits computing (May 2013-) (May 2013- ) (May 2017- ) programs offered by universities in Pakistan. It ensures that computing education imparted to students of computing is of high quality and meets the minimum standards prescribed by HEC. Accreditation by NCEAC is mandatory for every computing program offered by any public or private university or degree awarding institution in Pakistan.

In this age of information and knowledge, it is imperative to ensure quality and purpose of our educational programs. Computing profession, undoubtedly plays a pivotal role in the development of a nation. To improve quality of computing education in Pakistan requires regular review, guidance, and quality improvement mechanisms. Accreditation process is considered an effective instrument to achieve these goals.

Dr. Jamil Sawar Dr. Manzoor Elahi Tamimy Dr. Muhammad Sayeed Ghani Member NCEAC Member NCEAC Member NCEAC (May 2017- ) (May 2017- ) (May 2017- )

2 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Members ( May 2017 - May 2021 ) NCEAC Secretariat

Muhammad Jawad Hussain Hafiza Sumaira Hafeez Adnan Mansha Arslan Butt Program Coordinator Deputy Program Coordinator Software Engineer Software Engineer

Dr. Ayub Alvi Dr. Shoab A Khan Dr. Faisal Ahmad Khan Kakar Chairman NCEAC Vice Chairman NCEAC Member NCEAC (March 2016-) (May 2017- ) (May 2013- )

Mahnoor Fatima Adeel Aftab Syed Usama Ali Muhammad Tanveer Business Analyst Technical Intern Technical Intern Ofﬁce Attendant

Introduction

Dr. Jamil Sawar Dr. Manzoor Elahi Tamimy Dr. Muhammad Sayeed Ghani Member NCEAC Member NCEAC Member NCEAC (May 2017- ) (May 2017- ) (May 2017- )

Annual Report 2017-18 | 3 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Governing Council of NCEAC Executive Summary

Following are the current members of the Governing Council of NCEAC. The members are National Computing Education Accreditation Council (NCEAC) was established by HEC in th appointed by HEC for a period of four years. On 26 May, 2017, HEC notiﬁed the current 2005. This Council started off by forming a committee to develop a framework and standard membership of the Council. operating procedures (SOPs) for Accreditation of Computing Education. The Council evaluated ﬁrst program in 2006 (?). It also started an awareness campaign for the universities, so that they could prepare themselves for accreditation. Moreover, training programs were also started for Name of Member Designation & Department its Program evaluators.

1. Dr. Ayub Alvi (Chairman) Rector, NUCES (FAST) During the year under review (2017-18), NCEAC organized four workshops to improve skills 2. Dr. Shoab A Khan (Vice Chairman) Professor, EME, NUST of its Program Evaluators (PE’s). These workshops were conducted in Karachi, Lahore, Peshawar and Islamabad. The objective was to strengthen accreditation capabilities of Program 3. Executive Director HEC Evaluators, so that they could assess the programs in a uniform manner. These Training 4. Director General QAA, HEC Workshops were organized with the cooperation of Quality Assurance Agency (QAA), HEC. 5. Dr. Faisal Ahmad Khan Kakar Dean of Sciences, BUITEMS, Quetta The NCEAC‘s General Council and the Accreditation Standard Committee meets four times in 6. Dr. Jamil Ahmad Vice Chancellor, KUST, Kohat a year. Therefore, four meetings were held in HEC Islamabad during the year. These meetings were presided by the Chairman NCEAC. 7. Dr. M Jamil Sawar, Director IT MTBC, Rawalpindi 8. Dr. Manzoor Elahi Tamimy Associate Prof., CIIT, Islamabad NCEAC in collaboration with PASHA, organized Training seminars on “Emerging 9. Dr. Muhammad Ali Maud Professor, UET, Lahore Technologies” from 8th August to 15th August, 2018 at Islamabad, Lahore, Karachi & Peshawar. These seminars were aimed at Computing graduates, Faculty members and industry 10. Dr. Sayeed Ghani Associate Dean, IBA, Karachi professionals. The purpose of these training seminars was to create awareness and to impart 11. Dr. Zartash Afzal Uzmi Director, Confiz Solution, Lahore some know-how about the emerging fields in Computer Science. These included Blockchain, Machine Learning, Cyber Security, Data Analytics & Big Data, Open Stack & Cloud 12. Managing Director Pakistan Software Engineering Board Computing, and Freelancing. 13. President Pakistan Software Houses Association Over the past year or so, NCEAC has been developing an Online Registration System for 14. Chairman Punjab Information Technology Board computing professionals, graduates and students. In the first phase, NCEAC has collected data 15. Secretary Ministry of Information Science & Technology of twenty five thousand computing students and graduates of Accredited Universities and Institutes. It is expected that this System will be ready during 2019. 16. Director Directorate of Information Technology, KPK 17. Secretary Information & Technology Dept , Baluchistan NCEAC is also developing an online Accreditation Application for universities. This is to be launched in the first quarter of 2019. 18. Secretary Information Science & Technology Dept,. Sindh 19. Secretary Ministry of Information Technology & Telecom NCEAC is working in close collaboration with universities of Pakistan to develop awareness about the benefits of accreditation. 20. Secretary Secretary Education, Gilgit-Baltistan

4 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Governing Council of NCEAC Executive Summary

Annual Report 2017-18 | 5 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Accreditation

An objective of accreditation is to ensure that degree programs are being offered with the help of prescribed facilities, and with at least a certain minimum faculty resources. This helps prospective students to gain conﬁdence about the quality of education they can expect to receive at a particular university. It is a process to assure quality in degree programs in educational institutions. It would require an educational institution or program to meet a deﬁned standards or criteria. It is not a ranking system. It is simply an assurance that a program or institution meets a minimum standard.

Accreditation helps the following purposes:

o Assuring Quality o Guidance for Improvement o Easing Transfer of students between Universities o Recognition of Qualiﬁcations o Increase Employer Conﬁdence

Importance of Accreditation

o Helps students and their parents to choose quality university programs. o Enables employers to recruit better graduates. o Gives institutions and universities a structured mechanism to assess, evaluate, and improve the quality of their programs.

Scope & Accreditation Procedures

Scope

The following undergraduate (BS) programs in Computing fall under the purview of NCEAC:

1) Computer Science 2) Information Systems 3) Information Technology 4) Software Engineering 5) Bio-informatics

6 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Online Accreditation Process Framework

Annual Report 2017-18 | 7 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Achievements

Programs Accredited

As of February 2019, NCEAC has accredited 332 undergraduate Computing Degree Programs (BSCS, BSSE, BSIT, BS-Bioinformatics & BSIS). List of NCEAC Accredited Programs is given in Annexure A:

Accreditation Inspection Committee Visits . During the Year 2017 & 2018, ninety eight degree programs of 72 Universities were evaluated for accreditation (some universities offer more than one computing program) These included ﬁrst time visits and also repeat accreditation visits (to review progress on the recommendations of NCEAC for upgrading Computing labs, infrastructure, learning resources and other facilities).

Annual Program Accreditations

Visited Program Till 2018 - 364 80

70 67

60 58

49 50 50

40 35 33 30 24 20 17 12 9 9 10 1 0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

8 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Achievements Programs Accredited Between July 1, 2017-June 30, 2018

Programs Accredited Batches 2013 2014 2015 2016 As of February 2019, NCEAC has accredited 332 undergraduate Computing Degree Sr.# Name of University/Institution Program - - - - Programs (BSCS, BSSE, BSIT, BS-Bioinformatics & BSIS). List of NCEAC Accredited 2017 2018 2019 2020 Programs is given in Annexure A: 1. Air University, Islamabad Campus Computer Science X X Army Public College of Management Sciences 2. Computer Science Objectionable Accreditation Inspection Committee Visits (APCOMS)

Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan Computer Science . 3. Campus X During the Year 2017 & 2018, ninety eight degree programs of 72 Universities were Information evaluated for accreditation (some universities offer more than one computing program) 4. Bahria University, Islamabad Campus Technology X X These included ﬁrst time visits and also repeat accreditation visits (to review progress on the 5. Bahria University, Lahore Campus Computer Science X Software recommendations of NCEAC for upgrading Computing labs, infrastructure, learning 6. Beaconhouse National University, Lahore Engineering X X resources and other facilities). Center for Advanced Studies in Engineering 7. Computer Science X X X (CASE), Islamabad 8. City University of Science & IT, Peshawar Computer Science X Annual Program Accreditations Software 9. City University of Science & IT, Peshawar Engineering X X Software 10. COMSATS University, Sahiwal Campus Engineering X Software 11. COMSATS University, Attock Campus Engineering X Visited Program Till 2018 - 364 12. COMSATS University, Islamabad Campus Computer Science X X X 13. COMSATS University, Islamabad Campus Software 80 Engineering X X X 14. COMSATS University, Sahiwal Campus Computer Science X 15. COMSATS University, Vehari Campus Computer Science X X 67 70 Software 16. COMSATS University, Wah Campus Engineering X X X 58 Dir College of Engineering & Computing Software 60 17. Sciences., Dir Engineering Zero Visit 18. Forman Christian College, Lahore Computer Science 49 50 X X X 50 Software 19. Foundation University, Rawalpindi Campus Engineering X 20. Gift University, Gujranwala Campus Computer Science X 40 35 21. Hamdard University, Karachi Campus Computer Science X X 33 22. Indus University, Karachi Computer Science X 30 23. Indus University, Karachi Software X 24 Engineering 24. Information Technology University, Lahore Computer Science X X X 20 17 25. International Islamic University, Islamabad Computer Science X X 12 26. International Islamic University, Islamabad Software X X 9 9 Engineering 10 27. IQRA University, Islamabad Campus Computer Science X X Software 1 28. IQRA University, Islamabad Campus Engineering X X 0 29. Jinnah University for Women, Karachi Computer Science X X X 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Software 30. Jinnah University for Women, Karachi Engineering X X

Khan Institute of Computer Science & Information X 31. Information Technology (KICSIT), Kahuta Technology 32. Lahore Garrison University, Lahore Computer Science X

Annual Report 2017-18 | 9 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Batches 2013 2014 2015 2016 Sr.# Name of University/Institution Program - - - - 2017 2018 2019 2020 Lahore University of Management Sciences Computer 33. (LUMS), Lahore Science X X X Mohammad Ali Jinnah University (MAJU), Computer X X 34. Karachi Science Mohammad Ali Jinnah University (MAJU), Software 35. Karachi Engineering X X 36. NUST SEECS, Islamabad Computer Science X X Pakistan Institute of Engineering & Applied Information 37. Sciences (PIEAS), Islamabad System X X X 38. Preston University, Karachi Computer Science 39. Preston University, Kohat Computer Science 40. Preston University, Peshawar Campus Computer Science Accreditation for 6 Months 41. University of Central Punjab, Lahore Computer Science X University of Engineering & Technology, Computer X X X 42. Lahore Science University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Computer Pending for Re-visit 43. Gujrat Science University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Software 44. Gujrat Engineering Pending for Re-visit University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Information 45. Gujrat Technology Pending for Re-visit University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Computer X 46. Gujrat Science University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Software 47. Gujrat Engineering X University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Information X 48. Gujrat Technology Computer 49. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Science Re-visit Required Software 50. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Engineering Re-visit Required Information 51. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Technology 52. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Computer Science X Software 53. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Engineering X 54. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Technology X 55. University of Lahore, Islamabad Campus Computer Science X Software 56. University of Lahore, Lahore Campus Engineering Re-visit Required Software 57. University of Lahore, Lahore Campus Engineering X X 58. University of Malakand, Malakand Computer Science X Information 59. University of Malakand, Malakand Technology X University of Management & Technology, Computer X 60. Sialkot Campus Science

10 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Batches Batches 2013 2014 2015 2016 2013 2014 2015 2016 Sr.# Name of University/Institution Program - - - - Sr.# Name of University/Institution Program - - - - 2017 2018 20 19 2020 2017 2018 2019 2020 University of Management & Technology, Software 61. X Lahore University of Management Sciences Computer Sialkot Campus Engineering 33. X X X (LUMS), Lahore Science University of Sargodha, Faisalabad, Women 62. Computer Science X Mohammad Ali Jinnah University (MAJU), Computer X X Campus 34. Karachi Science 63. University of Sargodha, Faisalabad, Women Software X Mohammad Ali Jinnah University (MAJU), Software Campus Engineering 35. Karachi Engineering X X University of Sargodha, Faisalabad, Women 36. NUST SEECS, Islamabad Computer Science X X Information 64. Campus Technology X 37. Pakistan Institute of Engineering & Applied Information X X X Sciences (PIEAS), Islamabad System University of Sargodha, Mandi Bahauddin 65. Computer Science Re visit Required 38. Preston University, Karachi Computer Science Campus Computer Science 39. Preston University, Kohat University of Sargodha, Mandi Bahauddin Software Re-visit Required 66. Campus Engineering 40. Preston University, Peshawar Campus Computer Science Accreditation for 6 Months University of Sargodha, Mandi Bahauddin Information Re-visit Required 41. University of Central Punjab, Lahore Computer Science X 67. Campus Technology University of Engineering & Technology, Computer 42. X X X University of Sargodha, Mandi Bahauddin Computer Science Lahore Science 68. Campus X 43. University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Computer Pending for Re-visit University of Sargodha, Mandi Bahauddin Software Gujrat Science 69. Campus Engineering X 44. University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Software Pending for Re-visit University of Sargodha, Mandi Bahauddin Gujrat Engineering 70. Campus Technology X University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Information University of Wah, Wah Computer Science X 45. Gujrat Technology Pending for Re-visit 71. University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Computer Ziauddin University, Karachi (North Software 46. X 72. Engineering (Zero Visit) Gujrat Science Nazimabad) University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Software 47. Gujrat Engineering X Accreditation Inspection Committee University of Gujrat (Hafiz Hayat Campus), Information X 48. Gujrat Technology Computer 49. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Science Re-visit Required For every visit, NCEAC constitutes an Accreditation Inspection Committee (AIC) (from Software 50. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Engineering Re-visit Required among the approved Program Evaluators.) to evaluate a program. The NCEAC Accreditation Inspection Committee comprises 2 to 4 Members. 51. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Information Technology 52. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Computer Science X Software Program Evaluators 53. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Engineering X 54. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Campus Technology X Distinguished senior faculty members in computing domain are approved as Program University of Lahore, Islamabad Campus Computer Science X 55. Evaluators. They are faculty members in reputed universities. Evaluators are PhD in relevant Software 56. University of Lahore, Lahore Campus Engineering Re-visit Required field, with at least five years post PhD experience and at least 3 years teaching experience. Software 57. University of Lahore, Lahore Campus Engineering X X NCEAC have currently 103 Program Evaluators, out of which 21 were inducted in 2017-18. 58. University of Malakand, Malakand Computer Science X Information 59. University of Malakand, Malakand Technology X University of Management & Technology, Computer X 60. Sialkot Campus Science

Annual Report 2017-18 | 11 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

PROGRAM EVALUATOR PROVINCE WISE

Baluchistan 3% Sindh 24% Federal 29%

KPK

Punjab 11% 33%

Accreditation Inspection Visits to Institutes

AIC Visit to Bahria University, Islamabad Dec 11, 2017

12 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

PROGRAM EVALUATOR PROVINCE WISE

Baluchistan 3% Sindh 24% Federal 29%

KPK

Punjab 11% 33% AIC Visit to NUST-SEECS, Islamabad January 4, 2018

Accreditation Inspection Visits to Institutes

AIC Visit to Bahria University, Islamabad Dec 11, 2017 AIC Visit to BILQUIS Postgraduate College, Rawalpindi April 24, 2018

Annual Report 2017-18 | 13 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Program Evaluators Evaluators from Public Institutes 43. Adnan Habib UET, Taxila FEDERAL 44. Asad Hussain CIIT, Lahore Evaluators from Private Institutes 45. Ehsan Ullah Munir CIIT, Wah Cantt. Name University 46. Farman Ali Khan CIIT Attock 47. Haroon A Babri UET, Lahore 1. Aamer Nadeem CUST, Islamabad 48. M Ikram Ullah University of Sargodha 2. Aftab Maroof NUCES (FAST), Faisalabad 49. M Murtaza Yousaf PUCIT, Lahore 3. Arshad Ali Shahid NUCES (FAST), Islamabad 50. M Ramzan Talib GCU, Faisalabad 4. Ejaz Ahmad NUCES(FAST), Islamabad 51. Muhammad Ali Maud UET, Lahore 5. Hassan Mujtaba NUCES(FAST), Islamabad National Textile University, 6. Ijaz Ahmed Qureshi IQRA University, Islamabad 52. Muhammad Asif Faisalabad 7. Kashif Munir NUCES(FAST), Islamabad 8. Naveed Ikram Riphah University, Islamabad 53. Muhammad Ilyas University of Sargodha 9. Nayyer Masood CUST, Islamabad 54. Muhammad Shahbaz UET, Lahore 10. Saad Naeem Zafar Riphah University, Islamabad 55. Muhammad Sharif CIIT, Wah Cantt. 11. Shafaat A Bazaz CASE, Islamabad 56. Nadir Shah CIIT, Wah Cantt. 12. Waseem Shahzad NUCES (FAST), Islamabad 57. Saleem Ullah KFUET, Rahim Yar Khan 13. Zohaib Iqbal NUCES(FAST), Islamabad 58. Shahzad Sarwar PUCIT, Lahore 59. Suleman Mazhar IT University, Lahore Evaluators from Public Institutes 60. Syed Mansoor Sarwar PUCIT, Lahore 14. Abdul Jalil IIU, Islamabad 61. Waqar Mehmood CIIT, Wah Cantt. 15. Asad Naeem Air University, Islamabad 62. Waqar ul Qounain Jaffry PUCIT, Lahore 16. Farhana Jabeen CIIT, Islamabad 63. Zubair Nawaz PUCIT, Lahore 17. Habib Bukhari CIIT, Islamabad 64. Zulﬁqar Habib CIIT, Lahore 18. Irfan Ul Haq PIEAS, Islamabad SINDH 19. M Manzoor Ilahi Tamimy CIIT, Islamabad Evaluators from Private Institutes 20. M Moazam Faraz NUST, Islamabad 21. Majid Iqbal CIIT, Islamabad 65. Aqeel Ur Rehman Hamdard University, Karachi 22. Mian M Hamayun NUST, Islamabad 66. Asim Imdad Wagan MAJU, Karachi 23. Muazzam A Khan Khattak NUST, Islamabad 67. Feroz Ahmad Siddiqui IQRA University, Karachi 24. Muhammad Asim Noor CIIT, Islamabad 68. Jawad Ahmad Shamsi NUCES(FAST), Karachi 25. Muhammad Shiraz Federal Urdu Univ., Islamabad 69. M Atif Tahir NUCES(FAST), Karachi 26. Nasro Minallah CIIT, Islamabad 70. M Mubeen Movania DHA Suffa University, Karachi 27. Raﬁa Mumtaz NUST, Islamabad 71. M Shahab Siddiqui Jinnah Univ. for Women, Karachi 28. Sarah S Khan NUST, Islamabad 72. Noman Islam IQRA University, Karachi 29. Sharifullah Khan NUST, Islamabad 73. S.M. Aqil Burney IoBM, Karachi 30. Shoab A Khan NUST, Islamabad 74. Syed Asif Ali SMI University, Karachi 75. Syed Imran Jami MAJU, Karachi PUNJAB 76. Zubair A Sheikh MAJU, Karachi Evaluators from Private Institutes Evaluators from Public Institutes 31. Aasia Khanum FC College Lahore 77. Abdul Rehman Soomrani IBA Sukkar 32. Abdul Aziz Superior University, Lahore 78. Aftab Ahmad Sheikh Sindh Madrasatul Islam, Karachi 33. Adnan Abid UMT, Lahore 79. Akram Sheikh MUET, Jamshoro 34. Fakhar Lodhi Gift University, Gujranwala 80. Imdad Ali Ismaili University of Sindh, Jamshoro 35. Jahangir Ikram LUMS, Lahore 81. M Sadiq Ali Khan University of Karachi 36. Khalid Hussain University of Lahore 82. Muhammad Sayeed Ghani IBA, Karachi 37. Naveed Arshad LUMS, Lahore 83. Mukhtiar Ali Unar MUET, Jamshoro 38. Qaiser Durrani Gift University, Gujranwala 84. Nadeem Mehmood Karachi University of 39. Shafay Shumail LUMS, Lahore 85. Nasir Tauheed IBA, Karachi 40. Syed Muhammad Ahsan Qarshi University, Lahore 86. Noor A Sheikh Shah Abdul Latif Univ., Khairpur 41. Tabassum Naz University of Lahore 87. Shakeel Khoja IBA, Karachi 42. Zartash Afzal Uzmi LUMS, Lahore 88. Tehseen Jilani University of Karachi

14 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Annual Report 2017-18 | 15 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

KHYBER PUKHTUNKHAWA Evaluators from Private Institutes 89. Fazal e Basit NUCES (FAST), Peshawar 90. Masroor Hussain GIKI, Swabi 91. Zahid Haleem GIKI Swabi Evaluators from Public Institutes 92. Ambreen Shahnaz SBBWU, Peshawar 93. Fawad Qayum University of Malakand 94. Jamil Ahmad KUST, Kohat 95. Khizar Hayat CIIT, Abbottabad 96. Muhammad Abid Khan University of Peshawar 97. Neelam Gohar SBBWU, Peshawar 98. Sajid Anwar IM Sciences, Peshawar 99. Salma Noor SBBWU, Peshawar 100. Umer Farooq UST, Bannu BALOCHISTAN Evaluators from Public Institutes 101. Abdul Samad BUITEMS, Quetta 102. Faisal Ahmed Khan Kakar BUITEMS, Quetta 103. M Khalid Badini University of Balochistan, Quetta

EVALUATORS BY SECTOR

Private 39%

Public 61%

Meetings and Workshops

General Council and Accreditation Standard Committee Meetings

NCEAC General Council (GC) evaluates the reports prepared by its Program Evaluators after accreditation visits. NCEAC GC deliberates on the observations of the accreditation team, to decide the batches of students to be accredited. Other operational matters are also considered in these meetings. During the Financial Year 2017-18, NCEAC held four General Council Meetings. In these Meetings, 72 degree programs of 47 Institutes were presented.

16 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

BALOCHISTAN Group Photo after NCEAC 27th General Council Meeting Oct 19, 2017 Evaluators from Public Institutes

101. Abdul Samad BUITEMS, Quetta 102. Faisal Ahmed Khan Kakar BUITEMS, Quetta 103. M Khalid Badini University of Balochistan, Quetta

EVALUATORS BY SECTOR

Private 39%

Public 61% NCEAC 28th General Council Meeting Oct 19, 2017

Region Wise Training Workshops of Program Evaluators

NCEAC conducted four Program Evaluators Training Workshop in different Regions. About forty participants from each Region attended these workshops. The Main focus of trainings Meetings and Workshops was on: • System of Accreditation (Zero Visit, Interim Visit & Accreditation Visit) General Council and Accreditation Standard Committee Meetings • Process & Procedure of Program Accreditation • Selection of PEs & Outcomes of Accreditation Visits (Purpose of Accreditation Visit NCEAC General Council (GC) evaluates the reports prepared by its Program Evaluators after and PE Roles) accreditation visits. NCEAC GC deliberates on the observations of the accreditation team, to • Steps for Seeking Accreditation decide the batches of students to be accredited. Other operational matters are also considered in • Proposed Improvements & Suggestions in Accreditation Process these meetings. During the Financial Year 2017-18, NCEAC held four General Council • Features of Program Assessment and Accreditation Meetings. In these Meetings, 72 degree programs of 47 Institutes were presented. • Principles of Effective Assessment

Annual Report 2017-18 | 17 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

• Code of conduct for Accreditation Inspection Committee (AIC)/Program Evaluators • Attributes of Program Evaluators • Format/Structure of the AIC Report /Sample Templates • Assessment Exercise and Interaction with Stakeholders • Accreditation as an Instrument of Quality Enhancement

NCEAC 4th Program Evaluator Training Workshop at Federal Region was held on March 2, 2018 at Margala Hotel Islamabad (Dr. Shafay Shamail, Associate Professor-LUMS, Lahore was the Recourse person of training Workshop)

NCEAC 4th Program Evaluator Training Workshop at Sindh Region was held on February 8, 2018 at HEC Regional Centre Karachi (Dr. Zubair A Sheikh, President MAJU, Karachi was the Resource person of this Workshop)

18 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

NCEAC 4th Program Evaluator Training Workshop at KPK Region was held on February 22, 2018 at HEC Regional Centre Peshawar (Dr. Shafaat Ahmad Bazaz, Vice Chancellor, CASE Islamabad was the Resource person of this Workshop)

NCEAC 4th Program Evaluator Training Workshop at Lahore Region was held on February 17, 2018 at HEC Regional Centre Lahore (Dr. Shoab A Khan, HoD CS, CEME, NUST, Islamabad was the Resource person of this Workshop)

Annual Report 2017-18 | 19 National Computing Education Accreditation Council NCEAC ANNUAL REPORT

Region Wise Training Seminars on Computer Technologies

Region Wise Training Seminars on Computer Technologies A total of twelve training seminars were arranged with the collaboration of HEC A total of twelve training seminarsand Pakistan were arranged Software with House the collaborationAssociation (P@of HECSHA,) NCEACin Islamabad, Lahore, Karachi and and Pakistan Software HousePeshawar. Association Out (P@of twelveSHA) inseminars, Islamabad, five Lahore, were held Karachi in Islamabad, and two in Lahore, four in Peshawar. Out of twelve seminars,Karachi fiveand one were in held Peshawar in Islamabad,. These seminars two in wereLahore, attended four inby more than 150 Karachi and one in PeshawarThe. These Resource seminars Persons were attendedfor these by seminars more than belonged 150 participants. to both academia and industry The Resource Persons for theseprovided seminars training belonged on the followingto both academia five topics and: industry. They provided training on the following five topics: • Blockchain • Blockchain • Machine Learning • Machine Learning • Data Analytics and Big Data • Data Analytics and Big Data• Cyber Security, and • Cyber Security, and • Open Stack and Cloud Computing • Open Stack and Cloud Computing

Mr. Haris Hassan (L) receiving a souvenir from Chairman NCEAC (R)

20 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council NCEAC ANNUAL REPORT

Region Wise Training Seminars on Computer Technologies

Meeting of HEC Councils about Online Registration System for students, Alumni and Qualiﬁed Professionals

A meeting about “Registration of Students, Alumni and Qualiﬁed Professionals” was held on February 12, 2018, under the supervision of Quality Assurance Agency of HEC. It was attended by the Chairman and secretarial staff of the following Councils. . National Business Education Accreditation Council National Accreditation Council for Teacher Education National Agriculture Education Accreditation Council National Technology Council National Computing Education Accreditation Council, and Representatives of Quality Assurance Agency, HEC

The Executive Director, HEC (Dr. Arshad Ali) briefed about the purpose of the Meeting. Chairman NCEAC briefed the participants about the previous three meetings on student registration system. NCEAC IT team demonstrated campus panel & administrative panel of the student registration system.

Upcoming Measures in 2019

Mr. Haris Hassan (L) receiving a souvenir from Chairman NCEAC (R) Accreditation Automation System Region Wise Training Seminars on Accreditation Automation System for Program Evaluators Mr. Haris Hassan (L) receiving a souvenir from Chairman NCEAC (R) Region Wise Awareness Seminars for students and other stakeholders for the awareness of the beneﬁts of Accreditation and feedback from employers about Alumni of graduates in the respective ﬁelds for improving quality of programs being offered at universities. Accreditation Inspection Visits of Accredited and non-Accredited Institutions. Induction & Training of new Program Evaluators for Accreditation Inspection Committee.

Annual Report 2017-18 | 21 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Annex A

Inclusive Accredited Batches of Institutes

1. Abasyn University, Islamabad Campus 5. Army Public College of Management BS (Software Engineering) Sciences (APCOMS), Rawalpindi Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2011 Fall 2011 ------2. Abasyn University, Peshawar Campus Fall 2009 BS (Computer Science) ------Batches admitted in Fall 2007 Fall 2013 Fall 2012 6. Bahauddin Zakariya University, ------Multan Campus Fall 2010 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 ------Fall 2006 ------BS (Software Engineering) ------Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 Fall 2007 Fall 2012 BS (Information Technology) ------Batches admitted in Fall 2010 Fall 2007 Fall 2009 7. Bahria University, Islamabad Campus 3. Air University, Islamabad Campus BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2014 Fall 2012 Fall 2013 Fall 2011 ------Fall 2010 Fall 2011 Fall 2009 Fall 2010 Fall 2008 Fall 2009 Fall 2007 Fall 2008 BS (Information Technology) Fall 2007 Batches admitted in Fall 2015 4. Aligarh Institute of Technology, Fall 2014 Karachi BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Fall 2009

22 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Annex A 8. Bahria University, Karachi Campus 13. Capital University of Science & BS (Computer Science) Technology, Islamabad Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Inclusive Accredited Batches of Institutes Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2012 Fall 2013 1. Abasyn University, Islamabad Campus 5. Army Public College of Management ------Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Sciences (APCOMS), Rawalpindi Fall 2010 Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2009 14. CECOS University, Peshawar Fall 2008 Fall 2012 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2007 Fall 2011 Fall 2011 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2012 9. Bahria University, Lahore Campus 2. Abasyn University, Peshawar Campus Fall 2009 BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) ------15. Center for Advanced Studies in Fall 2007 Batches admitted in Engineering (CASE), Islamabad Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) 6. Bahauddin Zakariya University, Batches admitted in Fall 2012 10. Balochistan Uni. Of IT, Eng. & Mngt Multan Campus Fall 2015 ------Sciences, Quetta BS (Computer Science) Fall 2014 Fall 2010 BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2009 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 Fall 2012 ------Fall 2013 ------Fall 2012 Fall 2011 Fall 2006 ------Fall 2011 BS (Software Engineering) 16. City University Of Science & IT, ------Fall 2010 Batches admitted in Peshawar ------Fall 2009 Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2007 Fall 2008 Fall 2012 Batches admitted in BS (Information Technology) BS (Information Technology) ------Batches admitted in Fall 2015 Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2010 Fall 2007 Fall 2013 Fall 2009 Fall 2012 Fall 2013 Fall 2012 7. Bahria University, Islamabad Campus Fall 2011 Fall 2011 3. Air University, Islamabad Campus BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 ------BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Fall 2009 Fall 2009 Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2008 Fall 2008 Fall 2014 Fall 2012 Fall 2013 Fall 2011 11. Baqai Medical University, Karachi Fall 2007 ------Fall 2010 BS (Bioinformatics) Fall 2006 Fall 2011 Fall 2009 Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2010 Fall 2008 Batches admitted in Fall 2009 Fall 2007 12. Beaconhouse National University, Fall 2014 Fall 2008 BS (Information Technology) Lahore Fall 2013 Fall 2007 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2012 Fall 2015 Batches admitted in Fall 2011 4. Aligarh Institute of Technology, Fall 2014 Fall 2010 ------Karachi BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2008 Fall 2015 Batches admitted in Fall 2007 Fall 2014 Fall 2009 Fall 2006 ------Fall 2012

Annual Report 2017-18 | 23 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

17. COMSATS Institute of Information Batches admitted in Technology, Abbottabad Campus Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) Spring 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2014 19. COMSATS Institute of Information Spring 2014 Technology, Islamabad Campus Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) Spring 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2012 Fall 2015 Spring 2012 Spring 2015 ------Fall 2014 ------Spring 2014 Fall 2010 Fall 2013 Spring 2010 Spring 2013 Fall 2009 Fall 2012 Spring 2009 Spring 2012 Fall 2008 Fall 2011 Spring 2008 Spring 2011 Fall 2007 Fall 2010 Spring 2007 Spring 2010 Fall 2006 ------Spring 2006 ------Fall 2005 Fall 2008 Spring 2005 Spring 2008 Fall 2004 Fall 2007 Spring 2004 Spring 2007 BS (Software Engineering) ------Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 Fall 2005 Spring 2013 Spring 2005 Fall 2012 Fall 2004 Spring 2012 Spring 2004 BS (Bioinformatics) 18. COMSATS Institute of Information Batches admitted in Technology, Attock Campus Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) Spring 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2011 Fall 2013 Spring 2011 Spring 2013 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Spring 2012 Fall 2015 ------Spring 2015 ------Fall 2014 Fall 2010 Spring 2014 Spring 2010 Fall 2013 Fall 2009 Spring 2013 Spring 2009 Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Spring 2012

24 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

17. COMSATS Institute of Information Batches admitted in 20. COMSATS Institute of Information Spring 2008 Technology, Abbottabad Campus Fall 2013 Technology, Lahore Campus BS (Software Engineering) BS (Computer Science) Spring 2013 BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2014 19. COMSATS Institute of Information Fall 2012 Spring 2013 Spring 2014 Technology, Islamabad Campus Spring 2012 Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2011 23. COMSATS Institute of Information Spring 2013 Batches admitted in Spring 2011 Technology, Vehari Campus Fall 2012 Fall 2015 Fall 2010 BS (Computer Science) Spring 2012 Spring 2015 Spring 2010 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2014 Fall 2009 Fall 2015 ------Spring 2014 Spring 2009 Spring 2015 Fall 2010 Fall 2013 Fall 2008 Fall 2014 Spring 2010 Spring 2013 Spring 2008 Spring 2014 Fall 2009 Fall 2012 Fall 2007 Spring 2009 Spring 2012 Spring 2007 24. COMSATS Institute of Information Fall 2008 Fall 2011 Fall 2006 Technology, Wah Campus Spring 2008 Spring 2011 Spring 2006 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2007 Fall 2010 Fall 2005 Batches admitted in Spring 2007 Spring 2010 Spring 2005 Fall 2010 Fall 2006 ------Fall 2004 Spring 2010 Spring 2006 ------Spring 2004 ------Fall 2005 Fall 2008 ------Spring 2005 Spring 2008 21. COMSATS Institute of Information Fall 2008 Fall 2004 Fall 2007 Technology, Lahore Campus Spring 2008 Spring 2004 Spring 2007 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2007 BS (Software Engineering) ------Batches admitted in Spring 2007 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 ------Fall 2013 Fall 2005 Spring 2013 ------Spring 2013 Spring 2005 Fall 2012 ------Fall 2012 Fall 2004 Spring 2012 ------Spring 2012 Spring 2004 Fall 2004 BS (Bioinformatics) 22. COMSATS Institute of Information Spring 2004 18. COMSATS Institute of Information Batches admitted in Technology, Sahiwal Campus BS (Software Engineering) Technology, Attock Campus Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Spring 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2015 Batches admitted in Fall 2011 Fall 2013 Spring 2015 Fall 2013 Spring 2011 Spring 2013 Fall 2014 Spring 2013 BS (Software Engineering) ------Spring 2014 Fall 2012 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 Spring 2012 Fall 2015 ------Spring 2013 ------Spring 2015 ------Fall 2014 ------25. DHA Suffa University, Karachi Fall 2010 Spring 2014 ------BS (Computer Science) Spring 2010 Fall 2013 Fall 2009 Batches admitted in Fall 2009 Spring 2013 Spring 2009 Fall 2013 Spring 2009 Fall 2012 Fall 2008 Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Spring 2012

Annual Report 2017-18 | 25 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

26. Federal Urdu Uni. Of Arts, Sci. & Fall 2007 Tech., Islamabad ------BS (Computer Science) ------Batches admitted in Fall 2004 Fall 2010 BS (Software Engineering) Batches admitted in Fall 2007 27. Forman Christian College, Lahore ------BS (Computer Science) ------Batches admitted in Fall 2004 Fall 2015 BS (Information Technology) Fall 2014 Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2007 Fall 2012 ------Fall 2011 ------Fall 2004

28. Foundation University, Rawalpindi 33. Government College University, Campus Lahore BS (Software Engineering) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2011 Fall 2012 Fall 2010 Fall 2011 ------Fall 2010 Fall 2008 Fall 2009 ------Fall 2008 Fall 2005

29. Ghulam Ishaq Khan Institute, Swabi 34. Hamdard University, Islamabad BS (Computer Science) Campus Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2012 Fall 2011 Fall 2011 35. Hamdard University, Karachi Campus BS (Computer Science) 30. Gift University, Gujranwala Campus Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2015 Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2014 ------31. Global Institute, Lahore Fall 2011 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 Batches admitted in Fall 2009 Fall 2011 Fall 2008

32. Government College University, 36. HITEC University, Taxila Faisalabad BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2008 Fall 2013 Fall 2012

26 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

26. Federal Urdu Uni. Of Arts, Sci. & Fall 2007 37. IBA, Karachi ------Tech., Islamabad ------BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 BS (Computer Science) ------Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2004 Fall 2014 42. Institute of Business & Technology BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2010 Fall 2013 (BizTek) Karachi Batches admitted in Fall 2007 Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) 27. Forman Christian College, Lahore ------Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) ------Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2004 ------Fall 2015 BS (Information Technology) ------Fall 2010 Fall 2014 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 Fall 2007 Fall 2006 Fall 2008 Fall 2012 ------Fall 2005 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2011 ------Fall 2004 Batches admitted in Fall 2004 Fall 2012 28. Foundation University, Rawalpindi 33. Government College University, 38. Imperial College, Lahore ------Campus Lahore BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 BS (Software Engineering) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2012 43. International Islamic University, Fall 2013 Fall 2011 Fall 2011 Islamabad Fall 2012 Fall 2010 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2011 ------39. Indus University, Karachi Batches admitted in Fall 2010 Fall 2008 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2014 ------Fall 2009 Batches admitted in Fall 2013 ------Fall 2008 Fall 2005 Fall 2014 Fall 2012 ------Fall 2011 29. Ghulam Ishaq Khan Institute, Swabi 34. Hamdard University, Islamabad Fall 2012 ------BS (Computer Science) Campus ------Fall 2009 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 Fall 2008 Fall 2013 Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2007 Fall 2012 Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Fall 2006 Fall 2011 Fall 2014 Fall 2005 35. Hamdard University, Karachi Campus Fall 2004 BS (Computer Science) 30. Gift University, Gujranwala Campus Batches admitted in 40. Information Technology University, BS (Software Engineering) BS (Computer Science) Fall 2015 Lahore Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2014 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2014 Fall 2014 ------Batches admitted in Fall 2013 ------Fall 2015 Fall 2012 31. Global Institute, Lahore Fall 2011 Fall 2014 Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 Fall 2013 Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Fall 2009 ------Fall 2011 Fall 2008 41. Institute of Business & Fall 2009 Management Karachi Fall 2008 32. Government College University, 36. HITEC University, Taxila BS (Computer Science) Fall 2007 Faisalabad BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Fall 2006 BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2005 Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2012 Fall 2004 Fall 2008 Fall 2013 ------Fall 2012

Annual Report 2017-18 | 27 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

44. IQRA National University, Peshawar 48. Jinnah University for Women, Karachi BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2012 Fall 2016 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2015 Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2012 ------45. IQRA University (Main Campus) ------Karachi ------BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in Fall 2008 Fall 2010 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in Fall 2008 Fall 2015 Fall 2014 46. IQRA University, Islamabad Campus BS (Computer Science) 49. Karakuram International University. Batches admitted in Gilgit Fall 2015 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2014 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2012 Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Fall 2010 Fall 2012 Fall 2009 BS (Information Technology) Fall 2008 Batches admitted in Fall 2007 Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Batches admitted in 50. Khan Institute of Computer Science & Fall 2015 Information Technology (KICSIT), Fall 2014 Kahuta BS (Information Technology) 47. ISRA University, Hyderabad Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Spring 2013 Fall 2013 Fall 2012 51. Lahore College for Women University, ------Lahore Fall 2010 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in Fall 2008 Fall 2004 BS (Software Engineering) Batches admitted in 52. Lahore Garrison University, Lahore Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2010 Fall 2013 Fall 2009

28 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

44. IQRA National University, Peshawar 48. Jinnah University for Women, Karachi 53. Lahore University of Management 58. NAML College, Mianwali BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Sciences (LUMS), Lahore BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Zero Visit Fall 2012 Fall 2016 Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2015 Fall 2015 59. National Textile University, Faisalabad Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2014 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2012 ------Fall 2013 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2011 45. IQRA University (Main Campus) ------54. Madresa Tul Banat College, Sadiqabad Fall 2010 Karachi ------BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2008 Fall 2012 60. National University of Computer & Fall 2010 BS (Software Engineering) Emerging Sciences-FAST, Chiniot- Fall 2009 Batches admitted in 55. Mirpur Uni. Of Sci. & Tech., Mirpur Faisalabad Campus BS (Computer Science) Fall 2008 Fall 2015 AJ&K Batches admitted in Fall 2014 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2012 46. IQRA University, Islamabad Campus Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) 49. Karakuram International University. Fall 2012 61. National University of Computer & Batches admitted in Gilgit Fall 2011 Emerging Sciences-FAST, Islamabad BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2015 BS (Computer Science) Campus Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) ------Fall 2012 Fall 2008 Batches admitted in Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2007 Fall 2014 Fall 2011 Batches admitted in BS (Information Technology) Fall 2013 Fall 2010 Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2012 Fall 2009 BS (Information Technology) Fall 2012 Fall 2011 Fall 2008 Batches admitted in Fall 2011 Fall 2010 Fall 2007 Fall 2012 Fall 2009 BS (Software Engineering) 56. Mohammad Ali Jinnah University Fall 2008 Batches admitted in 50. Khan Institute of Computer Science & (MAJU), Islamabad Fall 2007 Fall 2015 Information Technology (KICSIT), BS (Computer Science) Fall 2006 Fall 2014 Kahuta Batches admitted in BS (Information Technology) Fall 2010 62. National University of Computer & 47. ISRA University, Hyderabad Batches admitted in Fall 2009 Emerging Sciences-FAST, Karachi BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 Fall 2008 Campus Batches admitted in Spring 2013 Fall 2007 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2006 Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2012 51. Lahore College for Women University, Fall 2014 57. Mohammad Ali Jinnah University ------Lahore Fall 2013 (MAJU), Karachi Fall 2010 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2008 Fall 2004 Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2013 Fall 2010 BS (Software Engineering) BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in 52. Lahore Garrison University, Lahore Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2014 Fall 2007 Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2006 Fall 2010 Fall 2013 Fall 2009

Annual Report 2017-18 | 29 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

63. National of Computer & Emerging Fall 2010 Sciences-FAST, Lahore Campus Spring 2010 BS (Computer Science) ------Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 Fall 2008 Fall 2012 Spring 2008 ------Fall 2010 66 NUST-SEECS, Islamabad Fall 2009 BS (Information Technology) Fall 2008 Batches admitted in Fall 2007 Fall 2009 Fall 2006 Fall 2008 Fall 2007 64. National University of Computer & Fall 2006 Emerging Sciences-FAST, Peshawar Fall 2005 Campus Fall 2004 BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2016 Fall 2012 Fall 2015 Fall 2011 Fall 2014 Fall 2010 Fall 2013 Fall 2009 Fall 2012 Fall 2008 Fall 2011 Fall 2007 Fall 2006 67. PAF-Karachi Inst. of Economics & Tech, Karachi 65. National University of Modern BS (Computer Science) Languages, Islamabad Campus Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2012 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 Fall 2010 Spring 2013 Fall 2009 Fall 2012 Spring 2012 68. Pakistan Institute of Engg. & ------Technology, Multan ------BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 Batches admitted in Spring 2010 Fall 2014 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Spring 2013 Fall 2012 Spring 2012 ------

30 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

63. National of Computer & Emerging Fall 2010 69. Pakistan Institute of Engineering & Batches admitted in Sciences-FAST, Lahore Campus Spring 2010 Applied Sciences (PIEAS), Islamabad Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) ------BS (Computer Information System) Batches admitted in ------Batches admitted in 74. Preston University, Kohat Fall 2013 Fall 2008 Fall 2016 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2012 Spring 2008 Fall 2015 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2014 Fall 2014 Fall 2010 66 NUST-SEECS, Islamabad ------Fall 2009 BS (Information Technology) ------75. Preston University, Peshawar Campus Fall 2008 Batches admitted in ------BS (Computer Science) Fall 2007 Fall 2009 ------Accreditation for Fall 2006 Fall 2008 ------6 Months Fall 2007 Fall 2008 64. National University of Computer & Fall 2006 Fall 2007 76. PUCIT, Lahore Emerging Sciences-FAST, Peshawar Fall 2005 Fall 2006 BS (Computer Science) Campus Fall 2004 Fall 2005 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Fall 2004 Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2003 Fall 2011 Fall 2013 Fall 2016 Fall 2010 Fall 2012 Fall 2015 70. Pakistan Navy Engineering College ------Fall 2011 Fall 2014 (PNEC), Karachi Fall 2008 Fall 2010 Fall 2013 BS (Management Information System) Fall 2007 Fall 2009 Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2006 Fall 2008 Fall 2011 Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2007 Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Fall 2006 67. PAF-Karachi Inst. of Economics & Fall 2010 Fall 2012 Tech, Karachi Fall 2009 Fall 2011 65. National University of Modern BS (Computer Science) Fall 2008 Fall 2010 Languages, Islamabad Campus Batches admitted in Fall 2007 ------BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2012 Fall 2006 Fall 2008 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2007 Fall 2013 Fall 2010 71. PMAS Arid Agriculture Uni, Fall 2006 Spring 2013 Fall 2009 Rawalpindi BS (Information Technology) Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Spring 2012 68. Pakistan Institute of Engg. & Batches admitted in Fall 2012 ------Technology, Multan Fall 2006 Fall 2011 ------BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 Fall 2010 Batches admitted in 72. Preston University, Islamabad Campus ------Spring 2010 Fall 2014 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2008 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2007 Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2006 Fall 2013 Fall 2012 Spring 2013 ------77. Qurtuba University, DIKhan Campus Fall 2012 ------BS (Computer Science) Spring 2012 Fall 2009 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2010 ------73. Preston University, Karachi ------BS (Computer Science) ------Fall 2007

Annual Report 2017-18 | 31 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

78. Rachna College of Eng. & Tech, 83. Sindh Madresatul Islam University, Gujranwala Karachi BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2011 Fall 2013 Fall 2012 79. Riphah International University, Islamabad 84. Sukkur Institute of Business BS (Software Engineering) Administration, Sukkur Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Fall 2010 Fall 2014 Fall 2009 Fall 2013 ------80. Sarhad University of Science & Tech, Fall 2011 Peshawar Fall 2010 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2013 Fall 2007 Fall 2012 Fall 2006 ------Fall 2005 Fall 2010 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2009 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2014 Fall 2007 Fall 2013 Fall 2006 ------BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Fall 2010 Fall 2013 Fall 2009 Fall 2012 85. SZABIST, Hyderabad Campus 81. Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Women BS (Computer Science) University, Peshawar Batches admitted in BS (Bioinformatics) Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Fall 2013 86. SZABIST, Islamabad Campus Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Fall 2010 Fall 2014 Fall 2009 Fall 2013 Fall 2008 BS (Computer Science) 87. SZABIST, Karachi Campus Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2013 82. Sindh Institute of Mgmt. & Technology, Fall 2012 Karachi Fall 2011 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 Interim Visit Fall 2009

32 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

78. Rachna College of Eng. & Tech, 83. Sindh Madresatul Islam University, 88. The Women University, Multan 93. University of Education, Multan Gujranwala Karachi BS (Computer Science) BS (Information Technology) BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2010 Fall 2011 Fall 2013 Fall 2013 Fall 2012 BS (Information Technology) 94. University of Engineering & Technology (Lahore), Narowal 79. Riphah International University, Batches admitted in Campus Islamabad 84. Sukkur Institute of Business Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Administration, Sukkur Interim Visit Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) 89. University of AJ&K, MZD 95. University of Engineering & Fall 2011 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Technology, Lahore Fall 2010 Fall 2014 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 Fall 2013 Fall 2010 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2009 Fall 2015 80. Sarhad University of Science & Tech, Fall 2011 Fall 2008 Fall 2014 Peshawar Fall 2010 Fall 2007 Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2009 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2012 Fall 2011 Batches admitted in ------Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2007 Fall 2010 Fall 2012 Fall 2009 Fall 2012 Fall 2006 Fall 2011 ------Fall 2005 Fall 2008 Fall 2010 Fall 2007 Fall 2010 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2009 Fall 2006 Fall 2009 Batches admitted in Fall 2008 Fall 2005 ------Fall 2014 Fall 2004 Fall 2007 Fall 2013 90. University of Balochistan, Quetta Fall 2006 ------BS (Computer Science) 96. University of Engineering & BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Technology, Taxila Batches admitted in Fall 2010 Fall 2009 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2013 Fall 2009 BS (Information Technology) Batches admitted in Fall 2004 Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2003 85. SZABIST, Hyderabad Campus Fall 2009 81. Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Women BS (Computer Science) 97. University of Gujrat (Haﬁz Hayat University, Peshawar Batches admitted in 91. University of Central Punjab, Lahore Campus), Gujrat BS (Bioinformatics) Fall 2011 BS (Computer Science) BS (Information Technology) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2013 86. SZABIST, Islamabad Campus Fall 2015 Fall 2014 Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2014 ------Fall 2011 Batches admitted in ------Fall 2010 Fall 2014 ------Fall 2009 Fall 2013 Fall 2011 ------Fall 2008 ------Fall 2008 BS (Computer Science) 87. SZABIST, Karachi Campus Fall 2009 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Batches admitted in 92. University of Education, Lahore Fall 2014 Fall 2013 BS (Information Technology) BS (Software Engineering) 82. Sindh Institute of Mgmt. & Technology, Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Karachi Fall 2011 Fall 2009 Fall 2014 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 Interim Visit Fall 2009

Annual Report 2017-18 | 33 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

98. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Batches admitted in Campus BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2014 103. University of Management & Fall 2013 Technology, Sialkot Campus BS (Software Engineering) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2014 Fall 2013 BS (Software Engineering) BS (Information Technology) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2014 Fall 2013 104. University of Management and Technology, Lahore 99. University of Haripur, Haripur BS (Computer Science) BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2013 Fall 2012 Fall 2012 ------Fall 2010 Fall 2009 Fall 2008 100. University of Lahore, Islamabad BS (Software Engineering) Campus Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2012 Fall 2013 ------101. University of Lahore, Lahore Campus Fall 2009 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2008 Batches admitted in BS (Information Technology) Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2011 Fall 2013 Fall 2010 Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Batches admitted in 105. University of Peshawar, Peshawar Fall 2015 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2014 Batches admitted in Fall 2008 102. University of Malakand, Malakand Fall 2007 BS (Software Engineering) Batches admitted in 106. University of Poonch, Rawalakot Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2011 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2013 Batches admitted in BS (Information Technology) Fall 2012

34 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

98. University of Gujrat, Lahore Sub Batches admitted in 107. University of Sargodha, Faisalabad, ------Campus BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 Women Campus ------Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2007 Fall 2014 103. University of Management & Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2013 Technology, Sialkot Campus Fall 2013 Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) BS (Computer Science) BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2007 Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2014 Fall 2013 111. University of Swat, Swat Fall 2013 BS (Software Engineering) BS (Information Technology) BS (Computer Science) BS (Information Technology) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in atches admitted in Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Fall 2013 Fall 2014 112. University of Wah, Wah Fall 2013 104. University of Management and 108. University of Sargodha, Mandi BS (Computer Science) Technology, Lahore Bahauddin Campus 99. University of Haripur, Haripur BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Fall 2012 Fall 2014 Fall 2011 Fall 2013 Fall 2012 BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2010 Fall 2012 ------Batches admitted in ------Fall 2014 113. Usman Institute of Technology, Fall 2010 Fall 2009 BS (Information Technology) Karachi Fall 2008 Batches admitted in BS (Computer Science) 100. University of Lahore, Islamabad BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2014 Batches admitted in Campus Batches admitted in Fall 2014 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2013 109. University of Sargodha, Sargodha Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2012 Campus Fall 2012 Fall 2013 ------BS (Computer Science) Fall 2011 ------Batches admitted in ------101. University of Lahore, Lahore Campus Fall 2009 Fall 2010 Fall 2009 BS (Computer Science) Fall 2008 ------Fall 2008 Batches admitted in BS (Information Technology) ------Fall 2012 Batches admitted in Fall 2007 114. Ziauddin University, Karachi (North Fall 2011 Fall 2013 BS (Software Engineering) Nazimabad) Fall 2010 Fall 2012 Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) (Zero Visit) BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2010 Batches admitted in 105. University of Peshawar, Peshawar BS (Information Technology) Fall 2015 BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in Fall 2014 Batches admitted in Fall 2010 Fall 2008 ------102. University of Malakand, Malakand Fall 2007 ------BS (Software Engineering) Fall 2007 Batches admitted in 106. University of Poonch, Rawalakot Fall 2012 BS (Computer Science) 110. University of Science & Technology, Fall 2011 Batches admitted in Bannu BS (Computer Science) Fall 2010 BS (Computer Science) Batches admitted in BS (Software Engineering) Batches admitted in Fall 2013 Batches admitted in Fall 2012 BS (Information Technology) Fall 2012 Fall 2011 ------

Annual Report 2017-18 | 35 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

36 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Annual Report 2017-18 | 37 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Annex B

NCEAC BUGET UTILIZATION REPORT FY 2017-18

38 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Annex B

NCEAC BUGET UTILIZATION REPORT FY 2017-18

Annual Report 2017-18 | 39 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

40 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Annual Report 2017-18 | 41 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

42 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Annual Report 2017-18 | 43 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

44 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Annual Report 2017-18 | 45 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Picture Gallery

4th PE Training workshop at Islamabad held on March 2, 2018

4th PE Training workshop at Lahore held on February 17, 2018

46 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Picture Gallery

Training Seminar on Machine Learning at NUCES-FAST, Lahore held on August 13, 2018

4th PE Training workshop at Islamabad held on March 2, 2018

Training Seminar on Cyber Security at NUCES-FAST, Islamabad held on August 8, 2018

4th PE Training workshop at Lahore held on February 17, 2018

Program Evaluators Training Workshop at Sindh Region on Feb 8, 2018

Annual Report 2017-18 | 47 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Dr. Shafaat Ahmad Bazaz (L) receiving a certiﬁcate from Chairman NCEAC (R)

Dr. Salma Noor (L) receiving a certiﬁcate from Chairman NCEAC (R)

Program Evaluators Training Workshop at Federal Region on March 2, 2018

48 | Annual Report 2017-18 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Dr. Shafaat Ahmad Bazaz (L) receiving a certiﬁcate from Chairman NCEAC (R)

23rd Accreditation Standard Committee Meeting held on March 15,2018

Dr. Salma Noor (L) receiving a certiﬁcate from Chairman NCEAC (R)

28th General Council Meeting held on March 15, 2018

Program Evaluators Training Workshop at Federal Region on March 2, 2018

Annual Report 2017-18 | 49 National Computing Education Accreditation Council

Press Release

50 | Annual Report 2017-18