Cannon Air Force Base, NM Back up Book
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DCN: 11646 Cannon Air Force Base, NM Back Up Book Final Deliberation Hearings August 24 -27 DCN: 11646 USAF BRAC 2005 Base MCI Score Sheets (The questions that lost the most points are at the top of the list.) Max Points This is the maximum number of points this formula can contribute to the overall MCI score. Earned Points This is the number of points this formula did contribute to the overall MCI score for this base. Lost Points The difference between Max Points and Earned Points. Running Score from 100 The maximum MCI score is 100 and the minimum is 0. This is a running balance that shows the impact of the lost points from the formula evaluation on the overall MCI score for the base. Running --Max Earned -Lost from Jormula ---Points Points Points -100 1248.00 Proximity to DULZ f6+',e&4 / 14.72 1.47 13.25 86.75 / 1245.00 Proximity to Airspace Supporting Mission (ASM) 14.72 2.64 12.08 74.67 '/ 1266.00 Range Complex (RC) Supports Mission 14.84 3.40 11.43 63.24 , -. '/ 1249.00 Airspace Attributes of DDULZ 7.99 0.80 ( &3qQ 56.05 P* h 1271.00 Prevailing Installation Weather Conditions rv 3k+ 3 5.06 0.00 5.06) 50.99 \jf / V&- 8.00 Ramp Area and Serviceability 4.67 1.17 350 47.49 )( ,, / - , 7 1246.00 Proximity to Low Level Routes Supporting Mission @.5), 3.68 0.28 3.40 44.09 1233.00 Sufficient Munitions Storage ,w -2.80 0.00 2.80 41.29 1241.OO Ability to Support Large-Scale Mobility Deployment &/y*RrJ--. 2.64 0.00 2.64 38.65 1205.20 Buildable Acres for Air Operations Growth Jv&/ .+ 7~~ 1.96 0.31 1.65 37.00 l2O5.10 Buildable Acres for Industrial Operations Growth- ' 1.96 0.49 1.47 35.53 1214.00 Fuel Dispensing Rate to Support Mobility and Surge 1.76 0.34 1.42 34.1 1 1243.00 Airfield Elevation 3.68 2.43 1.25 32.86 213.00 Attainment IEmission Budget Growth Allowance 1.68 1.01 0.67 32.19 1250.00 Area Cost Factor 1.25 0.59 0.66 31.53 1235.00 Installation Pavements Quality 4.67 4.09 0.58 30.95 1402.00 BAH Rate 0.88 0.65 0.22 30.73 1207.00 Level of Mission Encroachment 1.49 1.36 0.14 30.59 1269.00 Utilities cost rating (U3C) 0.13 0.07 0.05 30.54 9.00 Runway Dimension and Serviceability 2.80 2.80 0.00 30.54 1232.00 Sufficient Explosives-sited Parking 4 2.24 2.24 0.00 30.54 1242.00 ATC Restrictions to Operations 4.14 4.14 0.00 30.54 1403.00 GS Locality Pay Rate 0.25 0.25 0.00 30.54 DCN: 11646 USAF BRAC 2005 Base MCI Score Sheets Base Score Sheet for Selfridge ANGB MCI: SOF 1 CSAR (The questions that lost the most points are at the top of the list.) Max Points This is the maximum number of points this formula can contribute to the overall MCI score. Earned Points This is the number of points this formula did contribute to the overall MCI score for this base. Lost Points The difference between Max Points and Earned Points. Running Score from 100 The maximum MCI score is 100 and the minimum is 0. This is a running balance that shows the impact of the lost points from the formula evaluation on the overall MCI score for the base. Running --Max Earned -Lost from Formula ---Points Points Points -100 ( 1245.00 Proximity to Airspace Supporting Mission (ASM) / R 14.72 2.50 12.22 87.781 1266.00 Range Complex (RC) Supports Mission 14.84 2.74 12.09 75.69 1248.00 Proximity to DULZ 14.72 7.06 7.66 68.03 /77\ 1249.00 Airspace Attributes of DZILZ 3x 7.99 2.46 62.50 1246.00 Proximity to Low Level Routes Supporting Mission 3.68 0.34 3.34 59.16 1233.00 Sufficient Munitions Storage 2.80 0.00 2.80 56.36 1241.OO Ability to Support Large-Scale Mobility Deployment 2.64 0.00 2.64 53.72 1235.00 Installation Pavements Quality 4.67 2.33 2.33 51.39 1205.10 Buildable Acres for Industrial Operations Growth 1.96 0.02 1.94 49.45 1271.OO Prevailing Installation Weather Conditions - 3 5.06 3.34 -1.72 47.73 1205.20 Buildable Acres for Air Operations Growth 1.96 0.76 1.20 46.53 1243.00 Airfield Elevation 3.68 2.92 0.76 45.77 1250.00 Area Cost Factor 1.25 0.53 0.72 45.05 9.00 Runway Dimension and Serviceability 2.80 2.10 0.70 44.35 213.00 Attainment 1 Emission Budget Growth Allowance 1.68 1.O1 0.67 43.68 1214.00 Fuel Dispensing Rate to Support Mobility and Surge 1.76 1.22 0.54 43.14 1402.00 BAH Rate 0.88 0.40 0.48 42.66 1207.00 Level of Mission Encroachment 1.49 1.15 0.34 42.32 1403.00 GS Locality Pay Rate 0.25 0.05 0.20 42.12 1269.00 Utilities cost rating (U3C) 0.13 0.09 0.04 42.08 - 8.00 Ramp Area and Serviceability 4.67 4.67 0.00 42.08 1232.00 Sufficient Explosives-sited Parking 2.24 2.24 0.00 42.08 1242.00 ATC Restrictions to Operations 4.14 4.14 0.00 42.08 DCN: 11646 W.E. Kellogg Air Guard Station Battle Creek MI 28-29 July 2005 COMMISSION STAFF: Ken Small LIST OF ATTENDEES: MG Culter Michigan Adjutant General BG Heaton Michigan Assistant Adjutant General Col Seidel Commander, 1 1 O~ Fighter Wing 269 580-3221 Col Augustine Vice Commander, 1 1oth Fighter Wing Col Lanezy Michigan Civil Engineer Capt Bagby Commander, USN Reserve Unit, Battle Creek Col Nadrasik Commander, Fort Custer Training Center, Michigan National Guard Lt Col Hinga Commander, 5 1" WMD Civil Support Team, MI NG Lt Col San Clamente 11 oth FW Chef of Safety (Project Officer for visit) 269 873-2417 Mr. Dehn Administrator, Battle Creek Tax Increment Finance Authority MAIN FACILITIES REVIEWED: Munitions Storage Area (storage, munitions maintenance, missile maintenance) Vehicle Maintenance Engine Test Stand Phase Dock and Maintenance Hangar Munitions Load Training Facility Tanks, Racks, Adaptors, Pylons Maintenance/Gun Maintenance Shop Engine Maintenance Shop Avionic Maintenance Shop Simulator Building Security Police Building Ramps Wing Headquarters KEY ISSUES IDENTIFIED: Values assigned by model for MCI understate the military value and capacity of the Battle Creek AGS. Ramp Area and serviceability of ramp are under valued Land available for additional construction is under valued DCN: 11646 Airfield elevation is 900' but runway length is 10,000 ft Munitions storage new, licensed, and in use for high explosives , missiles and gun munitions Large state managed ranges north of airport; 7,500 acre Ft Custer adjacent to AGS Unit experience and patriotism unrewarded A-1 0 pilots have high time in type (one over 4000 hours), A- 10s have all modifications completed Manning level over loo%, highest of ANG A-1 0 units since 2001 One of three fighter units in the ANG to have deployed to three combat operations Facilities under valued: Facilities are 12 years old or less: Purpose designed for the ANG and the fighter mission New munitions storage and maintenance area Runway extension paid by citizens through millage assessment Control tower match fund paid by citizens Extensive rehab project complete on aircraft munitions loading training hangar Reservists and key Air Guard Technicians not expected to move to Selfridge Commander estimates 3 years to attain C-1 status for A-10 unit conversion at Selfridge Training bulge for aircrews and maintenance personnel; AETC capacity questioned Briefing materials included analysis of MCI by the Upjohn Institute. INSTALLATION CONCERNS RAISED: One of two secure State locations within Michigan State contingency operating location for many activities Provides second runway with significant state infrastructure available COMMUNITY CONCERNS RAISED: Do not want to see guard unit closed. Citizens extended the runway to provide better service to guard Citizens purchased land to prevent encroachment Economic impact will be significant as there are only 73,000 people in area REOUESTS FOR STAFF AS A RESULT OF VISIT: None DCN: 11646 DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE - Air Force Base Structure Report - As Of 30 Sept 03 NAME BLDGS BLDGS NEAREST ZIP BLDGS OWNED BLDGS LEASED TOTAL ACRES SITE COMPONENT CITY PHONE CODE OWNED SQFT LEASED SQFT ACRES OWNED PRV($M) MIL CIV OTHER TOTAL Boles Wells Water System Annex AF Active Alamogordo Bonito Lake Water System Annex AF Active Canizozo Cannon AFB AF Active Clovis Cannon Meadows Hsg Area AF Active Portales Cannon Place Hsg Area AF Active Clovis Holloman AFB AF Active Alamogordo KirUand AFB AF Active Albuquerque Melrose AF Range AF Active Melrose OTHER SlTE(S) : 13 New Mexico Total: New York Air Force Plant No 59 AF Active Johnson City Francis S Gabreski Airport (ANG) Air Natl Guard Westhampton Beach Griffiss Northeast Air Defense Air Natl Guard Rome (NEAD) ANG Hancock Field ANG Air NaU Guard North Syracuse Newport Test Annex No 2 AF Active Newport Transmitter Niagara Falls IAP-ARS AF Reserve Niagara Falls Rome Laboratoly AF Active Rome Schenectady Airport ANG Air Natl Guard Schenectady Stewart IAP Air Natl Guard New Windsor Vemm Test Annex AF Active Verona OTHER SITE(S) : 19 New York Total: North Carolina CharlotteIDouglas IAP (ANG) Air Natl Guard Charlotte Dare County Range AF Active Stumpy Point Fort Fisher Recreation Site AF Active Kure Beach Pope AFB AF Active Spring Lake Seymour Johnson AFB AF Active Goldsboro Stanly County Airport Air Natl Guard Abermale OTHER SITE(S) : 9 North Carolina Total: North Dakota Cavalier AFS AF Active Mountain US Locations that do not meet criteria of at least ten (10) Acres AND at least $10M PRV.