Issue 408 November 9, 2007 Discovery Islander.ca
www.discoveryislander.ca www.discoveryislander.ca 2 Discovery Islander #408 November 9th, 2007 Island Calendar
Submit your event: eMail: [email protected] • fax: 285-2236 • drop-off: 701 Cape Mudge Rd. The Regulars Day by day • Quadra Legion - Now open Fridays and Saturdays at 4:00pm Saturday, November 10 • Every Monday - Badminton, 7:30 Cape Mudge Hall - Film Show Presented by Sierra Quadra Q.C.C. - Parent and Tots 9:30 am - noon Q.C.C. End of Suburbia at 7 pm Escape from Suburbia at 8:30 pm • Every Tuesday - Smile Makers Kidz Klub Q.I. Bible Church from 2:4 -4:15 pm Sunday, November 11 - Kalina Folkdancers -QCC, 7:30 to 9:30 pm, Sept.to Apr. - Remembrance Day Service Quadra Legion - Sketching group at Firesign Studio 10 am-12:00 pm Please be seated by 10:45 am sharp, Luncheon after service, Social at 5 pm - Al-anon meeting, 7.30 pm at the Childrens Centre Monday, November 12 • Every Wednesday - Moms and Babes 11 am - noon Q.C.C. - Garden Club - Guest speaker from Linnea Farm Q.C.C. -Community Lunch noon Q.C.C. Support local food producers and learn to ‘grow your own’. 7pm - Badminton, 7:30 pm Cape Mudge Hall Tuesday, November 13 • Every Thursday - Parent and Tots 9:30 am - noon Q.C.C. - Quadra Quilters Q.C.C. - Isle Sing 3-4:30 pm Q.C.C. upstairs, use South entrance 9 am - 2 pm - Prayer Meeting, 7:00pm at Quadra Island Bible Church Saturday, November 17 - 7-9:30 PM: Life drawing sessions at Firesign Studio 285-3390 - An Evening with Shane Philip - playground fundraiser Q.C.C. • Every Friday - Free Pool, Darts and Shuffleboard at the Legion 4 pm to 1am 7 pm • Every Saturday - Legion Meat Draw 5:00pm to 6:30pm Friday, November 16 - Peace Vigil, Noon, Q.Cove Post Office - Flu Clinic Q.C.C. • Every Sunday ‑ Sunday Service QI United Church 10:30 10:30 am -1:00 pm - Family Worship Service 10:30am Quadra Island Bible Church Friday November 23 - Buddhist Meditation 10:00 am Upper Realm - Christmas Craft Fair Q.C.C. - Sunday Celebration, Centre for Positive Living - 900 Alder St. C.R. 10:20 - 11:20 am 4-9 pm • 1st and 3rd Wednesday - Food Bank 1-2 Community Centre - Banff Mountain Film Festival Campbell River Tidemark • 3rd Sunday of Month - Raw Food Pot Luck 5 - 7pm 285-3827 7pm • Last Saturday - Bonus $50 cash draw or gift certificate. Quadra Legion 6:30 pm Saturday November 24 - Christmas Craft Fair Q.C.C. Next Deadline: Monday, November 19th 2007 10 am - 3 pm Santa arrives at noon on the firetruck!
Island Calendar is a list of on island events. Please submit separately for the Island Calendar - Banff Mountain Film Festival Q.C.C. and News & Events or indicate in your submission if you would like your event placed in both. 7pm Following the text order exactly as above for email submissions is appreciated (month, date, day, Island Calendar online: title, place and time), use the title as your email subject. Current advertisers welcome to submit www.discoveryislands.ca/news events but not-for-profit items will be given priority. Thank you. They shall grow not old as we that are left grow old; Age shall not weary them nor The years condemn. At the going down of the sun And in the morning, www.legion.ca We will remember them.
Discovery Islander November 19th
Shane Philip [email protected] Action Images * Michael Desjardins www.discoveryislander.ca Discovery Islander #408 November 9th, 2007 3 IslanderDiscovery Island Forum Issue 408 November 9th, 2007 Say your piece: eMail: [email protected] • fax: 285-2236 • drop-off: 701 Cape Mudge Rd. Published bi-weekly and distributed free throughout the Discovery Islands by: Discovery Islands media & publishing PO Box 280 Quathiaski Cove, Taxes and TFLs B.C. V0P 1N0 Tel.: 250 285-2234 Fax: 250 285-2236 701 Cape Mudge Rd. Dear Sir Filed with the Discovery Islander Office hours: Mon-Thurs 10-4pm Perhaps in this slower time of the year Quadra To: CBC Radio Victoria email: [email protected] residents may have a few minutes to consider the I listened with interest to this morning’s story implications of two events which have transpired Publisher/Editor: Philip Stone about the lack of first nation consultation when over the summer. As many will know B.C. Assessment Westrn Forest Products private land was removed Staff Reporter: Tanya Storr completed a comprehensive re-assessment of all Area from their TFLs. In my view, the latest move by J properties this past summer. My contacts at the Printing: Castle Printing 285-3695 the province to permit removal of WFPs private assessment office assure me that the total assessed value lands without compensation is a sell-out of the © Discovery Islander 2007 All Rights Reserved of properties in Area J will rise significantly as a result public interest. Opinions expressed in this magazine are those of this process. They have found many properties for of the contributors and do not represent the which structures and improvements have not been As a Biologist, I was the District Habitat views of the publisher. previously assessed. Hence in addition to valuations Officer for the Fish and Wildlife Branch of the increasing due to the demands of the real estate Ministry of Environment, Campbell River, for Agreement # 1408585 market, many Quadra residents will find the assessed most of the 1990s. As such, I was responsible value of their properties very much higher than in for the management and protection of fish and previous years. wildlife habitat on TFL private lands. Working in conjunction with the Ministry of Forests, those Printed on recycled paper We have also been advised that Area J will become lands were managed to the same standards, as crown part of a new Regional District. One with a much TFL land, for fish and wildlife habitat, biodiversity, Discovery Islands smaller total assessed value than its predecessor. As this Media and Publishing timber sustainability, and other non-timber values. new Regional District will ultimately grow to provide After removal from the TFL, in terms of fish and a similar range of administrative services, it will require Subscriptions available wildlife habitat, these lands are subject only to the a budget similar to the former one. The mayor of Gold Federal Fisheries Act and 2 arcane sections of the $30.00* for 6 months River, to his credit, has recognized that spreading the .00* BC Wildlife Act that protect eagle and heron nest $50 for 12 months (* includes GST) administration cost over a smaller asset value base will trees. The companies are free to maximize short result in higher, per property, tax charges. Call 250 285-2234 for details term shareholder returns at the expense of non- Hence exists the need to increase taxes, coupled timber values. with an up to date assessment in one area of the new Submission Guidelines The timber companies placed these private Regional District. You will note that other areas Items for publication are welcomed on subjects lands in TFLs because they received inducements of the district have not had recent comprehensive of interest to the Discovery Islands community. or compensation from the province for doing assessments. Area J will then bear more of the tax Please help us by following these guidelines: so. There may be good and justifiable reasons for increase than other areas in the new District. • Please print handwritten material clearly. removing private land from a TFL. But, in a quid • Electronic items sent by email & must be saved In a system focused upon equality, tax rates in area pro quo world, the company should be compensating as Word or rtf formats. Please spell check in J should drop next year to ensure that Area J residents the Province for this removal, either in cash, or Canadian English. Sorry no floppies. are not paying a greater proportional share of the preferably, in land or restrictive covenants. Forest • No MS Publisher, WordPerfect files or graphics in total tax burden. Once all property assessments in the Minister Coleman was recently quoted as saying that Word files please. Send imported graphics separately. District are up to date, regional district wide rates can WFP had paid stumpage on the timber harvested • Please use the title of the item as email subject be adjusted to reflect the level of service in each area. from the WFP lands that are being removed. The & send multiple items in separate emails. Not that tax equality can ever be achieved. Minister is misinformed, stumpage is not paid on • Please don’t send original irreplaceable However, the taxing administration has a golden private TFL land, only the provincial timber tax material, make a trip to a copier first!! opportunity coming to extract a disproportionate which is an entirely different matter. If the Minister • Please remember to caption & credit photos amount of new tax revenue from Area J residents, is this badly informed about stumpage, is he in a and artwork. Don’t write on the back of photos owner’s and renters alike. It may be worth your reader’s position to make decisions about removal of land use labels or Postits™. while to watch their new tax assessment(s) closely and from TFLs? This decision does not pass the “smell” pay attention to the formation of the new District and test and needs to reviewed in public. While every effort is made to include all items to its initial tax policy. Sincerely; submitted, errors and accidental omissions do occur David Alger Regards and the Discovery Islander should be only one part Quadra Island of your publicity efforts. M. Gouge Articles, letters and artwork are all welcome for publication in ‘Island Forum’ Opinions & endorsements expressed herein are those of the contributors and do not represent the views of the publisher. Next Deadline If you would like to see an alternative point of view represented submit something yourself. We reserve the right to edit for space and content. 7 pm. Monday, November 19th Next deadline 7pm November 19th www.discoveryislander.ca 4 Discovery Islander #408 November 9th, 2007 I should like to make the following Quadra Island Public Service Announcement Re: Killing our Thank You! Cancer Rate, On behalf of the Wild Salmon We, the Fire Dept., would like to give a huge thank-you to Quadra Foods, Environment, And Wolves, Cougars Gotta love those anti-fish farmers— Heriot Bay Tru Valu, and Schnieders And Bears Of gonna save the wild salmon by grilling it Meats for their donations to us for our Future Planning on the bbq. How about some marmot Halloween evening at the Bay hall. We Regarding cancer and our Quadra Island burgers to go with that? And some are grateful to the Island’s business’ and environment on Quadra Island: While spotted owl roasted with a nice wild to Schnieders. Thank-you to all who resently researching Quadra Island rice stuffing? came by in costume, chatted, ate, drank history, in Campbell River Public I’m all for protecting wild salmon. hot choc. to warm up and supported Library, I read a book from the library Re: Their Official But come on folks, by killing it and this evening. We will see you next year! shelves titled ‘Edge of Discovery ~ A Community Plan eating it? Before the poor guy even gets Sincerely, QIVFD History of Campbell River District’ a chance to reproduce? I don’t think so. As residents of the island since the by D.E. Isenor, E.G. Stephens, and I’ll stick to such radical ideas as cleaning Smashing Pumpkins? last ice age, their voice has never been D.E. Watson. This book describes up spawning grounds and consuming heard in the formulation of human It is usually a pleasure to drive by a geological survey conducted on the farmed product. OCPs. It has always been what people at this time of year to view the creative Quadra Island during 1914, when Bruce Banta needed. How people needed to sell handiwork of the island pumpkin carvers, geologists surveyed a 1.5-mile wide off their acreages to newcomers to and then to watch the faces change as they band of limestone running from Open finance their retirement or help out Many Thanks regress back to nature This year just as the Bay to Granite Bay. They analysed their offspring. Or how they needed faces were beginning to take their place samples from this limestone band and To all who aided in finding my little affordable housing for seniors or young many were pushed off and smashed. found a significant deposit in Granite dog Muffin. Special thanks to Debbie families so the school can stay open. The good news, I saw a family today Bay containing 27.5% radioactive Mortimer who picked her up, took her Never a thought was given to the choosing an honoured place for their uranium. A mining company staked a home and cared for her overnight. You pressure of thousands more residents jack-o-lantern today. Don’t let the party claim, and planned to build a uranium are a very special lady. on wildlife. Just keep growing has been poopers win, if you haven’t placed your mine in Granite Bay. This mine did not Thanks again the mantra. pumpkin please do, there’s lots of space eventuate, due to uranium discoveries Joy Fowler . Bev elsewhere in Canada. The majestic predators of Quadra would not assert their right to claim all After reading this account I of the island, but merely to maintain immediately thought of Quadra their place on it. But even the best Island’s cancer rate. Exposure to game management cannot protect radioactivity causes cancer. Quadra them from human over-population, residents who blame the pulp mill for which seldom over-takes us in one Quadra’s cancer rate may be better to fell swoop, but incrementally through blame Quadra’s natural radioactive innocuous steps. rock. In 1914 when Quadra’s geology was surveyed, not so much was In 2007 it’s 2700 people and let’s say known about radioactivity. Perhaps thirty years later it will be 10,000, the the matter was given little attention, population of Saltspring Island today. then forgotten about. Are there other How many cougars and wolves live on areas of radioactive rock on Quadra Saltspring now? Answer: zilch. Squat. apart from in Granite Bay’s limestone? Nada. Zero. Are some of us living on radioactive Clearly what is needed is not Land? Drinking radioactive water? Do wildlife management, but human any of Quadra’s aquifers run through management. Not stewardship, but radioactive rock? Some Quadra wells studentship. have too much boron or too much Therefore the OCP for the arsenic to be potable. Do some Quadra Predators of Quadra Island calls for a wells have too much radioactivity? limit on people. And in the same spirit Quadra residents can have their water of exclusivity, their hearings are closed analysed, but does that analysis include to human input. a Geiger counter reading? Quadra property owners should perhaps take Tim Murray Geiger counter readings of their land, Quadra Island, BC and their well water. Also, people who go caving in Q-Beans Granite Bay limestone caves should bear in mind that they could be Coffee exposing themselves to radioactive rock. Quadra Island’s radioactive rock is a factor in future planning. Only organically grown, fair-trade coffee. Kiosk opens at 6:00 a.m. Greg Ross daily at the Q-Cove ferry terminal.
www.discoveryislander.ca Discovery Islander #408 November 9th, 2007 5 Dear Mr. Liseth, Never Again Wild Salmon Unite BC This is partly in response to your letter Dear Editor, and also to several requests I have had Dear Editor, from others to elaborate on the issues I just walked through the Quadra surrounding TimberWest’s corporate Last weekend in Port McNeill I forget the total collapse of the east coast Island cemetery. There’s a plaque in the activities on our island. back commemorating 58 war veterans. attended a protest walk against open [cod] fishery. In spite of all the evidence, 58 brave men most of whom fought in net fish farming. One remarkable government and industry are refusing I am in complete agreement with you WWll and WWl. I was surprised to see thing about this event was that it to listen. that the large areas of mature forest land on Quadra Island are a defining feature that one had served a long time ago in was organized by a logger. My guess This coming together in Port McNeill of our island home. The management of India and ‘Afghanistan’. is that it was attended by about 100 of loggers and environmentalists, the timber resources and conservation people, many of them loggers and their ordinary people who are very concerned The most recent war represented of the parkland have the potential to families. is just the beginning. What can you was Korea. I was a toddler then. I barely give people economic, recreational and I’m kind of in awe of Alexandra do? Join public protests, write your remember. I remember my dad though, environmental benefits indefinitely. WWll - air force. He was compelled to Morton, the noted scientist from MLA. Remember this issue when you serve to stop tyranny, to stop the war. Simoon Sound whose work with whales vote. More info - want to help? www. But personally I don’t believe that the ‘Never again’ he was told. ‘Never again’ has been wisely acclaimed and who friendsofwildsalmon.ca or call Roberta management of the TFL lands on Quadra would we be asked to give the supreme has more recently been studying and at 285-2061. Island by TimberWest are benefiting everyone equally. The lion’s share is going sacrifice of our loved ones. Thousands writing about the damage done by fish Roberta Robson gave their lives, for peace, willingly for farms in the Broughton Archipelago. to a group of ‘anonymous’ shareholders us. Well, there she was walking beside me in thousands of miles from here. the pouring rain through Port McNeill. Now Canada is again at war. Canadians TFL 47 may have been the very model Some points made by Ms. Morton are killing and being killed, participating Editor, Discovery of sustainable silviculture under previous during her speech following our walk in a U.S. led war for control of the world’s tenureholders but today it is under the through town were: Islander oil. History will undoubtedly show this management of a self-professed ‘real estate Sir; to be true. Peaceful Canadians have been • Wild salmon are the backbone company’ whose income trust corporate sucked into going to war once again and of the whole ecology of the coast. The I must take Phil Stone to task for structure demands that they plunder our ancestors are mocked. Did they give whales, the bears, the wolves, the eagles, publishing an unsigned, unacredited irreplaceable timber even below market value their lives in vain and for a lie? ‘Never the trees themselves. Life on the coast is letter damming the TFL logging to satisfy shareholder returns. To add insult again’ we were told. sustained by the salmon. on Quadra island. Who is this ‘3rd to injury TimberWest are one of the major generation Quadra Islander’ who slams purportraitors [sic] of raw log exports. Soon no one will be left that truly • Fish farms are placed in the most our logging pratices & the decimation remembers WWll, the brutality of it and sensitive areas where the little smolts What happened recently near Jordan of animals & threats to eco-tourism? the reasons our loved ones gave their lives, from all the rivers are forced to go past River with Western Forest Products that we might live in peace. Standing up them. Sea lice abundance near fish farms Does he/she exist? What possible being permitted by the government to to the USA during Vietnam honoured has been shown to be 30,000 times reason could there be to not want (or sell a huge swath of TFL to an urban our fathers and the sacred promise made higher than natural levels (Raincoast require) a signature on a letter? developer for millions of dollars could easily happen on Quadra Island. them. Research). Sea lice can kill juvenile fish The TFL (#47, formerly #2 has even at low levels (Watershed). This Remembrance Day let’s insist that existed since 1953, taking effect in The issue is not one of historical forest Canada’s involvement in the war against • Industrialized fish farming has 1985. It is the largest reason that management but current and future control Afghanistan end. It not only lends George negatively effected the tourism industry. Quadra Is. retains a rural character. over our public lands. Our community Bush credibility, it destroys our own and is Farms regularly use acoustic harassment ten acre stump ranches & estates do should wrest control of this land from the actually prolonging the conflict. devices to scare away marine mammals. not represent a rural community; the provincial government and TimberWest Whales no longer frequent parts of woodlots & farms do. so we can truly discuss our island’s future Lets’ insist our elected officials and not have it dictated to us by a faceless the Broughton since the advent of fish The TFL harbours & build a great return Canada to its historical role of corporation and racketeering government farming. population of game while preserving peacekeeper. It’s time to stop offering up whose bottom lines are making profit for • The government is being dishonest. lakes & watercourses, all varieties of our own children for needless sacrifice and people who don’t live here. selling our ancestors short. The opposite It is leading people to believe that it is vegetation, & the unique rock features of war is peace. Let’s stand up for it - ‘Lest possible to have both open net fish of the limestone belt. As for the unsigned letter, what does that really matter? Our home is what We Forget’. farming and wild salmon. Ms. Morton Arne Liseth made it very clear that you can have is being discussed here, and I don’t just K C Cudmor only one or the other, not both. Don’t mean Quadra. - Philip Stone Heriot Bay
A Unified Voice for the Islands' Business Community
very I co sla is n JOIN TODAY D d s s &ORUM