Archeological Identification and Evaluation Study of Chesapeake & O
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THROUGH THE GREAT VALLEY AND INTO THE MOUNTAINS BEYOND ARCHEOLOGICAL IDENTIFICATION AND EVALUATION STUDY OF CHESAPEAKE & OHIO CANAL NATIONAL HISTORICAL PARK SANDY HOOK TO HANCOCK (MILE MARKERS 59 TO 123) Volume I PREPARED FOR: NATIONAL CAPITAL REGION NATIONAL PARK SERVICE 1100 OHIO DRIVE, S.W. WASHINGTON, D.C. 20242 PREPARED BY: THE LOUIS BERGER GROUP, INC. 2445 M Street NW Washington, D.C. 20037 Final Report January 2009 THROUGH THE GREAT VALLEY AND INTO THE MOUNTAINS BEYOND ARCHEOLOGICAL IDENTIFICATION AND EVALUATION STUDY OF CHESAPEAKE & OHIO CANAL NATIONAL HISTORICAL PARK SANDY HOOK TO HANCOCK (MILE MARKERS 59 TO 123) VOLUME I Final Report PREPARED FOR: National Park Service National Capital Region 1100 Ohio Drive, S.W. Washington, D.C. 20242 PREPARED BY: John Bedell, Charles LeeDecker, Stuart Fiedel, Jason Shellenhamer THE LOUIS BERGER GROUP, INC. 2445 M Street NW, Suite 400 Washington, D.C. 20037 January 2009 FOREWORD This is the first of three volumes reporting the results of a three-year archeological survey of the central 64 miles of the Chesapeake & Ohio Canal National Historical Park (C&O Canal Park) carried out for the National Park Service (NPS), National Capital Region, from 2005 through 2007. Although more than a hundred archeological sites have been recorded in the C&O Canal Park, much of the park remains unexplored, and little is known about most of the recorded sites. Since the park borders the Potomac River, the archeological potential of its 13,000 acres is enormous. To learn more about the archeological resources of the park, and to assist the park in managing those resources, funds were devoted to implement the Systemwide Archeological Inventory Program (SAIP) in this area. The SAIP was developed to address the requirements of the National Historic Preservation Act (specifically Sections 106 and 110), Executive Order 11593, and the Archeological Resources Protection Act. The rationale for the archeological survey was based primarily on the NPS’s resource management needs under Section 110 rather than being driven by development or capital improvement projects within the park. The park’s total length of 184.5 miles was divided into three segments for the SAIP project. The research reported here focused on the central segment comprising 64 miles between Sandy Hook and Hancock, spanning the Great Valley from the Blue Ridge to the Alleghenies (Figure 1). An earlier study covered the eastern 59 miles, from Georgetown to Sandy Hook (Fiedel et al. 2005). The NPS plans to fund future study to examine the archeology of the upper, western segment of the C&O Canal Park. In order to address multiple audiences most effectively—the general public, park staff, NPS, review agency staff, and the archeological community—this report is organized in a way that differs from the standard cultural resource study. This volume (I) presents a narrative, designed for the general public, of the prehistory and history of the Potomac in the Great Valley, based on the archival and archeological field investigations; it is intended for the non-technical reader and does not contain specific information about site locations. In order to avoid excessive repetition, this volume treats briefly some topics that were extensively discussed in the reports on the eastern segment of the park. Volume II provides a more technical description and assessment of the project’s research goals, methods, and findings, and concentrates on a presentation of the prehistoric research. In organization and content, it more closely follows the professional standards of the cultural resource management industry and is intended for distribution only within the professional community. Volume III, also intended for limited distribution, contains additional technical materials and appendices, including artifact inventories, a summary list of radiocarbon dates, and transcripts of the archival documents that are most important to the historical narrative contained in Volume I. i MM 123 MM 59 ii FIGURE 1: Map of the Cheasapeake & Ohio Canal SOURCE: National Park Service TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME I Chapter Page THE CANAL AND THE RIVER ................................................................................................... 1 ONE RIVER, MANY LANDS...................................................................................................... 3 The Potomac ................................................................................................................. 3 Prehistory ...................................................................................................................... 5 THE FIRST PEOPLE .................................................................................................................. 7 HUNTERS AND GATHERERS: THE EARLY ARCHAIC................................................................. 11 SLOW, SLOW CHANGE: THE MIDDLE ARCHAIC ...................................................................... 15 MIGRATION AND CULTURE CHANGE: THE LATE ARCHAIC ..................................................... 18 POTS AND THEIR PEOPLE: THE EARLY WOODLAND................................................................ 25 WHERE DID THE PEOPLE GO? THE MIDDLE WOODLAND ....................................................... 31 MAIZE AND VILLAGE LIFE: THE LATE WOODLAND................................................................ 34 The Indian Way............................................................................................................. 34 The Late Woodland in the Great Valley....................................................................... 39 The Luray Complex at the Spring Dell Road Site ........................................................ 45 AN EMPTY PLACE: THE GREAT VALLEY IN THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY ............................. 48 Warfare and Disease ..................................................................................................... 48 Henry Fleet’s Potomac Expedition, 1632 ..................................................................... 50 Refugees........................................................................................................................ 52 THE COLONIAL FRONTIER....................................................................................................... 54 Indians and Traders....................................................................................................... 54 The Land Rush.............................................................................................................. 60 Squatters and Settlers at Antietam Bottom ................................................................... 67 The Germans................................................................................................................. 69 The Archeology of the Frontier .................................................................................... 76 Spring Road Dell Site .......................................................................................... 80 THE FRENCH AND INDIAN WAR .............................................................................................. 83 iii TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Chapter Page THE EARLY IRON INDUSTRY ................................................................................................... 101 THE NINETEENTH CENTURY ................................................................................................... 109 Rural Life in the Valley ................................................................................................ 109 Industry ......................................................................................................................... 117 Building the Canal ........................................................................................................ 118 Labor Strife and Financial Turmoil ..................................................................... 119 Searching for Workers’ Camps............................................................................ 129 THE CIVIL WAR ...................................................................................................................... 132 Garrisons and Skirmishes ............................................................................................. 132 Antietam and Gettysburg Campaigns ........................................................................... 133 The Canal in Wartime................................................................................................... 138 CANAL LIFE ............................................................................................................................ 139 Lock Keepers and Other Canal People ......................................................................... 139 The End of the Canal .................................................................................................... 140 REFERENCES CITED ................................................................................................................ 141 iv LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Figure Page 1 Map of the Chesapeake & Ohio Canal ......................................................................... ii 2 Excavations Along the C&O Canal .............................................................................. 2 3 Map of the Hagerstown Valley..................................................................................... 3 4 The Potomac River in the Great Valley.......................................................................