DNA Demethylation Is Initiated in the Central Cells of Arabidopsis and Rice
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DNA demethylation is initiated in the central cells of Arabidopsis and rice Kyunghyuk Parka,1, M. Yvonne Kimb,1, Martin Vickersc, Jin-Sup Parka, Youbong Hyuna, Takashi Okamotod,2, Daniel Zilbermanb,2, Robert L. Fischerb,2, Xiaoqi Fengc,2, Yeonhee Choia,2, and Stefan Scholtene,2 aDepartment of Biological Sciences, Seoul National University, 151-742 Seoul, South Korea; bDepartment of Plant and Microbial Biology, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720; cDepartment of Cell and Developmental Biology, John Innes Centre, Norwich Research Park, Norwich NR4 7UH, United Kingdom; dTokyo Metropolitan University, 192-0397 Tokyo, Japan; and eUniversity of Hamburg, 22609 Hamburg, Germany Contributed by Robert L. Fischer, November 17, 2016 (sent for review August 26, 2016; reviewed by Anna Koltunow and Nathan M. Springer) Cytosine methylation is a DNA modification with important regula- whereas overlaps with sequences that repress expression can en- tory functions in eukaryotes. In flowering plants, sexual reproduction hance gene activity (5, 6). CG methylation is also common within is accompanied by extensive DNA demethylation, which is required the transcribed regions of genes, where its function is presently for proper gene expression in the endosperm, a nutritive extraem- unclear (6). bryonic seed tissue. Endosperm arises from a fusion of a sperm cell In addition to methyltransferases, plants encode enzymes that carried in the pollen and a female central cell. Endosperm DNA can remove methylation from DNA (7). One of these, DEMETER demethylation is observed specifically on the chromosomes inherited (DME), is expressed in Arabidopsis thaliana male and female ga- from the central cell in Arabidopsis thaliana, rice, and maize, and metophytes, primarily in the vegetative and central cells, respec- requires the DEMETER DNA demethylase in Arabidopsis. DEMETER tively (8, 9). In the vegetative cell, DME catalyzes demethylation of is expressed in the central cell before fertilization, suggesting that thousands of discrete loci, most of which are relatively euchromatic endosperm demethylation patterns are inherited from the central TEs (10, 11). The maternal endosperm chromosomes inherited cell. Down-regulation of the MET1 DNA methyltransferase has also from the central cell are also extensively demethylated at simi- been proposed to contribute to central cell demethylation. However, lar sequences in Arabidopsis (10) as well as in the distantly re- with the exception of three maize genes, central cell DNA methyl- lated monocots rice (12) and maize (13). As in the vegetative cell, ation has not been directly measured, leaving the origin and mech- demethylation of maternal endosperm chromosomes requires anism of endosperm demethylation uncertain. Here, we report DME in Arabidopsis (10), and loss of DME function disrupts en- genome-wide analysis of DNA methylation in the central cells of dosperm gene expression, gene imprinting, and causes seeds to Arabidopsis and rice—species that diverged 150 million years ago— abort (8, 14). Several lines of evidence strongly argue that the as well as in rice egg cells. We find that DNA demethylation in both demethylation observed in the endosperm is inherited from the species is initiated in central cells, which requires DEMETER in Arabi- central cell: Only the central cell-derived chromosomes are deme- dopsis. However, we do not observe a global reduction of CG meth- thylated (10, 12, 13), DME is rapidly down-regulated following ylation that would be indicative of lowered MET1 activity; on the sperm fusion (8), and genes activated by demethylation are expressed contrary, CG methylation efficiency is elevated in female gametes in the central cell (15, 16). Down-regulation of MET1 in the central compared with nonsexual tissues. Our results demonstrate that cell has also been proposed to contribute to demethylation (2, 17). locus-specific, active DNA demethylation in the central cell is the origin of maternal chromosome hypomethylation in the endosperm. Significance DNA methylation | central cell | egg cell | epigenetics | gene imprinting Flowering plant reproduction involves two fertilization events: a sperm–egg fusion that forms the embryo, and a sperm–central cell lowering plant sexual reproduction is carried out by multicel- fusion that forms the nutritive extraembryonic endosperm. Flular gametophytes that arise through mitosis from haploid Chromosomes in the embryo, endosperm, and other plant tissues meiotic spores (1–3). The male gametophyte, pollen, consists of are modified by methylation, a covalent addition to cytosine in two sperm cells and a companion vegetative cell. The vegetative DNA that regulates gene expression. Maternal endosperm chro- cell forms the pollen tube that delivers the sperm into the female mosomes inherited from the central cell display a pattern of ex- gametophyte, where one of the sperm cells fuses with an egg to tensive demethylation, which is essential for seed development in form the zygote and the other sperm fuses with the homodiploid Arabidopsis thaliana. Demethylation is presumed to occur in the central cell to form the triploid endosperm (1–3). The endosperm central cell, but direct evidence for this is very limited. Here, we is an extraembryonic, placenta-like tissue that nourishes the em- provide a genome-wide DNA methylation analysis of Arabidopsis bryo and—particularly in monocots like rice and maize—the and rice central cells, which demonstrates that the demethylation seedling after germination (4). Monocot endosperm also consti- observed in the endosperm is indeed initiated in the central cell. tutes the bulk of human nutrition (4). Proper gene expression in the endosperm requires extensive Author contributions: T.O., D.Z., R.L.F., and Y.C. designed research; K.P., M.Y.K., J.-S.P., Y.H., reprogramming of DNA methylation (5). Methylation is a covalent X.F., and S.S. performed research; M.V., D.Z., X.F., and Y.C. analyzed data; and D.Z. and X.F. wrote the paper. modification of cytosine that is accurately copied after DNA rep- Reviewers: A.K., CSIRO, Australia; and N.M.S., University of Minnesota. lication, thereby passing epigenetic information during cell division (6). Plant methylation is categorized into three contexts: CG, CHG The authors declare no conflict of interest. (H = A,T,orG),andCHH(6).CGmethylation,themost Freely available online through the PNAS open access option. abundant and widespread of the three, is maintained by the MET1 Data deposition: The data reported in this paper have been deposited in the Gene Ex- pression Omnibus (GEO) database, www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo (accession no. GSE89789). DNA methyltransferase (6). All three types of methylation are 1 found in transposable elements (TEs), which are transcriptionally K.P. and M.Y.K. contributed equally to this work. 2 repressed and heritably silenced by methylation (6). TE and To whom correspondence may be addressed. Email: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], or TE-like methylated sequences that overlap gene regulatory regions [email protected]. — influence gene expression overlaps with transcriptional start sites This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10. and other regions that promote expression cause gene silencing, 1073/pnas.1619047114/-/DCSupplemental. 15138–15143 | PNAS | December 27, 2016 | vol. 113 | no. 52 www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1619047114 Downloaded by guest on September 25, 2021 However, with the exception of three maize genes (16, 18), DNA AB0.54 Sperm 1 1 Sperm methylation has not been analyzed in the central cell, leaving the 0.54 Genes CC Rep2 1 TEs CC Rep2 Embryo Embryo dme/+ n origin of endosperm demethylation uncertain. noita CC oitalyhtemGC ddme/+m Here, we report genome-wide analysis of DNA methylation in CC Rep1 l CC Rep1 VC CCC yhtemGC Endosperm VC the central cells of Arabidopsis and rice as well as in rice egg cells. Endosperm We find that DNA demethylation in both species is initiated in central cells, which requires DME in Arabidopsis. However, we do 0 0 0 0 0 not find evidence for a global reduction of CG methylation that -2 10-1 2-3 4 3210-11 2-2 10-1 2-3 4 3210-12 CDkb kb would be indicative of reduced MET1 activity. Instead, we find 0.7 .22 0.22 0.7 TEs CC Rep1 CC Rep22 0.22 TEs Embryo that CG methylation is efficiently maintained in the central cells dme/+ n noitalyhtemG Sperm CC o Embryo VC it Endosperm of both species and in rice eggs. Our results support locus- a lyhtemHH VC specific, active demethylation in the central cell as the cause of dme/+ Endosperm endosperm hypomethylation. CC Rep2 CC H CC Rep1 C C Sperm Results 0 0 0 0 0 -2 10-1 2-3 4 3210-10 1 2 -2 10-1 2-3 4 3210-12 Isolation of Arabidopsis Central Cells. We used the INTACT (Iso- kb kb lation of Nuclei Tagged in specific Cell Types) approach (19, 20) to Fig. 2. DNA methylation in Arabidopsis central cells in comparison with isolate central cell nuclei from wild-type Arabidopsis plants. A re- other cell types. Genes (A) and TEs (B–D) were aligned at the 5′ and 3′ ends. porter protein (Nuclear Targeting Fusion, NTF) consisting of a Methylation within each 100-bp interval was averaged and plotted from nuclear envelope localization domain fused to GFP was expressed 2 kb away from the annotated gene or TE (negative numbers) to 4 kb into from the DD7 central cell-specific promoter (Fig. 1) (21). Nuclei the annotated region (positive numbers). The dashed lines represent the were released from ovule tissue protoplasts and captured using points of alignment. Previously published data are from ref. 10. anti-GFP antibodies; purity was calculated as the fraction of GFP+ nuclei in the obtained sample (Fig. S1). For DNA methylation confined to sequences that show demethylation of maternal chro- analysis, we used two biological replicates, one with 85% purity (87 mosomes in the endosperm (10), nearly the entire distribution is on + + GFP nuclei; replicate 1) and one with 90% purity (75 GFP the right side of the graph for both replicates (red traces in Fig.