DOCSLIB.ORG

Has-Ellison on Petropoulos, 'Royals and the Reich: the Princes Von Hessen in Nazi Germany'

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Has-Ellison on Petropoulos, 'Royals and the Reich: the Princes Von Hessen in Nazi Germany' H-German Has-Ellison on Petropoulos, 'Royals and the Reich: The Princes von Hessen in Nazi Germany' Review published on Friday, September 1, 2006 Jonathan Petropoulos. Royals and the Reich: The Princes von Hessen in Nazi Germany. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 2006. xix + 524 pp. $37.50 (cloth), ISBN 978-0-19-516133-5. Reviewed by J. Trygve Has-Ellison (University of Texas at Dallas)Published on H-German (September, 2006) Making the Nazis Respectable Jonathan Petropoulos's new monograph offers an explanation for a puzzling paradox of the Third Reich--the troubled relationship between the radical Nazi movement and the conservative representatives of the traditional order. In his monograph, Petropoulos chooses the brothers Prince Philip and Prince Christoph von Hessen as an example of this paradox in order to draw larger conclusions about the confluence of interest between the former ruling houses and the Nazi leadership. In addition, Petropoulos briefly examines the continued presence and influence of the princely families on modern-day Germany and draws some tentative conclusions about their significance for twentieth-century German history. One suspects that this work will be the opening salvo in a slew of new English-language case studies that explore the relationship of the old elite to the National Socialist movement, as well as their respective fates in the FRG and GDR; it may lay out a new course in Third Reich studies as well. Petropoulos's monograph is one of many recent studies that have applied social historical methods to the nobility; like their Bielefeld counterparts, the new historians of the nobility use concepts originating with Norbert Elias and Pierre Bourdieu, such as habitus or cultural capital, when discussing the distinctive milieu of the nobility. Although this approach is the starting point for Petropoulos, he departs from the model by teleologically relating the stories of Prince Philipp and Prince Christoph of Hessen. Petropoulos's work is particularly interesting because he was given access to the Hessen family private archive. The former princely families in what was the Bonn Republic still control their archives--written permission must be secured from the head of the royal household before research can commence. For research on the Bavarian Wittelsbachs fulfilling this requirement has been a simple process; for families who had members implicated in the policies of the Third Reich like the Hessen, Schaumberg and Waldeck, historians have rarely received access. That Petropoulos has managed to do so speaks to both changing social attitudes and Petropoulos's diplomatic abilities. The work is divided into eight chapters with the following themes: the interconnectedness of the nobility from the Second Empire through the Great War; the Princes von Hessen during the Weimar Republic; Nazi high society; princely careers in the Nazi state; roles in an increasingly radical regime; miscalculation and misfortune; denazification and postwar justice; and rebuilding after the war. Citation: H-Net Reviews. Has-Ellison on Petropoulos, 'Royals and the Reich: The Princes von Hessen in Nazi Germany'. H-German. 09-30-2014. https://networks.h-net.org/node/35008/reviews/44778/has-ellison-petropoulos-royals-and-reich-princes-von-hessen-nazi Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 1 H-German Petropoulos's main goal is to examine the reasons why members of the princely families became involved with the Nazi party and how they reacted to its increasingly criminal behavior (pp. 3-4). As Petropoulos shows, a greater statistical percentage of the higher nobility joined the Nazi party than almost any other occupational group or social class (p. 5)--if one counts the former ruling houses as an occupational group or a social class (historically dubious in both cases). Nonetheless, Petropoulos has identified a significant fact--that members of the highest social strata, those who enjoyed the greatest prestige within German society, joined the Nazi party in large numbers. The motives for accommodation with the NSDAP varied between individuals, families, confessions and generations. Broadly speaking, Catholic families were more resistant to the blandishments of the Nazi elite than their Protestant cousins, and the younger cohort of princes who came of age during World War I or the Weimar Republic were far more likely to embrace National Socialism as the solution to Germany's problems than the older generation (p. 6). Most joined in 1932 or later. Many were drawn in by Hitler's personal magnetism, rather than party ideology. All of those who did join did so for similar reasons: resentment over their dispossession; fear of Bolshevism; hope of restoration; securing of the family fortune; patriotic and idealistic sentiments; and--not least--the hope that the Nazis would solve contemporary social problems by uniting the masses behind a patriotic program that would steer them away from attempts to expropriate princely wealth and property. The Princes von Hessen were picked as the primary example because of their close relationship to the English royal family. After all, Englishness was a virtual inoculation against the fascist disease--or not (if we think of the Duke of Windsor, Sir Oswald Mosley or Randolph Churchill). This work, in many ways, is a portrayal of the "fascist gentleman." Princes Philip and Christoph "possessed considerable ability and combined a commitment to their illustrious family with a love of country. Indeed, their gravitation to National Socialism was motivated by certain idealism. [They] embodied contradictory qualities and cannot be portrayed in an entirely negative or, conversely, entirely positive light" (pp. 14-15). In fact, the princes' connection to the English royal family and their sympathetic personal qualities make their attraction to the movement even more compelling as a case study. These were cultivated, well traveled and educated men with a sense of humor--not the sort of people who would enthusiastically sing a verse from the "Horst Wessel Lied." It is just this dichotomy, that internationally-connected and cultivated individuals could support a criminal regime; could continue to have Jewish friends while espousing official antisemitism; could continue warm and close relationships with family members from Great Britain and Russia while advocating Germany’s global dominance; could appreciate the great art works of Europe and yet help Hermann Göring and Adolph Hitler loot these same works, that gives Petropoulos's work its greater significance. The princes' road to National Socialism was often tortuous. The von Hessen, like many noble families, suffered disproportional causalities during World War I (two elder brothers were killed in the war) and then were blamed for its failure afterwards. The princes were attracted to National Socialism as well because of their frustration with the lack of acceptable careers (the numbers of officers were limited by the Versailles Treaty); the promise of monarchical restoration by Adolf Hitler and Göring; the stabilization of their property and finances under the Nazis because Hitler did not favor expropriation; and the apparent modernity of the Nazi movement. The nobility and modernity are not oxymoronic--as Karl Möckl commented about nobles during the Second Empire, most embraced almost all forms of modernity (with the exception of political democratization).[1] Many princes enthusiastically joined the SS, which had as one of its goals the creation of a new elite based on blood and race, rather than on ancient pedigree--an exceptionally modern, if toxic, theory.[2] In the case of Citation: H-Net Reviews. Has-Ellison on Petropoulos, 'Royals and the Reich: The Princes von Hessen in Nazi Germany'. H-German. 09-30-2014. https://networks.h-net.org/node/35008/reviews/44778/has-ellison-petropoulos-royals-and-reich-princes-von-hessen-nazi Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 2 H-German Prince Christoph, he failed at every career he attempted during the Weimar Republic and was attracted to the SS by its pronounced elite military ethos. So much so, that although close to Hermann Göring and possessed of a relatively safe desk job with the Luftwaffe, he chose to fight, and subsequently die, in the Allied invasion of Italy. One suspects that for most nobles, high and low, the possibility of wearing a uniform and fighting (confirming one's nobility) was of greater significance than ideology or strongly held political views. Perhaps the most disquieting part of Petropoulos's work is his explicit, excellent chapter on Nazi high society (pp. 97-135). Former royal families did in fact make the National Socialist elite acceptable to many traditional elements within German society. These princely families retained social and cultural capital even after the fall of the monarchy, which was expended on behalf of the fascists. Whether they fully understood the implications of Hitler's ideology or not, they helped "normalize" the radical nature of the movement, and in so doing, disarmed misgivings at home and abroad about the new rulers. This is an excellent piece of scholarship by Petropoulos and fits well with his earlier work on art policy in the Third Reich. There are, however, a few flaws. Appendix one is purportedly a list of members of the NSDAP from the high nobility (pp. 380-389). It however, includes family names such as Baudissin,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Declining Homogamy of Austrian-German Nobility in the 20Th Century? a Comparison with the Dutch Nobility Dronkers, Jaap
    www.ssoar.info Declining homogamy of Austrian-German nobility in the 20th century? A comparison with the Dutch nobility Dronkers, Jaap Veröffentlichungsversion / Published Version Zeitschriftenartikel / journal article Zur Verfügung gestellt in Kooperation mit / provided in cooperation with: GESIS - Leibniz-Institut für Sozialwissenschaften Empfohlene Zitierung / Suggested Citation: Dronkers, J. (2008). Declining homogamy of Austrian-German nobility in the 20th century? A comparison with the Dutch nobility. Historical Social Research, 33(2), 262-284. https://doi.org/10.12759/hsr.33.2008.2.262-284 Nutzungsbedingungen: Terms of use: Dieser Text wird unter einer CC BY Lizenz (Namensnennung) zur This document is made available under a CC BY Licence Verfügung gestellt. Nähere Auskünfte zu den CC-Lizenzen finden (Attribution). For more Information see: Sie hier: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.de Diese Version ist zitierbar unter / This version is citable under: https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:0168-ssoar-191342 Declining Homogamy of Austrian-German Nobility in the 20th Century? A Comparison with the Dutch Nobility Jaap Dronkers ∗ Abstract: Has the Austrian-German nobility had the same high degree of no- ble homogamy during the 20th century as the Dutch nobility? Noble homog- amy among the Dutch nobility was one of the two main reasons for their ‘con- stant noble advantage’ in obtaining elite positions during the 20th century. The Dutch on the one hand and the Austrian-German nobility on the other can be seen as two extreme cases within the European nobility. The Dutch nobility seems to have had a lower degree of noble homogamy during the 20th century than the Austrian-German nobility.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    Cambridge University Press 0521836182 - Nobles and Nation in Central Europe: Free Imperial Knights in the Age of Revolution, 1750-1850 William D. Godsey Excerpt More information Introduction “The Free Imperial Knights are an immediate corpus of the German Empire that does not have, to be sure, a vote or a seat in imperial assemblies, but by virtue of the Peace of Westphalia, the capitulations at imperial elections, and other imperial laws exercise on their estates all the same rights and jurisdiction as the high nobility (Reichsstande¨ ).” Johann Christian Rebmann, “Kurzer Begriff von der Verfassung der gesammten Reichsritterschaft,” in: Johann Mader, ed., Reichsritterschaftliches Magazin, vol. 3 (Frankfurt am Main and Leipzig, 1783), 564. Two hundred years have now passed since French revolutionary armies, the Imperial Recess of 1803 (Reichsdeputationshauptschluß ), and the dissolution of the Holy Roman Empire in 1806 ended a matchless and seamless noble world of prebends, pedigrees, provincial Estates, and orders of knighthood in much of Central Europe.Long-forgotten secular collegiate foundations for women in Nivelles (Brabant), Otmarsheim (Alsace), Bouxieres-aux-` Dames (Lorraine), Essen, Konstanz, and Prague were as much a part of it as those for men at St.Alban in Mainz, St.Ferrutius in Bleidenstadt, and St.Burkard in W urzburg.The¨ blue-blooded cathedral chapters of the Germania Sacra were scattered from Liege` and Strasbourg to Speyer and Bamberg to Breslau and Olmutz.Accumulations¨ in one hand of canonicates in Bamberg, Halberstadt, and Passau or Liege,` Trier, and Augsburg had become common.This world was Protestant as well as Catholic, with some chapters, the provincial diets, and many secular collegiate foundations open to one or both confessions.Common to all was the early modern ideal of nobility that prized purity above antiquity, quarterings above patrocliny, and virtue above ethnicity.
    [Show full text]
  • Abstract “Just For
    ABSTRACT “JUST FOR ME”: BOURGEOIS VALUES AND ROMANTIC COURTSHIP IN THE 1855 TRAVEL DIARY OF MARIE VON BONIN by Margaret Estelle Breidenbaugh This thesis considers the origins of the embourgeoisement of the mid-nineteenth-century German aristocracy through the lens of the summer 1855 travel diary of twenty-year-old Landedelfräulein (country noble maiden) Marie von Bonin, the oldest daughter of Maria Keller and landowner and politician Gustav von Bonin. Scholars of German history have often contended that the influence of middle-class values on German nobles originated with print culture and socio-political movements. While this thesis neither contradicts, nor focuses on these claims, it examines the ways that the lived experiences of everyday people also gave birth to middle-class values. Focusing on the themes of Heimat (home), travel and education, and romantic courtship, this thesis concludes that Marie’s bourgeois views were not revolutionary; rather, they exemplified the influence of middle-class values on the mid-nineteenth century German aristocracy. “JUST FOR ME”: BOURGEOIS VALUES AND ROMANTIC COURTSHIP IN THE 1855 TRAVEL DIARY OF MARIE VON BONIN A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Miami University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Department of History by Margaret E. Breidenbaugh Miami University Oxford, Ohio 2018 Advisor: Erik Jensen Reader: Steven Conn Reader: Nicole Thesz © Margaret Estelle Breidenbaugh 2018 “JUST FOR ME”: BOURGEOIS VALUES AND ROMANTIC COURTSHIP IN THE 1855 TRAVEL
    [Show full text]
  • Deutscher Adel – Wikipedia 05.05.17, 1655
    Deutscher Adel – Wikipedia 05.05.17, 1655 Der Titel dieses Artikels ist mehrdeutig. Zur gleichnamigen Erzählung von Wilhelm Raabe siehe Deutscher Adel (Wilhelm Raabe). Der deutsche Adel war bis zur Aufhebung des Standes im Jahre 1919 eine Bevölkerungsgruppe mit Vorrechten in der Gesellschaft, insbesondere übte er in den meisten deutschen Territorien die Herrschaft aus oder war zumindest maßgeblich an ihr beteiligt.[A 1] Der Adel wird häufig mit jahrtausendalter, bis auf die Germanen zurückgehende Tradition in Verbindung gebracht. Vom Mittelalter bis 1806 war er eng verbunden mit dem durch die Römisch-deutschen Kaiser regierten Heiligen römischen Reich deutscher Nation, dem freilich auch Gebiete zugehörten, die anderer Nationalität waren. Aufgrund der gleichen Herkunft und sehr ähnlichen Rangstufen (Adelstitel), hatte der deutsche Adel mit dem österreichischen Adel viele Gemeinsamkeiten. Der letzte römisch-deutsche Kaiser, Franz II. (HRR) nach seiner Kaiserkrönung, 1792 Erst in der Spätphase des deutschen Adels entstand unter der Führung Preußens das Deutsche Reich, das bis zur Novemberrevolution durch den Deutschen Kaiser repräsentiert wurde, ebenso wie die Teilstaaten durch die Bundesfürsten der Teilstaaten. Die Archäologie kennt früheste Herrschaftszeugnisse vor allem aus Grabfunden und Resten ehemaliger Villen und Burgen, die als solche „adeligen Lebens“ gedeutet werden[1], ohne dass sichere Aussagen über die soziale Struktur von Gemeinschaften gemacht werden können, zu denen keine schriftlichen Zeugnisse vorliegen.[2] Caesars Schrift De bello Gallico (52/51 v. Chr.) und die Germania des Tacitus aus dem Jahre 98 n. Chr.[3][A 2] werden oft als https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutscher_Adel#Adel_und_Nationalsozialismus Page 1 of 35 Deutscher Adel – Wikipedia 05.05.17, 1655 erster Beleg für die Existenz des germanischen Adels aufgefasst.
    [Show full text]
  • Nobles Into Germans
    William D. Godsey, Jr.. Nobles and Nation in Central Europe: Free Imperial Knights in the Age of Revolution, 1750-1850. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004. xi + 306 pp. $85.00, cloth, ISBN 978-0-521-83618-0. Reviewed by Todd Berryman Published on H-German (July, 2006) William Godsey has written a highly insight‐ mates range from 350 to above 500), Godsey skill‐ ful portrayal of the Holy Roman Empire's imperial fully manages this otherwise unwieldy topic by nobility during its crucial century of outward de‐ limiting his analysis to the 108 "knightly houses cline. Specialists will be pleased that this volume active in the second half of the eighteenth century is no mere historiographical digest of recent in Electoral Mainz." Of these, he is particularly in‐ works. Rather, it is the product of exhaustive re‐ terested in the 60 families "represented in Mainz's search conducted in nearly two dozen public and cathedral chapter" (p. 8). private archives within Austria, the Czech Repub‐ Two classic studies have dominated the histo‐ lic and Germany. For this reason, Godsey consis‐ riography of Electoral Mainz: F. G. Dreyfus's ac‐ tently offers his readers not only fresh perspec‐ count of the electorate's socioeconomic conditions tives, but also fresh material. during the second half of the eighteenth century Godsey's work comes during a period of re‐ and T. C. W. Blanning's later study on the transfor‐ newed interest in Europe's historical nobilities.[1] mation of Mainz's political institutions during Within the context of Central Europe, the study of roughly the same period.[3] Mainz's notable and the so-called high nobility (Hochadel or Re‐ highly controversial archbishop-elector, Karl ichsstände) has particularly benefited from this Theodor von Dalberg, has also enjoyed considera‐ resurgence of scholarly activity.[2] But literature tion by biographers.[4] But the free imperial on the free imperial knights (Reichsrittershaft) knights of Mainz have received far less treatment, nevertheless remains sparse.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Quaternionen, Pdf, 658 KB
    The Four of each Estate - Quaternionen der Reichsverfassung A short survey of the literature and pictorial presentations by Steen Clemmensen Introduction 2 The Quaternionen 2 Types of sources 4 Some sources compared 5 The families named as quaternionen 9 Bibliography 31 Index armorum 34 Index nominorum 36 © 2012 Steen Clemmensen , Farum, Denmark, www.armorial.dk Four of each Estate - Quaternionen der Reichsverfassung Introduction The concept of the Quaternionen der Reichsverfassung (the Foursomes of the constitution of the Empire), also known as Viergruppen von Reichsständen (Four of each Estate), die Vier Säulen von das Reich (Four Pillars of the Empire), is a unique german phenomenon. Several sets of 4 names of families, town or territories were accorded a special place as representatives of the people, seen not only as the generally accepted trinity of clergy, nobility and commoners, but as a finely stratified society placed as a counterweight to the prevailing 'monopoly' of the seven electors in deciding who should be emperor (and how he ought to rule) – in time moving on to infer a certain special quality on the members – at least on some of these. The Quaternionen The earliest evidence of this mythology is the statues on the front of the Frankfurter Römer or Rathaus, added in 1414, and this was probably related to a visit by the then recently elected head- of-state Sigismund of the maison de Luxembourg (r.1411-1437). The imagery of the Quaternionen of the Holy Roman Empire of the German Nation (HRR) became widespread during the 15th to 17th centuries, and might be found in literature, as mural decorations as well as on drinking glasses.
    [Show full text]
  • Adelige Über Sich Selbst Westfälische Quellen Und Archivpublikationen Band 29 LWL-Archivamt Für Westfalen
    Adelige über sich selbst Westfälische Quellen und Archivpublikationen Band 29 LWL-Archivamt für Westfalen Gunnar Teske (Hg.) Adelige über sich selbst Selbstzeugnisse in nordwestdeutschen und niederländischen Adelsarchiven Münster 2015 Gedruckt auf säurefreiem und alterungsbeständigem Papier © 2015 Landschaftsverband Westfalen-Lippe, LWL-Archivamt für Westfalen Das Werk ist urheberrechtlich geschützt. Die dadurch begründeten Rechte, insbesondere die der Übersetzung, des Nachdrucks, der Entnahme von Abbildungen, der Funksendung, der Wiedergabe auf fotomechanischem oder ähnlichem Wege und der Speicherung in Datenverarbeitungsanlagen bleiben, auch bei nur auszugsweiser Verwertung, vorbehalten. Die Vergütungsansprüche des § 54 Abs. 2 UrhG werden durch die Verwertungs- gesellschaft Wort wahrgenommen. Titelbildnachweise: Titelseite Schreibkalender des Clamor Eberhard von dem Bussche, 1627–1665. Archiv Hünnefeld, Niedersächs. Landesarchiv Osnabrück, Dep. 24 b, II, Nr. 224 ff. Rückseite Seite aus dem Tagebuch der Helene Gräfin von Plettenberg-Lenhausen, 1897. Archiv Hovestadt, N 7. Gestaltung: Markus Bomholt, Münster Satz: Markus Schmitz, Büro für typographische Dienstleistungen, Altenberge Druck und Verarbeitung: Lonnemann GmbH, Selm ISSN 0946-0594 ISBN 978-3-936258-22-6 Inhaltsverzeichnis Vorwort 7 Arianne Baggerman und Rudolf Dekker Selbstzeugnisse, eine Literaturgattung des Adels? 11 Bastian Gillner Leerstellen in der Selbstbeschreibung. Konfession in adeligen Selbstzeugnissen aus Westfalen, dem Rheinland und den Niederlanden 21 Antje Diener-Staeckling
    [Show full text]
  • Claus Graf Schenk Von Stauffenberg Familie
    Claus Graf Schenk Von Stauffenberg Familie Yanaton globe draftily if blunt Dabney spoon or sieged. Uric and alike Dionysus still librate his howdies unutterably. Which Elmer buffeted so disconnectedly that Algernon adjoins her boast? Collect the row that you want to confirm while using the dictionary. Zeitpunkt keine familie kam und albert bassermann, and founder of the most of alamy images and general ludwig beck, von claus schenk graf von vietinghoff in polen. Was wanted because Hitler was losing the war? Let the Generals kill the Corporal, or vice versa, preferably both. Schwangerschaftswoche und der resistance fighter claus schenk graf von den anderen widerstandsgruppen um seinen tod seiner frau studiert jaeger wird. Gemeinsam mit seiner Frau studiert Jaeger Agrarwirtschaft an der landwirtschaftlichen Hochschule in Tettnang am Bodensee. The Nazis detained the entire Stauffenberg family executed one of Claus' brother. Widerstandes gefunden, die Canaris schwer belasteten. Edgar Stiller, Ducia und Thalhammer statt. Auf Capri lernte Gaevernitz ihre Einzelschicksale kennen und erfuhr, wie knapp sie dem Tode entronnen waren. Die war sie jedoch zu keinem Zeitpunkt. Nach dem Kriege wurde er ein Mitglied der konservativen Deutschnationalen Volkspartei. Continue to oberst claus schenk graf claus von stauffenberg, kein golf gti vor weihnachten wird er mitglied des nazi armeen waren, including claus von stauffenberg seine kurdische opposition. Lively Stone The Autobiography of Berthold Von Schenk Paperback 1197 Free shipping Claus Schenk Graf von Stauffenberg Brand New Free shipping in. Mai in Niederdorf aufgehalten haben, da er laut Sigismund Payne Best an einem dieser beiden Tage dort Dokumente verbrannte. Berlin during office hours of the very same day.
    [Show full text]
  • Polish Nobility and Its Heraldry: an Introduction
    P a g e | 1 Polish Nobility and Its Heraldry: An Introduction by Piotr Pawel Bajer Table of content: Introduction History of Polish Nobility, Its Origins, Prerogatives and Structure Polish Heraldic Law Nobilitacja or Ennoblement Indygenat or Naturalisation Origins of Polish Heraldry : Shield Crest Helmet Crest coronet Mantling War Cries Supporters, Mottoes and other accessories Polish Mediaeval Coats of Arms in European Armorials Polish Mediaeval Coats of Arms in Polish Armorials and Other Sources Polish Armorials (16th - 20th century) Notes Bibliography ------- Introduction It will not be an overstatement to say that Polish heraldry is unlike any other style of heraldry, as it is considerably different from the Anglo-Norman heraldry with which most people in the Western countries are familiar. Many P a g e | 2 heraldists from a non-Polish background with whom I came to contact had very little understanding of it. Some thought of it as being exotic, "poor" or inferior. Because of thoughts like these, there seems to be a tendency to downgrade Polish nobility itself and to treat it as something second rate. It is my belief that those opinions derive solely from the lack of knowledge and understanding, which is due to the shortage of literature on the subject in languages other than Polish. I believe that once we will fill the gap and more information on the subject will be published in English and other languages, people fascinated with heraldry will begin to see that Polish herby, just like Hungarian cimerei, have a unique style and are worth studying on their own. I happen to believe that Polish heraldry is fascinating precisely because it is different.
    [Show full text]
  • EUI WORKING PAPERS SPS No
    EUI WORKING PAPERS SPS No. 2005/07 Declining homogamy of the Austrian and German nobility in the 20th century? A comparison with the Dutch nobility JAAP DRONKERS EUROPEAN UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE Political and Social Sciences Department SPS 2005-04.indd 1 10/01/2006 14.50.42 EUROPEAN UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE DEPARTMENT OF POLITICAL AND SOCIAL SCIENCES Declining homogamy of the Austrian and German nobility in the 20th century? A comparison with the Dutch nobility JAAP DRONKERS EUI W orking Paper SPS No. 2005/ 07 This text may be downloaded freely only for personal academic purposes. Any reproductions, whether in hard copies or electronically, require the consent of the author. If cited or quoted, reference should be made to the full name of the author(s), editor(s), the title, the working paper, or other series, the year and the publisher. ISSN 1725-6755 © 2005 Jaap Dronkers Printed in Italy European University Institute Badia Fiesolana I – 50016 San Domenico di Fiesole (FI) Italy http://www.iue.it/ http://cadmus.iue.it/dspace/index.jsp Abstract Has the Austrian-German nobility had the same high degree of noble homogamy during the 20th century as the Dutch nobility? Noble homogamy among the Dutch nobility was one of the two main reasons for their ‘constant noble advantage’ in obtaining elite positions during the 20 th century. The Dutch on the one hand and the Austrian-German nobility on the other can be seen as two extreme cases within the European nobility. The Dutch nobility seems to have had a lower degree of noble homogamy during the 20th century than the Austrian- German nobility.
    [Show full text]
  • Nobles and Nation in Central Europe: Free Imperial Knights in the Age of Revolution, 1750-1850 William D
    Cambridge University Press 0521836182 - Nobles and Nation in Central Europe: Free Imperial Knights in the Age of Revolution, 1750-1850 William D. Godsey Frontmatter More information NOBLES AND NATION IN CENTRAL EUROPE This is a study of Central European nobles in revolution.As one of Germany’s richest, most insular and most autonomous nobilities, the Free Imperial Knights in Electoral Mainz represented the early modern noble ideal of pure bloodlines and cosmopolitan loyalties in the old society of orders.But this world came to an end with the outbreak of the revolutionary wars in 1792.Quite apart from the social, economic, and political dislocations and loss, the era from 1789 to 1815 also meant a cultural reorientation for the nobility.William D. Godsey, Jr.here explores how nobles in post-revolutionary Germany gradually abandoned their old self-understanding and assimilated with the new cultural ‘nation’ while aristocrats in the Hapsburg Empire, which had taken in many emigr´ es´ from Mainz, moved instead towards supranationalism.This is a major contribution to debates about the relationship between identity, cultural nationalism, supranationalism, and religion in Germany and the Hapsburg Empire. william d. godsey, jr. is Tenured Research Fellow of the His- torical Commission at the Austrian Academy of Sciences, Vienna.He is the author of Aristocratic Redoubt: The Austro-Hungarian Foreign Office on the Eve of the First World War (1999). © Cambridge University Press www.cambridge.org Cambridge University Press 0521836182 - Nobles and Nation in Central Europe: Free Imperial Knights in the Age of Revolution, 1750-1850 William D. Godsey Frontmatter More information new studies in european history Edited by peter baldwin, University of California,Los Angeles christopher clark, University of Cambridge james b.
    [Show full text]
  • The Donaueschingen Armorial (DWF) Belongs to This Group by Content and Style and in Part by Organisation
    Donaueschinger Wappenbuch Edited and reconstructed by Steen Clemmensen from Karlsruhe, Badische Landesbibliothek Hs. Don. 496 Donaueschinger Wappenbuch DWF Contents: 1. Introduction and summary 3 2. Manuscript 4 3. Imaginary arms 7 4. Foreigners 9 5. German nobles 11 App. A Segments 15 App. B Segment and page structure 16 App. C Society memberships in segment 18 App. D Possible membership of the Leitbracken society 19 App. E Drawing styles 21 App. F Members of the Bodensee group 24 Donaueschinger Wappenbuch 25 Bibliography 163 Ordinary of arms 172 Ordinary of crests 185 Name index 196 © 2012, Steen Clemmensen, Farum, Denmark, www.armorial.dk 2 1. Introduction and summary A number of german late medieval armorials belong to the Bodensee group, named after their region of manufacture. Strictly speaking, they do not make up a series of copies, but they share a number of features. All include many marker coats-of-arms, i.e. combinations of legends and figures-of-arms unlikely to have been invented independently. Some are curious mistakes of actual arms, but most belong to the imaginary arms attributed to non-christian realms or to names from literature. Some armorials include segments of ternionen (three best of each), notably the Nine Worthies, quaternionen (the Pillars of the Empire), and / or organize parts of the german nobility by their membership of tournament societies. Woodblocks were used for prestamping the outlines of shields, helmets and manteling, and several were reused for different armorials. It is likely that part of the sources used wasere older collations owned by or readily accessible to the artisans responsible.
    [Show full text]