Body and Technology ISSN 1815-8927 Mass Media Registration Certificate PI No
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
№ 152019 Body and Technology ISSN 1815-8927 Mass media registration certificate PI No. FS77-35818 © Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences, 2019 © European University at St Petersburg, 2019 © University of Oxford, 2019 FORUM FOR ANTHROPOLOGY AND CULTURE (annual English version of Antropologicheskij forum (in Russian, quarterly)) General Editor Albert Baiburin (Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences / European University at St Petersburg, St Petersburg, Russia) Deputy General Editor Nikolai Vakhtin (European University at St Petersburg, St Petersburg, Russia) Editor, English language edition Catriona Kelly (New College, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK) Associate Editors Yuri Berezkin (Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences / European University at St Petersburg, St Petersburg, Russia) Yury Chistov (Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences, St Petersburg, Russia) Boris Firsov (European University at St Petersburg, St Petersburg, Russia) Sheila Fitzpatrick (Sidney University, Sidney, Australia) Andrei Golovnev (Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences, St Petersburg, Russia) Caroline Humphrey (University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK) Konstantin Pozdniakov (INALCO, Paris, France) David Ransel (Indiana University, Bloomington, USA) Sergei Shtyrkov (Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences / European University at St Petersburg, St Petersburg, Russia) Steve Smith (University of Essex , Colchester, UK) Sergei Sokolovskiy (Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia) Valentin Vydrin (INALCO / CNRS, Paris, France) Faith Wigzell (University College, London, UK) Secretary of Editorial Board, Copy Editor Olga Boitsova (Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences, St Petersburg, Russia) Copy Editor, Website Editor Alexandra Piir (Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences / European University at St Petersburg, St Petersburg, Russia) Сopy Editor, Proofreader Daria Mishchenko (Institute for Linguistic Studies, Russian Academy of Sciences / Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences, St Petersburg, Russia) Translator, Copy Editor Alexandra Kasatkina (Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences / National Research University Higher School of Economics, St Petersburg, Russia) Reviews Editor Maria Pirogovskaya (European University at St Petersburg, St Petersburg, Russia) Founders and Publishers Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera), Russian Academy of Sciences, St Petersburg, Russia European University at St Petersburg, St Petersburg, Russia 5 CONTENTS Forum for Anthropology and Culture. 2019. No 15 From the Editors . 7 Forum 38: Body and Technology Editors’ Questions . 11 Elena Gudova, Asya Karaseva, Magdalena Kozhevnikova, Victor Krutkin, Aleksandra Kurlenkova, Anna Malyar, Dmitriy Mikhel, Igor Morozov, Michel Rivkin-Fish, Irina Sirotkina, Elena Sokolova, Liliia Zemnukhova . 13 Sergei Sokolovskiy . Anthropology of the Living and the Dead: The Case of the Human Body and Technics (An Afterword to the Discussion) . 83 The Human in Techno-Media: New Topics in Anthropological Research Sergei Sokolovskiy . Bodies and Technologies through the Prism of Techno-Anthropology . 97 Elena Sokolova . The Smartphone as Witness: Technological Mediation of Bodily Sensory Experience . 116 Evgenia Nim . Self-tracking as a Practice of Quantifying the Body: Conceptual Outlines . 137 Articles Stanislav Petriashin . Socialist Realism and Ethnography: The Study and Representation of Soviet Contemporaneity in Ethnographic Museums in the 1930s . 155 Dmitriy Timoshkin, Konstantin Grigorichev . ‘Non-Place’ outside Time: Indeterminacy as the Specificity of the Existence of Localities in a Post-Soviet City (The Case of Irkutsk) . 183 Reviews Alexandra Kasatkina . Translations at the End of the World: A Review of Anna Lowenhaupt Tsing, Grib na krayu sveta: o vozmozhnosti zhizni na ruinakh kapitalizma . Moscow: Ad Marginem Press, 2017, 376 pp . (Russian transl . of Anna Lowenhaupt Tsing, The Mushroom at the End of the World: On the Possibility of Life in Capitalist Ruins . Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2015, 352 pp .) . 205 FORUM FOR ANTHROPOLOGY AND CULTURE 2019 No 15 6 Ivan Kirpichnikov . A Review of Jan Hennings, Russia and Courtly Europe: Ritual and the Culture of Diplomacy, 1648–1725 . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016, XII+297 pp . (New Studies in European History) . 216 Sergei Shtyrkov . The Catechon as a Category of Orthodox Consciousness: Outlines of Russian Political Eschatology: A Review of Victor Shnirelman, Koleno Danovo: eskhatologiya i antisemitizm v sovremennoy Rossii [The Tribe of Dan: Eschatology and Anti-Semitism in Modern Russia] . Moscow: St Andrew’s Biblical Theological Institute Press, 2017, XIV+617 pp . 221 7 FROM THE EDITORS FROM THE EDITORS It is now exactly fifteen years since the first issue of our parent journal, Antropologicheskij forum, was published . Issue no . 1, which also initiated Forum for Anthropology and Culture, opened with a broad discussion, ‘Cultural Anthropology: The State of the Field’, which asked participants to address questions such as the reasons behind the declining interest in the traditional culture of the Russian countryside . The decade and a half since then has seen a large number of changes, some of them (for instance, the geopolitical situation) definitely for the worse . However, that relatively short period of time has also witnessed the reintegration of Russian scholarship — to a significant if not universal degree — into global discussions of key social and cultural problems . Younger scholars now without hesitation apply theoretical texts and cultural criticism in languages other than Russian to the analysis of contemporary pheno mena, and indeed to the examination of historical reality . The ‘Forum’ with which this issue opens, on technology and the body, is a striking illustration of the shift in approach . A Soviet scholar of the 1980s (indeed a scholar from more or less anywhere) would have found the collision of these two topics, whatever their legitimate separate existence in the academic world, more than a little perplexing . However, Russia is now one of the world’s most e-aware societies, while the huge transformation of physical self- awareness and of bodily existence as ‘image’ and ‘performance’ (exemplified by the large number of businesses offering cosmetic procedures in any and all urban centres) is obvious even FORUM FOR ANTHROPOLOGY AND CULTURE 2019 No 15 8 to the most superficial observer . Here the object, though, is not so much to address the glamour industry that has already had quite a lot of discussion (in a recent multi-handed book edited by Helena Goscilo and Vlad Strukov), as to foster an interdisciplinary dis- cussion of topics such as biotechnology, biopolitics and power, robotics, and the entire boundary between ‘the natural’ and ‘the artificial’ in circumstances of radically altered possibilities for man- made objects and states . The ‘Forum’ is followed by an article cluster examining these themes at greater length and with relation to extended treatments of empirical material . A second topic examined in the issue is the (re)imagination of the past . An article by Stanislav Petriashin examines the relationship between the ideological stereotypes of Socialist Realism familiar from painting, cinema, and literature, and the world of the Soviet museum at the same period . Meanwhile, Dmitriy Timoshkin and Konstantin Grigorichev provide a fascinating exploration of an ‘in between’ site in the historic city of Irkutsk, somewhere that cuts across different layers of city identity and proves unclassifiable in terms of the governing ideological imaginary . The issue concludes with three reviews taken from across the journal’s range of interests . Alexandra Kasatkina’s review of Anna Lowenhaupt Tsing’s celebrated study, The Mushroom at the End of the World, suggests both the reach of anthropological work and the pitfalls of trying to convey cultural analysis across the language divide (a number of significant misunderstandings in the Russian translation are identified) . Sergei Shtyrkov’s respectful, but exacting review of Victor Shnirelman’s enormous survey of Russian eschatology, The Tribe of Dan, continues the discussion of religious practice set out in our previous issue, while also picking up on themes of significance here . Finally, Ivan Kirpichnikov assesses Jan Hennings’s study of Russian diplomacy and its international resonance in the early modern period, a book profoundly absorbed in the language of gesture and bodily enactment, so echoing once more the questions that are intensively discussed in the ‘Forum’ . Once more, we express our thanks to the authors, for their willing- ness to participate in the English number, to the participants in the ‘Forum’, and especially to Sergei Sokolovskiy, whose work as editor of the ‘Forum’ and article cluster was essential to the coordination of this issue and the Russian publications on