Representations, Racialization, and Resistance: Exploring Asian American Picturebooks, 1993-2018
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REPRESENTATIONS, RACIALIZATION, AND RESISTANCE: EXPLORING ASIAN AMERICAN PICTUREBOOKS, 1993-2018 Joanne Heejoo Yi Submitted to the faculty of the University Graduate School in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in the School of Education, Indiana University December 2020 Accepted by the Graduate Faculty, Indiana University, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Doctoral Committee ________________________________________ Donna Adomat, EdD, Chair ________________________________________ Sharon Daley, PhD ________________________________________ Mitzi Lewison, PhD ________________________________________ Robert Kunzman, PhD December 7, 2020 ii Copyright © 2020 Joanne Yi iii To Halmoni iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This dissertation marks the end of a long, arduous road of profound learning and the start of a new chapter. Along the way, I have been indebted to so many people who have influenced my work, supported and encouraged me, and kept me afloat. I would like to express my deep appreciation and gratitude towards my committee for their support. The courses I took with Dr. Mitzi Lewison and Dr. Robert Kunzman were some of the most impactful of my graduate career as I encountered new ways to perceive democracy, literacy, and equity. Not only that, but I was confronted each class with their personhood and was inspired by their thoughtfulness and integrity. I have been uplifted by the support of Dr. Sharon Daley, who is an example of the very best teachers you had as a child or read about in books. Her kindness, dependability, and professionalism are a boon to all who encounter her in places of learning. Finally, I cannot express the depth of my gratitude for my dissertation chair and advisor, Dr. Donna Adomat. I remember the very first email I received from her welcoming me to IU and inviting me to her children’s literature class. I did not know yet what it meant to be a scholar, and I was genuinely surprised and humbled by her unwavering belief in our potential as scholars with something important to contribute. She called us “future colleagues,” invited us to conferences, and encouraged us to submit our final projects to research journals. She sparked my deep dive into Asian American literature and propelled me forward on a path I had not realized was before me. She has been my advocate, firmly teaching, supporting, and mentoring me for seven years running, and I am utterly thankful. I am so grateful to my colleagues and professors for their support, which I have felt deeply over the years. I recall the many handwritten notes sent in the mail or tacked to the wall of my carrel, the emails in capital letters saying, “YOU CAN DO THIS!,” the brief (as well as the extra-long) conversations in the hallways of the SoE, the texts, care packages, and more. To Heidi, Amanda, Adam, Jill, Casey, Breanya, Mike, and Arnell—I will not forget the kindness, laughter, and conversations, which so often v appeared when I needed them most. I also wish to acknowledge the Asian American scholars I have met along this journey. Sarah, Ji, Betina, Jung, Erica, Poushali, Paul, Noreen, Nithya, and Marina have been a constant source of laughter, challenge, and learning, and the very best model of what a supportive network of colleagues looks like. More than that, their commitment to Asian American representation is a true source of inspiration and motivation. Thank you. Of course, I owe my mental sanity and so much of my academic and personal growth to my dear friends Alex and Summer. I feel like I won the lotto in my friendships with them. Not only did their nearly daily barrage of texts bring me so much laughter and support, but they buoyed me in the deepest trenches of this dissertation work, offering me encouragement and perspective to keep moving forward. Finally, my journey as a graduate student and scholar would not have been possible without the unwavering love, patience, and support of my family. My parents, Steven and Healim Yi, are the embodiment of love and sacrifice. I understand the beauty, struggle, and resilience of the Asian American experience because of them. My husband, Grey, and my children, Judah, Teddy, and Moss, have kept me rooted and planted where I need to be most, and I love you always. Last but not least, I could not have completed this dissertation without my sister, Annie. Her love and care for the kids gave me the space, time, and peace of mind to write, and her challenging questions and insights about my research improved and progressed this work in innumerable ways. vi Joanne Yi REPRESENTATIONS, RACIALIZATION, AND RESISTANCE: EXPLORING ASIAN AMERICAN PICTUREBOOKS, 1993-2018 This qualitative study explores representations of Asian Americans in picturebooks through a critical content analysis. While public interests in diversity and equity in children’s literature have increased in recent years, the nature of the publication growth of Asian American books for young readers is largely unknown due to the industry practice of conflating Asian and Asian American content and authorship. This study addresses gaps in literacy research by providing a comprehensive examination of 356 Asian American picturebooks spanning 26 years. In addition, this study uses data from the Cooperative Children’s Book Center, including publishing rates and trends, to look beyond the texts at the systemic forces affecting children’s literature. This study uses a conceptual framework grounded in Asian American Critical Race Theory (AsianCrit), which describes the specific mechanisms of racialization experienced by Asian Americans in the United States. To consider how Asian Americans are represented and racialized in picturebooks, the study focused on the following questions: (1) How are Asian American picturebooks represented, in regard to publication rates and trends over time, within the broader context of Asian Pacific (AP) and Asian Pacific American (APA) children’s literature?, (2) How are Asian Americans represented in picturebooks according to genre?, and (3) How are Asian Americans represented in picturebooks according to racial/heritage identity? The major findings of this study demonstrate that Asian American picturebooks have been published in marginal numbers since 1993 and continue to be infrequently produced. While many Asian American authors and illustrators demonstrated resistance to racializing mechanisms in their texts, the picturebooks comprised limited genres that recurrently represented Asian Americans using stereotypical tropes, such as the forever foreigner and the model minority. The texts also largely conflated Asian vii American identities with East Asian identities, leading to a neglect and silencing of South Asian and Southeast Asian perspectives. The omissions of heritage identities, genres, and character roles revealed how racialized representations are constructed and maintained in picturebooks. Simultaneously, the need to increase the number of texts, genres, and perspectives in picturebooks suggests how advocacy efforts towards equitable representations may be directed. ________________________________________ Donna Adomat, EdD, Chair ________________________________________ Sharon Daley, PhD ________________________________________ Mitzi Lewison, PhD ________________________________________ Robert Kunzman, PhD viii TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...................................................................................................................... v TABLE OF CONTENTS ......................................................................................................................... ix LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................................... xiii LIST OF FIGURES .............................................................................................................................. xiv LIST OF APPENDICES......................................................................................................................... xv CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ...............................................................................................................1 Asian Americans in the United States ........................................................................................................... 4 Asian American Children’s Literature ............................................................................................................ 6 The Problem ................................................................................................................................................... 9 Purpose of Study .......................................................................................................................................... 10 Research Questions ........................................................................................................................ 11 Significance of Study .................................................................................................................................... 11 Content and Organization of Chapters ........................................................................................................ 13 CHAPTER 2: REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE .......................................................................................... 15 Key Constructs and Terminology ................................................................................................................