A report from the nation, on the occasion of its most recent biennial, proves that market 76 factors—or the absence thereof— have little to do with the vibrancy of art-making.

By Sara Roffino LETTER FROM

Kimani Beckford’s Young, Gifted , and Black, 2016, in oil on canvas.

eveloping an art scene these days is a matter of formula: bring together investors, warehouses, starchitects, canapés, and ... voila. Capital, more than creative ambition, tends to drive such development, with places like Dubai and Shanghai serving as prime examples of the use of private wealth to spur creative industries. It’s an approach espoused by the glitterati of the art world circuit—who right now are likely somewhere along the route from Athens for Documenta, to New York for Frieze, to Venice for the Biennale, to Kassel for the second round of Documenta, and then, finally, to Basel, before a summer respite. Though their art world is global, it remains decidedly insular. In , however, where artists work in relative—although decreasing—isolation from the rest of the art world, artistic ambition is flourishing despite the absence of significant capital. The Jamaica Biennial, on view through May 28, offers an opportunity to take stock of the art scene in a country whose creative force has already made an outsize contribution to world culture through music, but has yet to find a place within the art world establishment. Organized by the National Gallery of Jamaica (ngj), under the directorship of Veerle Poupeye, the 78 biennial brings together more than 90 artists at three venues around the country, including the recently established National Gallery West in Montego Bay and Kingston’s Devon House—a colonial-era mansion built by the first black Jamaican millionaire in 1881. The former home, also the first place to house the National Gallery, retains its period decor, with antique furnishings and historic photographs on the walls. For the biennial, six artists were invited to install works in dialogue with the space itself, and its complex legacy, and they do so with significant success. Upon entering, visitors are welcomed by Leasho Johnson’s installation In the Middle. Stockpots and speakers are set on a dining room table-sized platform about a foot off the ground. The pots are set atop the surface while the speakers are embedded within, leaving concave circles. Both are covered in a reddish substance, which, in places, drips and pours from the vessels. A pair of red childlike legs leans into a pot so that the rear-end sticks up, seeming to moon the entire room. Another set of legs, adorned in high heels, kicks outward from the bottom of a pot as if a child had fallen backward and couldn’t escape. The dark humor sets in, as does the context of the setting, imbuing the works with a clear historical weight. Yet deciphering what it is requires a bit of local knowledge. First, one must be familiar with Daggering—a relatively recent development in dancehall culture that has a woman lying on the ground with her legs apart and a man jumping from a height, landing on top of her and miming sex. National Gallery trustee and biennial juror Suzanne Fredericks explains, “It’s almost like the Village Venus, 2016,

women are empowered by disempowering by Judy Ann MacMillan. KINGSTON OF JAMAICA, GALLERY AND HERE: NATIONAL PAGE PREVIOUS

ART+AUCTION MAY 2017 | BLOUINARTINFO.COM Detail of Parallel Realities Dwelling in the Heartland of my People, 2016, by Jasmine Thomas-Girvan, in the dining room of Devon House.

79

An initial aversion themselves. They give up their power and yet retain it the current symbols of what represents that system,” she says, pointing to to the plight of the sufferer (Pietá), in some way.” As for the pots, “We call them Dutchies a silver platter with stickers of corporate logos affixed to the surface. 2017, by Nicola in Jamaica, which is a shortening of Dutch pots,” “Historically we have moved on, there are no more plantations, but the Feldman-Kiss. Johnson says. “They’re really cheap reproductions of system is alive and well in the form of multinational corporations and the cast iron pots, and are made out of scrap material. Jamaicans talk about debt in which many Caribbean countries are drowning.” their famous rice and peas, which are done in a pot like that. It’s an The afternoon following the opening at Devon House in February, the important staple to the social setting.” Fredericks continues, “It’s a pot in main exhibtion launched at the ngj, bringing hundreds of people to the which things are stewed for a long time on a low heat. It simmers up, and it building, originally designed as a department store along Kingston’s comes to a head, but then it simmers down.” waterfront—a gorgeous stretch that despite various efforts over the years In the formal dining room of Devon House is an installation by has failed to thrive. Tightly installed through all but a few of the galleries Jasmine Thomas-Girvan, Parallel Realities Dwelling in the Heartland of (where historical exhibitions remain on view), many of the works My People. In contrast to Johnson, whose subtlety does much to create continue the self-reflective discourse that has taken over Devon House. depth in his work, Thomas-Girvan looks you in the face while punching Seemingly straightforward photographic portraits of a young man and a you in the gut. “Devon House represents the colonial ideal, and many young woman by Marlon James (no relation to the novelist) are Jamaicans have antique furniture and very fine china and crystal in their complicated when considered alongside his Couple Strangers, an homes. It’s something that everybody aspires to,” the artist says. “When ambigious photograph of a couple, dressed for a night out, or perhaps for we are aping another culture and we have ideals that come from Carnaval or Halloween, as the woman’s witch hat suggests the possibility somewhere else, that’s okay—but there’s something at the root of it that she is in costume. Two photographs by Michael Chambers—one of a we need to look at seriously as well.” Parallel Realities Dwelling in the young man who is albino and sporting a black mohawk, the other of two Heartland of My People stretches throughout the room, with dozens women in ruffled white garb with covered heads—were striking, possibly (if not hundreds) of vignettes depicting the history of Jamaica. “These are because of their indecipherability. Simultaneously requiring and NICOLA FELDMAN-KISS NICOLA

BLOUINARTINFO.COM | MAY 2017 ART+AUCTION Above: Nicholas Rose’s Trelawny-Untitled (Win-gie), 2016, in 80 permanent marker, house paint, and oil paint. Right: Cowheadman, 2007, by Peter Dean Rickards. BOTH IMAGES: NATIONAL GALLERY OF JAMAICA GALLERY NATIONAL IMAGES: BOTH

ART+AUCTION MAY 2017 | BLOUINARTINFO.COM rejecting a narrative, the works are clearly not formal studies, yet neither back to 1938, the biennial added a broader regional outlook in 2014 when do they seem to function as documentary. it introduced a special projects section, with seven artists from the Painted portraits by Tina Spiro , Alicia Brown, Judy Ann MacMillan, Caribbean asked to participate this year, along with the 84 artists in the Nicholas Rose, and Gregory Bailey range vastly in temperament and invited and juried sections. Amanda Coulson, director of the national tone. Where Spiro’s Ma Jaica, 2015, an idealized and dreamy portrait of a gallery of the Bahamas, and Christopher Cozier, an artist and writer woman who, in lieu of hair, has a lush forrest growing on her head, replete based in Port of Spain, Trinidad, both jurors for the biennial, open the with flowers and a few buildings, is celebratory, Brown’sExchange , 2016, exhibition catalogue with a discussion of the potential of a shared and MacMillan’s Village Venus, 2016, are contemplative. Bailey’s Caribbean identity. “The idea of ‘nationhood’ and ‘sovereignty’ was so Colonial Legacies, 2016, manages to address Jamaican politics without important in the formation of our countries that I think it’s hard—even being limited by them. His bold, precise work is somehow fun in spite of scary—to disconnect from that idea,” writes Coulson. “It was its seriousness. Rose, working on a blue plastic tarp rather than a canvas, necessary,” she continues, “to be able to imagine a new identity post- uses hard black lines to define a figure set against an impressionistic independence but perhaps, moving forward, we need to identify a way to sunset—his Trelawny-Untitled (Win-gie), 2016 , is a measured study find strength in numbers as a regional collective.” in contrasts. Integral to taking a regionalist approach would be the cultivation of The latest in a long line of Jamaican national exhibitions that dates collectors of contemporary Caribbean art. Collectors in Jamaica “tend to be conservative,” says Poupeye. “We had a retrospective for Barrington Watson, who was an academic painter, and I had corporate sponsorship coming out of my ears for that exhibition, but it is the hardest thing for me to get corporate sponsorship for a contemporary exhibition. There’s no culture of patronage for that. It’s something I hope will change, but it’s an uphill battle that has to do with the perception of what art is, what it should be, what it should look like, and so on.” Coulson is part of a cohort of artists, curators, and writers with 81

From left: Phillip Thomas’s High-Sis in the Garden of Heathen, 2017; an installation shot of Leasho Johnson’s exhibition “Belisario & the Soundboy,” earlier this year at the artist- run non-profit New Local Space (nls), which was established in Kingston in 2012. FROM LEFT: NATIONAL GALLERY OF JAMAICA, NEW LOCAL SPACE, KINGSTON SPACE, LOCAL NEW OF JAMAICA, GALLERY NATIONAL FROM LEFT:

BLOUINARTINFO.COM | MAY 2017 ART+AUCTION Caribbean roots who have spent time abroad and are now returning to Devon House, established New Local Space (nls)—an artist-run the region, with hopes they can help build that culture. Paul Morrison, a non-profit in Kingston that she describes as “micro-residency” and a marketing consultant who lived in Washington, D.C. and New York for “micro-project space,” in 2012 after spending several years in the States. 10 years, launched the Red Easel pop-up gallery in 2015. “I want to “We have really good artists here,” she says. “We have a good art school. provide spaces for artists and I want to demystify art by having it in public We have a good museum that incorporates contemporary art spaces,” he says, describing why he has curated exhibitions of emerging programming into its exhibitions. So the question was how we can create artists in a car dealership, in the middle of a town square, and on the something dynamic with all of those ingredients already in place.” nls campus of the University of the West Indies. “I work with corporations as presents exhibitions and produces a podcast in addition to hosting the sponsors because they are trying to engage with that audience as well, so residency, and it also “fills other gaps within the contemporary art scene,” they get the benefits of interacting with a creative industry and they’re she says, “such as doing portfolio reviews and helping establish avenues seen as innovative by being a part of something that is also innovative.” for artists who are leaving the Edna Manley College of the Visual and Deborah Anzinger, an artist whose work is on view in the biennial at Performing Arts to enter into a dialogue with the already active

82

From left: Alexander Cooper’s undated Symbols of Life,in oil on canvas; and Alicia Brown’s Exchange, 2016, also in oil on canvas. BOTH IMAGES: NATIONAL GALLERY OF JAMAICA GALLERY NATIONAL IMAGES: BOTH

ART+AUCTION MAY 2017 | BLOUINARTINFO.COM From left: Couple Strangers, 2016, by Marlon James; Isaac, 2014, by Michael Chambers.

to address the realities of Jamaica, Barrett is now focusing more on education and is teaching at Edna Manley College of Visual and Performing Arts, where she is re-designing curricula in partnership with 83 the school. “Some of the courses I’m working on deal with cultural strategy and positioning so that students get a better understanding of the varied scope of the contemporary art world,” she explains. While there is clearly work ahead for the Jamaican art scene, explicit support from the government is a positive sign that progress is possible. Senator Hon. Thomas Tavares-Finson, the chairman of the board of the ngj, is proposing legislative changes in order to ease the import and sale of art in Jamaica. “We recognize that for the contemporary art scene to truly flourish, changes need to be made in context to current customs and consumption tax,” he says. “We need to create a bonded warehouse model for exhibitions such as the biennial, and to widen that remit to contemporary art scene.” Committed to widening the scope of art commercial galleries who also want to bring in artwork for exhibitions discourse and practices in Jamaica, the residency is open to both and local sale so they are able to do so without costs that negate any kind international and Jamaican artists and writers. Acknowledging the of profit for the artist or the gallery.” Senator Tavares-Finson also points importance of developing a market for artists, Anzinger says, “We out that “the government of Jamaica has a strong history in supporting wanted to come up with a program that didn’t rely on the art market, but the development of the visual and performing arts locally.” rather could determine an art market. We’ve now found that a lot of the “We founded and fund the Edna Manley College,” he says, which is people who started following the artists we work with eventually end up “the only tertiary art institution in the English-speaking Caribbean. And collecting these artists. We want to facilitate an understanding of the we initiated and fund the National Gallery of Jamaica.” artistic process and develop that relationship before it becomes a Writing in the biennial’s exhibition catalogue, Fredericks notes that commercial relationship.” “public and private funding is still virtually non-existent, the Returning to Jamaica after living in New York and London, art conventional commercial gallery model is unsustainable, media advisor Rachael Barrett was planning to open an exhibition venue called engagement is minimal, art writers are moving away from critical _space in Kingston in 2016. After working for more than a year on a Jean- thought, and a new generation of collectors is hiding somewhere! And Michel Basquiat show, Barrett had to call off the exhibition because of yet,” she continues, “there is an increasing vibrancy to the contemporary complications with the building. Realizing she needed to adapt her plan art scene.” FROM LEFT: MARLON JAMES; MICHAEL CHAMBERS JAMES; MARLON FROM LEFT:

BLOUINARTINFO.COM | MAY 2017 ART+AUCTION 84 Boxer left Jamaica in the 1960s. 1960s. the in Jamaica left Boxer Cornell, at medicine study to Jamaican Intuitives. the as known championing—are his who—through artists by made of it much of art, atrove amid ( of Jamaica Gallery National of the director a long-term ondissertation Francis Bacon and a write to person first The A Jamaican National Treasure David role and them his Boxer the Intuitive recognizing artists in discusses ngj After receiving a scholarship a scholarship receiving After ), Boxer lives in Kingston Kingston in lives ), Boxer Art+Auction with Intuitives the and art on Jamaican reflects Boxer Here, before. year the establish helped the run to art,” of Jamaican “mother the Manley, Edna by 1975, invited he was in Jamaica to he returned When and photography.installations, paintings, drawings, assemblages, own his making began and history art discovered soon He ’s Roffino. Sara ngj , which she, which

was to work on the collection. The The collection. towas work onthe goal my so main uneven, very and small very was of Jamaica Institute the from Iinherited collection The curator. only the was I and curator— the and director the over took both as and founded was Gallery National the after year one back Icame Jamaica. of Institute at the Intuitives the now to show called are what used they to Jamaica back Icame When ART+AUCTION had no training, but were trying to but were trying no training, had who painters were Sunday artists self-taught the Mostly Intuitives. of the afew included which artists, for one self-taught and artists professional called they for what exhibitions—one to have two used of Jamaica Institute work. The of Jamaican her beginning the Beadseller Manley’s Edna , in did purchase, was I thing first very MAY2017 , from 1924, which was 1924, was , from which

| BLOUINARTINFO.COM “Woody” Joseph David Boxer David with works by Boxer, Boxer, by works with carvings by by carvings Milton George The The Edna Manley Winston Patrick The interior of ’s home, home, ’s William , and , and and , and and .

THE ONYX COLLECTION SARA ROFFINO including these artists in the National National the in artists these including started Ihad that fact the and exhibition Eye” “Intuitive the but it both was it, accepted of finally sort They eye. but you have atrained directions, certain you in steer that intuitions You eye. you haveeye, atrained may have you don’t sayI would to them, intuitive have an who say, would too.”were people “I’m intuitive Eye.” Intuitive There “The exhibition, the with of Kapo’s existence. work in collection largest the to buy him persuaded I office in was he when and artist important an as Kapo recognize people to first of one was the Seaga, Edward minister, prime The former figure. known a already was he so arevivalist, and preacher a as known was Kapo else. everybody call onto of but settled that’s we’ve what sort term, aproblematic is that artists—even mainstream were exhibition of the two-thirds actually when exhibition, Intuitive an put together I’d said sculpture—they and painting for both maximum the Igave him because exhibition, the works in eight had Kapo like somebody that upset four. was People were very sculptor or painter of works per number maximum The respect. same the with all them treated and together artists the We all carefully. placed 1922 to 1982,” Iworked it and out very Art, it “Jamaican Icalled States. United the to travel in Smithsonian for the exhibition an to curate invited Iwas that after Shortly artists. academic the from especially resistance, alot of also was but there were amazed, Alot of people exhibition. a ground-breaking catalogue. for the text major the written I’ve and Miami in Museum work Pérez ashow at of the his having they’re work Now, was. of his majority the where know to even seemed nobody fact, In known. work not was well but his artists, greatest of our 1975. in retrospective Ifelt one was he Dunkley together. Ishowed everyone and artists of self-taught idea now, the Iabolished onright going is that biennial of the forerunner the is which Exhibition, National the Istarted When fashion. academic an in paint BLOUINARTINFO.COM I chose the word “Intuitive” in combination combination in word “Intuitive” the I chose Eye,” was 1979 which “Intuitive In the Idid aJohn was shows Idid earliest of the One |

MAY 2017 ART+AUCTION always used to sign his works with “J.” works with his Isaid, to sign used always but you Ican’t know write.” He catalogue, his to sign me wants “A Germany from man said, He to me. to talk needed he said over and Woody came and Joseph there lot of foreigners Eye,” were a there “Intuitive of the opening the we had when ago. Iremember years afew died Joseph’s who work. He’s sculptors of one the Exhibition. National the and Gallery National the through developed Intuitives of the afew Quite disregarded. notwould be up, they turned one anew about if so were all Intuitives the what who understood people two were there least at five ofjudges the that sure to prominence. them brought that Exhibition one of his children to write it on the sculpture sculpture it onthe to write children ofone his get always would He J. the howknow to carve didn’t either. howdidn’t He know to do that “that’s okay, J.” your put down go and he But Boxer’s Kingston helped found the her in 1995.She Jamaican art,” Edna Manley the “mother of member of the was named for for named was home. Manley, school, which I was just looking at William “Woody” at William looking just I was made Ialways Exhibition National For the the library at at library the ngj Forerunner national art committee was also a also was set within within set founding , in 1974., in 1941, by by 1941, is is ,

uptown, and browsed through one of the books books of one the through browsed and uptown, bookstore biggest the is which bookstore, have gone must he to Sangster’s because Woody Joseph’s way work was it the looked did reason the that and about intuition nonsense it was that said basically he and sculptures, of his nature African the Woody and Joseph about we were talking once and Intuitives the disliked He onhim. abook writing supposedly was he because artists top academic of the the other arguments. arguments. other the of many as ludicrous as was That bookstore? to a aJgoing who can’t write even man a that, you imagine Now can art. on African Gleaner for the critic the with at war constantly generally. intuition or an intuitive, the and unconscious collective the between connection signature. it out chip would he for his then and When I did the “Intuitive Eye,” Iwas “Intuitive the Idid When a is there that is of my theories One , who was actually on the payroll of one payroll onthe , who actually was 85 86 World” [co-organized by El Museo Museo by El World” [co-organized the of Crossroads “Caribbean: exhibition the in Dunkley the sawwork of John I first exhibition come together? this did how and Dunkley about learn you did How beyond. and Jamaica howdiscuss exhibitionthe to themesthe of came be, artist’s the work, role and his in Art outside solo of and first the Jamaica, exhibition his of works take to placein more than 40 years. curatorial advisor, 14, exhibition—onJanuary the view through 2018—is Dunkley’s show first NawiDiana along independent with curator Nicole Smythe-Johnson, David with Boxer as serving ( opens at Museum Pérezthe Miami artist, Art “John Neither Dunkley: Day nor Night,”international first the exhibition theof greatlate, Jamaican Jamaica’s John Dunkley in Miami + Auction ’s Roffino Sara checkedwith in Nawiin advance theof opening to subsequent trips to Kingston, his his to Kingston, trips subsequent work Dunkley’s by captivated was and Miami in presentation our organize I helped to traveled which 2012], in Museum Studio the and Museum, Queens the Barrio, del Spider’s Web pamm in 2014. in pamm . On . On

) on May 26. Curated by holdings of the National Gallery, Gallery, National of the holdings exceptional the particularly work, art history. its and region to the commitment of embodiment excellent an seemed and interest, out of that show grew The me. struck really pamm pamm ’s ’s ART+AUCTION works, namely homestead, the of anumber to in returned he that images of landscape types afew are landscapes and within that there work is his in theme dominant 1930sthe ’40s. and most The in produced was exists work that only the country, outwas of the he work while producing have been 1947. in died and might he while So abroad for 1931, work in traveling after to Jamaica returned Dunkley the work from this period? in themes dominant the of some are ’40s, what and ’30s and the from works select you did Why ’s ’s

MAY2017

| BLOUINARTINFO.COM

FROM LEFT: RANDALL RICHARDS AND ONYX FOUNDATION; KEN DUNKLEY FROM LEFT: RANDALL RICHARDS AND THE WALLACE CAMPBELL COLLECTION; RANDALL RICHARDS AND ONYX FOUNDATION BLOUINARTINFO.COM but an was self-taught was Dunkley time? same at the working regional and global artists to relation in contextualized be work his can How assembling production. his in possible as comprehensive to as be we wanted so 1976, since together shown been works haven’t The possible. work as of much his as together to bring show attempts This oeuvre? his of rest the to relate works these do How animals. and figures recurrent as well as vegetation, and flora for depicting vocabulary visual adistinct approach and compositional particular have avery paintings of his Most of of flowers. avase still-life one and recreation, and life everyday of scenes some Bustamante, politicians, Roosevelt and works featuring two also are There or roads. paths receding and ravines, scenes, pastoral Images from opposite left : left Feeding the Fishes, mahogany; Player media on plywood. on media paintings in mixed ca. 1940; 1940; ca. undated; John Dunkley Flowers , ca. 1941. All All 1941. , ca. undated, in Acrobat, Vase of of Vase Tennis Tennis , also | ’s ’s

MAY 2017

ART+AUCTION

how Dunkley’s biography biography Dunkley’s how It’s to say for certain not possible work? his in evident abroad from influences there particular techniques or Are practice? his affect Jamaica of outside life his did How ways. many in insider an much very was he “outsider” artist, an as of Dunkley to think tempting it’s while So culture. “Jamaican” establishing a distinctly of project the in engaged very was which and Jamaica colonial then was what in institution ( of Jamaica Institute the who were involved with historians, curators, and politicians of artists, of acircle part was He history. art Westand African importantly, European, Chinese, and Kingston, in peers his press, international and local the from imagery popular by influenced to be seems palette, and style particular avery with executed and imaginative very while work, his and culture of visual avid consumer ioj ), a cultural ), acultural interesting to think how that may may how that to think interesting it’s so photographs, coloring or retouching possibly point, some at Rica Costa in photographer worked he for a that believed it is For instance, connections. and perspectives new him have offered would travels his to in exposed was and encountered Dunkley what that believe generally, we also More places. of those memories his to or traveled he places depicting is Scenery Cuban Scenery as such ontitles based assume, but we made, he what influenced , that in some instances he he instances some in , that and and Panama and, significantly, elsewhere. elsewhere. significantly, and, Jamaica in both shaped have been would sensibility and life way his the discusses she influences, direct down doesn’t she pin abroad. While to work traveled who likewise figure Jamaican acontemporary is Garvey Marcus subject.” “diasporic a as peers side his along moment this in Dunkley show contextualizing of the catalogue the in published is that text awonderful has writer, sepia or black-and-white palette. almost sometimes his especially his work, have influenced Olive Senior, a historian and and ahistorian Senior, Olive 87