Draft of October 21, 2016 Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 5/2/11 TOP ARGELANDER STARS: PEDAGOGY & PRIZE S. R. Kulkarni Draft of October 21, 2016 ABSTRACT Stellar astronomy, fueled by massive capital investments, advances in numerical modeling and theory, is resurgent and arguably is on the verge of a magnificent renaissance. Powerful time domain optical surveys, both on ground and in space, are producing data on variable stars on an unprecedented industrial scale. Those with deep knowledge of variable stars will stand to benefit from this resurgence. Notwithstanding these developments, in some astronomical communities, classical stellar astronomy has been in the doldrums. I offer a modest proposal to establish a basic level of familiarity with variable stellar phenomenology and an attractive scheme to make research in variable star astronomy visible, alluring and fashionable. 1. A RESURGENCE IN STELLAR ASTRONOMY modelers to compare theory to observations at the few Stellar astronomy is now on the rise. Kepler with its percent (or even lower) level. exquisite photometric precision has revolutionized the The future landscape in stellar astronomy is extremely field of extra-solar planets and additionally has kick- promising. I justify this statement with just three exam- started the rich field of astero-seismology. The Gaia mis- ples. First is the implication to stellar astronomy arising sion is poised to initiate a revolution in astrometry on a from the recent findings by LIGO (Abbott et al. 2016) { scale that astronomers have not seen for nearly a century. not only are stellar black hole binaries abundant but the This grand expectation is grounded in the large number masses of the black holes was surprisingly higher than ex- of stars for which precision astrometric measurements pected. These two findings are motivating astronomers will be obtained by Gaia. Pan-STARSS has laid down a to explore entirely new paths of stellar evolution in which deep multi-band photometric grid over three quarters of not only low metal abundance but rapid rotation is ex- the sky. Next year, the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) pected to strongly influence the evolution of stars. Sec- will begin a 3-year survey of the Northern sky, sharply fo- ond, several findings over the last few years, from time cused on the dynamic optical sky (that is, variable stars, domain surveys { wild diversity in pre-supernova mass transients and moving objects). In 2018 the TESS mis- loss, new types of super-luminous supernova { clearly sion is expected to start routine observations. TESS will show that massive stars have multifarious evolutionary focus on precision photometry of stars brighter than 12 paths and multifaceted deaths. These advances are still mag. However, full frame images will allow observations being digested. It is now clear that future textbooks on of fainter stars over substantial areas of the sky. stellar astronomy will have not one but several chapters One should not discount smaller and nimble invest- on the evolution and endings of massive stars. Finally, ments such as ASAS, ASAS-SN and Evryscope. Many it is becoming clear that massive stars in binary systems such projects are trail blazers. Finally, it is both grat- may play a major role in the ionization history of the ifying and astonishing, despite the massive capital in- early Universe (z ∼ 6; Ma et al. 2015). vestment by professional astronomers, that amateur as- 2. F. W. ARGELANDER tronomers continue to make serious contributions to stel- lar and supernova research. With the modern background laid out I now arrive at While above we have focused on astrometry and pho- the primary goal of this writeup { the anticipated resur- tometry there has been good progress in spectroscopic gence of variable star astronomy. It is by now well known 1 surveys (e.g. RAVE and the ultra-low resolution spec- that forecasting the future is difficult . Furthermore, it is 2 troscopy of Gaia). There is now a (timely) movement almost always wrong. However, it is said that a knowl- edge of the past helps understand the future better. In arXiv:1610.06285v1 [astro-ph.SR] 20 Oct 2016 to repurpose the massively-multiplexed spectrographs of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) for stellar astron- that spirit our journey begins with Friedrich Wilhelm omy. Argelander (1799{1875) who is considered as the found- As can be deduced from the above summary the capi- ing astronomer of the modern era of variable stars. tal investment in stellar astronomy has been substantial. Argelander was born in what is now Lithuania. He un- However, stellar astronomy is a fairly mature field. Thus dertook his PhD under the famous German astronomer merely obtaining large volumes of superior data without Friedrich Bessel at the University of K¨onigsberg located 3 corresponding superior theoretical framework will not re- in what is now called Kalingrad. Following his PhD, in sult in realization of the full gains of the capital invest- 1823, he moved to the Turku Observatory. In 1832 he ments. Fortunately, there has been good progress on 1http://www.famous-quotes-and-quotations.com/ the theoretical and modeling fronts. Nowadays, on a yogi-berra-quotes.html routine basis, astronomers undertake multi-dimensional, 2http://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/ if not three-dimensional, modeling of stars and related why-experts-are-almost-always-wrong-9997024/?no-ist phenomena. Tools such as MESA allow observers and 3The modern name for this University is Immanuel Kant Baltic Federal University. 2 S. R. Kulkarni moved to Helsinki where he supervised the construction definite theory be given, which can refer the of the then new Helsinki observatory. His primary ac- light changes to any one cause. But happily, complishment, up until this point, was the investigation hypotheses, even if full of error, fail us not. of the Sun's motion with respect to other stars. In 1837 Omitting those which at first glance are seen he moved to Germany and took up the Directorship of to be untenable, they resolve themselves into the Observatory of the University of Bonn (which was, at the following three. the time, one of the best funded observatories). It was in Bonn, in 1844, he began studies of variable stars. Sep- 1. Revolution of the stars on their axes, their arately, since 1826, he was a corresponding member of surfaces being of different luminosity on the the St. Petersburg Academy of Sciences. Clearly, Arge- different sides, whereby they would be brighter lander was not only energetic but also a pan-European if they turned towards us the side of greatest astronomer. illumination, or conversely, darker if the side Argelander was an expert in astrometry and photom- of less illumination. etry. Along with his students and colleagues he was re- 2. Revolution on their axes, with strongly com- sponsible for the famous star catalog, Bonner Durch- 4 pressed figure, and considerable variation of musterung (BD). This catalog, consisting of 324,188 angle of the axis of rotation towards the line of stars with magnitude brighter than about nine, had 0 sight. If the axis nearly coincides with the line an astrometric precision was 0:1 in declination and of sight, then the star turns towards us a very 0.1 second in Right Ascension (RA). It was the first com- extensive surface, sends us much more light, prehensive astrometric and photometric catalog of the and therefore shines brighter than if they, be- Northern sky. The catalog, for its time, was considered cause of a very large angle, turn their edge, if to have superior photometry. I may so call it. The BD catalog laid the standard for future photo- metric and astrometric star catalogs.5 The BD catalog 3. Huge planets revolving around the stars, in the was re-issued in 1950! Many BD stars serve as absolute plane of whose orbits the line of sight nearly photometric standards for ground- and space-based tele- falls and which, therefore, by inferior conjunc- scopes (e.g. BD +28◦ 4211, BD +17◦ 4708). Separately, tion with the star, cut off a large part of the Argelander founded the Astronomische Gesellschaft (As- light formerly coming from it to us, so that it tronomical Society), which in collaboration with many seems less bright. observatories expanded his work to produce the AG cat- alogs.6 The first of these hypotheses seems to be the most plausible and, in general, to explain ob- 2.1. Variable Stars & Argelander served appearances of several of the stars, if A small note in Popular Astronomy by Annie J. Can- we assume that the constitution of these stars non of the Harvard College Observatory (Argelander & is similar to that of our Sun. Cannon 1912) written in 1911 is an excellent gateway to Argelander's suggested phenomena can be summarized appreciate the role played by Argelander in the devel- 7 opment of variable star astronomy. In that note Cannon as: (1) rotational modulation of star spots , (2) pre- refers to a chapter on variable stars, entitled An appeal to cession of a rapidly rotating ellipsoidal star, and (3) transits of extrasolar planets. Although none of Arge- the friends of Astronomy, written by Argelander for the 8 1844 edition of Schumacher's Astronomical Year book. lander's eighteen original variables fit his hypotheses , Argelander exhorts fellow astronomers to undertake ob- star spots and transiting extrasolar planets are today servations of variable stars and catalog the photometry. commonly observed phenomena. Doubtless, Argelander Cannon notes \After reading the article, one feels like stood on the shoulders of giants; observations of tran- reviewing the advances in our knowledge of the variable sits within our solar system date back to at least 1631, stars since 1844.