View metadata,citationandsimilarpapersatcore.ac.uk N19T–glxe:idvda:NC42 itnescale distance – 4527 NGC individual: galaxies: – 1991T SN words: Key galaxies. host early-type and a in late-type luminosities support Ia not SNe do corrected between data difference present significant the particular, In 1997cn. SN 1991bg and degree SN high like events a underluminous shows including uniformity, colour, of and bright- decline-rate their different, for quite corrected ness, are supernovae Ia among nitudes mag- absolute nitudes. the of uncertainty significant in results un- certainty reddening as the 1991T However, SN explosion. interpreting super-Chandrasekhar a for motivation the removes characteristics also light-curve and similar having supernovae with Ia discrepancy other the removes largely distance short relatively ooosml Hmye l,19)adteHradsample after supernovae, Harvard Ia most the that demonstrated and cor- 1999) 1996) al., to et al., (Riess has et one Cal´ (Hamuy The which 1999). sample for Richtler, Tololo and maximum, Drenkhahn at 1998; rate, (Tripp, colour rect decline the the also Besides is 1993). it (Phillips, such decline-rate parameters the light-curve as on lumi- dependence their their particular and under- in nosities supernovae, the low-redshift is of models standing cosmological constraining for redshifts su the for precondition A Introduction 1. is 1991T SN to thus and mod- 4527 distance NGC The to supernovae. ulus other to respect overlu- with apparent minosity its and behaviour spectroscopic its the on of both grounds “peculiar” labelled been has fluctu- supernova brightness surface This by ations. measured 1991T, SN Ia type the of Abstract. 4 ¿ ¾ Richtler T. and Ia decline-rate supernovae of of uniformity magnitudes absolute the corrected and colour 1991T SN of brightness The eevd../Acpe ... Accepted / ... Received cp,otie tteSaeTlsoeSineIsiue hc sop- 5-26555. is NAS which contract NASA Institute, under Inc., Science AURA, Telescope by erated Space the at obtained scope, arXiv:astro-ph/0011440 23 Nov 2000 ?? 3(81.4 81. N19T 10. G 57 12.04.3) 4527; NGC 11.09.1 1991T; SN 08.19.5 (08.19.04; 03 are: codes thesaurus Your later) hand by inserted be (will no. manuscript A&A ? a-lnkIsiu f¨ Max-Planck-Institut Astr for Institute A` N. 670 Observatory, Gemini Concepci´ de Universidad eso ute ht lhuhteitiscaslt mag- absolute intrinsic the although that, further show We eiiSineFellow Science Gemini Tele- Space Hubble NASA/ESA the with observations on Based epeetadsac oNC42,tehs galaxy host the 4527, NGC to distance a present We ½ ,J.B.Jensen uenve eea uenve individual: supernovae: – general supernovae: nm,Uiest fHwi 60Wolw rv,Hnll,H 96822 HI Honolulu, Drive, Woodlawn 2680 Hawaii of University onomy, rAtohsk otah11,871Grhn e M¨ bei Garching 85741 1317, Postfach Astrophysik, ur ?? n eatmnod F´ de Departamento on, csflueo asproa thigh at supernovae Ia of use ccessful ¾ ,J.Tonry hk lc io I970 ([email protected]) 96720, HI Hilo, Place ohoku ¼9 : ¼ ¦ ¿ .Barris B. , ¾6 : ¿¼ sc,Casilla ısica, ¿ n .Drenkhahn G. and , .This 6-,Concepci´ 160-C, an- ihddsac,bsdo h Lrlto o ehisobserved Cepheids estab- for well PL-relation less the or on more based a distance, lished has 1981B, SN of host the 4536, NGC and 4527 NGC of distances the about known is What 1.1. Ia respective the of luminosities the and SNe. a group known galaxy is this what briefly of recall we result, its and literature. the more is which 4527, NGC bulge the of in fluctuations brightness surface on based 1991T, SN 1981B). (SN SNe, 4536 NGC Ia and for neigh- 1960F), hosts (SN two been 4496 of NGC have distance also which the galaxies, to spiral equal (1999) boring be al. to et distance Fisher occur. its can assumed deviations large that known is where it distance, Tully-Fisher individual a no is besides there determination cluster, Virgo distance the of side near the on cated dwarfs. white two of super-Chandrasekhar merging the a following was explosion 1991T SN Their of- that features. also suggested spectral abnormal analysis and these 1991T of SN interpretation an about fer knowledge present the (1999) discuss al. et Fisher peculiarities. luminosity, spectroscopic exhibited high also allegedly it its Besides 4527. NGC in 1991T SN 1999). Richtler, and (Drenkhahn con- SNe type-Ia is other shorter luminosity with its a sistent thus at that and assumed, shown place initially be took than could distance event it example, Ia 4526, overluminous NGC For in apparently parameter. 1994D this key SN the of case is the galaxy in host the the to Obviously, interest. distance particular over- of apparently are the supernovae present, luminous probably are distribution lumi- supernovae nosity the of redshifts, end high bright at the towards Since effects dim. selection too or bright too either are they that of brightness. degree maximum their high in surprisingly uniformity a exhibit corrections, appropriate eoew rsn u ehdo itnedetermination distance of method our present we Before to distance individual an present to is paper our of aim The lo- is 4527 NGC that agreement general is there Although is overluminosity of example extreme more Another sense the in deviate to seem however, supernovae, few A G 4536? NGC nhn emn ([email protected]) Germany unchen, n hl,([email protected]) Chile, on, 4 cuaeta hti vial in available is what than accurate ASTROPHYSICS ASTRONOMY ? AND provided byCERNDocumentServer ottedistance the bout brought toyouby CORE ½ 2 T. Richtler et al.: The brightness of SN1991T by HST (Saha et al., 1996a; Saha et al., 1996b). However, the Table 2 lists the photometric parameters for our SNe taken Cepheid data are to a minor degree subject to interpretational from Hamuy et al. (1996). The reddening values and their un- manipulation, depending on details of the data reduction and certainties are those quoted by Fisher et al. (1999). also of the selection of Cepheids used for the distance determi- Using the correction terms for colour and decline-rate, and

nation. Saha et al. (1996b), for instance, quote a distance modu- the Cepheid distance modulus for NGC 4536, one arrives at the

:¼7

lus to NGC 4536 of ¿½ mag, while Gibson et al. (2000) give corrected absolute maximum magnitudes given in Table 3.

:95 ¦ ¼:¾¿ ¿¼ mag. The Cal´an-Tololo and the Harvard sample demonstrated Tully-Fisher (TF) distances have been measured both for that there is no observable offset between the corrected abso- NGC 4527 and for NGC 4536. If we use the new TF calibra- lute magnitudes of SNe Ia in early-type and late-type galaxies. tions given by Sakai et al. (2000) and the TF data given by Within the uncertainty limits, SN 1981B matches the SNe Ia

Pierce (1994), we then get distance moduli (averaged over B , in the Fornax cluster and also to some of the Ia’s in other spi-

Á ¿¼:78 ¿¼:8¼

Ê, )of and for NGC 4527 and NGC 4536, re- ral galaxies, although uncertain photometry and uncertain ex-

:6 ¿¼:5 spectively. Pierce (1994) himself quotes ¿¼ and , respec- tinction make the comparison more difficult (Drenkhahn and

tively. The differences are consistent with the dispersion of the Richtler, 1999). However, the brightness of SN 1991T is in-

:¿ ¼:4 TF relation which is about ¼ – mag. In this sense, the TF consistent with that of SN 1981B or other supernovae, if the data are in agreement with the Cepheid distance of NGC 4536. Cepheid distance of NGC 4536 is also adopted for NGC 4527. Moreover, the TF distances cannot support any distance dif- Table 3 demonstrates that this discrepancy is not very depen-

ference between NGC 4527 and NGC 4536 and it appears rea- dent on the adopted reddening, although the error bars overlap,

:95 ¦ ¼:¾¿ sonable to assume a distance modulus of ¿¼ mag for almost exclusively as a result of the reddening uncertainty (see NGC 4527 as well. Fisher et al. (1999) for a compilation of the relevant literature).

2. Revised relations between SN Ia maximum brightness, 3. The distance to NGC 4527 from surface brightness decline rate and colour fluctuations It is now clear that the intrinsic maximum brightness of SNe Ia We measured a new and accurate distance to NGC 4527 using vary by approximately 1 mag. Using both the “Cal´an-Tololo” the near-IR surface brightness fluctuation technique. Two 128- sample (Hamuy et al., 1996) and the Harvard sample (Riess second images of NGC 4527 taken with NICMOS on the Hub- et al., 1999), we below present handy relations between maxi- ble Space Telescope were recovered from the archive. These

mum brightness (extinction corrected), decline rate and colour images were taken using the NIC2 camera using the F160W

¼¼

Î Á

for the B , ,and bands. We define the colour as the dif-

: ½¿

filter, and have a spatial resolution of ¼ FWHM. The ex-

B Î ÑaÜ

ference between the ÑaÜ and maximum magnitudes, cellent resolution and very low background (approximately

¼¼

B Î B Ø which is not necessarily the colour at, say, the - 18.9 mag/ Ù at F160W) make detection of surface brightness maximum. These relations are revised versions of those given fluctuations straight-forward in the bulge of NGC 4527. in Drenkhahn & Richtler (1999), which only included the The calibration and techniques for determining IR SBF dis- Cal´an-Tololo sample. A similar analysis, based on the Cal´an- tances using NIC2 in the F160W bandpass were developed by Tololo sample alone, has been done by Tripp & Branch (1999). Jensen et al. (2000). This calibration relies on direct measure- A colour dependence is definitively present, but it is difficult ments of SBFs, both in the I and F160W bands, to nearby in the individual case to distinguish between an intrinsic red spirals with well-determined Cepheid distances (Tonry et al., colour and reddening. We also point out that only the galactic 2000; Jensen et al., 2000). The absolute fluctuation magni-

foreground reddening can be accounted for, because internal 

= 4:86 ¦ ¼:¼5 tude calibration Å (statistical uncertainty reddenings are not available. However, if reddening dominated only) presented by Jensen et al. (2000) is essentially constant

the colour dependence of SN luminosities, we would expect

Î Á µ=½:½6

with galaxy colour redward of ´ . NGC 4527 Î

distinctly larger colour coefficients in B and .

Î Á µ=½:¾¿ ¦ ¼:¼¿

has a colour of ´ (J. Tonry and the op- ¾ The coefficients in Table 1 result from a -fit to the data of tical SBF team, private communication) in the region of the

41(24inthe Á band) SN Ia from Hamuy et al. (1996) and Riess galaxy where the SBF analysis was performed. We adopted the

et al. (1999). The listed values are the best fits to the relation Galactic extinction for NGC 4527 from Schlegel, Finkbeiner,

A =¼:¼95

& Davis (1998) B mag, implying a correction of

Ñ · b ¡ ´¡Ñ ¡Ñ µ

½5 ½5

ÑaÜ only 0.01 mag at F160W. Jensen et al.’s calibration also showed

·Ê ¡ ´B Î ´ B Î µµ

ÑaÜ ÑaÜ ÑaÜ

ÑaÜ (1)

excellent agreement between giant ellipticals and the bulges of

¡ ÐÓg cÞ · Z

=5 spiral galaxies, thereby confirming that the calibration applies Ñ

with ÑaÜ being the foreground extinction corrected magni- equally well to the old, smoothly-distributed stellar populations

Î Á b Ê tudes in B , and , the decline-rate coefficient, the colour in the centers of spirals as to the giant elliptical galaxies tradi-

coefficient, and Z the zero-point of the Hubble diagram defined tionally targeted for SBF studies. by the merging of both SNe samples. For the determination of The methods for measuring SBFs are described in several the foreground extinction we used the dust maps of Schlegel papers (see Blakeslee et al. (1999) for a review); the infrared et al. (1998). techniques used here are are described by Jensen, Tonry, & T. Richtler et al.: The brightness of SN1991T 3

Table 1. The table lists the coefficients according to our correction formula (1) for the relation between brightness, decline rate,

and colour.

Z b Ê ¡Ñ B Î

ÑaÜ ÑaÜ

Band ½5

B ¿:¿45 ¦ ¼:¼5½ ¼:6½ ¦ ¼:¾½ ¾:5¿ ¦ ¼:6¾ ½:¾¿7 ¼:¼

Î ¿:¿56 ¦ ¼:¼4½ ¼:66 ¦ ¼:½8 ½:6¾ ¦ ¼:5¿ ½:¾¿7 ¼:¼

Á ¿:½½8 ¦ ¼:¼5¼ ¼:¿5 ¦ ¼:½9 ½:½¾ ¦ ¼:58 ½:¾¿¼ ¼:¼½7

Table 2. This table lists the photometric parameters for SN 1991T and SN 1981B SNe according to Hamuy et al. (1996). The

Î Á B , , magnitudes are not extinction corrected. The reddening values and their uncertainties are those quoted by Fisher et al.

(1999) and the uncertainty of the reddening of SN 1991T reflects the variety of literature values.

B Î Á E ´B Î µ ¡Ñ

ÑaÜ ÑaÜ ½5

Host Galaxy SN ÑaÜ

:69 ¦ ¼:¼¿ ½½:5½ ¦ ¼:¼¿ ½½:6¾ ¦ ¼:¼¿ ¼:¾¼ ¦ ¼:½¼ ¼:94 ¦ ¼:¼5

NGC 4527 1991T ½½

:¼¿ ¦ ¼:¼¿ ½½:9¿ ¦ ¼:¼¿ ¼:½¼ ¦ ¼:¼5 ½:½¼ ¦ ¼:¼5 NGC 4536 1981B ½¾ —

Table 3. This table lists the corrected absolute maximum magnitudes of the SNe according to (1) and a distance modulus of

:95

¿¼ , corresponding to the Cepheid distance of NGC 4536. The photometric parameters are taken from Table 2 and are extinction

A =E ´B Î µ=4:½ A =E ´B Î µ= ¿:½ A =E ´B Î µ=½:5

Î Á

corrected with B , and (Rieke and Lebofsky, 1985). To illustrate

´B Î µ=¼:½¿ the effect of a different reddening, we also give for SN 1991T the values for a reddening of E which has been

advocated by Phillips et al. (1992).

 Å Å Å

ÑaÜ Î;ÑaÜ Á;ÑaÜ

Host Galaxy SN B;

´B Î µ=¼:¾¼ ¿¼:95 ¦ ¼:¼9 ½9:87 ¦ ¼:5½ ½9:85 ¦ ¼:¿8 ½9:64 ¦ ¼:½7

NGC 4527 1991T (E )

´B Î µ=¼:½¿ ¿¼:95 ¦ ¼:¼9 ½9:75 ¦ ¼:¾8 ½9:74 ¦ ¼:¾½ ½9:5¿ ¦ ¼:½½

NGC 4527 1991T (E )

:95 ¦ ¼:¾¿ ½9:¾6 ¦ ¼:¾6 ½9:¾5 ¦ ¼:¾¼ NGC 4536 1981B ¿¼ —

Luppino (1998) and Jensen et al. (2000). Basically, the dis- The spatial power spectrum was constructed and fitted to crete nature of stars in galaxies leads to variations in the num- a linear combination of the scaled PSF power spectrum and ber of stars imaged by each pixel in the detector because of a constant, white-noise background. The two components are Poisson fluctuations. The fluctuations in surface brightness are plotted using dashed lines in Fig. 2, and the solid line is distance-dependent: distant galaxies look smooth compared to their sum. The “fluctuation power” (in electrons/pixel) is the nearby ones because the number of luminous stars imaged scale factor by which the power spectrum of the normalized by each pixel is larger. The variations are convolved with the PSF must be multiplied to match the data over the range in

point-spread function (PSF) of the telescope, in this case the wavenumbers where the PSF is dominant. The fit shown in =4¼

diffraction pattern of HST as imaged by the NIC2 camera. In Fig. 2 was constructed for wavenumbers between k and

¼¼ ¼¼

: ¿¾ ¼: 96 practice we observe the variations in luminosity from pixel to 100, corresponding to spatial scales between ¼ and , pixel rather than variations in the number of stars, so surface where the PSF component dominates. Lower wavenumbers are brightness fluctuations are dominated by the brightest stars in not used because the power spectrum is contaminated by ex- the galaxy. Because the most luminous stars are red giants in tra power from large-scale residuals of the galaxy subtraction;

old populations, SBFs are approximately 30 times brighter at at wavenumbers higher than 100 the white-noise component

k =4¼ F160W than in the optical Á band. dominates. The fit between and 100 is excellent across the entire power spectrum, and yields a fluctuation power of

The initial image processing proceeded with the galaxy im-

:8 ¦ ¾:6 46 electrons/pixel in the 256 s exposure. The fluctua- ages being flattened and combined after a small bias correc- tion power is 15.6 times larger than the white-noise component tion was applied to remove mismatches between detector quad- (effectively the S/N ratio of the observation). rants. During each of the two exposures, the NIC2 array was read multiple times to allow for the temporal rejection of cos- Once the fluctuation power was determined, the appar- mic rays. Additional cosmic rays were corrected when combin- ent fluctuation magnitude was easily computed and the dis- ing the two images. The results are shown in the left panel of tance modulus determined using the Jensen et al. (2000) cal-

Fig. 1. The inner few arcsec of NGC 4527 are choked with dust ibration. The apparent fluctuation magnitude of NGC 4527 is

Ñ =¾5:4¼ ¦ ¼:¼7 lanes in the disk, and these were masked prior to proceeding  ,where the uncertainty is the statistical uncer- with the SBF analysis. Point sources were also identified and tainty arising from the power spectrum fit (0.054 mag), the un- masked. A smooth model of the galaxy luminosity profile was certainty in the PSF normalization (0.061 mag), and the uncer- then constructed and subtracted. An image of NGC 4527 with tainty in the sky background subtraction (0.028 mag), all added the galaxy subtracted, showing the stellar SBFs, is shown in the in quadrature. As the PSF and sky were not measured explic- right panel of Fig. 1. itly for the observations of NGC 4527, we used the best values 4 T. Richtler et al.: The brightness of SN1991T

Fig. 1. The NIC2 F160W image of NGC 4527 is shown using a square-root grayscale on the left. The same image with the smooth galaxy profile subtracted is shown on the right, using a linear stretch. Point sources apparent in the galaxy-subtracted

image were masked prior to measuring the spatial power spec-

¼¼

: ¾ trum. The field of view is ½9 across. Fig. 2. The azimuthally-averaged spatial power spectrum is

and uncertainties from the library of values collected by Jensen shown for the galaxy-subtracted image with point-sources re- 

et al. (2000). Subtracting the absolute fluctuation magnitude Å moved. The solid line is the sum of a white-noise (constant)

Ñ Å µ=¿¼:¾6 ¦ ¼:¼9

yields a distance modulus of ´ ,cor- component and the scaled PSF power spectrum (both shown

:¿ ¦ ¼:5¼ responding to a distance (good to 5%) of ½½ Mpc. with dashed lines). The scaling of the normalized PSF is the

NGC 4527 is significantly closer than the bulk of the Virgo =¼ power at k , and is the surface brightness fluctuations flux cluster. from which the fluctuation magnitude is computed. The IR SBF calibration presented by Jensen et al. (2000) is derived from Cepheid distances to a handful of nearby spirals (Ferrarese et al., 2000), and is hence subject to any systematic tances. We adopt them here since they are also the basis for the uncertainties that affect the Cepheid distance scale generally SFB calibration using Cepheids. To this list, we add SN 1991T. (such as the distance to the LMC or any period-luminosity de- The reddenings used for the extinction calculation are adopted pendence on metallicity, for example). The distance modulus from Phillips et al. (1999). With these data and the correction uncertainty for NGC 4527 quoted here does not include the ad- terms for decline rate and colour presented above, we obtain

ditional systematic uncertainty from the Cepheid distance (es- the corrected absolute magnitudes compiled in Table 4. The

:½6 timated to be ¼ mag) scale beyond that incurred by linking uncertainties in the table (in mag) result from a formal error IR SBFs to the Cepheid distances. propagation of the different parameters involved. The formally resulting Hubble constant values are also given as the mean of the individual Hubble constant values in the different filters. 4. The comparison with other SNe Ia Uncertainties in the distances do not necessarily dominate It is now interesting to compare SN 1991T with other Ia SNe the total uncertainties. Uncertain reddening values and hence in spiral and early-type galaxies, for which more or less accu- uncertain maximum colours make a significant contribution in rate distances are known from either Cepheids, from globular the case of reddened SNe. This is illustrated in the case of cluster luminosity functions, or from surface brightness fluctu- SN 1991T, where the two different reddening values from the ations. If we keep the coefficients for decline-rate and colour literature are adopted (see Table 3). Moreover, in some cases

correction fixed and distinguish between late-type and early- the adopted light curve parameters are more a matter of histori-

Î Á type host galaxies, the resulting zero-points are for B , , , cal reconstruction than of exact measurements. This is the case

respectively (the number of SNe involved are in parentheses): for SN 1937C, SN 1960F, and SN 1974G (see van den Bergh

¿:¿4 ¿:¿¾ ¿:¼4

(14), (14), (9) for early-type host galax- (1996) for the relevant literature).

¿:¾9 ¿:¿¿ ¿:½½ ies, and (29), (29), (16) for late-type host If we skip SN 1991T because of the large reddening uncer-

galaxies. It is apparent that there is no significant difference tainty, and SN 1937C, SN 1960F, and SN 1974G from the SNe

½9:½5 ¦ ¼:½5 ½9:½5 ¦ ¼:½¿

in the corrected absolute magnitudes between SNe Ia in early- with Cepheid distances, we get , ,

½8:9¿ ¦ ¼:½7 type and late-type hosts. We therefore expect the same for SNe mag as the weighted means (weight factors are

in galaxies whose distances are known. the inverse photometric uncertainties) of the absolute magni-

Î Á

tudes for B , ,and , respectively. The corresponding Hubble

:9 ¦ 4:7 69:¿ ¦ 4:½ 68:7 ¦ 4:½ constant values are 68 , , km/s/Mpc. 4.1. SNe in late-type galaxies

Including all SNe in Table 4, and adopting for SN 1991T

´B Î µ=¼:¾

Gibson et al. (2000) give a compilation of parameters for the 8 the higher reddening value of E mag, we get

½9:¾5 ¦ ¼:½¿ ½9:¾5 ¦ ¼:½½ ½8:9¿ ¦ ¼:½¿ SNe Ia in late-type galaxies, which have measured Cepheid dis- , , . The corre-

T. Richtler et al.: The brightness of SN1991T 5

:8 ¦ ¿:8 65:9 ¦ ¿:¿

sponding Hubble constant values are 65 , , SN 1991bg agree so well with those of the other SNe. This is

:7 ¦ 4:½ 68 km/s/Mpc. perhaps an indication that due to the small number of red SNe, We thus face the unsatisfactory situation that in spite of the the error of the colour correction is overestimated. huge effort which has gone into the determination of distances, the resulting Hubble constant is still influenced by the “free- dom” of selecting the “right” SNe. 5. Discussion The formal brightness differences between the SNe in Tabs. 4

4.2. SNe Ia in early-type galaxies

¼:¿¼ ¦ ¼:¾5 ¼:¾9 ¦ ¼:¾5 ¼:¿½ ¦ ¼:½7 B

and5are , , for ,

Á E ´B Î µ=¼:¾ SNe Ia in S0 or elliptical galaxies are less affected by extinc- Î , , respectively, if all SNe are taken ( in

tion. There exist some SNe with good photometry in nearby case of SN 1991T). If SN 1991T, SN 1960F, and SN 1974G are

¼:¾½ ¦ ¼:¾ ¼:½9 ¦ ¼:¾¾

early-type galaxies (Tab. 5). The Fornax cluster plays a par- skipped, the differences reduce to , ,

¼:¿ ¦ ¼:¾ ticularly important role by hosting three SNe Ia: SN 1981D and . Most SNe Ia in late-type galaxies probably and SN 1980N in NGC 1316, and SN 1992A in NGC 1380. have different progenitors from SNe Ia in early-type galaxies, Of these, the light curve of SN 1981D has a bad photometry as the distribution of decline-rates suggests: we find only fast and we skip it here. Then there is SN 1994D in NGC 4526 decliners in early-type galaxies, but the entire range of decline- (Drenkhahn & Richtler (1999)) and SN 1991bg in NGC 4374. rates in late-type galaxies (e.g. Richtler et al. (2000a)), which, The latter has a reputation as a strongly underluminous event. however, are dominated by slow-decliners. We adopt the light-curve parameters from the following Also Tripp & Branch (1999) got a marginally smaller Hub- sources: SN 1980N, SN 1991bg, and SN 1992A from Hamuy et ble constant if they select only spirals from the Cal´an-Tololo al. (1996), SN 1994D from Drenkhahn & Richtler (1999). The sample in combination with Cepheid calibrated host galaxies. distance of SN 1994D has been determined by the method of However, the corresponding brightness difference is within the globular cluster luminosity functions and we adopt it also from statistical uncertainty. Since the combined Cal´an-Tololo and

Harvard samples show that the decline-rate and colour correc-

:4 ¦ ¼:¿ Drenkhahn & Richtler (1999) (¿¼ ). Della Valle et al.

tions completely account for the intrinsicbrightness difference,

:¿ ¦ ¼:½6 (1998) applied this method to SN 1992A and got ¿½ , which is in very good agreement with the distance of For- we are apparently forced to draw the conclusion that any re- nax galaxies determined by surface brightness fluctuations maining difference after correction is due to a systematic dif- (Jensen et al. (1998)) and with two of the three late-type galax- ference in the distances to early- and late-type host galaxies. ies, for which Cepheid distances are available (Ferrarese et But even that is not entirely clear. The Fornax cluster distance is

al. (2000)). There exists no published individual distance yet dominant for the average Ia brightness in early-type host galax-

:6¼ for NGC 1316, but preliminary results from the analysis of ies. A distance modulus of the Fornax cluster of ¿½ mag,

its globular cluster system (G´omez et al., in preparation) in- as now advocated by Ferrarese et al. (2000), would brighten

:¾ dicates very good agreement with SN 1992A and we adopt the two Fornax Ia’s in Table 5 by about ¼ mag, which would

cause the brightness difference almost to vanish.

:¿5 ¦ ¼:¾5

¿¼ . For NGC 4374, we take the distance modulus

¿½:¿5

:¾ ¦ ¼:½

quoted by Ferrarese et al. (2000) (¿½ ), which is in very On the other hand, the case for mag as the Fornax

:½7 ¦ ¼:½ good agreement with the recent SFB modulus of (¿½ ) distance modulus is strong (Jensen et al. (1998), Richtler et by Neilsen & Tsvetanov (2000). al. (2000b)). Moreover, two of the three Fornax spirals with

The weighted average values (weight factors are the in- Cepheid distances from Ferrarese et al. are quoted with dis-

:4¿ ¦ ¼:¼7 ¿½:¿9 ¦ ¼:½¼

verse uncertainties) of the absolute, corrected magnitudes are tance moduli ¿½ and and thus agree

½8:96 ¦ ¼:½8 ½8:97 ¦ ¼:½6 ½8:66 ¦ ¼:½¼ B Î , , for , , very well with the distance based on surface brightness fluc-

Á , respectively. The corresponding Hubble constant values are tuations and globular cluster luminosity functions. The Hub-

:¿ ¦ 6:¾ 75:4 ¦ 5:4 78:½ ¦ ¿:8 75 , , km/s/Mpc. ble constant values from Tab.5 also fit well to the value of Besides SN 1991bg, another strongly underluminous event 77 km/s/Mpc, emerging from the SFB survey by Tonry et al. was SN 1997cn in the elliptical galaxy NGC 5490 (Turatto (2000). But since some of the supernovae with Cepheid dis- et al., 1998). No individual distance determination is known, tances still agree within the uncertainties, it would be prema- but the galaxy should be well in the Hubble-flow (heliocentric ture to claim a difference between SFB distances and Cepheid recession velocity 5008 km/s). Therefore, a consistency check distances.

is possible by assuming a Hubble constant of 70 km/s/Mpc and Based on the sample of spiral host galaxies, Tripp & Branch

Å = ½9:46

correspondingly a distance modulus of 34.2 mag. Given the (1999) derive B as the colour and decline-rate

light-curve data by Turatto et al. (1998) and assuming zero ex- corrected blue luminosity for SNe Ia. One notes, however, Î

tinction, we get for the corrected absolute magnitudes in B , , that the mean difference between their adopted distance mod-

½9:¼¾ ¦ ¼:57 ½9:½½ ¦ ¼:45 ½8:85 ¦ ¼:½½ ¼:¿

Á , , . Thus even uli plus apparent brightness and our values is already mag.

B Î =¼:65 ÑaÜ such a red SN like SN 1997cn with ÑaÜ is This demonstrates how uncertain the SN Ia brightness in spiral consistent with the other SNe. It is striking that in spite of the galaxies still is. A deeper discussion, particularly on the Hubble large errors, especially in B, caused by the large and uncertain constant and the zero-point uncertainties of the distance scale, colour corrections, the absolute magnitudes of SN 1997cn and is beyond the scope of our paper and we refer the reader to 6 T. Richtler et al.: The brightness of SN1991T

Table 4. This table lists the corrected absolute maximum magnitudes of 8 SNe Ia, whose distances have been measured by Cepheids, together with SN 1991T, for which now the new distance modulus of 30.26 has been used. The distances and light curve parameters are adopted from Gibson et al. (2000), the reddening values, except those for SN 1991T, are from Suntzeff et al. (1999). The uncertainties follow from an error propagation of the various parameters involved. Systematic distance scale uncertainties are not accounted for. The corresponding Hubble constants are the average values (not weighted) of the respective

band values.

Å Å Å À

ÑaÜ Î;ÑaÜ Á;ÑaÜ ¼

Host Galaxy (type) SN B;

´B Î µ=¼:¾¼ ½9:½8 ¦ ¼:5¾ ½9:½6 ¦ ¼:¿9 ½8:95 ¦ ¼:½8 68:6 ¦ ½½:6

NGC 4527 (Sab) 1991T (E )

´B Î µ=¼:½¿ ½9:¼6 ¦ ¼:¾9 ½9:¼5 ¦ ¼:¾¾ ½8:84 ¦ ¼:½8 7¾:¾ ¦ 7:¿

NGC 4527 (Sab) 1991T (E )

½9:¼9 ¦ ¼:¾8 ½9:¼9 ¦ ¼:¾7 ½8:86 ¦ ¼:¾5 7½:¿ ¦ 8:9

NGC 4639 (Sab) 1990N

½9:¾6 ¦ ¼:¾7 ½9:¾5 ¦ ¼:¾½ 66:½ ¦ 7:4

NGC 4536 (Sab) 1981B —

½9:½9 ¦ ¼:4½ ½9:½9 ¦ ¼:¿7 68:¼ ¦ ½¾:4

NGC 3627 (Sb) 1989B —

½9:¾8 ¦ ¼:4½ ½9:¾7 ¦ ¼:¿5 ½9:¼9 ¦ ¼:¾8 65:¼ ¦ ½¼:5

NGC 3368 (Sab) 1998bu

½8:9¼ ¦ ¼:4¼ ½8:88 ¦ ¼:¿7 ½8:8½ ¦ ¼:¿4 76:4 ¦ ½¿:½

NGC 5253 (Im pec) 1972E

½9:¾9 ¦ ¼:¿7 ½9:¾7 ¦ ¼:¿¿ 65:5 ¦ ½¼:6

IC 4182 (SAm) 1937C —

½9:55 ¦ ¼:4¼ ½9:65 ¦ ¼:¿7 56:4 ¦ ½¼:¾

NGC 4496A (SB) 1960F —

½9:58 ¦ ¼:47 ½9:57 ¦ ¼:¿9 57:½ ¦ ½½:¿ NGC 4414 (SAc) 1974G —

Table 5. This table lists the corrected absolute maximum magnitudes of SNe Ia in early-type galaxies. Refer the text for data

sources.

Å Å Å À

ÑaÜ Î;ÑaÜ Á;ÑaÜ ¼

Host Galaxy (type) SN B;

½9:¼½ ¦ ¼:¾9 ½9:¼¾ ¦ ¼:¾7 ½8:58 ¦ ¼:¾5 76:¾ ¦ 9:7

NGC 1380 (S0) 1992A

½9:¼5 ¦ ¼:¿¼ ½9:¼5 ¦ ¼:¾7 ½8:68 ¦ ¼:¾5 74:¾ ¦ 9:5

NGC 1316 (S0pec) 1980N

½8:76 ¦ ¼:¿5 ½8:7¾ ¦ ¼:¿4 ½8:46 ¦ ¼:¿½ 8½:5 ¦ ½¾:¾

NGC 4526 (S0) 1994D

½9:¼¿ ¦ ¼:6½ ½9:½¼ ¦ ¼:49 ½8:75 ¦ ¼:½¾ 7¿:½ ¦ ½¿:7

NGC 4374 (E) 1991bg

´B Î µ=¼:¾ ¦ ¼:½ Branch (1998), Gibson et al. (2000), Tonry et al. (2000) and E . Although the uncertainty is large, references therein. mainly caused by the uncertain reddening, there is no reason to Given the above arguments, the present data on super- conclude that SN 1991T has a peculiarly high luminosity, as the novae absolute magnitudes does at best marginally support a comparison with other SNe shows. Thus the model of a super- small difference in the absolute corrected magnitudes of SNe in Chandrasekhar explosion advanced by Fisher et al. (1999) can early-type and late-type galaxies, which, however, is of the or- not be motivated by the new distance. der of present uncertainties in the respective absolute distance Since also underluminous events like SN 1991bg and scales. SN 1997cn are consistent with the corrected absolute magni- We further recall that systematic uncertainties in the dis- tudes of the other SNe, there is now no single SN known, which tance scale of Cepheids and globular cluster luminosity func- deviates strikingly, in accordance with the homogeneous sam-

tions have not yet been included. For example, all distance ples of the Cal´an-Tololo and the Harvard sample. Since there is

:5¼

moduli based on Cepheids use ½8 mag as the LMC distance evidence that SNe Ia in late-type and early-type galaxies stem

:¾ ½8:7 modulus, whereas values between ½8 and mag appear in from different parent populations, (see Leibundgut (2000) for the literature, e.g. Walker (1999). a general review on SNe Ia) this may indicate that there is no One can only conclude that progress regarding a further de- evolutionary effect as far as the corrected absolute magnitudes crease of the uncertainty of the Hubble constant must come are concerned. This is encouraging for the use of SNe Ia in from both sources: we need more well observed SNe Ia in cosmological contexts. nearby spirals and early-type galaxies and a more accurate zero-point determination of the distance scale. Acknowledgements. We greatly appreciate the help of the NICMOS team, which provided advice, software and the photometric zero point used in the SBF analysis. We also acknowledge the helpful contribu- 6. Summary and Conclusions tion of the optical colour data by the Optical SBF team (J. Tonry, J. By applying the method of surface brightness fluctuations to Blakeslee, E. Ajhar, and A. Dressler). The NICMOS GTO team was supported by NASA grant NAG 5-3042. J. Jensen acknowledges the the bulge of NGC 4527, we measured an accurate distance to support of the Gemini Observatory, which is operated by the Asso-

this galaxy, which hosted SN 1991T. Our result for the dis- ciation for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under a cooperative agree-

:¾6 ¦ ¼:¼9 tance modulus is ¿¼ . With this distance, the absolute ment with the National Science Foundation on behalf of the Gem-

maximum magnitudes of SN 1991T, corrected for decline rate ini partnership: the National Science Foundation (United States), the

Î Á ½9:½8 ¦ ¼:5¾ ½9:½6 ¦ ¼:¿9

and colour, in B , , are , , Particle Physics and Astronomy Research Council (United Kingdom),

½8:95 ¦ ¼:½8 and , respectively (adopting a reddening of the National Research Council (Canada), CONICYT (Chile), the Aus- T. Richtler et al.: The brightness of SN1991T 7

tralian Research Council (Australia), CNPq (Brazil) and CONICET (Argentina). J. Tonry and B. Barris were supported in part by NASA grant GO-07453.0196A.

References Blakeslee, J. P., Ajhar, E. A., and Tonry, J. L., 1999, in A. Heck and F. Caputo (eds.), Post-Hipparcos Cosmic Candles, p. 181, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston Branch, D., 1998, A&AR 36, 17 Della Valle, M., Kissler-Patig, M., Danziger, J., and Storm, J., 1998, A&A 299, 267 Drenkhahn, G. and Richtler, T., 1999, A&A 349, 877 Ferrarese, L., Mould, J. R., Kennicutt, R. C., et al., 2000, ApJ 529, 745 Fischer, A., Branch, D., Hatano, K., and Baron, E., 1999, MNRAS 304, 67 Gibson, B. K., Stetson, P. B., Freedman, W. L., et al., 2000, ApJ 529, 723 Hamuy, M., Phillips, M. M., Suntzeff, N. B., Schommer, R. A., Maza, J., and Aviles, R., 1996, AJ 112, 2398 Jensen, J. B., Tonry, J. L., and Luppino, G. A., 1998, ApJ 505, 111 Jensen, J. B., Tonry, J. L., Thompson, R., Ajhar, E. A., Lauer, T. R., Rieke, M., Postman, M., Weymann, R. J., and Liu, M., 2000, in preparation Leibundgut, B., 2000, A&AR in press, astro-ph/0003326 Neilsen, E. and Tsvetanov, Z., 2000, ApJ 536, 255 Phillips, M. M., 1993, ApJ Lett. 413, L105 Phillips, M. M., Wells, L. A., Suntzeff, N. B., Hamuy, M., Leibundgut, B., Kirshner, R. P., and Foltz, C. B., 1992, AJ 103, 1632 Phillips, M. N., Lira, P., Suntzeff, N. B., et al., 1999, AJ 118, 1766 Pierce, M. J., 1994, ApJ 430, 53 Richtler, T., Drenkhahn, G., G´omez, M., and Infante, L., 2000a, A&A, submitted Richtler, T., Drenkhahn, G., G´omez, M., and Seggewiss, W., 2000b, in J. Bergeron and A. Renzini (eds.), From Extrasolar Planets to Cos- mology: The VLT opening Symposium, ESO Astrophysics Sym- posia, p. 259, Springer Rieke, G. H. and Lebofsky, M. J., 1985, ApJ 288, 618 Riess, A. G., Kirshner, R. P., Schmidt, P., et al., 1999, AJ 117, 707 Saha, A., Sandage, A., Labhardt, L., Tammann, G. A., Schwengeler, H., Macchetto, F. D., and Panagia, N., 1996a, ApJS 107, 693 Saha, A., Sandage, A., Labhardt, L., Tammann, G. A., Schwengeler, H., Macchetto, F. D., and Panagia, N., 1996b, ApJ 466, 55 Sakai, S., Mould, J., Hughes, S. M. G., et al., 2000, ApJ 529, 698 Schlegel, D. J., Finkbeiner, D. P., and Davis, M., 1998, ApJ 500, 525 Suntzeff, N. B., Phillips, M. M., Covarrubias, R., et al., 1999, AJ 117, 1175 Tonry, J. L., Blakeslee, J. P., Ajhar, E. A., and Dressler, A., 2000, ApJ 630, 625 Tripp, R., 1998, A&A 331, 815 Tripp, R. and Branch, D., 1999, ApJ 525, 209 Turatto, M., Piemonte, A., S., B., et al., 1998, AJ 116, 2431 van den Bergh, S., 1996, ApJ 472, 431 Walker, A., 1999, in F. Caputo and A. Heck (eds.), Post Hipparcos Candles, p. 125, Dordrecht:Kluwer