DOCSLIB.ORG

Asbestos-Related Conditions) (Scotland) Bill

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Asbestos-Related Conditions) (Scotland) Bill D23 Justice Committee Damages (Asbestos-related Conditions) (Scotland) Bill Written submission from Union of Construction Allied Trades and Technicians UCATT welcomes the common sense decision of the Scottish Government to overturn the disgraceful decision of Law Lord’s in October 2007 by introducing the Damages (Asbestos-related Conditions) (Scotland) Bill to the Scottish Parliament on 23rd June 2008. The reality of asbestos exposure is that our members diagnosed with plural plaques are faced with the mental anguish of knowing that employers exposing them to asbestos may have given them a potential death sentence. We must be clear here as to where the responsibility lies, many employers know the risks associated with asbestos, they always have, but some choose to play fast and loose with workers lives. UCATT experiences first hand how harrowing it is speaking to someone suffering from an asbestos related disease, we have to visit families and present compensation cheques to families that have lost loved ones. Financially calculated recklessness needs to be stopped. The issue of asbestos related disease is a key issue for the trade union movement and in particular those of us representing building workers. We know that the peak of associated illness has yet to come and UCATT will continue to speak up for our members and their families on the issue. In 2007, UCATT legal services undertook twenty legal cases of asbestos related cancers. We won compensatory payments totalling nine hundred thousand pounds, with a further ninety thousand pounds of claims won yet to be settled. But no amount of money can ever replace the loss of a loved one, killed because they went to work in an industry where they were exposed to asbestos. In 2007 eleven of our members, suffered death as a result of exposure to asbestos. In October 2007 the Law Lords ruled that workers who have developed pleural plaques would no longer receive compensation. Pleural plaques are a scarring of the lung caused by exposure to asbestos fibres. 1 D23 In their judgement the Law Lords believed that pleural plaques was not an injury that merits compensation as it allegedly was “symptomless”. However, the Law Lords disregarded that workers diagnosed with pleural plaques experience severe mental distress. In addition, it is often a first stage to developing other asbestos-related diseases such as asbestosis and mesothelioma, the latter being always fatal with a short life expectancy. The decision to stop payments brings down an established right to compensation, which had existed for 20 years. It is estimated that the ruling will save insurers of companies who exposed their workforce to asbestos more than £1bn over the next four decades. An individual now diagnosed as suffering from asbestos-related pleural plaques under this law has no claim. Therefore there is no obligation on any employer or insurer to respond to any claim. There is no possibility whatsoever of recovering the costs of the effort in trying to locate employers and insurers just in case the individuals exposed to asbestos develops into one of the compensatable conditions. Under the old law an individual who suffered from pleural plaques could initiate a claim and obtain compensation on a provisional basis. This gave the individual and the dependents security should one of the serious complications develop in later life. The insurers would be identified and judgment obtained. If the individual were unlucky enough to develop a condition such as mesothelioma it would simply be a question of quantifying the claim. The victim would have the security of knowing that their family was protected. As the law now stands an individual will have to wait until one of the compensatable conditions develops before being able to pursue a claim. Frequently an individual who develops mesothelioma will die within six months of diagnosis, sometimes even more quickly. Therefore if mesothelioma were diagnosed in an individual who had for many years had pleural plaques then the work in identifying a defendant and insurer, which could have been carried out many years before, would have to be carried out much later and in a very short space of time. The dying victim would not have the security of knowing that his family would be protected. Anyone who has taken a statement from a person dying of mesothelioma will know what a harrowing experience it is to try and think back over decades to identify exposure occurring many years before in order that the claim can be proved. This will be particularly problematic if, once the claim is made, the employer’s insurers challenge the accuracy of the information and evidence. If a pleural plaques case had been pursued and all the issues dealt with at the time of the pleural plaques claim being settled then there will be no problem in dealing with areas of contentious evidence if a serious illness develops at a later stage. Union lawyers know the frustration of evidential points being taken by 2 D23 defendants at the death of a claimant, something that can threaten the success of a claim. A further obvious disadvantage of the new law is that the investigations will be made far later than if the factual evidence and legal issues had been settled at the time of diagnosis of pleural plaques. For example a 20-year gap between the date of diagnosis of pleural plaques and the diagnosis of a condition such as mesothelioma provides plenty of time for firms to go into liquidation and insurance records to be lost by brokers or underwriters. Therefore a claim that might once have been successful could well be lost. The ruling and its underlying ignorance and misjudgement appalled UCATT. Following the ruling UCATT sent out a letter to all Members of Parliament alerting them to the disastrous impact of the ruling. We are delighted that the Scottish Government has taken the lead and put forward this Bill which will simply overturn the decision of the Law Lord’s in Scotland and ensure that Scottish workers can claim compensatory payments for diagnosis of plural plaques. We hope that all members of the Scottish Parliament gives full support to this Bill and it becomes legislation in due course without any delay. 3 D23 Appendix 1 – Case Summaries- UCATT Members Asbestos Related Illness Cases since 2000 1. UCATT branch member joiner had a successful claim for mild asbestosis settled in 2004. Compensation was £8000. 2. UCATT member claimed against Glasgow CC and Upper Clyde Shipbuilders for Pleural plaques. Award was £5623.50 after deductions in respect of Chester St insurance govt scheme for former Iron Trades. 3. UCATT member secured £13500 for mild/moderate asbestosis after exposure at the Caledon yard in Dundee. 4. An Uphall-based shopfitter died from mesothelioma. We pursued acclaim against Scottish Midland Coop Soc (Scotmid) for the family and obtained compensation of £111,000. 5. A Dundee joiner who contracted Pleural plaques due to exposure with Caledon yard, Dundee University and Dundee cc. Compensation of £7000 obtained in 2005. 6. Edinburgh man contracted Pleural plaques due to exposure with Henry Robb shipyard, MOD and Alexander Halls (now Hall and Tawse). Compensation of £7000 in 2006. 7. A Grangemouth member died from mesothelioma due to exposure with William Denny and son ltd- compensation of £108,000 in 2005. 8. Erskine member contracted pleural thickening and pleural plaques- exposure on Clydeside claim against British Shipbuilders- recovered compensation of £11500. 9. A Greenock member recovered £12250 for pleural plaques- claim was against Greenock dockyard. 10. Dunfermline joiner contracted pleural plaques due to exposure with Burntisland Shipbuilding, and Henry Robb ltd at Leith. Compensation was £10000. 11. Edinburgh joiner contracted moderate/severe asbestosis with W and JR Watson Leith. Compensation of £46500 obtained. I hope these case summaries are helpful for you. We do of course have a number of asbestosis and Pleural plaque claims ongoing, the latter ones now being re-commenced in anticipation of the Damages Bill going through over coming months. 4 .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Bow-Tow 27 LR.Pdf
    Issue 27 : Nov 2020 - Jan 2021 THE NEWSLETTER OF NEWHAVEN HERITAGE Canmore.org.uk/collection/1437634 Above: Western Harbour and Newhaven aerial photograph taken facing West. Photo courtesy of Canmore IN THIS ISSUE . OUR FOND FAREWELLS / NEWHAVEN PAGEANT / MULBERRY HARBOURS / DAVID MACKENZIE / OLD SCHOOL TIES / PRECIOUS GIFTS / A SUNNY DISPOSISH / 2021 NEWHAVEN CALENDAR / WARDIE BAY BEACHWATCH / NEWHAVEN GARDENS GROUP - SHIP SHAPE / TIME & TIDE/ FACEBOOK FOOTNOTES . and more NEWHAVEN HERITAGE CENTRE is recognised as a Scottish registered charity No. SC044837 1 OUR FOND FAREWELLS THE WEATHER DRAWS in with longer nights and shorter days, and lockdown (in some form, likely wherever you are in the world) returns. The water seems blacker in the harbour and the decorative lighting in the streets seems somehow chiller, with a lack of people on the pavements By Dr J J “Jeff” Liston FLS, beneath it. 2020 has been a tougher year, not just with COVID, but the Chair of Newhaven Heritage people taken from us in this time, whether relatives, colleagues or friends (or even former milkmen from Fountainbridge). Not least among these is David Mackenzie, a dedicated researcher and member of our committee, for whom an obituary can be found elsewhere in this issue. His understanding of archives and the information that could be gleaned from them and online to aid the restoration of a proper Newhaven Museum to the area was utterly invaluable in the last year, and he will be sorely missed. A further loss is my Vice-Chair, the redoubtable Heather Yang. As well as a ‘chairship’, we have some things in common: most bizarrely, Heather and I have both worked in Kunming in Yunnan Province, China.
    [Show full text]
  • Ship-Breaking.Com Information Bulletins on Ship Demolition, # 8 - 11 from January 1, to December 31, 2007
    Ship-breaking.com Information bulletins on ship demolition, # 8 - 11 from January 1, to December 31, 2007 Robin des Bois 2008 Press release January, 24th 2008 Global Statement 2007 of Shipping Vessels Sent to Demolition For the 2nd consecutive year, Robin des Bois has been studying in detail the reality of the ship breaking market. The mobilisation and the analysis of about thirty diverse and specialised bibliographical sources made it possible to establish an inventory of the vessels sent to be demolished in 2007. In 2006, Robin des Bois tallied 293 vessels sold for demolition. In 2007, we listed 288 of them. If this decline in demolished vessels is modest (-2%), it is a little more significant with regard to the total weight of recycled metals: 1.7 million ton in 2007 against 1.9 million in 2006 (-10%). The situation differs however according to the category of ships considered: the number of tankers (oil tankers, chemical tankers, gas carriers) dismantled in 2007 increased by almost 30 % compared with 2006 whereas that of the bulk carriers and other general cargo ships decreased by almost 40 %; the average age of the tankers sent to demolition is 29 years, the average age for all the vessels is 31 years, the average age of bulk carriers 34 years. Of the 288 vessels, 95 (33 %) were under a European flag or belonged to ship-owners established in the European Union or members of the European Association of Free Exchange (EFTA) or members of the principalities like Monaco. Not one of the international exchanges linking these European ship-owners to non-European demolition sites were preceded by any asbestos removal.
    [Show full text]
  • Sunrise in Korea, Sunset in Britain: a Shipbuilding Comparison
    Copyright By Dan Patrick McWiggins 2013 The Dissertation Committee for Dan Patrick McWiggins certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: SUNRISE IN THE EAST, SUNSET IN THE WEST: How the Korean and British Shipbuilding Industries Changed Places in the 20 th Century Committee: __________________________ William Roger Louis, Supervisor ____________________________ Gail Minault ____________________________ Toyin Falola ____________________________ Mark Metzler ____________________________ Robert Oppenheim SUNRISE IN THE EAST, SUNSET IN THE WEST: How the Korean and British Shipbuilding Industries Changed Places in the 20 th Century by Dan Patrick McWiggins, B.A., M.A. Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin December 2013 DEDICATION This dissertation is dedicated to the memories of Walt W. and Elspeth Rostow Their intellectual brilliance was exceeded only by their kindness. It was an honor to know them and a privilege to be taught by them. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This dissertation has been a long time in the making and it would not have been possible without the help of many people around the world. I am particularly indebted to Professor William Roger Louis, who has been incredibly patient with me over the eight years it has taken to get this written. Regular work weeks of 60+ hours for years on end made finding the time to advance this project much more difficult than I anticipated. Professor Louis never lost faith that I would complete this project and his encouragement inspired me to keep going even when other commitments made completion look well-nigh impossible.
    [Show full text]
  • Mast Special Collection
    The Marine Technology Special Collection. List of Catalogued Materials. The Marine Technology Special Collection List of Catalogued Materials Revised 11 May 2012 Contents Part 1 & 2: Company records, plans, and photographs Materials catalogued to date Shipbuilding, marine engine building, shiprepairing, and marine equipment suppliers: ca.10% of 53,000 items are catalogued, cataloguing in progress. Shipbreaking: 40,000 items, list not yet available, cataloguing pending. Photographs for all topics: list not yet available, cataloguing pending. An example record <Name of organisation>. <town, country where organisation based>, <type of business>. <number of materials catalogued>, <dates of materials>, <Types of materials>. where:- <Name of organisation> may be approximate, sometimes because of name changes which are too numerous to list here. <dates of materials> is not the dates the organisation existed. A & P Appledore. Newcastle. Consultants. 10 items, 1970-1990, Facilities & Products. Publicity. How to search this list This list is arranged alphabetically by the name of the organisation. Search this PDF on your computer by using the Adobe “find” search function. Make your searches very simple, usually ONE WORD is best. Example searches o A & P Appledore & Co. Ltd. Search for appledore o William Denny & Co. Ltd. Search for denny o Y.A.R.D. Search for yard or Y.A.R.D. o Sunderland Shipbuilding Co. Search for sunderland shipbuild (using truncation shipbuild which will find shipbuilder, ..ers, ..ing. o A shipbuilder based in Sunderland search for sunderland or if necessary as a last resort shipbuild 1 The Marine Technology Special Collection. List of Catalogued Materials. Alphabetical list of names of organisations:- A & P Appledore.
    [Show full text]
  • U DEW Archives of Ellerman's Wilson Line 1825-1974
    Hull History Centre: Archives of Ellerman’s Wilson Line U DEW Archives of Ellerman's Wilson Line 1825-1974 Historical Background Hull might be considered an unsuitable location for what at one time was the largest privately owned shipping company in the world, with its awkward 27 mile approach up the Humber from the North Sea. Nevertheless, here was founded the firm of Thomas Wilson Sons & Co. (TWSC), later Ellerman's Wilson Line (EWL), but known for most of its life and now remembered as the Wilson Line. Furthermore, the activities of this single company helped to make Hull Britain's third largest port by the beginning of the twentieth century. In March 1904 TWSC owned some 99 vessels, most of which had been built by the local firm of Earle's Shipbuilding and Engineering Company Limited, which had itself been bought by TWSC shortly before. Thomas Wilson, the founder of the firm, was born in Hull on 12 February 1792. He went to sea as a boy but then became a clerk with Whitaker, Wilkinson & Co., importers of Swedish iron ore, later becoming their commercial traveller in the Sheffield area. On 1 September 1814 he married Susannah John West and they eventually had 15 children. The story goes that, with a growing family, he asked his employers for a rise, was refused, and in 1820 chose to set up in business for himself, relying on various partners for the provision of capital. The first of these in 1822 was John Beckington, a merchant and iron importer from Newcastle. The firm of Beckington, Wilson & Co.
    [Show full text]
  • Book Reviews
    Book Reviews Rajesh Basrur, Anit Mukherjee, and inclined to perceive India as the defen- T.V. Paul (eds.). India-China Maritime sive state in Indo-China competition, Competition: The Security Dilemma at and China as the aggressor, perhaps Sea. Cass Series in Naval Policy and even anarchic, state. The distinction History (ed. Geoffrey Till). London and between the aggressor and defensive New York: Routledge, www.routledge. nations is left unstated viz. China and com, 2019. xiii+192 pp., illustrations, the United States, but the implication tables, charts, index. US $155.00, cloth; that China is an unpredictable, anarchic ISBN 1-978-03670-0154-4.^pp state actor remains tacit. India-China Maritime Competition A compilation of the work of eleven offers two distinct analytical approach- scholars, Basrur, Mukherjee, and Paul es. First, the topics the contributors cov- (henceforth Basrur, et al.) present a rich er span the geographic region between volume focusing on the Indian-Ocean Pakistan and, eventually, the United Region (IOR), the archipelagos of States. Distinct focus is placed on the Southeast Asia, and the Asia Pacific Re- IOR, on China, and on the states affect- gion. They draw attention to the mari- ed by China’s swelling and increasing- time security dilemma existing between ly modern navy (People’s Liberation India and China, which is defined as Army Navy [PLAN]) and aggressive any situation where either state actor foreign policy in the form of the bur- makes a strategic decision that the other geoning Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). actor perceives as a threat. This results The second area of focus is the effect of in a corresponding action whereby the the United States on Sino-Indian securi- first state actor chooses to respond in ty relations, and policy implementation kind.
    [Show full text]
  • Proposed Abolition of British Shipbuilders Corporation
    PROPOSED ABOLITION OF BRITISH SHIPBUILDERS CORPORATION Government response to consultation JULY 2012 Proposed abolition of British Shipbuilders Corporation - Government response Contents Contents........................................................................................................................................... 2 Consultation process and summary responses .......................................................................... 3 Government response .................................................................................................................... 4 Next steps ........................................................................................................................................ 5 Respondents.................................................................................................................................... 6 Annex A............................................................................................................................................ 7 Annex B.......................................................................................................................................... 22 2 Proposed abolition of British Shipbuilders Corporation - Government response Background 1. British Shipbuilders is a public corporation that owned and managed large parts of the British (but not Northern Irish) shipbuilding industry. It was established by the Aircraft and Shipbuilding Industries Act 1977. 2. British Shipbuilders has now privatised all of its active
    [Show full text]
  • Twilight of Newhaven: the Transformation of an Ancient Fishing Village Into a Modern Neighborhood
    University of Kentucky UKnowledge Theses and Dissertations--History History 2020 TWILIGHT OF NEWHAVEN: THE TRANSFORMATION OF AN ANCIENT FISHING VILLAGE INTO A MODERN NEIGHBORHOOD Asa James Swan University of Kentucky, [email protected] Author ORCID Identifier: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5641-0066 Digital Object Identifier: https://doi.org/10.13023/etd.2020.209 Right click to open a feedback form in a new tab to let us know how this document benefits ou.y Recommended Citation Swan, Asa James, "TWILIGHT OF NEWHAVEN: THE TRANSFORMATION OF AN ANCIENT FISHING VILLAGE INTO A MODERN NEIGHBORHOOD" (2020). Theses and Dissertations--History. 57. https://uknowledge.uky.edu/history_etds/57 This Doctoral Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the History at UKnowledge. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations--History by an authorized administrator of UKnowledge. For more information, please contact [email protected]. STUDENT AGREEMENT: I represent that my thesis or dissertation and abstract are my original work. Proper attribution has been given to all outside sources. I understand that I am solely responsible for obtaining any needed copyright permissions. I have obtained needed written permission statement(s) from the owner(s) of each third-party copyrighted matter to be included in my work, allowing electronic distribution (if such use is not permitted by the fair use doctrine) which will be submitted to UKnowledge as Additional File. I hereby grant to The University of Kentucky and its agents the irrevocable, non-exclusive, and royalty-free license to archive and make accessible my work in whole or in part in all forms of media, now or hereafter known.
    [Show full text]
  • Downloaded for Personal Non-Commercial Research Or Study, Without Prior Permission Or Charge
    https://theses.gla.ac.uk/ Theses Digitisation: https://www.gla.ac.uk/myglasgow/research/enlighten/theses/digitisation/ This is a digitised version of the original print thesis. Copyright and moral rights for this work are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This work cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Enlighten: Theses https://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] Scottish Shipbuilders & the Australian Market, 1901-1971 Michael James Macdonald Submitted for the degree of M.Litt University of Glasgow Department of Economic & Social History January 2007 © Michael J. Macdonald, (2007) ProQuest Number: 10390703 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a com plete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. uest ProQuest 10390703 Published by ProQuest LLO (2017). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code Microform Edition © ProQuest LLO.
    [Show full text]
  • The Log Quarterly Journal of the Nautical Association of Australia Inc
    THE www.nautical.asn.au LOG QUARTERLY JOURNAL OF THE NAUTICAL ASSOCIATION OF AUSTRALIA INC. VOL. 51, NO. 4, ISSUE 214 - NEW SERIES 2018 Wainui (8,701/1955) (H.Stott/NAA collection) Harry Stott captured Union Steam’s Wainui on the St. Lawrence following dry docking and repainting in Union livery at Montreal in 1965 after being handed over by New Zealand Shipping Co as their Whangaroa. Her sister, Whakatane, had already been acquired by Union in 1964 and renamed Waitaki. The two ships were obtained to service Union’s Eastern service and this they did for just over four years until a prolonged industrial dispute on Wainui was resolved by transferring both vessels within the P&O Group to British India, thus ending Union Steam’s 83 year connection with the Sub Continent. Wainui went to the scrapyard as Dromeus in 1974 and the 1954-built Waitaki followed her under the name Truthful in 1979. PRINT POST PUBLICATION NUMBER 100003238 ISSN 0815-0052. All rights reserved. In late October the offshore patrol vessel HMNZS Otago conducted a passage exercise with the patrol boat HMAS Wollongong off the east coast of Australia. Earlier, on 22 October, Civil Defence Minister Kris Faafoi joined Otago to the atolls of Tokelau to assess village emergency preparedness plans, in the event of natural disaster in the Pacific Islands. In late August the RNZN announced the purchase of a dive and hydrographic ship, the 85-metre Edda Fonn, a 15-year-old survey and light construction vessel. The ship will replace the decommissioned dive tender HMNZS Manawanui and hydrographic survey ship HMNZS Resolution.
    [Show full text]
  • Proposed Abolition of British Shipbuilders
    PROPOSED ABOLITION OF BRITISH SHIPBUILDERS Government response to consultation JULY 2012 Proposed abolition of British Shipbuilders – Government response Contents Contents........................................................................................................................................... 2 Consultation process and summary responses .......................................................................... 3 Government response .................................................................................................................... 4 Next steps ........................................................................................................................................ 5 Respondents.................................................................................................................................... 6 Annex A............................................................................................................................................ 7 Annex B.......................................................................................................................................... 22 2 Proposed abolition of British Shipbuilders – Government response Background 1. British Shipbuilders is a public corporation that owned and managed large parts of the British (but not Northern Irish) shipbuilding industry. It was established by the Aircraft and Shipbuilding Industries Act 1977. 2. British Shipbuilders has now privatised all of its active shipbuilding subsidiaries and the one
    [Show full text]
  • News and Views
    World Ship Society Southend Branch News and Views Newsletter Edition 25 22nd February 2021 Chairman & Secretary Stuart Emery [email protected] News & Views Coordinator Richard King [email protected] Thanks go to everybody their contributions. For this edition we have shown the credits February is usually the month of our members night where people give a short talk on a subject of their interest. Arguably News & Views is like this all of the time. But this edition is an attempt at a reader’s edition and coincided with a U3A Maritime meeting. Contents News Visitors Quiz Readers Edition Quiz Tony Weber Roger Pics Roger Sentance Heritage Harbours Stuart Emery Port Waikto Eddie Long SB Cymric Graham Dent Colins Pics Colin Paynter Port of Whitstable Tony Weber HMS Caroline Tony Weber Eddie Hardiman Pics Eddie Hardiman Canberra Phil Major Maxima Peter Acton The Story of the Flying Enterprise Eddie Long MV Royal Sovereign John Waithe Destroyer Depot ships Richard King One fact wonders Great Eastern Tony Weber Eddie Long Richard King Shipbuilding – Swan Hunter Wallsend Part 2 1930’s Richard King Short History of a Line -Caledonian Mc Brayne Richard King News Michelin Commits to Shipping Tyres on Sail-Powered Cargo Ships Tire manufacturer Michelin has agreed to ship some of its tires using two sail-powered cargo ships being developed by French shipping line Neoline. Under the agreement, tires will be loaded in containers and shipped from Michelin’s facilities in Halifax, Nova Scotia to Saint-Nazaire, France as soon as the Neoline’s first ships enter service in 2023.
    [Show full text]