DOCSLIB.ORG

Mongolia's Constitutional Crisis

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Mongolia's Constitutional Crisis University of Chicago Law School Chicago Unbound Journal Articles Faculty Scholarship 2001 When Courts and Politics Collide: Mongolia's Constitutional Crisis Tom Ginsburg Gombosuren Ganzorig Follow this and additional works at: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/journal_articles Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Tom Ginsburg & Gombosuren Ganzorig, "When Courts and Politics Collide: Mongolia's Constitutional Crisis," 14 Columbia Journal of Asian Law 309 (2001). This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Scholarship at Chicago Unbound. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal Articles by an authorized administrator of Chicago Unbound. For more information, please contact [email protected]. WHEN COURTS AND POLITICS COLLIDE: MONGOLIA'S CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS TOM GINSRG * GOMBOSUREN GANZORIG I. INTRODUCTION Mongolia's political system has received well-deserved attention as one of the most successful examples of democratization in the Asian region Since 1990, Mongolia has undergone peaceful constitutional change and has conducted several democratic elections. Human rights are well- respected, the media is free and political competition exists? This is all the more remarkable given that constitutional democracy has developed "without prerequisites,"3 that is, without a previous history of democracy or social pluralism that is sometimes thought necessary for democracy to flourish. During the early years of transition, Mongolia's Constitutional Court played an important role in facilitating democratic change. The court occasionally overturned parliamentary legislation while serving as a vehicle to protect human rights and the constitutional scheme. However, in recent years Mongolia's Constitutional Court has found itself at the center of a major controversy regarding the very structure of the political system. Through a series of decisions that has placed it at odds with the legislature, the Court has raised questions about its ability to play an appropriate role in a constitutional democracy. This article traces the origins of the current • Assistant Professor of Law, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. •* Former Judge, Supreme Court of Mongolia; Adjunct Professor, Texas Wesleyan University School of Law. 1. See annual reports in ASIAN SURVEY (1991-97). 2. U.S. DEP'T OF STATE, MONGOLIA HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT 2000; Tom Ginsburg and G. Ganzorig, Constitutionalism and Human Rights in Mongolia, in MONGOLIA INTRANsmo.4 (OLE BRuuN AND OLE ODGAARD, EDS, 1996.) 3. Steven Fish, Mongolia: Democracy without Prerequisites,9 J. De-1OC. 127 (1998). HeinOnline -- 14 Colum. J. Asian L. 309 2000-2001 COLUMBIA JOURNAL OFASIAN LAW[ [14:2 problems with the Mongolian constitutional scheme and describes the Court's role in precipitating the political crisis. II. BACKGROUND: MONGOLIA'S TRANSFORMATION AND THE 1992 CONSTITUTION Mongolia is a landlocked country located between Russia and China. Beginning in the 12 th century, its tribes united and conquered the largest empire the world has ever known, but gradually the country came to be dominated by the Manchu empire that governed China.4 Until 1911, Mongolia was administered as part of the Chinese empire. With China convulsed in revolution and chaos for the next decade, Mongolia began to seek its independence and in 1921, established an independent republic with the help of the Soviet Union. For the next seven decades, Mongolia was dominated by Soviet influence although it always maintained its independent statehood. A single party, the Mongolian People's Revolutionary Party (the "MPRP"), controlled politics. Following the collapse of the Berlin Wall in 1989, Mongolian students began to demand democratic reforms. The ruling MPRP agreed and a new period of democracy was introduced. 5 One of the most important tasks was constitutional reform, and a large drafting committee was established with representation from all political parties. After canvassing some one hundred foreign constitutions, the new Constitution was promulgated in early 1992.6 The Constitution featured a new unicameral parliament called the State Great Hural, a directly elected President, and a Constitutional Court with the power to strike legislation that was unconstitutional. Mongolia's Constitutional Court is a nine-member body with three members appointed by each of the President, the State Great Hural, and the Supreme Court. Cases can be brought to the Court by certain designated governmental officials as well as by any member of the public who sends a petition alleging a violation of the constitution.7 Petitions are initially considered by one member of the Court.' If the member believes there is a constitutional violation, a three-member panel of the Court hears the case. 4. See generally ROBERT WORDEN AND ANDREA MARLES, MONGOLIA: A COUNTRY STUDY (1991). 5. See Tom Ginsburg, Between Russia and China: PoliticalReform in Mongolia, 35 ASIAN SURVEY 459 (1995). 6. Alan J.K. Sanders, Mongolia's New Constitution,32 ASIAN SURVEY 42 (1992). 7. CONST. OF MONGOLIA, Art. 69. 8. Law on Constitutional Court, Art. 9(1) HeinOnline -- 14 Colum. J. Asian L. 310 2000-2001 2001] MONGOLIA S CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS A decision on unconstitutionality is automatically forwarded to the State Great Hural that has the right to accept or reject the Court's decision. If the State Great Hural accepts the decision of the Court, the act in question is deemed unconstitutional. On the other hand, if the State Great Hural rejects the finding of unconstitutionality, the case is sent back to the Constitutional Court for consideration by the full court en banc. The full court's decision is final.9 This procedure of legislative approval of declarations of unconstitutionality, which has some parallels with the procedure of the Constitutional Tribunal in Poland until 1997, reflects residual socialist notions of parliamentary sovereignty, namely that parliament has a legitimate role in constitutional interpretation. The debates over institutional design in Mongolia, however, ultimately culminated in a system where the Court has the final say on constitutionality. In the elections immediately following the new Constitution, the MPRP won an overwhelming victory and for the next four years controlled the government and State Great Hural. Parliamentary legislation was occasionally challenged before the Constitutional Court in minor cases, and the Court was willing to strike legislation. Furthermore, the State Great Hural became embroiled in a number of disputes with the first President, P. Ochirbat. The Constitutional Court had to resolve some of these disputes as well, and by and large mediated them in a manner that led to increased legitimacy of the Court. Mongolia's democratic system seemed to be deepening despite the political dominance of the former communist party."0 III. THE 1996 ELECTION AND ITS AFTERMATH In the 1996 parliamentary elections, the National Democrat-Social Democrat coalition came to power for the first time." Before a government could be formed, however, a member of the coalition petitioned the Court to prevent the coalition from filling the cabinet with members of the State Great Hural, relying on a provision in the Constitution that "members of parliament shall have no other employment."' 2 The issue turned on the type 9. Law on Constitutional Court Procedure, Art. 3(3). 10. See Tom Ginsburg, Betreen Fireandice: Mongolia in 1996,37 ASIAN SURVEY 60 (1997); DeepeningDemocracy: Mongolia in 1997,38 ASIAN SURVEY 64 (1998). 11. IM. 12. CONST. OF MONGOLIA, Art. 29. The question of this member's motivation in bringing the suit is puzzling. D. Lamjav was a senior member of the Social Democratic Party, and had been a professor of K Gonchigdorj, the Speaker of Parliament. At one time he was considered a potential presidential candidate for the Party, and w*as considered to be a person of great intellect, with the highest levels of integrity and devotion to the Constitution. Some observers suggested that he filed the petition when it became clear that he would not be offered a cabinet post, hoping that by HeinOnline -- 14 Colum. J. Asian L. 311 2000-2001 COLUMBIA JOURNAL OFASIAN LAW [14:2 of political system established by the 1992 Constitution. Was it a presidential system where the cabinet is unrelated to the parliament? Or a parliamentary system, wherein the government is formed by the leading parties in parliament? The Court initially found that parliamentary deputies could not hold cabinet posts. This provoked the rancor of the democratic coalition and forced it to scrap its anticipated government lineup, requiring a scramble to find qualified persons to fill the cabinet. The coalition's leadership accused the Court of acting in a politically motivated fashion, and called for more "scientific" methods of constitutional interpretations, such as a detailed inquiry into the travaux prepartoires of the constitutional drafting committee. 3 The State Great Hural was controlled, for the first time, by the new parties, and they were given an opportunity to accept or reject the Court's judgment. They predictably rejected it, leading to a reconsideration of the case by the full panel of the Court. A second round of arguments was held. National Democratic Party lawyer and Member of Parliament (MP) B. Delgerma argued that the parliamentary model had been adopted as a reaction to the socialist "presidential" system and the over-concentration of power in the hands of a single individual. It would be anti-democratic to
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Committee on the Human Rights of Parliamentarians
    138th IPU ASSEMBLY AND RELATED MEETINGS Geneva, 24 – 28.03.2018 Governing Council CL/202/11(b)-R.2 Item 11(b) Geneva, 28 March 2018 Committee on the Human Rights of Parliamentarians Report on the mission to Mongolia 11 - 13 September 2017 MNG01 - Zorig Sanjasuuren Table of contents A. Origin and conduct of the mission ................................................................ 4 B. Outline of the case and the IPU follow up action ........................................... 5 C. Information gathered during the mission ...................................................... 7 D. Findings and recommendations further to the mission ................................ 15 E. Recent developments ................................................................................... 16 F. Observations provided by the authorities ..................................................... 17 G. Observations provided the complainant ....................................................... 26 H. Open letter of one of the persons sentenced for the murder of Zorig, recently published in the Mongolian media ................................................................ 27 * * * #IPU138 Mongolia © Zorig Foundation Executive Summary From 11 to 13 September 2017, a delegation of the Committee on the Human Rights of Parliamentarians (hereinafter “the Committee”) conducted a mission to Mongolia to obtain further information on the recently concluded judicial proceedings that led to the final conviction of the three accused for the 1998 assassination of Mr. Zorig
    [Show full text]
  • Harvard Polo Asia by Abigail Trafford
    Horsing Around IN THE HIGHWAYS AND BYWAYS OF POLO IN ASIA We all meet up during the six-hour stopover in the Beijing Airport. The invitation comes from the Genghis Khan Polo Club to play in Mongolia and then to head back to China for a university tournament at the Metropolitan Polo Club in Tianjin. Say, what? Yes, polo! Both countries are resurrecting the ancient sport—a tale of two cultures—and the Harvard players are to be emissaries to help generate a new ballgame in Asia. In a cavernous airport restaurant, I survey the Harvard Polo Team: Jane is captain of the women’s team; Shawn, captain of the men’s team; George, the quiet one, is a physicist; Danielle, a senior is a German major; Sarah, a biology major; Aemilia writes for the Harvard Crimson. Marina, a mathematician, will join us later. Neil and Johann are incoming freshmen; Merrall, still in high school, is a protégé of the actor Tommy Lee Jones—the godfather of Harvard polo. And where are the grownups? Moon Lai, a friend of Neil’s parents, is the photographer from Minnesota. Crocker Snow, Harvard alum and head of the Edward R. Murrow Center at Tufts, is tour director and coach. I am along as cheer leader and chronicler. We stagger onto the late-night plane to Ulan Bator (UB), the capital of Mongolia, pile into a van and drive into the darkness—always in the constant traffic of trucks. Our first camp of log cabins is near an official site of Naadam—Mongolia’s traditional summer festival of horse racing, wrestling and archery.
    [Show full text]
  • Congressional-Executive Commission on China Annual
    CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA ANNUAL REPORT 2007 ONE HUNDRED TENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION OCTOBER 10, 2007 Printed for the use of the Congressional-Executive Commission on China ( Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.cecc.gov VerDate 11-MAY-2000 01:22 Oct 11, 2007 Jkt 000000 PO 00000 Frm 00001 Fmt 6011 Sfmt 5011 38026.TXT CHINA1 PsN: CHINA1 2007 ANNUAL REPORT VerDate 11-MAY-2000 01:22 Oct 11, 2007 Jkt 000000 PO 00000 Frm 00002 Fmt 6019 Sfmt 6019 38026.TXT CHINA1 PsN: CHINA1 CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA ANNUAL REPORT 2007 ONE HUNDRED TENTH CONGRESS FIRST SESSION OCTOBER 10, 2007 Printed for the use of the Congressional-Executive Commission on China ( Available via the World Wide Web: http://www.cecc.gov U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 38–026 PDF WASHINGTON : 2007 For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office Internet: bookstore.gpo.gov Phone: toll free (866) 512–1800; DC area (202) 512–1800 Fax: (202) 512–2104 Mail: Stop IDCC, Washington, DC 20402–0001 VerDate 11-MAY-2000 01:22 Oct 11, 2007 Jkt 000000 PO 00000 Frm 00003 Fmt 5011 Sfmt 5011 38026.TXT CHINA1 PsN: CHINA1 VerDate 11-MAY-2000 01:22 Oct 11, 2007 Jkt 000000 PO 00000 Frm 00004 Fmt 5011 Sfmt 5011 38026.TXT CHINA1 PsN: CHINA1 CONGRESSIONAL-EXECUTIVE COMMISSION ON CHINA LEGISLATIVE BRANCH COMMISSIONERS House Senate SANDER M. LEVIN, Michigan, Chairman BYRON DORGAN, North Dakota, Co-Chairman MARCY KAPTUR, Ohio MAX BAUCUS, Montana TOM UDALL, New Mexico CARL LEVIN, Michigan MICHAEL M. HONDA, California DIANNE FEINSTEIN, California TIM WALZ, Minnesota SHERROD BROWN, Ohio CHRISTOPHER H.
    [Show full text]
  • “Access to Environmental Justice: Ngo Environmental Advocacy on Mining-Related Environmental Issues in Mongolia”
    “ACCESS TO ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE: NGO ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCACY ON MINING-RELATED ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES IN MONGOLIA” ULZIILKHAM ENKHBAATAR A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF LAWS GRADUATE PROGRAM IN LAW OSGOODE HALL LAW SCHOOL, YORK UNIVERSITY TORONTO, ONTARIO October 2020 © Ulziilkham Enkhbaatar, 2020 ABSTRACT In this thesis, I apply the theory of environmental justice to determine how NGOs use substantive and procedural environmental rights to advocate for mining-affected nomadic communities in Mongolia. Environmental NGOs often possess legal and scientific expertise pertinent to resolving and mitigating environmental risks and demanding justice for environmental damages on behalf of the mining-affected local communities. Based on the environmental justice theories, I have constructed a theoretical framework to examine how NGOs access and implement environmental justice tools, both domestically and internationally. Using a multi-methods research approach, including documentary analysis and qualitative interviews with NGO experts and lawyers, I was able to uncover the experiences, difficulties, and challenges faced by NGOs as they seek favourable environmental outcomes. My findings demonstrate that domestic and international environmental justice tools provided opportunities to NGOs to litigate, advocate, negotiate, and mediate the disputes between marginalized mining-affected nomadic communities and their much-larger opponents, mining companies. ii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to express my deep gratitude and sincere appreciation to my wonderful, kind and caring supervisor, Professor Estair Van Wagner, for her tremendous personal and professional support and guidance in writing this thesis during the challenging effects of the Covid-19 pandemic. I also would like to thank Professor Shin Imai, the LLM thesis supervisory committee member, for his unwavering support and guidance.
    [Show full text]
  • From Catalonia to California: Secession in Constitutional Law
    GINSBURGFINAL (DO NOT DELETE) 4/25/2019 7:35 PM FROM CATALONIA TO CALIFORNIA: SECESSION IN CONSTITUTIONAL LAW Tom Ginsburg & Mila Versteeg I. INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................................... 925 II. IS THERE A RIGHT TO SECESSION? ...................................................................... 933 A. International Law .............................................................................................. 933 B. Constitutional Law ............................................................................................ 936 III. SECESSION IN THE WORLD’S CONSTITUTIONS: A GLOBAL OVERVIEW ........ 940 A. Constitutional Secession Clauses ......................................................................... 940 B. Related Constitutional Design Choices ............................................................... 943 IV. THE PURPOSES AND EFFECTS OF CONSTITUTIONAL SECESSION CLAUSES ................................................................................................................... 945 A. Negotiating Secession Clauses and Prohibitions ................................................... 945 B. Effects of Secession Clauses and Prohibitions ....................................................... 947 C. Design Options of Secession Clauses and Prohibitions ......................................... 949 1. Right to Secession ........................................................................................ 949 2. Prohibition of Secession ..............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 1 an Analysis of the Mongolian Political and Economic Transition: A
    An Analysis of the Mongolian Political and Economic Transition: A Model Democracy with a Promising Future By Enkhtaivan Oyunbazar May, 2015 A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a baccalaureate degree in (Economics) in cursu honorum Reviewed and approved by: Dr. Alexander Mirescu Submitted to The Honors Program, Saint Peter’s University March 23, 2015 1 Acknowledgements I would like to thank all of the people who have been helpful, supportive, and caring to make this work possible. I am extremely thankful to have a wonderful family, friends, and teachers who have helped me throughout life and continue to support me in any endeavor. Special thanks to the Director of the Honors Program Dr. Rachel Wifall and my advisor for this work Dr. Alexander Mirescu from the Department of Political Science. Abstract Mongolia is a democratic free market-oriented Asian state and it is the second largest land locked country in the world. Located between the Russian Federation and the People’s Republic of China, Mongolia’s total area of 1.6 million square kilometers encompasses an area greater than that of Britain, France, Germany, and Italy combined; four times the size of Japan. Mongolia is the fifth largest country in Asia and it is also the least densely populated country in the world; the country’s population reached only three million in 2015. Mongolia became the second communist country in the world after the USSR when the Bolsheviks advised the young Mongolian nationalists to establish a Marxist state. Mongolia emerged as a supplier of raw materials and food for the USSR’s Siberian industries and towns leading up to the transition.
    [Show full text]
  • UNIVERSAL PERIODIC REVIEW MIDTERM PROGRESS REPORT by MONGOLIA on ITS IMPLEMENTATION of RECOMMENDATIONS Report by the Human Rights Forum
    UNIVERSAL PERIODIC REVIEW MIDTERM PROGRESS REPORT BY MONGOLIA ON ITS IMPLEMENTATION OF RECOMMENDATIONS Report by the Human Rights Forum May 2018 ONE. INTRODUCTION Mongolia submitted a second national report on its human rights situation to the UN Human Rights Council and received 164 recommendations out of which it committed itself to 150 recommendations. Please see the chart below for information on the implementation of the recommendations. Implementation of UPR recommendations 19% 16% 65% Implemented In progress Not implemented TWO. BACKGROUND Mongolia participated for the second time in the Universal Periodic Review (UPR) of the UN Human Rights Council (HRC) and committed itself to implement 150 recommendations during the plenary session of UN HRC on 5 May 2015. The remaining 14 recommendations were not accepted as they were concerned with the parliamentary legislative power. Since the different opinions of government and non-governmental organizations on the translation of the recommendations after the first session hindered the implementation stage, the second session, conducted by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA), concluded the integration of the translated recommendations, finalized in consultation with civil society organizations. Development of an implementation plan, again, with input from civil society organizations during the second stage, proved to be a good practice and helped to correct previous mistakes. The plan was approved on 11 May 2016, by Government Decree No. 204. For the monitoring of the implementation progress an ex-officio council chaired by the Minister for Justice and Home Affairs (MoJHA) was established with State Secretaries, heads of agencies, and representatives from the civil society. Requirements of the plan for the submission of a mid-term report on the implementation of the recommendations to the UN HRC by January 2018, as well as submission of an implementation report to the non-executive council every January and to the Government every February, help to enforce the implementation.
    [Show full text]
  • Scanned Using Book Scancenter 5033
    Globalization ’s Impact on Mongolian Identity Issues and the Image of Chinggis Khan Alicia J. Campi PART I: The Mongols, this previously unheard-of nation that unexpectedly emerged to terrorize the whole world for two hundred years, disappeared again into obscurity with the advent of firearms. Even so, the name Mongol became one forever familiar to humankind, and the entire stretch of the thirteenth through the fifteenth centuries has come to be known as the Mongol era.' PART II; The historic science was the science, which has been badly affect­ ed, and the people of Mongolia bid farewell to their history and learned by heart the bistort' with distortion but fuU of ideolog}'. Because of this, the Mong ­ olians started to forget their religious rituals, customs and traditions and the pa­ triotic feelings of Mongolians turned to the side of perishing as the internation ­ alism was put above aU.^ PART III: For decades, Mongolia had subordinated national identity to So­ viet priorities __Now, they were set adrift in a sea of uncertainty, and Mongol ­ ians were determined to define themselves as a nation and as a people. The new freedom was an opportunity as well as a crisis." As the three above quotations indicate, identity issues for the Mongolian peoples have always been complicated. In our increas­ ingly interconnected, media-driven world culture, nations with Baabar, Histoij of Mongolia (Ulaanbaatar: Monsudar Publishing, 1999), 4. 2 “The Political Report of the First Congress of the Mongolian Social-Demo ­ cratic Party” (March 31, 1990), 14. " Tsedendamdyn Batbayar, Mongolia’s Foreign Folicy in the 1990s: New Identity and New Challenges (Ulaanbaatar: Institute for Strategic Studies, 2002), 8.
    [Show full text]
  • Downloaded from Manchesterhive.Com at 10/02/2021 09:03:16PM Via Free Access Andrew Higson
    1 5 From political power to the power of the image: contemporary ‘British’ cinema and the nation’s monarchs Andrew Higson INTRODUCTION: THE HERITAGE OF MONARCHY AND THE ROYALS ON FILM From Kenneth Branagh’s Henry V Shakespeare adaptation in 1989 to the story of the fi nal years of the former Princess of Wales, inDiana in 2013, at least twenty-six English-language feature fi lms dealt in some way with the British monarchy. 1 All of these fi lms (the dates and directors of which will be indi- cated below) retell more or less familiar stories about past and present kings and queens, princes and princesses. This is just one indication that the institution of monarchy remains one of the most enduring aspects of the British national heritage: these stories and characters, their iconic settings and their splendid mise-en-scène still play a vital role in the historical and contemporary experience and projection of British national identity and ideas of nationhood. These stories and characters are also of course endlessly recycled in the pre- sent period in other media as well as through the heritage industry. The mon- archy, its history and its present manifestation, is clearly highly marketable, whether in terms of tourism, the trade in royal memorabilia or artefacts, or images of the monarchy – in paintings, prints, fi lms, books, magazines, televi- sion programmes, on the Internet and so on. The public image of the monarchy is not consistent across the period being explored here, however, and it is worth noting that there was a waning of support for the contemporary royal family in the 1990s, not least because of how it was perceived to have treated Diana.
    [Show full text]
  • Mongolian European Chamber Of
    MONGOL Since 1991 the MESSENGER 500 ¥ No. 07-08 (1076-1077) MONGOLIA’S FIRST ENGLISH WEEKLY PUBLISHED BY MONTSAME NEWS AGENCY Friday, February 17, 2012 Mongolia Economic Happy Tsagaan Sar! Forum planned for early March The Mongolian Economic Forum 2012 will run on March 5-6. At a February 10 press conference, organizers of the forum reported about the preparations and measures for the forum. As of information given by MP S. Oyun; Deputy Finance Minister Ch.Gankhuyag; Ch.Khashchuluun, head of the National Development and Innovation Committee; and P.Tsagaan, senior advisor to the President, the forum that is to be organized for the third time, will run this year under the motto ‘Together for Development’. The forum will have sub-meetings under themes on economic development, social policy and competitiveness, and bring together over 1000 foreign and domestic participants. During the forum, it is planned to publicly introduce Mongolia’s development forum until 2021 issued by Open Society. MP S. Oyun said, “In reality, why isn’t poverty decreasing while the economy has grown over the past five or six years. We believe that issues on how to decrease poverty and what should be done for the fruits of economic growth to improve livelihoods will develop into hot discussions during the forum. For instance, the statistical figures on poverty percentages are very confusing. The National Statistical Committee evaluates the poverty rate at 39 percent while the World Bank says it is lower using a different methodology to evaluate poverty. Therefore,
    [Show full text]
  • Law, As for Election of the State Great Hural
    UNOFFICIAL TRANSLATION LAW ON ELECTION PART ONE CHAPTER ONE: GENERAL PROVISIONS Article 1. Purpose of the Law Article 2. Legislation on election Article 3. Legal terms and definitions Article 4. Basic principles of election Article 5. Principles for election activity organization Article 6. Elections Article 7. Election system Article 8. Types of election Article 9. Election stages Article 10. Election time frame CHAPTER TWO: ELECTIVE RIGHTS Article 11. Right of a citizen of Mongolia to elect and be elected Article 12. Right to nominate candidate for the election of the State Great Hural and its Members Article 13. Right to nominate a candidate for Presidential election Article 14. The right to nominate a candidate for the election of the Citizens’ Representatives’ Hural Article 15. Prohibiting simultaneous candidacy CHAPTER THREE: BASIS FOR ELECTION ACTIVITY IMPLEMENTATION Article 16. Regular election, setting and announcement of the polling day Article 17. Setting and announcement of non-regular election Article 18. Setting and announcement of by-election Article 19. Setting and announcement of re-election Article 20. Polling day of elections other than regular election CHAPTER FOUR: STRUCTURE OF ELECTION TERRITORY Article 21. Election territory Article 22. Election constituency Article 23. Election precinct CHAPTER FIVE: ELECTION AUTHORITY Subchapter one: General provisions Article 24. Election authority Article 25. Administration and structure of an election authority Article 26. Administration and organization of a polling authority for citizens residing in a foreign country Article 27. Operation procedures of election authorities Article 28. Staff and officials of an election authority Article 29. Economic and legal guarantee for election officials Subchapter two: The central election authority Article 30.
    [Show full text]
  • Constitutional Crises
    University of Pennsylvania Law Review FOUNDED 1852 ________________ Formerly American Law Register ________________________ VOL. 157 FEBRUARY 2009 NO.3 ARTICLE CONSTITUTIONAL CRISES † †† SANFORD LEVINSON &JACK M. BALKIN [W]e must never forget that it is a constitution we are expounding. [It is] a constitution, intended to endure for ages to come, and consequently, to be adapted to the various crises of human affairs. 1 McCulloch v. Maryland Among all the other Roman institutions, [the dictatorship] truly deserves to be considered and numbered among those which were the source of the greatness of † W. St. John Garwood and W. St. John Garwood, Jr. Centennial Chair in Law, University of Texas Law School; Professor of Government, University of Texas at Aus- tin. †† Knight Professor of Constitutional Law and the First Amendment, Yale Law School. We are extremely grateful to a number of law schools that gave us the oppor- tunity to present different versions of this Article while it was very much a work in pro- gress. In chronological order, they are the Georgetown University Law Center, the Michigan and Quinnipiac Law Schools, the Legal History Workshop at Harvard Law School, the University of Minnesota Law School, and Vanderbilt Law School. We also benefited from responses by Bruce Ackerman, Keith Whittington, Mark Tushnet, and Adrian Vermeule. 1 17 U.S. (4 Wheat.) 316, 407, 415 (1819). (707) 708 University of Pennsylvania Law Review [Vol. 157: 707 such an empire, because without a similar system cities survive extraordinary cir- cumstances only with difficulty. The usual institutions in republics are slow to move . and, since time is wasted in coming to an agreement, the remedies for republics are very dangerous when they must find one for a problem that cannot wait.
    [Show full text]