EDUCATION of POOR GIRLS in NORTH WEST ENGLAND C1780 to 1860: a STUDY of WARRINGTON and CHESTER by Joyce Valerie Ireland
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EDUCATION OF POOR GIRLS IN NORTH WEST ENGLAND c1780 to 1860: A STUDY OF WARRINGTON AND CHESTER by Joyce Valerie Ireland A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Philosophy at the University of Central Lancashire September 2005 EDUCATION OF POOR GIRLS IN NORTH WEST ENGLAND cll8Oto 1860 A STUDY OF WARRINGTON AND CHESTER ABSTRACT This study is an attempt to discover what provision there was in North West England in the early nineteenth century for the education of poor girls, using a comparative study of two towns, Warrington and Chester. The existing literature reviewed is quite extensive on the education of the poor generally but there is little that refers specifically to girls. Some of it was useful as background and provided a national framework. In order to describe the context for the study a brief account of early provision for the poor is included. A number of the schools existing in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries continued into the nineteenth and occasionally even into the twentieth centuries and their records became the source material for this study. The eighteenth century and the early nineteenth century were marked by fluctuating fortunes in education, and there was a flurry of activity to revive the schools in both towns in the early nineteenth century. The local archives in the Chester/Cheshire Record Office contain minute books, account books and visitors' books for the Chester Blue Girls' school, Sunday and Working schools, the latter consolidated into one girls' school in 1816, all covering much of the nineteenth century. Warrington Library archives contain similar records on the Warrington Blue Coat School, the Warrington National and Sunday schools, the Society of Friends' school at Peniceth, Warrington, and the British and Foreign school. An important and original find were the records kept by many women who had managed girls' schools in every aspect from selecting and employing teachers, fund-raising, curriculum, welfare, discipline, school times and holidays and keeping detailed accounts. The final conclusions were that while provision for educating poor girls was almost always included at the outset, their education could be dispensed with when financial difficulties arose and their curriculum was usually much less ambitious than that for the boys. This study has gone some way to remedy the neglect of the history of educating poor girls that was found in most of the literature. Education of Poor Girls in North West England 6780-1 860 A Study of Warrington and Chester Contents Page Introduction 1 Proposed Research Literature Review 3 The Two Locations 17 Thesis Structure 22 Chanter I Overview of Provision of Education for the Poor 24 Introduction Provision before the Nineteenth Century 25 The Voluntary School Societies 26 Role of the State 27 Church and State 28 Conclusions 37 Chanter H Education Provision in the Region in the Early Nineteenth Century 38 Introduction Charity Provision and Endowments before 1800 39 Educational Revival in the early part of the Nineteenth Century 47 Conclusions 55 Chapter III Developments through the 1 830s and 1 840s 57 Introduction Expansion of School Provision 57 Chester Diocesan Board of Education 64 Rival Schools 66 The Quakers 73 Conclusions 80 1 Chapter IV Women's Involvement in the Education 82 of Poor Girls Introduction Women as Managers 84 Raising and Handling Finance 86 Administration of Schools: Teachers, Pupil Teachers and Curriculum 88 Welfare of Teachers and Pupils 95 Conclusions 102 Conclusions 105 Summary of fmdings and what might follow Notes and References 108 Bibliography 120 11 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS My time as a postgraduate student at the University of Central Lancashire has been a very pleasant experience. This has been largely due to my Director of Studies, Dr Keith Vernon, and my thanks go to him for his unfailing guidance, support and encouragement and for being available to help at almost any time. Without his professional but friendly advice and suggestions this research would not have been completed with so few problems. My second supervisor, Dr Wendy Webster, has read and criticised my written work throughout and her comments have helped me to focus on the important aspects that have emerged from the research. Both offered me support in what at times can be a somewhat lonely task. Other academic staff have been of great help in organising postgraduate events which have provided the opportunity to meet fellow students, broadening my knowledge in a number of ways. The administrative staff have been equally supportive, answering queries and helping to solve personal problems. The library staff were invaluable in guiding me when I had difficulty locating necessary material. In the record offices at Chester and Preston and the library at Warrington the knowledge and helpfulness of the archivists made my research a fruitful and pleasurable experience. St. Deiniol's residential library at Hawarden provided a peaceful haven where it was possible to work without intemiption and where some contemporary research material was to be found. Finally, but most importantly, my grateful thanks go to my husband, Tom, who not only encouraged me throughout but supported me with all kinds of practical help. He has fed me, relieved me of many domestic chores and generally made life very easy while I carried out my research. EDUCATION OF POOR GIRLS IN NORTH WEST ENGLAND c1780 TO 1860 A STUDY OF WARRINGTON AND CHESTER INTRODUCTION AND LITERATURE REVIEW Proposed Research Gender issues in education are raised from time to time when people become concerned about some particular aspect. At the present time in the early twenty-first century there is something approaching panic about the failure of boys to be as successful as girls in attaining acceptable standards in such basic skills as reading and writing. Boys are more disaffected by the school system than girls and the latter are ahead at all levels, now comprising the majority going on into higher education. Measures are being implemented in attempts to rectif' this. The reverse situation obtained in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries when, with a few notable exceptions, less concern was shown for the lack of provision for girls' education or for their withdrawal from school for domestic and other reasons. Even during much of the twentieth century, after the advent of universal and compulsory education, it was often thought a waste of time educating girls who would only work for a short time before marrying and withdrawing into family life. Thus expectations for girls were much lower than those for boys. There has been a growing body of research into the education of girls but much of this has mainly concentrated on the last two or three decades of the nineteenth century and the twentieth century since the sources are deemed to be more plentiful and records more methodically kept than previously. Any work covering earlier decades was more likely to consist of studies of a small selection of, usually middle class girls, and the few women who were pioneering in the field of education for girls. It is intended in this thesis to explore the education of poor girls when mass education began to grow in the late 1700s and early 1800s up to the start of the major move for the state to control all education in the 1850s and 1860s. Definitions of class were beginning to appear and terms used were the 'deserving' poor, the working classes and the middle classes. For the purposes of this research the main subjects will be what were later referred to by the Newcastle Commission in 1861 as the independent poor'. These were artisans, tradesmen and other skilled people, who were not usually extremely poor but often found extras such as education difficult to pay for, so apart from a few references to workhouse provision, there will be little reference to paupers' situations. As will be seen, education provision was frequently for orphans of the independent poor or where one parent had died or for some children of large families. Such education was normally very basic with rarely the opportunity to study science, learn a foreign language or even have history or geography lessons. Their status in life demanded that they should be trained to 'habits of industry', with skills of special use to their betters and future employers. 'Book learning' was seen by many as not suitable for or desired by the poorer classes and parents would lose the earning power of their children. The exception was the belief by many that everyone should be taught to read the Bible for themselves and this was a main motive for establishing many of the schools for the poor. It was believed that reading the Bible would per se lead to good Christian lives and moral behaviour. For those who opposed educating the poor the fear was that the lower classes would also read other material and might try to rise above their station in life. Also there was in the last decades of the eighteenth century a constant fear of revolution as could be seen happening in a number of European countries as in France in 1789. The method will be to focus on two contrasting towns, both now in Cheshire, the city of Chester and the market and manufacturing town of Warrington, which was in Lancashire until boundary changes in 1974. Although it will be seen that girls were generally less well provided for throughout the period in question there is in fact evidence of quite extensive provision at times and in some places. Such provision was also a useful outlet for many women who could not otherwise pursue a career in the same way that their fathers, husbands and brothers could.