Effectiveness of Automatic Section Speed Control System Operating on National Roads in Poland
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ziolkowski R. Effectiveness of Automatic Section Speed Control System Operating on National Roads in Poland ROBERT ZIOLKOWSKI, Ph.D. Traffic Engineering E-mail: [email protected] Preliminary Communication Bialystok University of Technology Submitted: 19 Aug. 2018 Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering Accepted: 5 Apr. 2019 Wiejska 45E, 15-351 Bialystok, Poland EFFECTIVENESS OF AUTOMATIC SECTION SPEED CONTROL SYSTEM OPERATING ON NATIONAL ROADS IN POLAND ABSTRACT injuries, 15% reduction in accidents causing serious Driving speed remains within the most important factors injuries and 20% reduction in accidents involving fa- in road safety, and speed not only affects the severity of a talities (Figure 1). In Poland the consideration of the crash but is also related to the risk of being involved in a driver’s speed focuses mainly on instantaneous speed crash. Inappropriate speed is responsible for more than a investigations conducted on national roads which are third of all fatal accidents occurring on roads. In Poland the characterised by the highest number of deaths and se- problem of speeding drivers is widely present. Hence, effec- vere injuries [7-9]. During the last two decades a num- tive speed management and enforcement of speed limits ber of activities and campaigns towards the improve- on existing roads plays an important role. Possible solutions ment of safety conditions on roads in Poland have for rural roads are very limited and are focused mainly on administrative speed limitations and speed cameras en- been undertaken. Those included among the others forcement. However, due to their limited effectiveness new include: renovations of vertical and horizontal mark- solutions are still being sought. High expectations are as- ings, black spots, speed cameras, road rebuilding, TV sociated with the automatic section speed control system and radio campaigns against speeding and drug driv- that has recently been introduced in Poland. The aim of this ing. However, their results were not satisfied or their ef- paper is to examine the efficiency of the automatic section fectiveness was limited and hence, new solutions are speed control system on the basis of speed surveys collect- still being sought. Since 2011 the Centre for Automat- ed on chosen national roads where the system for sectional ed Traffic Surveillance (CANARD) started to operate. speed control was first implemented. Conducted compar- isons and statistical analyses included driver’s average Its main objective is prevention of the greatest threat speed, speed percentiles, the number of speeding drivers on roads – over-speeding. In 2016 they finalised, sup- as well as speed heterogeneity. To evaluate the efficacy of ported by EU funds, the installation of automatic sec- the sectional speed system, speed measurements were tion speed control system that includes 30 sections also conducted on fourteen, similar in geometry and func- located on national roads in Poland. Similar systems tional characteristics, reference national roads located in already operate in Europe bringing positive effects in Podlaskie voivodship in Poland without any specific speed safety statistics. In the Netherlands and Austria the enforcement. number of fatalities and serious accidents was re- duced by more than 50%. In Italy the effects showed KEY WORDS a reduction of 15% in average speeds, 51% in the traffic management; section speed control; excessive speed; heterogeneity of speed; 100.0 ] % 1. INTRODUCTION [ 80.0 Driving speed remains one of the most important 60.0 factors in road safety, and speed not only affects the 40.0 severity of a crash but is also related to the risk of being involved in a crash [1-4]. According to the International 20.0 Transport Forum [5], unadjusted and excessive speed 0.0 is the main cause of one third of all fatal road crashes -20.0 -15.0 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 -20 e.g. in Ireland, Hungary, Poland, Lithuania. The same All accidents Fatalities conclusions emerge from official statistics published Change in accident/injury rate -40 yearly in Poland by the Police Headquarters [6]. Addi- Light injuries tionally, higher speed involves higher risk of accident -60 Change in speed [%] and possible consequences. Lots of attention is giv- en to an effective speed reduction as 5% reduction Figure 1 – The Power model of the relationship between in speed leads to 10% reduction in accidents causing speed and road safety [2] Promet – Traffic & Transportation, Vol. 31, 2019, No. 4, 435-442 435 Ziolkowski R. Effectiveness of Automatic Section Speed Control System Operating on National Roads in Poland number of fatalities and 27% in the number of the in- and another 14 sections were chosen on national jured. In Norway the reduction of 12% for injury crash- roads running through Podlaskie province and con- es was insignificant, but the number of killed or severe- stituting the reference sections in later comparisons ly injured was significantly reduced by 49% [10-13]. (Figure 2b). In case of automatic section speed control Investigations conducted for this study focused on system, sections of the speed data were gained from sectional speed measurements conducted on several the operator of the system (CANARD – Center for Au- sections of national roads in Poland which were first tomatic Control of Traffic). Speed measurements on equipped with an automatic section speed control sys- those sections were performed with the use of a set tem (ASSC). Investigations included roads where the of two ANPR (Automatic Number Plate Recognition) system has been in operation for at least 12 months, cameras installed on the check points. Vehicles pass- so that the drivers were already familiar with its pres- ing through the check points located at the beginning ence. and end point of every controlled section were detect- The main objective of this study paper was to ex- ed and recorded by video-cameras. Each camera read amine the efficiency of the automatic section speed the vehicle number plate and encrypted it using the control system in rural and built-up areas. The as- cryptology methods. When the vehicle exits the section sessment was conducted in terms of its influence the number plate is again read and matched to the on changes of main speed parameters e.g. average plate captured at the beginning of the section. Using speed, speed percentiles, percent of speeding drivers these two data records and the elapsed time between and speed homogeneity. The speed data were record- them, the system calculated the average speed based ed on road sections with the speed control system and on the length of the section. To evaluate the effective- for comparative analysis on other, similar in geometry ness of the ASSC system for comparative analyses 14 characteristics, national roads located in Podlaskie road sections without any but administrative speed voivodship in Poland. restrictions were chosen. Those sections included six rural road segments with 90 km/h speed limit and 2. RESEARCH AREA AND SPEED eight segments in built-up areas: two segments with a ACQUISITION 70 km/h speed limit and six segments with 50 km/h speed limit. The chosen roads are national ones with Research area included 22 sections of national prevailing long distance travellers so it is believed that roads – eight of them under the surveillance of the such conditions would prevent a situation where lo- automatic section speed control system (Figure 2a) cal habits could interfere with results. All investigated ASSC_4 ASSC_2 NR_1 ASSC_3 NR_12 NR_14 NR_7 NR_8 NR_5 NR_2 ASSC_6 NR_6 ASSC_1 NR_10 ASSC_5 NR_9 NR_11 NR_3 ASSC_7 NR_12 ASSC_8 NR_4 NR_13 a) ASSC sections b) Measurement points on reference national roads in Podlaskie province Figure 2 – Speed measurement sites 436 Promet – Traffic & Transportation, Vol. 31, 2019, No. 4, 435-442 Ziolkowski R. Effectiveness of Automatic Section Speed Control System Operating on National Roads in Poland roads are single carriageway, two-directional roads. To effective solutions of speed management because perform section speed measurements on those seg- administrative speed limits are not very powerful as ments a set of two ANPR cameras was used and mea- one of the basic measures being applied. Their effec- surements were accomplished within one month with tiveness, based on the results presented in Table 1, is an average number of 400 vehicles recorded. highly questionable. The average speed recorded on six rural roads 3. DATA ANALYSES with 90 km/h speed limit was 86.4 km/h and the dif- ference between the highest and the lowest average 3.1 Speed measurements on reference speed value was 13.9%. Even more distinct differenc- national roads in Podlaskie voivedeship es can be observed in terms of 85th and 15th percen- tile. The difference between these parameters related Average speed values collected during the mea- to the average speed can be used to evaluate the het- surements and basic speed parameters are present- erogeneity of speed (SH). The highest and the lowest ed in Table 1. The administrative speed limit for those SH values were achieved for road sections NR_6 and sections was 90 km/h on rural roads and 70 km/h or NR_3 (SH = 22.2% and SH = 11.8%, respectively). 50 km/h in the built-up areas. As a general conclusion In case of national road sections in built-up areas arising from the presented data it can be seen that with implemented local 50 km/h speed limits the lots of drivers did not adjust their driving speed to the average speed was 55.3 km/h and the difference in existing speed limit especially in the built-up areas. In average speed between the highest (NR_14) and the each case, except of road section NR_7 and NR_13, lowest (NR_13) section was 31.8%. High heterogeneity the average speed was above the existing limit.