The Faded Emotions of Scheveningen, Vienna, Waterloo. Remembrance Cultures in the Netherlands in a European Context
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
331 The Faded Emotions of Scheveningen, Vienna, Waterloo. Remembrance cultures in the Netherlands in a European context Beatrice de Graaf 1 Introduction 1 tions are also organised throughout Belgium and the Netherlands to locate other battle fields in the The year 1815 has imprinted itself on the year slipstream of the last Napoleonic resistance be- 2015 with great vigour and variety; and not only tween 1813 and 1815, or to look for lost fortresses because of the hausse in studies, monographs and defence bulwarks that were created during and novels that have been published on the topic these years of European warfare. Traces of that of Vienna, Waterloo, Napoleon, Alexander, etc. strife can still be found just below the surface of Outside this academic scope of interest, there many First World War remembrance sites, simply were huge re-enactment parties at Waterloo and begging for excavation and attention. elsewhere, and ringing public statements from This juxtaposition and interplay of amateur in- ministers and chancellors were disseminated, terest in the historical events of 1815, with appeal- from Vienna to The Hague, from New York to ing novels and romantic stories, straightforward Brazil. All told, these activities definitely ranked archaeological digging and a wave of deft and de- the year 2015 among the most successful celebra- tailed Congress of Vienna publications have cre- tions since 1815. That was especially so in the ated a space of remembrance, of memory and his- Netherlands where the celebrations started in tory that can only be described as multi-layered, 2013 already, with the commemoration of the re- a bit edgy sometimes (when British and German turn of the House of Orange to the Low Countries versions of the Battle of Waterloo clash, for exam- in November 1813, and lasted until 21 September ple), but overall fairly positive in their basic tone. 2015, the bicentennial of the formal coronation of Be it martial, military demonstrations of victor’s King William I. pride, re-enactments of the ‘landing’ of King Wil- The year 1815 is not only back as a memorial liam I on the beach of Scheveningen in 1813 (with moment, it has also returned and re-presented it- live coverage of real helicopters and special forces, self in its material, physical form. For example, to the bewilderment of the historians amongst the Operation Nightingale, a program initiated and spectators)3, or very artful and creative presenta- conducted by British military personnel with tions of Viennese culture, of diplomatic master a background in archaeology, enables veterans craft and European peace-making – everything with posttraumatic stress symptoms to participate was allowed. This eclectic cavalcade of totally in excavations at the site of Waterloo, searching diverse commemorations of the 1813–1815 events for more historical details, the remains of killing was especially visible in the way that the Neth- grounds and tracing battle movements.2 Excava- erlands carried out its bicentennial celebrations. For this country, not only were the defeat of Na- 1 Thanks to John Kok for his assistance with the edit- poleon and the peace-making process of Vienna ing. The research leading to these results has received honoured, the bicentennial of the creation of the funding from the European Research Council under Dutch monarchy, as restoration and promotion the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme of the House of Orange (the former Stadholders), (FP/2007-2013) / ERC Grant Agreement n.615313. 2 Theo TOEBOSCH, Waterloo: Veteranen op het slagveld, in: NRC Handelsblad, 21–22 November 2015; Glasgow 3 (Terug)kijken: de aankomst van prins Willem Frederik archaeologists begin dig at Waterloo battlefield, BBC in Scheveningen, in: NRC Handelsblad, 30 November News, 29 April 2015. 2013. 332 VI. Erinnerungskulturen was also celebrated. In the story of the 1813/15 bi- and consolidate within the limits and confines of centennial, as it was remembered and re-enacted a space demarcated by the sentiments that can be in the Low Countries (the current Netherlands and effectively triggered and mobilized. Populations, Belgium taken together), everything comes to- elites, poets and armies can be aroused and mo- gether: martial and pacifist strands, the Congress bilized, but not to every whim. That is why we of Vienna, the two Paris peace conferences, the introduce the emotional turn in history here. return of the House of Orange, the battle of Water- Elsewhere, I have made the case for applying loo, national and international sentiments, north- this emotional approach to the history of security, ern Dutch and southern Belgian identities. in particular to the history of 1815 and the emer- In this article, I will consider to what extent gence of a European security culture.4 That one’s the year 1815, to be more specific, the years 1813– emotions influence one’s thoughts and behaviour 1815, initiated the establishment of a myth of na- needs little documentation, although how and why tional unity (of the northern and southern parts of they do is a matter of continuing debate. Nonethe- the country) within a context of European peace less, taking the role that emotions have played into and security. I will show how different meanings account when studying the past is increasingly were inscribed in this historical space, how con- recognized as a legitimate historiographic ap- flicting images of national and international, Eu- proach. Although many different and contrasting ropean, and specifically Dutch importance vied understandings still come into play, even on the for dominance, which agents influenced this pro- basic level of what is meant by the ‘emotional turn cess of myth- and memory-making, and in which in history’ and concerning how these emotional guise, in the end, the myth of 1813/15 lived on. states in past times may be accessed, Frevert and In describing this process, there is an intricate others have done much to professionalize the field and inextricable linkage between ‘Scheveningen’, of the study of emotions in history.5 ‘ Vienna’, and ‘Waterloo’ as veritable geographic Windows of opportunity for collective emo- lieux de mémoires. We could argue that Vienna tions to be aroused and mobilized open up espe- had its origin, its reason for being and its mili- cially in times of crisis and upheaval, as in 1813/15. tary foundation in Waterloo, and on the fields of The ‘emotions of 1815’ were a mixed bag of very Flanders. For the making of the Dutch 1813/15- myth, both Waterloo and Vienna started with Scheveningen, symbolizing the return of the Sov- 4 Beatrice DE GRAAF, Bringing Sense and Sensibility ereign Prince, Stadholder William VI (the later to the Continent. Vienna 1815 revisited, in: Journal of King William I). I will describe how the newly Modern European History 13/4 (2015), pp. 447–457. The inaugurated king of the Netherlands, William I, lines that follow are taken from that paper. 5 Cf. Ute FREVERT, Emotions in History. Lost and found, keyed in on the emotional capital of 1813/15 and New York 2011; Ute FREVERT/Monique SCHEER/Anne how under his rule (and that of his heirs) a culture SCHMIdt/Pascal EITLER/Bettina HITZER/Nina VER- of remembrance was created and constructed, piv- HEYEN/Benno GAmmERL/ Christian BAILEY/Margrit oting around the two harbinger moments to their PERNAU, Emotional Lexicons. Continuity and Change houses: national reinstallation (1813) and inter- in the Vocabulary of Feeling 1700–2000, Oxford 2014; Jan PLAMPER, Geschichte und Gefühl. Grundlagen der national confirmation (1815). These moments in- Emotionsgeschichte, München 2012. See also Nicole voked different, even contradictory emotions and EUSTACE/Eugenia LEAN/Julie LIVINGSTON/Jan PLAM- influenced an ambivalent course of remembrance PER/William M. REddY/Barbara H. ROSENWEIN, AHR – only to peter out altogether in the second half of Conversation. The historical Study of Emotions, in: The the 20th century. American Historical Review 117/5 (2012), pp. 1487– 1531. Other attempts have, for example, already ad- dressed the emotion of “trust” in the history of inter- The emotional turn in history and the emo- national relations. Cf. Eric VAN RYTHOVEN, Learning tions of 1813/15 to Feel, Learning to Fear? Emotions, Imaginaries, and Limits in the Politics of Securitization, in: Security Dia- Remembrance cultures are shaped by powerful logue 46/5 (2015), pp. 458–475; Michael TORSTEN, Time agents, by opinion brokers, and by monuments to get Emotional. Phronetic reflections on the concept of trust in international relations; in: European Journal of erected. These cultures can, however, only thrive International Relations 19/4 (2013), pp. 869–890. The Faded Emotions of Scheveningen, Vienna, Waterloo 333 strong sentiments and desires. Feelings of fear and at Vienna, the impressive and illustrious meeting anxiety on the one hand, and a longing for peace, ground of monarchs and emperors at the lavish tranquillity and order on the other, were translated dinners and salons of the Austrian capital, but the into political metaphors (old and new alike) and total dedication and loyalty of a handful of Dutch informed new concepts of and ways of thinking royalists in Holland kept the spirit of the Dutch about international relations. A novelist like Sir independence alive. Not the redistribution and Walter Scott, famous in those days, found audi- rearrangement of the European map and the carv- ences for his nostalgic, romantic and highly ‘his- ing out of bits and pieces amongst the European torical’ works in a time when millions of people diplomats, but the early and timely resurrection of had been affected by the Napoleonic wars, reper- national resistance sealed the fate of the Kingdom. cussions of which had spread from Egypt to Rus- Moreover, the ‘myth of 1813’ especially features sia. In the words of Lukács, “hence the concrete William I, the son of the fugitive Stadholder Wil- possibilities for men to comprehend their own liam V who, on hearing the news of the invading existence as something historically conditioned, Napoleonic armies, fled the country by a shipping for them to see in history something which deeply boat in its darkest hours on 18 January 1795.