Back to the Red Cliff: Reflections on the Narrative Mode in Early Literati Landscape Painting Byjerome Silbergeld
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BACK TO THE RED CLIFF: REFLECTIONS ON THE NARRATIVE MODE IN EARLY LITERATI LANDSCAPE PAINTING BYJEROME SILBERGELD IN 1082, WRITING FROM POLITICAL EXILE IN SOUTH helped illuminate the study of broader topics. China, Su Shi, hao Dongpo @ $$ 9 @ (1037- Yet despite the frequent excursions into this 1101) described a moonlit journey down the material, I propose still another trip back to the Yangzi River past the famous historical battle site Red Cliff. Not only does the "hypnotic effect" of of the Red Cliff. He composed this in the fu ,k@ the topic encourage a periodic retelling, but all or "prose-poem" form, which was popular at the these previous studies still leave some of the most time of that ancient battle, in A.D. 208, and which basic issues unresolved: the authorship and dat- Su helped to revive after centuries of neglect. ' In ing of three major paintings on this theme; which 1601, the chief arbiter of taste for his time, Dong of Su's two prose-poems is illustrated by some of Qichang B g g, wrote on Su Shi's surviving these paintings; and, most importantly, the very manuscript of this "Red Cliff' prose-poem (now relationship of these painted images to the writ- preserved in the National Palace Museum, ten text. What can be learned from an explora- Taibei) , 'This fu of Mr. [Su] Dongpo transforms tion of this topic is broader than might be ex- the Chu Sao $$ & his handwriting transforms the pected, for these questions bear directly on our Orchid Pavilion Manuscript. Of all Song literature, understanding of Chinese literati painting in its this is the ~ltimate."~The spell of Su Shi's "Red formative years. Cliff' prose-poem lingers on in modern times, as described by Lin Yutang: "the poet establishes a prevailing mood that casts a hypnotic effect on The "Qiao Zhongchang " Handsmoll the reader, no matter how many times he has read [it] bef~re."~Even Su Shi himself, having gone At least five Song-period paintings on the ''Red there once and written of it in unforgettable Cliff' topic can still be studied. These include two terms, felt compelled to go back "for another trip versions that, arguably, illustrate the first prose- past the base of the Red Cliff' and risked writing poem: a tall handscroll now attributed to Wu about it a second time.4 Yuanzhi B $$ g of the late twelfth century (fig. The "Red Cliff' poems' theme of political ex- 5; National Palace Museum, Taibei) and a fan by ile had particular resonance in Su Shi's own time, Li Song 3 from the early thirteenth century when the scholar class was deeply rent by faction- (fig. 2; Nelson-Atkins Museum). And there are alism and public service was punctuated by rough three Song handscroll versions of the second dismissal from office. This was still truer in the prose-poem: one attributed to Qiao Zhongchang decades that followed, when half of China was {$ g, probably painted prior to 1123 (fig. 1; conquered by Jin Tartars and many northern Nelson-Atkins Museum); one after an original, scholars became exiles in their own land. Not now missing but (all too loosely) said to be by surprisingly, illustrations of Su's two prose-poems Zhao Bosu Wf @ a (1124-82), copied by Wen appeared almost immediately. Those works initi- Zhengming 2 @ in 1548 (fig. 4; National Pal- ated one of the longest standing pictorial tradi- ace Museum, Taibei);' and one by Ma Hezhi tions, dealing with the theme of political exile, ,% $12 , in the mid-twelfth century (fig. 2; Pal- and they now comprise some of the earliest sur- ace Museum, Beijing).8 Ultimately, it can be viving works in the literati tradition of painting shown which prose-poem each painting is relat- that emerged from the cultural circle of Su Shi ed to, and it can be shown that the paintings in and his friends. each group share a common stylistic source. Prob Popular through the centuries, Su Shi's "Red ably representing the oldest surviving illustration Cliff' prose-poems are now among the most fre- of each prose-poem, the scrolls attributed to Wu quently translated into English of any Chinese Yuanzhi and Qiao Zhongchang are the most im- verse. Paintings based on these poems have been portant of these and represent the focus of this the subject of a number of studies and have study. 20 JEROME SILBERGELD The Qiao Zhongchang attribution (fig. I), art, Li Gonglin 3 /i B9-was recorded in the based on Su's second "Red Cliff' prose-poem, is eighteenth-century imperial catalogue, Ship baqi supposedly the oldest of all these paintings, but ;6 E, in a colophon neither signed nor the work is without signature or artist seals, and even extant today. lo the attribution lacks any substantial evidence. The This historical murk contrasts with the visual oldest inscription, dated 1123, is by Zhao Ling- clarity of the scroll itself, which of all "Red Cliff' zhi Wf + @, a member of the Song royal family scrolls best illustrates the physical setting of Su and a painting collector who in his youth knew Shi's excursions. Of the two pictorial traditions Su Shi; but Zhao wrote only of his feelings for that emerge from Su's two poems, this work es this long-deceased acquaintance and left no clue tablishes for the latter poem a more literal ap- to the artist's identity. The only reference link- proach to the narrative treatment of text, with the ing this scroll to Qao Zhongchang-a cousin and repeated appearance of major figures, architec- painting student of Su Shi's close colleague in ture, and landscape settings in a long, narrative FIG.1 continued. BACK TO THE RED CLIFF 21 FIG.1. Qiao Zhongchang, attributed, LatterProse-Poem on the Red Cliff,handscroll, ink on paper, 29.5 x 560 cm. The Nelson-Atkins Museum. Kansas City. 22 JEROME SILBERGELD format (in nine distinct scenes; Su Shi is depict- and as a reliable guide to a kind of painting Su ed eight times and his home appears three times). himself must have admired. l3 Indeed, then, rath- Not ~erelyconservative, this approach is conspic- er than harboring the unsavory air of a pastiche, uously archaistic, adopting Li Gonglin's mode of this scroll reveals the ways in which, and the strik- reference to Six Dynasties and Tang narrative ing degree to which, the leading Yuan scholar traditions. The spatial treatment of architecture painters based their trademark styles-perhaps and many of the landscape motifs clearly dem- their whole landscape "revolution"-on Song pre- onstrate a knowledge of Tang painting, asJames cedents by Su Shi, Li Gonglin, and friends. Cahill suggested in describing "the strong bilat- An old-fashioned narrative following step by eral symmetry of the house and yard near the step the sequence of the second "Red Cliff'prose- end," "the strange shell-like forms of Qiao poem, the so-called Qiao Zhongchang painting Zhongchang's rocks," and "the square-cut formal- visually introduces, with greater credibility than ized drawing of fractured rock strata." l1 Even the can be found anywhere else, the setting for Su peculiarly modulated brushwork used for the Shi's Red Cliff excursions. By 1079, Su had spent rocks makes a knowing statement about mid- a decade in outspoken opposition to the politi- Tang traditions, and the looming scale of the poet cal reforms designed by Wang Anshi 3 9 6, compared to his diminutive companions looks reforms which would have reshaped the nature back to earlier norms. of Chinese government had they succeeded and Beyond the lack of proper documentation, the which from Su's "conservative" point of view chief connoisseurial problem obscuring the date would have undermined the hallowed indepen- and attribution of this work--or at least instill- dence of the Confucian scholar-official. In that ing my own doubts about them-arises from its year, his political adversaries charged Su with writ- more progressive features, from artistic details ing poetry "slanderous" of the emperor (that is, that too clearly anticipate later literati painters, of opposing Wang's policies, which the emperor especially those of the mid-to-late Yuan. Some of then favored), and he was cast into the imperial these progressive characteristics have already censorate prison for 130 days. In December, af- been noted by Cahill-willows like Zhao Meng- ter a lengthy trial and imperial review of the case, fu's Wf j& and Wang Meng's E and low, Su was demoted to low rank and ordered into rolling hills like Huang Gongwang's % fi %.I2 exile under tight travel restrictions. l4 Soon after In addition, there are texture strokes (at the very arriving in the small, rustic town of Huangzhou beginning and end) distinctively like Huang % $11 in February 1080, Su (and his family, which Gongwang's, slender tree trunks like Ni Zan's arrived shortly after) lived at a government way- B,thick-trunked pines like Wang Meng's, station intended to house officials traveling up Zhang Wu's 5 @, or Yao Tingmei's j& s, and down the Yangzi River. Located beneath a dried-mud embankments derived perhaps from hill known as Lin'gao g$ @ and set just a "few the Li-Guo 3-3 tradition by way of Huang Gong- dozen steps" above the north bank of the Yangzi wang, a bridge drawn just like one by Wang Meng, River, this crude abode was distinguished not by and so forth. Looked at from a skeptical perspec- its architecture but by a lovely view of the river tive, this work assumes the aura of a pastiche.