Feeding Habits, Food Requirements, and Status of Bering Sea Marine Mammals
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FEEDING HABITS, FOOD REQUIREMENTS, AND STATUS OF BERING SEA MARINE MAMMALS NORTH PACIFIC FISHERY MANAGEMENT COUNCIL P. 0. Box 103136 ANCHORAGE, ALASKA 99510 November 1, 1982 Cotmcil Document 1119 Prepared By Alaska Department of Fish and Game Fairbanks, Alaska Alaska Department of Fish and Gaine Anchorage, Alaska and University of Washington Seattle, Washington Ftmded by NOAA/NMFS 1.0 TITLE PAGE FINAL REPORT TO; North Pacific Fishery Management Co1mcil P.O. Box 3136 DT Anchorage, Alaska 99510 CONTRACT NO.: 81-4 TITLE: FEEDING HABITS, FOOD REQUIREMENTS, AND STATUS OF BERING SEA MARINE MAMMALS PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATORS: Lloyd F. Lowryl, Kathryn J. Frostl, Donald G. Calkins2i Gordon L. Swartzman3, and Susan Hills 1 November 1982 1 Alaska Department of Fish and Game, 1300 College Road, Fairbanks, Alaska 99701 2 Alaska Department of Fish and Game, 333 Raspberry Road, Anchorage Alaska 99502 3 University of Washington, Center for Quantitative Science, Seattle, Washington 98195 2 2 .O PREFACE The history of human interaction with marine resources shows a consistent pattern of discovery and overexploitation, usually followed by programs of conservation or protection which often result in recovery of depleted stocks. This pattern applies equally well to populations of fishes, shellfishes, and marine mammals. Although many aspects of population ecology of exploited species are poorly known, there is little doubt that human intervention has been a major factor in most population declines. Observations made during exploitation and subsequent recovery of stocks have provided a considerable body of empirical information which has formed the basis for management programs applied to commercial marine resources. Such single-species management, although preferable to unregulated exploitation, has limited utility since each species obviously interacts with many other organisms and environmental factors. This has led to the widespread adoption of ecosystem-based management as the framework on which to base present and future resource exploitation decisions. Unfortunately, although intellectually appealing and already incorporated into management philosophies, ecosystem-based management has yet to become a practical reality. However, that has not reduced the desire of concerned individuals and agencies to consider ecological interactions among animals and their environment when planning for conservation and management of resources. In the United States, two relatively recent pieces of federal legislation, the Fishery Conservation and Management Act (FCMA) of 1976 and the Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972, have had a marked effect on management of marine fisheries and mammals. Although both endorse and encourage ecosystem-based management, the former stresses development of programs for utilization of fishery resources, while the latter emphasizes protection of marine mammal species, a difference which generally reflects prevailing public opinion in this nation. Since many marine mammals feed on commercially exploitable fishes and shellfishes, they obviously may affect and be affected by commercial fisheries and fishery management plans. Although such biological interactions between marine mammals and fisheries undoubtedly occur throughout the waters regulated under the FCMA, much attention has been focused on the situation in the Bering Sea. The Bering Sea, which supports what is probably the most diverse marine mammal fauna of any of the world's oceans, has long been exploited for its rich fishery resources. As management plans, mandated by the FCMA, began to be developed for those fisheries, attempts were made to incorporate ecosystem-level consideration of interactions between marine mammals and fishery resources. Those considerations were only partially successful due principally to the lack of an organized data base on marine mammals and the absence of a functional framework with which to consider the magnitude and implications of possible interactions. In 3 response, the North Pacific Fishery Management Council, in conjunction with the Marine Mammal Commission, issued a contract to the Alaska Department of Fish and Game to compile, summarize, and evaluate available marine mammal data; examine and evaluate existing Bering Sea ecosystem models; and provide suggestions for directing future research on marine mammal-fishery interactions in the Bering Sea. Our attempts to attain these objectives have resulted in the lengthy report which follows. For a number of reasons our task has been far from simple. The short time allotted to this project, approximately 9 months, has precluded an orderly consideration of much of the information we have located. For example, in some instances we have had to discover references, request them from foreigrt scientists, and have them translated before they could be included in species summaries, evaluated, and considered in the development of a research plan. The number of marine mammal species included in this review (26) is largely responsible for the sheer bulk of the report and the intensive effort required for its preparation. Lastly, this is the first review of its type dealing with biological interactions among marine mammals and fisheries in the Bering Sea. The subjects of marine mammal-fishery interactions in general and density-dependent responses of marine mammals have only recently begun to receive significant attention. Available reports on these subjects, although in some instances useful summaries of existing information, fall far short of providing a comprehensive framework with which to evaluate the Bering Sea situation. We therefore consider this report as a working document rather than a definitive statement which adequately describes or resolves the question of interactions between marine mammals and fisheries in the Bering Sea. Certainly we have missed some existing relevant information and more is being produced virtually daily. Users of the report will undoubtedly differ as to their opinion regarding its usefulness. We have of necessity resorted to generalizations when summarizing available data and assume that those requiring more detailed information can and will access the referenced literature. We hope that our considerations and assessments will serve to focus attention and future research in such a way that concrete progress can be made in the consideration of how marine mammals and fisheries may affect one another. It is disappointing to be able to say at present little more than that marine mammals eat fishes that fishermen would like to catch and that fishermen catch fish that marine mammals otherwise might eat. 4 3 .O EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report is a compilation, summary, and evaluation of available data on feeding habits, food requirements, and status of Bering Sea marine mammals. Included are an annotated bibliography, a research plan designed to fill major data gaps, and a discussion of the utility of data for assessing interactions among marine mammals and commercial fisheries in the Bering Sea/Aleutian Islands region. Considered in the report are 26 species of marine mammals, including eight species of baleen whales, eight toothed whales, eight pinnipeds, and two carnivores. Although for most species it is possible to generally describe the foods eaten in the Bering Sea, with the exception of the northern fur seal, data are not adequate for determining the quantitative composition of the diet. Estimates of food requirements generated by one of several methods are also usually available but are of unknown reliability in most instances. Measurements of indicators of population status are accompanied by natural and sampling variability, the magnitude of which is often large or unknown. Although there can be little doubt that some marine mammals compete with commercial fisheries, there is no conclusive evidence to show how marine mammals may affect and be affected by fisheries in the Bering Sea. A variety of techniques can be used for assessing interactions among marine mammals and commercial fisheries. Estimates of quantities of fishes consumed by marine mammals are useful for comparison with fishery harvests and are required as inputs for the NMFS Bering Sea ecosystem model DYNUMES/PROBUB. However, such estimates are not presently reliable due to the usual lack of necessary data and possible variability associated with available information. Attempts to correlate changes in marine mammal population status with activities of fisheries have not to date been successful. Correlations of this type are unlikely to be conclusive due to the difficulty of obtaining needed information with adequate accuracy. Ecosystem models and simulations, while appealing since they could allow predictions of interactions and effects, are not yet adequately developed and tested. Available data are adequate to produce a conceptual assessment of the likelihood of significant interactions with present and potential fisheries based on general considerations of feeding habits and population status of marine mammals. This assessment produced the following categories: high probability of interaction--northern fur seal, Steller sea lion, harbor seal, spotted seal, belukha, harbor porpoise, and sea otter; moderate probability of interaction--gray whale, walrus, Dall's porpoise, ribbon seal, and bearded seal; and low probability of interaction--killer whale, minke whale, beaked whales, polar bear, fin whale, blue whale, sei whale, humpback whale, bowhead whale, right whale, and sperm whale. The research