PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev

Original language: English PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2)

CONVENTION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN ENDANGERED SPECIES OF WILD FAUNA AND FLORA ______

Twenty-second meeting of the Plants Committee Tbilisi (Georgia), 19-23 October 2015

Strategic matters

Cooperation with other biodiversity-related multilateral environmental agreements

COOPERATION WITH THE GLOBAL STRATEGY FOR PLANT CONSERVATION OF THE CONVENTION ON BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY (RESOLUTION CONF. 16.5)

1. This document has been submitted by the Representative of North America (Mr. Hesiquio Benitez) as Chair of the intersessional working group on ‘Cooperation with the Global Strategy for Plant Conservation [GSPC] of the Convention on Biological Diversity [CBD] (Resolution Conf. 16.5)’, in collaboration with the Mexican Scientific Authority (CONABIO).*

Background

2. At the 21st meeting of the Plants Committee (PC21, Veracruz, May 2014), Mr. Benitez introduced document PC21 Doc. 8.2 con “Cooperation with the Global Strategy for Plant Conservation of the Convention on Biological Diversity (Res. Conf. 16.5)”.

3. Following consideration of document PC21 Doc. 8.2, and on the basis of the recommendations included in it, the Plants Committee:

3.1. Noted Resolution Conf. 16.5 and the “List of potential CITES activities and products and their contribution of the objectives and targets of the updated Global Strategy for Plant Conservation 2011- 2020” in its Annex.

3.2 Encouraged Parties to report on progress with their implementation of Res. Conf. 16.5 to the regional representatives of the Committee.

3.3. Agreed that the chair of the intersessional working group on GSPC (the representative of North America, Mr. Hesiquio Benitez), in consultation with the Secretariat, present a report at the present meeting of the Plants Committee on progress with implementation of Res. Conf. 16.5. And,

3.4. Established an intersessional working group on GSPC, with the following mandate and membership:

3.4.1 Mandate:

a) Monitor compliance with the recommendations formulated by the PC at its 21st meeting regarding the implementation of Res. Conf. 16.5; and

* The geographical designations employed in this document do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the CITES Secretariat (or the United Nations Environment Programme) concerning the legal status of any country, territory, or area, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The responsibility for the contents of the document rests exclusively with its author.

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 1 b) Prepare a progress report for review at PC22.

3.4.2. Membership:

a) Chair: Representative of North America (Mr. Benitez)

b) Members: Representatives of Africa (Ms. Khayota), Asia (Mr. Fernando), Central and South America and the Caribbean (Ms. Rivera) and Oceania (Mr. Leach), and Alternate representative of Europe (Mr. Carmo);

c) Parties: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and United States of America; and

d) IGOs and NGOs: UNEP-WCMC, International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), Botanical Gardens Conservation International and TRAFFIC International.

Progress achieved by the working group

4. The working group focused on reporting the contribution to all CITES-relevant targets of the GSPC, in this sense and based on Annex of Res. Conf. 16.5, the following targets were not addressed:

CITES potential contribution GSPC Target (according to Annex to Res. Conf. 16.5) 4. At least 15% of each ecological region or vegetation type Not directly applicable, as CITES works at secured through effective management and/or restoration. species level. 5. At least 75% of the most important areas for plant diversity of each ecological region protected with effective management in place for conserving plants and their genetic diversity. 6. At least 75% of production lands in each sector managed sustainably, consistent with the conservation of plant diversity. 9. 70% of the genetic diversity of crops including their wild Not directly applicable. relatives and other socio-economically valuable plant species conserved, while respecting, preserving and maintaining associated indigenous and local knowledge. 10. Effective management plans in place to prevent new biological Not directly applicable. Nevertheless, invasions and to manage important areas for plant diversity CITES Parties have recognized the link that are invaded between trade and alien invasive species in Resolution Conf. 13.10 (Rev. CoP14) on Trade in alien invasive species.

5. For all the remaining Targets (i.e. CITES-relevant GSPC targets), and in order to prepare the progress report of its mandate, on July 15th 2015 the working group consulted the Management and Scientific Authorities to all CITES Parties through the communication DGCII-322/2015, requesting them to fill in a questionnaire by August 10th 2015.

6. At the time of preparing the present document, the following 34 Parties had responded to the questionnaire:

1) Argentina 15) Italy 28) Seychelles 2) Austria 16) Jamaica 29) Slovakia 3) Brasil 17) Mexico 30) Spain 4) Bulgaria 18) Monaco 31) Switzerland 5) Chile 19) Montenegro 32) Turkey 6) Colombia 20) Montserrat 33) United Kingdom of 7) Costa Rica 21) Netherlands Great Britain and 8) Cuba 22) New Zealand Northern Ireland 9) Czech Republic 23) Norway (including 10) Denmark 24) Panama Overseas 11) Ecuador 25) Peru Territories, UKOTs) 12) Finland 26) Portugal 34) United States of 13) Greece 27) Republic of America 14) Honduras Moldova

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 2 7. Furthermore, by request of the Chair of the working group the Secretariat has prepared a report on its contribution to the implementation of Targets 1-3 and 14-16 of GSPC (Annex 4).

8. Based on the inputs derived from the consultation to Parties, as well as the report prepared by the Secretariat (Annex 4), the Chair of the working group has prepared a “Draft report of CITES contribution on the implementation of GSPC 2011-2020 (Res. Conf. 16.5)” available in Annex 3 to the present document, which also includes a preliminary assessment of CITES performance for on the implementation of each of GSPC’s Objectives.

9. It is important to note that the Chair of the GPSC Working Group found that Target 13 (Indigenous and local knowledge innovations and practices associated with plant resources, maintained or increased, as appropriate, to support customary use, sustainable livelihoods, local food security and health care) was challenging to keep track of from a CITES perspective, and for now has not been considered by the draft report (Annex 3); yet this can be reconsidered in the process of updating said report.

Recommendation to the Plants Committee

10. Take note of the draft report in Annex 3 of the present document, and make recommendations to the working group aimed to improve it, and agree to present its final version for consideration of CoP17.

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 3 PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) Annex 1

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 4

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 5 PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) Annex 2

Questionnaire on the implementation of Res. Conf. 16.5: “Cooperation with the Global Strategy for Plant Conservation [GSPC] of the Convention on Biological Diversity”1

Party: Institution: Authority: [Specify if Management Authority, Scientific Authority, or other] Contact information of the person Name who fills the questionnaire Email Phone Other:

Please provide the following information:

1. Related to GSPC’s Target 1 1.1. Which of the CITES listed plants native to your country are described online*:

Species Appendix Hyperlink(s) Observations

*Add rows as needed

1.2. Of the species listed above, what percentage do they represent in comparison to the estimated total of the known CITES listed plants native to your country? %

2. Related to GPSC’s Targets 7 and 8 Of the total number of plant species listed under CITES’ Appendix I (approx. 360), which are currently under in situ and/or ex situ conservation schemes in your country, as follows*:

Appendix I species Conservation schemes Observations In situ Ex situ [yes/no] [yes/no]

*Add rows as needed

1 The present questionnaire is focused on the Targets of the GSPC 2011-2020 (https://www.cbd.int/gspc/strategy.shtml) most relevant to CITES Parties, as recognized in the Annex to Res. Conf. 16.5 (http://www.cites.org/eng/res/16/16-05.php).

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 6

3. Related to GSPC’s Target 12 Indicate which CITES plant species native to your country (and subject to international trade) are managed through sustainable use practices:*

Species Appendix Non-detriment Quota Other finding (NDF) [yes/no] [yes/no]

*Add rows as needed.

4. Additional remarks on the contributions of your country to the implementation of Res. Conf. 16.5:

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 7 PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) Annex 3

“Draft report on CITES contribution to the implementation of GSPC 2011-2020 (Res. Conf. 16.5)”2

The present draft is based on the information provided by the 34 Parties that responded to the questionnaire in Annex 2, and the report of the Secretariat in Annex 4.

Objective I: Plant diversity is well understood, documented and recognized 1.1. Of the 34 responding Parties: a) 15 Parties reported that around 80-100% of their native CITES-listed plants have online descriptions, namely: Austria, Brazil, Bulgaria, Chile, Colombia (according to the information provided by its Scientific Authority), Czech Republic, Greece, Italy, Mexico, Montserrat, Norway, Portugal, Switzerland, UK, and USA. In most of these cases, the majority of the hyperlinks provided represented national-managed online platforms. b) 2 Parties reported that around 50-70% of their native CITES-listed plants have online descriptions, these were: Finland and Peru. c) 10 Parties reported that around 0.10-25% of their native CITES listed plants have online descriptions, these were: Argentina, Costa Rica, Cuba, Ecuador, 1. Target 1: Honduras, Panamá, Republic of Moldova, An online flora of all known plants Seychelles, Spain, and Montenegro. The links on the species with online descriptions (according to Parties responses) can be consulted in the spreadsheet in Annex 5 of the present document. 1.2. Furthermore (as provided by the Secretariat), CITES has the following publications or checklists available: a) Checklist of CITES Species– 2013: http://checklist.cites.org/#/en b) CITES Wiki Identification Manual: https://www.cites.org/eng/resources/wiki_id.php c) Kew Garden CITES references for plants: http://www.kew.org/data/cites.html d) Piante Grasse - (publication of the “Associazione Italiana Amatori delle piante Succulente”) – Volume 9 e) Piante Grasse - Volume 12 f) Species+ Database: http://www.speciesplus.net/ According to the Secretariat’s report, since CoP13 to the date: a) 36 Appendix I species have been selected under the 2. Target 2: Periodic Review of the Appendices process (PR), of which: An assessment of the conservation 5 have completed reviews (with a PC document to support status of all known plant species, as with the supporting statement); and 31 have ongoing far as possible, to guide conservation reviews (which include 7 species of Sclerocactus spp., with action the results of the PR to be presented for consideration of the present meeting of the Plants Committee [PC22, Georgia 2015]).

2 As mentioned in the present document, Targets 4-6 and 9-10 are not reported here since CITES has no direct contribution to them, as recognized by Res. Conf. 16.5.

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 8 b) 69 Appendix II species have been selected under the PR, of which: 8 have completed reviews (whether a decision to retain, amend their listings) with a PC document or amendment proposal with the supporting statement; 1 review was suspended; and the remaining 60 are ongoing (including 7 species of Sclerocactus spp. with the results of the PR to be presented for consideration of PC22). c) During the reported period, 118 plant species have been under review by the Significant Trade process (ST), all of them with results recorded in PC working documents. d) A total of 95 plant taxa have been the target of a 3. Target 3: successfully adopted amendment proposal, as follows: 16 Information, research and associated correspond to amendment proposals related solely to outputs, and methods necessary to annotations (amendment of existing annotations, or implement the Strategy developed merging thereof, inclusion of certain populations in App. II); and shared 1 resulted in the deletion from App. I; 34 resulted in the deletion from Ap. II; 1 resulted in the transfer from Appendix II to I; 3 resulted in the transfer from Appendix I to II; 40 resulted in the inclusion under Appendix II. Furthermore, the UNEP-WCMC trade database represents one of the main sources of information, that serves as the basis of the analysis that guide the decision making processes for CITES plant listed species, mainly: Significant Trade (Res. Conf. 12.8 [Rev. CoP13]), Periodic Review (Res. Conf. 14.8 [Rev. CoP16]), Amendments to the Appendices (Res. Conf. 9.24 [Rev. CoP16)]. Preliminary assessment of CITES performance in contributing to Good Objective I:

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 9

Objective II: Plant diversity is urgently and effectively conserved Regarding the approximately 300 plant species currently listed in Appendix I (an based solely on the 34 responding Parties): a) Around 34 plant taxa are currently protected under in situ 7. Target 7: conservation schemes in any of the following 13 countries: At least 75 per cent of known Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Cuba, threatened plant species conserved in Finland, Italy, Mexico, Panamá, Peru, UK, and USA. situ. b) Furthermore, 5 Parties mentioned having no native Appendix I species in their countries: Austria, Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Montserrat, and Norway. 8. Target 8: Similarly, regarding the approximately 300 plant species At least 75 per cent of threatened currently listed in Appendix I, around 33 taxa are currently plant species in ex situ collections, known to be protected under ex situ conservation schemes in preferably in the country of origin, and any of the following 13 countries: Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, at least 20 per cent available for Cuba, Ecuador, Finland, Greece, Italy, México, Monaco, recovery and restoration programmes. Panamá, Peru, and the UK. Preliminary assessment of CITES performance in contributing to Perfectible Objective II:

Objective III: Plant diversity is used in a sustainable and equitable manner 11.1. Listings under CITES Appendices (https://cites.org/eng/app/appendices.php), applicable to the 180 Parties to the Convention: a) Approximately 300 plant species are currently listed under Appendix I of CITES. Their trade is regulated by the applicable provisions of the Convention, in particular: Art. III (and other related Resolutions and Decisions; particularly Res. Conf. 16.7 on non- detriment findings, or NDFs). 11. Target 11: b) Approximately 29,600 plant species are listed under No species of wild flora endangered Appendix II of CITES. Their trade is regulated by the by international trade applicable provisions of the Convention, in particular: Art. IV (and other related Resolutions and Decisions; particularly Res. Conf. 16.7 on non-detriment findings, or NDFs). c) Approximately 12 plant species are listed under Appendix III of CITES. Their trade is regulated by the applicable provisions of the Convention, in particular: Art. V (and other related Resolutions and Decisions). 11.2. Furthermore, all the information reported under this Annex contributes to the implementation of Target 11. 12 Target 12: a) Of the 34 responding Parties, 11 specifically mentioned that All wild harvested plant-based under their domestic legislation, all Appendix I and II CITES products sourced sustainably. listed species are subject to the Conventions provisions related to the formulation of non-detriment findings (NDFs) in compliance with the provisions of Arts. II and IV of the Convention, as well as Res. Conf. 16.7; most of them specified that the formulation of NDFs is made on a case by case basis. This, in addition to the domestic measures set in place which might include the implementation of stricter measures. These Parties were: Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Ecuador, Honduras, Jamaica, Mexico, New Zealand, Peru,

UK, and USA. b) Similarly, 6 countries explicitly mentioned the establishment of quotas for a total of around 400 Appendix I and II taxa. These countries were: Bulgaria, Colombia, Ecuador, Jamaica, Peru, and Republic of Moldova. However this might represent a strong underestimation of CITES plant species with established quotas at a national level. c) Furthermore, CITES website hosts sections to aid

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 10 compliance to its provisions, such as:  NDF Section, where Parties can find the most updated information and guidance on the formulation of NDFs for species listed under Appendices I and II: https://cites.org/eng/prog/ndf/index.php  The 2015 national export quotas available at: https://cites.org/sites/default/files/common/quotas/2015/ ExportQuotas2015.pdf d) Regarding the regulation of main specimens in trade, there are around 15 annotations in the Appendices relevant to plant species, which are focused on regulating the main specimens in trade. Preliminary assessment of CITES performance in contributing to Good Objective III:

Objective IV: Education and awareness about plant diversity, its role in sustainable livelihoods and importance to all life on earth is promoted 14. Target 14: On the CITES Virtual College Parties can find courses, The importance of plant diversity and reference materials and training slides that, although no the need for its conservation specific to flora, can provide a strong platform to train Parties incorporated into communication, on how CITES works. education and public awareness programmes. 15. Target 15: The number of trained people working with appropriate facilities sufficient according to national needs, to achieve the targets of this Strategy. Preliminary assessment of CITES performance in contributing to Objective Perfectible IV:

Objective V: The capacities and public engagement necessary to implement the Strategy have been developed 16. Target 16: Although the CITES Secretariat has formalized the cooperation Institutions, networks and with numerous institutions, international organizations and partnerships for plant conservation multilateral environmental agreements, the existing MoUs do established or strengthened at not focus on flora matters only. They address general national, regional and international cooperation for all CITES species (animals and plants) or for levels to achieve the targets of this animal species and, none of them is specific for plant species. Strategy. Preliminary assessment of CITES performance in contributing to Perfectible Objective V:

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 11 PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) Annex 4

Overview of the Secretariat’s capacity building materials with emphasis on the activities related to the GSPC and Resolution Conf. 16.5 on Cooperation with the Global Strategy for Plant Conservation of the Convention on Biological Diversity

1- This Annex has been prepared by the Secretariat under request of the Chair of the intersessional working group on the GSPC. It provides examples of capacity building materials and tools available on the CITES website. The Secretariat is aware that many other capacity building materials and tools have been developed by, and are available from, Parties.

GSPC’s Targets

2- GSPC’s Target 1: An online flora of all known plants. Resume of CITES publications or checklists available on the CITES website:

a- Checklist of CITES Species – 2013

b- Identification Manual – Fauna and Flora

c- Piante Grasse - (publication of the “Associazione Italiana Amatori delle piante Succulente”) – Volume 9

d- Piante Grasse - Volume 12

e- CITES Identification Guides

f- Kew Garden CITES references for plants

3- GSPC’s Target 2 and 3: Conservation status of all known plant species…and…Information to implement the Strategy: Resume of amendment proposals and periodic review as well as the Review of Significant Trade since CoP13 (2004) to date is shown in Table below.

4- GSPC’s Target 14 and 15: List of CITES tools that are available on the CITES website on flora:

On the CITES Virtual College Parties can find courses, reference materials and training slides that, although no specific to flora, can provide a strong platform to train Parties on how CITES works.

5- GSPC’s Target 16: List of MoUs on partnerships that the CITES Secretariat has formalized for plant conservation on flora matters, including a brief description of each:

Although the CITES Secretariat has formalized the cooperation with numerous institutions, international organizations and multilateral environmental agreements, the existing MoUs do not focus on flora matters only. They address general cooperation for all CITES species (animals and plants) or for animal species and, none of them is specific for plant species.

PC22 Doc. 7.2 (Rev. 2) – p. 12

Table Summary of Periodic Review proposals submitted to CoPs for amendments to Appendices I and II (Article XV of the Convention), taxa selected for Periodic Review of species included in Appendices I and II [Resolution Conf. 14.8 (Rev. CoP16)] and Review of Significant Trade in specimens of Appendix-II species [Resolution Conf. 12 (Rev. CoP13)] since CoP13 to date

Periodic Review Sig. Trade status and Review Amendment Per. Review 3 Amendment recommendation and PC Higher taxa Genus / Species App proposal submitted record Proposal [para j /Res. mtg to CoP document (Conf.14.8 selecting Rev. CoP16)] taxa

P ANACARDIACEAE Operculicarya decaryi II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 22 no no

Operculicarya decaryi II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 51 no no

Doc.

Operculicarya hyphaenoides II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 23 no no

Operculicarya pachypus II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 24 no no

7.2 (Rev. 2)

APOCYNACEAE Hoodia spp. II Inclusion in App. II CoP 13 Prop 37 no no Amendment of

Hoodia spp. II CoP16 Prop. 52 no no annotation

– Hoodia gordonii II no PC21

Pachypodium bispinosum II no PC15

Selected between

Pachypodium brevicaule II CoP 15 & CoP17. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

Pachypodium namaquanum II no PC19

Pachypodium succulentum II no PC15

Rauvolfia serpentina II no PC15

AGAVACEAE Selected between

Agave arizonica not listed Deletion from App. I CoP14 Prop. 22 CoP13 & 15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review stopped.

3 CITES listing in July 2015 4 Hyperlinks attached to the species names are linked to the Review of Significant Trade Management System

Selected between

Agave parviflora I CoP13 & 15, Retain PC21 Doc. 19.1 no in Appendix I Selected between

P Agave victoriae-reginae II CoP13 & 15, Retain PC21 Doc. 19.1 no C2 in Appendix II

Doc. Selected between Transfer from App. I to

Nolina interrata II CoP14 Prop. 23 CoP13&CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no App. II

Proposal at CoP14

7.2 (Rev. 2)

Yucca queretaroensis II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 50 no no

AMARYLLIDACEAE Galanthus elwesii no PC21 ARALIACEAE Panax ginseng and Panax Amendment of the

– II CoP16 Prop. 53 no no quinquefolius annotation

14 BROMELIACEAE Selected between

CoP13 & CoP16.

Tillandsia harrisii II PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Present listing in II appropriate. Selected between

Tillandsia kautskyi not listed Deletion from App. II CoP16 Prop. 54 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

Selected between CoP13& CoP15 and

Tillandsia kammii II yes PC21 Doc. 19.1 no reselected between CoP15 & CoP17

Selected between CoP13& CoP15 and

Tillandsia mauryana II yes PC21 Doc. 19.1 no reselected between CoP15 & CoP17

Selected between

Tillandsia sprengeliana not listed Deletion from App. II CoP16 Prop. 55 CoP13&CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Proposal at CoP16 Selected between

P Tillandsia sucrei not listed Deletion from App. II CoP16 Prop. 56 CoP13&CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no C2 Proposal at CoP16

CACTACEAE CACTACEAE spp. and all taxa Delete annotations #1

Doc.

II CoP15 Prop. 25 no no with annotation #1 and #4

7.2 (Rev. 2) Carnegiea gigantea II no PC21 Pereskia spp. and

not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop. 24 no no Quiabentia spp. Selected between

Pereskia aculeate not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

– CoP13& CoP15

p. Selected between

15 Pereskia aureiflora not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

Selected between

Pereskia bahiensis not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskia bleo not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskia diaz-romeroana not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskia grandifolia not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskia guamacho not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskia horrida not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskia lychnidiflora not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

Selected between

Pereskia marcanoi not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskia nemorosa not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

P Selected between

C2 Pereskia portulacifolia not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

Doc. Selected between

Pereskia quisqueyana not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

7.2 (Rev. 2) Selected between

Pereskia sacarosa not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskia stenantha not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

– Selected between

Pereskia weberiana not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no p. CoP13& CoP15 16 Selected between

Pereskia zinniiflora not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop.24 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

Pereskiopsis spp. not listed Deletion from App.II CoP14 Prop. 25 no no Selected between

Pereskiopsis aquosa not listed Deletion from App.II CoP14 Prop. 25 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskiopsis blakeana not listed Deletion from App.II CoP14 Prop. 25 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskiopsis diguetii not listed Deletion from App.II CoP14 Prop. 25 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskiopsis kellermanii not listed Deletion from App.II CoP14 Prop. 25 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskiopsis porteri not listed Deletion from App.II CoP14 Prop. 25 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Pereskiopsis rotundifolia not listed Deletion from App.II CoP14 Prop. 25 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

Selected between

Pereskiopsis spathulata not listed Deletion from App.II CoP14 Prop. 25 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

Sclerocactus brevihamatus II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

P Review ongoing.

C2 Selected between

Sclerocactus erectocentrus I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

Doc. Review ongoing.

7.2 (Rev. 2) Selected between

Sclerocactus glaucus I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

Sclerocactus intertextus II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

–

Review ongoing.

17 Selected between

Sclerocactus johnsonii II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

Sclerocactus mariposensis I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

Sclerocactus mesae-verdae I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

Sclerocactus nyensis I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

Sclerocactus papyracan-thus I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

Selected between

Sclerocactus parviflorus II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

P Sclerocactus polyancistrus II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no C2 Review ongoing.

Doc. Selected between

Sclerocactus pubispinus I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

Review ongoing.

7.2 (Rev. 2) Selected between

Sclerocactus scheeri II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

Selected between

–

Sclerocactus sileri II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

p. Review ongoing.

Selected between

Sclerocactus spinosior II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. CACTACEAE and Cactaceae spp. (#4) and Merging and ORCHIDACEAE Orchidaceae spp. (#8) in

II amendment of CoP14 Prop. 26 no no Appendix II, and all taxa annotations annotated with annotation #1

Adonis vernalis, Guaiacum spp., Hydrastis canadensis, Nardostachys grandiflora, Panax ginseng, Panax quinquefolius,

C2 Picrorhiza kurrooa, Podophyllum

2 hexandrum, Pterocarpus Amendments of the

Doc. santalinus, Rauvolfia serpentina, II CoP14 Prop. 27 no no annotations Taxus chinensis, T. fuana,

7.2 (Rev. 2) T. cuspidata, T. sumatrana, T. wallichiana,Orchidaceae spp. in Appendix II, and all Appendix-II and -III taxa annotated with annotation #1

–

p. COMPOSITAE Selected between

Saussurea costus I CoP13 & CoP15. PC19 SumRec . no

Retain in App. I CRASSULACEAE Dudleya stolonifera and Dudleya Selected between

not listed Deletion from App. II CoP16 Prop. 57 PC21 Doc. 19.1 no traskiae CoP15 & CoP16

CUCURBITACEAE Zygosicyos pubescens II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 26 no no

Zygosicyos tripartitus II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 27 no no CYCADACEAE Selected between CoP 15 and

Cycas beddomei I PC20-SumRec no COP17. Retain in Appendix I DIAPENSIACEAE Selected between

Shortia galacifolia not listed Deletion from App. II CoP14 Prop. 28 CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

DIDIEREACEAE Selected between

Alluaudia ascendens II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 PC19 Review ongoing. Selected between

P Alluaudia comosa II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no C2 Review ongoing.

Doc. Selected between

Alluaudia dumosa II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

Review ongoing.

7.2 (Rev. 2) Selected between

Alluaudia geayi II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

Selected between

–

Alluaudia humbertii II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

p. Review ongoing.

Selected between

Alluaudia montagnacii II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

Alluaudia procera II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

Alluaudiopsis fiherenensis II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 PC19 Review ongoing. Selected between

Alluaudiopsis marnieriana II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

Decarya madagascariensis II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

Selected between

Didierea ascendens II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

P Didierea comosa II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no C2 Review ongoing.

Doc. Selected between

Didierea dumosa II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

Review ongoing.

7.2 (Rev. 2) Selected between

Didierea madagascariensis II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

Selected between

–

Didierea mirabilis II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

p. Review ongoing.

Selected between

Didierea procera II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Selected between

Didierea trollii II CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. DIOSCOREACEAE Selected between CoP13 & CoP15.

Dioscorea deltoidea II To be reconsidered PC21 Doc. 19.1 no between CoP15 & CoP17 EBENACEAE Inclusion of the

Diospyros spp. II populations of CoP16 Prop. 58 no no Madagascar in App. II

EUPHORBIACEAE Euphorbiaceae II II, Annotation CoP13 Prop.38 no no

Euphorbiaceae II II, Annotation CoP13 Prop.39 no no Euphorbia spp. included in Amendments of the

II CoP14 Prop. 29 no no Appendix II annotations

C2 Euphorbia abdelkuri II no PC21

Doc. Euphorbia alfredii II no PC17 Euphorbia ankarensis II no PC17

7.2 (Rev. 2) Euphorbia antso II no PC17 Selected between CoP13&CoP15.

Euphorbia antisiphilitica II PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Present listing in II

–

is appropriate.

22 Euphorbia aureoviridiflora II no PC17

Euphorbia banae II no PC17 Euphorbia beharensis II no PC17

Euphorbia berorohae II no PC17

Euphorbia biaculeata II no PC17 Euphorbia bongolavensis II no PC17

Euphorbia bulbispina II no PC17

Euphorbia candelabrum II no PC15 Selected between

Euphorbia capsaintemariensis I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Euphorbia capuronii II no PC17

Euphorbia capmanambatoensis II no PC17

Euphorbia croizatii II no PC17 Selected between

Euphorbia cremersi I PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15 Selected between

P Euphorbia cylindrifolia I PC21 Doc. 19.1 no CoP13& CoP15

2 Selected between

Euphorbia decaryi I PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Doc. CoP13& CoP15

Euphorbia denisiana II no PC17

7.2 (Rev. 2)

Euphorbia didiereoides II no PC17 Euphorbia duranii II no PC17

Euphorbia elliotii II no PC17

–

p. Selected between

23 Euphorbia francoisii I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

Review ongoing.

Euphorbia famatamboay II no PC17 Euphorbia fianarantsoae II no PC17

Euphorbia genoudiana II no PC17 Euphorbia geroldii II no PC17

Euphorbia globosa II no PC21 Euphorbia gottlebei II no PC17 Euphorbia guillauminiana II no PC17 Euphorbia hedyotoides II no PC17

Euphorbia herman-schwartzii II no PC17

Euphorbia hofstaetteri II no PC17

Euphorbia horombensis II no PC17

Euphorbia iharanae II no PC17

Euphorbia itremensis II no PC17, PC19

C2 Euphorbia kondoi II no PC17

Euphorbia labatii II no PC17, PC21

Doc. Euphorbia leucodendron II no PC17

7.2 (Rev. 2)

Euphorbia leuconeura II no PC17 Euphorbia lophogona II no PC17

Euphorbia mahabobokensis II no PC17

–

Euphorbia mangokyensis II no PC17

24 Euphorbia misera not listed Deletion from App. II CoP15 Prop. 28 no no

Selected between

Euphorbia moratii I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

Euphorbia neobosseri II no PC17 Euphorbia neohumbertii II no PC17

Euphorbia pachypodioides II no PC17 Selected between

Euphorbia parvicyathophora I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

Euphorbia paulianii II no PC17 Euphorbia pedilanthoides II no PC17 Euphorbia perrieri II no PC17

Euphorbia primulifolia II no PC17 Euphorbia primulifolia var. II no PC17 begardii Selected between

C2 Euphorbia quartziticola I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing.

Doc. Euphorbia razafindratsirae II no PC17

Euphorbia robivelonae II no PC17 7.2 (Rev. 2)

Euphorbia rossii II no PC17 Euphorbia sakarahaensis II no PC17

Euphorbia stellata II no PC15

–

p. Euphorbia stenoclada II no PC17

Euphorbia suzannae-marnierae II no PC17 Selected between

Euphorbia tulearensis I CoP13& CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing. Euphorbia viguieri II no PC17 Euphorbia waringiae II no PC17 LAURACEAE Inclusion in App. II with

Aniba rosaeodora II CoP15 Prop. 29 no no annotation

Aniba rosaeodora II Amend the annotation CoP16 Prop. 59 no no

LEGUMINOSAE

Caesalpinia echinata II Inclusion in App. II CoP14 Prop. 30 no no

(Fabaceae) Inclusion of the

Dalbergia spp. II populations of CoP16 Prop. 63 no no Madagascar in App. II

P Inclusion in App. II with

C2 Dalbergia cochinchinensis II CoP16 Prop. 60 no no annotation

Doc. Dalbergia granadillo and

II Inclusion in App. II CoP14 Prop. 31 no no Dalbergia retusa

7.2 (Rev. 2) Dalbergia

II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 61 no no granadillo and Dalbergia retusa

Dalbergia stevensonii II Inclusion in App. II CoP14 Prop. 32 no no

Dalbergia stevensonii II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 62 no no

–

Selected betwen

p. CoP13 & CoP15.

26 Platymiscium pleiostachyum II PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review completed. Delete from App.

Pterocarpus santalinus II no PC15, PC21

Senna meridionalis II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 30 no no

Senna meridionalis II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 64 no no

LILIACEAE Aloe acutissima II no PC17 Selected between

Aloe albiflora I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 Review ongoing Aloe antandroi II no PC17

Aloe betsileensis II no PC17

Aloe bosseri II no PC17

Aloe bulbillifera II no PC17

Selected between

Aloe calcairophila I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing

Aloe capitata II no PC17

C2 Aloe capitata var. capitata II no PC17

Aloe capitata var. cipolinicola II no PC17

Doc. Aloe capitata var. gneissicola II no PC17

7.2 (Rev. 2) Aloe capitata var. quartziticola II no PC17 Selected between

Aloe compressa I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing

–

Aloe conifera II no PC17

27 Selected between

Aloe delphinensis I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing

Aloe deltoideodonta II no PC17 Selected between

Aloe descoingsii I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing Aloe divaricata II no PC17

Aloe erythrophylla II no PC17 Aloe ferox II no PC15 Selected between

Aloe fragilis I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing

Aloe guillaumetii II no PC17

Selected between

Aloe haworthioides I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing Selected between

P Aloe helenae I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no C2 Review ongoing

Doc. Aloe humbertii II no PC17 Aloe ibitiensis II no PC17

7.2 (Rev. 2)

Aloe imalotensis II no PC17

Aloe isaloensis II no PC17

Aloe itremensis II no PC17

–

Selected between

Aloe laeta I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no

28 Review ongoing

Aloe macroclada II no PC17 Selected between

Aloe parallelifolia I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing Selected between

Aloe parvula I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing

Aloe poliphylla II no PC17

Aloe pratensis II no PC17

Aloe prostrata II no PC17 Selected between

Aloe rauhii I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing

Aloe suarezensis II no PC17 Selected between

Aloe suzannae I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing

C2 Aloe trachyticola II no PC17

Aloe vaombe II no PC17

Doc. Aloe vaotsanda II no PC17

7.2 (Rev. 2) Selected between

Aloe versicolor I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing

MELIACEAE Cedrela spp. not listed Inclusion in App. II CoP14 Prop. 33 no no

–

Swietenia macrophylla II no PC17

29 ORCHIDACEAE Orchidaceae, included in

II in II, Annotation CoP13 Prop.40 no no

Appendix II Orchidaceae, included in

II in II, Annotation CoP13 Prop.41 no no Appendix II Orchidaceae, included in

II II, Amend annotation CoP13 Prop.42 no no Appendix II ORCHIDACEAE spp. included in

I Amend the annotation CoP15 Prop. 31 no no Appendix I Amendment of the Orchidaceae spp. included in annotation to

II CoP14 Prop. 34 no no Appendix II Orchidaceae spp. included in App. II

Amendment of the Orchidaceae spp. included in annotation to

II CoP14 Prop. 35 no no Appendix II Orchidaceae spp. included in Appendix II

P C2 Transfer from App. I to

2 Cattleya trianaei II CoP13 Prop.43 no no

App. II

Doc.

Calanthe alleizettei II no PC17

7.2 (Rev. 2)

Christensonia vietnamica II no PC15

Cymbidium erythrostylum II no PC17

Dendrobium chrysotoxum II no PC21

– Dendrobium eriiflorum II no PC19

30 Dendrobium moschatum II no PC21

Myrmecophila tibicinis II no PC15 Selected between CoP13 & CoP15.

Peristeria elata I Review completed. PC21 Doc. 19.1 PC17 Delete from Appendix I

Renanthera annamensis II no PC17 Transfer from App. I to

Vanda coerulea II CoP13 Prop.44 no no App. II

OROBANCHACEAE Cistanche deserticola II I & II, Annotation CoP13 Prop.45 no PC17 PALMAE Beccariophoenix Inclusion of the seeds

II CoP15 Prop. 32 no PC17

madagascariensis of the species in App. II

Chrysalidocarpus decipiens I Transfer from II to I CoP13 Prop.46 no no

Dypsis decaryi (Neodypsis Inclusion of the seeds

II CoP15 Prop. 33 no no decaryi) of the species in App. II

Lemurophoenix halleuxii II no PC17

C2 Marojejya darianii II no PC17

Ravenea rivularis II no PC17

Doc.

Satranala decussilvae II no PC17

7.2 (Rev. 2)

Voanioala gerardii II no PC17

PASSIFLORACEAE Adenia firingalavensis II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 34 no no

Adenia firingalavensis II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 65 no no

– Adenia olaboensis II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 35 no no

Adenia subsessifolia II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 36 no no

Adenia subsessifolia II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 66 no no

PEDALIACEAE Uncarina grandidieri II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 67 no no

Uncarina stellulifera II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 68 no no PODOCARPACEAE Selected between CoP13 & CoP15.

Podocarpus parlatorei I yes PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Present listing is appropriate. PORTULACACEAE Selected between

Lewisia serrata II yes CoP15 & CoP17, PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing PROTEACEAE Selected between

Orothamnus zeyheri not listed Deletion from App. II CoP15 Prop. 37 no CoP13&CoP15 Deletion from Appendix Selected between

Protea odorata not listed CoP15 Prop. 38 no II CoP13&CoP15

ROSACEAE Prunus africana II no PC21 RUBIACEAE Selected between

Balmea stormiae I CoP13 & CoP15. PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Review ongoing

SANTALACEAE Osyris lanceolata II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 69 no no

2 TAXACEAE Taxus chinensis, T. cuspidata,

Doc.

T. fuana, T. sumatrana and all II Inclusion in App. II CoP13 Prop. 48 no no infraspecific taxa of these species

7.2 (Rev. 2) Taxus chinensis, T. cuspidata, Amendment of the

II CoP14 Prop. 36 no no T. fuanaand T. sumatrana listing in App. II Amendment of the

Taxus cuspidata II CoP14 Prop. 36 no PC21 listing in App. II

–

Taxus wallichiana II Inclusion in App. II CoP13 Prop.47 no PC15

32 THYMELAEACEAE

Aquilaria spp. and Gyrinops spp. II Inclusion in II CoP13 Prop. 49 no no

Deletion of the

Aquilaria spp. and Gyrinops spp. II CoP16 Prop. 70 no no annotation

Gonystylus spp. II Inclusion in App. II CoP13 Prop. 50 no no

VALERIANACEAE Nardostachys grandiflora II no PC15, PC21

VITACEAE Cyphostemma elephantopus II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 39 no no

Cyphostemma laza II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 40 no no

Cyphostemma laza II Inclusion in App. II CoP16 Prop. 71 no no

Cyphostemma montagnacii II Inclusion in App. II CoP15 Prop. 41 no no WELWITSCHIACEAE Selected between CoP 13 & CoP15,

Welwitschia mirabilis II PC21 Doc. 19.1 no Retain in Appendix II

ZINGIBERACEAE Selected between CoP 13 and CoP15.

Hedychium philippinense II To be reconsidered PC21 Doc. 19.1 no between CoP15 &

P CoP17

ZYGOPHYLLACEAE Inclusion in App. II with

Doc. Bulnesia sarmientoi II CoP15 Prop. 42 no PC21 annotation

7.2 (Rev. 2)

–