<<

(m

Hawarian Humane Society People for aniitjals. A«i»ials for people. 2/00 Waiatae Avenue Honolulu, 96826 808.356.2200 • HawalianHumane.orq

Date: Feb. 21, 2018

To: Chair Rep. Scott Nishimoto Vice Chair Rep. Joy San Buenaventura and Members of the Judiciary Committee

Submitted By: Stephanie Kendrick, Public Policy Advocate Hawaiian Humane Society, 808-356-2217

RE: Testimony in support of HB2072, HDl: Relating to HRS 711-1109 Thursday, Feb. 22, 2018, 2 p.m., Capitol room 325

The Hawaiian Humane Society supports the passage of House Bill 2072, which would prohibit the use of specific tethering equipment and techniques that are injurious to . However, we oppose the proposed amendments reducing the penalties for a tethering violation.

We understand the intent of the penalty change is to compel compliance with the new law without imposing a misdemeanor charge. But as the animal service provider for Oahu, we can attest that our humane investigators already use education when possible to modify behavior. Citations are issued and charges are brought only if attempts at education have failed to change illegal behavior and there is documented evidence of harm to one or more animals. In recent years the Legislature has strengthened animal cruelty penalties to recognize the serious nature of these crimes. These amendments would erode those efforts.

We do agree that psychological counseling (page 5, line 13 through page6, line 3) may be a useful tool for rehabilitating animal cruelty offenders. We would support the addition of that option to the existing sentencing guidelines for all animal cruelty cases. Our suggested amendments are attached.

The cruelty provisions of HB2072 will elevate the quality of life for dogs and enhance public safety. Aside from the penalty changes, HB2072 offers well-vetted language that supported in the prior two sessions by both groups and law enforcement.

We ask you to strike the language reducing penalties for violators and give the remaining bill your full support. Please let me know if I can be of assistance.

The Hawaiian Humane Society is dedicated to promoting the human animal bond and the humane treatment of ail animals. RELATING TO SECTION 7 1 1 - 1 1HAWAII 0 9 , REVISED STATUTES

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF HAWAII:

SECTION 1 . S e c t i7 o 1 n 1 - 1 1H 0 a 9 w , aR i e i v i sS e t d a t u ti e s s , a m e n dt e or d e aa d sf o l l o w s :

" § 7 1 1 - 1C 1 r 0 u 9 e lt t oa y n i m ai l nt s h es e c o n d d e g r e e( 1. )A p e r s c o o n m m it t h s eo f f e no s fc e r u e lt t oa y n i m a l s i nt h es e c o d n e d g r i e f et h ep e r s intentionally, o n k n o w i no g r l y , recklessly:

( a )Overdrives, o v e r l o t a o d r s t , u rt e o s r , m e nb t e s a , t s ,

c a u ssubstantial e s b o d i i l n y j u t r o y ,o rs t a r va e n s y

a n i m ao l rc , a u st e h s eoverdriving, overloading,

t o r t ut r o e r , m eb n e t a , t io n r gs , t a r v o i f na g n ya n i m a l ;

( b )D e p r i a v p e e s ta n i mo a f ln e c e s ss a u r s y t e n a a s n c e

d e f i ni e ns d e c t i7 o 1 n 1 - 1 1i 0 n 0 c , l u dt i h n e g

reguirements r e l a t t i o na g d e q u s a h t e e l to e r rc , a u s e s

[ s u ct h h ] adeprivation; t

( c )M u t i l a p t o e i s s , oo n r sk , i l lw s i t h on u e t ea d n ya n i m a l

o t h et r h ai n n s e cv t e s r , m io n ro , t h ep r e s tp s r ; o v i d e d

t h at t h eh a n d l o i r nextermination g o fa n yi n s e c t ,

v e r m io n ro , t h ep r e si t sc o n d u ci t na e c d c o r d w a i n t c h e

s t a n d a a n r da d c c e p t p a e b s lc t e o n t rp o r l a c t ia c n e da s l l

a p p l i c l a a b w la s e n dregulations;

( d )K e e pu s s , e so , ri na n yw a yi sc o n n e cw t i e to d h r

i n t e r e i s n tt e h d em a n a g e o m f e ,o n r tr e c e i m v o e n s ef y o r

t h ea d m i s so i fa o n n yp e r s t o o n ,a n yp l a ck e e po t ru s e d f o rt h ep u r p oo s ff e i g h t o i r nb g a i t ia n n g yb u l lb , e a r ,

c o c ko , ro t h ea r n i m aa l n , di n c l u e d v e e s rp y e r s w o h n o

encourages, a i d so , ra s s i st t h s e r eo i r nw , h op e r m i t s

o rs u f f ea r n s yp l a ct e ob es ok e po t ru s e d ;

( e )C a r r io e rc s a u st e o sb ec a r r ii e n do , ru p oa n n y

v e h i co l ro e t h econveyance, r a n ya n i mi a n la c r u eo l r

i n h u m m a a n n e n e r ;

( f )C o n f i o n r ec s a u st e o sb ec o n f i ni e na d ,k e n no e r l

c a g ea , n yp e ta n i m i a n la c r u eo l ri n h u m m a a n n e n e r ;

( g )T e t h ef r a s s , t et n i s e , so , rr e s t r aa id n o s gt oa

d o g h o ut s r e e , ef , e n co e r ,a n yo t h es r t a t i o n a r y

o b j e [ c b t y ]o ,ru s ea s t r o l lp e u y l , l ec y a , b lo e r ,

r u n n il n i g nd e e s i g t n o ea d t t a a c d h o gt ot w o

s t a t i o o n b a j r e y c t s ;

( i )I ft h ed o gi su n d et r h ea g eo fs i xm o n t u h n s l e s s

t h ed o gi se n g a gi e na d s u p e r v a i c s t e i d v i t y ;

( i i )I na configuration t h a t :

(A) E n t a n go l re e n s d a n gt e h r ed s o go ; r

(B) P r e v e t n h t ed s o gf r oo m b t a i nn i e n c g e s s a r y

sustenance, a sd e f i ni e nt d h ic s h a p t e r ;

( i i iI ) ft h et e t h i e s rs h o r tt e h r af n i vt e i m et s h e

l e n g o t f ht h ed o g 'b s o d ya , sm e a s u f r r e o dt m h e

t i po fi t sn o st e ot h eb a so e fi t st a i lu , n l e s s

t h ed o gi se n g a gi e na d s u p e r v a i c s t e i d v i t y ;

( i v )I ft h er e s t r ai i sa n t t o wo rl o gc h a io n ri s

disproportionate t ot h es i zo e rw e i g o h f tt h ed o g

s u ct h h at t h er e s t r ai i n n h t i b t i h t ef s r e e m o v e m o e f nt t h ed o gw i t h t i h n ea r ea a l l o wb e y d

t h et e t h eo r r ;

( v )B ym e a no s fa c h o kc e o l l ap r i , n cc h o l l ao r r ,

p r o nc g o l l ap r r ; o v i t d h e a da t p e r s i o s nn o t

p r o h i b f i r t o eu m d s i n[ g o u cre-otraints] h a c h o k e

c o l l ap r i , n cc h o l l ao r rp , r o nc g o l l w a h r e n

w a l k ia nd g o gw i ta h h a n d - hl e e l a d so h rw h i la e

d o gi se n g a gi e na d s u p e r v a i c s t e i d v io t r y ;

( h )C o m m io t rA s s s i sa t n s o t hi e nt r h ec o m m i s o s f ia o n n y

a c ts p e c i fi i nsubsections e d ( 1 ( ) a )t h r o u( g 1 ( h ) g [— ) ] ^

p r o v i t d h e a da t p e r s w o h n oi sc o n v i co t fc e o d m m i t t i n g

o ra s s i s ta i n n o g t hi e nt r h ec o m m i s o s f ia o na n c t

s p e c i fi i no e u d b p o o ( t 1 i (g ) o n lt - h is s e c t is o h n a l, l

m a yi , na d d i t t i o oa n n yo t h ep r e n a l t a i l e s sb o , e

s e n t e np c u e r d s u t a o ns t u b s e c ( t 4i )o (n bA ) s .u s ei d n

t h is s e c t i" o a n s , s i m s e t a " nt s oi n s t i g e a n t g e a ,i g n e ,

o rf u r t ht e h r ec o m m i s o s f ia o na n c tp r o h i b u i n t d e e d r

t h is s e c t i o n .

( 2 )S u b s e c ( t 1 i ( ) o a n, ) ( b , ) ( c , ) ( e , ) ( f , ) ( g , )a n d( h ) s h a ln l o ta p p lt y o :

( a )A c c e p v t e e t d e r i p n r a a r c y t i c e s ;

( b )A c t i v i c t a i r e r s io e nf d o rs c i e n t r i e f s i e c a g r o c v h e r n e d

b ys t a n d ao r fa d c s c e p educational t e d o rm e d i c i n a l

p r a c t i o c r e s ;

( c )P e sc t o n t ro o p l e r a t c i o o n n d s u cp t u e r d s u t a o nc t h a p t e r

1 4 9b A ya p e sc t o n t ro o p l e r a l t i o c r e n p s u e r d s u t a o n t c h a p t4 e 6 r 0 Ji , ft h ep e s c t o n t ri o s lp e r f o ru m n e d d ea r

w r i t tc e o n n t r a c t .

( 3 ) W h e n e a v ne yra n i m i a s ls os e v e r i e nl jy u rt e h d a t t h e r e i sn or e a s o n probability a b l e t h a i t t sl i f o e ru s e f u l nc ea nsb s e s a v e dt ,h ea n i m m a a l yb eimmediately d e s t r ow y i e t d h oc u r t e a t i n g a n yo f f e nu s n e d et r h i s s e c t i o n .

( 4 ) C r u e lt t o ya n i m ai l n st h es e c o d n e d g r i e s ea misdemeanor f o re a c a h b u s a e n d i m ae l x , c e [ p w t h e t r h e a ]i t f t h e o f f e n[ s i e n v o l] v e s

( a ) I n v o l t v e nso rm o r p e e ta n i m ai l n sa n o y n ei n s t a n c e

[ w h i ct h h ] e ,c n r u e lt t o ya n i m ai l n st h s e e c o n d

d e g r i e s ea c l a sC sf e l o n yo [— r ] ;

( b ) I n v o l n v ie ns o e rf e w ep r e ta n i m ai l n sa n yo n ei n s t a n c e

a n di n v o l a v nea s c tp r o h i b iu nt de edouboecti-oft r

-fi ( ) g , ) t h i s s e c t it o h n e t n h ed e f e n ds a h n a t lb l e

g u i l o t f ya p e t tmisdemeanor y a n di na d d i t t i o oa n n y

o t h ep r e n a l ts i h e a s lm l a ya l s b o es e n t e na c s e d

f o l l o w s :

-firj-— Q Ff o i r r so t f f e nu s n e d eo r u b s o c t( i1 < )o g n -)-!-

------— P a y m o e f na tf i n o e fn o tm o r t e h a ■$ n - ■3 f 0 o 0 r

e a c a h b u s g e n d i m a i r ^

(B A) I fd e e m appropriate e d b yt h ec o u r t ,

c o m p l e to fieducational o n c l a s si e n sa n i m a l

a b u sprevention; e p r o v i t d he a dt t h ec o u r t

s h a ln l o to r d ec r l a s su e n s d et r h i p s a r a g r a p h

i fc l a s sa e r s en o tr e a d ia l v y a i l af b r l o ea m n

a n i m w a e l l f aorganization r e o ra s i m i l a r appropriate organization d e s i g n b a y tt e h d e

c o u n i t n yw h i ct h h eu n d e r l o y f i f n e g n s e

o c c u r ra e n d d ;

(GB) I fd e e m appropriate e d b yt h ec o u r t ,

c o m p l e o t f ia oc n o u r o s f epsychological

counseling; o r .

( i i ) — Q F O o G r G o o n r ds u b s o q o u f e f n o t nu o n o d e ^

o u b a o c ( t 1 i < ) o q n ) !

----fAf-— Payment o fa f i no e fn o tm o rt e h a$ n 5 0f 0 o r

e a ca h b u s a e n d i m a l ;

---— Completion o fs i x t eh e o n u ro s fc o m m u n i t y

■ee r v ia c n e d ;

----fG-)-— Imprioonment o fn ol o ot p h at n w od a ya s n dn o

m o rt e h at n h i r d t a y y s ;

------p r o v i t d h e a d tnotwithstanding , s e c t i7 o 0 n 6 — {2} 6 4>— 3 a - l A

f i n ec s o l l e cu t n e d d et r h ip o a r a g ro a h p a h lb l op a i- d G e

t h ed i r e c o t f of r i n a no c ft e h ec o u n i t n yw h i ct h h e

u n d e r l o y f i f n e g no s c e c u r ra e sa d ,g e n e rf a u l n d

-realization o ft h ac t o u n t y -r-11

SECTION 2 .T h iA s c td o en s o ta f f e r c i t g ha t n s dd u t it e h s a t m a t u rp e e d n , a l tt i h e aw s t e ri e n c u r ra e n d dproceedings , t h aw t e r e b e g ub n e f o i r t e se f f e c td i a v t e e .

SECTION 3 .S t a t u tm o a r t y e r t i o ab l er e p e a i l s eb d r a c k e t e d a n ds t r i c kN e e n w .s t a t u tm o a r t y e r i i s aunderscored. l

SECTION 4 .T h iA s c ts h a lt l a ke e f f e o c n tJ u l1 y ,2 0 1 8 . HAWAII ASSOCIATION OF ANIMAL WELFARE AGENCIES Hawaiian Humane Society Hawaii Island Humane Society Kauai Humane Society Maui Humane Society Date: February 21, 2018

To: Chair Rep. Scott Nishimoto Vice Chair Rep. Joy San Buenaventura and Members of the Judiciary Committee

RE: Testimony in support of HB2072: Relating to HRS 711-1109 Thursday, Feb. 22, 2018, 2 p.m., Capitol room 325

The Hawaii Association of Animal Welfare Agencies (HAAWA) supports the passage of House Bill 2072, which would prohibit the use of specific tethering equipment and techniques that are injurious to dogs.

HAAWA represents the four county animal service providers in the state of Hawaii. Our independent local nonprofits are united in support this change in policy.

The harmful tethering of dogs is an issue on all of our islands. The constant confinement and isolation of dogs is dangerous both for the animals and the people around them. Dogs are happiest when they are treated as close members of their human families.

Please support this measure with the exception of the proposed amendments reducing the initial penalty to a petty misdemeanor. While the intent of that change might have been to allow offenders to correct their behavior without incurring a misdemeanor charge, our humane investigators already use education first to modify behavior. Citations would follow only if the illegal activity is not corrected. Please do not retreat from the recent gains the Legislature has made in strengthening animal cruelty penalties.

We ask you to support the well-vetted language in HB2072, which was endorsed in the prior two sessions by animal welfare groups and law enforcement, and reject the penalty amendments.

Thank you for considering our testimony on this important issue.

Sincerely,

Lisa Fowler, President & CEO Donna Whitaker, Executive Director Hawaiian Humane Society Hawaii Island Humane Society

Orianna Skomoroch, Interim Executive Director Jerleen Bryant, CEO Kauai Humane Society Maui Humane Society HB2072 - Support

Keeping dogs on chains their whole life is extremely cruel and especially since there are inexpensive alarm systems now, it is totally unnecessary. Anyone with a heart or any sense can see how cruel it is. I would hope that also the poor dogs living their life in a small kennel will be addressed at some point too. I feel so heartbroken for these innocent souls and so helpless, just looking on and not being able to do anything to help them. Please have a heart and do what is right. I volunteer my time to the humane society and rescue groups so I see the poor animals that come in with the dug-in chains in their necks and the permanent scars. Please help them, be their voice. Mahalo, Cindy Cabrera

Diane Spears - Support

PLEASE PASS HB2072. All dogs deserve a good life, being chained up is a horrible act of cruelty. My heart breaks every time I see dogs chained, in today’s world the Hawaiian culture of owning dogs as yard art/guard dogs desperately needs to end.

PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE PASS HB2072. THIS IS SO IMPORTANT TO THE HEALTH AND WELFARE FOR DOGS.

In advance, Thank you so much.

Sincerely,

Diane

Wayne Niide - Support

Please pass HB2072, which would prohibit the use of specific tethering equipment and techniques that have been found to be injurious to dogs.

Dogs that are denied a proper pack relationship with their families are more prone to bite.

Chained dogs are more likely to attack without provocation.

Most of the language in this bill was supported in the prior two sessions by both animal welfare groups and law enforcement. It is a step in the right direction.

I request that the committee strike the proposed amendments reducing the penalties for a tethering violation. These amendments are contrary to actions taken by the Legislature to address animal cruelty crimes more seriously.

Please reject the reduced penalties for violators and support the rest of this bill.

Thank You!

Wayne Niide

Jennifer Chiwa - Support

Aloha, Members of the Committee on Judiciary. My name is Jennifer Chiwa.

Please support HB 2072 HD1 which would prohibit the use of tethering equipment and techniques that would be harmful to dogs. It's my understanding that most of the language in this bill was supported in previous sessions by law enforcement and animal welfare groups. However, please strike proposed amendments which would reduce penalties for a tethering violation. To reduce these penalties is, in my opinion, to reduce the seriousness of animal cruelty. Please reject these reduced penalties and support the rest of this bill. Mahalo.

Jennifer Chiwa

Suyin Phillips - Support

Dear legislator,

I’ve waited years for this issue to return to the table at the state legislature. Did you know that in California it’s illegal to tie your to something (a post, tree, structure) for more than just a few mins (while you run in and a coffee, mail a package, etc..). And in Hawaii, it’s perfectly legal to tie your dog to a tree for his entire life, so long as you stick a water bowl and cover in reach? Such is the case of Taisho, who sits and ages in a grassless dirt front yard in my mother’s neighborhood of Waialae Iki. We neighbors recall when the puppy first arrived about 10 years ago. We were concerned when the cute fluffy puppy was tied to their mango tree ... day and night, and NEVER seen on a walk. Taisho remains tied to that tree, day and night, year after year, since she arrived at their home 10 years ago. I have approached the owners, an elderly Japanese couple, asking if I may walk their dog ... no luck. I’ve filed complaints to the Hawaiian Humane Society, but their hands are tied bc it’s not illegal in Hawaii. I’ve even considered stealing the damn dog. Wouldn’t it be splendid if HB 2072 is passed and I could make one last call to HHS and that dog could be rescued from that f@*king tree for the last couple years of her now senior life? I pulled over and took this attached picture of her just today.

I strongly SUPPORT HB 2072 to limit dog chaining/tethering! Hawaii needs protection for neglected tethered dogs from Waianae to Waialae Iki! Thank you for taking the time to listen your constituents.

Suyin Phillips Adjunct Professor

Susan Bambara - Support

Aloha honorable Representatives,

Please pass HB2072. Animal health and welfare is a vital component to a community's health and well- being. Modeling kind and thoughtful behavior toward our fur friends is a step toward modeling that kind of thought and care to each other.

Thank you,

Susan

Susan Bambara Kurtistown

Diana Tevaga - Support

Aloha,

I humbly write to share my support for Bill HB2072 to prohibit certain restraints and tethers that endanger or deny sustenance to a dog.

In my opinion there are dangers to chaining or tethering a dog for an extended period of time and also for short periods by themselves. Below are a list of the horrible possibilities that can happen when neglectful owners chain or tether their dog(s).

* Cannot escape from aggressive wild animals(ie: wild pigs) or free-roaming dogs * Do not receive adequate physical activity. * Death by strangulation after trying to jump over an object, such as a dog house * May be more likely to bite than well-socialized dogs. * Are susceptible to overheating and freezing in extreme weather. * Often lunge or pull against a chain, causing abrasions and injury to the neck. * Suffer high-exposure to disease-carrying insects including ticks, fleas, and mosquitos. * Are forced to urinate and defecate in the same area where they eat and sleep. * May continuously from boredom and frustration. * Chain can become embedded in a dogs neck

I wholeheartedly support any Bill that will provide a dog the happy life it deserves to have. https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=2072&year=2018

Mahalo nui, Diana Tevaga

Kiana Dempster - Support

I was born and raised in Hawaii. I have witnessed firsthand the damage that a lifetime on a chain can do to a dog. I have seen neighbors never adjust collars or chains so they resulted in growing into their necks. I have seen dogs chained to porches that jumped off the porch and hung themselves. This would not have happened if they were not chained. I have seen bad neighbors go into other neighbors yards and beat dogs on chains because they bark nonstop. The dogs suffer in agony. They are bored, upset, and in pain. They lose the hope of being free. I have neighbors who NEVER let their dogs loose. I have lived on my current street for the past twelve years. My neighbor has literally gone through about 40 dogs in that time. He goes away for days and the dogs scream for food and water. Thedogs chains wrap around the buckets and knock them over. The water spills and they dehydrate to death. They wrap around trees and get stuck in the bushes and starve to death. I report my neighbor over and over to the humane society but they keep saying that there is nothing they can do because chains are legal. Sometimes my neighbor leaves for five or six days. When he comes back he throws the dead dogs in the bushes and gets more dogs. Please help to make it stop.

Chains are nasty. Chains are deadly. Chains kill. They kill both the mind and the spirit. They kill the flesh. Please make having dogs on chains illegal. THINK OF THE LIVES YOU WILL SAVE. THINK OF THE DOGS. NOTHING ELSE MATTERS BUT THEIR WELFARE. THEY CANNOT SPEAK FOR THEMSELVES. THEY CANNOT HELP THEMSELVES.

SHOW YOUR HEARTS  SHOW YOU CARE SHOW THAT HAWAII IS A PROGRESSIVE AND LOVING STATE. SHOW THAT OUR ALOHA SPIRIT EXTENDS BEYOND THE HUMAN SPECIES.

THE ANIMALS NEED YOUR HELP. RIGHT NOW THERE ARE 17 DOGS NEXT DOOR THAT YOU COULD SAVE. #PLEASEHELP

Malia Bohol - Support

Please pass bill HB2072. Our island dogs have been tortured enough. Please help break the chains!

Mahalo- Bohol

Annie Emilyon - Support

We need laws on chaining up animals. When chaining an animal, the owners should have condition about using collars and the chain should have a certain amount of length so the animal have a proper area to roam inAlso if they are an outside pet, they should have shelter requirements. I believe the abuse and negligence on animals is a huge crime. It’s frankly sickening me that people do horrible things to helpless animals. Please help pass laws to defend these helpless souls!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Sincerely Annie Emilyon

Estelle Bowie - Support

Please pass HB 2072. The conditions of many chained dogs is simply inhumane. No animal deserves to live in barbaric conditions, without sufficient food, water, shelter, or affection. If a person wants to have a dog in their lives, whether it's a working dog or a pet, it is our responsibility as humans to adequately care for them. Thank you for your consideration, Sincerely, Estelle Bowie.

Rachel Kirk - Support

Please pass HB2072!

Carla Bissell - Support

Please pass this bill and start the process for improving the quality of life for dogs in our state. As a former employee of the Kauai Humane Society I can tell you with first hand experience that dogs that are chained suffer tremendously both physically and mentally. Please lets start the process in helping educate people to better care for these special animals and help them recognize the suffering that chaining causes. Mahalo, Carla Bissell

Katelyn Hill - Support

Please pass HB2072 to stop chained dogs. It is extremely inhuman and heartbreaking. They are living beings with , and feelings just like we are. Just like YOU are. They deserve to be loved, and cared for. Not left chained to something, tired of fighting for freedom from the restriction. I personally own a dog that I rescued from the Honolulu Humane Society, and she has thick rings of scars around her back ankles where fur never grew back, from previously being chained to something by whoever her cruel previous owners were. To this day, no matter how much she loves and trusts us as her new family (which is a lot, she’s come a long way), she still gets uneasy and scared about her back legs being touched because the fear of being chained back up, and injured from it, is instilled in her. Dogs do not deserve this. No animal does. It needs to stop! Please stop chained dogs. Thank you for your time in reading this. ❤️

Roland Green - Support

Please pass HB2072 for the health and welfare of our local dog population.

Thank You, Roland Green The Pooch Mobile Kamuela

Alexandra Hilsabeck - Support

Aloha, Please pass bill HB2072. No living, loving creature deserves to be chained outdoors. When isolated, dogs can start to display signs of aggression, or anti social behavior. These animals are intelligent, and have so much love to give. Please don't allow people who abuse and neglect dogs to continue chaining their dogs. What kind of life is it to be chained, left outside during blazing heat, or cold rainy weather? It's abuse, and cruel. A lot of these animals aren't even being fed, or given any water. We love pitbulls here in Hawai'i, so let's make a change and show everyone how loving these dogs, along with many other dog breeds, can be, and end the abuse of chaining dogs. Please pass bill HB2072. Mahalo, Voice for dogs.

Ayumi Furutani - Support

Please pass HB2072

Dale Harrington - Support

Life at the end of a chain is a slow and painless mental and physical death for a dog. Please pass this bill.

Dale Harrington Kailua Kona

Joy and Allen Pagan - Support

Dear Sir or Madam,

I send this email on behalf of all K9's who cannot voice their needs to be cared for in a humane way. Human beings here in the Aloha State must be held accountable for for the neglect, abuse, imprisonment, starvation and cruelty inflicted upon dogs here in our state. Please pass HB2072!!

Mahalo,

Joy and Allen Pagan

Shop owners of

MOTO-WURX 65 MAKAALA ST HILO, HI. 96720

Maile Van Unen - Support

I support the bill and ask for your help to pass it. I’m 22 years old and my fiancé (27) are part of the future of Hawai’i. We are born and raised on O’ahu and are pescatarians and believe that dogs are just another shape/form of family and if people take the time to adopt a dog, they should put in time to take care of them and keep them happy just like they would do to their own family members. I know by having and dogs of my own that all we need to do is take time to care for them and treat them well so they’ll relax and behave so we can take the dogs inside the home instead of leaving them outside. I know together we can help animals live a better life at home.

Pat & Scarlet Eskildsen, Lena Naipo - Support

Mahalo! We hope this passes.

Pat & Scarlet Eskildsen, Lena Naipo - Support

Please pass HB2072. We need to be the voice for these animals that are at the mercy of us humans. Thank you for your compassion.

Andrea Baer - Support

Please pass HB2072, which would prohibit the use of specific tethering equipment and techniques that have been found to be injurious to dogs.

Please also strike the proposed amendments reducing the penalties for a tethering violation as these amendments would erode the efficacy of steps taken by the Legislature to take animal cruelty crimes more seriously.

Thank you for your time,

Andrea Baer

Kihei, HI

Laura - Support

Please pass HB2072.

Ilene Harrington - Support

Aloha,

We are known as the Aloha state which means we welcome people with love. But behind the scenes the animal cruelty is horrendous. Where is the Aloha in our treatment of Dogs? Chaining dogs is a torture in the worse way. It psychologically and physically abuses the dog. Since we are suppose to represent love how can we allow this to continue in our State?

If I was in front of you I would get on my hands and knees and beg you to please pass this bill.

Mahalo,

Ilene Harrington Kailua-Kona

Stone Willow - Support

Aloha,

I live in Honomu, a small town north of Hilo, on the Big Island.

I'm writing to encourage you to please vote for HB2072. I've seen far too many dogs neglected and abused, kept on short chains every single day of their lives. This is inhumane and calls to the Humane Society do not make a difference. Dogs deserve better treatment, to be walked and get proper exercise. Often times these dogs on chains aren't given water and food daily, so they are undernourished and sickly.

It's time that the state address this problem and follow through on enforcement. HB2072 is a good beginning.

Mahalo,

Stone Willow Honomu, Hawaii

Kendall Rau - Support

Please pass bill HB2072. It is heartbreaking to see a living creature spend it's entire life on a 3 ft. chain.

Thank you, Kendall Rau Laura Myers - Support

Please support the passage of HB 2072, the bill regarding the inhumane tethering of animals, and also please try to remove the step backward represented by lessening the fine for those who disregard this law.

Hawaii has a long way to go insofar as the rights of animals are concerned; please help these creatures who cannot help themselves.

Thank you.

Laura Myers

Ashlee Haavisto - Support

To Whom It May Concern,

As a constituent and resident of Hawaii Island, I am writing to urge that this bill be passed. It is important to the health and safety of our island's dogs that we begin regulating and improving conditions for chained dogs. I would hope that with the passage of this bill, we as residents and representatives can begin to open up a broader, more honest conversation about the detriments of chaining animals. Dogs are often considered to be members of our families. We want the best and we want better for all members of our families, dogs included. Please consider the passage of this bill fully and outright. I am confident that it is a huge stepping stone toward changing the way we treat our dogs here in Hawaii, and it will send a message to the world that we are ready to move forward in the right direction.

Thank you for your time.

--Ashlee Haavisto

Jennifer Jo - Support

Dear Representatives, I humbly ask your support of HB2072. I am asking on behalf of animals who are kept tied up every second of every day because they unfortunately do not have a voice to speak up for themselves. They probably did speak up at first when they were tied up, but unfortunately their voice was ignored and they were probably told to stop barking and quiet down. How could they be upset being chained up on a small tie while their family sat in the comfort of a warm and dry home? How could they bark for attention and love which is what the facility they adopted them from expected of their family to give them? Please stop this abuse of animals by passing this bill and hopefully discourage irresponsible pet parents from adopting animals just to chain them up for their entire lives. A convicted murderer in jail has more freedom than these dogs do, and yet all the dogs have done wrong is get adopted by careless and irresponsible parents? Please give us hope that there may be a day when we drive our local roads and do not see any dogs tied up. Thank you, Jennifer Jo Puna Hawaii

Pamela Small - Support

Dear Sir or Madam:

I am writing today to voice my support of HB 2072. It is the right and humane thing to do to put guidelines in place for the tethering of dogs on Hawaii. Animal cruelty is an issue that can not be taken lightly. While many people who tether their animals do so in a humane and responsible manner, there are many more who do not. These animals need legal protection from the conditions in which, through no fault of their own, they find themselves.

Please do right by the dogs of Hawaii and pass HB 2072.

Mahalo, Pamela Small Kawaihae, HI

Liz Herring - Support

To Whom this may concern,

I ask you to please pass HB2072. As an animal lover and someone that loves dogs, like I’m sure some of you do, I passionately ask you to pass this bill. By passing this bill you will help educate people on how to properly take care of their dogs. Thank you for your consideration.

Mahalo, Liz Herring, Kauai resident

Candy & Jim Casper - Support

Aloha, Please consider voting to pass HB2072. My husband and I live in Na'alehu and feel this is an important step to protect dogs on the Big Island. Mahalo, Candy & Jim Casper

Naalehu, HI

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/20/2018 6:34:54 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing K. Saiki Individual Support No

Comments:

I strongly support HB 2072. If it passes, it will about time. Hawaii is so behind on animal cruely compared to the mainland u.s.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/20/2018 7:56:53 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing M. Markl Individual Support No

Comments:

Hello Committee Members And Chair(s):

As dogs can feel, they need to be protected from anything such as tethering equipment and techniques that injure them. Just like us, they do not want pain, want protection and to safely belong. You have that special power to do this. Please use it now, and give them the mercy you'd want if you were in their situation. Whether we've used our power to stop suffering or not, I believe we will be accountable to life for our actions and decisions. Please pass HB2072 and continue working with your colleagues until it passes this session into law. Thank you.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/20/2018 8:12:02 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing lynne matusow Individual Support No

Comments:

Please pass HB2072, which would prohibit the use of specific tethering equipment and techniques that have been found to be injurious to dogs. Dogs that are denied a proper pack relationship with their families are more prone to bite.

Chained dogs are more likely to attack without provocation. There was a news story tonight about a Big Island dog that was found emaciated, with a chain collar embeded in his neck. Only through the support and care of the family that found the dog, Laki, is he now doing well. He has gainee more than 20 pounds and is very loving. Dogs should not be chained.

However, I ask you to strike the proposed amendments reducing the penalties for a tethering violation. These amendments represent an erosion of steps taken by the Legislature to take animal cruelty crimes more seriously.

Please reject the reduced penalties for violators and support the rest of this bill.

Lynne Matusow

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 12:27:39 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Jaunette Itsuno Individual Support No

Comments:

I am a resident of Hawaii and I support HB2072, HD1. I would like to mention an additional tethering abuse situation which I have seen in Hawaii and is not specified in this bill. I have observed situations where dogs in Hawaii are tethered by a rope or chain and unsupervised near a public sidewalk or road on unenclosed property. This leaves the dogs in a vulnerable position as they can be harmed since there is no physical barrier to the property. I also noticed that the dogs who are put in that situation seem more aggressive than normal to anyone walking by the property since they are in a risky situation themselves.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 7:26:29 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Lisa Kaluna Individual Support No

Comments:

Aloha,

I am writing today in support for HB2072. Our Humane Society and police aren't able to take action because the laws don't define what abuse or neglect is (so I was told when trying to rescue a dog). This bill is a great start that I hope will give people some ability to protect these innocent and helpless souls.

Thank you,

Lisa M. Kaluna

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 7:58:47 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Jean Smail Individual Support No

Comments:

The restraint of any animal for an extended time is inhumane and unnecessary. The damage that can be done both physically and mentally to these poor animals. Laki was found on January 4th, lying near death by our property. He had been tethered with a metal choke chain and a heavy metal wire and heavy clasp. The choker had been put on wrong and was in the constant chicken position. Because of this, the chain acted like a saw moving back and forth, with no way to release. It cut through his skin, muscle, nerves until it reaches his spine where it stayed for such a long length of time that it imbedded , and healed over more then an inch under his neck. As it started to heal, the metal began to corrode and made all the tissue under his skin necrotic. Only the ends of the chain and the heavy clasp were visible. The tissue had grown through each link of the chain making it very difficult to remove. That was finally accomplished with a 3 hour surgery. The damage was severe and the healing has been excruciating for him as there was no tissue to suture, so open wounds have been healing with medical treatment for almost two months.

There is no reason to leave any animal on a line for extended time, especially a metal choke chain, which should NEVER be used to tether a dog.

PLEASE pass this law to regulate how people can tether animals. Obviously some people need laws to show them the correct way to treat their animals. Cruelty to any animals is not necessary, and should not be tolerated by any of us.

LAKI DESERVED BETTER AND SO DOES EVERY ANIMAL LEFT TO SUFFER.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 8:23:26 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing All people that Love and cherish their dogs for Katharine E Avery Support No the service they provide, unconditional Love!

Comments:

I have a neighbor who ties his dogs up with six feet of rope.They are all tied separately so they don't get any play time or love from each other. They howl incessantly and my heart goes out to them. It is time as a nation we stop torturing the animals that Love us so unconditionally! These living beings are more than worthy of the attention this bill requests! Please use your heart to make this law happen! Mahalo

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 9:48:12 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing ERICA PEREZ Individual Support No

Comments:

To: Chair Nishimoto of the Judiciary Committee

From: Erica Perez, Hawaii Island resident

RE: I am testifying in Full Support of HB 2072 HD 1

I live in Orchidland Estates on Hawaii Island. I see dog abuse and mistreatment of animals all over Hawaii Island. I have witnessed dog's with embeded chains and collars in their neck, blood running down their body. I have seen dogs chained to a tree with a 5ft lead, only to be beaten by humans for barking or making noise. I have had my own dog held hostage by a friends neighbor, with the threat of skinning her and hanging her from a tree.

All of these cases I contacted the local HIHS or in the later situation the Police dept. I have been told by police and humans society personnel to take the matter in my own hands, as their is no law stating that it is illegal.

If laws do not change, in support of and protection, animal owners and lovers are going to do exactly what the HIHS and Police recommend. Leading to unstable and un-safe communities.

Please PASS HB 2072 HD1 for the love of innocent creaters!!!! PLEASE

Mahalo nui for your time,

Erica Perez

TO: Honorable Chair Nishimoto and Members of the House Committee on Judiciary Feb 22, 2018, 2pm

SUBMITTED BY: Inga Gibson, Policy Consultant, West Hawaii Humane Society [email protected], 808.922.9910

RE: SUPPORT for HB2072 with Suggested Amendments; Relating to Dog Tethering

The West Hawaii Humane Society respectfully urges your support of HB2072 with the below strengthening and clarifying amendments.

This important measure aims to limit the manner in which a dog is tethered to reduce the likelihood of entanglement or injury. Dogs are highly social animals who need interaction. Tethered dogs are 3 times more likely to bite than non-tethered dogs and of those bites, children are 5 times more likely to be the victims. Limiting dog tethering not only improves the quality of life and care for the dog but protects public safety, by reducing the likelihood of dog bites and aggression.

We suggest the following amendments: - Expanding the educational counseling and psychological assessment provision for those who assist in the commission of unlawful dog tethering to ALL offenses under section 711-1109 and to apply to those who commit and those who assist in the commission of a violation. Counseling and psychological assessment is especially important in egregious cases of cruelty or those involving minors. Cruelty against animals is both a predictor and precursor to other violent behavior. For children who commit it is important to identify if that child may be modeling such behavior or is a current victim of abuse. - Animal care and control agencies should retain their current discretion to charge a misdemeanor for unlawful tethering, as with other offenses under this section, rather than lowering penalties to a petty misdemeanor. While most tethering offenses are related to a lack of education, resulting in a warning and education of the owner, other cases may be more serious, especially if the owner has repeatedly been warned or the offense results in serious injury or death of the animal.

1

- Removing reference to 1st and 2nd degree tethering offenses including community service. Counseling, community service and other penalties/provisions remain under judicial discretion appropriate to the individual case. - Clarifying that each animal involved constitutes a separate offense

Thank you for your consideration of this testimony and the above proposed amendments.

2 Matthew Deane - Support

Sent from the moon.

Hannah Deane - Support

Dogs deserve happy healthy lives!

Dana Jenkins - Support

Please pass HB2072, which would prohibit the use of specific tethering equipment and techniques that have been found to be injurious to dogs.

Dogs that are denied a proper pack relationship with their families are more prone to bite.

Chained dogs are more likely to attack without provocation.

Most of the language in this bill was supported in the prior two sessions by both animal welfare groups and law enforcement. It is a step in the right direction.

We do, however, request that the committee strike the proposed amendments reducing the penalties for a tethering violation. These amendments represent an erosion of steps taken by the Legislature to take animal cruelty crimes more seriously.

Please reject the reduced penalties for violators and support the rest of this bill.

Mahalo,

Dana Jenkins

Juliet Pearson - Support

I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside. Too many of these animals spend their entire lives at the end of a chain and suffer deplorable conditions. This must stop. All living creatures should be treated with respect.

Mahalo Nui Loa, Juliet Pearson

Darlene Ferrantino - Support

Please pass bill #2072 on Thursday to support and protect Hawaii's tethered dogs. They are our "best friend' and need to be treated humanely. Thank you

Magda Khordoc - Support

Please pass HB2072 Magda Khordoc Waikoloa Village, 96738, HI

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 10:43:49 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Steven Jacquier Individual Support No

Comments:

I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside.

Mary Strong - Support

I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside

The condition that Laki was found in and the pain the dog has endured is appalling! The only good outcome is that the fact that people do treat dogs (and other animals this way has been brought to public attention.

I see dogs tied out that I know are getting only the most basic care. I have called the humane society and police and had minimal success. The dogs get a little better care for a while at best...

My number one concern is for the dogs. I also see that having dogs that bark and whine continuously in neighborhoods can affect the right of homeowners peace and quiet and potentially property values.

I do believe that mistreatment of an animal should be a criminal offense. Dogs deserve to be let off their tethers each day, have proper housing, continuous water, adequate food and health care.

Aloha,

Mary Strong HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 10:57:36 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Rene Umberger Individual Support No

Comments: HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 11:09:56 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Vivian S. Toellner Individual Support No

Comments: https://www.facebook.com/A-dog-named-Laki-308644822976139/ A dog named Laki is on Facebook, and you can see many before and after pictures- including the surgery.

This is a recently 2018 terrible case on the Big Island of Hawaii. The pictures I hope to submit, are very upsetting, so please be warned. Mahalo to the wonderful veterinarian who did the surgery. It is terrible and don't understand how something like this can happen. I hope legislature can help. Aloha & Mahalo.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 11:11:46 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Stephany Cecil Individual Support No

Comments:

The normalized mistreatment of dogs in Hawaii is disgraceful. We need to move in the direction of humane treatment for our in Hawaii.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 11:18:38 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Rodrigo Romo Individual Support No

Comments: HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 11:23:35 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Janine Tully Windward Hui Support No

Comments:

TESTIMONY IN SUPPORT OF HB 2072 HD 1

Please stop the use of inappropriate tethering equipment and techniques that hurts dogs. It is known that chaining dogs for long periods of time throughout the day promotes aggressive behavior in dogs and it is simply inhumane. Dog advocates have worked long and hard to pass this bill. Please take action now.

Janine Tully, President

Windward Dog Park Hui

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 11:32:25 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Selene Mersereau Individual Support No

Comments:

I supoort this bill prohibiting the use of tehering equiment and techiniques that are unjurious and cruel to dogs.

Please reject the reduced penalities for violators.

Thank you for being a voice for respect and compassion in our treatment of animals.

Diane Kawamoto - Support

I support HB2072 - please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii dogs that are tethered outside.

Sincerely, Diane Kawamoto

Terri Lo - Support

“I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside.” Too much of this is happening in Hawaii and needs to be handled immediately!

Mahalo,

Terri Lo

Jasmine Kropik - Support

I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside.

Judy Mick - Support

Aloha - I have been a pet sitter/dog walker in Hawaii for 30 years. Tethering a dog is cruel and should be severely limited. One of the stickers on my business car says "Don't tether, build a fence". Tethering puts dogs at great risk as shown by vets records of dogs with embedded chains around their necks. It also allows people who would harass a dog the ability to do so. Living life at the end of a tether can create aggression in a canine and puts unknowing humans (especially children) at great risk which is preventable. There is no positve aspect of tethering, Thank you. Judy Mick, Kailua

Mary Menacho - Support

I support HB2072 - please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii's dogs that are tethered outside.

Having a law for this should not be necessary, but unfortunately it is. Hawaii needs stronger laws to prevent dangerous and inhumane tethering methods.

Mahalo for your time and consideration on this important issue,

Mary Menacho

Big Island Resident

Sandra Vogel - Support

Please pass HB2072. I believe it is important to the health and welfare for Dogs to not be chained. They are social pack animals and need love,attention, and freedom just like other living creatures. They can smile and play, be sad and lonely, and joyfully greet you when you return home. They deserve safety and care. Mahalo, Sandra Vogel Tiki Lane Ocean View Hawaii 96737

Marta Gonzalez-Lloret - Support

I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside. Hawaii really needs stronger laws to prevent dangerous and inhumane tethering methods. Thank you for your consideration,

Marta Gonzalez-Lloret Professor, UH Manoa

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 12:33:36 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Danielle Swenson Individual Support No

Comments:

To: Chair Nishimoto of the JUD Committee

From: Danielle Swenson / Kona resident

Re: Support of HB 2072 HD1

Aloha Committee Members and Chair -

I am a pet owner and have made the Big Island my home now for over 17 years. It is so very hard to see animals tethered and boxed up in kennels. I know you know how common it is. We need to change the culture of this and that is a hard thing to do.

My neighbors have a pitbull that they used to tether. She has broken off of her 10' tether at least 3 times, and has attacked my husband as well as other folks in the area. Because it is kept this way, not getting any exercise or ability to move around more than it's 10' radius, it is extremely hostile. I know other dog owners of these types of breeds that provide humane care and their animals are amazing and sweet - not hostile. It is unacceptable that I cannot walk my neighborhood in fear of tethered dogs breaking free. Absolutely ridiculous. This type of treatment breeds hostile animals that put us all at risk.

I'm also not proposing caged animals either. Now, my neighbor's poor dog is kenneled in a small space day in and day out. She barks at everything. What a miserable life. It is so sad and unfortunately, we as neighbors have to hear her moaning in misery or barking for attention. I'm curious why the verbiage in this bill allows for a tether to be "5 times the length of the dog" but I do not see anything in how large a kennel must be.

Bottom line - if you have an animal, have the means to care for it in a humane way. Otherwise, what is the point. I know people have dogs for protection, but that does not mean it needs to be kept in poor conditions or not receive anything other than a cage with a feeding once a day.

Mahalo for your consideration.

Danielle Swenson

February 21, 2018

To: COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY Rep. Scott Y. Nishimoto, Chair Rep. Joy A. San Buenaventura, Vice Chair

Re: Strong Support for HB2072

Hrg: HB2072 February 22, 2018 at 2pm

Healthy Pets United is dedicated to pet health by promoting a happy life for pets through education and advocacy.

Healthy Pets United strongly supports HB2072 which would prohibit certain restraints and tethers that endanger or deny sustenance to a dog.

In promoting a healthy life for dogs, it would be ideal that every dog would share a home with their human family, however, that is not always possible. For those situations where tethering is necessary, it is important that dogs who live outdoors be protected.

Dogs are highly social animals and need interaction. Tethered dogs are three times more likely to bite than non-tethered dogs. Limiting dog tethering not only improves the quality of life and care for the dog but protects public safety, by reducing the likelihood of dog bites and aggression.

Please pass HB2072. Thank you for the opportunity to provide testimony on this important issue affecting animals in Hawaii.

Respectfully submitted,

Chase Kessler Director

PO Box 61681 Honolulu, Hawaii 96839 www.healthypetsunited.org [email protected] HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 12:54:21 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Christine Russo Individual Support No

Comments:

I strongly support HB2072. Animals should not be confined to kennels, ropes, chains, etc. I also agree with all other measures in the bill designed to protect animal welfare.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 1:05:39 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing romel pasaoa Individual Support No

Comments:

I strongly support this bill

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 1:10:01 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Smith Individual Support No

Comments: HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 1:15:26 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Dana Jenkins Individual Support No

Comments:

I support HB2072, which would prohibit the use of specific tethering equipment and techniques that have been found to be injurious to dogs. Dogs that are denied a proper pack relationship with their families are more prone to bite. Chained dogs are more likely to attack without provocation.

Most of the language in this bill was supported in the prior two sessions by both animal welfare groups and law enforcement. It is a step in the right direction. However, I request that the committee strike the proposed amendments reducing the penalties for a tethering violation. These amendments represent an erosion of steps taken by the Legislature to take animal cruelty crimes more seriously.

Please reject the reduced penalties for violators and support the rest of this bill!

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 1:24:47 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing C. Azelski Individual Support No

Comments:

Please pass HB2072. What helps animals helps people by improving our communities. Thank you.

Colin Luck - Support please pass HB2072

Colin Luck Waikoloa Village

Susannah Welch - Support

Aloha,

I am writing in support of HB2072 to help define dog abuse/neglect. I find animal mistreatment abhorrent and unnecessary and, when it occurs, our Humane Society and police aren't able to take action because the laws do not clearly define animal abuse or neglect. This bill is a great step toward reducing animal cruelty and suffering and I hope it will officials and the general public better protect pets. Thank you for your time and consideration.

Susannah Welch

Hilo, HI

Joy L. Namelo - Support

Good Afternoon,

Please pass HB2072 and help keep innocent dogs healthy and safe, while educating owners on how to properly care for them.

On walks with my dog, we pass a house that often has a dog tethered in the carport. We have had to untangle this poor dogs leg from the line that was tightly wound around it. To leave an animal unattended and at risk is irresponsible and unacceptable.

If a person wants to keep their home safe - get locks/alarms/cameras. If they’re - use their own skill. Just wanting an accessory - go to Sears.

Animals are living beings, but unfortunately too many of us are deaf to the language of reason, decency and compassion, which is why they suffer.

Once again I ask that HB2072 be passed.

Aloha,

Joy L. Namelo

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 1:54:35 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Nina Alena Beatty Individual Support No

Comments:

I support this bill! Please pass this bill so the neglect and abuse of animals in Hawaii can take one more steo to coming to an end.

The bill does reduce penalties for tethering offenses, which I oppose, but I fully support the rest of the bill.

Emily Twidwell - Support

Aloha,

As a previous owner of a pitbull, I set to work with a dog trainer to work on her behavior. The trainer told me that one of the most important things was not to put her on a tether or chain. The tether promotes aggressive behavior.

As I drove through neighborhoods in Puna, I would see so many dogs in cages or chained up. Nobody pets them, nobody cares for them. I don't know why they even have them. They deserve better. Dogs should not be allowed to be tied up for their entire lives. What kind of life is that?!

Please help the dogs achieve a better standard of living!

Thank you, Emily Twidwell

Lauren Butcher - Support

I support HB2072- please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii's dogs that are tethered outside.

Lauren Butcher Registered Voter

Rosemary Karlsson - Support

Please support HB2072 to define animal abuse/neglect.

People who abuse and/or neglect animals sometimes later abuse/neglect children, partners, or the elderly. I’ve done dog rescue for 20 years and seen plenty of abuse and neglect, it’s revolting what people do to animals.

Rosemary Karlsson

Marybeth Weber - Support

I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside. The treatment of animals in this state is despicable. People that treat animals badly will also treat people badly.

Marybeth Weber

Volcano HI

Jude Riley - Support

I lived on the Big Island for over 10 years and while there saw too many poor dogs who lived entire lives on short chains. When living in a house on the southwest corner of Olena & Makuu Dr. in Hawaiian Paradise Park (our house directly across the St from Malamalama Waldorf School) we had many terrifying incidence with such dogs. The neighbor to the South next to us had about five dogs on his property which he left there all alone and came to feed every day or two. Nobody lived at the property, only the dogs, chained up on short chains seperately. Many times his dogs would escape and come into our property and scare my son & I and challenge our dog. The poor things were probably looking for some contact with anyone, or some food, but being chained up all their days made them crazy. We were lucky we were never hurt. During our time there someone was; a pack of dogs who had escaped attacked a woman jogging and killed her. I believe if you went to the property on Olena that is the second from Makuu, on the West side of the road, you would find dogs still there and all alone still today, almost five years since my son and I lived there. Chaining up dogs and never letting them off is cruel and inhumane but it is also dangerous to people, not to mention the endangered species of the island (like the Nene). Please stop these people from treating these poor animals like this! Thank you, Jude Riley

Nona Wilson - Support

I strongly support HB2072 and encourage stiffer penalties for abuse of animals in our state. As a medical professional, I have seen animal abuse be a precursor of abuse of others like children and the elderly. The cycle of abuse of a living creature has got to stop.

Seth Bullard - Support

Not only is the confinement horrible it is also dangerous, especially for kids. Canines are pack animals and NEED social contact with others and humans. Continuous lack of contact is ALWAYS detrimental to a dogs mental health. They are unable to respond appropriately to other dogs and humans. In such situations children are at risk because they are unable to recognize the danger and often reach for a dogs neck which the triggers instincts for the dog to defend himself.

Austen Stone - Support

“I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside.”

Thank you, Austen Stone, MPH

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 2:14:20 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Kirsten C. Individual Support No

Comments: Victoria B. Anderson - Support

Dear Judiciary Committee:

Please pass HB2072, to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside. The treatment of Laki amounted to torture; no other way to describe it. Common decency instructs us to prevent this from happening to other animals.

Mahalo,

-- Victoria B. Anderson Honolulu

Taylor L Palmer - Support

Aloha,

I am writing to urge lawmakers to please pass HB2072.

Every time I return home to Hawaii, I am reminded of how awful the lives of some of these dogs are. Year after year, I pass by the same dogs, in the same dirt patch, on the same chain, with the same dilapidated “structure” to shield them from the elements. They exist and die in the same empty space they’ve been chained to all their life.

It is sad, it is cruel, it is wrong.

Moreover, what message does our treatment of animals send to our children? To our visitors? To our communities?

Please help be part of the change.

Sincerely, Taylor

Angie McCall - Support

I support HB2072

To: Honorable Chair Nishimoto, House Judiciary Committee members In Support Of: HB2072, with amendments Date: February 22, 2018 2:00 p.m. Testimony By: Keith Dane, Hawaii Policy Advisor, The Humane Society of the

On behalf of Hawaii members and supporters of The Humane Society of the United States, I appreciate the opportunity to submit this written testimony in support of HB2072, to limit the tethering of dogs.

HB2072 creates reasonable standards for chaining dogs who live outdoors, addressing a critical issue with impacts on both animal welfare and human health and safety. The legislation offers common sense protections for Hawaii’s dogs: a) requires that dogs who are kept outdoors be provided proper and humane restraints, with collars and tethers that won’t cause pain and suffering, b) provides basic standards for the type of chain used to prevent tangling and c) requires that dogs who are tethered or chained have constant access to necessary sustenance.

This story of Laki, a Big Island dog found near death with a chain embedded in his neck, just aired on KHON on Tuesday, February 20, 2018, and is a prime example of why Hawaii needs stronger laws to prevent dangerous and inhumane tethering methods: http://khon2.com/2018/02/20/couple-nurses-chained-dog-back-to-health-as-new-bill- aims-to-protect-animals/. Graphic images of Laki’s condition may be seen at https://www.facebook.com/A-dog- named-Laki-308644822976139/.

While our hope is that every dog would share a home with his or her human family, we recognize that is not always the case, so it is important that dogs who live outdoors be protected. Specifically, we support laws that provide minimum standards of care for dogs who live their entire lives at the end of a chain.

Constant, improper chaining puts a dog’s health and safety at risk. In many cases, the necks of chained dogs become rubbed raw and covered with sores, the result of poorly fitted collars and the dogs’ yanking and straining to escape confinement. Additionally, it is shockingly common for law enforcement officers to find dogs with embedded collars, a horrible situation where the collar grows into the skin, which typically requires surgery. Tethers can pose a serious risk to a dog’s overall health. In a statement issued by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, experts explain, “a tether can become tangled around or hooked on the dog’s shelter structure or other objects, further restricting the dog’s movement and potentially causing injury.”

The vagueness of our current law makes it difficult for law enforcement officers who want to take action before a dog has suffered an injury or death. HB 2072 will create clear guidelines for the owner and the officer. The intention of this bill is not simply to punish violators, but to create clear and reasonable expectations for the humane treatment of tethered dogs, and to allow responsible owners the ability to take proactive steps to comply.

HB 2072 is supported by The Humane Society of the United States and all four county-contracted humane societies in Hawaii. The Humane Society of the United States requests a favorable report on HB2072.

Keith Dane 301-312-1489 HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 3:35:10 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Damione Verdusco Individual Support No

Comments:

Aloha,

Please pass HB2072.

Respectfully submitted,

Damione Verdusco

Stephanie McLaughlin - Support

I support HB 2072. It should be against the law to tether a dog on a chain outside for hours at a time. Stephanie McLaughlin, -- Stephanie McLaughlin "Be the change you wish to see in the world."

Kimberly and Joseph Fenech - Support

Please pass HB2072.

Dogs emotional and physical health erode when chained. They deserve to be treated with compassion.

Please pass HB2072.

Respectfully, Kimberly and Joseph Fenech

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 4:03:22 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing David A Bice Individual Support No

Comments: HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 4:06:43 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Stephanie McLaughlin Individual Support No

Comments:

Chaining a dog is wrong. It only creates more problems, causes the dog to become aggressive and can hurt or kill the dog. Chaining a dog for long periods of time is cruel and inhumane and should be outlawed.

Debra Greene Valencia - Support

Dear Sir or Madam, I'm writing you today to ask for your help to get HB2072 passed. I support HB2072 and ask that you please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside. Thank you

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/21/2018 6:35:42 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Cathy Goeggel Animal Rights Hawai'i Support Yes

Comments:

Animal Rights Hawai'i has observed and documented the misery of chained/tethered dogs for many years. It appears that our legislature doesn't care about the plight of these dogs. Hawai'i may be paradise for tourists, but it is not for animals. It is disgraceful that with ALL the local support for strong legislation, HB2072, as amended, is so manini in its request. Please pass HB2072 HD1 -please show some aloha for man's best friend.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/22/2018 12:32:52 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Natalie Parra Individual Support No

Comments: HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/22/2018 6:56:06 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Mike Moran Individual Support No

Comments:

Aloha Chair Nishimoto and committee members. Mike Moran from Kihei. Sorry, I know this is late, bur please give consideration to the import of showing care and concern for creatures who have no voice nor vote This bill asks little, but it is a start. Dogs do so much good for humans, and we in turn give back little. Your vote can be a manini step to fixing this. Mahalo, Mike

Brajen Sky Pelc - Support

Please pass HB2072

Link to bill: https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=2072&year=2018

Brajen Sky Pelc

Kauai

April Blades - Support

Dear Committee,

I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside.

Thank you, April Blades

Lorraine Garnier - Support

Dear Judicial Committee Members

“I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside.”

This story of Laki, a Big Island dog found near death with a chain embedded in his neck, aired on KHON last night, and is a prime example of why Hawaii needs stronger laws to prevent dangerous and inhumane tethering methods: http://khon2.com/2018/02/20/couple-nurses- chained-dog-back-to-health-as-new-bill-aims-to-protect-animals/. sincerely,

Lorraine Garnier

Ashley Hogue - Support

I strongly support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside.

I lived in a neighborhood in Makawao where this is a very apparent practice and is not ok.

Mahalo for your consideration,

Ashley Hogue

Jennifer Connery - Support

To whom it may concern: I have always felt that animals should be respected the same way as humans. By chaining a dog up in a yard goes against every natural instinct for any animal. It is the equivalent to a human in jail. I feel this bill will allow dogs to finally have more freedom and actually be able to enjoy a proper life that is well deserved. Thank you for your time and consideration consideration.

Katie - Support

I am in full support of passing HB2072, as chaining dogs for long periods of time is cruel to them both physically and mentally.

Petho-Zimmermann Csilla - Support

“I support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside.”

Jane Hylton - Support

I strongly support HB2072 – please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii’s dogs that are tethered outside!

Jane Hylton

Naalehu, HI

Siobhan Radway - Support

A chained dog is a suffering creature. He who chains the dog suffers too, but unawares. A chained dog, who is not simply outside for a couple of hours of fresh air & to go to the bathroom, but who exists in this hell is often destined to become a dangerous dog. The kind that will attack people who venture near-even if they intend to help it. Thus often leading injury & death to both people & the dog. Please stop this hateful practice. Save the Souls. Sincerely, Siobhan Radway

Michele Velasco - Support

Aloha! Kindly support this bill that will help be an advocate for dogs who are being kept tethered. These voiceless dogs need our help. Thank you so much. Aloha, Michele Velasco

Nanette Boeh - Support

Please pass HB 2702. Dogs are helpful to humans in many ways. They deserve to have humane care and treatment, including exercise and veterinary care. Mahalo

Nanette Boeh

Hawi, HI

Amanda Turner - Support

Please pass HB207

-Amanda Turner

Patricia Shields - Support

Chair Nishimoto and the Judiciary Committee:

First of all, I wish to thank you all for supporting this important bill, and for giving us the opportunity to help make it law.

I hereby submit testimony in support of HB 2072 for the following reasons:

• No animal deserves to be tethered to a pole or a railing outdoors for any reason, especially for prolonged periods of time without any type of shelter, food and water or positive interaction by the people who possess said animal. • Humans in prison are not tethered, and they have committed crimes. Animals are tethered yet they commit no crimes. • Anyone who is reported to or seen to be violating the basic humane treatment of an animal should be fined and/or lose the right to have any animal.

Dogs are not meant to be a cheap alternative to an alarm system, and should not be treated as such.

Thank you for your time and consideration in support of HB 2072.

Patricia Shields

Honolulu, HI.

Dr. Jana Levin - Support

Please pass HB 2072.

Mahalo,

Dr. Jana Levin Kailua Kona HI 96740

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/22/2018 9:16:40 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing naomi egami Individual Support No

Comments: Ginny Tiu - Support

Dear Chair Nishimoto and Committee Members,

I urge you to please support HB 2072. Dogs are social creatures, who feel what we feel and suffer as we do. They depend on us to do the humane thing for them. Also, a dog that is unreasonably restricted will be more aggressive.

Thank you so much for your kind consideration. Aloha, Ginny Tiu

Drinda Maxwell - Support

Please pass this bill to end the cruel practice of tethering!

Drinda Maxwell

Franny Pueo - Support

Aloha I support HB2072 and please do "PONO" for our island dogs who are being subjected to abused. Because we don't see a striking hand on a tethered dog, we assume there is no abuse, but abuse comes in many ways. Long hours on a short chain, where this poor animal poops where it eats, or it becomes hyper barking in its own language asking to be free even to be taken for a walk.

Aggressive behavior is a learned behavior caused by such solitude at the end of a short chain as dogs are social animals and denied time to be off chains.

I have witness people in our community who are completely ignorant on how to care for a dog. Its horrible, and if we don't educate people and the only way is to pass HB2072, they will continue to mistreat a dog by such misuse puppy to adult life.

Since they feel its only a dog, and that's how they were taught to keep in short chains, or no housing to protect from the elements, etc., the cycle of abuse continues from one generation to another.

Many of those dogs (once sweet and calm) once getting loose from such short chain and constantly being chain-up, are and have attacked other animals including humans.

Frannie Pueo Pres. Hui Pono Holoholona

My neighbor has chained his dogs from puppies to adults for years!, and month back one broke loose from his short chained and killed the other dog.

Stephanie Shipp - Support

I strongly support HB2072.

Please pass this important bill to increase protections for Hawaii's dogs that are tethered outside.

This is a photo of my dog whom we adopted from the Kona shelter 5 years ago. He was deaf and two years old at the time weighing only 35 pounds. He had been tethered outside his entire life. A chain had started to embed itself around his neck

Now he is 6 yrs old and 120 pounds

Please pass this important Bill.

Dogs deserve a better life than on the chain.

Thank you

Stephanie Shipp

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/22/2018 9:53:13 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Anne Forshey Individual Support No

Comments:

I am proud to be a resident of Hawaii, in part for our long history of compassion for individuals and animals. I strongly support the proposed updates to Section 711-1109, HI Revised Statutes in HB 2072. Please pass HB2072, which would prohibit the use of specific tethering equipment and techniques that have been found to be harmful to our dogs. Pls note:

- Dogs that do not bond with their families and caregivers are more prone to social problems and biting.

- Chained dogs are more likely to attack without provocation.

This bill was supported in the prior two sessions by both animal welfare groups and law enforcement. Now is the time to TAKE ACTION - this IS a step in the right direction.

Request that the committee strike the proposed amendments reducing the penalties for a tethering violation. These amendments represent an erosion of steps taken by the Legislature to take animal cruelty crimes more seriously.

Please reject the reduced penalties for violators and support the rest of this bill. Mahalo.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/22/2018 10:11:16 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Antonella Scolpini Individual Support No

Comments:

My name is Antonella Scolpini-Heisel.

Been a Maui resident since 1989, and a MHS volunteer since many of these years. I saw first hand the utterly detrimental effect of chaining/tethering dogs for long periods of time on the victims of this inhumane practice. Their confidence gone, so they become very nervous, fearful and highly anxious. They potentially can become dangerous dogs for the community.

Please implement serious rules like in the State of California where a dog cannot be chained and tethered for longer than 3 (three) hours in a 24 hour period, and the leash has to be 3 times the lenght of the dog from tip of nose to tip of tail.

Thanks for listening, Antonella-Scolpini-Heisel

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/22/2018 11:03:10 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing John NAYLOR Individual Support No

Comments:

Please pass HB2072 HD1 -please show some aloha for man's best friend.

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/22/2018 11:13:55 AM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Jeff Heisel Individual Support No

Comments:

Please support this new bill as it adds a few important protections for our "man's best friends".

Hawaii is known as a progressive state and this helps in keeping up that reputation.

Mahalo, Jeff Heisel, Kihei

HB-2072-HD-1 Submitted on: 2/22/2018 12:18:45 PM Testimony for JUD on 2/22/2018 2:00:00 PM

Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Ashley Wilcox Individual Support No

Comments:

Please pass this bill to protect dogs from this barbaric abuse. No animal deserves this type of treatment. Thank you.

Laura Martinson - Support

Please pass HB2072- Animals do not deserve to be chained up 27/7.

Multiple Testifiers - Support

We must all support humane treatment of our animals as our kuleana. SUPPORT HB2072 Please see the attached file of almost 10,000 signatures to get dogs off chains in Hawaii.

Sylvia Dolena Owner, Pele Lani Farm, LLC Pahoa

Name From Comments 1. angie ali KEAAU, HI we need to comply with the usda ruling which so many other states have adopted already. decline of our communities is the result of current practices which are against the usda ruling regarding Animal Welfare Act 2. Vince Miller Eden Valley, MN 3. Greg Stewart Keaau, HI 4. Sylvia Dolena Pahoa, HI Animal cruelty must be stopped. 5. Irene EKlund Ocean View, HI What some of the dog owners on the Big Island do do their fur children is disgusting....Please stop. 6. charles master Denver, CO 7. aj Em BOISE, ID 8. Dennis Kaplan MAYFIELD HEIGHTS, OH 9. mauricio carvajal , Chile 10. Brigitta MacMillan Deal, 11. Angel W. Jersey, United Kingdom 12. corine cathala Pierrelatte, 13. ljiljana jokic sarajevo, Bosnia And Herzegovina 14. Irene Brosseit Herford, 15. Vic Bostock ALTADENA, CA 16. Anneke Andries Raamsdonksveer, 17. Paola Scodellari Roma, 18. Jon Prochovnick LINDENWOLD, NJ 19. Lorraine Andersen LOUISVILLE, KY 20. Animal lover Workington, United Kingdom 21. Lisa Kaluna Keaau, HI 22. KimJ SorryUnwell Peterboro, United Kingdom 23. Judy Apelis CLIFTON, NJ 24. Stella Roma, Italy Gambardella 25. Jenny star Toronto, problems 26. Mark Stewart Aberdeen, United Kingdom Page 2 - Signatures 1 - 26 Name From Comments 27. James Mulcare CLARKSTON, 28. Ludo Stassijns Lebbeke, 29. Penny Gerrard , Canada 30. Ljiljana Milic Belgrade, Serbia 31. Paulo Reeson Toronto, Canada 32. Edward & Gail DENVER, CO Laurson 33. Henny Uhl Montsauche-les-Settons, France 34. NICK ROBLEY MANCHESTER, United Kingdom 35. Apostle Kontos Athens, Greece 36. Mike Robertson Toronto, Canada 37. michelle taylor , 38. GM seabra Anadia, Portugal 39. Deborah Stott El Monte Los Angeles County, CA 40. Joann Copper Tucson, AZ 41. Dominique LANG Vaison-la-Romaine, France 42. Dianna Gilmore GIG HARBOR, WA 43. Mari No Fwds LINDEN, CA Dominguez 44. Antoinette VICTORVILLE, CA Gonzales 45. Maryann Staron EVERGREEN PARK, IL 46. Roxana Moya Santiago, Chile 47. masayuki tanaka tsukuba, Japan 48. Kiku Rangel Taipa-Macau, Macao 49. Kim Taber Deerfield Beach, FL 50. Jane Jiles Marietta, 51. Alisa Burr Elberta, AL 52. jenny ablan Coolidge, AZ 53. Angeles Madrazo Campeche, Mexico 54. Thomas Rangel Taipa-Macau, Macao 55. Joanne Wilson Hudson, Canada This is disgusting abuse of harmless animals. Greedy abusers are less than human, I wish they meet the same destiny they bestow to these (continues on next page)

Page 3 - Signatures 27 - 55 Name From Comments 55. Joanne Wilson Hudson, Canada (continued from previous page) Starving. Neglected, abused animals. People are outrageously disgusting! 56. Ananya Bangkok, Boonyarattaphun 57. Martina Behla Berlin, Germany 58. Linda Tarumasely BEAVERTON, OR 59. gay johnson Huffman, TX 60. Monika V Paris, France 61. jadranka vidovic , Croatia 62. Karin Geens Booischot, Belgium 63. Anna Neusuess Berlin, Germany 64. Alyssa Keaau, HI Fehrenbach 65. Grazia Le Cannet, France Gambalunga 66. hELEN York, United Kingdom hEARFIELD 67. Nelly PRESTAT CHAUFFRY, France 68. Hent catalina - bucarest, Romania maria 69. Elsie Au BKK, Thailand 70. Maelie bugat Artiguelouve, France 71. Sanand D Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium 72. Caridad Peñalver Madrid, Spain Albaladejo 73. tineke Heutinck Arnhem, Netherlands 74. Christelle Mckie 1148, Switzerland 75. Wendy Leys belgium, Belgium 76. Ted Williams RALLS, TX 77. christine mael carhaix, France Bouteloup 78. Rudy Gallardo Euless, TX 79. Angelflowers ALPINE, AR Dawkins 80. A. F. Berlin, Germany 81. Frédéric Nelcha Saint-Prex, Switzerland 82. Mickey Wells Houston, TX

Page 4 - Signatures 55 - 82 Name From Comments 83. christina soli athina, Greece 84. Bruce Forster Gateshead, United Kingdom 85. Bartha Sjoerdsma Leeuwarden, Netherlands 86. Veronica Baez , Argentina 87. Sheila Gilbert Broadstairs, United Kingdom 88. Corrina Parker Toowoomba, Australia 89. Emmanuelle Trêves, France Michon 90. Janine Vinton Hastings, Australia 91. Mark van der Zuidlaren, Putten Netherlands 92. Aurelia Girardi Gioia del Colle, Italy 93. martin luce worcester, United Kingdom 94. Monika Bachmann Euskirchen, Germany 95. Hanneke Mol Poortvliet, Netherlands 96. Fiona Curran orne, France 97. isabel esteve castelloli, Spain 98. Athina Peter 22303 , Germany 99. Niina Bejling Stockholm, ראשון לציון, Yael Saydon Israel .100 101. Anna Maietta London, United Kingdom 102. Petra , Germany Hegenscheidt 103. Chantal Buslot Hasselt, Belgium 104. Judy Champion Ozark, AL No animal should EVER suffer such abuse. 105. Joan How Luton, United Kingdom 106. Robert Jemgum, Germany wiehemeijer 107. esther Kemperle st veit an der glan, 108. Maria van Geel Zdroisko, Poland Getekend

Page 5 - Signatures 83 - 108 Name From Comments 109. bellinda Oosterbeek, Rolf-jansen Netherlands 110. Julien Eberle ihgff, France 111. Akiko Sakaguchi setagayaku, Japan 112. muriel compain istres, France 113. Lisa Braem Hillsboro, OR 114. martine naudin masseret, France 115. Silvina Ares Rosario, Argentina 116. Lacey Levitt San Diego, CA 117. Nicole Weber PASADENA, MD 118. Ewa Lockard St. Disdier - Le Devoluy, France 119. Ian Williams Midvale, UT 120. Marianne Rehfeld REDWOOD CITY, CA 121. Javier Beraza Zaragoza, Spain 122. Katarzyna Płock, Poland Jasińska 123. Sarika Arora Alpharetta, GA 124. djamila grouci Nanteuil les meaux, France 125. Nadia gauvin Paris, France 126. Monica Wilfart Mons, Belgium 127. cheneval catherine chambery, France 128. Hilde Broeckx Ternat, Belgium 129. Jozef Lesaffre Brasschaat, Belgium 130. Peggy Stillwater, OK Fehrenbach 131. Ainsley Watson Winslow, United Kingdom 132. Denise Brook Dublin, 133. Yvonne de waard Lelystad, Netherlands 134. Greetje de Roo Almere, Netherlands 135. Natsuko Reitman San Diego, CA 136. Nelleke S D, Netherlands 137. Akemi Fukuyoshi HongKong, Hong Kong 138. Karen GEE Arva, Canada 139. Maria Tüchler Kirchbach, Austria

Page 6 - Signatures 109 - 139 Name From Comments 140. Michelle Hayward Kempston, United Kingdom 141. Linda Hinson Cove City, NC Totally wrong to treat an animal like this. Not cool to break their spirits and their hearts! 142. Mary Mayers SAINT PETERSBURG, FL 143. Bobbi Jo Parsley ATWOOD, IL 144. Helen A no Zirndorf, Germany forwards please 145. Sandy Glenn Ottawa, KS 146. A. O.Schaller Leimbach, Germany 147. Francesca Billiotte PONTLEVOY, France 148. ANNIE VALLET clamart, France 149. nelly mettrop Spijkenisse, Netherlands 150. Ruth Gregg Belfast, United Kingdom 151. Isobel Ewing Larne, United So cruel Kingdom 152. jutta mettbach geesthacht, Germany 153. Dany Coclin Tricot, France 154. Ross Sutherland ADA, OH This is ridiculously cruel - shame on Hawaii. 155. louise calleja , 156. Mariana Lukacova Moldava Nad Bodvou, Slovakia 157. Karin van Rijswijk Waaleijk, Netherlands 158. seyhan arslan Roosendaal, Netherlands 159. Anne Haarhoff George, South Africa Abysmal. 160. evi xanthopoulou thessaloniki, Greece 161. Gonny Stevens Lanaken, Belgium 162. Frances Vasquez Roswell, NM We must protect and be the voice of those who can not do it for themselves! All Lives Matter! 163. christiane witz , France 164. Nikoleta Tzenova , 165. Marta Do Stockholm, Sweden Nascimento 166. Bianca Brader Herne, Germany 167. angelika wegner burscheid, Germany

Page 7 - Signatures 140 - 167 Name From Comments 168. monika nitsche bad sooden-allendorf, Germany 169. Gerlinde Holzer Guntersdorf, Austria 170. Richard , France Berenguer 171. Elizabeth , , McGowan United Kingdom 172. Marie Rickard Toronto, Canada 173. Andrelene Babbitt OREFIELD, PA 174. rachel davies Merthyr tydfil, United Kingdom 175. Mary Thomas RICHMOND, CA 176. Carolyn Walker Greene, NY 177. Danielle Dimanche Seyne, France 178. Oleg Kobetz Kemerovo, Russian Federation 179. iwona van Katwijk delft, Netherlands 180. Manika Khosla Mumbai, India 181. Anita Hansen Riedstadt, Germany 182. Gity grupe Negenborn, Germany 183. Tina Michelakis Hasselt, Belgium 184. shawn mack kelowna, Canada 185. Anastasia Dunn Belfast, United Kingdom 186. Ivonne Carlson FORT MYERS, FL 187. Tara B. CASSOPOLIS, MI Please adopt modern animal welfare laws that ban the tethering of dogs. A dog belongs in a fenced yard or indoors with their human family. Chaining is both cruel to the dog and dangerous to the community. 188. Ирина Гущина Санкт-Петербург, Russian Federation 189. Cynthia Walton Onancock, VA 190. m. kincer SHELBY whoever own's this dog in this picture should have the dog TOWNSHIP, MI taken away.look how skinny the dog is he/she is being starved...call your local humane society or call several humane societies and ask them to come out and check on this dog,,here where i live they cut the chain right off and take them to the humane soc. so call and ask them to help this dog..thats animal abuse this dog NOT being fed properly !! 191. chris maes brux, Belgium

Page 8 - Signatures 168 - 191 Name From Comments 192. Helga , Germany Kronenwerth 193. Leslie Vanlessen Lanaken, Belgium 194. Christopher Evans Near Byton Hand, United Kingdom 195. Leona Casteels Mechelen, Belgium 196. Shirley COSTA Rio de Janeiro, 197. Iris Sinai Marlboro, NJ 198. Alexandr Vyshneve, Yantselovskiy 199. christine marest, France marchand 200. Nadine Buriassi Aix La Fayette, France 201. Marie DIAS LA VARENNE SAINT HILAIRE, France 202. Christine Fenton Elk Point, Canada 203. Lisa Mazzola TAMPA, FL 204. karine schmitt , France 205. Brenda Dumont GREAT Why would anyone want a dog that you are just going to BARRINGTON, MA chain up outside and leave them there 24/7???? It's not good for a dog to be left alone all the time it's no wonder that child was mauled because when someone abuses animal by mod of being alone all the time they turn nasty and unsocial!!! An animal does not want to be treated this way anymore then a human does so if you are going to get a dog just to tie the poor thing up DONT GET A ANIMAL AT ALL!!!! These dogs need to be taken away from the people who "own" them!!! This is just plain disgusting!!! 206. celine jaranowski etel, France 207. chloé gallia lausanne, Switzerland 208. VERONIQUE SIGEAN, France BONDONI 209. jerome masuy Paris, France 210. Natalie Klotzer Espoo, 211. Frauke Behrendt Würzburg, Germany 212. sieglinde frey neusiedel am steinfeld, Austria 213. rosette putzeys hasselt, Belgium 214. Donna Rose BUTLER, PA Sherman 215. nicole bonhoure crozes hermitage, France

Page 9 - Signatures 192 - 215 Name From Comments 216. Aria Spenser FORT MYERS, FL THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS CRUELTY AND SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE DONE IMMEDIATELY. 217. Silvia Cappi Barzago, Italy 218. Adele Meroni Barzago, Italy 219. Karen Cavey CHANHASSEN, MN 220. laborgrupo armer Nürnberg, Germany teufel c/ o dieter reger 221. Helene Collet Saint Paul en Foret, France 222. Anna Rossini pisa, Italy 223. Claudia Binfa CHICAGO, IL 224. debra wilson troy, VA 225. Leslie Angulo Le petit Quevilly, France 226. Carol Salganik Owings Mills, MD Please unchain you dogs. 227. Angelika Mönchengladbach, Yarahmadi Germany 228. Erika Howards CLEARWATER, FL 229. Sandra Vito Valencia, Spain 230. Laila Sunde Odda, 231. Lynn Carin North Hills, CA Dogs do not belong tied to any chains that are tied to stationary objects...it's CRUEL and it's diminishes the quality of their lives. This is NOT the way for any animal to live - it's WRONG. Hawaii needs to get on board about this issue. Do not allow these innocent animals to suffer any longer. Make sure Hawaii follows the laws already made regarding dogs on chains, PLEASE. 232. Joan Quigg Saint John, Canada 233. Sonia Minwer Ubeda, Spain Barakat Requena 234. Karina Utech Berlin, Germany 235. Irene Hamburg, Germany Nawo-Eichner 236. Cristina Seica Anadia, Portugal 237. Kathy , Canada Efthymiakopoulos 238. Marie Krmpf Champigny, France 239. Olga Bagena Jackson, MN 240. Jennifer Jones Wonthaggi, Australia 241. josé vazquez Ambilly, France

Page 10 - Signatures 216 - 241 Name From Comments 242. marianne van vliet spijkenisse, Netherlands 243. annie van-san houdeng-goegnies, Belgium 244. Janell Cooper HENDERSON, NV 245. Mary Rossiter Springfield, OR 246. Debbie Regan HAMILTON, NJ 247. carine henin Charleroi, Belgium 248. Michele H Chatsworth, CA 249. jocelyne lapointe terrebonne, Canada 250. Cyndee Kott Grand Rapids, MI 251. Oliver Jordi Rüedisbach, Switzerland 252. Manuela Arioli Milano, Italy 253. Simone Maes Gent, Belgium 254. melanie johnson crewkerne, United Kingdom 255. Herman Morren Breukeleveen, When people abuse animals, they abuse also people, this Netherlands next step is very small. 256. Olga Troyan Taraz, Kazakhstan 257. gianni staquet thuin, Belgium 258. Marga Gili Palma, Spain 260. Marinella Bigoni Modena, Italy 261. Sara McCarthy Homestead, FL 262. Debbie Michaels Carbrooke, United Kingdom 264. Barb Knight MARS HILL, NC Dogs in Hawaii and else where, DO NOT BELONG ON 3 FT LOGGING CHAINS!! The dog in the picture is STARVING!! Someone needs to call the ASPCA IMMEDIATELY!! 265. Danuta Watola Kalety, Poland 266. Barbara Lestorti Waterbury, CT This is clearly abuse and neglect!!! Seriously! Consider the total radius of three feet! No where to move, run, sleep and just be a dog. 267. Barbara Vieira STATEN ISLAND, NY 268. Pedro J. Zapopan, Mexico Mazariegos 269. Wilma Vbrandwijk vlaardingen, Netherlands 270. Ravindra Polgasowita, Sri munasinghe Lanka

Page 11 - Signatures 242 - 270 Name From Comments 271. Alexandra Sandoz Mayens de Chamoson, Switzerland 272. Mimoun Benouda N/A, France 273. Debi Leitner Greensboro, NC 274. myrna britton santa cruz, CA this is certainly cruelty 275. Annette München, Germany Berghammer 276. ROSANGELA são paulo, Brazil ARAUJO 277. Jillian Fiedor BILLINGS, MT 278. Peggy Binnion LITCHFIELD, OH 279. Sue Harrington MARTINEZ, CA Shame! 280. Tina Problems Stockholm, Sweden continue 281. Elli Loe North Vancouver, Canada 282. Alice Turlo Geneve, Switzerland 283. Luc Roux Pontgibaud, France 284. Lone Fundby Scarborough, Canada 285. Sigrid Müller Illschwang, Germany 286. caroline joly coulogne, France 287. liliane gantois Namur, Belgium 288. Beth McHenry PARKSLEY, VA 289. Pat Bowen BASTROP, TX 290. Natasha Newell Swan close, United Kingdom 291. GGmaSheila WILLMAR, MN Dillon 292. Zsuzsanna Mátraderecske, Kerényi 293. Jane Rita JOHNSTOWN, PA “It’s a matter of taking the side of the weak against the strong, something the best people have always done.” - Harriet Beecher Stowe 294. edy van den bergh willebroek, Belgium 295. Christine Lincoln Wharton, NJ 296. Esther Lopez Almansa, Spain 297. flavia pellizzari centre , Canada

Page 12 - Signatures 271 - 297 Name From Comments 298. Reinaldi Ragasa Aberdeen, United Kingdom 299. P Holmes PITTSBURGH, PA 300. Mia van de Loo Waalwijk, Netherlands 301. Doris Roemer St malo, Canada 302. Elena Villarrubia Madrid, Spain 303. norma villalobos el cajon, CA 304. Valerie Fruchard Lyon, France 305. Derek Richardson Wallsend, United Kingdom 306. wendy sanderson Hackney, United Kingdom 307. Gisela Gama Esposende, Portugal 308. Derek Richardson Wallsend, United Kingdom 309. Kelly Ross Port Williams, Canada 310. Barb Livingston LIVINGSTON, TX 311. Wendy Tinkler Christchurch, 312. Erzsibet Yurekli Saint Paul, MN 313. margaret Collette Thorigné fouillard, France 314. Régine Ducène Ath, Belgium 315. Katt Sims Stuart, VA 316. Lawren Rudley BLACKWOOD, NJ 317. Elaine McPherson Imperial, MO 318. Linda Jones SEDONA, AZ 319. Marianne Franck / Saale, Ich bin gegen Tierquaelerei, denn Tiere sind Wesen und Germany keine Sache, sie fuehlen und leidenwie wir Menschen. Stoppt das toeten der Hunde, lieber Kastrieren und Chipen(registrieren). Bitte zeigen Sie , das Sie auch ein Herz fuer dieseHunde haben ! 320. Michelle Kruize Winschoten, Netherlands 321. K Rus Jax, FL 322. Hollie Dawson Stoke-on-Trent, United Kingdom 323. JUANITA MARIA MERIDA YUCATAN, ARJONA Mexico 324. Melissa Bailey Lowell, MI

Page 13 - Signatures 298 - 324 Name From Comments 325. Lucy Hamby Tujunga, CA 326. Susan Randall Arvada, CO 327. IRENE PERRYSBURG, NY Last time I looked, Hawaii was part of the United States! TUZZOLINO Why aren't they following the law????? 328. paula haessley Mesa, AZ Hawaii IS part of USA!! Laws say NO tieing out!! 329. Hak Kim Charlotte, NC 330. Mohamad New York, NY ElAyoubi 331. Jeannette Cheeks Grizzly Flat, CA 332. Susan Finlon Chicago, IL 333. Andy Carlson Kenosha, WI 334. S Jitreun Ch, Thailand 335. Adriana Cadena Eso de México, Téllez Mexico 336. Elle Perkins NY, NY 337. Martina Zalguizuri Isaba Navarra, Spain 338. Philippa Powers , BC, Canada 339. Lanelle Lovelace Columbia, CA 340. naemi motoyama saitama, Japan 341. g pearson somerset, United Kingdom 342. stephanie dowell MOUNT AIRY, NC 343. Anna Polaris BEVERLY HILLS, CA 344. Barbara Preusser Pgh, PA 345. Chuck Densmore Clarkston, MI 346. James Walker JANESVILLE, WI 347. Crystal Rochester, NY Khammanivong 348. J. Olafsson Winnipeg, Canada 349. kerry huley KELSEYVILLE, CA 350. Harry Robinson JUNEAU, AK 351. Sue McGuey Brampton, Canada 352. Mary DeCraemer Clarkston, MI Shameful!!!!! 353. Frances Moniz Hilo, HI This is very inhumane. You can help them have better lives. 354. gina de Minelli blois Loire et cher, France 355. Ted Shauer Berkeley, CA 356. Patricia Frederick Lincoln, NE 357. Ferris Goins Kountze, TX This should be done in all states Page 14 - Signatures 325 - 357 Name From Comments 358. Carla Jones Deca3, AL 359. Kathy Henion MATHER, CA 360. J.J. v. Dongen Rijssen, Netherlands 361. Diana Fairbanks Salina, KS 362. Sandra Faucher Massey, Canada 363. Penny Bacon site Didsbury, Canada issues 364. Betty Guidry St. Martinville, LA 365. Beth-Ann Norton Chestnut Hill, MA 366. Lisa Ward 60657, IL This is not the life a dog shpuld live... They need food water and shelter and love!!!! 367. Bonnie Eicksteadt Rockford, IL No animal should live their life on a chain. 368. Tracey Haftmann las vegas, NV 369. Natalie Longarini Ottawa, Canada 370. Darryl Brees Saline, MI 371. Erin Canipe Charlotte, NC 372. KAYE MCMINNVILLE, TN HOLDER-NEAL 373. kenneth las cruces, NM williamson 374. Mike Bishop Wickliffe, OH 375. Norma Benitez Monrovia, CA 376. Danielle Blair Clayton, NC Unfair 377. Billie Flippo Springfield, MO 378. William Bach Bethel Park, PA 379. Darlene Bramhall Pierce City, MO 380. Samantha Young Reading, PA 381. Joyce Smock Jacksonville, IL 382. Tamara Watson KEAAU, HI 383. eki febiyanti Jakarta, 384. Danielle B Zanesville, OH 385. Regina Marlatt Port alberni, Canada Stop this practice now! 386. Judy Penna HOLIDAY, FL 387. Robin Riley Lincoln, NE 388. Walter Firth Wollstonencraft, Australia 389. Carolyn Leavitt Easton, PA 390. Vickie Smith Arlington, TX

Page 15 - Signatures 358 - 390 Name From Comments 391. Michelle Eaker Adamsville, AL 392. mauro torelli villarotta- luzzara, Italy 393. Stuart Herron Fake city, Canada 394. Beth Davis Fort Wayne, IN 395. doria wosk miami, FL 396. Alison Cahalan Murphy, TX 397. Shirley Miller Eden Valley, MN 398. Darlene Rupino MIDDLETOWN, NJ 399. Dana Zeniecki Milwaukee, WI 400. ilene harrington Kailua-Kona, HI 401. manana Tbilisi, Georgia kartvelishvili 402. Bonnie McKnight Laconia, IN Get them off the chains and feed them 403. Belle Hickman Long Beach, CA 404. JUDITH NIQUE OWATONNA, MN 405. Patricia Lo Luxemburg, Luxembourg 406. Allen Olson MINNEAPOLIS, MN 407. Tanya Kasper Wimberley, TX Protect animals! 408. Darla Mccoy Greenbrier, AR 409. Lona Goudswaard Rijswijk, Netherlands 410. Elisabeth Hansson Uppsala, Sweden 411. john byron paignton, United Kingdom 412. Chris Bickford New York, NY 413. Rodica , Romania Barlanescu 414. Detelina Sofia, Bulgaria Guecheva 415. Eneri Gardav Taninges, France 416. Silvia Lossgott Vienna, Austria 417. Inge Bjorkman Mariannelund, Sweden, Sweden 418. Linda Fischer Port alberni, Canada 419. André Henrique Cambuquira, Brazil Bacci 420. Adeline Wong , Singapore 421. Daniela Schnelzer Göppingen, Germany 422. Valerie Reed , Australia

Page 16 - Signatures 391 - 422 Name From Comments 423. Sandy Amador Holmdel, NJ 424. iza fabisz Bristol, United Kingdom 425. ROBERTO Asso, Italy MERITONI 427. Gottfried Messmer Karlsfeld, Germany 428. Dagmar Leischow Hamburg, Germany 429. AL Lim Singapore, Singapore 430. Geisha Garcia La Coruña, Spain 431. Ruth Litton SOUTH YARMOUTH, MA 432. Martina Hasimausi Berlin, Germany 433. ERIKA SOMLAI , Hungary 434. isabelle trevisan Pordic, France 435. Steffie Cassar , Malta Torreggiani 436. Julie Stuckey PENSACOLA, FL this is an outrage! 437. Nicola VeryBusy Somewhere, United Foster Kingdom 438. Lynne Thrower Nottingham, United Kingdom 439. Ed Vieira STATEN ISLAND, NY 440. Kristy McDonough Mount Gambier, Australia 441. Carolyn Fay London, United Kingdom 442. bernadette Paris, France chevreau 443. robert groves crawley, United Kingdom 444. mia carijn wielsbeke, Belgium 445. Ruth Smithson Clacton, United Kingdom 446. moya fry courtomer, France 447. Debra Doucette Quincy, MA 448. Darlene Abbott Sacramento, CA 449. Ans van ewijk Drunen, Netherlands 450. Erika Czelenk Balassagyarmat, Hungary 451. Carol magee Coupeville, WA

Page 17 - Signatures 423 - 451 Name From Comments 452. Tanya Kay Bentleigh east, Australia 453. chhime dolma amsterdam, Netherlands 454. elisabeth molines la seyne sur mer, France 455. Sandy Riding TAYLOR, UT 456. Kelley OConnor Hamburg, NY 457. MARTINE gerauld savonnieres devant bar, France 458. Geneviève LE THORONET, BLANC France 459. kathy brunner Sheffield Lake, OH 460. Doris Matte Porto Alegre, Brazil 461. melody Jacobsohn Johannesburg, South Africa 462. Terrie Phenicie ATHELSTANE, WI 463. Delia Rutter Manchester, United Kingdom 464. Susan Hale Prague, Czech Republic 465. Sylvie Auger Trois-Rivieres, Canada 466. Joan Walker BISHOP, CA 467. Sherry Kohn BOCA RATON, FL 468. Anne M No Fwd Plaisir, France Pls 469. Kerstin Strobl Marktoberdorf, Germany 470. Stephen Landry Dartmouth, Canada 471. Jacqueline COLOMA, MI Schmidt 472. Lynda Mercer , Australia 473. Lilia Saito Shimizu, Japan 474. scott edwards COLLINSVILLE, VA 476. veronique labeeuw zwevezele, Belgium 477. mary foley cork, Ireland 478. Lisa Neste HIGH POINT, NC 479. Cristiane Ramos São Paulo, Brazil 480. Igor Lukic Subotica, Serbia

Page 18 - Signatures 452 - 480 Name From Comments 481. Michelle TARPON SPRINGS, Wiedemann FL 482. Lydia Edwards Seneca, MO 483. Ruth Cain CLEARWATER, FL 484. J Roth ALGONQUIN, IL 485. Josy Canova Sion, Switzerland 486. Elizabeth bradley centerville, IA This is not ecceptable!!we need to get their laws changed for these poor dogs. 487. Marie Collins Orrville, OH 488. Pablo Bobe Buenos Aires, Argentina 489. Carol Bischoff Heerlen, Netherlands 490. Simone Duffin Koraleigh, Australia 491. Kathleen Whiting, NJ Robinson 492. Sharon Reynolds Non-us, United Kingdom 493. Joana Cipriano Coimbra, Portugal 494. Helene Bigbaiev Kew Gardens, NY 495. Amanda Dossey Farmingville, NY 496. catherine gaspard bruxelles, Belgium 497. Marco Baracca Milano, Italy 498. Maurizio Aurelio Vaprio d'Adda (MI), Mischi Italy 499. Annie Carro CHAZELLES SUR LAVIEU, France 500. Jodi Geery Danville, CA 501. druelle yves , France 502. Alexis Fasolka Marion Heights, PA 503. Angelika Höxter, Germany Schui-Lindthaler 504. Rehana VN Selcourt, South Africa 505. Sue Cone Hull, United Kingdom 506. john kay Liverpool, United Kingdom 507. Lee Davies Neath, United Kingdom 508. Mary Massie Eugene, OR 509. Tanja Lepikko Smålandsstenar, Sweden

Page 19 - Signatures 481 - 509 Name From Comments 510. Colette Othis, France Dominguez 511. ELIZABETH CENTREVILLE, MD LEPRE 512. Julie Menna Stockton, UT 513. CATHERINE , France BOLLY 514. mary luke renton, WA 515. Lilian Fries GAITHERSBURG, MD 516. tatiana lisina hjhj, France 517. june bullied Toronto, Canada ban chaining dogs the world over 518. Clea Hodge Huntington, NY 519. Barbara Campbell Vidor, TX 520. Bonnie Verdun, Canada McCrimmon 521. Bella Bk tholen, Netherlands 522. Eva George WARREN, MI 523. Hans de Vos Schoondijke, Netherlands 524. lea nat lucinges, France 525. Regine LOEUIL Hamoir, Belgium 526. Petra Stadtmueller Erlensee, Germany 527. rosa blanckaerts Antwerpen, Belgium 528. sofia cammrano adsvsd, Argentina 529. elisa bianca udine, Italy colavitti 530. Susanne Wiesneth Neuenbürg, Germany 531. cathy nolane paris, France 532. Jan Turner Bloomington, IN 533. anna yeshua ramat gan, Israel HAWAII...shame on you. 534. Jeannette Kurtistown, HI These dogs are ferocious and a danger to people and DePriest especially children. Also, they're miserable, most starving or deprived of basic needs: Shelter, water, food, human contact. This petition needs to be sent up for vote as soon as possible. 535. Lucy Pérez Chilpancingo, Mexico 536. Van Phan Bay point, CA 537. Thea Limon BIG BEAR LAKE, CA 538. Jess Bancarz UpNorth, Canada

Page 20 - Signatures 510 - 538 Name From Comments 539. paula lloyd burton on trent, United Kingdom 540. wendy kelly COVENTRY, United Kingdom 541. Cristina Dias Matosinhos, Portugal 542. bridie harding estombar, Portugal 543. Andre Ferro Helmond, Netherlands 544. Debbie bates Eastpointe, MI 545. wendy smith nelson, United Kingdom 546. Stavie Saunders Farmingville, NY 547. Marcine McBride MELBOURNE, FL 548. Anita Youabian La, CA 549. Solange Sanchez Betim, Brazil 550. manuela wolter san.jose, Costa Rica 551. Elizabeth Clay !eaau, HI I saw this with 2 dogs in Hpp big Island. It broke my heart. You can see their livrpes were miserable and broken. This is abuse. They could not even get together their chain link so heavy and shirt. Wow came up with this law were idiots, not caretakers if the animal kingdom of this earth. Mahalo 552. Phillip Anderton Poole, United Kingdom 553. Gilmara Moreira São Paulo, Brazil 554. Béatrice LIÈGE, Belgium SILVESTRE 555. Mirella Leite London, United Kingdom 556. Marie Kearton Bolton, United How would WE like it, if we were treated so? Kingdom 557. Karen Gram Distrito Federal, Mexico 558. BEATRIZ LANUS, Argentina RINALDI 559. Harry Notaro Surrey, United Kingdom 560. Nico Font Edinburgh, United Kingdom 561. Alex Lang Rösrath, Germany 562. Elaine Darlow Ventnor, United Disgusting treatment of animals in Hawaii.Shocked. Kingdom 563. Elizabeth Elizabeth, CO Haymond Page 21 - Signatures 539 - 563 Name From Comments 564. Jodi Phillips Albrightsville, PA 565. Ruth Griffiths Powys, United DISGUSTING ANIMAL CRUELTY VILE HAWAII! THIS Kingdom CHAINING OF DOGS SHOULD BE BANNED! THIS DOGS RIBS ARE SHOWING . HE IS BEING STARVED !!! WHICH IS WHAT YOU CAN EXPECT FROM SOMEONE WHO CHAINS & TORTURES DOGS IN THIS WAY! WHAT THE HELL IS THE MATTER WITH THE LAW HERE THAT IT THINKS ITS OK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! INHUMANE SCUM 566. Patricia Cross SAN JOSE, CA 567. Perola Padovani São paulo, Brazil 568. Bruce Abbott NEWARK, DE 569. Lisa Abraham Winnipeg, Canada 570. Claudia Acosta Amsterdam, Netherlands 571. Debora De lang Amsterdam, Sickkkk!!! Help them. Netherlands 572. Lisa Conner WOODBURY, NJ 573. Dr. Stefan Husum, Germany Petersen 574. Miia Suuronen Tampere, Finland 575. Susanne Varel, Germany Wischinski 576. Leigh Saunders HASTINGS, New Zealand 577. peter jays melbourne, Australia 578. norma lucia fonzo ROSARIO, Argentina 579. Genomiel Gines JERSEY CITY, NJ 580. jacky saul truro, United Kingdom 581. Ronda Mohr FLINT, MI 582. Barbara Walklate Staffordshire, United Kingdom 583. Maria Schulz Timisoara, Romania 584. Natalie Van Deurne, Belgium Leekwijck 585. Diana Beamish Ludlow, United Kingdom 586. A D Thunder Bay, Canada The scum should suffer the same way.. eye for an eye 587. Ann Conney Consett, United Kingdom 588. a alonso la plata, Argentina 589. Alda Beal Irineu, Brazil

Page 22 - Signatures 564 - 589 Name From Comments 590. Kirsty Turner Hartlepool, United Kingdom 591. Angela AWAY , Germany 592. Marie Rosso Kannapolis, NC 593. Sue schümmer ulm, Germany 594. Erla Kristjansdottir Reykjavík, Iceland 595. Maja Dordevic Las Vegas, NV 596. Marilyn Miravalles Quezon, 597. Danielle Holmes Adelaide, Australia 598. terry corley Luther, OK 599. Ingunn Sørensen Porsgrunn, Norway 600. Ewa Michalak Chorzów, Poland 601. Joyce Levy Zionsville, IN 602. Liliána Tóth Balmazújváros, Hungary 603. Crystal Jones Selinsgrove, PA 604. Ruhee Baltz London, United Kingdom 605. Mandy Orr Kilmarnock, United Kingdom 606. Christy Nemmer YORK, PA 607. mario santos lisboa, Portugal 608. Salaheddin Kristianstad, Sweden Moustafa 609. Diana Nguyen Port lavaca, TX 610. Sheila Paul Galeton, PA 611. Joyce Grajczyk KENT, WA 612. Cheryl Korwes mpls, MN 613. A Spiess Abbotsford, Canada 614. Michael Jacob Niddatal, Germany 615. Steven Barry Mannheim, Germany 616. Linda Trendler Bothell, WA 617. Hazel Rice SEATTLE, WA 618. Darcel Kashmark MOORHEAD, MN 619. Karin ST PETERSBURG, Braunsberger FL 620. Jo Mallinger New Plymouth, New Zealand

Page 23 - Signatures 590 - 620 Name From Comments 621. Kelly Charles Placerville, CA Who are the owners??? Put them on the chain and let them starve! 622. Raul Humberto San miguel de tucuman, Argentina 623. jill Gallager Franklin Lakes Bergen County, NJ 624. Diana Bosco Pune, India 625. Lisa Maccaro Pikeville, NC 626. Gina Soares Chesapeake, VA 627. Val Mar PHOENIX, AZ That is so cruel! 628. Heather Kennedy Campbeltown, United Kingdom 629. moon hong ho chi minh, Viet Nam 630. Kathy Rafferty Jacksonville, NC 631. Jan Lalumiere Lowell, MA 632. veronica blanco hurlingham, Argentina 633. Kimberly Wood Tomahawk Lincoln County, WI 634. Jane Kohan CLAYTON, NC 635. Lois HAMILTON SCHERTZ, TX 636. nancy lowe Barrie, Canada Noone should be tied to a log, or anything else, without having ample slack....human or non. Chaining shouldnt be allowed, period. 637. Jami Martinez SEDRO WOOLLEY, WA 638. Ada Smith Mountain view, CA 639. Glenys Rawdon Winnipeg, Canada 640. Scott cochuyt ROCK ISLAND, IL 641. Michael John , Slovenia Smith 642. Lhamo Ingrik Toronto, Canada 643. martha m whiting, NJ 644. niloufar tavakoli ANAHEIM, CA 645. MONICA WISCONSIN, Mexico RAMIREZ 646. maurizio grini lucca, Italy 647. Jeff Zimmer Ottawa, Canada 648. Kathryn Wirthgen Phoenix, AZ 649. Miguel de Jaureguiberry, Bethencourt

Page 24 - Signatures 621 - 649 Name From Comments 650. Stacey Rolston Stutterheim, South Africa 651. Jaz Calma Caloocan, Philippines 652. claudia barra epping, Australia 653. Lisa Sadighi Chatham, NJ 654. Kevin Alberto obregon, Mexico Guzman 655. Debbie Baughman Germantown, WI 656. Abel de jesus Xalapa, Mexico Rodríguez zavala 657. josiane caron Houdain, France 658. Wendy Finn Barrie, Canada 659. Jo Tumuyu Jakarta, Indonesia 660. Jennifer Evans WORTHINGTON, OH 661. Gail Horley Nanaimo, Canada 662. Hamidah Lakhani Calgary, Canada 663. John Pfaff Imhoff's gift, South Africa 664. Lisa Pitts Calgary, Canada 665. Peggy Kimbell Bossier City, LA 666. Susan Civitano FAIRFIELD, CT 667. abby spitzer croton, NY 668. Logan Welde Philadelphia, PA 669. Allyson Kirkland Worcester, MA 670. monika poole BAHAMA, NC 671. john pasqua ESCONDIDO, CA ban all tethering of great animals worldwide now. 672. Linda L Hudye la Prairie, This is so cruel and so inhumane ... and it is happening in a Canada "civilized state/country??? This must end now. No more visits to Hawaii for my household. 674. Marie Wakefield NEWPORT, OR 675. Lynn Barnes Brown City, MI 676. Jade Hall Durban, South Africa Dogs should have a yard to run in with no chain!! If you can't do that you shouldn't have one !! 677. Yasiu Kruszynski CHICAGO, IL 678. Mee leng ChAn INDIANAPOLIS, IN 679. chun Teo indianapolis, IN 680. Pippa Dell London, United Kingdom 681. Ruby Cornier Menlo patk, CA

Page 25 - Signatures 650 - 681 Name From Comments 682. 中田 和範 甲府, Japan 683. Genevieve Simon Arusha, Tanzania, United Republic Of 684. Deborah London, United Kingdom 685. Janet Peters Escondido, CA 686. Arabella Cox Calvert Green, United Kingdom 687. CARA Colorado Springs, CO This is animal abuse. If the people who govern and lead our Wisenbaker communities see fit to abuse animals, what hope do the rest of us have? What hope do the animals have?? Disgraceful. 689. geri galindo Niles, MI Please do something for these poor dogs. They do not deserve to be like this. This is so cruel and injustice, how would you like to be like this. Please stop this. God Bless these poor dogs. Wake up, stop this. 690. Sugeno Chiharu 大阪, Japan 691. George Theobald Cooktown, Australia 692. Alex Font Edinburgh, United Kingdom 693. Ida Parday Solna, Sweden 694. Ashley Schiano Cranston, RI 695. Jean Robinson Bedfordshire, United Kingdom 696. Adela Estudillo Anaheim, CA 697. Juan Carlos Rico Madrid, Spain Arrabal 698. Louise Buhler Sydney, Australia 699. Sonja Elidottir Kolsas, Norway 700. hanri van wyk bloemfontein, South Africa 701. Denisee Garstang Maidstone, United Kingdom 702. Françoise Rosieres, Belgium Ponteville 703. Romana Kruisz Wien, Austria 704. HENRI VALENCE, France GUAZZONI 705. Nhot Dinh Hanoi, Viet Nam 706. Laura Monjik Pula, Croatia 708. raleigh koritz MINNEAPOLIS, MN

Page 26 - Signatures 682 - 708 Name From Comments 709. Zuzana cechtice, Czech Šindelářová Republic 710. nafeesa southside, Australia the owner should be on that chain not the dog some one shareef-anderson take that dog before it dies there,, take him fed her and give her a good home why take picture rescue the dog 711. Maria Antonia Medellin, Gomez Rojas 712. claudia correia Portimao, Portugal 713. kathleen lavelle victoria, Canada 714. Danis Haritatos Athina, Greece 715. Isabel Großmann , Germany 716. Annick Charles Chatillon sur chalaronne, France 717. Jan Garen Swansea, United Kingdom 718. Deb Scarborough, ME Kalikow-Pluck 719. David Andrews Hove, United Kingdom 720. Hans Flocke Sankt Augustin, Germany 721. Ralf Groneberg Osterode, Germany 722. linda starrett HOLLAND, MI 724. Neeraj Dehraj Delhi, India 725. Donna Chaput Cumberland, RI 726. Dana Kánská Davle, Czech Republic 727. Melanie Golz Neustadt, Germany 728. hattori takako 大阪市, Japan 729. Lisa Zarafonetis DALLAS, TX 730. Josephine Keen Romford, Essex, United Kingdom 731. Jane Mackinnon Manchester, United Kingdom 732. Archangel Michael Nicosia, Cyprus 733. Christiane Bade münchen, Germany 734. Samuela Bernetti Fermo, Italy 735. Patricia E G. WAYNESBORO, VA 736. Rachael Pasta Adelaide, Australia 737. Susie Amerise Oro Valley, AZ

Page 27 - Signatures 709 - 737 Name From Comments 738. Paula Wilding Consett, United Kingdom 739. Shashank SINGH Lucknow, India 740. John B Aberteifi, United Kingdom 741. Rafael Fuster Brea Madrid, Spain 742. Lolli Milore Palma, Spain 743. Siyus Copetallus Mexico, Mexico 744. mariette vanseer Antwerpen, Belgium 745. karin schmitz worms, Germany 746. Gena Simmons London, United Kingdom 747. Zelime Gizzi Denver, CO 748. Debs Newcombe Newcastle Upon Tyne, United Kingdom 749. adrienne jones goldcoast, Australia 750. sheila mahoney aberdeen, United Kingdom 751. Claudia Callimaci Saint_Louis, Canada 752. Sylvie Bertrand Thetford Mines, Canada 753. Annika Virginia Water, United Bjornsdotter Kingdom 754. Marcelo Thurman EVANSTON, IL 755. Lisa Robbirds DEFUNIAK SPGS, FL 756. Paulette Baglyos Cleveland, OH 757. angela kohnke Tornesch, Germany 758. Margaret Rizzo Sydney, Australia 759. Gwen Walsh CHAGRIN FALLS, OH 760. Debrah McCabe Waterville, Canada 761. Robert Kirsch Willowick, OH 762. Elizabeth Paula Rio, Brazil 763. Cindi Greeson Newport, NC 764. ayako makishita sapporo, Japan 765. Helen Fielding By Taynuilt, United Just how bloody stupid and cruel can people get - I can only Kingdom think of them as arseholes 766. bettina Soworka Erfurt, Germany 767. Marie Lindwall Sydney, Australia

Page 28 - Signatures 738 - 767 Name From Comments 768. S Van wijnen spijkenisse, Netherlands 769. Patrick Flatt Clinton, TN 770. Kristin Lang Sistrans, Austria 771. Thomas Olson Elyria, OH 772. Julie Purdue Traralgon, Australia 773. Susan Holmes Newborough, United Kingdom 774. rahma sari pekanbaru, Indonesia 775. akrita kalra new delhi, India 776. Anne Miettinen Tampere, Finland 777. Herbert Staniek Vienna, Austria 778. Sergio Sarcina Cassano d' Adda - MI, Italy 779. Janet Clarke Burgess Hill, United Kingdom 780. yukari morita simanekenn, Japan 781. sevda cakir assen, Netherlands 782. paris karali zug, Switzerland 783. møller bagsværd, 784. Aline ARGILON Paris, France 785. Becky Kroeger YUMA, AZ 786. Wendy Schroeder DENVER, CO 787. Michelle Mason Penrose, CO 788. Mike Baldasio Niagara Falls, Canada 789. Jeanette Barwick Brigg, United Kingdom 790. p p vijayawada, India 791. Ann Ward Machynlleth, United Bloody morons STOP this vile treatment of dogs!!! Kingdom 792. Sabrina Kaltner München, Germany 793. mar vlan Athens, Greece 794. Emmanuel Paris, France Delannoy 795. cristian cejas villa maria, Argentina 796. Patricia Gehring Sheridan, WY 797. Kerstin Bräuer löbau, Germany 798. Razum Ivan Achau, Austria

Page 29 - Signatures 768 - 798 Name From Comments 799. Vincenza De Surbo ( Le ), Italy Filippis 800. Ralf Lenhard St. Ingbert, Germany 801. W. Clark LYNCHBURG, VA 802. Deanna LaBella Newark, DE 803. Kornelia Weber Warszawa, Poland 804. Sophie Zhang Richmond Hill, Canada 805. Peg Coogan Jacksonville, NY 806. Carol Price San Pedro, CA 807. Maria Laura Valladolid, Spain Miguel Peñas 808. Claudia Bogota, Colombia Hernandez 809. ioana ionita bacau, Romania 810. Elaine Allan Ardentinny, United Kingdom 811. Sylvia Gries Eppenbrunn, Germany 812. Suzanne Taylor Swindon, United Kingdom 813. ute ziegler heusweiler, Germany 814. petra meerwaldt hamburg, Germany 815. anke imme cuxhaven, Germany 816. Cleuza Pandolfi ARAÇATUBA, Brazil 817. Antje Rohde Nochern, Germany 818. Joann Trappe, PA Fontanarosa 819. cornelia heppner Bremerhaven, Germany 820. WENDY Douglas ABERDEEN, United Kingdom 821. Mariette Van veen , Netherlands 822. Ewa Kornatowska Nowa Iwiczna, Poland 823. Mehrafarin Emami Montreal, Canada Langroodi 824. Anita Erhard Götzis, Austria 825. sylvie lamotte sedan, France

Page 30 - Signatures 799 - 825 Name From Comments 826. jill small abertillery, United Kingdom 827. Lisbeth Hansson Trollhättan, Sweden Omg get help to this poor furebaby! 828. Anita Tsutsunen Espoo, Finland 829. esther wolthuis Almelo, Netherlands 830. Kerstin Walter Neuenstein, Germany 831. Diane Ward Woolston, United Kingdom 832. Kerstin Grübel Berlin, Germany 833. Rudolf Mühl Michelstadt, Germany 834. Marlis Bader Thun, Switzerland 835. Maxine Bakhtiar Dorset, United Kingdom 836. James Wolcott NEW ALBANY, IN 837. Karin Bukovac Freinsheim, Germany 838. Claudia Heindl Wien, Austria 839. Susan Henderson Glasgow, United Kingdom 840. Doris Koinig Mönichkirchen, Austria 841. Sena Toksoy Samsun, Turkey 842. Rachael Hilton Keaau, HI 843. Ruth Fichtner Salzburg, Austria Mag. Dr. 844. Rita Schlaefli Buchberg, Switzerland 845. Amanda Barnabas Congleton, United Kingdom 846. goldi muencz ramat hashofet, Israel 847. karin behle wermelskirchen, Germany 848. Olga Ros Celis L'Hospitalet de Llobregat, Spain 849. Christiane von Grossbottwar, Blücher Germany 850. Paulo Sisinno Rio De Janeiro, Brazil 851. vasilovici camelia rogolo, Italy 852. Richard barcelona, Spain Fernandez 853. Jill Studer Mooresville, IN

Page 31 - Signatures 826 - 853 Name From Comments 854. BARBARA penryn, United BUCKNALL Kingdom 855. hitotake hayashi takamatsu, Japan 856. Dimpy Gowda Bangalore, India 857. Virginia Golding Ysterplaat, Cape Town, South Africa 858. Sabine Berger Paris, France 859. Fiona Lau Stouffville, Canada 860. Everette Little Houston Harris County, TX 861. Gino Czaster Buffalo, NY 862. Marcia Wind Lake, WI Bringardner 863. Barbara DeFilippis Washington Crossing, PA 864. Jutta Braun berlin, Germany 865. Sylvia Baumann Leverkusen, Germany 866. Anita Andela Leiden, Netherlands 867. Márcia Paiva Viçosa-MG, Brazil 868. Maria Pires PENHA DE FRANÇA(LISBOA), Portugal 869. Bianca witt Neukirchen, Germany 870. Lynn Marlow San Jose, CA 871. Gisela Dülmen, Germany Maaß-Weber 872. shirley boyce meadow, UT 873. CRISTINA TANDIL, Argentina FERNANDEZ 874. Helene Lapointe Keremeos, Canada There is man's sickness and indifference even in one of the most beautiful place on the planet. 875. Sylviane Muller , France 876. Christin Margraten, Vertommen Netherlands 877. nuria silva sao paulo, Brazil 878. Diana Birch Cazorla, Spain 879. Sydney Kelston Calgary, Canada 880. Annnette filliat Metz, France 881. Kitami Hanada Settu, Japan 882. Nita Vegana Florence, Italy

Page 32 - Signatures 854 - 882 Name From Comments 883. Swapna Stafford, TX Mudigonda 884. Susanne Retzer Tuttlingen, Germany 885. Gaby Maul Bridel, Luxembourg 886. Janice Cowett PRESQUE ISLE, ME 887. Sabine Glasgow Ballymoney, United Kingdom 888. Teresa Servin Reseda, CA 889. Liat Zuckerman SAN FRANCISCO, CA 890. sergio morales cuernavaca, Mexico 891. Rosie Prantner München, Germany 892. Diana Kinder Shade, OH 893. Tiharu Nagatani Iwamisawasi, Japan 894. Tina Jordan Mililani, HI 895. lana gebahi lachine, Canada 896. Jaehee Shim Uijungbu, Korea, Republic Of 897. Marisol Lastres , Azerbaijan 898. Christian , Austria Wegenschimmel 899. Sylvie Béclard Cholet, France 900. Erik Hansen Århus, Denmark 901. Teresa Alvarez Rosario, Argentina 902. Harriet Brown COSTA MESA, CA 903. Deborah Barclay Stoneycreek, Canada 904. Ericka Adams Evansville, WI 905. Donna Crookwell, Australia Winterbottom 906. Chris Usami rexdale, Canada 907. Sam Chaudhri Manchester, United Kingdom 908. Andréa Branco São Paulo, Brazil 909. andreas , Germany piechnitzek 910. Debbie Gibson Lynchburg, VA 911. Jacqueline Waterloo, Canada Schmidt 912. Carole McRae Redwood City, CA

Page 33 - Signatures 883 - 912 Name From Comments 913. Yoshitaka Murata Long Beach, CA 914. Jacqueline Barden Alameda, CA 915. Michael Briand Chico, CA 916. Alex Armstrong Long Beach, CA 917. ljudmilla birjukova tapa, 918. Pia Laamanen Helsinki, Finland 919. 佐々木 清美 緑井4丁目32-10, Japan 920. Vadim Goberman Las Vegas, NV 921. Renate Ebrecht Mannheim, Germany 922. Mirna Acuna Los Angeles, CA This is so sad! I am outraged something must be done right away to help these poor babies! 923. Alissa Casias La Grange Park, IL 924. Jennifer Brown Valparaiso, IN 925. ellen dorfman Olympia, WA no chainging NONE and 3 foot that's insanity 926. NANCY Parks, AZ WALDROP 927. Sibylle Knor Aidlingen, Germany 928. Michael Herr Roedermark, Germany 929. Marleen Geudens Westerlo, Belgium 930. Alan Haas Cambridge, Canada 931. Anna Swanepoel Klerksdorp, South Those people are rubbish and a plague on this earth!! Africa 932. Charlotte Roelofs Weert, Netherlands 933. Michel ROUSSEL Paris, France 934. Wilma Lagrand zeeland, Netherlands 935. joyce alexander edinburgh, United Kingdom 936. Maria Sobieska Rotterdam, Netherlands 937. jonathan Milton keynes, United alexander Kingdom 938. Tracey Bass Orpington, United Kingdom 939. ken roach rocester, United Kingdom 940. dave nicoletti jannali, Australia 941. Angelika Scheidt , Germany 942. Terttu Kirjavainen Helsinki, Finland

Page 34 - Signatures 913 - 942 Name From Comments 943. Diane Dickinson Neptune City, NJ 944. josephine m,skala, Malta gallagher 945. ewa glapinska nowy targ, Poland 946. Astrid Laban Korschenbroich, Germany 947. nathalie hamard MONTPOTHIER, France 948. Jacqueline Cohn Myrtle Beach, SC 949. Daniela Nenz Lugano, Switzerland 950. astrid bogaerts houthulst, Belgium 951. Alice Hancock Christchurch, New Zealand 952. Karin Hersbruck, Germany Zimmermann 953. DAVID Keaau, HI STEVENSON 954. D BELLETTY SINGAPORE, Singapore 955. kiyomi nakahara nisinomiya, Japan 956. Berthe Barbet CARROLLTON, France 957. Frederique Crapa Esch sur alzette, Luxembourg 958. Renu Jagasia east Brunswick, India 959. eliana pasini vittorio veneto, Italy 960. Christiane Wagner Ludwigshafen, Germany 961. Jacqueline Peipert Brighton, IL 962. Maria Maiar San Marcos, CA 963. Andrea Zago Oderzo, Italy 964. 宇都宮明子 大阪市, Japan うつのみやあきこ 965. Shanta Ban Durgapur, India 966. Catherine Noyce Salisbury, United Kingdom 967. Michelle Walker Surrey, United Kingdom 968. Lesli Civille Sandy, UT 969. kim Jong sun Ttyy, Korea, Republic Of

Page 35 - Signatures 943 - 969 Name From Comments 970. Linda Neering Crdar Lake, IN 971. Brittney Krug Bismarck, ND 972. Petra Novakova Dolni Podluzi, Czech Republic 973. JOANNA mielec, Poland sledziona SLEDZIONA 974. Cyndi Young Encinitas, CA 975. Sandra Tucker CASA GRANDE, AZ 976. Michael Rice Concord, CA 977. Carlyn Montes De FOREST KNOLLS, Oca CA 978. Jo Kellabrew Spokane, WA 979. Diane Sparks Mansfield, TX 980. Jane Toop Christchurch, United Kingdom 981. Petra Kreuzer Mühldorf, Germany 982. arthittayarasami nonthaburi, Thailand vacharasathira 984. Jan Giekens Weert, Netherlands 985. hyvn atilla demir muğla, Turkey 986. Rosemary Keaau, HI Karlsson 987. Lenka Rihova Prague, Czech Republic 988. metka zoya obrul Slovenske Konjice, Slovenia 989. ana maria de lisboa, Portugal sebastiao 990. Scott Rondeau Wauwatosa, WI 991. andrea rotterdam, maertzdorff Netherlands 992. chris hamilton farmington, NH 993. Ferry Mes Vlissingen, Netherlands 994. Brent Morrissey QUEEN CREEK, AZ 995. Diane Langejnas Irvine, CA Get dogs off 3 foot logging chains in Hawaii. 996. mehlika öztan antalya, Turkey 997. Els Bol Zoetermeer, Netherlands

Page 36 - Signatures 970 - 997 Name From Comments 998. ines johansson Morjãrv, Sweden 999. Dennis Dougherty San Rafael Marin County, CA 1,000. Michelle Bechtol Sonoma, CA 1,001. roos hermes hoensbroek, Netherlands 1,002. Heather Woolley Antrim, United Cruelty is not clever,it is not funny for the poor Animal who is Kingdom on the other end of the chain...Shameful.. 1,003. Marina Markova , Russian Federation 1,004. Stephanie Casias Chicago, IL 1,005. Meggi Stürmer Elsenfeld, Germany 1,006. Patricia Marenco Brooklyn, NY 1,007. susanna thessaloniki, Greece minacheili 1,008. Liana Buttles Kentfield, CA 1,009. Patrizia Moosseedorf, Alessandrini Switzerland 1,010. Gail loofbourrow KAILUA KONA, HI 1,011. Julie Ellis Westbury, United Kingdom 1,012. Ellen Prior MILL CREEK, WA 1,013. hidemi shim 大阪, Japan 1,014. Irene Bendhiba Köln, Germany 1,015. myra seddon rochdale, United Kingdom 1,016. Irene Huber Arnold, MO 1,017. Debra Del Santo Johnston, RI 1,018. Mehreme Benicia, CA Muhametaj 1,019. Lynda Evans Merthyr Tydfil, United Kingdom 1,020. Jay L Marvin Pahoa, HI Please stop this abuse 1,021. Laurie driver Reykavik, Iceland 1,022. Ann Cawley St.Joseph, MO 1,023. Iveta Kubovicova Povazska Bystrica, Slovakia 1,024. Frances Darcy Sligo, Ireland 1,025. M. B. Fjellheim Storslett, Norway

Page 37 - Signatures 998 - 1,025 Name From Comments 1,026. Janie Dent Ipswich, United Kingdom 1,027. letizia balsamo perinaldo, Italy 1,028. JENS Hansen Bellingham, WA 1,029. Marcia Tressoldi São Paulo, Brazil 1,030. Catherine Till Rockhampton, Australia 1,031. Annlouise Sundsbruk, Sweden Stop this killing now devil bastards, karma coms to all this Andersson People werry soon.!!! 1,032. susan sander clearwater, FL HAWAII THIS IS ALOHA, REALLY, I LIVED THERE, WHAT THE HECK, THIS IS SICK, GET LAWS TO PROTECT ALL DOMESTIC, AND FARM ANIMALS NOW!!! 1,033. Judy Rees Glenalta, Australia 1,034. Lois Haynes Jacksonville, FL No animal deserves to be treated like this. They are given to us from God to love and take care of. Please stop this cruelty. 1,035. Jutta Klar Hellenthal, Germany 1,036. mir otten KERKRADE, Netherlands 1,037. Janice Buckley Manchester, United Kingdom 1,038. Karen Thomas Garland, TX 1,039. Tracy Wahl Maple Ridge, Canada 1,040. Kimberly Shannon Westville, IL 1,041. Betty Barker Glade Spring, VA 1,042. Marilyn Flynn Cutchogue, NY 1,043. Joe Young CINCINNATI, OH 1,044. steve kent Hamilton, OH 1,045. Tracey Dengate Parkes, Australia 1,046. Chansamone Oldsmar, FL Phouangpheachanh 1,047. Irina Derkunsky Kovdor, Russian Federation 1,048. Brenda Morris EVESBORO, NJ 1,049. Alana Bacon Melbourne, Australia 1,050. Sharon Ferrell Houston, TX 1,051. Bill Westerman Tewantin, Australia 1,052. Michelle Keller Gilbert, AZ 1,053. Analisa Luedtke Houston, TX

Page 38 - Signatures 1,026 - 1,053 Name From Comments 1,054. Gail Stern Tarpon Springs, FL 1,055. Alison Hope Kent, United Kingdom 1,056. Golida Klein The Hague, Netherlands 1,057. Jo Hearnden Brighton, Australia 1,058. Ingrid Hahn Oberhaching, Germany 1,059. Tina Forster Wien, Austria 1,060. Rose Kerr Felton, CA This is very cruel and wrong 1,061. Marta Szweda Kozakowice Gã£â£ã¢â£ã£â¢ã¢, Poland 1,062. Ekaterina Glebova Moscow, Russian Federation 1,063. M S Helsinki, Finland 1,064. joshua Hernandez Wahiawa, HI 1,065. Christina Kovacs Wolfurt, Austria 1,066. Dalibor Gajda Ostrava, Czech Republic 1,067. Inge Stadler Hilpoltstein, Germany 1,068. lisa jones stevenage, United Kingdom 1,069. Lydia zink Hannover, Germany 1,070. Kapu Ford Honolulu, HI There need to be stiff laws in Hawaii there needs to be MAJOR FINES against owners that treat their pet like it doesn't matter that's bullshit that's animal cruelty and jail sentence as well. I am here in the mainland trying to get my puppy home and what Hawaii expect from our babies that coming from the mainland our babies are well taken care of those babies in Hawaii are not taking care of or even treated the way they should be taken care of. Hawaii I needs to get penalties for falsely charging all these charges for us to be our babies back home. There rules are bullshit 1,071. Moira Kilmarnock, United Ban this all over the world. McCorrmack Kingdom McMenamin 1,072. Anita Maxwell Alexander, AR 1,073. Ольга Чичерова Волгоград 400066, Russian Federation 1,074. Janet Behrendt Lindau, Germany 1,075. Tina Eisel Ludwigshafen, Germany

Page 39 - Signatures 1,054 - 1,075 Name From Comments 1,076. Francisca Zurich, Switzerland Brechbuehler 1,077. Brigitte Sponagel Bretten, Germany 1,078. Verena Enger, Germany Dutschmann 1,079. Melanie Chrobok Mönchengladbach, Germany 1,080. Tanja Hopf , Germany 1,081. frank rump 55555, Germany 1,082. Nathalie Bogaert Antwerpen, Belgium 1,083. petra egging Arnhem, Netherlands 1,084. Erika Rabe Erfurt, Germany 1,085. Jennifer Ölke Hamburg, Germany 1,086. Sandra Engel , Germany 1,087. Julia Frijns Schwabach, Germany 1,088. Angy Voina Siegen, Germany 1,089. Annik Zeller Baden, Switzerland 1,090. Darren clark Hailsham, United Kingdom 1,091. Renée Condé Rhyl, United Kingdom 1,092. Tini van Zetten lienden, Netherlands 1,093. michele tritscher strasbourg, France 1,094. Michael Langdon London, United Kingdom 1,096. Dagmar Grabsch Berlin, Germany 1,097. carolina shimba Taboão da Serra, Brazil 1,098. Claudia Neuhalfen Bonn, Germany 1,099. C U Romania, Romania 1,100. irene schweizer frenkendorf, Switzerland 1,101. Оксана Спивак Moscow, Russian Federation 1,102. Dr. Angela Raab bad Breisig, Germany 1,103. Jalal Lakhnati , Germany 1,104. Cynthia Franke Kassel, Germany 1,105. Merja Heinonen Turku, Finland 1,106. Alexandra Dr.Tr.Severin, Tomescu Romania

Page 40 - Signatures 1,076 - 1,106 Name From Comments 1,107. Hagen Simon Oberstaufen, Germany 1,108. Tamara Althoff Monguzzo, Italy 1,109. Suzan Toma Sittard, Netherlands 1,110. Rita Wolff Hannover, Germany 1,111. Kathleen Worcester Park, O'Halloran Surrey, United Kingdom 1,112. jim sack fort wayne, IN 1,113. Shirley Layfield Leasowe, United Kingdom 1,115. Barbara Ferrucci LITTLE EGG Young HARBOR, NJ 1,116. jane emad hurghada, Egypt 1,117. Irene kleiner hätzingen, Switzerland 1,118. Franco Finazzi Milano, Italy 1,119. Merete Lykke Odense, Denmark Hansen 1,120. Marina Trofin COTTLEVILLE, MO 1,121. Bonnie Daut COVINGTON, WA 1,122. Nicole DuFrene THOUSAND OAKS, CA 1,123. Stacey Massey None, VA Culture or not it is wrong to abuse another living creature for your own benefit. Dogs are such loyal creatures and deserve love and companionship. 1,124. fred dale london, United Kingdom 1,125. Sheila Montoya El Prado, NM 1,126. Kristina Sedic Zagreb, Croatia 1,127. Sherri Lynn Maricopa, AZ Bingham 1,128. Heike Multani Glauchau, Germany 1,129. Janne Detlefsen Roskilde, Denmark 1,130. Rita Pirrotte Bridel, Luxembourg 1,131. Danielle Port Coquitlam, Moorhouse Canada 1,132. Carol Croston SUTTON, United Kingdom 1,133. Lise Vandal Alma, Canada 1,134. Beatrix Saenftl , Germany

Page 41 - Signatures 1,107 - 1,134 Name From Comments 1,135. Beate Vossen Remscheid, Germany 1,136. Coralyn Bowd Bexhill on sea, United Kingdom 1,137. wend6 beerens weelde, Belgium 1,138. Dina ManyIssues NEWINGTON, NH Chain their owners and leave them chained Smith 1,139. Lisa Lewis GARNER, NC 1,140. NANCY Lane Woodburn, OR 1,141. Karen Kornbau PAHOA, HI 1,142. Marco Reinelt Mülheim an der Ruhr, Germany 1,143. Sonja Kufner München, Germany 1,144. Lara Ruffinatto Pinerolo, Italy 1,145. Julie Price Cwmtillery/Abertillery, It's time animals were treated with respect United Kingdom 1,146. Jo Eisenrich Stephenville, TX WTH?? 1,147. Manuela Zeiler Wien, Austria 1,148. Anna Hernandez Fountain Valley, CA 1,149. George Martin Viskovo, Croatia 1,150. Diana Hedgers ANDERSON, IN 1,151. Claudia Hofer 1040, Austria 1,152. Michelle Austin Athina, Greece 1,153. Michelle Weirich Glen mills, PA Cruel !! 1,154. Wendy Detky Warminster, PA 1,155. Ceire Carmichael Derry, United Kingdom 1,156. Michele Mooresville, NC Symington 1,157. Vincenzo Caserta, Italy Caporale 1,159. Bonita Cheek Portland, OR 1,160. Ludmila vorobieff sao paulo, Brazil 1,161. Hans-Günther Bettendorf, Germany Schranz 1,162. Andrea Abel Aschaffenburg, Germany 1,163. yvonne piatocka vanderhoof, Canada So Cruel.... 1,164. Margot loesch Düdelingen, reinertz Luxembourg 1,165. Amanda Caulkett My. Morris, MI

Page 42 - Signatures 1,135 - 1,165 Name From Comments 1,166. Jenny Yavuu Michelstadt, Germany 1,167. Reinhold Pecher Gerstetten, Germany 1,168. Kim Defreese Laguna Hills, CA 1,169. Christa Lohrig Korschenbroich, Germany 1,170. Ellen Alexander GREENWOOD VILLAGE, CO 1,171. Merethe Rehbehn Vojens, Denmark 1,172. Iris Reinhard Friesenheim, Germany 1,173. susan biggs col city, IN FEED them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 1,174. Jennifer Lovendegem, Belgium D'herckets 1,175. Beth Larson Tempe, AZ 1,176. Martha B Torres Estado de México, Mexico 1,177. COMANESCU Ttier, Germany CAROLINA 1,178. Stephanie Toronto, Canada Faustino 1,179. Anna Stein , Germany 1,180. Maureen Dalley Clacton On Sea, United Kingdom 1,181. Renata Rebetez Mexico, Mexico 1,182. MARIA MANUEL MEM MARTINS, AFONSO Portugal 1,183. LUIZ FERNANDO TORRES RS, Brazil ACHE GARCEZ 1,184. daniela plüschau wedel, Germany 1,185. julie hanlon ny, NY Cruelty must be banned. There is no arguing visible suffering in man or animal. It must be stopped, write the laws that demand change. 1,186. fatima menarelo americana, Brazil 1,187. Mariann Adcock Antioch, TN 1,188. tereza cristina santa barbara do vieira da silva oeste, Brazil 1,189. maureen middlesbrough, benjelloun United Kingdom 1,190. Martine Curtis Staffordshire, United Kingdom

Page 43 - Signatures 1,166 - 1,190 Name From Comments 1,191. selma castanheira rio de janeiro, Brazil santos 1,192. Anthony Lee SAN RAMON, CA HAWAII IS A LOSER 1,193. Yvonne Trumpf Schaafheim, Germany 1,194. eleusa fornazari curitiba, Brazil 1,195. Dinitha Fernando Wien, Austria 1,196. Elli Diemer Otzweiler, Germany 1,197. Phyllis Kaelin Jeffersonville, IN 1,198. Siendrra Mehmeti Tetovo, Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic Of 1,199. Keith Michelen San Pedro Sula, Honduras 1,200. Andrea Weyer Laaber, Germany 1,201. Elena Barybina Valencia, Spain 1,202. mirjam white TONASKET, WA 1,203. Ursula Esperanza Mérida, Mexico Gómez Isaac 1,204. Danielle Realan Rio Grande, Brazil Alves 1,205. Eliette Bozzola Muël, France 1,206. Marilda Ferreira Miami, FL 1,207. Evelyne Mabillard Meyrin, Switzerland 1,208. Patti Gouker Albuquerque, NM 1,209. Zoe Rolt Crawley, United Kingdom 1,210. Marie Dalerstedt Skepplanda, Sweden 1,211. federica bracciotti lucca, Italy 1,212. Melissa Holt GARLAND, TX 1,213. Pauline James Kuching, 1,214. Christina Webster Middlesbrough, United Kingdom 1,215. diane lockett hidden valley lake, CA Planning to go to Hawaii, not now. I won't go for a vacation to a state that thinks it's OK to treat animals like this. 1,216. Linda Mcloughlin London, United Kingdom 1,217. allison fitzpatrick Cambuslang, United Kingdom 1,218. E Zuniga SANTA MONICA, CA 1,219. Ellie Colu Toronto, Canada

Page 44 - Signatures 1,191 - 1,219 Name From Comments 1,220. Danny Chan Montreal, Canada 1,221. lizzy jacobs kessel, Belgium 1,222. marlena mollet del valles, Comi la gente normal puede ser tan cruel massalska Spain massalska 1,223. susan parrish las vegas, NV 1,224. Erica Wheeler Butte Valley, CA 1,225. Angelika Recla Erfurt, Germany 1,226. Jaromir Borysek Uhersky Brod, Czech Republic 1,227. Joy Edwards Bowie, MD 1,228. Lenore Kudaka Thunder Bay, Canada 1,229. Cinzia Amiconi Cave Creek, AZ 1,230. Dobrovolskay Kiev, Ukraine Lyudmila 1,231. Kim Casella Folcroft, PA 1,232. Janet Coleman Apple Valley San Bernardino County, CA 1,233. Diane Austin Simi Valley, CA 1,234. Tracey Anzalone Clearwater, FL 1,235. Priscilla Rodriguez VALENCIA, CA 1,236. Caro Monaghan Queeton, Australia 1,237. tomas toth oulton, United Kingdom 1,238. Sabrina Guyll Los Angeles, CA 1,239. Pamela Ace Appleton, WI 1,240. Christine Lockhart Porter, TX 1,241. Rachel Collins Princeton, WV 1,242. Ana Araque Fuengirola, Spain 1,243. Jackie Marsh Wildwood, FL This is HEARTBREAKING to hear how HAWAII TREATS CANINE FAMILY COMPANIONS' WHO HAVE BEEN SCIENTIFICALLY PROVEN TO HAVE EMOTIONS & FEELINGS!!!!!! THIS IS UTTER ABUSE IT'S TOURCHER!!! CLEARLY THE PICTURE OF THIS POOR INNOCENT STARVED NEGLECTED PUP PHOTOGRAPHED ON THIS ATROCIOUS CHAIN IS EMACIATED, HAS NO RESPECT AS A LIVING SOUL! ISOLATED FROM THE LOVE & CARE IT SO DESPERATLY NEEDS & DESERVES!!! THIS IS EXTREMLY DISTURBING!!! (continues on next page)

Page 45 - Signatures 1,220 - 1,243 Name From Comments 1,243. Jackie Marsh Wildwood, FL (continued from previous page) I HAD NO IDEA HAWAII WAS NOT A CULTERED SOCIETY NOR DID I KNOW THIS TREATMENT OF INNOCENT LIFE IS PRACTICED! I PLEED ON BEHALF OF THESE INELEGANT LOVING LOYAL CANINES WHO HAVE NO VOICE' WHO ARE MAN'S BEST FRIEND, WHO VISIT CHILDREN'S CANCER WARDS TO BRING A SMILE & HOPE TO A CHILD WHO MAY BE DYING' AS WELL AS ASSIST IN GOVERNMENT AGENCIES & POLICE SERVING THEIR COUNTRY HERE IN AMERICA AS WELL AS SERVICES OF MILITARY' SNIFFING OUT BOMBS, AIDING IN MAJOR DRUG BUSTS, AID FOR THE BLIND' HELP IN LOCATING MISSING & EXPLOITED CHILDREN ADD WELL AS CRIMINALS, THEY ARE MOVIE & TV CELEBRITIES JUST TO NAME A FEW! THEY ARE OUR AMERICAN HERO'S! HAWAII EDUCATE THEMSELVES TO STEP UP WITH THE TIMES OF NO TOLERANCE OVER IGNORANCE 1,244. Mishika Cleveland, TN Rosewood 1,245. Cara Didion Toledo, OH 1,246. Annemarie colo vale, Australia Hasemann 1,247. Gianna Macias Mexico City, Mexico 1,248. Spencer Sullivan COLUMBUS, OH 1,249. Ana Lucia Wagner Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Teles 1,250. Karen Presson Baltimore, MD What a cruel way to have to live. 1,251. Glor Gal San Antonio, TX 1,252. Gordon Leslie Kona, HI 1,253. Duane Marston Edmonton, Canada 1,254. Duane Marston Edmonton, Canada 1,255. Gary Klose Pittsburgh, PA 1,256. Britt-Inger Öst Skarpnäck, Sweden 1,257. cristina carloni riva del garda, Italy 1,258. Karl-Heinz Pfeiler Lünen, Germany 1,259. Patricia McCaskill SEBASTOPOL, CA 1,260. Julie Braun New , MI 1,261. Kelly LaCombe Seattle, WA 1,262. Silke Linden Melbourne, Australia 1,263. Teresa Cefai Kappara, Malta 1,264. Lina SEREIKIENE Vilnius, Lithuania

Page 46 - Signatures 1,243 - 1,264 Name From Comments 1,265. Diana Albrecht linkenheim, Germany Ich bin für ein Verbot, ein Hund gehört zur Familie ins Haus und nicht an die kette! 1,266. Suzan Egan Melbourne, Australia 1,267. Merit Tabak Carlton, Australia 1,268. jane key telford, United Kingdom 1,269. Carl Hoffmeister Casselberry, FL 1,270. Sonia Szewczuk cairns, Australia 1,271. Laura Ramirez Benicia, CA 1,272. Izabela Jedlicze, Poland Bogusławska 1,273. Sofia Madjitov Karmiel, Israel 1,274. paola mapelli Inzago, Italy 1,275. Christine Bisdorff Ehnen, Luxembourg 1,276. lilit margaryan yerevan, Armenia 1,277. Wendy Forster Gateshead, United Kingdom 1,278. dana dogru galati, Romania 1,279. Trish Johnstone Petrie, Australia 1,280. brenda Ritchie kitchener, Canada 1,281. Elenia Kelly Herzliya, Israel 1,282. enrico miolli settimo, Italy 1,283. Tina Parry Sudbury, United Kingdom 1,284. Carmen Yalcin Friedland, Germany 1,285. annie fernandez marcillac, France 1,286. Adela Dvorska Borovnicka, Czech Republic 1,287. zenaide silveira Blumenau sc, Brazil 1,288. Inge Diverio Stresa, Italy 1,289. Marcia Helena BARRETOS, Brazil Lopes 1,290. Deborah Southend on sea, Zarb-Cousin United Kingdom 1,291. Christine Moerfelden-Walldorf, Said-Günther Germany 1,292. Debra Connolly TOMS RIVER, NJ 1,293. Carmen Restrepo Bogotá, Colombia 1,294. Marija Tomovic Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 47 - Signatures 1,265 - 1,294 Name From Comments 1,296. Nathalie St Louis bourgfelden, Kusnierek France 1,297. Danielle Snyder Santa Rosa Beach, FL 1,298. Jane Smith Yeovil, United Kingdom 1,299. shanna lord port st lucie, FL 1,300. leigh thorn exeter, United Kingdom 1,301. Susan Russell Doncaster, United Kingdom 1,302. Nerudo Chigubu RICHARDSON, TX 1,303. Michelle Stone Cuyahoga Falls, OH 1,304. Corinna Mochwitz Averlak, Germany 1,305. ozaki mahiro oosakashi, Japan 1,306. Sally milne Salisbury, United Kingdom 1,307. Justa Kruger Pretoria, South Africa 1,308. sylvie HEBERT lyon, France 1,309. Ann Childs Burton on trent, United This chaining of dogs is outrageous. Why have a dog to Kingdom chain them up. Bloody ignorant imbeciles. They are supposed to be family. Treat them as such.cruel bastards. 1,310. Barbara Sedici Arezzo, Italy 1,311. Brenda Arnold Conroe, TX 1,312. Caroline Grieve Surrey, Canada 1,313. mizara la oren, Russian Federation 1,314. Ximena Suarez Gardena, CA Lopez 1,315. Sari Alie Jakarta, Indonesia 1,316. Ellen Davis Kelso, WA STOP CHAINING DOGS 24/7 TO TREES; TIRES; THESE ARE PETS AND COMPANIONS. THEY DESERVE TO COME INSIDE YOUR HOME. DOGS ARE NOT LAWN ORNAMENTS!!!! SHOW THEM SOME LOVE AND KINDNESS!!! 1,317. Telma Apparecid Batatais (SP), Brazil Donzelli 1,318. 東名 眞須美 市原市五井東, Japan 1,319. Shirley Griffiths OLDHAM, United Kingdom

Page 48 - Signatures 1,296 - 1,319 Name From Comments 1,320. Sachiko Usami Imabari, Japan 宇佐見佐知子 1,321. dayle peters Sacramento, CA 1,322. Lorraine Seneca, SC Fitzpatrick 1,323. Robert Franz Oberhausen, Austria Kasberger 1,324. jacqueline Verviers, Belgium christophe 1,325. Laura Ronchi Monza, Italy 1,326. Adrika Thaliadan Gulbarga, India 1,327. Nancy Hurst North Baltimore, OH 1,328. Mariah Ancona Kailua kona, HI 3 ft is animal cruelty should be least 100 ft rigaud 1,329. Tania Leslie Kealakekua, HI Read the petition first - this is not my culture!! Please sign and share! 1,330. Eva-Maria Haak Salzgitter, Germany 1,331. Heather Lang Lompoc, CA 1,332. Marga Star Zuidlaren, Get Dogs Off 3 foot Logging Chains in Hawaii. Netherlands 1,333. Megan Gelman Kailua Kona, HI 1,334. neofitos landis athens, Greece 1,335. Tereza Cristina São Paulo, Brazil Marins 1,336. Janina Grage Herne, Germany 1,337. Kahea Weza Kailua kona, HI 1,338. Erica Rose Coventry, United Kingdom 1,339. siv osterback greaker, Norway 1,340. Marianne Ocean view, HI Cagampang 1,341. Chen Boon Fook SELANGOR, Malaysia 1,342. Tracy McPherson Jacumba, CA 1,343. Nia Loots Newcastle Emlyn, United Kingdom 1,344. Jacqueline Peter Schachen, Switzerland 1,345. Sonja fiolka falkensee, Germany Weil ich die Petition unterstütze 1,346. Maria manuela cascais, Portugal lopes

Page 49 - Signatures 1,320 - 1,346 Name From Comments 1,347. Roland Honicke Victoria, Canada 1,349. Sarah Mischke Chicago, IL What kind od sick bastard would put a dog or any animal on a heavy chain. They are the ones who need a heavy chain locked around their neck a dumped in a landfill or sewer. 1,350. Adriana Guevara Bogota, Colombia 1,351. Delma Kay Captain Cook, HI 1,352. Donetta Bishop Shepherdsville, KY 1,353. Silja Alter Weßling, Germany 1,354. Stefan Bunk München, Germany 1,355. Christina Guaro, Spain Håkanson 1,356. Vesna Cajnko Ljubljana, Slovenia 1,357. Gabriela Dragoi Hunedoara, Romania 1,358. Anna Luhlmann Ingolstadt, Germany 1,359. Jenny Fortsch Prescott, AZ 1,360. Tisha Bredeson Captain cook, HI 1,361. markus kohler tüßling, Germany 1,362. Karin Guenther Cuxhaven, Germany 1,363. Maryse devos la Louvière, Belgium 1,364. Ana Novak Ljubljana, Slovenia Keep the humans on the chains so they will see how this feels. Only a monster how did this should feel this, nobody else. 1,365. Paula Warner Lakewood, CA 1,366. ashlea ryan bradford, United Kingdom 1,367. Elizabeth Fryer Mt. view, HI Life in solitary confinement 1,368. Judith Flanders Kamuela, HI 1,369. Montse Prieto leon, Spain 1,370. Ter Anderson Fernie, Canada 1,371. Amandine Paris, France Piedvache 1,372. Jefferson Finney Kamuela, HI 1,373. Anaite Briz Guatemala, Guatemala 1,374. Deb Pomfret Manchester, United Kingdom 1,375. Anika Huebner Hamburg, Germany 1,377. Dianita Canizalez El Cajon, CA 1,378. Judy Haas Chatham, VA

Page 50 - Signatures 1,347 - 1,378 Name From Comments 1,379. Linda Hutchison Vancouver, WA Destroy the chains! Or replace the dogs with the owners to the end of the chain!!! 1,380. Jennifer Peterson Herndon, VA 1,381. Kajah Kennedy Hattie's, MS 1,382. Lisa Schneider White lake, MI This is cruel to an innocent being to be tied out like this on a gawd-awful heavy chain. That pup wonders what it did to be treated so cruelly. What is wrong with humans; so defective in their brains! I would like to hang that person who does this out on a chain! You get no pet, ever!!! 1,383. Laurie Monceaux Bueche, LA This is cruel and unjust and just shouldn't be done.. TREAT PETS THE WAY THAT YOU YOURSELF WOULD LIKE TO BE TREATED.. let's put this chain on you how would you like it??? 1,384. Lelia Cosimbescu Richland, WA 1,385. Robyn Oamaru, New Edmondston Zealand 1,386. Meagan Pulia Kealakekua, HI 1,387. Sally Ramirez Hagerstown, MD 1,388. Siobhan Radway Capt cook, HI 1,389. Gena Sparagno Fife, WA How do you watch something suffer everyday and not do anything to help? 1,390. Toni Tanner Mesquite, NV 1,391. Carey Demapan Hilo, HI 1,392. Justine Rock elizabeth vale, Australia 1,393. paula martins bremen, Germany 1,394. Leslie Heard Kailua Kona, HI 1,395. James San Diego, CA Bustamante 1,396. Willem Kom hoogezand, Netherlands 1,397. Ana Naumovska Skopje, Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic Of 1,398. Jackie Short Chelmsford, United Kingdom 1,399. Frank Ehmke Schachen, Switzerland 1,400. Tanja Paganal Zürich, Switzerland 1,401. ADELE Urbanek mödling, Austria 1,402. Екатерина Лесной городок, Шмелева Russian Federation

Page 51 - Signatures 1,379 - 1,402 Name From Comments 1,403. Tom Rooze Borken, Germany 1,404. Chelsea Wallace Komoka, Canada 1,405. Deborah Ramos San Diego, CA Please do something about this terrible problem now! 1,406. Bev Adamson Stockton, NJ 1,407. tatjana helman zagreb, Croatia 1,408. Daniela Bress Niedersachsen, Germany 1,409. Marisol Ackerman Mitchell, NE 1,410. Roselyn Perdomo New York, NY 1,411. Linda Percival Walton on thames, United Kingdom 1,412. Asia Morris Kealakekua, HI 1,413. Bärbel Paulsen Heide, Germany 1,414. Patricia WOOD Malaga, Spain 1,415. Billie Dennis Anthony, NM 1,416. Laura Marlow Anaheim, CA Animals suffer and have rights ! 1,417. marianne Melbourne, Australia salvatore 1,418. Janice Paul Surrey, Canada 1,419. Peggy Mann Aberdeen, SD 1,420. maria carranza Guatemala, They deserve a better life, loving owners, not being chained Guatemala for life and they look really skinny aswell 1,421. Kassia Pencek Lancaster, PA 1,422. Susan Knutsen Stillwater, NJ 1,423. Christina Schoon Midland, TX No animal should be chained. 1,424. Christine Strickling Portland, MI 1,425. Nicole O'Neil Fort Ann, NY Dogs love us more than we love ourselves. They never deserve anything like this. Would you do this to a child? 1,426. Diana S Tucson, AZ 1,427. Jen Thomas NYC, NY 1,428. Nichole Watts Denver, CO 1,429. Claudine-Sylvie Paris, France Cassagne 1,430. Domenique Egg harbor city, NJ This is mans best friend and they deserve better!! This Marazzi antiquated way of keeping animals is an atrocity to a beautiful island! 1,431. Valery Burks Shreveport, LA 1,432. Rosemarie Nürnberg, Germany Stockenreiter

Page 52 - Signatures 1,403 - 1,432 Name From Comments 1,433. Barbara Byerly Ruckersville, VA This is inhumane and barbaric. 1,434. Lisa J Ashworth Fort myers, FL HELP ALL ANIMALS 1,435. Gloria Cameron New Castle, PA 1,436. Sunny Saunders Knoxville, TN 1,437. Kerry Kuraya Kapolei, HI I live in Hawaii and I'm ashamed to say the Aloha spirit and caring mentality does not always extend to the 4 legged and helpless. 1,438. Anja Knies Meckenbeuren, Germany 1,439. Jeannine Kühn bm, Germany 1,440. Mercedes Dotter Philadelphia, PA 1,441. Karola Windweh Hainburg, Germany 1,442. sylvie rovea , France 1,443. Marion Schorr Kelmis, Belgium 1,444. Rosemary Perth, Australia Disgusting treatment of innocent animals Hugharts 1,445. James Macks FAYETTEVILLE, NC 1,446. Terry Henderson Albuquerque, NM 1,447. christine MÄNTSÄLÄ, Finland KETTUNEN 1,448. Barbara Gantt Phoenix, AZ This is so mean and cruel that it is still allowed, This needs to stop. 1,449. Tawnja Ching Mountain View, HI 1,450. Sandra Heilberger Nürnberg, Germany 1,451. Sarah Tyndall Huddersfield, United Kingdom 1,452. Maria Socorro LOS ANGELES, CA 1,453. Curt Afdahl Metamora, IL How disgusting my fellow two-leggers are. If only...If ONLY the world were a better place. 1,454. MARINA Murphy BARROW IN FURNESS, United Kingdom 1,455. Noelle Ostman Auburn, WA 1,456. Kristianne Stone Victoria, Canada 1,457. Julie Acs-Ray Brownstown, MI 1,458. Janice Murdoch Keaau, HI Dogs on chains/teether/runners its all wrong!! 1,459. CHERI KALENA HAIKU, HI 1,460. Debi Bradley Kailua-Kona, HI 1,461. Jeny Schonberg Madrid, Spain 1,462. S Emery Hilo, HI

Page 53 - Signatures 1,433 - 1,462 Name From Comments 1,463. Malia Bohol Hilo, HI 1,464. Nathan Degner CHICAGO, IL 1,465. Misa Cajnko Ljubljana, Slovenia 1,466. Heidi Shuff Kailua-Kona, HI 1,467. Barbara Breskin Hove, HI 1,468. Lausch Günter Wien, Austria 1,469. Melanie Gunn Alford, United Kingdom 1,470. Nicole Salzburg, Austria Schellenberg 1,471. Julie Martin FREDERIC, WI Please get dogs off 3 foot logging chains in Hawaii!! 1,472. Loan Ngo Vancouver, Canada 1,473. Kim Ek Hilo, HI 1,474. Adelheid Pokorny Idar-Oberstein, Germany 1,475. Nicola Banks Skelmersdale, United Kingdom 1,476. sandra lane Keaau, HI Everyday I see this as I drive in my neighborhood. It breaks my heart. It is like chaining a toddler. Do the right thing-Stop this horrible abuse. Educate, legislate, and enforce. 1,477. Brigitte Coloos Dunkerque, France 1,478. RAFFAELLA S. Lazzaro di Savena GUZZETTI BO, Italy 1,479. Johanah Merritt Manitou Springs, CO 1,480. SHARI OLANDER Pahoa, HI Allowed?! It should be a crime. 1,481. Alexa Hilaire Wakefield, United Kingdom 1,482. Isabelle LA FORET, FERNANDES France 1,483. etancelin les andelys, France 1,484. Julia Schebach Hornstein, Austria 1,485. maren exem basel, Switzerland 1,486. Rebecca Martello GRANTS PASS, OR 1,487. Andrea Edahl Olpe, Germany 1,488. Sabine G. Euskirchen, Germany 1,489. Sylvia Sawetzki Konstanz, Germany 1,490. Franny Kinslow Mt View, HI 1,492. Iveta Remecká Heřmanův Městec, Czech Republic 1,493. Kalliope M. Nirwana, Germany

Page 54 - Signatures 1,463 - 1,493 Name From Comments 1,494. G. Petersen Saskatoon, Canada 1,495. Shasta Fox Keaau, HI 1,496. Duncan Scott Concord, CA 1,497. Leslie Bennett waikoloa, HI Save our dogs and animals 1,498. Cindy Scroggins Jacksonville, AR Please stop this inhuman practice of chaining dogs. Its been proven to have negative effects in temperament. Its just very cruel and sad. 1,499. Monika Romaniak Kraków, Poland 1,500. christel person aix, France 1,501. Desiree Berrigan Mt. View, HI 1,502. N o GRAND PRAIRIE, TX 1,503. Martha Amundsen Kailua-Kona, HI 1,504. Lisa Olivarez Captain Cook, HI 1,505. Karin Riedel Keaau, HI 1,506. Shelly Gumm Pahoa, HI 1,507. kim wilson rockglen, Canada The cruelty on this planet simply needs to STOP 1,508. Terry Wallerstedt St. Joseph, MO 1,509. Jess Ban Edmonton, Canada 1,510. trudie yoshino tokyo, Japan 1,511. Eva Wertheimer Danville, CA 1,512. Vera Böblingen, Germany Kebsch-Müller 1,513. Larry Saltzman Naarehu, HI Animal cruelty is wide spread on his island and it needs to be stopped. 1,514. kathryn chambers kearns, UT 1,515. Anna Rossini Pisa, Italy 1,516. J. Olafsson Winnipeh, Canada 1,517. Bettina KAT bad wildungen, Germany 1,518. Cheryl Eiduke Chardon, OH 1,519. nancy inman geneva, OH 1,520. Gerri Woodall Columbus, OH 1,521. Cindy Deighton Willowick, OH 1,522. linda detels SAN FRANCISCO, CA 1,523. Ingrid Reich Eriskirch, Germany 1,524. Sherri Conroe, TX Cunningham 1,525. Charity Mission Woodland Hills, CA

Page 55 - Signatures 1,494 - 1,525 Name From Comments 1,526. Lisa Salazar SHASTA LAKE, CA 1,527. Jennifer Whilt La canada, CA 1,528. Cathy Goeggel Honolulu, HI 1,529. Debra Watson Wake Forest, NC Owners need to be left on a 3 foot chain. 1,530. Mary Young Glendale, CA No living creature should be tied or attached so inhumanely by chains or other bindings that prevents them from mobility and the escape in the event of imminent or perceived danger to their well-being. To do so without regard is intentional cruelty and an act of abuse. 1,531. Kathryn Irby GULFPORT, MS Stop Abusing these innocent, loving dogs!!! Animals are Creatures of God, not Man!! 1,532. Alexis Jamison Mililani, HI 1,533. Regina Dorsett Flintstone, GA 1,534. Maureen Manzene Brewerton, NY 1,535. Evelyn Bird Bexhill on Sea, United Kingdom 1,536. Elodie CASPAR NANCY, France 1,537. Rebecca Scholze Boyceville, WI I am a chained dog advocate in my area. Dogs on chains become neglected yard ornaments. It is no life. 1,538. Brigitte König Büttelborn, Germany 1,539. Pamela Rodden Longmont, CO 1,540. Hans Ng Singapore, Singapore 1,541. Magi Driscoll Salt Lake City, UT This is not right. Please take the chains off these poor animals. Please start prosecuting people who are fighting these dogs. They don't want to fight! They don't want to be chained up & neglected! They want & deserve to be loved & cared for! 1,542. Nigel Griffiths Chesterfield, United Kingdom 1,543. Anne Boggs Mountain view, HI Not acceptable - all lives matter 1,544. Vera Lukashina Moscow, Afghanistan 1,545. Andra Aprodu BUCHAREST, Romania 1,546. Barb Stuckel STATELINE, NV 1,547. Madison Idso STATELINE, NV 1,548. Morgan Idso GAVIOTA, CA 1,549. Jeff Idso DANVILLE, CA 1,550. Barbara Idso DANVILLE, CA 1,551. Jonathon Stern Sydney, Australia 1,552. Ana Sotelo Keaau, HI Animals don't have a voice to speak out for themselves so someone has to do it! All living creatures matter.

Page 56 - Signatures 1,526 - 1,552 Name From Comments 1,553. Sue H Cambridge, Canada 1,554. grace Liu Honolulu, HI 1,556. m moran maui, HI 1,557. M. Markl Honolulu, HI Please help now. 1,558. Michal Rosenthal Giv'atayim, Israel 1,559. Darleen Owens Kihei, HI This is just another example of cruelty to animals in Hawaii, please help do something about it NOW! 1,560. Katarzyna Wysoka, Poland I love animals Bienenda 1,561. Makani Dias Paauilo, HI It is important to me because People need to think. how would you feel if you were treated like that. how would you like it if you were abused. dogs have feelings, even if they are not in your life until your time on this planet ends, you are in their lives until theirs does no dog deserves to be abused or put down. they have feelings and deserve a chance they can't speak for themsleves so we have to. they should make it a fellony to abuse animals. if i could i would adopt them all. 1,562. MaryLou Ewa Beach, HI DePondicchello 1,563. Chelsea DeMore Hilo, HI 1,564. Misti Mills Terre Haute, IN 1,565. Melita Romero Sparks, NV 1,566. Kayleigh White Johannesburg, South Africa 1,567. Christi Fox Green Valley, Canada 1,568. Debra Casey Malone, NY 1,569. Anna Paris Augusta, GA 1,570. Bambi Williams Bridgeville, DE 1,571. Peggy Overstreet HUNTINGTON Chaining a dog outdoors with no appropriate shelter should BEACH, CA be outlawed. if a dog cannot be indoors and treated like family then the people should not have a pet. this is no life ever for any pet! 1,572. Rachel Maher Dartmouth, Canada 1,573. Deniz Rehklau Alpharetta, GA 1,574. Linda Nosser Valley Forge, PA 1,575. Michele Montsch Milford, DE Anything that has to do with the care of animals is important to me! 1,576. Rena ESCONDIDO, CA Zaman-Zade 1,577. David Pacheco Willmar, MN 1,578. Alex Mobley Jacksonville, FL

Page 57 - Signatures 1,553 - 1,578 Name From Comments 1,579. Debra Pratt Golden, CO Because it is a form of ANIMAL ABUSE! 1,580. Angela Rhea Lutz, FL Because this is animal abuse and it is hideous!! 1,581. Lindsey Evans, CO Steinmiller 1,582. Tara Deon Niagara falls, NY Quality of life for all living creatures..dogs love with all of there being..they deserve to be happy 1,583. Virginia Wonder hanover, PA 1,584. Christine Littles Reisterstown, MD Dogs are loving animals and deserve to be freeed 1,585. Mala Ram Piarco, Trinidad And Tobago 1,586. Susan Patenaude Huachuca City, AZ 1,587. Dawn Bonaparte Roanoke Rapids, NC 1,588. Emily Williams Bay village, OH 1,589. Kristen Bell AUSTIN, TX 1,590. Sondra Rodgers SPRING HILL, FL 1,591. Karleah Sidky Parkland, FL 1,592. Maria Sastre Miami, FL People don't understand animals in general feel pain and joy and dogs are amazing 1,593. Marcia Turner Barnsdall, OK This is important to me because no dog should have to live life on a chain for any reason 1,594. Lori Beck Allen, TX 1,595. Angela Farr Clarksville, TN 1,596. Sara Adams Anderson, IN I am a dog lover. 1,597. Alexandra Washington, PA Contrafatto 1,598. Kristy Carver Diamond Bar, CA 1,599. Zandra Hanna Bend, OR I rescue pits and this is disgusting to me that people chain their dogs up. 1,600. Sally kneipp Ellendale, DE 1,601. Cheryl Bailey Quincy, WA 1,602. rachel lovich perth, Australia 1,603. Kerriann Exner Aurora, CO 1,604. Deborah Gruber Meadville, PA Because it's not humane to leave a dog chained. They need love and attention!! Not a spot in the backyard!!😡 1,605. Julie Herman Eau Claire, WI 1,606. Josephine Springfield, MO Morrison 1,607. Laura Riebel Casselberry, FL 1,608. eduardo tanajero juarez, Mexico vilas

Page 58 - Signatures 1,579 - 1,608 Name From Comments 1,609. Matt Jugran Ewa Beach, HI Love our dogs. Treat them better and never chain up. 1,610. Chantell Durban, South Africa To stop animal abuse. Set him free O'Kennedy 1,611. Bettina Seidel Gera, Germany 1,612. Renee Piraino Madison, WI Dogs have feelings too. This must stop!!!! 1,613. Aurelie Farreyrol Machtum, Luxembourg 1,614. Julie Isola Verona, WI 1,615. Claudine Scheun Mellet, Belgium 1,616. Stacy Schmitz Fond Du Lac, WI 1,617. Jenna Razner Fond du Lac, WI 1,618. Andrea Baer Kihei, HI 1,619. Alex Werjefelt Kamuela, HI 1,620. Lisa King Volcano, HI Dogs need more room or they become neurotic over time. Dogs should not be continuously chained. 1,621. Sandra Jacksonville, NC Wichrowski 1,622. Ann Bayshore, NY Tedeschi-Davidson 1,623. Kat Reeves Yamba, Australia 1,624. yolanda schultes Wittenbach, Switzerland 1,625. bos claudine poligny, France 1,626. Peter Bobbermen Bundaberg, Australia 1,627. Joanne Nolan Redfern, Australia 1,628. Anette Schneller , Schließe von ganzem ❤️der petition an Germany 1,629. Ute Blum Hennef, Germany 1,630. sab flo lyon, France 1,631. ΑΝΑΣΤΑΣΙΑ ΕΥΟΣΜΟΣ, Greece ΧΛΩΡΟΥ 1,632. Jennifer Sesnick Waldwick, NJ 1,633. Sandra Gamböck Wiener Neudorf, Austria 1,634. Christian Lorenz Großkarolinenfeld, Germany 1,635. Kathrin Siegmund Blankenfelde-Mahlow, Germany 1,636. Shayne O'Brien Portland, OR 1,637. Markus Lucio , Germany

Page 59 - Signatures 1,609 - 1,637 Name From Comments 1,638. Paul Cherryman Toronto, Canada 1,639. Franziska Treuen, Germany Gerhardt 1,640. rose moore Yale St. Clair County, MI 1,641. Nina Hagen Mannheim, Germany 1,642. Sylvia Champigny s/M, FUCCINELLI France 1,643. A. O.Schaller Leimbach, Germany 1,644. Roswitha Wedel, Germany Hanowski 1,645. maria de almeida Berkeley, CA 1,646. Vanna Pagnozzi 64560 Riedstadt, Germany 1,647. Manuela Oberkirch, Germany Düsterwald 1,648. Shirley Moore Tavarnelle VP, Italy 1,649. Jutta Christof Laßnitzhöhe, Austria Der Mensch ist so ein Bastard!!! 1,650. Shweta Chaklader Leicester, United Kingdom 1,651. Madeleine PERNES les Rampling Fontaines, France 1,652. frédéric pulcini frontignan, France 1,653. Yukari Waki Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 1,654. Angela Fricke Bad Sachsa, Germany 1,655. Rosi Zang Aschaffenburg, Germany 1,656. Ronny De Coster Ghent, Belgium 1,657. Giles Rayner Tetbury, United Kingdom 1,658. Gary Schutt Watford, United Kingdom 1,659. Christina Frutuoso Esch, Luxembourg 1,660. rocky randy gelderland, Netherlands 1,661. fay carne jersey, Jersey 1,662. Michaela Beck Dürnkrut, Austria 1,663. Shane O'Brien Brisbane, Australia 1,664. Lisa Malousi Stuttgart, Germany

Page 60 - Signatures 1,638 - 1,664 Name From Comments 1,665. Lourdes Escobar 00000, Honduras 1,666. Petra Lippmann Hage, Germany 1,667. Judith Sadura Bad-vöslau m, Austria 1,668. Hugo Bouffioulx, Belgium DEROULOU 1,669. Franziska Zeidler Berlin, Germany 1,670. Hermine Amsterdam, Groenendaal Netherlands 1,671. Ewa Ewa Kętrzyn, Poland 1,672. annelie Moser idar-oberstein, Germany 1,673. Jennifer Brandt Avondale, AZ 1,674. Nena Woelk Limache, Chile 1,675. Mizuho Kojima 多治見市, Japan 1,676. Jacqueline Martigny, Switzerland Lavanchy 1,677. Donna Tolzien San Juan Capistrano, CA 1,678. Marie - Louise Basel, Switzerland Galliker 1,679. Camilla Mackeson Brooklyn, NY 1,680. Doreen Yaeger Bellevulle, MI 1,681. Flaviana Domitilla Wellington, New Zealand 1,682. Rowena Carino Tabaco, Philippines 1,683. Amy James Kuching, Malaysia 1,684. Zara C Manchester, United Kingdom 1,685. Vicky Humbarger Magnolia, TX 1,686. Maria Alice Simao Brasilia, Brazil 1,687. Rebecca Randle Irving, TX 1,688. Katrina Carter Perth, Australia 1,689. Michael Smith Cirencester, United I am sick of seeing the words 'tradition', 'culture', 'heritage', Kingdom etc to defend the most heinous acts against animals. Some of us have managed to evolve into civilized human beings without suffering any psychological or social trauma over leaving our sordid past behind. 1,690. Petra Jones Andover, United Kingdom 1,691. eleni skarlatos DARWIN, Australia

Page 61 - Signatures 1,665 - 1,691 Name From Comments 1,692. Cheryl Stewart Weed, CA 1,693. Regina Wielsch Gemünden, Germany 1,694. janka tata, Hungary kajabálós-csepű 1,695. Christopher PORTLAND, OR Stasney 1,696. Alison Jones Gwynedd, United Kingdom 1,697. Christine Paranaque, Cerqueda Philippines 1,698. Susan Griffiths Klagenfurt, Austria 1,699. Fay Atkins Adelaide, Australia 1,700. Peter Rylander Johanneshov, Sweden 1,701. Siegrid Roedel Herzogenaurach, HELP AND SAVE Germany 1,702. Ana Carpio Valencia, Spain 1,703. louise lew kota kinabalu, Malaysia 1,704. Manuela Bergkamen, Germany Eggermann 1,705. Marianne Lentzweiler, Faron-Haon-MangenLuxembourg 1,706. Erbenova Avalon, Australia 1,707. Meli Kirchmeier Mollis, Switzerland 1,708. Junie Llanelli, United Walters-Aust Kingdom 1,709. margrith KLEIN RÖMERSWIL, Switzerland 1,710. Maroin Mhadhbi Erlensee, Germany 1,711. Christel Fabienke , Germany Ich schließe mich der Petition an 1,712. Leonella Leoni perugia, Italy 1,713. Martine cuisenaire Hastière, Belgium 1,714. Carina Zandonelli Luftenberg, Austria 1,715. Katia Tunison Santos, Brazil 1,716. Andrea Bausch Erzhausen, Germany 1,717. jasmin crossman Hemer, Germany 1,718. Marie.jeanne Marck, France Choquet

Page 62 - Signatures 1,692 - 1,718 Name From Comments 1,719. Mireille CARVIN ST MANDRIER, France 1,720. patricia sryma bochum, Germany 1,721. Véronique BURN eragny, France 1,722. Petra Essen, Germany Hegenscheidt 1,723. Agata Bruun Dragor, Denmark 1,724. Katalin Konya Szatymaz, Hungary Jakus 1,725. Sandra Meyer Luzern, Switzerland 1,726. ANNE MARIE , Morocco TOUBOUL 1,727. Michael Blanke Kassel, Germany 1,728. Nicole Martin koblenz, Germany 1,729. linda maccario , France 1,730. debbie melville wirral, United Kingdom 1,731. ute hopfgartner elsbethen, Austria 1,732. Astrid Süßbrich Diez, Germany 1,733. Françoise Belfort, France Fendeler 1,734. Anna Altner Michelbach an der Bilz, Germany 1,735. Francesco Caserta, Italy Giaquinto 1,736. Sybil R Austin, TX 1,737. Violetta Hartmann Dahme/Mark, Germany 1,738. haley west perth, Australia 1,739. patricia coenen grivegnee liege, Belgium 1,740. Natally Klaric Montreal, Canada 1,741. Jeeva Nadarajah Singapore, Singapore 1,742. Karmen Katz ASTORIA, NY 1,743. Deriaalvesdeoli Amparo, Brazil Oliveira 1,744. Gaby Muller Soleuvre, Luxembourg 1,745. Judith Stef Graz4, Austria 1,746. Stephanie Myers Greenfield Ctr, NY

Page 63 - Signatures 1,719 - 1,746 Name From Comments 1,747. Rob Chloe Sam Highgate, United Neeson Kingdom 1,748. florence israel behen, France 1,749. Edda Hambrecht Essen, Germany 1,750. Petra Beekmans Regensburg, Germany 1,751. Анна Зубова Плес, Russian Federation 1,752. Candice tharp WILDWOOD, FL 1,753. Tiziana Dordoni Corsico Mi, Italy 1,754. Chee Siew Im Georgetown, Malaysia 1,755. Malaika Ronnenberg, Weißmann Germany 1,756. John Stafford Altavista, VA 1,757. Martine Van Merchtem, Belgium Ransbeeck 1,758. Mary Panchal Parma hts, OH 1,759. Tina Charette Sanford, ME 1,760. Shari Miller Los osos, CA 1,761. malik griffin Knightdale, NC 1,762. Carol Rushton LA GUANCHA, Spain Algar 1,763. christiane ciardi gignac, France 1,764. Theresa Crovello Fall River, MA 1,765. Karen Yorba Linda, CA 1,766. Nathalie Urban Saarbrücken, Germany 1,767. vasiliki paschalidi patmow, Greece 1,768. Josiane Perche Gorbio, France 1,769. Virginie Bonett Suresnes, France Boisseranc 1,770. marilou jung roth , France 1,771. sandy paganucci SANTA ROSA, CA 1,772. marilena zubani mazzano, Italy 1,773. Patrice Leroux Calais, France 1,774. Gabrielle RAMBOUILLET, COLLADANT France 1,775. barbara barski Berlin, Germany 1,776. véronique Langlet Louvres, France

Page 64 - Signatures 1,747 - 1,776 Name From Comments 1,777. francoise cheutin fere en tardenois, France 1,778. jean-simon bégin cap santé, Canada 1,779. Imke Born Saarbrücken, Germany 1,780. Birgit Kremer Weil, Germany 1,781. Martine Leroux Saint Quentin, France 1,782. Anita Erhard Götzis, Austria 1,783. huguette vignaux oberschaeffolsheim, France 1,784. Barbara Joosten Witten, Germany 1,785. françoise dominois gisors, France 1,786. PAT STURGE BASINGSTOKE, United Kingdom 1,787. Laura olsen HUNTLEY, IL 1,788. RONEL ALLEN PENSACOLA, FL 1,789. Patrícia RIo de janeiro, Brazil GWINNER 1,790. Ene Pe Brussel, Belgium 1,791. Laurence Stahr Lomme, France 1,792. Marlies Labude Hannover, Germany 1,793. Emmanuelle Castleford, United ARNOLD Kingdom 1,794. Tina Ricard Rochester, NY 1,795. Verena Burger Starnberg, Germany 1,796. Tessa Hayward Nr Banbury, United Kingdom 1,797. Panagiotis Patra, Greece Rigopoulos 1,798. richard sciascia fontenay sous bois, L'amour de mes meilleurs compagnons et à la haine de ces France tortionnaires 1,799. Joanne Wright Sheffield, United Kingdom 1,800. Amy Doohan Penfield, NY 1,801. Hazel Silvester Near Newark, Notts., ANIMAL ABUSE - NO EXCUSE. THIS IS DISGRACEFUL United Kingdom ... 1,802. vanessa martinez le perreux sur marne, France 1,803. candy rhounan les ulis, France

Page 65 - Signatures 1,777 - 1,803 Name From Comments 1,804. MYLENE SAINT-GEORGES, LAMBERMONT Belgium 1,805. Dalila Luznar Ljubljana, Slovenia 1,806. marie maria marseille, France 1,807. CHRISTINE NICE, France ROSSSI 1,808. Silvia Angeloni Villaz St Pierre, Scozzari Switzerland 1,809. Sylvie Le ruyet Pluneret, France 1,810. Hans rodriguez TRIANGLE, VA 1,811. Shawn Rodriguez Mesa, AZ 1,812. Siomara Medrano Nasville, TN 1,813. Jane Harrison Coventry, United What is the matter with you people who do this? Scum! Kingdom 1,814. Christine Norrköping, Sweden Thörnwall 1,815. ines töpfel schönefeld, Germany 1,816. Tirza van der Tholen, Netherlands Zande 1,817. yvonne gratzl pyhra, Austria 1,818. amanda Bishop bristol, United Kingdom 1,819. Chris Weststrate Puttershoek, Netherlands 1,820. chantal thomas frejus, France 1,821. Florent Brachini Falicon, France 1,822. christelle Antoine Orléans, France coeugnet 1,823. Edilma Ipiranga Cotia, Brazil 1,824. marie-francoise rancy, France perchepied 1,825. myriam schwartz PLAISANCE DU TOUCH, France 1,826. Jodi Rodar PELHAM, MA 1,827. Martine Derouaux Bruxelles, Belgium 1,828. Anne-Sophie ROC PARIS, France d'avidson 1,829. ALEJANDRA DE MINATITLAN, Mexico LA FUENTE GARCIA 1,830. Sonia Jette Ste-sophie, Canada

Page 66 - Signatures 1,804 - 1,830 Name From Comments 1,831. Holly Dymond Exeter, United Kingdom 1,832. Laurence farge paris, France 1,833. marie Khattabi Cannes, France 1,834. Mariska Uithoorn, Netherlands Catsman-Okkersen 1,835. Mirta Ezer Tel aviv, Israel 1,836. Tsintzira Claudine Uccle, Belgium L horreur a chaque coin de rue דלרלבח, Israel גחבח כחבבח .1,837 1,838. Mauro Raffaelli Ravenna, Italy 1,839. Fernande Fournier Luxemburg, Auch Tiere haben ein Anrecht auf Frieden, Freiheit, Luxembourg Lebensraum und ein würdevolles Leben auf diesem Planeten! Nehmen, Sie Ihre Verantwortung, bitte. Helfen und handeln Sie menschlich und zügig. Harte Strafen und keine Tierhaltung mehr für solche " Menschen "! Tiere, sind Lebewesen! Dessen, sind Sie sich bewusst? Zivilisierte, Gesellschaft? Man erntert stets das was man sät. Vergessen, Sie dies nicht. Schande! Merci. 1,840. Anat Williams Tel Aviv, Israel 1,841. Helga Huber Celldömölk, Hungary Man sollte so manchen Mensch auch in Ketten legen. Er wird dann sehen was für ein trostloses leben das ist. Und dann bekommt ermal was zu Essen. die Menschen werden immer dümmer und gleichgültiger trotz Schulbildung. 1,842. Claire Loridan Papeete, French 1,843. Béa Winckelmans Charleroi, Belgium 1,844. Lotta Stenfelt Malmö, Sweden 1,845. sue wadland east sussex, United Kingdom 1,846. Christiane De Melsbroek, Belgium Ridder 1,847. Malin K Sthlm, Sweden 1,848. Marcie Perskin Flushing, NY Human Up 1,849. Pat Labik Philadelphia, PA 1,850. hector villas fierro juarez, Mexico 1,851. Sandy Denicola Canton, GA 1,852. jim penrose gravemhurst, Canada 1,853. Cristal Mota Sao paulo, Brazil 1,854. Nelly Scorbiac St Orens de Gameville, France 1,855. Dagmar Hilgefort Herford, Germany

Page 67 - Signatures 1,831 - 1,855 Name From Comments 1,856. sarah Allan Devon, United Kingdom 1,857. Pamela Seitz Hialeah, FL 1,858. Elizabeth Weiss Goodyear, AZ 1,859. Tina Chalmers Vancouver, Canada 1,860. Kathy Chadwell LAFAYETTE, IN 1,861. Cynthia Smith Cheshire, CT 1,862. Debra Curci Toms River, NJ 1,863. Kornelia Rüttgers Grevenbroich, Germany 1,864. СТАС АКСЁНОВ Тюмень, Russian Federation 1,865. Tânia Maria Alves Taubaté, Brazil Feliciano 1,866. mihaela gongescu Burlington On, Canada 1,867. а астрахань, Russian Federation 1,868. martine voyer SAINT-GÉRARD-MAJELLA, Canada 1,869. Hildegard Körner Rügland, Germany 1,870. Milina Shrestha Kathmandu, Nepal 1,871. Cyndi Cantu Jasper, IN There are other things that can be used then a logging chain. The dog also looks skinny to me. Might be starved also 1,872. Lynne Huntley Park Forest, IL 1,873. Andrea Bergen Moraga, CA 1,874. Susan Schwartz NEWARK, DE 1,875. Ruth Barnickel Eimke, Germany 1,876. Shirley Austin London, United Kingdom 1,877. luigi maria abbiategrasso, Italy castellazzi 1,878. christine beaudry WALTHAM, MA 1,879. lyuba pace midland, MI 1,880. jeanine smadja 83220 LE PRADET, France 1,881. Roberta Morrison NORTHGLENN, CO Totally inappropriate way to confine any animal. Chains are way too short to allow any freedom of movement, and would be heavy enough to cause painful muscle stress. No wonder these dogs, in general, are more likely to bite people. How (continues on next page)

Page 68 - Signatures 1,856 - 1,881 Name From Comments 1,881. Roberta Morrison NORTHGLENN, CO (continued from previous page) would you feel if you were forced to live on a heavy chain, that basically kept you confined within three feet of your toilet? That is how these dogs are forced to live their lives, and they don't enjoy it anymore than you would. Less, simply because their noses are so much better that ours, and they don't have the luxury of flushing their waste down a drain, but have to LIVE IN IT. 1,882. Laura Kreft Brigbton, CO 1,883. Marie Hiriberry Itxassou, France 1,884. Annett Walther Bitterfeld, Germany 1,885. Jina Harrell Sherman, TX 1,886. eva girit-azzolini heilshorn, Germany 1,887. Danielle Strasbourg, France 1,888. Colette PRESA ARCUEIL, France 1,889. Richard Frey Leopoldsdorf, Austria 1,890. Rosanna Teramo, Italy Gianfrancesco 1,891. Zoe Spiropoulou Haidari, Greece 1,892. Birgitta Pettersson Hedemora, Sweden 1,893. ginger stone Wilkesboro, NC PLEASE DO U PEOPLE HAV NO HEART I HOPE GOD TAKES CARE OF U 4 BEING SO EVIL 1,894. Marion Oldenburg, Germany Brannaschk 1,895. Andrea Warchol O'fallon, IL 1,896. Francine Canton , France poublet 1,897. lisa lee malmö, Sweden 1,898. Elaine Jung new Westminster, Canada 1,899. Titti Viprödsle Oslo, Norway 1,900. Ana Crespo Coimbra, Portugal 1,901. Ina Kornblum Memmingen, Germany 1,902. KIBRIA BRONX, NY CHOWDHURY 1,903. michaela svorc austria, Austria 1,904. Susan Aspland Swansea, United Kingdom 1,905. Darlene burke PITTSBURGH, PA 1,906. Mj Rostoll Jio, France

Page 69 - Signatures 1,881 - 1,906 Name From Comments 1,907. Laura Call fri East Hanover, NJ 1,908. EVE NOUMEA, New Caledonia 1,909. Joan Izatt So. Jordan, UT 1,910. Kirsty Young Mooloolaba, Australia 1,911. muriel minne chimay, Belgium 1,912. Lara Hembom Ashkelon, Israel 1,913. Pierre Closson Arquennes, Belgium 1,914. valerie vergeot vergnies, Belgium 1,915. Marie claire Marseille, France Lucchesi 1,916. Heike Thutewohl , Germany 1,917. Vanditta Diwakar Suva, 1,918. Cynthia Simpson Gorham, ME 1,919. Betty Harris Converse, TX 1,920. Sandra STEILACOOM, WA Charbonneau 1,921. Marlis Schmitz Voerde, Germany 1,922. Kyle Bracken MARINA DEL REY, CA 1,923. Jillian Walaski Cranston, RI 1,924. Lysiane Beaumont Tourcoing, France 1,925. Patricia Caswick Cutler Bay, FL 1,926. Kate Perkins Endwell, NY 1,927. Elodie Rodriguez Lafrançaise, France 1,928. Soraya Weatherby Chicago, IL 1,929. Sieglinda Du East London, South Preez Africa 1,930. Gael Marconi Quincy, MA 1,931. June Jordan Somerville, AL 1,932. Sharan Laird Glasgow, United Kingdom 1,933. Robin Sellers Springwater, NY 1,934. alice bex, Switzerland 1,935. Yvonne Brotzki Hatzenbühl, Germany 1,936. Selma Braido São Paulo, Brazil 1,937. FUENTES ALBI, France HAWAI is a sad country danielle 1,938. katja schmidt berlin, Germany

Page 70 - Signatures 1,907 - 1,938 Name From Comments 1,939. Gail Philadelphia, PA mercy towards animals not violence 1,940. corine renquet wasseiges, Belgium 1,941. Claudine Laudun, France MAMMERI 1,942. danielle jacques belgique, Belgium 1,943. Evelyn Lechner Wattens, Austria 1,944. Nicolette Ludolphi oslebs, Germany 1,945. Pam Bollinger Apache Junction, AZ Dogs dont belong on chains especially 3ft chains!!!!! Can we get anymore cruel? Dogs love to run and if you can't treat them like family then you dont need a dog 1,946. filiz Selman New roch, Turkey 1,947. maria mucci boschi di lari, Italy 1,948. brigitte hoin herzogenrath, Germany 1,949. Isabelle Obscur , France 1,950. Katharine Duffey Durham, NC 1,951. brenda allen London, Canada 1,952. Änna Bad Soden, Germany Diesenbacher 1,953. Lorraine Coughlan Ras Salmiya, Kuwait 1,954. christine caron domart en ponthieu, France 1,955. CHERYL HOPE, MI RAMRIEZ 1,956. Gabriele Angerer Wien, Austria 1,957. Patricia Martin PEEBLES, OH 1,958. Darlene Bangert San Tan Valley, AZ 1,959. Himena Lira Malmö, Sweden 1,960. Marla Hatton Hannibal, MO 1,961. masset lise LASSICOURT, France 1,962. David Magnante ft myers, FL 1,963. chrisanthi athens, Greece veloudaki 1,964. jaklien lammens waregem, Belgium 1,965. marcia sliwinski KENMORE, NY 1,966. Cathy Borrego BERWYN, IL 1,967. Jan Avery Luton, United Kingdom

Page 71 - Signatures 1,939 - 1,967 Name From Comments 1,968. Tamara Zobotke Gundelfingen a. d. Donau, Germany 1,969. Nancy Pointer SAN jose, CA 1,970. Silvana São Paulo, Brazil Schossland 1,971. Debbie Pletz Charles town, WV 1,972. sandra etchell nr, IL 1,973. Crystal maynes Wallaceburg, Canada 1,974. Sarah Vuu Espoo, Finland 1,975. Sandra Greene Susquehanna, PA Give them a stiff fine if it doesnt change take dogs and arrest them 1,976. nelly junet Roche Lez Beaupré, France 1,977. Jessica Black Denver, CO 1,978. Susana villlalba buenos aires, Argentina 1,979. Dava Stone Seagrove, NC 1,980. joelle orset daumazan, France 1,981. Larraine Belli Wilmington, NC 1,982. kathleen galle chatelet, Belgium 1,983. Joan Pueblo, CO These people need some education --logging chains are Lewandowski painful and only 3 ft limits the poor dog to a tiny exercise area. STOP this cruelty now. 1,984. Kimberly Crawford Boron, CA 1,985. Lisette de Waard Lelystad, Netherlands 1,986. Kathy Stoddard Napanee, Canada 1,987. Petra Hohmann Goslar, Germany 1,988. Dave Cooper London, United Kingdom 1,989. Linda Valdenaire Nice, France Stop à la maltraitance 1,990. JoAnn Paris Saint Lazare, Canada 1,991. Sheri MacMaster cOLUMBUS, OH 1,992. lyne paquet nice, France 1,993. Robert Crowe Hudson, MA 1,994. Evelyne Boehni S'Agata de Goti, Italy 1,995. Maria Fowler Abbeville, SC anybody who abuses an animal, in any way should do prison time. Only the lowest of the low abuses an animal. they are family and should be treated as family. If you can't love a pet and treat them as family---DO NOT GET A PET. 1,996. Shannon Cowett Chantilly, VA

Page 72 - Signatures 1,968 - 1,996 Name From Comments 1,997. Iveta Dzhonova Sofia, Bulgaria 1,998. Catherine Bazin Manduel, France 1,999. Danielle BREHEVILLE, France GUILLAUME 2,000. Esther Ruiz Burgos, Spain 2,001. joelle jacob heusy, Belgium 2,002. Anaïs Bruxelles, Belgium Verschueren 2,003. MURIEL SERAING, Belgium BERTRAND 2,004. patricia garfagnini entrecasteaux, France 2,005. Mélanie Bruxelles, Belgium Verschueren 2,006. Cecile Dupont Bruxelles, Belgium 2,007. Corine voisin Ploubazlanec, France 2,008. pierre poujol ecommoy, France 2,009. Ghislain Benoit Pau, France 2,010. Sarah Maache Casablanca, Morocco 2,011. angelina Laval, France lemonnier 2,012. annick pcion le portel, France 2,013. catherine labes paris, France pauvre bete les humains sont vraiment assassins et cruels 2,014. Julie Leguerni Bordeaux, France 2,015. Marie Rose Dijon, France ROBAR 2,016. Christine Solre le chateau, Vecchiato France 2,017. Brigitte Didat Ramonville Saint Agne, France 2,018. stéphanie jacq château arnoux, France 2,019. patrick calendre barbonne, France 2,020. Laetitia Cauchois Plomeur, France 2,021. Laurence Gaucher Reze, France 2,022. Martine ARLES, France REYBAUD 2,023. Sabrina Gorree Cluses, France 2,024. Aurelie Simondi Marseille, France 2,025. Jose Domingo Valbonne, France 2,026. estelle st-germain st-vianney, Canada

Page 73 - Signatures 1,997 - 2,026 Name From Comments 2,027. Nadia tir Montreuil, France 2,028. nadine dheur aywaille, Belgium 2,029. Jean-pierre Waremme, Belgium Englebert 2,030. Marie Christine St Martin de st Coutant maixent, France 2,031. Lisa Maloney Staten Island, NY 2,032. Josyane MANENT Corbère les Cabanes, stop à la maltraitance ! FAUCANIE France 2,033. michel houle charlemagne, Canada 2,034. Marie Lombaerts Bruxelles, Belgium 2,035. matthieu lenfant wavrin, France 2,036. Janet Dunn Gaspé, Canada 2,037. Maureen Lehman Leawood, KS 2,038. Maggy Bruxelles, Belgium Schurmann' 2,039. BEATRICE NOUMEA, France FARINA 2,040. viviane hugou les assions, France 2,041. efith becar bouchain, France 2,042. mario sierra ruiz juarez, Mexico 2,043. Herb Giacchina Sebastian, FL 2,044. lydia antoniades nice, France 2,045. Karenina Schuller So. Lake Tahoe, CA 2,046. josyane larmor plage, France grand-colas 2,047. Jennifer Lovett Stamford, VT 2,048. Pierrette Bolis L auberson, Switzerland 2,049. Aurelie Bou Marseille, France 2,050. Anne Hutchins Teaticket, MA 2,051. Angela Soler Le faouet, France 2,052. valerie soucasse Pau, France 2,053. Emilie Beaujean Suresnes, France 2,054. Catherine Vierzon, France LAVERGNE 2,055. Mireille Baré Fleron, Belgium 2,056. Andrea Figgs Sunnyside, NY

Page 74 - Signatures 2,027 - 2,056 Name From Comments 2,057. Marce Walsh HOUSTON, TX I am ashamed of man. "We should have respect for animals because it makes better human beings of us all."- "The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated."-Mahatma Ghandi 2,058. Axelle Gavrel Paris, France 2,059. Charlotte Weber Saint ouen, France 2,060. Elodie Bagnot Chambly, France 2,061. Denise Donovan Owosso, MI 2,062. Sylvie Turbert Nice, France 2,063. Peter Jennings Porthtowan, United Stop this cruelty now Kingdom 2,064. Barbara Martin Plantation, FL 2,065. Lisbeth Borg Lena, Norway 2,066. tommy newell greenbrier, TN 2,067. marie-eve cloutier st-amable, Canada 2,068. Thérèse Fisette Montréal, Canada 2,069. Hilena Fernandez Boynton Beach, FL 2,070. Jeanne Parsons Montreal, Canada 2,071. Maria Gouveia Myrtle Beach, SC This sickens me. Treat animals better! 2,072. Jacqueline Marseille, France Demolaize 2,073. Patricia Millozzi Oakland park, FL 2,074. Guylaine Laprise L'Ancienne-Lorette, Canada 2,075. julio barbosa moya juarez, Mexico 2,076. sreymean kouch Phnom Penh, Cambodia 2,077. catherine st-jean st-hyacinthe, Canada 2,078. Judy Michaels Bloomfield, NJ 2,079. Debra Freie Bourbon, MO 2,080. Lolita Thomas Vankleek hill, Canada 2,081. linda copin East Rockaway, NY 2,082. Caroline CIER Apt, France 2,083. Sherry Guzzi Tahoe City, CA 2,084. Nita Moser Little Rock, AR 2,085. Sarah Hernandez Capital heights, MD 2,086. Julee Rosa Olympic Valley, CA 2,087. Elisa Mazenq Bucarest, Romania

Page 75 - Signatures 2,057 - 2,087 Name From Comments 2,088. Gordana Hoffpauir MERRIAM VLG, MO 2,089. Manon Beraud Lyon, France 2,090. janny perez brunet arles raphele, France 2,091. Kathy Dal Tourcoing, France 2,092. nat pechot nevers, France les cruautés doivent êtres punies partout dans le monde ! 2,093. liz Maddrey Lorton, VA 2,094. Patricia Chollet Coullons, France 2,095. stephane gaston congis, France 2,096. Silvana De Felice Herstal, Belgium 2,097. Benoit Dewitte Liege, Belgium 2,098. Valri Katala Oceanside, CA 2,099. Isabelle Dir Phoenix, AZ 2,100. marie be marseille, France 2,101. syloviane gggg, France milliancourt 2,102. Marilyn Quartini Grenoble, France 2,103. jemy jem London, United Kingdom 2,104. Valerie Gillard Coulommiers, France 2,105. laurent sergent re"nnes, France 2,106. nicole bourdon Auros, France 2,107. Laura Gline Dilbeek, Belgium 2,108. Brigitte Maffliers, France Je signe et soutiens cette pétition Deschaintre 2,109. béatrice panchaud Prilly (Vaud ) Suisse, Switzerland 2,110. suzie stoltz Chula Vista, CA 2,111. Sarah Fuster Poivres, France 2,112. celine ducamps VILLERS COTTERETS, France 2,113. Jf Blazquez Saint Jean d'Illac, France 2,114. pat constant grand, France 2,115. JEANNE SMITH exeland, WI 2,116. Martine Noiret montelimar, France Je signe!!! 2,117. Viviane Delecroix St Germain du teil, France 2,118. patricia massa Cabessut, France 2,119. maxime fernandez aix, France

Page 76 - Signatures 2,088 - 2,119 Name From Comments 2,120. Marie Christine Rupt sur , Maurice France 2,121. Janick Vineuil, France Carmagnole 2,122. herta noske buchholz nordheide, Germany 2,123. Yvonne Chopard La cibourg, Switzerland 2,124. Joan Asmundo Toms River, NJ What the hell is wrong with you in Hawaii? I thought you were a gentle people not cruel to animals. I guess I was wrong. Someone needs to feed this poor dog. SHAME on all of you!!!! 2,125. Jodi Igard VALLEY VILLAGE, CA 2,126. francoise mascre LLUPIA, France 2,127. Linda Cook London, United Kingdom 2,128. monic rijkhoff amsterdam, Dogs are social animals and should not be kept on chains. Netherlands The dogs on the picture of this petition is emaciated... I hope something is done to save its life. 2,129. veronique reautey marsas, France 2,130. Linda Babb Torrance, CA 2,131. Claire BODELE ANTONY, France I signed 2,132. Sylvia Taaks Herscheid, Germany 2,133. Caroline Bravin Angers, France 2,134. carole DRAN Savigny-sur-Orge, France 2,135. Claire Madeleine Flers, France 2,136. Ophélie Navarro Walheim, France 2,137. Irina Temnikova San Gwann, Malta 2,138. Jeannine Broeckx Liège, Belgium 2,139. vera lebeta neudorf, Austria 2,140. Jeannine HELENDALE, CA Ragonese 2,141. Cyr Per Var, France 2,142. Fany Anon Cournonterral, France 2,143. patricia falsaperna la louviere, Belgium 2,144. hervé joway bruxelles, Belgium 2,145. MP Almansa Vic la Gardiole, France 2,146. nazia nauzeer Vacoas, Mauritius

Page 77 - Signatures 2,120 - 2,146 Name From Comments 2,147. Carita Karlsson Lahti, Finland 2,148. sonia g gregher, France 2,149. Liliane Gay Orléans, France 2,150. Valeria Belia Roma, Italy 2,151. brigitte berardo paris, France 2,152. Gisele Auger Sierck les bains, France 2,153. lydia hoorelbeke pont a vendin, France 2,154. Laurence Meunier Bondoufle, France 2,155. Sally Moos Bethel, VT Any so called "culture" treatment of innocent animals is absolutely no excuse for abuse of any animal. Shame on these people who are torturing these dogs, and calling it their culture....ignorance is no excuse for the torture of any living beings. 2,156. tiphaine bricoteau soissons, France 2,157. VIVIANE TRINCI ROUSSET, France 2,158. micheline joinville, France deberque 2,159. Lynda Sarrington herts, United Kingdom 2,160. annie cecille aix les bains, France 2,161. Caroline Knowles Derby, United Kingdom 2,162. josette sauvager chene chenu, France 2,163. Sophie Louis Saulx les , France 2,164. Aurore Canaleta Dremil, France 2,165. Julie Amaglio Epernay, France 2,166. jean pierre bercier olivet, France 2,167. catherine escleine bourg de peage, France 2,168. karin vandooren Heule, Belgium stop animal suffering 2,169. arline lohli las vegas, NV 2,170. Dominique Delcos Perpignan, France 2,171. Cédric Epinal, France Plantegenet 2,172. Michelle Welsh Langley, Canada 2,173. Marjorie Hubert Longwy, France 2,174. kathleen coryell mishawaka, IN HE NEEDS LOVE FOOD WALKING HELP 2,175. charay malas Chelsea, VT 2,176. Jelger Bakker Elsene, Belgium

Page 78 - Signatures 2,147 - 2,176 Name From Comments 2,177. michele bogaert champigny sur marne, France 2,178. josette meunier bondoufle, France punissez les pourrissssssssssssss 2,179. David Sallay Vif, France 2,180. julia fish wolverhampton, United Kingdom 2,181. Joëlle PETIT SAINT GERMAIN, France 2,182. alexandra caso hyeres, France 2,183. Michele Breut Berkel-Enschot, Netherlands 2,184. Alexis Lipsheim, France SCHWUTTGE 2,185. brandao Pont De Metz, France jacqueline 2,186. Linda Po Eastlake, OH 2,187. Kelly Lagace Sherwood Park, Canada 2,188. Micheline LAVENTIE, France THOMAS 2,189. christian landois nubecourt, France 2,190. Marion H Dudek Sanford, FL 2,191. Patricia BOUALI , France 2,192. D. Bullock GREENSBORO, NC 2,193. Xavier Borie Pont Saint Esprit, France 2,194. Janice Sampo Green Bay, WI 2,195. Annick SANCHEZ Rieux, France 2,196. carole damamme conches en ouche, France 2,197. Petra Jakubzik neuss, Germany 2,198. Monique Nice, France MANZONE 2,199. Cheryl Chaney BROWNS MILLS, NJ 2,200. Oxana Nikonova Berlin, Germany 2,201. Armande Béres Tongeren, Belgium 2,202. Apolline Paumier , France 2,203. Theresa Milloy Pierrefonds, Canada 2,204. valerie gicquel CARQUEFOU, France

Page 79 - Signatures 2,177 - 2,204 Name From Comments 2,205. Florina Malinge Brissac quince, France 2,206. Chantal Grogna Luxembourg, Simon Luxembourg 2,207. Fabienne , France PELLEGRINI 2,208. christiane guivarch st saturnin du bois, France 2,209. Marylène Ma Prunières, France petite fille de 4 ans 2,210. jessica stephan concarneau, France 2,211. Monica Sousa porto, Portugal 2,212. Claudia Uetze, Germany Wallies-Klose 2,213. Joanne Gray Ashington, United Kingdom 2,214. Maria Jazic Nürnberg, Germany 2,215. maryanne gauthier la roquette, France 2,216. reine menaut carignan de bordeaux, France 2,217. Missy Kendrick Valdosta, GA 2,218. Jennifer Fitch West Roxbury, MA 2,219. bernadette meier SAINT DIZIER, France 2,220. Chrystel Bourquin Chartrettes, France 2,221. corinne biou paris, France 2,222. Christine David Etueffont, France 2,223. Steph Vaucan Roullours, France 2,224. Lucie Sladkova Liberec, Czech Republic 2,225. Louise lasserre Marseille, France 2,226. Liz Kirby Highland, NY 2,227. Morgane Tamagni , France 2,228. Sabine Mayr Innsbruck, Austria 2,229. véronique charvet lyon, France 2,230. Isabelle Duvivier Villemarechal, France 2,231. Valerie Lucas Neuilly plaisance, France 2,232. Anna Żurek Warsaw, Poland 2,233. Valérie Humblot Blanzy, France

Page 80 - Signatures 2,205 - 2,233 Name From Comments 2,234. christian marandet Henon, France 2,235. Alexandra Shelby twp, MI Borhagen 2,236. Kathy Mertiam, KS Vorderbruggen 2,237. Rachel Shiels wales, United Kingdom 2,238. Lyne Forget Montreal, Canada Please ensure the humane treatment of dogs in Hawaii. 2,239. aaron fernandez juarez, Mexico maria 2,240. Coralie Zarola Meythet, France 2,241. Wendy Raeburn East Lothian, United Oh this is such cruelty get it stopped. Kingdom 2,242. Karen Pitts CARROLLTON, GA 2,243. O Olon Orlando Orange County, FL 2,244. Solangel Marseillef, France Lambert-Joffre 2,245. Leslie Kelly Alpine, CA 2,246. Rebecca Knoxville, TN This is a sickening way to treat dogs. NO CHAINS!! Crossland 2,247. Eera Lim singapore, Singapore 2,248. Ute Baker Lake Oswego, OR 2,249. Jan Pratt Middletown, OH No dog should be permanently chained anywhere regardless of the length of chain, much less a three foot one!! AND THIS DOG IS STARVING!!!!!!!! Why isn't that being addressed?????? Someone help this dog before he starves to death! My God he can't even scavenge!!!! 2,250. Thelma Schimit São Paulo, Brazil 2,251. françoise eckard Paris, France 2,252. pierre loiselle magnanville, France 2,253. Cheryl Reis Royal Oak, MI 2,254. Sarah Festraets Brussel, Belgium 2,255. Michaela Rümlang, Switzerland Krebesova 2,256. Mel valentin montpellier, France 2,257. Louise Lynch Knaresborough, United Kingdom 2,258. Alizée Bougault Crevin, France

Page 81 - Signatures 2,234 - 2,258 Name From Comments 2,259. Claudine Gérardin Puget sur Durance, Sadness... France 2,260. Riffard Anne Chamalières, France 2,261. Michelle Pittsburgh, PA Simon-weis 2,262. Janine Corday Scarborough, United Kingdom 2,263. Cindy Gossard Westfield, IN 2,264. Marie-Thérèse THOUROTTE, BADOR France 2,265. Catherine McLeod In erurie, United Kingdom 2,266. Laura Petit Dijon, France 2,267. Elizabeth Bennett Rutland, VT 2,268. Maria Klein Innsbruck, Austria 2,269. Marion Oswald Raden, Germany 2,270. Martina Bergmann Farchant, Germany 2,271. myriam deloustal uzes, France 2,272. Michelle Harris San Clemente, CA 2,273. Lidia Dzioba ul. Polna, Poland 2,274. Henna Kevin Kotka, Finland 2,275. CARLA NICOLAU VILA REAL, Portugal 2,276. Catherine Neal keaau, HI For obvious reasons this is abominable. Anyone who thinks this is ok should be prosecuted. The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated -Ghandi 2,277. Bolly Maus Innsbruck, Austria 2,278. Bine Innsbruck, Austria Regensburger 2,279. christine ponsy st jean de vedas, France 2,280. Jolanta Portland, OR Piatkowska 2,281. Janine Crescenzo Ossining, NY 2,282. Ann Houston Mountain View, HI 2,283. Filiesha Lerand Mountain view, HI Does any one need to ask this question??!! It is so obvious!!! If anyone would like to trade places with this dog.,,,then...maybe ask the question!!! 2,284. Gero Wölfel Amt Wachsenburg, Germany 2,285. Rocio Alfaro Miami, FL

Page 82 - Signatures 2,259 - 2,285 Name From Comments 2,286. Tracey Johnston Kihei, HI 2,288. Juliana Destresse courbevoie, France 2,289. Brigitte Hecht Regensburg, Germany 2,290. Joy Aloha Pahoa, HI Hawai’i law allows DOGS SUFFERING ON THREE FOOT CHAINS...TIED UP THERE ALL DAY AND NIGHT...!!! We are the ones who can help the dogs and the babies killed by dogs on chains…which just happened in Kauai. How wrong to do this to the very best companion and loving friend you can have in life a WONDERFUL DOG....if you read this, will you please sign this petition to help dogs so they do not end up like the sad sorry furbaby in this photo...it is soul searing and so sad...PLEASE...please sign it is simple to help…Thank you. 2,291. Rio Dejavoo Pahoa, HI This is just irresponsible and torture to a beautiful sentient being 2,292. Lisa Bartoletti Pahoa, HI Hawaii must step up and ban this supposedly cultural way of keeping dogs. It's sickening, unhealthy and of course, cruel. 2,293. curtiss klimes laporte, MN Do not see why anyone would use a logging chain for anything other than logging..Certainly not chaining up a dog..If you are going to have a dog for a companion, treat it so.. 2,294. Merle Yusi Mililani, HI ALL animals deserve to be treated humanely. That Hawaii still allows this kind of treatment to continue is an indication that this state doesn't care. Isn't it about time for Hawaii to show the world we are as caring about our animals as our children and elderly? 2,295. Robin Chase Santa Cruz, CA 2,296. Sequoia Heuer Hilo, HI 2,297. Will Pollock SPRINGFIELD, OR DOGS ARE PEOPLE TOO! 2,298. Meg Ryder Greystones, Ireland 2,299. Tammy Jennings Hilo, HI 2,300. Willem-Alexander Dublin, Ireland van der Webber 2,301. Todd Isakson Ogden, UT 2,302. Cynthia Shank Shelton, WA 2,303. Timothy Mertes Idyllwild, CA Animal cruelty needs to stop. 2,304. Peggy Mangan Pigeon, MI 2,305. Karen Stimson Orange, CT 2,306. Evan Russell Keaau, HI 2,307. Nandia Black Kildeer, IL Tethering dogs is cruel and inhumane and should be banned in the US. 2,308. Suzana Vuillermoz France, France

Page 83 - Signatures 2,286 - 2,308 Name From Comments 2,309. Rasha Zaki Cairo, Egypt Because it's abuse 2,310. Katrin Karpowski Riesa, Germany 2,311. Mikhail Krasnodar, Russian Alekseenko Federation 2,312. Elena Maltseva Ekanerinburg, Russian Federation 2,313. vera wessels Windhoek, Namibia 2,314. Sharon Bell Ookala, HI 2,315. Lindafaye Kroll Mt View, HI Two lots away from my house there are 7 or 8 hunting dogs tied up on a vancant lot, who maybe get fed once a day, but are sharved for attention and bark all day and all night long. Complaints have been filed but the police and animal control will do NOTHING! 2,316. Muhammad el paso, TX People should have a proper education about animals and Karboji animal behaviors. No animal should be tied down. it only causes anxiety, frustration and negative stressful energy. That in due time causes the animal to be aggressive/insecure towards people and other animals. Muhammad I.Karboji C.V.A. 2,317. natasja de winter warmond, Netherlands 2,318. lizzy jacobs kessel, Belgium 2,319. Judith Abel Basel, Switzerland 2,320. clara Z cubjac, France 2,321. Allison Zarbaugh Kapaa, HI 2,322. Debbie Cravatta Kamuela, HI 2,323. Laurie Elizares Hilo, HI They deserve a good life! 2,324. Alison Davies Hilo, HI I have seen abused animals--starving kittns left in snow...my last three dogs and cats are rescues. 2,325. Ada Motonaga Hilo, HI I feel the owner dont know only need to me education why heartbroken to the owner even the dogs especailly their baby they wirk hard to buy so much unwanted dog john m said his your freind sometime people cant affird kneel they expense if can help everybidy dog kneel everybody would be happy im w anxiet pts keep my mind goibg w them i took some didnt know their abuse giving thdm love would like to train them they are my pritect if im home alone fight daibetic two pts anxteiyt my dog inform me etc so plesae owner need proper education so much unwanted dog put to sleep sincereky dncouragment 2,326. Angelika Schechs Cham, Germany 2,327. Diana Mountain View, HI We should be so far beyond this! Compassion for all living Rojas-Nasvik beings should be a basic understanding.

Page 84 - Signatures 2,309 - 2,327 Name From Comments 2,328. Connelly Urbana, IL 2,329. Angie Flores Los Angeles, CA 2,330. Bobbi Sloan Redmond, OR 2,331. Andrea Martin Simi Valley, CA This is a terrible abuse of loving animals. Digs deserve the chance to stretch their legs and move about as is natural. End this barbaric chaining now! 2,332. Mary Eldridge Watkins Glen, NY They shouldn't have chains on them these sick individuals need the chains around their necks. How people could be so cruel I just can't understand! Dogs will do anything for your love! Please help them!!! 2,333. Christin Greenland Golden, CO 2,334. Sylvia Breuer Koblenz, Germany 2,335. regina recica ampflwang, Austria 2,336. rene haquard bertrambois, France 2,337. Denise Bonet Badalona, Spain 2,338. Gail Simms Hastings East Sussex, United Kingdom 2,339. sonja vidinli Jetzendorf, Germany 2,340. anke melzer hamburg, Germany 2,341. petra danis stein, Germany 2,342. lucie Klapproth Elbingerode, Germany 2,343. Irene Margot la Marina, San Walder Fulgencio, Spain 2,344. Annette Böcking Hohen Neuendorf, Germany 2,345. Tracey Bradstock Sheffield, United Kingdom 2,346. Bettina Dall'Asta Dahn, Germany 2,347. Marion Nüssel Eschweiler, Germany 2,348. Monika Skala Nünchritz, Germany 2,349. Håkan Forsberg Gnesta, Sweden 2,350. sandra alencar são paulo, Brazil 2,351. kyoko amo tokyo, Japan 2,352. diane dressler Muskogee, OK 2,353. Renata Puppin Pordenone, Italy 2,354. Pia Samuelsson Hörby, Sweden 2,355. vera schiffer alzenau, Germany 2,356. gudrun schwinn bischberg, Germany 2,357. Victoria Arias leon Santa Cruel de Tenerife, Spain

Page 85 - Signatures 2,328 - 2,357 Name From Comments 2,358. Gail Clark Fredonia, NY No state is beautiful when such cruelty lurks in the background. 2,359. Karen Snell COBDEN, IL 2,360. Anna Golanowska Gdańsk, Poland 2,361. perrin dominique lure, France 2,362. silvia mateo general pico, Argentina 2,363. Sandra Wirz Aarburg, Switzerland 2,364. cruz isar madrid, Spain 2,365. Natalia Natasha Izev, Russian Federation 2,366. Gherghina , Dumitrache Denmark 2,367. Jocelyne Peiffer Sourbrodt, Belgium 2,368. lili ana craiova, Romania 2,369. catrin wichmann bremen, Germany 2,370. Stefanie Tolski Darmstadt, Germany 2,371. Heidi Breschan Wien, Austria 2,372. sandra barker stoke on trent, United Kingdom 2,373. Ina Gerhold Großrosseln, Germany 2,374. Evelyne ANGOULEME, DOMPMARTIN-DERIFrance 2,375. Tony Skeet Hounslow, United Kingdom 2,376. Keiko Mimura okayama, Japan 2,377. Marion Jobe Cleveland, OH 2,378. Caroline Odell Kirkcudbright, United Kingdom 2,379. Grace Thorn Albury, Australia 2,380. Danielle Lavigne , France 2,381. Manuela Schultz Neumünster, Germany 2,382. Peter Cherrington Agia Efimia . Kefalonia, Greece 2,383. Ines Zehnder Badel, Switzerland 2,384. Frank Weimar, Germany Ziesenhenne

Page 86 - Signatures 2,358 - 2,384 Name From Comments 2,385. Rietje Kuiper Witmarsum, Netherlands 2,386. mario toch vlamertinge, Belgium 2,387. Gys Mignot Vasselin, France 2,388. Martina Hecht Berlin, Germany 2,389. arwa ali karbala, Iraq 2,390. Annette Heilbronn, Germany Laakmann-Fneiche 2,391. Meike Schmedt Osnabrück, Germany 2,392. maria lange mühlhausen, Germany 2,393. Hilde Stein Mstein, Germany 2,394. Edith Arnaud Venerque, France 2,395. Nath Dubuy Sannois, France 2,396. Jacqueline Raffalli Biot, France 2,397. zab m b, France 2,398. Sylvia Latscha Asp, Switzerland 2,399. Kristy Jochum Sutherland, NE 2,400. Dominique Lausanne, Tcherdyne Switzerland 2,401. Trina Díaz Alhaurín de la Torre, Ponerle cadenas a un perro es crueldad animal ya basta de González Spain tortura crueldad y maltrato animal hacia los perros 2,402. eleonora bulz bath, United Kingdom 2,403. Antoinette Groot Ankeveen, Netherlands 2,404. Heinz Freimark KIEL, Germany 2,405. Karolina Alf BERLIN, Germany 2,406. maria peteinaraki heraklion city creta, Greece 2,407. anette kussian filderstadt, Germany 2,408. Martina Hunger Pödeldorf, Germany 2,409. Manuela Nestler Erfurt, Germany 2,410. Diana Moore Belton, TX 2,411. Pamela kojis gary, TX 2,412. Elisabeth Unzog St.Marein im Mürztal, Schämt euch ihr Bestien,dass sind unsere Mitgeschöpfe !! Austria 2,413. Kurt Windler , Germany 2,414. Annika Wohlin Ängelholm, Sweden 2,415. Лара Принцева Алматы, Kazakhstan 2,416. Margaret Miranda S. Padre Island, TX

Page 87 - Signatures 2,385 - 2,416 Name From Comments 2,417. Daniela Fiorucci Umbertide, Italy 2,418. Galina Romankiv Riga, Latvia 2,419. Julie Tidball London, United Kingdom 2,420. Pascale BEROUD Pau, France 2,421. Himaddri Mount Lavinia, Sri Halgamuwa Lanka 2,422. Jana Kadlecikova Hopfgarten, Austria 2,423. Lorena Camps Alcala de Henares, Spain 2,424. Teri Wilson KETCHIKAN, AK These poor dogs need too be taken from current owner, who needs to be JAILED!!!! 2,425. petra penssler giessen, Germany 2,426. carole green chelmsford, United Kingdom 2,427. Kay Roberts London, United Kingdom 2,428. Fran Godwin Pensacola, FL 2,429. mesut subasi istanbul, Turkey 2,430. Diyana Dobreva Hamburg, Germany 2,431. Patricia Myers Ancramdale, NY 2,432. Gabriele Havelberg, Germany Schmidtke 2,433. France Boullet le Cannet, France 2,434. Stacey Thompson Deer Park, NY 2,435. Elke Caspari Weilmünster, Germany 2,436. Melanie Ullrich Dinslaken, Germany 2,438. Vec M. Hanau, Germany 2,439. Beata Froncisz Stronie Sl, Poland 2,440. Maryse Leroy Azay le Rideau France, France 2,441. Simone Barner Extertal, Germany 2,442. Els Godu Merendree, Belgium 2,443. Petra Golling, Austria 2,444. Mia Cardenas Fort Worth, TX 2,445. Kathleen Algonquin, IL McLaughlin 2,446. Anne-Louise Uddevalla, Sweden Wilske

Page 88 - Signatures 2,417 - 2,446 Name From Comments 2,447. Martine Van Adorp Bruxelles, Belgium 2,448. Eva Maria Muttenz, Switzerland Genovese 2,449. Maria Mia Glori kranj, Slovenia Giacomelli 2,450. vanessa dylewski grisolles, France 2,451. Ružena Tlmače, Slovakia Vinarcikova 2,452. Atiye Özcümen Berlin, Germany 2,453. Dora Minshull London, United Kingdom 2,454. Снежка Яначкова Попово, Bulgaria 2,455. Carmen Celea Bucharest, Romania 2,456. Paata Kekutia , Georgia 2,457. Dorelle Downes Gillingham, United Kingdom 2,458. Trang Le Sunnyvale, CA 2,459. Cristina Sarmiento valencia, Spain 2,460. Bonnie Welch Clinton Twp., MI THIS MAKES MY BLOOD BOIL!!!!! WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH PEOPLE????? STOP THIS NOW NOW NOW!!! TAKE THAT CHAIN OFF AND WRAP IT AROUND THE NECK OF THE ABUSER!!! ROT IN HELL!!!! 2,461. Duane Ferris St helena bay, South Africa 2,462. Christina Athens, Greece Kazantza 2,463. Tracy Newcombe Gloucester, United Kingdom 2,464. M A London, United Kingdom 2,465. yetta mcneil langley, Canada 2,466. Lorml I'm Cherry log, GA Schwartz 2,467. Denise Mattingly Modesto, CA 2,468. Ryan Hatton Southsea, United Kingdom 2,469. Jamie Hill Garden Grove, CA STOP THIS EVIL - SOMEONE NEEDS TO RESCUE THAT DOG AND TO HELL WITH THE POS WHO IS DOING THIS!!!! 2,470. beate schulze pettstadt, Germany 2,471. Renee Bradshaw Meadville, PA

Page 89 - Signatures 2,447 - 2,471 Name From Comments 2,472. Clare Wilder Bodmin, United Kingdom 2,473. ellen bader Phelan, CA 2,474. Michelle Fiscaro Wilmington, DE How would you like being chain up poor things never arround anybody sign me in 2,475. Maria Kiukkola Espoo, Finland 2,476. Julie Williams Gateshead, United Kingdom 2,477. Teresa Wright Sutton Coldfield, United Kingdom 2,478. Marianne Zito Wilmington, DE 2,479. johann meza chespeake city, MD 2,480. Ravi Kumar G Bangalore, India 2,481. Kristen Gilkeson LANSDOWNE, PA 2,482. Lieselotte Wenzl Vienna, Austria 2,483. Monika Sandrik Deißlingen, Germany 2,484. Alisa Howard Huntsville, AL 2,485. Margarida Odivelas, Portugal Rapoula 2,486. richard eggleston ottumwa, IA 2,487. Celia Robinson Camden, DE 2,488. Holly Esse Fredericton, Canada 2,489. Jennifer Artesi Barnstead, NH 2,490. ken lang Toronto, Canada 2,491. Chloweh Butcher London, United Kingdom 2,492. star light cairo, Egypt 2,493. louna badran , Lebanon 2,494. Agnes Losonczi budapest, Hungary 2,495. Stephanie Turpin Somerset, KY 2,496. Lillian Ingria Hollywood, FL 2,497. William Mobley Fortuna, CA 2,499. Maria Garcia , United Kingdom 2,500. Gail Cope Edinburgh, United Pls help Kingdom 2,501. barbara bierwirth petershagen, Germany

Page 90 - Signatures 2,472 - 2,501 Name From Comments 2,502. Vivien Moorhouse Walsall, West Midlands., United Kingdom 2,503. Jean San Antonio, TX MISERY ! ! ! If a Companion-Animal is not Family, you do Clelland-Morin not deserve a Companion ! ! ! 2,504. Zulma Fernandex R osario, Argentina 2,505. Jennifer Pruitt Sioux Falls, SD 2,506. Melanie Woodfield Coventry, United chambers Kingdom 2,507. Joanne Walstow Barlow, United Kingdom 2,508. Viesha Lewand Hepburn Springs, Australia 2,509. Alessandra São Paulo, Brazil Andraus 2,510. patrick mc cabe ennis, Ireland inhuman and needless. 2,511. Jesse Beck LINCOLN, NE 2,512. Irina Tesluk Rostov-on-Don, Russian Federation 2,513. JAMES HALL SAINT JOHN, Canada 2,514. Jean Lodge Greenville, DE Dogs belong with families, not on chains! 2,515. Caren Singer Palm Springs, CA 2,516. Jelena Hildesheim, Germany Hasic-Philipp 2,517. Sakhone Vista, CA Sengvilay 2,518. Nina Gataulin Toronto, Canada 2,519. Julie Beck York, United Kingdom 2,520. Wendy DeSatnick Germantown, MD 2,521. Sharon Fischer Granville, NY 2,522. Kay Walker Newark, OH 2,523. Ana Millaruelo Tujunga, CA 2,524. Diane Burket Warrenton, VA This is barbaric! Shame on you. 2,525. Emily English Farmingville, NY 2,526. Verena Wolter , Germany 2,527. Lydia Linkous Greenup, KY 2,528. Helena Eldorado do Sul, Krolikowski Brazil 2,529. Roberta Limoli Burlington, MA

Page 91 - Signatures 2,502 - 2,529 Name From Comments 2,530. Margaritha Boston, United Look at the very sad face, I could cry.Stop people from being Downes Kingdom so cruel to dogs or any animal. Please get this dog to a safe home. All they ask for is love. 2,531. athena salvador portland, OR 2,532. Paola Piva Milano, Italy 2,533. Betsy Burmeister Vineyard Haven, MA 2,534. Sylvie Rimlinger Lyon, France 2,535. Tricia Bangert Antelope, OR 2,536. Edna P Accardo Westbury, NY 2,537. teresa llopis quezon city, Philippines 2,538. Angie Murr Bronx, NY 2,539. Julia Watson Montreal, Canada 2,540. Linda Daleh Roseburg, OR 2,541. Shelley Krayer Dover, NJ 2,542. Allan Rubin Phila, PA 2,543. Celine Lambert Courseulles, France 2,544. Donna Griffin Siloam Springs, AR 2,545. hannelore jark boortmeerbeek, Belgium 2,546. Jamuna Llewellyn Forestville, CA 2,547. Margaret Cooke Yucca Valley, CA 2,548. Nicolas Riveros Città Della Pieve, Italy 2,549. Melody Hartley Stroudsburg, PA 2,550. Barb Barnett N.' Charleston, SC 2,551. Michael Sultana Jackson, NJ 2,552. Milada Hronková PRAHA, Czech Republic 2,553. Eric Hittra Tregueux, France 2,554. Francoise Vulpe Toronto, Canada 2,555. Davide Reveglia Lonate pozzolo, Italy 2,556. Iulia Ionela Petcu Oltenita, Romania 2,557. CRISTINA OLIVA BUENOS AIRES, Get Dogs Off 3 foot Logging Chains in Argentina Hawaii!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 2,558. andrea moore Norman, OK 2,559. Cheryl Weaver Chatham, United Kingdom 2,560. Carole ESCONDIDO, CA Take thos chains of these dogs , what is the matter with Divine-Snowney you,?

Page 92 - Signatures 2,530 - 2,560 Name From Comments 2,561. MARIA L Schneeberg, Germany 2,562. T P LOVELADIES, NJ 2,563. Praesens Absens Rotterdam, Netherlands 2,564. khira Deleye tourcoing, France 2,565. Frieda Carlson Fredonia, WI 2,566. Patricia Malherbe Lausanne, Switzerland 2,567. Sammarye Lewis San Jose, CA Cruelty is not culture. This is despicable, abusive treatment of these dogs... 2,568. Roxanne Becker LONGVILLE, MN 2,569. Sharifah Farah Kuala Lumpur, Debah Syed Malaysia Mohammad 2,570. Hiromi Sumi sojya, Japan 2,571. Trudie Jeffrey'so Bay, South Rees-Billson Africa 2,572. gina de. minelli.alf blois, France 2,573. Nicole Pinellas Park, FL I love animals & they need a voice. McClanahan 2,574. Jen Edrington Des Moines, IA 2,575. Tanja Kerler München, Germany 2,576. Cora Healy Livermore, CA 2,577. Cláudia Maria São Paulo, Brazil Gomes 2,578. Suzie Achin Carlsbad, CA 2,579. Ann-Marie Walker Warwick, RI 2,580. Delia Latorre San Sebastian, PR 2,581. Deirdre King Mona Vale, Australia 2,582. Kristine Mangan North Kingstown, RI 2,583. Susan Blackman Toronto, Canada inam against dogs being chained...any length. That's no life for a dog. Why have one? New, better, stricter & enforced laws needed!! 2,584. Cathy Stevens Hammond, LA 2,585. Carmen Palatine, IL Guillemette 2,586. Susan Stalow Waxahachie, TX 2,587. angelique sebban saint-maur, France 2,588. SUZANNE North Bondi, Australia GRUNBERG

Page 93 - Signatures 2,561 - 2,588 Name From Comments 2,589. Linda Bedno Baltimore, MD 2,590. Deb Yang Peoria, IL 2,591. Dirisha Fontana Garfield hts, OH 2,592. Sherry Wilton Kamloops, Canada 2,593. Harry Hill East Cowes, United Kingdom 2,594. colleen wasner olympia, WA 2,595. Melrose Dalisay Parañaque, Philippines 2,596. Margie Miller STATESVILLE, NC 2,597. Roberta Cutcher SAN PABLO, CA 2,598. Mary Greentree Batemans bay, Australia 2,599. Pablo Martinez Tafi Viejo, Argentina 2,600. Hana Smidova Plzen, Czech Republic 2,601. Claire DaBelko Deltona, FL 2,602. Beverly Terre Haute, IN Kriegbaum 2,603. Jacqueline Draszt Spokane, WA 2,604. Sonja Dittman PARK CITY, KY 2,605. Robyn Bonner Melbourne, Australia 2,606. Dian Hardy Sebastopol, CA 2,607. Jorge Enriquez Montevideo, Uruguay 2,608. Chinanan Kuala Lumpur, Khurasee Malaysia 2,609. Whitney Pt. Pleasant, WV This makes me so mad to see pets/animals treated like they Bonecutter are trash they did not ask to be stuck with you so if you dont want them there are so many people out there that would be more than happy to take good care of them 2,610. kerry owens Alpena, MI 2,611. Craig Bunting Louisville, KY 2,612. Christine Dunn Nazeing Waltham Abbey Essex, United Kingdom 2,613. Kay Labo Sydney, Australia 2,614. Cheah Agnes Tanjung Bungah, Malaysia 2,615. Andrea Vitelli casalguidi, Italy 2,616. Nancy Rothe Franklin, AR 2,617. Laura Gonzalez McAllen, TX

Page 94 - Signatures 2,589 - 2,617 Name From Comments 2,618. Danielle Augustino Manassas, VA 2,619. Carole Clifford Houston, TX 2,620. jim Pisani woodlyn, PA this has to stop 2,621. Amrita Biswas Kolkata, India 2,622. Jewell Batway Apache junction, AZ 2,623. Joseph Footer Pinellas Park, FL Totally inhumane. Join the 21st Century. 2,624. Sylvana Jennrich Hamburg, Germany 2,625. Lisa Bagnato Adelaide, Australia 2,626. Jonathan Morales Surrey, Canada 2,627. Jeanne Drazba New Hyde Park, NY 2,628. Evelina Soares Curitiba, Brazil 2,629. Janis Millu Reno, PA 2,630. Marina Núñez Buenos Aires, Argentina 2,631. ana polajnar skofja loka, Slovenia 2,632. Greta Miller Orlando, FL 2,633. peggy gliksman Las Vegas, NV 2,634. jean mcmillan owen sound, Canada Can we just tie the humans up to see how they like it? 2,635. Bianca Beyer LAS VEGAS, NV 2,636. R Beaupre GREEN BAY, WI 2,637. Cindy Mock Everett, PA 2,638. Margit Regensburg, Pernpeintner Germany 2,639. Nilsa Rodriguez Orlando, FL 2,640. Mary Woodard Maricopa, AZ I LOVE ANIMALS & DOGS ARE EXTREMELY IMPORTANT TO ME!!! I DON'T HAVE CLEAN LANGUAGE TOWARDS ANIMAL ABUSERS !!!!!! IN MY OPINION , THEY MUST DIE !!!!! 2,641. Takis Animalrights Serres, Greece 2,642. polly livanidis Toongabbie, Australia Barbaric! 2,643. Tanja Albrecht Oldenburg, Germany 2,644. Sandra Jasprizza Coolangatta, Australia 2,645. Gayle Ives Long Beach, WA 2,646. marianne willemse chiang mai, Thailand 2,647. Susan Bouchard Houston, TX 2,648. Karen Garcia Moxee, WA 2,649. Sushma Sapra Ludhiana, India

Page 95 - Signatures 2,618 - 2,649 Name From Comments 2,650. Chantel Cambridge, Canada Ramnanan 2,651. dave Garcin Rayton, South Africa 2,652. Teresa Pitre Milford, CT 2,653. Lorraine LaBare St.Augustine, FL 2,654. Kathi Dabel Riverton, UT 2,655. Daniele Halle Squamish, Canada 2,656. Embury Russell St aug, FL for real. animal abuse is rampid in hawaii. also thousands of stray cats everywhere, gotta spay and nueter feral cats. 2,657. Carol Drennan Jacksboro, TX These dogs should not have to live this way. If owners can't give them more they need to be found another home 2,658. Leslie Connor Hayward, CA This is cruel!!! 2,659. MJ Jordan Moneta, VA Evil & Subhuman! 2,660. Tamara Palmer Syracuse, NY 2,661. Liliana Ruiz Mtl, Canada 2,662. Anne Olsen Pukalani, HI Duh 2,663. Patti German Roanoke, VA 2,664. Ruchita Shah Nairobi, Kenya 2,665. Taylor Neely Lewiston, ID Save a dogs life 2,666. Angrika Leverette Chicago, IL 2,667. Julie Lutzow Dubuque, IA 2,668. Rakim Merrill Nashville, TN 2,669. Cathy Thompson Santa Rosa, CA How horrible for this poor baby, no dog should ever be chained up like this. How about if we put the owner on a 3 foot chain and see how they like it. It's a cruel way to treat a living breathing being. 2,670. Danielle Mcbride St.augustine, FL 2,671. Lisa Snowden Pineville, LA 2,672. Laurie Stinson Leroy, MI 2,673. Julio Toro San Maple, Canada Martin 2,674. Nancy Campbell Santa Rosa, CA Every animal is important and should be protected 2,675. monty foley warren, PA 2,676. Liselote Angel Lund, Sweden 2,677. Lucia Kirnos Boca Raton, FL 2,678. KIm Barrington Dandridge, TN 2,679. Loree Mezzanatto Indio, CA 2,680. Joice J Caldwell, ID

Page 96 - Signatures 2,650 - 2,680 Name From Comments 2,681. Nancy Duluth, GA This poor Montgomery 2,682. lela antia Gori, Georgia 2,683. Mijanou Sutcliffe West Vancouver, Canada 2,684. Donna Evens Totowa, NJ ALVINO 2,685. Marijana Giner Novi Sad, Serbia 2,686. Jes Selane SHERMAN OAKS, CA 2,687. Johanna MARY Rennes, France 2,688. Kim Harmon PORTLAND, OR 2,689. Laura Castro Las vegas, NV 2,690. christina tychonick squamish, Canada 2,691. Janice Chytra St. Catharines, Canada 2,692. Bianca Marascio Pramaggiore Ve, Italy 2,693. Anasua Roy Tumkur, India 2,694. Ritesh Duggal Jalandhar, India 2,695. Victoria Ingram Holbrook, NY 2,696. diana bryant ambleston, United Kingdom 2,697. Shirley Tan Newbury, CA 2,698. Tracy Bonner Stockport, United Kingdom 2,699. alice chua tavloban city, Philippines 2,700. Ella Kaplan Tel Aviv, Israel 2,701. linda parks Manassas, VA all living beings are important to me . There`s no excuse for any dog to be on such a chain. No one should have a dog if its not treated as part of the family and can live in the house as any family should. 2,702. Kiki Cordalis Langen, Germany 2,703. Doina Knutsen București, Romania 2,704. Francine Sutton, Canada Baribeault 2,705. wendy hill adelaide, Australia 2,706. Roma Fletcher Portsmouth, United Kingdom 2,707. Sally Starrett Dallas, TX

Page 97 - Signatures 2,681 - 2,707 Name From Comments 2,708. Annette Dillon Sarnia, Canada 2,709. Berdine Nel Faerie Glen, South Its cruel! Why have a dog if he cant live comfortably?? You Africa are more civilized than allowing that arent you?? 2,710. Crystal Marin Albuquerque, NM 2,711. Stephanie Kirkland, WA Christman 2,712. Caroline Toowoomba, Australia Peacefairy 2,713. John Smith ANN ARBOR, MI 2,714. Sandra Kiser Maiden, NC 2,715. Margret Wien, Austria Weissenbacher 2,716. Lance and Jenny MADISON, WI Peterson 2,717. Sreyoshi Bagchi Kolkata, India The dogs deserve better life 2,718. Laura Vazquez Venado Tuerto, Argentina 2,719. Nicolette Stan București, Romania 2,720. Eloise Engman Haiku, HI 2,721. Panos Messiou London, United Kingdom 2,722. silvia DE FILIPPIS ROMA, Italy 2,723. Peter Ballantyne Glasgow, United Kingdom 2,724. Arianne Bär Wolfhalden, Switzerland 2,725. Erica Stofberg Wellington, South Africa 2,726. Betsy Dooner Albuquerque, NM Because needless cruelty is bad for every one. Because if we don't stand up to it society will fail in retaining humanity 2,727. Connie Smith Fort Wayne, IN 2,728. Nicole Roussou Piraeus, Greece 2,729. Tam Anderson Perth, United Kingdom 2,730. marianne. Diday del vidre, France 2,731. Viviana Guadagno Roma, Italy 2,732. Sigrid Carter LACEY, WA 2,733. Nicole Hennig Herzogenrath, Germany

Page 98 - Signatures 2,708 - 2,733 Name From Comments 2,734. Татьяна Гришина Одинцово, Russian Federation 2,735. Liette Pedraza , NY 2,736. Archit Gupta Uttar Pradesh, India 2,737. Andrea Wien, Austria Löwenstern 2,738. Rita Wilde Polenz, Germany 2,739. Yelena San Francisco, CA Pecherskaya 2,740. Frances Johnson Lake Munmorah, Australia 2,741. Frédéric Nice, France Villepontoux 2,742. chandni majumdar kolkata, India 2,743. annie van keer opwijk, Belgium 2,744. Sherry Wilkins San Clemente, CA 2,745. Petronela Petrea Santa Marinella, Italy 2,746. Sandra Farrell Pittsford, NY 2,747. silvia van bommel moorsel, Belgium 2,748. michele mooney saskatoon, Canada 2,749. Pam Brandon Godley, TX 2,750. agnes trivier mezeriat, France 2,751. Andy Benik El Paso, TX 2,752. sanya gnc krsk, Russian Federation 2,753. Yvette Trolle Lemvig, Denmark Omarsson 2,754. Julia Ynina Moscow, Russian Federation 2,755. Eva Noren Uppsala, Sweden 2,756. Roslyn Fielding Goolwa, Australia Deranged behaviour by so called humans 2,757. Liana Roginsky Paris, France 2,758. gertrud roth erlensee, Germany der mensch ist doch die grösste bestie auf erden 2,759. Dawn Avila Aliso viejo, CA 2,760. Fran Lewis Evesham, United How can these 'people' put dogs through this hell? Kingdom 2,761. Magd Tzen Peraia, Greece 2,762. Marites Reimann Oslo, Norway 2,763. ludmila jancikova Český Těšín, Czech Republic

Page 99 - Signatures 2,734 - 2,763 Name From Comments 2,764. Paul Mannings Cardiff, United Kingdom 2,765. Leigh Wells JOHANNESBURG, South Africa 2,766. Isabel Basto Estoril, Portugal 2,767. cornelia springer wien, Austria 2,768. Leanne Green Melbourne, Australia 2,769. sandra wight durban, South Africa 2,770. jocelyne di franco grenoble, France 2,771. Lucie Klimová Prerov, Czech Republic 2,772. Camelia Maria Iasi, Romania Dobirceanu 2,773. Celeste Pomona, Australia What is wrong with people? Instead of improving mentally as Manwaring years go by it seems humans are dumbing down. 2,774. Rahul M Hyderabad, India 2,775. sandrine Pollet le cannet, France 2,776. Eva Ferret Lundamo, Norway Animals are living beings, not objects! Mehlum 2,777. cheryl bush darvel, United ....of all places....the beautiful, (ugly), island. Kingdom 2,778. M Kittermaster Langport, United Kingdom 2,779. Shargila zafryar ramat gan, Israel this is currelty, this is animal abuse. 2,780. Pamela Vigors Jimena de la Frontera, Spain 2,781. Sharon Haynes Isle of wight, United Kingdom 2,782. Louis Kaiser Bonn, Germany 2,783. Jennifer Don Katoomba, Australia This is too cruel, nothing justifies such torture to mans best friend. What have we become to abuse these loyal, intelligent ,affectionate creatures in such a way. Shame on the human animal, we are supposed to be the ones with a soul and a conscience, what an ugly joke we are. 2,784. Melina A Melbourne, Australia 2,785. Antonella Bini Milano, Italy 2,786. Pamela Anderson Aiea, HI 2,787. petra daskou lkjl.lm, United Kingdom 2,788. Rosemaria Siwek Seaton, United Kingdom

Page 100 - Signatures 2,764 - 2,788 Name From Comments 2,789. Katrien Pruydt Wetteren, Belgium 2,790. John Zolis Hillcrest, Canada 2,791. Mário Kubiš Banská Bystrica, Slovakia 2,792. Markus Bosshard Oetwil a. d. Limmat, Switzerland 2,793. Czapla Edyta Gravesend, United Kingdom 2,794. Ida Skjerden Saltnes, Norway 2,795. Vita Brunetti Maasmechelen, Belgium 2,796. Brenda Hiton Liverpool, United Kingdom 2,797. Heike Liermann Krauschwitz, Germany 2,798. Cindi Perez Santa clara, CA 2,799. Maureen Hughes Oxfordshire, United This is outrageous, free these poor dogs. Any tethered Kingdom animal will show vicious tendencies. 🐕🐶 2,800. Bianka Hillmer Dülmen, Germany 2,801. Sue Marston Ventura, CA Outrageous and sickening. Please end this NOW 2,802. suzanne o'meara cape town, South Africa 2,803. Elizabeth Coleman Ashford Kent, United Kingdom 2,804. Christy Ragsdale Boaz, AL 2,805. Anna Chyrek Wieliczka, Poland 2,806. Sarah Dannecker Gomaringen, Germany 2,807. Claudia Künzing, Germany Schadenfroh 2,809. Selena Wren Plymouth, United Kingdom 2,810. Friederike Küster Friedrichsdorf, Germany 2,811. Sue Parry Sheerness, United Kingdom 2,812. Eva Mattsson Skanör, Sweden 2,813. Martina Aiglstorfer Oberding, Germany 2,814. Amy Esin Langenau, Germany 2,815. keith Hall Sheffield, United Kingdom

Page 101 - Signatures 2,789 - 2,815 Name From Comments 2,816. Liane Pree Wien, Austria 2,817. Brigitte Corthay Versoix, Switzerland 2,818. Salvatore Alcamo, Italy Giampino 2,819. Melissa Lombardi Montreal, Canada 2,820. Ana Lopes Sesimbra, Portugal 2,821. Andrew Gray Kaohsiung, 2,822. Marie Sixtova Suchdol nad Luznici, Czech Republic 2,823. Jane Fong Hamilton, Canada This is so wrong, and cruel. Help them please!?!?! 2,824. Irene Makris San Ysidro, CA This practice is barbaric and is a th 2,825. Laura Smith Vancouver, Canada 2,826. Yvette Camps Perth, Australia 2,827. Brenda Couvee Mount Maunganui, New Zealand 2,828. Pamela Anderson Scotland, United Kingdom 2,829. Helga Ferraz Lisboa, Portugal 2,830. Debora Marciello Bronschhofen, Switzerland 2,831. Neil Ryding Warrington, United Kingdom 2,832. rita budimir hamburg, Germany 2,833. Agustina Gobbi Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires, Argentina 2,834. Susan Masoner Braunfels, TX This has got to end, 2,835. Bigayon Lee Seoul, Korea, Republic Of 2,836. rita ioannou lincs, United Kingdom 2,837. Heike Schmelzer Elmshorn, Germany 2,838. Anny Seavey Southwest Harbor, ME 2,839. Bruno Catalano Napoli, Italy 2,840. Rosa E Grand Island, NE Hernandez 2,841. Chermaine Torquay, United Aylward Kingdom 2,842. Vickie Sanders Salem, VA

Page 102 - Signatures 2,816 - 2,842 Name From Comments 2,843. Nadezda Halova Potstejn, Czech Republic 2,844. Melanie Kongehl Bahrdorf, Germany 2,845. Char Oneal Lynwood, CA 2,846. yancette Portland, OR Halverson 2,847. Cocki Beverloo Schiedam, No comment. Netherlands 2,848. Christine Singh München, Germany 2,849. Claudia Werner Sinzig, Germany 2,850. Japhette Bender Elim, Netherlands 2,851. Simona Eastlake Essex, United Kingdom 2,852. Eva Vytisková jihlava, Czech Republic 2,853. nina virtanen nastola, Finland 2,854. Hana Cibulkobá Karlštejn, Czech Republic 2,855. Pascal Leyne PARIS, France 2,856. Solange Robin Blausasc, France 2,857. Theresa F London, United Kingdom 2,858. Tracy Brace Plymouth, United Kingdom 2,859. Susanne Köhler Gernsheim, Germany 2,860. linelle smith toms river, NJ 2,861. Ashley Woolsey Bonham, TX 2,862. Dwayne Robbie New Haven, Canada 2,863. Carole Lowney Dighton, MA 2,864. Zuzana Belluova Čelákovice, Czech Republic 2,865. Karin Lindberg Göteborg, Sweden 2,866. Antony Sharp Aylesbury, United Kingdom 2,867. luba landeka Pancevo, Serbia 2,868. sabine Nartey Berlin, Germany 2,869. Susan Dixon Sunderland, United Kingdom 2,870. SOFIA Athens, Greece KALLIOLIA

Page 103 - Signatures 2,843 - 2,870 Name From Comments 2,871. cinzia giunta Roma, Italy 2,872. Natalie Miceli Bruxelles, Belgium 2,873. Ryan Spier Caterham, United Kingdom 2,874. Marleen Neus Zele, Belgium 2,875. annemie vervoort hagfors, Sweden 2,876. Nicola Wellbelove Littlehampton West Sussex, United Kingdom 2,877. Catherine Barrow Faversham, United Kingdom 2,878. Doris El Cajon, CA Hawaii, DO THE RIGHT THING!!! RESPECT and LOVE Rivas-Brekke your animals...or maybe we will have to BOYCOTT HAWAII!!! 2,879. Baria Ashraf Aligarh, India 2,880. irene kucyk bangor, Australia 2,881. Liesel Howe Uppingham, United Kingdom 2,882. Clare Eagles Bedford, United Awful, barbaric Kingdom 2,883. Kate Silverek Stockholm, Sweden 2,884. TERRI BAIRD Marysville, WA NO DOG SHOULD EVER BE CHAINED OR ABUSED BY A HUMAN..OR EATEN, BOILED OR BURNED ALIVEAND NEVER SHOULD A ANIMAL BE SKINNED ALIVE FOR ITS FUR OR ANY OTHER REASON...HUGE FINES AND HARSH VERY HARSH PUNISHMENTS SHOULD BE PUT IN PLACE AND ENFORCED UPON WHOEVER INTENTIONALLY HARMS AN ANIMAL 2,885. Kerryanne Shaw Glasgow, United Kingdom 2,886. Gladys soto camden, NJ 2,887. Olivia Vande Gothenburg, Sweden 2,888. Irina Korneva г.Москва, Russian МУчить так живое и устраиватьему тюрьму с адом Federation Пытки!! ВСЁ ВЕРНЁТСЯ!! 2,889. Elsie Canary Islands, Spain Clinton-Leslie 2,890. Margrit Anderegg Oberbipp, Switzerland 2,891. Helga Franken Den Haag, Netherlands 2,892. Vickie Winans Phoenix, AZ 2,893. Alisin Goddard Colo, Australia 2,894. Vera Milcic Bela Crkva, Serbia

Page 104 - Signatures 2,871 - 2,894 Name From Comments 2,895. Sybille Gulde Geislingen, Germany Keine Kettenhaltung der Hunde mehr. Denn auch diese Hunde haben das Recht auf Leben ohne Qual und gar Tod. Harte Tierschutzgesetze mit hohen Gefaengnisstrafen und hohen Geldstrafen, fuer die Tierquaeler, Tiermoerder, Tiermissbrauch ,Tierqual. Der auch diese Hunde sind Lebewesen mit Gefuehlen und einer Seele so wie wir Menschen auch. Sie sind keine Waren oder Gegenstaende zum Quaelen Foltern und Toeten 2,896. Jasmin Castens Hamburg, Germany 2,897. Beate Schubert Grevenbroich, Germany 2,898. Luzia Becker Rheinstetten, Germany 2,899. Terrie Phillips BREMOND, TX 2,900. Nicole Martin Koblenz, Germany 2,901. Lucie Tocekova Babice, Czech Republic 2,902. Ema Henick Skopje, Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic Of 2,903. liron solomon holon, Israel 2,904. Mirella Schuller Mondercange, Luxembourg 2,905. Sylvia Hemme KLAZIENAVEEN, Netherlands 2,906. Wisnu Cahyo Jakarta, Indonesia Handono 2,907. Jolanda Soethaert Vlissingen, Netherlands 2,908. Maria Croft Leeds, United Kingdom 2,909. Paul Critser Folkston, GA Sick even by ga. standards 2,910. marija rumberger siebnen, Switzerland 2,911. Christine Weckolsheim, France Spinnhirny 2,912. I. Flierman Deventer, Netherlands 2,913. nathalie vander blond, France bauwede 2,914. Candace Sunset, TX Alexander 2,915. Denise Serbest Bremen, Germany 2,916. Ada Macz Krefeld, Germany

Page 105 - Signatures 2,895 - 2,916 Name From Comments 2,917. lynn fraser waihi, New Zealand 2,918. Domi Kaiowa Bxl, Belgium 2,919. nessa miller irvine, KY hawaii is crap, paradise no more, poor dogs! please sign! 2,920. Ryan Fraser London, United Kingdom 2,921. Olga Vershkova Moscow, Russian Federation 2,922. Mars Greenwood Portland, OR Anyone who doesn't see this is cruel,abusive and unhealthy has a lack of compassion, common sense and no mental capacity to know right from wrong~! 2,923. zuzana tušova doubek, Czech Republic 2,924. Simone Bergmann Münster, Germany 2,925. Antonella Nielsen Copenhagen, Denmark 2,926. Christina BERG Ochtrup, Germany 2,927. Michele Trapasso Vauxrezis, France 2,928. Anne Bertrand Bruxelles, Belgium 2,929. Anita Dworacek Obergänserndorf, Austria 2,930. Susanne München, Germany Mühlhaus 2,931. Amanda Heywood Bury, United Kingdom 2,932. catherine hogg donaghadee, United Kingdom 2,933. Anne Persoon Leiden, Netherlands 2,934. olga arseneva bishkek, Kyrgyzstan 2,935. Sylvie grodard dijon, France 2,936. Kimberly mohar GRANDVIEW, WA 2,937. Guilda Azar tabet Mtayleb, Lebanon 2,938. Robin Snyder Tucson, AZ 2,939. Daisy Cooke London, United Kingdom 2,940. Bonnie LaRosa Melville, NY 2,941. liisa Hansen copenhagen, Denmark 2,942. Annette Grochau , Germany 2,943. Mireille Conzen Eschweiler, Germany 2,944. Malcolm Davey Melbourne, Australia

Page 106 - Signatures 2,917 - 2,944 Name From Comments 2,945. Gary Wildman Buckie, United Kingdom 2,946. Helena Hjo, Sweden Gustafsson 2,947. Susana Falconi Miami, FL 2,948. Susan Bortolussi Westfield, MA Animal cruelty 2,949. Jacqueline bronx, NY Fontanez 2,950. Anja Rudat Langen, Germany 2,951. ahona poddar kolkata, India 2,952. liliya crane chattanooga, TN 2,953. Sinje Seesen, Germany Fromme-Sachs 2,954. Samar Grandjean Uettligen, Switzerland 2,955. Park Jung Hyun Incheon, Korea, Republic Of 2,956. corina guri san cesareo, Italy 2,957. Maria Neumann Leimbach, Germany 2,958. Birgit Dierkes Grevenbroich, Germany 2,959. Brigitte Grimm Esssenbach, Germany 2,960. Yvette Santamaria Miami, FL 2,961. Patricia Chia Sabah, Malaysia 2,962. Edith Michels Teltow, Germany Einfach unmöglich möchten die besitzer 3m angekettet werden? 2,963. Katia Remondini toronto, Canada 2,964. Natalie Walther Ratzeburg, Germany 2,965. Ruth Beier Kamp-Lintfort, Germany 2,966. Rainer Deutrich salzgitter-bad, Germany 2,967. Amanda Tyler Norwich, United Kingdom 2,968. Anja Henning Syke, Germany 2,969. Katarina Durjak Bratislava, Slovakia 2,970. Marci Tressel Hilton Head Island, SC 2,971. Pam Kruger Hutchinson, KS 2,972. Diane Hall Redcrest, CA

Page 107 - Signatures 2,945 - 2,972 Name From Comments 2,973. Kim Yesildag Velbert, Germany 2,974. Steven Flip Glen cove, NY 2,975. Delores Joiner Salem, VA 2,976. Marion Schwarz Ulm, Germany 2,977. Beatrix Laad Wörgl, Austria Why????😢😢 2,978. tracy Molyneux yeovil, United Kingdom 2,979. Taner Toprak Düsseldorf, Germany 2,980. guilherme satto olimpia sp, Brazil 2,981. Sarah Maerz Berlin, Germany 2,982. Melanie Schütte Südbrookmerland, Germany 2,983. Cheryl Maloney franklin park, NJ this is a form of torture!!!!!!! and neglect how is this legal it needs to be addressed and these animals need to go to rescue now!!!!!!!!! 2,984. Jürgen Kernbach Berlin, Germany 2,985. Maria del Pilar Cm Madrid, Spain 2,986. Steffen Schulz Strausberg, Germany 2,987. Claudia Haller Innsbruck, Austria 2,988. Janelle Kennedy Overland Park, KS 2,989. Petet Batist Touille, France 2,990. Christelle Lafleur Nouméa, New Caledonia 2,991. Brigitte Forrer Winterthur, Switzerland 2,992. Stephanie Bauer Offenbach, Germany 2,993. Patricia Forlini Fontenay sous bois, France 2,994. Charles Cocchiaro Portsmouh, NH 2,995. Erdal Caliskan Frankfurt, Germany 2,996. Gitta Waterstraat Hamburg, Germany 2,997. Daina Moore Cambridge, United Kingdom 2,998. Julie Port Slough, United Kingdom 2,999. Viera Homolkova Kvetoslavov, Slovakia 3,000. Sabine Lange Hellenthal, Germany 3,001. Ines Schroeter Radeberg, Germany 3,002. Susan Kyle Manchester, United Kingdom

Page 108 - Signatures 2,973 - 3,002 Name From Comments 3,003. Sasa Loncar Novi Sad, Serbia 3,004. sandra urnäsch, Switzerland sturzenegger 3,005. Maria Paris ., Sweden 3,006. Erika Hudecek Wien, Austria 3,007. Eileen Thompson Rumford, RI These are living creatures. They deserve to have a life. What you are doing to them is not a life; it is torture! Have a heart!!! 3,008. Herta Graf Leoben, Austria 3,009. Marianne Ziller Salzburg, Austria Cruelty People in Hawaii 3,010. Helene Cremlingen, Germany Mårtensson 3,011. simone cavasse angouleme, France 3,012. Andrea Leschner Oberhausen, Germany 3,013. Paddy Sexton Cape Town, South Africa 3,014. Pamela Burridge New Cumberland, PA If you have to put a dog on a chain, you dont need a dog. 3,015. Elisabeth Avesta, Sweden Björklund 3,016. Elisabet Dale Stockholm, Sweden 3,017. ANN FINDLAY PLYMOUTH, United Kingdom 3,018. Lisa Caudill Lynch, KY 3,019. Jackeline Lozano Henderson, NV 3,020. Rahel Wächter Winterthur, Switzerland 3,021. Bep de Geus Dordrecht, Netherlands 3,022. Shirley Yong Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia 3,023. brigitte schober rosengarten, Germany 3,024. Elena Saroseka Rehovot, Israel 3,025. Lucia Cicchella Campobasso, Italy 3,026. Marie W. Hille, Germany 3,027. Heather Slater Toronto, Canada 3,028. Ana Pablo marilao, Philippines 3,029. Carolyn Birkbeck Preston, CT 3,030. Barbara Nawara Toronto, Canada THE NEXT PRIMITIVES IDIOTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!MOST BE STOP!!!!!!!!!!!

Page 109 - Signatures 3,003 - 3,030 Name From Comments 3,031. Conny Fidyka Albertshofen, Germany 3,032. rita schmidt Berlin, Germany 3,033. Carolin Wagner Madrid, Spain 3,034. rhenada tierling radway, Canada 3,035. noelia Barbera , Spain madrid 3,036. Becky Rowbottom Romford, United Kingdom 3,037. Nicole Geme7n Köln germany, Das ist nicht tiergerecht ; hoffe das schnell ein anderes Germany Gesetz herraus kommt.. 3,038. Monica Gubser Madulain, Switzerland 3,039. Maya Buchholz Bremerhaven, Germany 3,040. Torsten Meyer Hamburg, Germany 3,041. Monika Jessner Salzburg, Austria 3,042. Mena Viana Somerset, United Kingdom 3,043. Jose Falconi Gouy-Les-Pieton, Belgium 3,044. Tina Jungnitz Leisnig, Germany 3,045. Donna Mykyte RADWAY, Canada 3,046. Dani Strand WLB, NJ 3,047. Petra Klausing Bochum, Germany 3,048. Judy Dierks Arcadia, Australia 3,049. Marina Delaney Ferndown, United Kingdom 3,050. Birgit Bichler Feldkirch, Austria 3,051. Henriette Basel, Switzerland Bula-CdK 3,052. Jasmin Porschen München, Germany 3,053. Liane Poh Köthen, Germany 3,054. Darlene DRIVER LITTLE Elm, TX NO animal should be treated inhumanly 3,055. Sarah Storm Macclesfield, United Kingdom 3,056. jesus sanchez algeciras, Spain 3,057. Leanne Keane Victoria, Australia 3,058. Beppie Jeurissen Arnhem, Netherlands 3,059. Nadsanan Glen Carbon, IL Watcharakan

Page 110 - Signatures 3,031 - 3,059 Name From Comments 3,060. Diana Becker Hessen, Germany 3,061. Jennifer Adair Surprise, AZ 3,062. Kathy Jones BELLINGHAM, MA 3,063. Liss-Kari Arfvelin Västervik, Sweden 3,064. francoise chartres de bretagne, dartigues France 3,065. Brigitte Straub Labod, Hungary 3,066. Conny Pelz , Germany 3,067. Nicole Schmid We, Switzerland 3,068. aimée henriquez sta cruz, Aruba, Aruba 3,069. Reina Ilona , Germany Vildebrand 3,070. Elizabeth Nugen Friendship, WI 3,071. Sin Wolf Darmstadt, Germany 3,072. Janine Brown Revesby, Australia 3,073. Deborah Secane, PA McConnell-Yon 3,074. Cheryl Pepper Eltham, Australia 3,075. Laura kimeu nairobi, Kenya 3,076. Eva Maria Laasch Berlin, Germany 3,077. Paulina Martinez Quito, 3,078. Margrit Stössel Stein, Switzerland 3,079. Debz Jones Cambridge, United Kingdom 3,080. Cindy Araya Miami, FL Assholes?! 3,081. Darlene Dynega Bayonne, NJ 3,082. Sofia Stamou Athens, Greece 3,083. carola kabbe rodgau, Germany 3,084. Pavlína chomutov, Czech Kašubjaková Republic 3,085. Henna Shingh Dubai, United Arab Emirates 3,086. Sarah Buck Gothenburg, Sweden 3,087. Daniela Eckart Braunschweig, Germany 3,088. Susan Sharp Newport News, VA 3,089. Nadine-Danielle Hindelbank, Frech Switzerland

Page 111 - Signatures 3,060 - 3,089 Name From Comments 3,090. Gerard elshoff Rotterdam, Netherlands 3,091. Chantal Eldridge Austin, TX 3,092. Niina Anttinen Espoo, Finland 3,093. Alexis Azcárate Tezoyuca, Mexico 3,094. Rose Kicksee Guelph, Canada 3,095. Gisela von Wolff Frankfurt am Main, Germany 3,096. Nikita Heredia Milton Keynes, United Kingdom 3,097. Elsa Erding, Germany Schuhböck-Zaccaria 3,098. Catherine Concarneau, France 🌱 Feunteun 3,099. Andrea Schreyer Ludwigshafen, Legt die dreckige Menschheit an die Kette!!!Lasst die Tiere Germany frei😬😬😬👎👎👎😈😈😈 3,100. Monica Braberry Singapore, Singapore 3,101. lori burwell london, Canada Kindness and love is the answet and a 3 foot chain is anything but kind please change this law! 3,102. Robert Ducharme Bedford, Canada 3,103. Stefanie Mühltal, Germany Glueck-Kessler 3,104. l Williams Cornwell, United Kingdom 3,105. Ken Kurtz PHOENIX, AZ 3,106. Charlotte Alpen Hamburg, Germany 3,107. Stephanie Houston, TX Williams 3,108. Steffi Rink Stralsund, Germany 3,109. Marit Wick Holbæk, Denmark 3,110. joy conner Fitzgerald, GA 3,111. stephan wilhelm frankfurt, Germany 3,112. Petra Jozefowski Oberhausen, Germany 3,113. GRACE sioux falls, SD ANGELES 3,114. Cornelia Abedini Gundelfingen, Germany 3,115. Ann Bult Huron, SD 3,116. Allan Loney Brainerd, MN

Page 112 - Signatures 3,090 - 3,116 Name From Comments 3,117. Valentina Spirova Probistip, Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic Of 3,118. Sabine Rudolph Rödental, Germany 3,119. Elke Kloos Staig, Germany 3,120. jenni hirdes werther, Germany 3,121. Kim Petersen Houston, TX Hawaii is known for its beauty....how awful to tarnish it eith animal cruelty. 3,122. Romy Fischer Ludwigsburg, Germany 3,123. Daniela De Serio Bari, Italy 3,124. Antonietta Cliffside Park, NJ 3,125. Yorka ines Moen Trondheim, Norway 3,126. Yvette Eberhardt Delray, FL 3,127. Livia Hofer Uttendorf, Austria 3,128. susa borchers jenfeld, Germany 3,129. lucile lammers venon, France 3,130. Fiona Newton Herne Bay, United This cruelty has GOT to STOP!!!! Kingdom 3,131. Me Smit Zaandijk, Netherlands 3,132. Sandra Gallagher Wuppertal, Germany 3,133. Martina Tocek Prague, Czech Republic 3,134. Barbara Franchs CO SPGS, CO 3,135. Ruth Huyler Norton, MA 3,136. Kathleen Tuchen Osnabrück, Germany 3,137. Daniella Barbir Zagreb, Croatia 3,138. solovkina olga ashdod, Israel 3,139. maria cn veronika moscow, Russian Federation 3,140. Re tromp wieringerwerf, Netherlands 3,141. Kerstin Young Spanaway, WA 3,142. Justyna Lozowski Berlin, Germany 3,143. Christine Van lier Vilvoorde, Belgium 3,144. Susanne Barry Celle, Germany 3,145. julia adwar muttontown, NY 3,146. chako t kohsaka Hong Kong, Hong Kong

Page 113 - Signatures 3,117 - 3,146 Name From Comments 3,147. Jeanne MILLER MONTBELIARD, France 3,148. Nora Müller Elmshorn, Germany 3,149. Martin Bohli Mels, Switzerland 3,150. Harish Jadav Toronto, Canada 3,151. Stela Bankova Pernik, Bulgaria 3,152. Rhiannon Spragg Leyland, United Kingdom 3,153. jacqueline Munoz CHICAGO, IL 3,154. Francine Hébert Salaberry-de-Valleyfield,Interdisez l'enchaînement des chiens avec des chaînes de 3 Canada pieds à Hawaï. 3,155. Isabel Meyerhans Arcos de la Frontera, Never chain dogs, chain their owners. Spain 3,156. bruna longinotti Bresso, Italy 3,157. Kim Sturm Düsseldorf, Germany 3,158. Carina Barthel Elversberg, Germany 3,159. Nadine Jestram Bad oeynhausen, Germany 3,160. Amy Alexander WOODSTOCK, GA 3,161. Isabella Übersee, Germany Bachhammer 3,162. Tamara Althoff Monguzzo, Italy 3,163. Andrea Heider Völpke, Germany 3,164. jeanne lussier centralfalls, RI 3,165. Michelle Bernal Wilmington, IL Sentient beings deserve mutual respect and love....this is not love. This is barbaric. Please save these dogs. 3,166. Sara Sturz Bisbee, AZ 3,167. Claudette Drieborg, Netherlands Beezemer 3,168. Elsbeth Anna K. Braunschweig, Friedrich Germany 3,169. Stefi Mouriki Corfu, Greece 3,170. Alexander Winkler Güssing, Austria 3,171. Nancy Raymond BUFFALO, NY This is blatant animal cruelty and NO state should allow these animals to be chained at all. Hawaii is in the United States and need to step up and stop treating these dogs like trash. We are the voice for the voiceless and will NEVER stop. 3,172. Bettina Egli Appenzell, It's great unjustice. Switzerland 3,173. roni halpert ramat gan, Israel

Page 114 - Signatures 3,147 - 3,173 Name From Comments 3,174. Leslie Pfost Tacoma, WA 3,175. Mona Wessel Waterloo, Canada 3,176. ΣΟΦΙΑ ΣΠΑΝΟΥ ΚΕΡΚΥΡΑ, Greece 3,177. Carmen Hoffmann Leipzig, Germany 3,178. Christina Gomez revere, MA 3,179. DEBRA KOURTZ Freehold, NJ 3,180. Ria Putter Pretoria, South Africa 3,181. Jutta Wienke Emsdetten, Germany 3,182. Melinda Wise Glendale, AZ 3,183. Patrizia Rega Lucens, Switzerland 3,184. Lydia Tutus Bad Vilbel, Germany 3,185. Smadar Shamay Rishon le zion, Israel 3,186. Patricia Garley Burlington, Canada Damn horrific dont get a dog if it has to be chained outside PEOPLE who do this should be banned from owning a pet 3,187. Tina Tognolli Bad soden, Germany 3,188. N Skerry Gold coast, Australia 3,189. Sheryl Moran Shropshire UK, United Kingdom 3,190. Dominik Dippel Bielefeld, Germany 3,191. Denise Bennett London, United Kingdom 3,192. Juliet Treharne Pontyclun, United Why have a dog if you're going to chain it up outside?Dogs Kingdom are not commodities they are living breathing thinking beings!!! 3,193. hariana Días Bogotá, Colombia 3,194. Louisa Tücks Jucken, Germany 3,195. Brooke Bellino phoenix, AZ 3,196. Sandra Will Augsburg, Germany 3,197. Elisabeth Casatta Lana, Italy 3,198. Chairina Caesiria Curup, Indonesia 3,199. Patrice Davis Sequim, WA 3,200. Lynn Krawiecki Keene, NH 3,201. Teresa kos Rockingham, NC 3,202. Amelia Ojeda Düsseldorf, Germany 3,203. Isabel Santos Münster, Germany 3,204. gabriella krebs villeneuve-loubet, France 3,205. Desiree Zijlstra Den Haag, Netherlands

Page 115 - Signatures 3,174 - 3,205 Name From Comments 3,206. Marianne Englund Helsingborg, Sweden 3,207. Ilona Großostheim, Schubert-Weiler Germany 3,208. Lorraine Hanson Barnoldswick, United Kingdom 3,209. Marie robillard longwy, France 3,210. Pilz Graz, Austria 3,211. david de verny Winchelsea, United Kingdom 3,212. Ilonka Ballas Biblis, Germany 3,213. M. Poburski Bramsche, Germany 3,214. Lynn Jennings Vanderbilt, MI This is barbaric, evil, cruel and heartless. This is animal abuse. How could you allow this? Many compassionate states, have outlawed tethering, but you even allow 3 foot long logging chains. This is beyond cruel. Shame on you. 3,215. Astrid Schuster Bremen, Germany 3,216. Frank Lomas Manchester, United Kingdom 3,217. Sandra Gorsler Braunschweig, Germany 3,218. carmen maaß lauenburg, Germany 3,219. Svitlana Osinska ВИННИЦА, Ukraine 3,220. elena elena kiev, Ukraine 3,221. Catherine Stowmarket, United Kennard Kingdom 3,222. Maritta Schweigert Anklam, Germany 3,223. annah jetha London, United Kingdom 3,224. Anne Thane Haarby, Denmark PLEASE HELP THIS HEARTBREAKING MATTER Nielsen NOW🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼 PLEASE BAN CHAINED DOGS FOREVER🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼 3,225. Mary Barbosa Groved, TX 3,226. Linda Myburgh Cape Town, South Africa 3,227. John Dixon Manchester, United Kingdom 3,228. Sydney Friedman Machesney Park, IL 3,229. Herbert Kammann Kerkrade, Netherlands 3,230. Volinets Inna Andrushivka, Ukraine 3,231. Edwina Loftlin Washington, DC

Page 116 - Signatures 3,206 - 3,231 Name From Comments 3,232. Francesco Osnabrück, Germany Pascariello 3,233. Christine PASSY, France SOUDAN 3,234. Kathy Robinson South Riding, VA 3,235. Dagmar Bräuer Beuren, Germany 3,236. Nina Riechers Lauf, Germany 3,237. erika reico swartz creek, MI 3,238. Helena Cross Kings Langley, United Kingdom 3,239. Slavica Matic Beograd, Serbia 3,240. Magdalena Leja Sennfeld, Germany 3,241. Susan Walsh SMBA, Italy 3,242. Anna Mai Van Bytom, Poland 3,243. Jörg Starsberg Rantrum, Germany 3,244. Soni Awillmot Newbury, United Kingdom 3,245. Sandra Frei 7077, Switzerland 3,246. ARLIN KRAS Ivanec, Croatia 3,247. Bianca Lübeck, Germany Brüggemeier 3,248. Nevriye Anger Düsseldorf, Germany 3,249. Konstanzia Bohn Wien, Austria 3,250. Margitta Weller Dresden, Germany 3,251. Rachel Bose Liverpool, United Kingdom 3,252. Janet Martinez Baytown, TX 3,253. Rita Knudsen Brøndby, Denmark 3,254. Christiane Buße Düren, Germany 3,255. Glenda & Gilbert Burlingame, CA Fontana 3,256. Joëlle Rambert St Laurent du Var, France 3,257. rachel frisby no, United Kingdom 3,258. Charles Anderson Ringgold, VA jr 3,259. Hannelore Auer Kapfenberg, Austria Respekt für Tiere, sie sind Lebewesen wie wir!! 3,260. Isabell Lindner Hannover, Germany 3,261. Doni Stith Benton, AR

Page 117 - Signatures 3,232 - 3,261 Name From Comments 3,262. Roswitha Weser Büdingen/Michelau, Germany 3,263. sandra h 1100, Austria 3,264. Ellen Ewers Sønderborg, Denmark 3,265. Karen Pope Palm Springs, CA 3,266. Iolanda Iacobescu București, Romania 3,267. Susan Dearing Ceredigion, United Kingdom 3,268. LouAnn Cristillo Victor, NY 3,269. Darja Kadenšek Podplat, Slovenia 3,270. Khan Corina T, Romania 3,271. Diana Stout Portland, OR 3,272. Annette Landré Wesseling, Germany 3,273. elefteria alexiou giannitsa, Greece 3,274. Ines Urban Trostberg, Germany 3,275. Diana Springett El Cajon, CA 3,276. Helga Maier KÜNZELSAU, Unbedingt.Kein Tier mehr an der Kette.Es müsste mal der Germany Mensch an ner Kette. 3,277. Mona Bakr Giza, Egypt 3,278. Ingeborg Lansky Freiburg, Germany 3,279. sabiha arican Ankara, Turkey 3,281. Patti Mansfield Cumming, GA Its not right 3,282. The Gideon Melbourne, FL Animal Foundat The Gideon Animal Foundat 3,283. Nelly Ilg Freyung, Germany 3,284. Elisabeth Stock Saarbrücken, Germany 3,285. Michael Williams Stockport, United Kingdom 3,286. Sabine Wienken Vreden, Germany 3,287. Sheila Ledsham boston, United Kingdom 3,288. erna theil Grafrath, Germany 3,289. Sabine Riedel Himmelkron, Germany 3,290. Kelly Donivan El Cajon, CA 3,291. David G. Laramie Shrewsbury, MA 3,292. Myriam Corral New York, NY

Page 118 - Signatures 3,262 - 3,292 Name From Comments 3,293. laura jurmann vandalia, IL 3,294. EYGENIA KOS, Greece KOPELLOU 3,295. Heike Kubasik , Germany 3,296. Louis Schornoz Bern, Switzerland 3,297. nathalie Leroy Ligugé, France 3,298. susete cardoso johannesburg, South Africa 3,299. Merry Robinson Manton, MI 3,300. Liz Fischer Northglenn, CO 3,301. Amber Crocker Toccoa, GA Animals should be treated humanely. 3,302. Grant Dixon liverpool, United Kingdom 3,303. Simone Steger Zürich, Switzerland 3,304. Christine Polzin Berlin, Germany 3,305. Oscar A Taylor Milwaukee, WI 3,306. Alisa Clark Hiram, GA 3,307. Anita Teufl Ferschnitz, Austria 3,308. Michelle Barnett Marcellus, NY 3,309. Patty Walport Stevens Point, WI 3,310. Silvia Casali Parma, Italy 3,311. Nancy O'Neal GIDDINGS, TX 3,312. Mandy Arthurs Worcester, United Kingdom 3,313. cornelia sledge yellville, AR 3,314. Ragnhild Sollund Oslo, Norway 3,315. Pamela Miller Tolar, TX 3,316. Petra Mahlke Tolk, Germany 3,317. Kathy Drewes Dacono, CO 3,318. Nata D brovary, Ukraine 3,319. lola Sissane Alger, Algeria 3,320. Heike Wenzel Rheinberg, Germany 3,321. Donna B. Spalding, United Kingdom 3,322. Julia Sidelnikova The Woodlands, TX 3,323. Rena Skord Corfu, Greece 3,324. gladys vazquez haya, Netherlands 3,325. Sofia Kotlyar Denver, CO

Page 119 - Signatures 3,293 - 3,325 Name From Comments 3,326. Julia Otero The Woodlands, TX 3,327. Paulette Forte Phoenix, AZ 3,328. Bernd Liebl Kiefersfelden, Germany 3,329. Annabell Simon Woltersdorf, Germany 3,330. Gesa Luetkens Lefkada, Greece, Greece 3,331. susan borgen high ridge, MO 3,332. Brigitte Gutz Hoofddorp, Netherlands 3,333. Tracy Pazyra Tewksbury, MA 3,334. Rachel Brunt Stoke -On-Trent, United Kingdom 3,335. Sandra Edwins NORTH AUGUSTA, This is cruel and inhumane. Ridiculous that this is allowed. SC 3,336. Sharyn Van Dyk Nerang, Australia 3,337. julia golovina Almaty, Kazakhstan 3,338. Manuela Bestwig, Germany Brüggemann 3,339. vera schröder Dambeck, Germany 3,340. Sarah Renzi Ancona, Italy 3,341. Karin Lux Rheinbach, Germany 3,342. Nicole Friedrich Burglengenfeld, Germany 3,343. Sabine Scheps Feldkirchen, Germany 3,344. maike tommes Winterberg, Germany 3,345. Karen Whitney Croydon, Australia 3,346. Carola Gross Wokern, Ich verachte jede Form von Tierquälerei! Biedermann Germany 3,347. Nancy Smyer Lufkin, TX 3,348. Anja Daniilidis Steffenberg, Germany 3,349. Louise Harrison Rotherham, United Kingdom 3,350. Penny Treen Aemsteong, Canada I wouldnt do this to my worst enemy - not even the dope who does this - even though I might want to! 3,351. Nelleen Ortiz Solingen, Germany 3,352. Terry Jordan Los Angeles, CA 3,353. Susan Mcclelland Southport, United Kingdom 3,354. Laura Kasparian Boquete, Panama

Page 120 - Signatures 3,326 - 3,354 Name From Comments 3,355. Elli Roberts Fallbrook, CA 3,356. Gerd Vesterlund Sandviken, Sweden 3,357. Diana Kraus Straubenhardt, Stop! Stop! Stop! Germany 3,358. Carol Linton Shorter, AL Get this baby free 3,359. Rebecka Hässelby, Sweden Bernstone 3,360. Bianca Zen Venezia, Italy 3,361. Ertaç Hazer Nicosia, Cyprus 3,362. Shahrazad Baghdad, Iraq Baghdady 3,363. Zoe Rolland San Rafael, CA so cruel. 3,364. Donca Vianu Amsterdam, Netherlands 3,365. Kerstin Fischer Sebnitz, Germany 3,366. Janine Glodt Luxemburg, Luxembourg 3,367. Noelle Connor Palos Park, IL It is cruel and wrong to keep a dog on a chain all of the time, especially a short one. 3,368. Choong Yian Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia 3,369. linda anchondo hollister, MO 3,370. Tamila Wanicki Nürnberg, Germany 3,371. Elke Schulze Berlin, Germany 3,372. Patricia Santos San Leandro, CA 3,373. Andrea Thumlert Güglingen, Germany 3,374. Daisy Lang Linz, Austria Da ich Tiere Wertschätze! 3,375. christine burgess mouzon, France 3,376. Lotte Roitzsch Berlin, Germany 3,377. sharon dillon Ottsville, PA Step it up Hawaii!! Keeping your culture does not mean keeping your abusive practices. 3,378. Jill Just Dagenham, United this is an inhumane way to treat a dog Kingdom 3,379. Anna-Michelle Sandpoint, ID Johnson 3,380. Sabine Hofmann Walldürn, Germany 3,381. Louse Meikle Liverpool, United Kingdom 3,382. Donna Davis San Jose, CA 3,383. Janna Davenport PANAMA CITY, FL

Page 121 - Signatures 3,355 - 3,383 Name From Comments 3,384. Brigitte Maurer graz, Austria 3,385. Isabell Frey Wörth, Germany 3,386. Kerstin Sievers , Germany Es ist einfach nur GRAUSAM und UNMENSCHLICH!!! 3,387. Patricia Ashworth Rochester, NY Because dogs are loyal loving giving creatures that God put on this earth to love & be loved . They feel just like us . That's like putting your child on a chain .pleeeese stop this 🙏❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😩😭😪 3,388. GIERL JO Niederviehbach, Germany 3,389. lorraine williams wellington, South Bloody trash Africa 3,390. H Singh Vancouver, Canada 3,391. Theresa Tarricone Manahawkin, NJ 3,392. Albertine Hellange, Luxembourg Flammang 3,393. Susanne Vieira Wiesbaden, Germany 3,394. Michael Pelletier Jacksonville, FL No dog should be left chained up its life. This is creul. 3,395. B Drozdowska London, United Kingdom 3,396. Delphine pizarro bromeilles, France 3,397. Roberta Norris Scunthorpe, United Kingdom 3,398. Angela Stölting Tosterglope, Germany 3,399. lorraine pattrick manchester, United Kingdom 3,400. Dea Koiava NEW YORK, NY 3,401. Kathy Norton Gallatin, TN 3,402. Dawn Zegledi Deltona, FL 3,403. Dobrovolskaya Kiev, Ukraine Lyudmila 3,404. Remo Fally Tenniken, Switzerland 3,405. Tea Markic Dubai, United Arab Emirates 3,406. claudia davis pressath, Germany dont you humans ashame of what you doing to this animals???you should help them and not let them suffer on chains like that shame on you 3,407. Diane Sergiacomi North kingstown, RI 3,408. aline golla zwickau, Germany 3,409. Johanna Haslinger Losenstein, Austria 3,410. Vicky Fellows Maidstone, United Kingdom

Page 122 - Signatures 3,384 - 3,410 Name From Comments 3,411. Solveig Berlin, Germany Hunde an die Kette legen ist nicht artgerecht und muss Güldenpfennig daher verboten werden. Es sind sozialverträgliche Tiere und müssen ganz nah bei ihrem Menschen (Rudel) leben. Auch ist es inhuman, diese Tiere bei Wind und Wetter ohne eine geeignete Unterkunft, ohne frischem Wasser und Futter sich selbst zu überlassen. So eine unwürdige Haltung muss sofort untersagt werden und gehört verboten. 3,412. Kendra Rainwater douglasville, GA 3,413. Saskia Doneit Feldatal, Germany 3,414. Gabriele Zimpel Rodgau, Germany 3,415. lynne cameron Moray, United This is no life for a dog. Have you absolutely no heart or Kingdom compassion. 3,416. Debbie Holiday Rittman, OH 3,417. Sabine Nink Kaarst, Germany 3,418. ExoticSavannah LOS ANGELES, CA Cats 3,419. Lauren Las Vegas, NV Rasmussen 3,420. Gisela Jell Wien, Austria 3,421. Susanne Meyer Hauset, Belgium 3,422. ivonne neubert hennigsdorf, Germany Schluss mit der tierquälerei.. 3,423. Carla Maxey Mason, MI 3,424. Silvia Ferretti Fiorano modenese, Italy 3,425. Cindy Wasden Palm Bay, FL 3,426. Anders Hengsteler Dunnellon, FL 3,427. Debbie Makely Floral Park, NY 3,428. Denise Zijnen Frankfurt, Germany 3,429. Beatrice kay Warsaw, MO Harding 3,430. daisy dasher bellwood, IL Time to get out of the dark ages and into the present. Get the dogs off of those chains and treat them with love and kindness. Stop treating dogs like they don't matter because they do matter! ! 3,431. Sigrid Stroh Stemwede, Germany 3,432. Arja Vanttinen Somero, Finland 3,433. Gabriela Murner Eggstätt, Germany 3,434. Chrisoula Athens, Greece Panagiotopoulou 3,435. maria raja stockport, United Kingdom

Page 123 - Signatures 3,411 - 3,435 Name From Comments 3,436. Karin Simmeth Bamberg, Germany 3,437. Rosi Adler Radevormwald, Germany 3,438. Anja Dürig Ennetbaden, Switzerland 3,439. Melissa Paschy Wittmund, Germany 3,440. Jose Avetikyan Moscow, Russian Federation 3,441. Barbara Hack Hedingen, Switzerland das ist Tierquälerei und muss sofort verboten werden. 3,442. Ulla Jehles Mülheim an der Ruhr, Germany 3,443. Juliet Francis Uckfield, United Kingdom 3,444. tanja mitejew waldkraiburg, Germany 3,445. andrea kern sandhausen, Germany 3,446. Jorunn Sykkylven, Norway Kristoffersen 3,447. Sandra Peiter Hattingen, Germany 3,448. Hildegard Lahl Lippstadt, Germany 3,449. Eileen Thiemann Magdeburg, Germany 3,450. Hanneke Vischer Hellevoetsluis, Netherlands 3,451. Lisa Schager Summerville, SC 3,452. Marilyn Sowa Ottawa, Canada 3,453. Louise Boyce Glasgow, United Kingdom 3,454. Andreas Kuhn Wetzlar, Germany 3,455. Daniela Schmitz Wuppertal, Germany 3,456. Ingrid Heß Mannheim, Germany 3,457. Tracy Bingham Peterborough, United Kingdom 3,458. Ramona Merz Leimbach, Switzerland 3,459. anny mertens londerzeel, Belgium 3,460. silvia kucinski Thornhill, United Kingdom 3,461. DARYL Edmonton, Canada STILLWELL

Page 124 - Signatures 3,436 - 3,461 Name From Comments 3,462. Ilona Vaupel Willroth, Germany Wehe, dem Menschen, wenn auch nur ein Tier im Strafgericht Gottes sitzt. - hl. Franziskus von Assisi, Schutzpatron der Tiere - 3,463. Joanna M NEW BRITAIN, CT 3,464. Lesley Jones Leeds, United Kingdom 3,465. Ute Kroiss Büttelborn, Germany 3,466. Christiane Bottrop, Germany Herrschaft 3,467. Jacintha Archer Clare, Ireland 3,468. Monika Paepcke Kiel, Germany Was ist das denn schon wieder für eine widerliche Grausamkeit. Lasst doch endlich die aramen Hunde artgerecht leben. Habt Ihr denn dar keine Ahnung, was Ihr den Tieren antut. So eiskalte Menschen 3,469. solweig Hållnäs, Sweden westerblom 3,470. Sibille Krause Wittenberg, Germany 3,471. Carmelle Ventnor, United Ryan-Sammon Kingdom 3,472. Melanie Mattick Pinneberg, Germany 3,473. Suzanne LEBON ZÜRICH, Switzerland HORRIBLE CRUEL ASSH*** YOU ARE!! 3,474. Mary Strand Stockton, CA 3,475. lilli engel mörfelden, Germany 3,476. Kristy Laino Robinson, IL 3,477. mandy berndt oderwitz, Germany 3,478. agnes nelson lexington, KY 3,479. M Eich Philippsburg, Germany 3,480. Anette Klinger Horgen, Switzerland 3,481. Laurencia Garges les gonesse, Ihammouten France 3,482. Susan Cockerill Middles6brough, United Kingdom 3,483. Sophia Patterson Eastbourne, United Kingdom 3,484. Maureen Rice Glasgow, United Kingdom 3,485. Anne MARQUEZ Marseille, France 3,486. Raphaël Ponce , France 3,487. Johanna Merkel Goldkronach, Germany

Page 125 - Signatures 3,462 - 3,487 Name From Comments 3,488. Mark T Andersen Madisonville, KY 3,489. Patricia Gouge Carlisle, United Kingdom 3,490. Christa Meyer Luzern, Switzerland 3,491. Louise Barton Kidderminster, United Kingdom 3,492. catherine woods dublin, Ireland W T F????????? dont have a dog if you r e going to abuse him!!!!! 3,493. Magda Na, Poland LUKASINSKA 3,494. Marion Barnard Wyong, Australia 3,495. dagmar gyaki trausdorf, Austria 3,496. Fiona Scott Upper Hutt, New Zealand 3,497. Stephan Hoffeld , Germany 3,498. Diane Harms Germantown, MD 3,499. Mar Do Fontana, CA 3,500. Katharina Laaber, Germany Neumeier 3,501. Melanie Drewitt Bristol, United Kingdom 3,502. Eva Hiwan Abraha Southampton, United Kingdom 3,503. Dora Marie Rimouski, Canada Gedeon 3,504. Helga Siewert Untermerzbach, Germany 3,505. Margaret Morton Workington, United Kingdom 3,506. rebecca loibl lemon grove, CA 3,507. teresa pinelo botigas, Portugal 3,508. Kathleen Ralph Logan Village, Australia 3,509. debbie mangus olney springs, CO 3,510. Ewa Harrysson Tibro, Sweden 3,511. Rhonda Durham LAS VEGAS, NV 3,512. Reinhardt Simmelsdorf, Jassmann Germany 3,513. anna schatz kärnten, Austria 3,514. ilona klinkert Mannheim, Germany

Page 126 - Signatures 3,488 - 3,514 Name From Comments 3,515. Helen Win El Sobrante, CA What is wrong with this so called HUMAN RACE, that can be so brutal, sadistic and cruel to these animals. HORRIFIC. Oh this is just so sad. Heartless cold scumbags to treat animals so horribly. It needs to be banned. Treat animals with loving, kindness and respect.!! Heartbreaking to see this poor dog with blood from his eyes. How can people be so cruel. 3,516. Rosie Flint Brentwood, United Kingdom 3,517. Debreil Virginie Lyon, France 3,518. Susan Cochran Hawks, MI It is not right to do to these animals. 3,519. sandra leftwich Lebanon, TN 3,520. Fritz Warbruck Obligado, Paraguay 3,521. Jennifer Moss Fairfax, VA Its selfish to trest animals like this 3,522. Catherine Moinard London, United Kingdom 3,523. Christina Votta Souderton, PA 3,524. Wolfgang Zingel Düsseldorf, Germany 3,525. Sandra Just Leinfelden, Germany 3,526. Francie Stone Pleasanton, CA 3,527. Khatuna Tbilisi, Georgia Chkhikvadze 3,528. Kathleen Duirk CLEVELAND, OH 3,529. Ernamary Dunne Belchertown, MA 3,530. Erika Costermans Bekkevoort, Belgium 3,531. Robert Medina El paso, TX 3,532. Nawal Hammoud Desrborn heights, MI There is no reason why humans should be treated any differently than a dog! Can a human could withstand have a heavy chain around their neck all day all night, tied to a tree in extreme heat and just being miserably alive, if not then why the hell is ok for a dog to live that rotten way? Why, because they are a animal? If people cannot care for animals in a living and caring way, they should not be allowed to have any! 3,533. Verna Dentrey Cranbrook, Canada 3,534. Devon Miller PINE, CO 3,535. fabienne vialle périgueux, France 3,536. Heidi Childs Buderim, Australia get dogs off logging chains now 3,537. Rita Pesini North Wales No animal should spend it's life on the end of a chain. If you Montgomery County, can't make them a part of your family, you shouldn't have a PA dog! 3,538. Pat Lowe Jacksonville, FL

Page 127 - Signatures 3,515 - 3,538 Name From Comments 3,539. Lucie Tsai Hull, Canada 3,540. Colleen O'Neill Toronto, Canada Please stop tge anomal cruelty & abuse! Please let these dogs go! Find them a safe forever home! They deserve it. PleaSe step on to save them! This is completely barbaric & inhumane what is happening to them. Please help them now!! 3,541. Kristen P Hazlet, NJ 3,542. Janine Lupke Ribnitz, Germany 3,543. Bella Newhope Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia 3,544. cristina Guerra mariana, Brazil 3,545. Sandi Camargo Jersey city, NJ 3,546. olga lopez bloomfield, NJ 3,547. Mariya Dubrova Bielefeld, Germany 3,548. Elvira Schmutz Worblaufen, Switzerland 3,549. Gloria Bailey Ludington, MI 3,550. Katherine Divita Melbourne, Australia 3,551. Noreen Marshall Orchard Park, NY Stop this cruelty NOW !!!! 3,552. claudia fagim Boa Esperança-Rio Bonito Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 3,553. Kalyana Krishna ABBEVILLE, AL 3,554. valerie miller loris, SC this is horrible. for one thing build a fence an animal should not be chained and so short and so heavy. you should not have animals how would you like to be treated like this? you should be put in a tiny dark cell 3,555. Madeleine Norrköping, Sweden Larsson 3,556. Chris Hepperle Schelklingen, Germany 3,557. Emily C Smith COLLIERVILLE, TN 3,558. Heinz Studer Herrliberg, Get Dogs Off 3 foot Logging Chains in Hawaii Switzerland 3,559. Jelena Abramovic Novi sad, Serbia 3,560. Donna Owens Wolcott, VT 3,561. Sharmila Perera Moratuwa, 3,562. Simone Klein Schöningen, Germany 3,563. Ester Jeronimo Mission, Canada 3,564. Coleen Nearing Ottawa, Canada Shea

Page 128 - Signatures 3,539 - 3,564 Name From Comments 3,565. Sandra Colpetzer Acworth, GA 3,566. Barbara Whitsitt Ellicott City, MD 3,567. linda Hughes Louisville, KY 3,568. Deborah Lujan Arlington, WA 3,569. julie miles Quinte West, Canada 3,570. Nina Saurén Helsingfors, Finland 3,571. Valerie Bayer White, MI 3,572. Kelly Dunn Aliso, CA 3,573. Shyma Mohan Toronto, Canada 3,574. Hannah Becker Toronto, Canada Electrical chair must for badtards killing a animals! Enough it's Enough. 3,575. Karin Warrenburg Wisconsin rapids, WI 3,576. Cecilia Lippa Rome, Italy 3,577. kelly gray colorado springs, CO 3,578. Joyce Allbritain Bensalem, PA 3,579. Munchi Lok Brooklyn, NY 3,580. Leatha Robinson Cape Coral, FL 3,581. Elina Krell Gersten, Germany 3,582. RITA dionisi los cristianos, Spain Look in his eyes and feel his pain! 3,583. diane danielson herndon, VA please this is not a life for any dog 3,584. Irina kenyeres Budapest, Hungary 3,585. Meike Schmedt Osnabrück, Germany 3,586. dave miller holon, Israel 3,587. Colleen Hooper Lynchburg, VA 3,588. Suzanna MIAMI, FL Fernandez 3,589. Mara Alldrovandi Panama, Panama 3,590. George Perry Arnprior, Canada 3,591. Terry Vaccaro NORTH PLAINFIELD, NJ 3,592. stephanie cauler Millersville, PA 3,593. Anna Stein Melrose, MA 3,594. Ruwaynah Mazini Makkah, 3,595. Beata Uba Sosnowiec, Poland 3,596. Cindy Soh Singapore, Singapore 3,597. Elizabeth Loving West Sacramento, CA 3,598. William Clement Oakton, VA 3,599. nicole miranda mexico, Mexico

Page 129 - Signatures 3,565 - 3,599 Name From Comments 3,600. malgorzata puy denat, France 3,601. sally Shields lachine, MI No animal belongs on a chain..EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 3,602. Deepa Goyal Noida, India 3,603. Barbara Lee Sebastopol, CA 3,604. Heidi Machson Rockland, ME 3,605. Jan Wojciechowsk Evanston, Uganda 3,606. Christine Loop Oldcastle, Canada 3,607. Marnie Spencer Livermore, CA 3,608. Bta Farah Auckland, New Zealand 3,609. Edeltraud j Melsungen, Germany so soll kein Tier leben müssen, TRAURIG 3,610. Gail Selleg Chicago, IL 3,611. Belinda Sullaphen Asse, Belgium 3,612. patricia Giordano Toulon, France 3,613. Diana Marcelo Santa Rosa, CA 3,614. Doug Thomsen Lincoln, NE 3,615. Linda Corfu, Greece Ashton-Kokotou 3,616. Lou Calderon Glendale, CA 3,617. Angelika Wien, Austria Kwisda-Steffen 3,618. Barbara Wade Willow Grove, PA 3,619. elizabeth Stamford, CT porcheddu 3,620. Maria Daum Jühnde, Germany 3,621. Brenda Rottier Hellevoetsluis, Netherlands 3,622. ilse trauten neuss, Germany 3,623. Linda Wegweiser Marlboro, NJ 3,624. Miriam Wright Lafayette, CO 3,625. petra koudelkova Kadaň, Czech Republic 3,626. Rosa Arsiaga Abilene, TX 3,627. Renate Alinia Mainz, Germany 3,628. alexis Andrews Guthrie, KY 3,629. JosefineAnne Los Angeles, CA Gobreville 3,631. Randy Prescott FERNDALE, WA

Page 130 - Signatures 3,600 - 3,631 Name From Comments 3,632. Audrey Verite Bloomington, MN In want se enthis abuse be stopped and no use chains I think it's not good how you feel being chained this long and short chain can't walk around much not right this should be stopped I think chain should be illegal it's abipuse and torture also neglect people leave them out all day not right 3,633. Felipe Ruiz Bogotá DC, Colombia 3,634. Sathya Moodley Los Angeles, CA 3,635. Dar Zelyas Edmonton, Canada Get all dogs off all chains or tethers. What is wrong with you idiots 3,636. Nicole Grimm Schwalmstadt, Germany 3,637. Brigitte Metzger Heidelberg, Germany 3,638. Gill Gregory Southampton, United Kingdom 3,639. Rosemary Staten Island, NY This is a inhumane disgrace and must be stopped! McClaughry 3,640. Patricia sauer Costa Adeje, Spain 3,641. herbert Brandl wien, Austria 3,642. Alexs Stamm Paderborn, Germany 3,643. Heike schwengler 47445 moers, Germany 3,644. Ihsan Sari London, United Kingdom 3,645. [email protected], MA Mulhearn 3,646. Elvira Wolfer Nairobi, Kenya 3,647. Patricia Roche MOUNTAIN HOME, AR 3,648. Teresa Romano Milton Keynes, United Kingdom 3,649. daniela ortega weißenburg, Germany 3,650. Eva Bianchi Delaware, OH 3,651. Shashi Ashok Bangalore, India 3,652. Shelley Grover Bridgwater, United Kingdom 3,653. Stephane Waldens, Germany Pecenka 3,654. Tanja Maier Bruchköbel, Germany 3,655. Petra Stoiber Mainz-Kostheim, Germany 3,656. Alex. Mellin Berlin, Germany

Page 131 - Signatures 3,632 - 3,656 Name From Comments 3,657. Ramona Stirnat Ratingen, Germany 3,658. Cecelia Picket Pin Auburn, WA 3,659. Dominique Northeim, Germany Heindorff 3,660. Sonja Götz Gänserndorf, Austria 3,661. tomsov svetlana zfat, Israel 3,662. Melissa Baldwin Philadelphia, PA 3,663. Erna Wasserbauer Hall, Austria 3,664. bianka liehr Schönebeck, Germany 3,665. Constance Jokic Kaiserslautern, Germany 3,666. Shirley Coughlin Melbourne, Australia Shocking!!!! 3,667. Annina Picillo Sant'Angelo d'Alife, CE, Italy 3,668. Laurie Miller Bohemia, NY 3,669. Angela Bruist Abergavenny, United This is incredibly cruel; it doesn't surprise me that dogs kept Kingdom chained become aggressive. Chaining dogs should be illegal. 3,670. pina donofrio aalen, Germany 3,671. Andrea Bodor Eben im Pongau, Austria 3,672. Brigitte Seebauer Schwarzenfeld, Beenden Sie diese Qual, Hunde so anzuketten! Wie Germany abgebrüht muss man denn sein????? 3,673. Tiller Mani Vienna, Austria 3,674. Veronika Hennig Mönchengladbach, Germany 3,675. Sabine Thiel Berlin, Germany 3,676. Connie Haubold Gerbstedt, Germany 3,677. Jana Tritschler St.Kilian, Germany 3,678. Gabriela Gurdziel Weiden, Germany Barbaric!!! 3,679. Sarah Schmidt Tangermünde, Germany 3,680. Patty Stoll B, Switzerland 3,681. Christina Beck Erfurt, Germany 3,682. Amanda Willemse Randburg, Gauteng, South Africa 3,683. Gayla Mixon TOMBALL, TX 3,684. Lauren Scarlett London, United Fletcher Kingdom

Page 132 - Signatures 3,657 - 3,684 Name From Comments 3,685. lucia chua Cebu, Philippines 3,686. Dawn Ashley Hadleigh, United Kingdom 3,687. Susanne Zenk Wolfsburg, Germany 3,688. Dubravka Starovic Zagreb, Croatia 3,689. Andrea leistra Lochearnhead, United Kingdom 3,690. Hannelore Heil Barendorf, Germany 3,691. a kendik wien, Austria 3,692. Jennifer Balmforth Twickenham, United Kingdom 3,693. Gertraud Fauner Moerfelden-Walldorf, It is simply animal abuse Germany 3,694. Marc Daubelcour Nevers, France 3,695. Lynne Mclaughlan / , New Zealand 3,696. blazenka krizan cakovec, Croatia 3,697. Jacqueline WATSONVILLE, CA Cavalier 3,698. Jana Strasser Wien, Austria 3,699. June Potter London, United Kingdom 3,700. Yolanda Ledesma Thornton, CO 3,701. Susan Robert SANTA ROSA, CA 3,702. Helena Åberg Tampere, Finland 3,703. Penney Knight Nuneaton, United Kingdom 3,704. Marda De Wet SEA ISLE CITY, NJ 3,705. Bente Sollentuna, Sweden Anrås-Levander 3,706. Sue Holdsworth Suffolk, United Kingdom 3,707. Gina Houghton Watford, United Kingdom 3,708. Melis Basman Istanbul, Turkey 3,709. Angelica Monthey, Switzerland Chinellatoin 3,710. dodo lazarowicz münchen, Germany 3,711. Frendo Frederique MORLAIX, France

Page 133 - Signatures 3,685 - 3,711 Name From Comments 3,712. Liana Kruger Cape town, South Africa 3,713. Elizabeth Berserker, Australia Shanahan 3,714. david quadranti niederlenz, Switzerland 3,715. MARION STATEN ISLAND, NY LEDGER 3,716. Brent Pennell spruce grove, Canada 3,717. dinesh om proddatur, India 3,718. Diana Starek Füssen, Germany Das darf doch nicht wahr sein,sofort weg mit diesem Gesetz,das ist doch kein Leben für den Hund,echt traurig das dieses Gesetz immernoch besteht,echt furchtbar!! ! 😡😡😡 3,719. ramona badescu bucuresti, Romania 3,720. Roland Jonsson Härryda, Sweden 3,721. bruno michel Paris, France 3,722. Diane Wyles Torquay, United Kingdom 3,723. claire bowman plymouth, United Kingdom 3,724. sharmini Somerset West, South sewpersad Africa 3,725. Agata O'Halloran Glasgow, United Kingdom 3,726. gina shaw paignton, United Kingdom 3,727. Nagehan İstanbul, Turkey Güllüoğlu 3,728. Jeannette de Gilching, Germany Agnolo 3,729. Teena Christon Mandurah, Australia 3,730. Kate Pinches Balastya, Hungary 3,731. Evgenia Ashgelon, Israel Bludenova 3,732. erika hamza Debrecen, Hungary 3,733. elke holm wiesbaden, Germany 3,734. Centli Temple Edinburgh, United ton-Sanchez Kingdom 3,735. Catherine Geneva, Switzerland RUDOLF NNAJI 3,736. Susan Turnquist Athens, AL Page 134 - Signatures 3,712 - 3,736 Name From Comments 3,737. Ella Dusescu Bucuresti, Romania 3,738. Stella Lorenzo Union City, NJ 3,739. Elke Keilhack Wendlingen, Germany 3,740. Valerie Griffith Bristol, United Why are you so dam cruel this poor dog needs a proper Kingdom dogs life How about you try his present life for a few days cruel moron 3,741. Diana Grant Carmarthen, United Kingdom 3,742. Heidi Walter Kaiserslautern, Germany 3,743. Nelson Baker BETHESDA, OH 3,745. ia dzneladze tbilisi, Georgia 3,746. Astrid krüger warum, Germany 3,747. Arzu Karagülle Zürixh, Switzerland 3,748. Renate Schmid Dürnkrut, Austria 3,749. valerie devigne stotzheim, France 3,750. Irina Smical Baia Mare, Romania 3,751. Martina Hnida Euskirchen, Germany 3,752. Susana Soares Braga, Portugal 3,753. Lynn Holmes Chester, United Kingdom 3,754. Lisa Zazzarino Neuwied, Germany 3,755. Sandra Kaloudi Corfu, Greece 3,756. Andrea Scholten Almere, Netherlands 3,757. Bethany Stubbins Lincoln, United Kingdom 3,758. Claudia Kulhanek Wien, Austria 3,759. michele pearce paignton, United Kingdom 3,760. Nilgun Onder Samsun, Turkey 3,761. Ádám Szabó Balmazújváros, Hungary 3,762. Sofia Bjurstrom Åbo, Finland 3,763. Cheryl Simon Chalfont, PA This is inhumane! Period. Stop! 3,764. Donna Stevens Bristolville, OH 3,765. erika frey 3000, Switzerland 3,766. Kate Tattersdale Bishop Auckland, United Kingdom 3,767. Donna Unger Trappe, PA

Page 135 - Signatures 3,737 - 3,767 Name From Comments 3,768. Sandra Holst Buxtehude, Germany 3,769. Linda Davis Pietermaritzburg, South Africa 3,770. Liz Page Ptetoria, South Africa 3,771. Susan Brand Boston, MA 3,772. Renee Wilkins Easton, PA Animal ABUSE! 3,773. Isolde Godman Remseck, Germany 3,774. renate schindler glauchau, Germany 3,775. Crystal Hamilton Barberton, OH 3,776. tracy horsfall redhill, United Kingdom 3,777. lydie maheut fécamp, France 3,778. Jayme Archibald Kingston, Canada 3,779. Suzanne Hall Mont Alto, PA 3,780. Maren Heinig Sydney, Australia 3,781. Alison Harvey Burcough, United Kingdom 3,782. Brandy White Las Vegas, NV 3,783. Carol Farley Sandy hook, KY 3,784. Heidi Weinzierl Walting, Germany 3,785. Karen Baildon Blackburn, United Kingdom 3,786. Penny Howington New Bern, NC 3,787. Jennifer Knoxville, TN Watkins-Abby 3,788. Dave Fritz Cleveland, TN 3,789. Monika Galmiz, Switzerland Gosteli-Gyger 3,790. Laura Bargiggia Milano, Italy 3,791. Mike Morucci Ellicott City, MD 3,792. laurie wright brightwood, VA 3,793. Natalie Brunt , United Kingdom 3,794. Laurence Wyss Bretigny, Switzerland 3,795. Donna Cox The Colony, TX this is cruel and inhumane 3,796. Joeanne Tyrie Grantham, Australia 3,797. Paula Dwyer Torquay, United Kingdom

Page 136 - Signatures 3,768 - 3,797 Name From Comments 3,798. Lynne Morrissey Rocky Face, GA The dogs feel helpless when chained, and that's why they bite. Listen to the USDA! 3,799. Harriett Webb Lowell, MA Humans are so cruel 3,800. alexandra bíró budapest, Hungary Supposedly a heaven on earth island.... they r just as bad as any idiot american 3,801. Raimonda Kairytė Kiauleikių km., Kretingos raj., Lithuania 3,802. Martine Rataux Essey Les Nancy, que c'est dur de voir des animaux malheureux!! France 3,803. Tania Harrison Bridgetown, Australia 3,804. Christine Thomas JACKSONVILLE, FL 3,805. Daniela Lopez Ssstre, Argentina 3,806. marja-leena Helsinki, Finland puranen 3,807. Ana Camelia Bucharest, Romania Baiculescu 3,808. Toshinori Atsugi, Japan Kanashiro 3,809. Maureen Grant - Portsmouth, United Smith Kingdom 3,810. rajni bisht new delhi, India 3,811. celine anchen MONTEVIDEO, Uruguay 3,812. Alice Bågenholm Stockholm, Sweden 3,813. Linda Douglas Richmond, b.c., Show some compassion for living beings. They do not Bulgaria deserve punishment just for being dogs! 3,814. t lee st louis, MO 3,815. elke koska Köln, Germany 3,816. Heidi Stingelin Basel, Switzerland 3,817. Alice Cohen MOUNT AIRY, MD 3,818. Alisha Saro Kuching, Malaysia 3,820. Marjorie Jones Birmingham, United Kingdom 3,821. Vanessa Evans Derby, United Kingdom 3,822. Svetlana Svetlana Toliatty, Russian Federation 3,823. SHOBA NAIR perth, Australia 3,824. Donna Deese Denton, TX 3,825. Irene Heater Easton, PA

Page 137 - Signatures 3,798 - 3,825 Name From Comments 3,826. CAROLA LES LANDES HORRIBLE GENUSSON, France 3,827. louise brophy swansea, United Kingdom 3,828. C Cago Melbourne, Australia 3,829. Rodney Waddell Surprise, AZ 3,830. Susanne Stachel Zürich, Switzerland 3,831. Liz Sperber Kirchheim, Germany 3,832. Brenda Fries Madison, WI 3,833. phyllis walker STATEN ISLAND, NY 3,834. Marie Bianicci Dallas, TX 3,835. Jodie Richers ROSWELL, GA 3,836. Kelly Hudson Fort Wayne, IN That is animal abuse. No animal deserves to be treated this way. How would you like to be on a short chain? 3,837. Lydia Peters Cave Spring, GA 3,838. Suzanne Parodi South Lake Tahoe, CA 3,839. Ambur joshi gurnee, IL 3,840. Joanne Leblanc st. isidore, Canada They should chained those humans that do this instead. People have no common sense and no decency these days. So laws need to be put in place for these idiots. Not humane and disgusting practice. 3,841. Chris Ruffell Bridgetown, Australia 3,842. Sara Smith Egremont, United Kingdom 3,843. Anna Depergola Staten island, NY 3,844. Monika Mikulska Flagman, Jamaica 3,845. Hortrncia Guadalajara, Mexico Mendoza 3,846. Tijana Spasic Beogad, Serbia 3,847. Cristian Ponce Long beach, CA 3,848. Jane Chwastecki Hammond, IN 3,849. Deirdre Muir Johannesburg, South Africa 3,850. yuko kituka saga, Japan 3,851. Raimond Zerbis Stoke-on-Trent, United Kingdom 3,852. susan coleman Cherry Hill, NJ This is beyond heartless. You get more from an animal when you treat them well. This is torture by anyones standards except the people doing this.

Page 138 - Signatures 3,826 - 3,852 Name From Comments 3,853. Kim Zwicker LYNN, MA 3,854. Andrew Williams corsham, United Kingdom 3,855. Sabina Stefan Brisbane, Australia 3,856. Nymph Kellerman Pretoria, South Africa 3,857. Annelie Amrhein Hennef, Germany 3,858. Eveline Glötzl München, Germany 3,859. arielle digoy Westgate, United Kingdom 3,860. laurence ginet les allues, France 3,861. Lynn Navarra Bronx, NY 3,862. jeannette samuels linwood, PA 3,863. Darlene MacK Deseronto, Canada people who leave dogs out like this have no heart or feelings and should never own an animal.make it law that all dogs are treated with love and respect and make animal abusers pay for their cruelty to animals.Animals have hearts and feelings abusers have no ehart or feelings 3,864. maria yolanda villena, Spain tormo 3,865. Robert Piller llanwrda, United Kingdom 3,866. Martta-Liisa Harju Tampere, Finland 3,867. Joann Matter Bergenfield, NJ 3,868. caroline schmidt Subic Bay, Philippines 3,869. kay groce smyrna, TN 3,870. Kim Lisacek Philadelphia, PA 3,871. kimiko Yamamoto Toronto, Canada 3,872. PATRICIA RIDGEWOOD, NY BOECK 3,873. Marissa Navarro San jose, CA 3,874. Kajsa Bagenholm Stockholm, Sweden 3,875. MARTINE KAYE NEW CANEY, TX 3,876. Mark Lovell Bristol, United Kingdom 3,877. Karen Nealy Lehigh Acres, FL This is horrible for these beautiful animals. Stop it now 3,878. Kimberly Yorke Lewiston, ME 3,879. judy lim makatu, Philippines 3,880. Martha Cantu Monterrey, Mexico 3,881. Dee Fraser TACOMA, WA 3,882. amy Zikic Oshawa, Canada

Page 139 - Signatures 3,853 - 3,882 Name From Comments 3,883. Nina Höffer Hannover, Germany 3,884. ana antunes Lisboa, Portugal 3,885. Sharryn Goodman Calivil, Australia 3,886. Claudia Regina de Cotia, Brazil Cordeiro 3,887. Devinda Fernando Saint Simons Island, GA 3,888. Sylvia Z. prefontaines, France 3,889. Karen Pyles Harwood, MD Laws allowing dogs to be chained (with 3 ft. long heavy chain?!) outside need to be changed. This unacceptable and very inhumane! 3,890. Margarita Moon Navestock, United Kingdom 3,891. marie louise lo pringy, France cascio 3,892. Julie Kirk Lincoln, United Kingdom 3,893. Leslie Randall Moorpark, CA 3,894. Daisy Porter Eldon, IA 3,895. Gail James Hamilton, Canada 3,896. kirsi Lindfors Tampere, Finland 3,897. Nicole Nichols Lagrangeville, NY 3,898. Joanna Ramos Tujunga, CA 3,899. Pam Priestly Sheffield, United Because it's cruel,dogs are NOT meant to spend their lives Kingdom confined in that.eay cc 3,900. ERIKA MEXICO, Mexico GARTISDE 3,901. Patti Montgomery St Petersburg, FL 3,902. Susanne Juretko , Germany 3,903. Andrea Kraut Eschwege, Germany 3,904. Ruth Lindeman Burnsville, MN 3,905. Anna Dean Chester, VA 3,906. Denise Floyd Brunswick, GA 3,907. Christina Mann Port Saint Lucie, FL 3,908. Annalisa Allentown, PA Bertolazzi 3,909. Keegan Reddy Jhb, South Africa 3,910. viviana daniele misiones, Argentina 3,911. Leigh Swain Wakefield, United Kingdom

Page 140 - Signatures 3,883 - 3,911 Name From Comments 3,912. danièle guidi la Réole, France 3,913. Heidi Malsbender Düsseldorf, Germany 3,914. Inayara Bernatd Curitiba, Brazil 3,915. Indu Saxena Jodhpur, India 3,916. michel lambert Hersin-Coupigny, France 3,917. Denise Grand Quevilly, VERHAEGEN France 3,918. Disa Knight Burgess hill, United Kingdom 3,919. margit Ecker Eichgraben, Austria 3,920. Anna Kepowicz Düsseldorf, Germany 3,921. Angelika Lipjinski Weilheim, Germany 3,922. AnneMarie Kintop Corona, CA 3,923. susana giraudo buenos aires, Argentina 3,924. Annerose Salzgitter, Germany Wohlgemuth 3,925. Elizabeth Allen Delmar, CA 3,926. Tania llewellyn tonyrefail, United Kingdom 3,927. Eva Wischhusen Eltville, Germany 3,928. Natalie Buckingham, United Cooper-Lewis Kingdom 3,929. Brittany Ledesma WHITTIER, CA 3,930. Synnöve Sletten Gothenburg, Sweden YOU SHOULD BE TREATED IN THE SAME WAY!!!! I HATE WHEN INNOCENT ANIMALS ARE PAYING FOR YOUR AGRESSION!!!!! 3,931. Marilena Ene Bucuresti, Romania 3,932. Vi Johnson Oxford, United Kingdom 3,933. Alexander Bangkok, Thailand Zangenehpour 3,934. Lori Creasy Canyon Lake, TX If you wouldn't do it to a child you shouldn't do it to a dog! Signed from Texas! 3,935. Janet campbell Middlesbrough, United Kingdom 3,936. sandra klein mühlheim, Germany 3,937. Vlad Dana Biella, Italy 3,938. Robert Boath Killin, United Kingdom

Page 141 - Signatures 3,912 - 3,938 Name From Comments 3,939. Bev Salvadori Johannesburg, South Africa 3,940. Elisabeth Vosseler Neuss, Germany 3,941. George J. Winter Izola, Slovenia 3,942. Pat Grogan Stevenage, United Kingdom 3,943. Judy Clarke New Port Richey, FL 3,944. Linda Mavaega Independence, MO 3,945. Lynn Manieri San Mateo, CA 3,946. Karlijn Wevers As, Belgium 3,947. Judith Lamb Cincinnati, OH 3,948. emanuela mellot VASPERVILLER, France 3,949. Pedro Cruz Las Piedras, Puerto Rico 3,950. Susanne Schwann Sulz im Weinviertel, Austria 3,951. Rose Nelson Cupertino, CA 3,952. France Collet wasquehal, France 3,953. Tanja Parisi Großheubach, Germany 3,954. Robert Turski SEBASTIAN, FL 3,955. Theresa Gloucester, VA Cruelty has to be snubbed out. LaFata-White 3,956. terezia ildiko biharkeresztes, fogarasi Hungary 3,957. Caitlin Osepchuk Ocean Grove, NJ 3,958. gaby brown Colorado Springs, CO 3,959. Katherine Legg Dorchester, United Kingdom 3,960. William Perry Tonganoxie, KS 3,961. Belinda Klein Edmonton, Canada 3,962. Michele Snyder Windsor, PA WTF is wrong with you inhumane idiots. They should be allowed to PUT THESE CHAINS ON YOU . Do you have any idea how much these chains weigh ? This is TORTURE and UNACCEPTABLE , on EVERY LEVEL . This needs to end ...... YESTERDAY !! 3,963. GunBritt Hansen Göteborg, Sweden 3,964. Colby Steiner Corrales, NM 3,965. Bibi Göransson Kungsör, Sweden

Page 142 - Signatures 3,939 - 3,965 Name From Comments 3,967. Henry Orgel Charlottesville, VA When the hell will it end!!! EVERYBODY - Please sign this petition. Thank you. 3,968. Selina Steiner , Israel 3,969. Elvira Mietzner Villingen-Schwenningen, Germany 3,970. Sonia Naveen Delhi, India 3,971. Tosca Sommer Horw, Switzerland 3,972. Petra Hey Hiltpoldstein, Germany 3,973. Samantha Wilford Torquay, United Kingdom 3,974. Ellen Tieszen Plano, TX 3,975. Patrick LAMBERSART, PROUVOST France 3,976. Renee Kimball Lockhart, TX 3,977. Ivonne Gartside Mexico df, Mexico meza 3,978. Samantha Dark London, United Kingdom 3,979. Kathilyn Bigler Kettering, OH 3,980. Javid Ahmed Twickenham, United Kingdom 3,981. Nancy Walsh Independence, MO No animal should be chained! 3,982. Margot Schulz Wien, Austria 3,983. Cynthia Davie Saint Clair, PA Dear God!!!! Help these dogs!!! Poor babies. So sad that people could do this to animal. 3,984. Deborah Farnham, United O'Shaughnessy Kingdom 3,985. Jasmine Jas MANHATTAN, NY 3,986. Christine Santa Clara, CA thompson 3,987. roger scaramuccio madison, WI 3,988. carol barton shropshire, United Kingdom 3,989. Liz Woloski Beausejour, Canada 3,990. Lynda McMillan Eugene, OR 3,991. Barbara Preusser Pgh, PA 3,992. Joal Stone KATY, TX Please end this cruelty!!! 3,993. Britta Hansen Bowbells, ND 3,994. Lena M , AL

Page 143 - Signatures 3,967 - 3,994 Name From Comments 3,995. Betsy Calvin Springfield, IL 3,996. Johanna Hamburg, Germany Keine Ketten, keine Zwinger! Hunde gehören zur Familie!!! Mau-Diaz 3,997. Rebecca Bischoff Montebello, CA 3,998. margaret roy newcastle, United Kingdom 3,999. Sarah Wheeler Plymouth, United Kingdom 4,000. Ingo Grossmann Krefeld, Germany 4,001. MARTINE TESTU Ozoir La Ferrière, France 4,002. Vivienne Ben-Shir LONDON, United Kingdom 4,003. Julie Kirani Wolverhampton, United Kingdom 4,004. Lloyd Walsh anytown, MO 4,005. Tanya Britz otjiwarongo, Namibia 4,006. Jason Rios Bronx, NY 4,007. Helga Locher Brütten, Switzerland 4,008. shizuko ngashima OBIHIRO, Japan 4,009. wiktoria keiper bad schwalbach, Germany 4,010. Erika Kuich Nerja, Spain 4,011. Ιωάννα Ρεθυμνο, Greece Ζουρμπάκη 4,012. Ruth Seidel Bendorf, Germany 4,013. Dee Twitchell Norman, OK 4,014. Jane Phillips Torquay, United Kingdom 4,015. Rae Madden Köping, Sweden 4,016. Angelika Klebs Stuttgart, Germany 4,017. Dawn Shepley Phoenix, AZ 4,018. Kristin Heim Oberhaching, Germany 4,019. Monica Cook Gloucester, United Kingdom 4,020. Laura Rusbach Stockdorf, Germany 4,021. Mark Raverty Dumfries, United Kingdom 4,022. Kristy Clock Redmond, OR

Page 144 - Signatures 3,995 - 4,022 Name From Comments 4,023. Tuula Vilppu Skillingaryd, Sweden 4,024. Kerstin Murr Immenreuth, Germany 4,025. Suki Mason London, United Kingdom 4,026. Jessica Fesler COLO SPGS, CO 4,027. Annie Knutson Sanford, NC 4,028. lynn hall glendale, AZ 4,029. Camilla Ekman Roma, Italy 4,030. Nanci Nydegger Meridian, ID 4,031. Penny Hoover Maggie Valley, NC 4,032. bernadette gustin namur, Belgium 4,033. suzy devaux hensies, Belgium 4,034. michel/bernadette namur, Belgium charlier/gustin 4,035. lisa visco Washington, NJ Because this is harmful to the dogs and it makes me sick to think that they would think it's ok. How could they allow this please change your laws. Help these dogs don't let them suffer. Please!!! 4,036. Coen Meijers Breda, Netherlands Animal abuse is disgusting and should be prosecuted! 4,037. Corinne Martin Yzeure, France 4,038. Jocelyne Calvisio Rambervillers, France 4,039. Patricia Delabays Rolle, Switzerland 4,040. Tina Galvan Hawthorne, CA 4,041. Beatrice Sundfor Bergen, Norway 4,042. Sonia Brembati Udine, Italy 4,043. veronique bruxelles, Belgium germeaux 4,044. SCJ Hemmerich Jacksonville, FL 4,045. isabelle danuzzo st mars le briere, France 4,046. Sandra Iloputaife Braunschweig, Germany 4,047. Louise Brunet Ottawa, Canada Come on Hawaii you can do better than this...You are my favorite State ! Change that stupid law ! 4,048. Julie Gaston rouffiac, France 4,049. Erika Kohlmann Wuppertal, Germany 4,050. Lynne Stokes Bradford, United Kingdom 4,051. Tracey Connell Davenport, IA

Page 145 - Signatures 4,023 - 4,051 Name From Comments 4,052. Evi Ziereis Holzkirchen, Germany 4,053. shpresa kelmendi gent, Belgium 4,054. Fabrice JEAN Cagnes sur mer, France 4,055. Natalia Kotlas, Russian Chervochkina Federation 4,056. Leah Player St. Thomas, Canada 4,057. Mieke van dijk bergen Op Zoom, Netherlands 4,058. Maria Schultz Weston, FL 4,059. priscilla wallace roseville, CA 4,060. Lyn Green Basildon, United Kingdom 4,061. Doris Schnabel Overath, Germany 4,062. Rapp Sonia Mulhouse, France 4,063. Lynne Radfird Cleveland, United Kingdom 4,064. Michelle Sarnoski Lakewood, WA 4,065. wilfrid quevedo Guatemala, Guatemala 4,066. Constanze Jaron Kloten, Switzerland 4,067. Janet Fincannon CHARLESTON, SC evil must stop. 4,068. Renate Andersch Cologne, Germany These animal abusers must be punished for animal cruelty, it is a severe abuse to put a dog on a chain in the first place but to have the dog always on the chain is barbaric, to have a dog chained on a very heavy chain is gruesome and can lead to injuries. I demand that this chaining is be banned and that the dogs have social interaction with the owners or the must not have a dog. Dogs are peoples best friends and should be treated with respect and love as family members. What kind of people live there to treat dogs so cruel, why this horrendous suffering is afflicted to these helpless innocent dogs. 4,069. janice marshall Glasgow, United Kingdom 4,070. Terri Cordell Cloquet, MN 4,071. Matthew Wilson Sheffield, United Kingdom 4,072. Evgeniya Kulikova Moscow, Russian Federation 4,073. nathalie guillaume frasnes lez couvin, Belgium

Page 146 - Signatures 4,052 - 4,073 Name From Comments 4,074. Maureen Patrone Canton, MA 4,075. Brigitta Bleyer Wien, Austria 4,076. laura lah nl, IA 4,077. glenn cassel wyandotte, MI 4,078. Katarzyna Czernik Killarney, Ireland 4,079. Elsa Geeraerts Bruxelles, Belgium 4,080. lynn cross grimisby north east why important look your selfs ,that dog or any other dog lincs, United Kingdom deserve to be cruely kept like that its pure evil ,chain there masters up see if they like it ,and who took this picture should have got the poor dog loose ,you can see it is suffering 4,081. Iza Monalisa Sertãozinho, Brazil 4,082. Vivian Shirazi Springfield,, VA Would you like to be chained❓ Please 🛑STOP 🛑 NOW‼️ This is cruel animal abuse‼️Why do people get dogs if they can not take care of them properly. Please teach the people that chaining any animal is wrong. They are living creatures as humans are living creatures. Also, keep them in a clean environment and not filth. 4,083. Carol Treacy Petaluma, CA How can anyone treat another being with so much contempt, disregard and sadism? 4,084. Irene Leighton Manchester, United Kingdom 4,085. Barbara Bier München, Germany 4,086. Tanja Stabroek, Belgium Wagemakers 4,087. Alex Corti Subirats, Spain 4,088. Marcia Nevares Mexico, Mexico 4,089. Marija Brangjolica Skopje, Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic Of 4,090. FRANCOISE CLERMONT-FERRAND,QUI MERITE DÊTRE ATTACHE COMME CELA. ILS GIRARD France N'ONT PAS COMMIS DE CRIME. CE NE SONT PAS DES FORCATS. HONTE A CEUX QUI FONT CELA SUR DES ANIMAUX FAITS POUR COURIR.... 4,091. GHIULNAR CONSTANTA, CHESBAN GEMIL Romania 4,092. Tracy Fisk madbury, NH 4,093. Dupont Jeanne Paris, France Ces pauvres animaux doivent être libérés de ces chaines ! 4,094. Bryant Snedeker Diamond bar, CA 4,095. Steven Fielding Plymouth, United Kingdom

Page 147 - Signatures 4,074 - 4,095 Name From Comments 4,096. Kevin Helsley Erie, PA 4,097. Linda Wilkinaon BIglerville, PA 4,098. Christina Saint john, Canada Plumridge 4,099. Kathleen So. San Francisco, DeLander CA 4,100. Ashling Joyce Athlone, Ireland 4,101. Brendalynn Santa Maria, CA I am against tethering of dogs and any form of animal abuse Consul 4,102. Gladys Rivera, Uruguay 4,103. Julie Townsend Redlands, CA 4,104. Sue Goodman North York, Canada 4,105. Candy Perry Waverly, OH 4,106. Alejandro Villa Gesell, Argentina Raymundo Herrera 4,107. milagros alvarez , fiemoooooooooooooo diossssssssss 4,108. liz fischer palos hills, IL 4,109. Lisa Margetts Worrigee, Australia 4,110. Emerita Garcia Middletown, NY 4,111. Patricia Henson North port, FL 4,112. Gerlinde Prohaska Reyersdorf, Austria 4,113. Sabrina Schmidt Hinterbrühl, Austria 4,114. cristina siqueiros mexico, Mexico 4,115. ingrid lucinchi caracas, Venezuela 4,116. Dariusz Patrzalek Sosnowiec, Poland 4,117. Barbara Nozzi Rockton, IL 4,118. betty murphy long beach, CA this is an Hawaiian disgrace!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Change this NOW!!!!!!!!!!! 4,119. Julia Kelly Oakville, Canada Because it is not right to chain a dog on a 3 foot leash .. think hoe u would feel .. these dogs are social and mans best friend .. 4,120. Paul Santiago Xalapa, Veracruz., Firmado por la libertad de los animales. Olguin Mexico 4,121. Dov Shy Honolulu, HI 4,122. scott caldwell Birmingham, AL 4,123. Elizabeth Richland, WA Alexander 4,124. Annie Seet Singapore, Singapore 4,125. Fredericka Hart Wylie, TX

Page 148 - Signatures 4,096 - 4,125 Name From Comments 4,126. Laura Rodrick East Peoria, IL Ban chains all together. It's cruel and inhumane! 4,127. Donna Blair CRANSTON, RI 4,128. Terry Ridge Lakeview, OR 4,129. Barbara Hussey Kailua Kona, HI This is a simply hideous practice still going on in Hawaii. It must be stopped. Animals suffer and sometimes die when chained up in this way....or chained at all. 4,130. Olga Garcia Bell, CA 4,131. Emily Murr Mission Viejo, CA This is immoral and unjust. 4,132. Kelly Kramer Garden Grove, CA Shame on you Hawaii. Stop this inhumane treatment of sentient creatures. You know better! 4,133. Carly Clark Niceville, FL Pure INTENTIONAL animal cruelty. Also it is obvious these people w/ more tghan one chained up dog are doing something illegal on there property 4,134. maria ramirez Hollywood, FL 4,135. maureen boag toronto, Canada 4,136. Bonnie Allen Meridian, MS 4,137. Carol Davis Spokane, WA Putting dogs on chains is cruel. If you can't have a dog without chaining it up, DON'T get a dog! 4,138. Holly Graczyk Moorpark, CA 4,139. holger meyer Weyhe, Germany 4,140. Aguedys Houston, TX Whittaker 4,141. Petya Ryazkova Sofia, Bulgaria 4,142. Linda Thomas Kenockee, MI 4,143. Vanessa Marshall Grouville, Jersey 4,144. Chantal Martin Noumea, New IGNOBLE STOP😡😭 Caledonia 4,145. Dari Langone Brooklyn, NY 4,146. Joyce Phillips Muncie, IN 4,147. Guillemette Brin St Barthelemy, Guadeloupe 4,148. Blanche Norris Grove City, OH 4,149. Lee Mallatratt Durham, NC 4,150. Kathryn Baker ATLANTA, GA 4,151. Guadalupe Duran Mexicp, Macao 4,152. Traci Mays Largo, FL 4,153. Stacy Ulrich San Marcos, CA 4,154. Mindy Bruxvoort Edmond, OK 4,155. Carmen Tismanar Resita, Romania

Page 149 - Signatures 4,126 - 4,155 Name From Comments 4,156. Erin Myres San Diego, CA 4,157. Anne Garrity Tuskegee, AL 4,158. Pat Bastidas México, Mexico 4,159. Giselle Gaerlan Edmonton, Canada 4,160. olga Burnett San Antonio, TX 4,161. Suzanne Dougal Bradford, United Kingdom 4,162. Jennifer Coleman Highlands, NJ 4,163. Pam Goldberg Nyack, NY GOD IS WATCHING DEVIL SPAWN SOCIOPATHIC DIGRACEFUL TRASH! 4,164. Marcel Balmat Le Lignon, Switzerland 4,165. Larissa Watier Mexico, Mexico 4,166. Chika Ozaki Urayasu, Japan 4,167. Erin Waggoner Snohomish, WA 4,168. Kathy Kostajani Queens, NY 4,169. Ellen PRIOR BOTHELL, WA 4,170. Lars Bathory Palaiseau, France 4,171. didcie jacques mane, France 4,172. Ruby Houck Honey Brook, PA 4,173. alejandra san carlos, Venezuela escalona 4,174. Alexej Axenov Flensburg, Germany help, be human 4,175. Beverly Koblick Yorktown Heights, NY 4,176. Jennifer Minneapolis, MN Dogs are sentient beings and deserve better treatment. It's Geisheker also dangerous to keeps dogs chained. It fosters aggression. It's time for Hawaii to step into the modern world and respect animals and their communities. "We shall be judged by how we treat animals" - Ghandi 4,177. Melissa Osborne Idaho falls, ID 4,178. Rita Spangler Excelsior Springs, MO Why don't we just put the owners on a 3 foot chain and see how they like it....this is nothing by cruel and inhumane!!!!!!!!!!! 4,179. Valerie Bertelli Lower Lake, CA 4,180. Mike Peltier Kenosha, WI 4,181. Linda Dalton Rancho Cucamonga, CA 4,182. Melanie Wynne Ripon, CA 4,183. Leilani Chock Tigard, OR 4,184. Pamela Smith Sanford, FL

Page 150 - Signatures 4,156 - 4,184 Name From Comments 4,185. Mariana Trejo López Mateos, Mexico 4,186. Linda Mayo Appomattox, VA Why would you do this to a loving family members? Law needs to be changed, to set these babies free. 4,187. Shelley Hawi, HI No dog should live on s chain. It makes them aggressive Kreutzmann 4,188. Porscha Carter Antioch, TN 4,189. Jen Swanton Oxnard, CA No dog should be tied outside! 4,190. Marcy Chamblin Hamden, CT 4,191. Pere' Morris Austin, TX This is ridiculous. Why do these moron's need a petition to know this??? 4,192. Val WEITZ WOODLAND HILLS, CA 4,193. Sandra Kyrzakos Mississauga, Canada 4,194. julie lammert hugo, CO 4,195. Jill Mulford Longwood, FL 4,196. María Medina Estado de México, Mexico 4,197. Janet Locke Novato, CA How is encouraging dogs and boars to fight culture? It is barbaric. Please join the 21st Century. 4,198. Linda Salerno Smithville, TX 4,199. SuAnn Martinez San Jacinto, CA 4,200. Jana Foreso Los Angeles, CA 4,201. LUANN HUTCHINSON, MN SCHULTE 4,202. Cheryl Allen Sandia Park, NM 4,203. RACHEL Lujan Pomona, CA 4,204. yadallee laila Phoenix, Mauritius nobody has no right to abuse torture animals thy are fr God....those who harm innocent defenseless animals i pray God curse on thm thy never live in peace millions of uncurable diseases.....God curse on thier family too 4,205. josiane de angelis beaumont de pertuis, France 4,206. Nadege Felguera Bordeaux, France 4,207. Roger Pedersen Honningsvåg, Norway 4,208. Dawn Chaney Phila, PA 4,209. PAWAN SINGH PATNA, India 4,210. noemi suarez Guayaquil, Ecuador los animales son seres vivos capaces de sentir afecto y desgrado por las personas de acuerdo a como son tratados si esos perros continuan siendo encadenados no solos van a ir destruyendo la vida de ese pobre animalito sino tambien (continues on next page)

Page 151 - Signatures 4,185 - 4,210 Name From Comments 4,210. noemi suarez Guayaquil, Ecuador (continued from previous page) de las personas que saldrán lastimadas por causa de la agresividad que con mucha razon tendrá el perro. 4,211. Joyce August SF, CA 4,212. jeannette fridley Brooksville, FL HAVE SOME EMPATHY, WHAT IF THAT WERE YOU ON THE DAMN CHAIN! 4,213. Samantha Kingston, Australia Kenendy 4,214. CARMELA Trecate, Italy LICCIARDELLO 4,215. Elena de Martynoff Bruxelles, Belgium 4,216. Serena Athamneh Mosby, MO 4,217. Ursula Böhm Gersthofen, Germany 4,218. Maritza Sahlin Malmo, Sweden 4,219. Carolyn Rasso Riverside, CA Dogs are God's wonderful amazing creations! Chain up anyone who hurts them! 4,220. livia i Groslay, France 4,221. Kathrena Vega Carlsbad, CA 4,222. Beena V P Bangalore, India 4,223. Dorothée Canonne vaux Andigny, France 4,224. Ch Puy Croissy, France 4,225. Bon Dela Cruz Cainta, Philippines 4,226. Jen Lesher Santa Fe, NM 4,227. Tina McLees Woodridge, IL 4,228. FRANCE Roncq, France BERNARD 4,229. Jessy Joschko Berlin, Germany 4,230. Luz Avila-Acevedo Fort Myers, FL This is cruel and inhumane!! 4,231. Aline Dole Noisiel, France 4,232. Sonja Mayrhofer Salzburg, Austria 4,233. lori Gearhart ASHEVILLE, NC PURE FN EVIL 4,234. Susan Phillips San Rafael, CA No one, no living being should be tied up. Dog's freedom should be respected. 4,235. Melegueta Mattay Geilston bay, Australia 4,236. Theresa Hall Frederick, MD Chain up yourself and see how it feels. Do No Harm. End the abuse of all animals. Un-Chain! 4,237. Baltes ion London, United Valentina doinita Kingdom 4,238. Lilian Liotti CABA, Argentina 4,239. Jackie Ellis Pineville, NC

Page 152 - Signatures 4,210 - 4,239 Name From Comments 4,240. Laurie Rose Col spgs, CO 4,241. Deana Scott HASTINGS, New That is not a dogs life, stuck to a heavy duty chain. Its Zealand cruelty, and affects the dog in so many ways 4,242. Bianca Hasselfeldt Clenze, Germany 4,243. valerija pihler sp.duplek, Slovenia 4,244. Reinhard Stier Forch, Switzerland 4,245. maria ivanovic Caracas, Venezuela 4,246. Herbert Bolsinger Moraira, Spain Love and respect for All live 4,247. Anna Mária Százhalombatta, Udvarhelyiné Hungary Tomai 4,248. dan hamel crambrook, Canada 4,249. Véronique Lyon, France Bernard 4,250. IRA VUKUSIC RIJEKA, Croatia 4,251. Sarah White Brasted, United Kingdom 4,252. Casey Mcellen Horsham, United Kingdom 4,253. irene prianggodo tangerang selatan, Indonesia 4,254. Zsuzsanna Dankó Hajdúnánás, Hungary 4,255. Rosario Fuentes México, Mexico 4,256. SUSAN WILLIS , United Kingdom 4,257. Christina Schlack Ferndale, WA 4,258. Josef Littman Ashdod, Israel 4,259. Sab Char London, United Kingdom 4,260. rosagnna Santo Domingo, rodriguez Dominican Republic 4,261. Eveline BERARD RIORGES, France 4,262. Chris Wybranska Huddersfield, United Kingdom 4,263. nata ku Kirov, Russian Federation 4,264. veronique St Cyr sur Loire, Alvaresse France 4,265. Annie Carro CHAZELLES SUR LAVIEU, France

Page 153 - Signatures 4,240 - 4,265 Name From Comments 4,267. veronique fontenay le comte, stop bergeron France 4,268. chantal vanwinkel anderecht, Belgium 4,269. Heat Tomlinson London, United Kingdom 4,270. Brian Tant Clayton, NC 4,271. Sylwia Bartczak Falkirk, United SAVE THEM free them bastards!! Kingdom 4,272. Dominique Rueil-malmaison, Joussard France 4,273. Sandra Anderson Calgary, Canada 4,274. Mary Beatriz longchamps, Vieira Càceres Argentina 4,275. Aurore Laparu Eschau, France 4,276. joelle barrrier AUXY, France 4,277. Berangère COURBEVOIE, ROUDY France 4,278. Sammy Malacrida River edge, NJ 4,279. Mireille Lam Paris, France Pitié !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 4,280. Joelle SACHET Colombes, France 4,281. fernado ugarte Prien, Germany 4,283. donna nickles janesville, WI 4,284. Liz Little Nuneaton, United Kingdom 4,285. laila quraishi Hilversum, Netherlands 4,286. Michèle Lebourg Pavilly, France 4,287. Stephanie Bernert Böblingen, Germany 4,288. maryline bataille ychoux, France 4,289. Edith Segovia Asunción, Paraguay 4,290. Leslie Anderson Walnut creek, CA 4,291. juan antonio lopez albacete, Spain 4,292. Elizabeth Davito Navarre, FL 4,293. Josie Maynard Bournemouth, United Kingdom 4,294. seema bassi gurugram, India 4,295. Bernarda Salem, OR Zaragoza 4,296. Daniel Cabello Lechería, Venezuela 4,297. mariela guarino lippstadt, Germany

Page 154 - Signatures 4,267 - 4,297 Name From Comments 4,298. julie carner Schenectady, NY 4,299. Brenda Guzman Tala jalisco, Mexico 4,300. Fe camila Calamba, Philippines Azupardo 4,301. lisa cornell airmont, NY 4,302. Thelma Bryant Thorney Peterborough, United Kingdom 4,303. Carolina Cochabamba, Bolivia Fukushima loroño 4,304. Sarah Dell Norwich, VT 4,305. Cecilia Nunes Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 4,306. Virginie Giuliani Saint germain village, France 4,307. Kim Pellegrino Merritt Is, FL 4,308. Christina London, United Robertson Kingdom 4,309. Zuelyn Lacorda Davao city, Philippines 4,310. GRAZIA Motta Visconti, Italy MAROCCO 4,311. may Howie paisley, United Kingdom 4,312. anne gruetzner dortmund, Germany 4,313. rolande dumont haubourdin, France 4,314. Deb Lambert Pittsboro, IN Why Ian this important to me?!? Why not! Animals were put here on this earth by God in order that we be their caretakers. He entrusted them to us. This is cruel and I humans and needs to stop now. 4,315. Miss Stone Glos., United Kingdom 4,316. Maenhaut Tourcoing, France Christine 4,317. frieda lisens merksem, Belgium 4,318. Diane Obrien Jeff twp, PA Chains - inhumane. Hawaii should be ashamed. 4,319. Renee bayside, NY Schoenbrun 4,320. bernadette bouliac, France L'animal est bien plus supérieur à l'homme, qui est un être lacambre abject !!! 4,321. Ines Jambrek Zagreb, Croatia BIG SIGN AGAINST DOGS ON CHAIN !!!!!!!!!!! Petrak 4,322. Rhonda Lynn Wallingford, CT Feniolo Page 155 - Signatures 4,298 - 4,322 Name From Comments 4,323. Evs Bstad Fargo, ND 4,324. daniela zugnoni samedan, Switzerland 4,325. Irma Montanez Newark, NJ Why would you do that why they are loving animals why because you don't have soul 4,326. Sam Duncombe Nassau, Bahamas 4,327. valerie cabal strasbourg, France 4,328. Darryl Russell Benton, KS This is an outrage! 4,329. cynthia takaht Garfield Hts, OH 4,330. consuelo crespo saint-imier, Switzerland 4,331. maria lily vargas cochabamba, Bolivia pacheco 4,332. Bel Ange Johannesburg, South Africa 4,333. Jennifer London, United This is disgusting what next for these poor dogs Drummond Kingdom 4,334. Mike Wright Le Vibal, France 4,335. anna luneau anna liège, Belgium 4,336. Janina Saciuk Winnipeg, Canada 4,337. Mel Derron Zürich, Switzerland 4,338. Ana Araya Guanacaste, Costa Rica 4,339. Luisa Fernandez Jaén, Spain 4,340. nastja potočnik koper, Slovenia 4,341. Laura García Malaga, Spain 4,342. Catherine Palmer Yucaipa, CA I love the state of Hawaii, but this cruelty to pets is difficult to defend. If you can't love and take care of these defenseless animals as if they were a member of your family, then you don't deserve to have any pets. It is a known fact that these animals actually love humans and want to be a part of the family. Please don't allow laws to exist where they are allowed to be chained up and mistreated. If you have no heart for family pets, don't have one. 4,343. Vickie Rico Yuma, AZ 4,344. Don Sizemore Florence, AL 4,345. Ana Echevarria Gijon, Spain 4,346. Klaudia Zoisl Eibiswald, Austria 4,347. Grace Wong Chalfont, PA 4,348. Tracey Williams Tullahoma, TN 4,349. Diana Jiménez Mexico, Mexico

Page 156 - Signatures 4,323 - 4,349 Name From Comments 4,350. yvette catoul henin beaumont, France 4,351. ROBYN TULSA, OK THIS IS HORRIFIC STOPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP THIS WOODLEE 4,352. annie boulanger clichy sous bois, France 4,353. marin schneider frankfurt, Germany 4,354. Lorena Mella Piña La Serena, Chile 4,355. Brenda Peppard Shelby, NC 4,356. Gord Sanderson Calgary, Canada 4,357. Ekaterina Nikolova 15/1, Russian Federation 4,358. Marta Fraserburgh, United Prusinowska Kingdom 4,359. myra egan Surrey, United Kingdom 4,360. Jovaka Aleksic Beograd, Serbia 4,361. Elizabeth Freehold, NJ Roenbeck 4,362. Barbara Fey Mußbach, Germany 4,363. Drazenka Rudij Zagreb, Croatia Pavec 4,364. haustrate sandrine croix, France Get Dogs Off 3 foot Logging Chains in Hawaii 4,365. DEBBIE HOLTS SUMMIT, MO HAMMON 4,366. agnes moreau tours, France 4,367. Sharyn Luedke Alton, IL 4,368. Phoebe Margaret Yarmouth, Canada NO animal should be in chains; especially tethered this way, and on extremely short leashes out in horrid hot conditions alone and afraid of what's to come. Please PLEASE end this law for good!!! 4,369. Samantha Rose Sheerness, United Kingdom 4,370. melany ledesma bartolomé, Argentina 4,371. antonio balsera Madrid, Spain 4,372. Brigetta Johnson Bainbridge Island, WA 4,373. Lynne Bullock , United Kingdom 4,374. Geetu Poduval Pune, India 4,375. Patricia Turner Bakersfield, CA Turner

Page 157 - Signatures 4,350 - 4,375 Name From Comments 4,376. Joy Stevens Cannock, United Kingdom 4,377. Susann Knerr 4665, Switzerland 4,378. danijela stjepovic Beograd Cacak, Serbia 4,379. Lori Obrien Dundalk, Ireland 4,380. Fabienne Bovy Oupeye, Belgium 4,381. alexandra la guaira, Venezuela FIRMENNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN POR FAVOR FALTAN stpiljkovic dax MUCHAS FIRMASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS 4,382. Marie-France Fontenay-Trésigny, Taillebois France 4,383. maria isabel valladolid, Spain castillo garcia 4,384. Susan Wyatt Pasadena, MD 4,385. Jenny Skelton Halifax, United Kingdom 4,386. Jan Mann Okotoks, Canada 4,387. Todd Burgh Walkerton, IN 3 foot of chain ....that is just hard to beleave...It has got to stop ... 4,388. Linda Gilmore Berger, MO No animal should ever be mistreated this way. Put that chain around the owners neck for a month and keep him tied up that way. Let him see how he likes it. 4,389. Conchi Carrion Barcelona, Spain 4,390. Ann La Hayward, CA STOP IT DO THAT DOG THIS IS CALL ANIMALS ABUSE idiot 4,391. Ian Hands Birmingham, United Kingdom 4,392. Alejandra Ramírez San Luis Potosí, Mexico 4,393. Ingeborg Baierl Rodgau, Germany 4,394. Mel Walker Pembrokeshire, United Kingdom 4,395. Antje Lange Dortmund, Germany 4,396. marie-christian nancy, France Durand 4,397. majda navotnik ljubljana, Slovenia 4,398. Patrik Nesovice, Cook DEVOCELLE Islands 4,399. dede arroyos albi r, France 4,400. Hanna Cuno VALDEMARSVIK, Sweden

Page 158 - Signatures 4,376 - 4,400 Name From Comments 4,401. Rebecca Fullman Birmingham, AL 4,402. DEBBY PELLOM bradenton, FL 4,403. Patricia GERMAIN MOULAY, France 4,404. Bonnie radafshar Westbury, NY No dog should be chained like this. 4,405. angel mariani gloversville, NY 4,406. Лариса Москва, Russian Летуновская Federation 4,407. Drazana Priboj, Serbia Jakovljevic 4,408. Karin Bosshard Rmasen, Switzerland 4,409. Meghan Heathrow, FL this is cruelty and should be illegal Schuessler 4,410. myriam roussel hellemmes, France Horrible des monstres font subir cela 4,411. Shauna Lewis Wexford, Ireland 4,412. Kerstin Ficht Brackenheim, Germany 4,413. Rebecca A Schrot Medford, MA 4,414. Linda Copain Brooklyn, NY 4,415. Rachel Rawlings Wareham, MA Could we try to be civilized! This is horrific treatment!!!! Save these dogs!!!! 4,416. Mandy Tshibangu Devon, PA 4,417. Alissa Ebertz Webster, NY 4,418. nadine richer nevers, France 4,419. B Verbeek Essen, Belgium 4,420. Mary Ellen N. Adams, MA Please stop this cruel tethering of dogs. Faustini 4,421. Marilyn Stubler Dickinson, ND 4,422. Patricia Bowker Hudson, FL 4,423. Brenda Beal Sonoma, CA 4,424. ANA PEZO McLean, VA 4,425. Dina Caldwell Mount Vernon, NY 4,426. Katja Matthes Gladbeck, Germany 4,427. Sharon Minken San Anselmo, CA 4,428. Esther Lopez Tucson, AZ 4,429. maria moyers harrisonburg, VA 4,430. dori butterick Fuquay varina, NC this is animal abuse 4,431. Robert Raskey Falcon, CO 4,432. Sally Wieland Willits, CA

Page 159 - Signatures 4,401 - 4,432 Name From Comments 4,433. Angela Llandysul, United Richardson Kingdom 4,434. abby hampstead MK, United Kingdom 4,435. mike losban penzance, United Kingdom 4,436. FIORELLA lima, CHIABRA 4,437. Marjorie Caldon Ridgewood, NY 4,438. Diane Kelly Telford, United Kingdom 4,439. Stephen Welsh Bethlehem, PA 4,440. Phillip` Smith` Wigan, United Kingdom 4,441. Maria Difunde Cadiz, Spain En la actualidad la ley de Hawai todavía permite el uso de cadenas de registro de 3 pies de largo para amarrar permanentemente a los perros a los neumáticos, árboles y otros objetos estacionarios. Esto provoca la disminución de nuestras comunidades, así como pone a las personas en riesgo. También es Abuso Animal y está muy extendido en las islas 4,442. Janine Marliani Orihuela, Spain 4,443. Nicole weise lugau, Germany 4,444. Toni Sanders Travelers rest, SC It is so sad to me to see dogs on chains , the only life they know is on that heavy short chain ,everyone that does that to an animal should have to drag that chain around for a while 4,445. Renee wick veneta, OR 4,446. yolanda smith , NY 4,447. Sharon Grace Dunedin, FL 4,448. chrysanthi skiada Medford, NJ 4,449. Gail Jones Mazarron Murcia, Spain 4,450. Scott B. Gillespie, IL This makes me sick!!!!! The true animals here are the ones that chain these dogs up like this and should be prosecuted for severe animal abuse, let me chain these no good assh***s up!! 4,451. Doreen Pryor Tetbury, United Kingdom 4,452. Yvonne Bechthold Kronberg, Germany 4,453. kirsty holt consett, United Kingdom 4,454. Pebbles Arroyo Aguadilla, PR Animals deserve to be treated with respect. 4,455. Nigel Sawyer DECATUR, GA

Page 160 - Signatures 4,433 - 4,455 Name From Comments 4,456. Inez Giusti Bronx, NY This is disgusting that these poor animals are treated so badly. This type of abuse MUST be stopped. 4,457. Kim Ziegler Bakersfield, CA 4,458. Renee Alonso Port St. Lucie, FL 4,459. ARACELY QUITO, Ecuador GUANO 4,460. Silvana Falcone Basel, Switzerland 4,461. Karen Jasiak Howard Beach, NY 4,462. Joan Z Dufresne Leominster, MA 4,463. nora cano caracas, Venezuela 4,464. Renee Koenitzer Stittville, NY 4,465. Catherine Didsbury, Canada Desjarlais 4,466. deborah odonnell southern pines, NC Kind of surprised that Hawaii is so 'backwards' regarding humane laws for animals. Won't be visiting there any time soon. 4,467. barbara le-vahn leedfs, United Kingdom 4,468. Maria Ianc Zaragoza, Spain 4,469. Susan Wyndham Fredericksburg, VA 4,470. Beate Schütte Hanstedt, Germany 4,471. Arlene Macintodh Sunny Isles Beach, FL 4,472. Linda Ferrara Manorville, NY 4,473. josiane antoine , France 4,474. Kelly Solomon Houston, TX 4,475. Nick Belmon Bergvik, Sweden 4,476. Cathy Goodman Flanders, NY 4,477. Angela Stavinoha Whitehall, PA 4,478. Angela Mayer Ensenada, Argentina 4,479. Marci Shorno Blairstown, NJ 4,480. Lesley Good Fareham, United Kingdom 4,481. Angela Blades Padgate, United Kingdom 4,482. karla antoñanzas barcelona, Spain 4,483. G Griego Albuquerque, NM 4,484. Jeana Allred Paul, ID 4,485. sirena green kingston, NY 4,486. Mike Wood Fort Wayne, IN

Page 161 - Signatures 4,456 - 4,486 Name From Comments 4,487. Terilynn Bennett Pike, NY 4,488. Cheryl Caplan Wallingford, CT What the f*ck is wrong with you people?!! *humanity: the blight of the planet 4,489. Mark OFFERMAN NEW YORK, NY 4,490. Susan Pietri New York, NY Tears my heart to pieces to see man's best friend treated this way. Even if it's a working dog. So sad. 4,491. Jean Dixon Charlottetown, Post to Hawaii sites. Let that industry help. Canada 4,492. Darlene Schueler Estill Springs Franklin County, TN 4,493. Debbie Czujko Garfield, NJ 4,494. Kathleen Sigel Cmch, NJ 4,495. Ann Hammond Lancaster, OH 4,496. Stefan Krueger Troy, NY 4,497. Crystal stewart Butler, PA 4,498. K. Hendricks San Antonio, TX 3 foot chains?? How cruel!!! Y'all are really cruel to animals if you think that is fair in any way whatsoever!! You are messed up! Wake up!! Sorry sobs! YOU NEED TO STAY ON A 3 FT CHAIN FOR ABOUT A YEAR!!! 4,499. Guada Gamallo Ames, Spain 4,500. Lisa Sclafani SAINT JAMES, NY 4,501. Georgia Andon Phoenix, AZ Plz help these babies 4,502. barbara thompson roseville, CA 4,503. Judena Black Worthington, IN It's wrong, and heartless. 4,504. consuelo gallegos COACALCO, Mexico 4,505. Lauren Groff Vero Beach, FL 4,506. Kathryn Stensby Chicago Cook County, IL 4,507. Nichole Case East quogue, NY 4,508. Ayse Ozen Bron, France 4,509. Anna Sherling Rye Brook, NY 4,510. Patricia Gyselinck barrie, Canada 4,511. Adriana Lopez Bogotá Colombia, No es justo tenerlos amarrados con cadenas que lastiman y Colombia laseran sus pieles y tejidos,menos a sol y agua sin afecto ni caricias, son seres vivos sensibles noblescdulces inteligentebelloscque solo saben brindar amor incondicional 4,512. Kim Moore Boise, ID This is no life at all! It is just cruel! 4,513. Sandy Reyes Salt Lake City, UT 4,514. Eugenia Wofford Rochester, NY 4,515. Leslie Niglio Eht, NJ

Page 162 - Signatures 4,487 - 4,515 Name From Comments 4,516. Susan Founds Downingtown, PA 4,517. Barbara Drury Stroudsburg, PA No animal should be chained up 4,518. kathy Ballard Idaho Falls, ID 4,519. Teresa Tindoll Omak, WA This is cruel and inhumane. These dogs deserve a family who will love and care for them. They are sentient beings. 4,520. Marilyn Figueroa Phila, PA 4,521. Janice P. Joly Florence, AL 4,522. iris Morales Reilly LONG BEACH, NY 4,523. Susan Tomlinson Rocky mount, NC This is inhumane. ..it NEEDS TO STOP ! 4,524. Charlotte Cypress, TX This is WAY beyond 'just cruel' Bravenec 4,525. Cindy Porter HORNELL, NY they need to be a member of the family, not thrown outside and ignored!! 4,526. Judy Wilmarth Palmer, AK 4,527. noelene nr christchurch, New TOO CRUEL! sanderson Zealand 4,528. Maria Smith Chi, IL “The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated.” Gandhi 4,529. Theresa Elofsson Bradford, PA 4,530. Annette Hof Crooks, SD 4,531. C Vacarious Vsl, Canada 4,532. Debasri Roy NASHUA, NH 4,533. Charlene Winston New York, NY 4,534. Elizabeth Nateras México, Mexico S. 4,535. susan ignatowicz punta gorda, FL 4,536. Linda Smith Havrede Grace, MD 4,537. Jane Karasik Brooklyn, NY 4,538. Tina Andreatta Aptos, CA 4,539. Anastacia Correa Montvideo, Uruguay Firmado 4,540. Anita Clarke Lafayette, CA 4,541. Deb Booker Sioux falls, SD 4,542. Michelle Lewis Carlisle, IA 4,543. Jody Artale Atlanta, GA 4,544. Diane Boyer Chateauguay, Canada 4,545. Megan Odle Waverly, TN 4,546. Denise Kayser PORTLAND, OR 4,547. Linda Balcom Beverly Hills, FL 4,548. Claudia Florez Rockledge, FL Dogs dont belong on chains!!! Page 163 - Signatures 4,516 - 4,548 Name From Comments 4,549. angela torres queens, NY 4,550. Lynda Goin Edmonds, WA 4,551. Janet Wright Silver Spring, MD This cruelty must stop. 4,552. Donna Love Shirley, NY Its disgusting inhumane ABUSE! 4,553. Amy Mena Taylorsville, UT what the hell is wrong with people? This is animal cruelty. It has to stop. 4,554. Livia Petzold Duvall, WA 4,555. Susan Price Levittown, PA 4,556. Bonny Traughber Lafayette, TN 4,557. Donna Boguslav Astoria, NY 4,558. Lisa Barnett Farmington, AR 4,559. Mary Brian Baltimore, MD All animals deserve humane treatment so please stop this! 4,560. Amanda DiMaio Howell, NJ 4,561. Janey Busby Austin, TX 4,562. Clare Holahan Gurnee, IL 4,563. Susan Fogarty Hainesport, NJ 4,565. Donna Tomeo Massapequa Park, NY 4,566. Kelly Ayers Ontario, CA 4,567. Stephanie Davie, FL Witkoski 4,568. Sandra Bradford Fortuna, CA 4,569. Lynn Mansfield Monona, WI This law is inhumane and amounts to torture. 4,570. Shana Kelly Seattle, WA 4,571. Nancy Shankin Belleville, MI 4,572. marisela herrera managua, Nicaragua 4,573. Cara Vines Meridian, ID 4,574. Kristi Hermanson Madison, WI 4,575. Tori Taylor Calgary, Canada 4,576. DIANE Danielson Montello, WI An estimated 100-150,000 dogs on Hawaii island alone are currently kept on heavy chains, with some residents having 7-8 dogs chained up to trees-trucks- somewhere in their yard or just out in jungle, In this Heat. In 1997 the USDA ruled that people regulated by the Animal Welfare Act cannot keep dogs continuously chained. The American Veterinary medical Association has also spoken out against chaining on Bite Prevention Week YOU CAN DO BETTER. 4,577. Ramiqi Gloria Basel, Switzerland 4,578. Berenice Bernal Ciudad de México, Help please Mexico

Page 164 - Signatures 4,549 - 4,578 Name From Comments 4,579. sila paula dos colombo, Brazil santos 4,580. Vicky Sanders Durango, CO 4,581. Carol Revitz West palm beach, FL Putting dogs on chains is considered cruelty to animals. Why would Hawaii want to inflict this pain on animals 4,582. NORMA JONES LLANELLI, United Kingdom 4,583. ESPERANZA TOLUCA EDO. DE ESTO DEBE TERMINAR, SIN SERES VIVOS, FIRMEN PEREZ MEXICO, Mexico POR FAVOR !!!! 4,584. CARA DeFlorian CABOT, AR 4,585. Sandra Olsen Palmyra, TN Dogs do not deserve to live like this.it is abuse 4,586. Debbie McCray BAKER CITY, OR Where is the common sense of humanity here! These poor animals did nothing wrong why treat them so inhumane 😡😡 4,587. Jana Polillo Bend, OR 4,588. Vladimir Shaarey Tikva, Israel Zavelevich 4,589. Mickey Martin Claremont, CA 4,590. Diane Fulkerson Mammoth Lakes, CA 4,591. Pattie Kelly North Charleston, SC Pattie. Kelly 4,592. Joan Thitchener Ashley Falls, MA 4,593. Trish Morris Salisbury, United Kingdom 4,594. sandra rarick NEWBURY PARK, CA 4,595. Brenda Armitage Dixon, CA would you want to chained with a 3 foot chain? DO NOT OWN A DOG IF YOU CAN'T DO BETTER THAN THIS. 4,596. Betty Croak Harleysville, PA 4,597. Alison Clark Westhoughton Bolton, United Kingdom 4,598. TERESA BOWEN PONTIAC, MI I LOVE ALL ANIMALS. THEY ARE A LIVING CREATURES THAT GOD CREATED FOR TO ENJOY AND TO TAKE CARE OF THEM THATS WHAT GOD SAID. NOT TO MISUES ARE RESPONSIBILITY THAT WAS GIVEN TO US 4,599. vicky Saxton Traverse city, MI 4,600. Megumi Grasier Palos Verdes Estates, CA 4,601. Helena Lundblad Laupahoehoe, HI 4,602. marisol cañizares Cúcuta, Colombia 4,603. Deanna Marks Keaau, HI

Page 165 - Signatures 4,579 - 4,603 Name From Comments 4,604. Kimberly Detroit, MI Stankiewicz 4,605. delise bowley , United Kingdom 4,606. Claudia Baldo Quart, Italy 4,607. Jennifer Parket Los angeles, CA 4,608. Yvonne Knight Romford, United Kingdom 4,609. Karen Duncan Laupahoehoe, HI Dogs are social animals. Chaining them make them possessive and aggressive and is just wrong. Dogs in my neighborhood are chained on short leads and I never see anyone walking them or giving them the socialization they need and crave. People who chain dogs should NOT have dogs. Period. 4,610. Claudette Tooley Aurora, IL 4,611. Debbie Bardo Caerphilly, United Kingdom 4,612. Colette PERRET Villefranche, France 4,613. Linda Cote Kent, WA 4,614. Michele Andretta LA JOLLA, CA I am never going back to Hawaii. You people are nothing but animal abusers!!! 4,615. Linda Friend Pretoria, South Africa 4,616. Shaz Clarke London, United Kingdom 4,617. nelly begiashvili tbilisi, Georgia 4,618. Stefan Schulze Hameln, Germany 4,619. Paul Cherry Upminster, United Kingdom 4,620. Shelia McCullough Manchester, TN It should be animal abuse to do this. 4,621. yvonne olsen københavn s, What the h... is wrong with people? Denmark 4,622. Erika Fritz Mörf.-Walldorf, Germany 4,623. Debbie Gardo Catasauqua, PA 4,624. Donna Guarino West Harrison, NY 4,625. Zeljka Kamocaji Sarajevo, Bosnia And Herzegovina 4,626. Linda Borg Älandsbro, Sweden 4,627. Ginnette London, United Simmonds Kingdom 4,628. juan francisco Barcelona, Spain castro Page 166 - Signatures 4,604 - 4,628 Name From Comments 4,629. Treci Recatto Springfield, LA Take them off chains!!! Its cruel!!!! 4,630. Christiane Dalheim, Germany Es gibt zu viele perverse kranke Idioten, man muss etwas Reiß-Schäfer dagegen machen!!!! Es geht nur so!!!!! Auf die Regierung kann man sich nicht verlassen,schon traurig 😭 4,631. Evgeniya Moscow, Russian Terterashvili Federation 4,632. Deborah Mount laurel, NJ Dabrowski 4,633. Gordon Whillis london, United These drones are supposed to be civilised! I see nothing Kingdom that supports the theory. Morons 4,634. Wilma Karalis Ierapetra, Greece 4,635. Jill Kendall Lyndich, Australia 4,636. Tamara Sanikidze Moscow, Russian Federation 4,637. Miku Shah Gilbert, AZ 4,638. phillip breese kingstanding, United Kingdom 4,639. Terri M Carlson New Buffalo, MI Because I care 4,640. claudia john heusweiler, Germany 4,641. Alessandro Nova Kakhovka, Molokof Ukraine 4,642. Sheila Baggarley Charlotte, NC 4,643. Donna Birch Talbott, TN 4,644. nina hayzelden kent, United Kingdom 4,645. Bitel Elvy Asta Göteborg, Sweden Backman 4,646. Joke haan hoogezand, Netherlands 4,647. Ciss Powell Louth, United Kingdom 4,648. Melanie Look Ibbenbüren, Germany 4,649. Silvia Moreno Galapagar, Spain 4,650. Teresa Smith MBORO, TN 4,651. Maria Morillo torremolinos, Spain Ortega 4,652. Estelle Sanders Mechelen, Belgium 4,653. Tracie Stone Exeter, United Kingdom 4,654. Beth Santana Avon, OH 4,655. Véro Végane Bruxelles, Belgium

Page 167 - Signatures 4,629 - 4,655 Name From Comments 4,656. Kathleen Curran Ridgefield, CT Shame on you Hawaii - this is disgraceful 4,657. Heather Suffron Presque Isle, WI 4,658. Djuana Payne Canton, NC 4,659. Kristi Dolch Des Moines, IA 4,660. Patricia von der New York, Sweden Burg 4,661. sue west bean station, TN No dog should be a chain dog; they need to interact with humans; that's their purpose in this life. 4,662. Paula Voelkel Belleville, IL 4,663. ewa igras Montréal, Canada 4,664. Marie Fort Arlon, Belgium 4,665. Pascal Biewer Wadern, Germany 4,666. Beatrijs V. Ath, Belgium D'Herde 4,667. Diana Steenhuis Papendrecht, Netherlands 4,668. Nicole Kearney Beachwood, NJ 4,669. Annita Baid Berkshire, United Kingdom 4,670. Esme P Morley, United Kingdom 4,671. Mary IKnapp Kendall park, NJ Dogs shluld run free 4,672. Darlene Jesson Anaheim, CA 4,673. Petra Osawaru Neuwied, Germany 4,674. Anja Torgersen Munke Bjergby, Denmark 4,675. ute christner Essen, Germany 4,676. Laurie Martinez, CA Sparrow-Price 4,677. Laura Sequi , Italy 4,678. Shu Lin MOUNTAIN VIEW, CA 4,679. Janice Aedy Ruislip, United DISGUSTING CRUELTY!!!!!! Kingdom 4,680. Maria Palmer Huntersville, NC 4,681. Владимир Березники, Russian Истомин Federation 4,682. Mqarjorie Gilson Groom, TX 4,683. Marina Moscow, Russian Federation

Page 168 - Signatures 4,656 - 4,683 Name From Comments 4,684. Gisela Gern Sindelfingen, Germany 4,685. Beverlee Stone Woodland Hills, CA Goodman 4,686. Dr John F Doorish Brooklyn, NY Animals should either be brought indoors when it is too hot or too cold, or they should be taken away from the s0-called "owners!" 4,687. Cynthia Bremerton, WA Baumeister 4,688. kellie kinnett corfu, NY 4,689. Emma Thomas Ceredigion, United Kingdom 4,690. Dorothy Plummer Oxford, PA 4,691. erika moreno sanluis potosi, Mexico no podremos parar la crueldad con los animales pero ahi que intentarlo y no quedarnos de brazosw cruzados 4,692. Angwla Swift Halifax, United Kingdom 4,693. Karen Carruthers Carlisle, United Kingdom 4,694. Phyllis Jacobson Chicago, IL 4,695. milly slobotham Eastbourne, United Kingdom 4,696. Shirley Hartman Palm Coast, FL We have to be their voice. This is animal abuse and neglect. Please take him off the chains and to a veterinarian for treatment. 4,697. Carol Layer Pennsville, NJ 4,698. Saundra Smith Jackson, OH 4,699. Jana Williams Gastonia, NC 4,700. Don Hughes CEDAR HILL, TX Moral incompetence 4,701. Madeline Stewart Northampton, United Kingdom 4,702. Darlene Therrien Winnipeg, Canada 4,703. Amberly Winter Sedro Woolley, WA 4,704. Linda Higgins San Rafael, CA 4,705. Jan Haft Valley Village, CA Dogs need to be free to move around in the house or an enclosed yard! 4,706. Ingrid Phillips Geleen, Netherlands 4,707. Debbie Brent Columbia, MD dogs are sentient beings and it is cruel and abusive to keep them restrained on logging or any other type of chains. 4,708. Paula Regan Leeds, United evil practise by pschopa Kingdom

Page 169 - Signatures 4,684 - 4,708 Name From Comments 4,709. HELENA GLAZAR Ljubljana, Slovenia HOFBAUER 4,710. Александр Москва, Russian Михайлов Federation 4,711. don stone corpus christi, TX 4,712. Jack Herman , Italy 4,713. Susan Pierce Painted Post, NY 4,714. Joe Byrne Palm coast, FL 4,715. Lorna O'Shea Fayence, France 4,716. christine cabestany, France hernandez 4,717. Elaine Patrick Stark City, MO so cruel. 4,718. Elizabeth Manchester, NJ Shilanski 4,719. Neli Antalya- manavgat, Kondakhchiani Turkey 4,720. Janine Sanders Johannesburg, South Africa 4,721. hana mezei vanc, Canada Release this sweet doggie at once' .....let him be free now with good care for him" ...... 4,722. Violeta Lopez Mechelen, Belgium 4,723. Swagattaa Guwahati, India Sarmma 4,724. Rosa McDonald GASPORT, NY 4,725. Debbie Panter Hornell, NY 4,726. Ana Rivera Chicago, IL Because animals deserve better!! 4,727. Vickie Dudas Greenwich, CT 4,728. Elain Brown CLARKESVILLE, GA 4,729. JoAnn Howell Valparaiso, IN 4,730. Diderich Brodersby, Germany Langmannen 4,731. Shelagh Marshall West lothian, United Kingdom 4,732. Jeanne Bartsch Huntington, NY 'The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated.' ~ Mahatma Gandhi 4,733. Angela Murello, Italy Cavigliasso 4,734. xavier fernandez barcelona, Spain georges

Page 170 - Signatures 4,709 - 4,734 Name From Comments 4,735. PER BERGEN, Norway INGEBRIGTSEN 4,736. Lou Gephart Covington, OH 4,737. paula cook barnsley, United Just because a cruel and inhumane act has been done for Kingdom years does not make it part of your culture you idiots. Try to bring yourselves into the 21st century.... 4,738. kathy patton las vegas, NV 4,739. Rebecca Taylor Wallcrouch, United Kingdom 4,740. Eva Mcmaster Vardø, Norway 4,741. OLGA BENITEZ MEXICO, Mexico 4,742. David C. Mayer WILMETTE, IL 4,743. lorraine camm lincolnshire, United Kingdom 4,744. Jodi Traub Sioux Falls, SD 4,745. Rev Sue Howes Pleasant Hill, CA Hawaii...shame on you...I thought you were better then most states around here...this is crazy...and these dogs should not be like this...look at this dogs face with blood and tears..come on..wake up and get with it...the world knows how bad this is and is not happy...so treat these loving souls with love and compassion...no on logging chains..get them off of these evil things. 4,746. Zelda Conradie Struisbaai, South Africa 4,747. Jackie Gibbs Macclesfield, United Kingdom 4,748. Betty Hosner Lapeer, MI 4,749. Lale Halimoglu Istanbul, Turkey 4,750. Chris Santiago OSSINING, NY 4,751. Lu Parneaux Calimesa, CA Dogs are not pieces of furniture! They are sentient beings with feelings just like humans. Please, this must stop!!!! 4,752. Jodie Benjamin West Moors, United Kingdom 4,753. Carrie Brinkos Elizabeth, PA These idiots should not have animals! 4,754. Anne White Cochrane, Canada This is clearly a brutal and outdated law. 4,755. Angela Thomson Edinburgh, United Kingdom 4,756. Deni Hall Flora, IN 4,757. stan bryan calimesa, CA 4,758. JANET THOMAS LONDON, United Stop allowing this,so cruel not a third world country,a Kingdom beautiful island,which is really ugly.People should stop visiting your ugly islands.you are backward pople

Page 171 - Signatures 4,735 - 4,758 Name From Comments 4,759. james brusso raleigh, NC 4,760. Vanessa Beriain La Rioja, Spain 4,761. MARY taylor CHICAGO, IL 4,762. Sandra Carlin Warwick, RI 4,763. vera kierme sunnyside, NY cruelty 4,764. Marie Couture Toms River, NJ 4,765. beata stojalowska kerkrade, Netherlands im crying 4,766. Adriana Barros Toronto, Canada 4,767. Jodi Simmons Huntington, MA 4,768. Ani Kazantsev Melbourne, Australia 4,769. James Merrill Salem, OR 4,770. Lynda Pizzuto Los Angeles, CA 4,771. Paula Arsenault Kingwood, TX CRUEL 4,772. juju lafontene Lisboa, Portugal 4,773. Elena Knox Volcano, CA 4,774. P Pucher Janesville, WI 4,775. Sherry Schaffer Aberdeen, MD Barbaric! 4,776. Yolanda De los Cancún, Mexico Cobos 4,777. W Cariello baldwin, NY 4,778. Mitch Briggs Sheffield, United Kingdom 4,779. Diane Beeny Westfield, NJ 4,780. KARI NICKLAUS ROCHESTER, MN 4,781. Angela Ford Heiskell, TN 4,782. Tabitha Totten Cliffside Park, NJ 4,783. Beatriz Rosales Montreal, Canada 4,784. Tala Lakota White House, TN 4,785. Marla Rivera Bronxville, NY 4,786. julie parkin Torquay, United Kingdom 4,787. Carrie Davis Bangor, ME 4,788. Lisa Siroky Sarasota, FL 4,789. Angela Ruiz Palm Bay, FL 4,790. jan lauwasser berlin, Germany 4,791. Melissa Bridgewater, MA Moutsatsos 4,792. Michelle Peacock valley village, CA no living creature should EVER be on a chain!!

Page 172 - Signatures 4,759 - 4,792 Name From Comments 4,793. Diane Glass Cody, WY Cruelty is never acceptable 4,794. Cheryl Evard Gering, NE The only reason one would put a dog on a logging chain would be for . That's illegal and logging chains should be as well. 4,795. joanna ingleby kent, United Kingdom 4,796. Margaret Atkins Sheffield, United Kingdom 4,797. linda rohret Coralville, IA 4,798. Maria Alvarado Bradenton, FL 4,799. corine Noiren pap, France 4,800. Kelli Catropa Northport, FL 4,801. maryann sworen AVOCA, AP 4,802. Cheryl Dullabaun Redlands, CA I abhor mistreatment and torture of all beings! 4,803. Tuba Demir Varol istanbul, Turkey 4,804. Lisa Trendall LOWESTOFT, This is animal brutality at its worst...! Yet again another SUFFOLK., United animal plight coming from the land of the Free, unless your Kingdom an indigenous American or an Animal !! Get these dogs to safety now. If you can take photos of them, ypu can get to them. Get them into safety and a loving home instantly. 4,805. tracey brenland London, United Kingdom 4,806. Donna Dambrosio Aldan, PA 4,807. Irasema Flores Coral Springs, FL 4,808. Barry Spurr Stanmore, Australia 4,809. Linda Feldt PLYMOUTH, MN 4,810. Lori Pickail RINGWOOD, NJ 4,811. marian ciruelo bilbao, Spain 4,812. Lindsey Mathews Boise, ID 4,813. Teresa Elvira Barcelona, Spain 4,814. Terry Robinson Ogden, UT 4,815. Linda Bowes Mitchell, Canada Because no anim al should be treated this way. Would you do this to a person? 4,816. B J Van Camp Memphis, TN 4,817. Eric Brooks Devonport,, Australia 4,818. Sarah Taylor Bury St. Edmunds, United Kingdom 4,819. Glynneth Elser Durban, South Africa 4,820. JUDY DENDERA TORONTO, Canada 4,821. Julia still Lenox, MA

Page 173 - Signatures 4,793 - 4,821 Name From Comments 4,822. Barbara Ithaca, NY Keshishoglou 4,823. Rachel Casper, WY Blankenship 4,824. Diana Monks Victoria, Canada 4,825. Mark Ennis Penn Valley, CA 4,826. Debbie Honeywell Waynesboro, PA 4,827. Patricia McCauley Anaheim Hills, CA 4,828. Tamara Fassett Monte vista, CO This is barbaric and dangerous for all! Get rid of dog fights and boar hunts. This is just horrible! 4,829. Elizabeth Graham Temple Terrace, FL 4,830. Josiane Dumas Calgary, Canada 4,831. Terri Cecchini Richester, NY 4,832. john brusen E Perth, Australia 4,833. N T Waterloo, IA 4,834. Samantha Raftery victoria, Canada 4,835. Cariann Duncan, Canada Cause cruelty to animals is not right animals should be Robertson treated with respect. 4,836. Frances Rivera Brooklyn, NY Because I've had as a young girl dogs as pets. My father loved them as well. He brought home all the strays. I grew around them. They have feelings just like us. They get sad, and they get happy. They have families, they have so much courage, and wisdom. They don't deserve this. So yes that is why it is important to me. 4,838. Maggie Calkins Mante-Carlo, Monaco 4,839. martine vrassy Athens, Greece 4,840. Pat Gowland Bradford, United Kingdom 4,841. Debbie Heaton Cedar Rapids, IA 4,842. Joanne Tacy Malone, NY 4,843. pam brandis tamborine mountain, It is ignorant & cruel to think a dog should be tethered & Australia alone.They are very social & need to have more space.If you cannot contain a dog you should not have one! 4,844. derrick chesterton Naalehu, HI 4,845. Nakia Anderson Pueblo, CO 4,846. Lisa Francia Hendersonville, NC 4,847. Anne Settanni Normal, IL 4,848. Janine Ruffo Hartford city, IN 4,849. Marion Martin Carnegie, Australia

Page 174 - Signatures 4,822 - 4,849 Name From Comments 4,850. Michele Shinn WEST SACRAMENTO, CA 4,851. christian kaloga london, United Kingdom 4,852. coller sabine Magland, France 4,853. gillian grieder copenhagen, Denmark 4,854. Joan McCormick Milwaukee, WI 4,855. Jozee Tjoa Kralendijk, Bonaire 4,856. Gabriella Saja Casale litta, Italy 4,857. Donna Marsh London, United Kingdom 4,858. Abhimanyu Singh Jaipur, India 4,859. nadège Fourques Gard, carcanague France 4,860. lindsey Lewis Westcliff, United Kingdom 4,861. April Kanonik West Mifflin, PA 4,862. Silvia Catalina Bucharest, Romania OPRISAN 4,863. Angelia Becker Sullivan, MO I am the voice of all animals 4,864. Susan Coppinger Mesa, AZ Stop this cruel treatment. This is absolutely horrifying treatment of a precious life. Think hoe it would feel. Animals feel things like we do. Whoever did this needs punished and jailed. Make an example of them, and it may help to stop this. Obviously the people that do tgese sick things to animals are not going to stop out of the goodness of their hearts. They have no feelings. Sociopaths. 4,865. Radka Murgova South shields, United Kingdom 4,866. Mark Donnelly Renfrewshire, United Kingdom 4,867. Gunilla Swenson Norrköping, Sweden This is animalcruelty on the highest level!! SHAME on you!!! This has to STOP right NOW!!! 4,868. Joanna Gorniak Glasgow, United Kingdom 4,869. Michael Murphy London, United how cruel Kingdom 4,870. Beate Fielitz Stendal, Germany 4,871. saga sundström helsingfors, Finland 4,872. Elly Hilversum, Dorland-Verwaal Netherlands

Page 175 - Signatures 4,850 - 4,872 Name From Comments 4,873. Cathrine Sverre Oslo, Norway 4,874. Oleg Golenja Bremen, Germany 4,875. lyn pruneau pretoria, South Africa 4,876. Christopher Wright perth, United Kingdom 4,877. Kathy Eichhof Lake worth, FL 4,878. Nicholas Harris Figeac, France 4,879. Patricia Marshall Boston, MA 4,880. Helen Foote Osceola, IN 4,881. Jacqueline Jewula millom, United Kingdom 4,882. jeanne albin warsaw, MO 4,883. Mariam Bravo London, United Kingdom 4,884. Alma Jonsson Eskilstuna, Sweden 4,885. Nafsika Tentokali Thessaloniki, Greece 4,886. Heather Taylor Plympton park, Australia 4,887. Hilary Harris Catskill, NY Cruel. 4,888. alwy visschedyk west hollywood, CA 4,889. Chantal Beaudette L'Ange-Gardien, Canada 4,890. dishanie fernando toronto, Canada 4,891. Mary Gallo Lorain, OH 4,892. Lota Bernard Albany, NY This us degusting and Inhumane. No dog deserves to be chained up all the time outside 4,893. Amber Veeg Perth, Australia Sheer cruelty 4,894. Rhonda Banks Manchester, GA 4,895. Marjorie Gauntt Ft. Worth, TX Hawaii is part of the United States. They are not immune from our laws. 4,896. Abby Soyka Amherst Jct, WI 4,897. Darlene Ghents Holtsville, NY 4,898. Joanne Ferry Creston, Canada 4,899. Dabney Mason Viola, DE Dogs need to be able to move around. To chain them so tightly is brutality 4,900. joshua gogarty Pacific Grove, CA 4,901. Eugene Hyon New York, NY 4,902. Beverly Guz Howell, NJ 4,903. Maggie Aachen, Germany Heckmann

Page 176 - Signatures 4,873 - 4,903 Name From Comments 4,904. Dean Grice Rugeley, United Kingdom 4,905. Silvita Di Hanover, PA PUT THE CHAIN AROUND YOUR NECK...PSEUDO HUMAN !!! 4,906. Trudy Craig Sturgeon County, people need to be chained like the animals, so they can Canada experience what the poor animals go thru 4,907. Kate Chapman Royal wootton Bassett, United Kingdom 4,908. Julie Nora Sunnyside, NY 4,909. Ko Ferrandes Soustons, France 4,910. sekine tsuneo nishitokyo, Japan 4,911. PAm Hall Glen allen, VA 4,912. Denise Bunce Weston on the Green, United Kingdom 4,913. Sonia Bryan London, United So horrible and inhumane. Kingdom 4,914. M Paradis Rockport, MA 4,915. Kelly Martins Viseu, Portugal 4,916. Minna U Lyly, Finland 4,917. Janet Kennedy Dewsbury, United Kingdom 4,918. Lindsey Winters New port richey, FL 4,919. Michele Goldberg Encino, CA 4,920. Elisa F SANTA MARIA, CA 4,921. Arnold Scher N. Chesterfield, VA 4,922. Alison Everest Sevenoaks, United Kingdom 4,923. Frederic Dubois Mercus garrabet, France 4,924. Pauline York, United Kingdom McSweeney 4,925. Valerie Troup Westland, MI 4,926. Donna Crescioli Carmichael, CA 4,927. Kaylen Callahan Phoenix, AZ 4,928. Jennifer Willis Nottingham, United Kingdom 4,929. Carol Patterson RUSSELLVILLE, AR 4,930. Noelle Fincham HOXIE, KS 4,931. victoria mathew san antonio, TX

Page 177 - Signatures 4,904 - 4,931 Name From Comments 4,932. Soula Christos Johannesburg, South Africa 4,933. Gwen Larkin Swindon, United please this is so sad how cruel Kingdom 4,934. Pamela Thomas Lucasville, OH 4,935. ana locke goose creek, SC This is an assault to the community.... abuse and neglect by subhuman should not be tolerated..legislate for a tougher sentencing should be in every state in the nation. 4,936. Helen Wordsworth Pontefract, United Kingdom 4,937. Sabine Beffert Pforzheim, Germany 4,938. Sylvie Taliercio Megeve, France 4,939. Martine Sulpice Paris, France 4,940. Sylvia Cooke Warrington Cheshire, United Kingdom 4,941. Debbie Jenner South Boston, MA 4,942. DAve Siverns Tipton, United Kingdom 4,943. Jill I hara Leeds, United Kingdom 4,944. Wendy Palmer Sheffield, United Kingdom 4,945. Vanessa Clark Manchester, United Kingdom 4,946. Carmen David barlad, Romania 4,947. Teresa Maddox Irondale, AL I dont think any animal should be on any chain 4,948. surendra prasad hyd, India 4,949. MaryGrace , Malta Maxwell 4,950. Julie Pickhardt Savannah, GA 4,951. Daryl Cobb Bradford, United Kingdom 4,952. Janis Collins Waldorf, MD Evil and very cruel!!Change the laws to protect these innocent souls!! You do not need a dog if the dog will be on heavy or light weight chains and in yard all the time!! 4,953. Barbara Higgins LIVERPOOL, United Kingdom 4,954. Jossie Moran Ocklawaha, FL BARBARIC AND CRUEL...THESE DOGS DON'T DESERVE THIS TREATMENT..! 4,955. Martha Grünewald Düsseldorf, Germany 4,956. ARLENE CHESHIRE, CT MESSENGER Page 178 - Signatures 4,932 - 4,956 Name From Comments 4,957. Louise Fallon London, United Kingdom 4,958. Keziah Morgan Ipswich, United Kingdom 4,959. Mary Ann Toy CHICHESTER, NH 4,960. Gio Tonini Piacenza, Italy Sono un essere Umano e voglio bene a tutti gli Animali. 4,961. Rachel Michaux saint Nazaire, France 4,962. michelle lewis malaga, Spain 4,963. Jennifer Edwards Herne Bay, United Kingdom 4,964. Carole Arbour hudson, NH 4,965. Elaina Grant London, United Kingdom 4,966. Amanda Clark Glasgow, United Kingdom 4,967. Emilie Nora Brignais, France 4,968. Karen Watton Broseley, United Kingdom 4,969. Judith Church Fort Myers, FL 4,970. Dot Sanders London, United Kingdom 4,971. Janice Urban Derry, NH 4,972. Sandra Gottschall ....., Germany 4,973. jackie reddington mount joy, PA 4,974. Sharon Shelley Oklahoma City, OK This is so cruel and inhumane 4,975. Teresa Ng Caringbah, Australia 4,976. Adrian Freeman Toronto, Canada 4,977. Valerya Moscow, Russian Nikanorova Federation 4,978. june wolf Buffalo, NY 4,979. Nicolo Bucaria Luxembourg, Luxembourg 4,980. Sherie Riley Sydney, Australia 4,981. Danii Ghenadie Chisinau, Moldova, Republic Of 4,982. Graciela Beyer Apostoles, Argentina 4,983. Kay Lonas Friendly, WV 4,984. Robyn Wilson Lorton, VA 4,985. Stacy Grant Loveland, CO 4,986. Pam Woodall Bonham, TX Ate you kidding me? Let us put a logging chain on you!!#

Page 179 - Signatures 4,957 - 4,986 Name From Comments 4,987. valérie Thomas Mérignac, France 4,988. Barbara J. Pierce Lancaster, TX 4,989. Wendy Andersen Columbus, OH 4,990. Kerstin Folwerk Biederitz, Germany 4,991. Margarete Neuss, Germany Hohmann 4,992. Tina Smythe London, United Kingdom 4,993. VERA DE DARTMOUTH CAROLIS DEVON, United Kingdom 4,994. Carmen Crepo Vega alta, Puerto Rico 4,995. helen soucy DDO, Canada 4,996. Rich Moran Brighton, MA 4,997. Kristyna Susice, Czech Stuchlikova Republic 4,998. ANNEMARIE RIEMST, Belgium KONINGS 4,999. Carla Silva Sintra, Portugal 5,000. Christel Jensen Slagelse, Denmark 5,001. alina stan constanta, Romania 5,002. Linda Greenberg Novi, MI 5,003. Alice Poremba LAS VEGAS, NV This is cruel and by the looks of this it's also abuse and neglect. No dog should have to live in this kinda hell 5,004. Barb Schmidt Apple Valley, MN 5,005. Mo Butler Lincs, United Kingdom 5,006. Antonella Rinaldi Roma, Italy 5,007. Lucy Lefebvre Ottawa, Canada 5,008. Marie Olsson Stockholm, Sweden 5,009. Lisa McKown College station, TX Because this is abuse and cruelty to animals stop this! 5,010. Warren Walker Maple Ridge, Canada 5,011. Maria Halloday Petetborough, United Kingdom 5,012. Mary Lagarde Goudswaard, Netherlands 5,013. Nikki Stoltenberg Grand blanc, MI 5,014. Thomas Miller Harrisburg, PA 5,015. Betina Nancy Albertslund, Denmark Reese

Page 180 - Signatures 4,987 - 5,015 Name From Comments 5,016. C Harris Glastonbury, United Kingdom 5,017. Nancy L. Lyon Fremont, CA 5,018. Jessica Curran Manchester, NH 5,019. Lindy Von Dohlen Pasco, WA 5,020. Yu-Na Chung BOSTON, MA 5,021. Marjorie Hass Hartshorne, OK 5,022. Christine nicholls york, United Kingdom 5,023. Reverend Jane Graton, CA Eagle 5,024. Tanya Seiverd Quarryville, PA 5,025. Colette Mannion London, United Kingdom 5,026. Lori Letourneau West Baldwin, ME Terrible!!! 5,027. bonnie courson new castle, PA 5,028. Madeleine Fisher Los Angeles, CA Currently Hawaii still law allows for use of 3 foot long logging Kern chains to permanently tie out dogs to tires, trees, other stationary objects. This causes decline of our communities as well as puts people at risk. It is also Animal Abuse and it is widespread on the islands. In 1997 the USDA ruled that people regulated by the Animal Welfare Act cannot keep dogs continuously chained. The American Veterinary medical Association has also spoken out against chaining on Bite Prevention Week. Fighting dogs are all kept chained. 5,029. Jacqueline Barrhaven, Canada Lamoureux 5,030. Roslyn Thompson Barton upon Humber, United Kingdom 5,031. Kim Waters Lower Belford, Australia 5,033. Laura Streit Milton, GA What a disgrace for Hawaii. This is a shameful secret that needs to come out and the laws need to be changed. So disgusting. 5,034. Leona Stewart Seminole, FL So damm cruel 5,035. Nancy MITCHELL Brechin, Canada 5,036. Debra Combs Blfd, WV 5,037. Nadja Leijonros Gothenburg, Sweden 5,038. Virginia Ma Wan, NT, Hong Hawaii is all about Ohana. This is barbaric and unnecessary. MacQueen Kong ALL LIVES MATTER. Stop the cruelty 5,039. Silvia Borges São paulo, Brazil 5,040. ryan sam South Windsor, CT 5,041. Martin Serena Fremont, CA Page 181 - Signatures 5,016 - 5,041 Name From Comments 5,043. trish ninaltowski stockton, NJ 5,044. Candice Spangler Roseville, CA 5,045. Donna Calver Norwich, United Kingdom 5,046. Enrique Figueroa Ventura, CA 5,047. Stephanie Nottingham, United Greatorex Kingdom 5,048. Lisa Martin London, United Kingdom 5,049. Joy Doogan Dumbarton, United Kingdom 5,050. Lorraine Fell Glasgow, United Kingdom 5,051. Sara Herrnicht Banstead, United Kingdom 5,052. Deborah Holt Manchester, United Kingdom 5,053. J Litchfield Caterham, United Kingdom 5,054. Lynne McGhie GLASGOW, United Kingdom 5,055. Helen Bishop Lincoln, United Kingdom 5,056. Lesley Denman Horley Surrey England UK, United Kingdom 5,057. Sharon Fidler Notts, United Kingdom 5,058. Elisa Manso Alfenas, Brazil Monteiro 5,059. Beth Dunn Walsall, United Kingdom 5,060. Sue Layer de la Haye, Dogs need to live indoors with the family not left outside DiMarco-Jones United Kingdom chained for years disgusting way to treat a living thing 5,061. Kerry-lynn Wortley Belfast, United Kingdom 5,062. Sapphire Mcinnes Blidworth, United Kingdom 5,063. A. Penardo Coventry, RI 5,064. Janet Shaw-Rutter Okehampton, United This is horrendously cruel to the dogs and must be stopped. Kingdom Dogs need freedom to move, exercise and perform natural dog behaviours. 5,065. Anne Cooper Mudgee, Australia

Page 182 - Signatures 5,043 - 5,065 Name From Comments 5,066. Shona Shipp Withersfield, United Kingdom 5,067. Helen Viner Devon, United Kingdom 5,068. Katherine Taylor Burnham on sea, I agree with the letter sent and it's reasons United Kingdom 5,069. Beth Thompson Hull, United Kingdom 5,070. Jay Kasraie Nottingham, United Its cruel dogs should be socialised not chained up and given Kingdom gunpowder to eat to make them aggresive Disgraceful ! 5,071. Clare Eagles Bedford, United Kingdom 5,072. ROY BRAMLEY MANSFIELD, United Kingdom 5,073. Elizabeth Usher Liverpool, United Kingdom 5,074. Angela Sanderson Tillsonburg, Canada 5,075. Alison Mason Toronto, Canada 5,076. Jen Saint Leicester, United Kingdom 5,077. Rachel Keeling Derby, United Kingdom 5,078. George Wilford Torquay, United This is no way to treat a living creature, they need love and Kingdom respect. 5,079. Eldon Sellars Heanor, United Kingdom 5,080. Lisa Thompson Hull, United Kingdom 5,081. colin redwood cardiff, United Kingdom 5,082. Victoria Fegan Nottingham, United Kingdom 5,083. Marianne Beames Malaga, Spain 5,084. Emma Foley Sleaford, United Kingdom 5,085. Claire Barber Bishops Stortford, United Kingdom 5,086. Gretchen Hunter MIddletown, MD 5,087. Veronika Olivier LEHIGH ACRES, FL 5,088. Kate Willison Matlock, United Kingdom 5,089. Audrey Meyer Roodepoort, South Stop abusing animals!!!!!!!! Are you living in the bloody dark Africa ages!!!!!! 5,090. Jessica Cain Athens, GA Page 183 - Signatures 5,066 - 5,090 Name From Comments 5,091. carole valenzuela Temple City, CA Think of yourself having to spend your life on a 3 ft chain. If not for you then why is it ok for them! It's not! 5,092. Paul Jenkins Toronto, Canada 5,093. Christy Hayes Pinconning, MI Because I love dog 5,094. Jane Mansfield, United FletcherBarnes Kingdom 5,095. Mark Kennedy Jackson, MI This is so sad, so cruel, so inhumane. Humans are the most evil monsters on this planet :-( 5,096. Sue Amell Harmony, FL 5,097. Diane house Loughborough, United Humanity treated quality of life of dogs cruel Kingdom 5,098. Teresa Coleman Nottingham, United Kingdom 5,099. Carolyn McIntyre Alexandria, United Kingdom 5,100. Jackie Robinson Oshawa, Canada 5,101. Carol Weatherall Stourbridge, United Kingdom 5,102. Michela Rebuli London, Canada 5,103. teresa robertson columbia, SC 5,104. Kristina Hall Hull, United Kingdom 5,105. Mark Lazeration Grand island, NY 5,106. J D Belfast, United Kingdom 5,107. Mariane Santo Milton, Canada 5,108. Sally Wilson Buena Park, CA 5,109. Rose Kasili Nottingham, United Kingdom 5,110. Mary Crosthwaite Fremont, CA 5,111. Glenys Hierzer Bradbury NSW, Australia 5,112. Sarah Hope Melbourne, Australia It is wrong and it has to stop. Tourism to Hawaii will drop because we share this information worldwide! 5,113. DAV WATSON hull, United Kingdom 5,114. Annette Ashton Glasgow, United Kingdom 5,115. Maria Bradley Coogee, Australia 5,116. Cynthia Deherve Drogenbos, Belgium 5,117. Marilyn N. Las Vegas, NV 5,118. Nick Hemmesch Las Vegas, NV

Page 184 - Signatures 5,091 - 5,118 Name From Comments 5,119. Roslyn Salazar Cornwall, NY Because I hate animal abuse. Why wouldn't it be important. Please end this barbaric practice now. 5,120. Irene Bouslama Clamart, France 5,121. BB Schumann Milwaukee, WI 5,122. Kostas Grigorakis Athens, Greece 5,123. Tammy Springfield, OH Huennerkopf 5,124. Claudia Ferreira Johannesburg, South Da Silva Africa 5,125. janet holtz twin lake, MI 5,126. Serena Michaelle Sydney, Australia B 5,127. Carmen Rico toronto, Canada 5,128. Michele smith Trenton, NJ 5,129. Christine Grace Robbinsville, NJ 5,130. barbara leone rockaway, NJ 5,131. AURO LIMON mexico, Mexico Freedom. 5,132. Liz Pain Woking, United Stop this cruelty now! Kingdom 5,133. katrin kunze gladbeck, Germany 5,134. Barbara Nestelbach, Austria Schmölzer 5,135. Patricia Gladding ASHEVILLE, NC GET DOGS OFF THREE FOOT LOGGING CHAINS IN HAWAII ‼️ 5,136. Sonya Barclay Linlithgow, United Kingdom 5,137. Lisa Downing Fletcher, NC 5,138. Sudeshna Ghosh Calcutta, India 5,139. Sudeshna Ghosh Calcutta, India 5,140. Vera Diepen London, Canada WTF - this is a supposed desired vacation destination??? Boycott! 5,141. Vicky Lightfoot London, Canada Unspeakable cruelty 5,142. Melanie Calgary, Canada I am so disgusted and SO disappointed in Hawaii!!!! STOP Weinmeyer THIS NOW! 5,143. Teri German Whiteland, IN 5,144. Melissa Brewer Portland, OR 5,145. Martina Cranbrook, Canada Frensemeier 5,146. Yan Loh Singapore, Singapore 5,147. kenneth beggs volcanoo, HI

Page 185 - Signatures 5,119 - 5,147 Name From Comments 5,148. Julie Dawson Orpington, United Kingdom 5,149. Tina Koudalakian Keaau, HI 5,150. Amy Fogle Clinton, NC 5,151. David Kettell Rochester, NY These dogs are innocent 5,152. Julie Brown Durham, United Kingdom 5,153. Joseph Yersak Fayetteville, NC No dogs deserves that 5,154. Luis Jonathan Madrid, Spain Pastor Fernández 5,155. Arlene Hale Newberry, FL This is insane, take the dog off the chain, why the hell would you even oun a dog on a 3 foot chain? 5,156. John Morewood San Jose, CA 5,157. Marina Spagnolo Hickory, NC 5,158. Eric Le masson Lanester, France 5,159. Annie O'Neill Ann Arbor, MI HUMANS this is beyond cruel beyond heartless and so inhumane! 5,160. Veronica Marquez San Bernardino, CA It is important to me because I don't think it is fair what they are doing to these poor fur babies they deserve a second chance at life and to be rehabilitated so they can get better and be able to be adopted in to loving forever homes why be blaming them for what they are pitbulls or not they should be excepted just like any other breed I am so sick and tired of these poor babies getting blamed for everything they should not be tied up on chains or left without food or water they should have everything a nice dog house plenty of shade food water just because they are animal's don't make it ok this just ain't right it is up to us to be their voice and to step up and protect them make sure they are given the proper treatment that they deserve educate yourselves before you assume the worst stop making them look bad that is why they are misunderstood and given the bad reputation they are not born bad it is the owners that raise them that way you raise them right they can get the most gentle loving caring protective fur babies all they want is to be loved given a chance and be part of a family no matter how bad they are treated or abused left for dead hungry abandon they still stand by you and love hard so give them that same respect let them know that their life's matter 5,161. Mary Garcia Mesa, AZ 5,162. Stacy Potz Clark's Grove, MN 5,163. Carmen Gil Soto Oviedo, Spain 5,164. Lori Combs Walled lake, MI 5,165. Kathy Maldonado Palm bay, FL

Page 186 - Signatures 5,148 - 5,165 Name From Comments 5,166. Rick Montoya Wrightwood, CA 5,167. Angel Stanca Avon Lake, OH 5,168. Selena Dixon Windsor, CA 5,169. Kimberly Nichols Hamilton, AL 5,170. R Bren Sullivan, IN Pittie lover ! Dog lover ! TGIF has to stop 🛑 5,171. Ann Mitchell Victoria, Canada 5,172. allison bergeron bridgton, ME 5,173. Meg May Brazil, IN 5,174. Kathy Snavely Melbourne, FL This is beyond cruel -- I would expect this from a 3rd world country if I hadn't read this is Hawaii. Forget culture -- this is archaic and cruel 5,175. Cheryl Earnest Centennial, CO 5,176. Karlee Barker Carrollton, GA 5,177. Robin Jones Longview, TX NO DOG SHOULD BE TIED OUT. ESPECIALLY ON A 3 FOOT CHAIN. IT'S INHUMANE AND CRUEL AND IS ABUSE AND NEGLECT. DOGS ARE SOCIAL ANIMALS AND SHOULD LIVE INSIDE WITH THEIR HUMANS. GET IT TOGETHER HAWAII AND GET INTO THE 21ST CENTURY 5,178. Lisa Schools Vancouver, WA 5,179. Sheryl Perryville, KY This is so cruel. Love them or don't have them. They Champagne deserve so much better, this is a horrible way to treat another creature. 5,180. Pamela Hilton Findlay, OH I do not believe in fighting or abusing digs 5,182. Dianna Correa Forest park, GA 5,183. Gina Vigliotti Port Charlotte, FL It is a very poor way for those dogs to live. They need to be shown love and to be cared for. We are their voice !!! 5,184. martha rico san antonio, TX 5,185. Connie Williams Leduc county, Canada To save those poor dogs from those heavy chains 5,186. Karen Royce Whittier, NC 5,187. Melissa Jones Waitakere, New Zealand 5,188. Carmen Gregory Valley Center, CA 5,189. Lisa Kuffel Chicago, IL Becuz itnis wrong an dthey shouldn't have pets if they can't take care of them 5,190. Dawn Hawkins Alpharetta, GA Shameful.... 5,191. Brittany Trujillo Garden grove, CA 5,193. Scot Monroe San Antonio, TX 5,194. Alison Roberts Edgewood, NM

Page 187 - Signatures 5,166 - 5,194 Name From Comments 5,195. Lynn Thomas Bromont, Canada 5,196. Ron McPherson Blaine, WA Dogs are supposed to be family. 5,197. Lesa Cook Kansas City, MO No Animal should ever be abused and treated like this. Throw them in jail for abuse we are their voices and the only ones that can save them. 5,198. Dawn Hogarth Whitby, Canada 5,199. Tammie Burnette Stanfield, NC 5,200. Tina Littlefield Massapequa Park, NY 5,201. Darcy Pomponio Hadley, PA 5,202. Jennifer Kanady EL DORADO, CA FREE OUR FETTERED FOUR LEGGED FAMILY! Our dogs do NOT deserve to exist like PRISONERS without any possibility of parole. We call them our BEST FRIENDS....well it's time WE start being THEIRS! They have waited LONG ENOUGH ! It's 2017! STOP this BARBARIC practice!! UNCHAIN OUR DOGS AMERICA! 5,203. Lynnette Spratley Macon, GA 5,204. Simone Morrison Huntsville, AL 5,205. Tammy Luppino Winchendon, MA 5,206. Moira Wells Kiln, MS 5,207. Michelle Stringer Friday Harbor, WA 5,208. Montse Monge Barcelona, Spain 5,209. Jeanne Crabb Fremont, CA 5,210. Lindsau Rhebb McDonald, PA 5,211. Muriel Mercier Astoria, NY 5,212. Jill Morris Lincoln city, OR Be their voice ❤️ 5,213. Dawn Ranek Contoe, TX 5,214. Paula Olney, MD this is abuse and is horrible!! Schum/Hamed 5,215. TERA BORDEN FONTANA, CA This is no life for them to live so why is it being allowed!!?!?! 5,216. Maria Chanino Algueirao lisboa, Portugal 5,217. Sandra Beach Madera, CA 5,218. Carol SANTA BARBARA, Kommerstad-ReicheCA 5,219. Robert Crego Conyngham, PA No animal should be chained to anything!!!! My dogs are always on a leash with me by there side and never left alone. It's a companionship when they are on a leash, I am there for them and they are there for me and my family. My dogs are family. I do not chain my children up outside so I do not (continues on next page)

Page 188 - Signatures 5,195 - 5,219 Name From Comments 5,219. Robert Crego Conyngham, PA (continued from previous page) chain my animals up outside. They are living creatures not possessions 5,220. Marmei France Davis, CA 5,221. Todd Halcomb Saint louis, MI 5,222. Carole Spencer Oklahoma City, OK 5,223. Dorthe Hansen Langeskov, Denmark 5,224. Morgan Minas Mastic, NY 5,225. Eileen Rutledge Aurora, CO 5,226. Lisa Snowden Baton rouge, LA 5,227. Amanda OOB, ME Bernheisel 5,228. Holly Harris Dunedin, FL Cruel, inhumane, and torture. 5,229. Patty Kowalczyk Peru, IL 5,230. Olga Touati Ipswich, United Kingdom 5,231. jennifer rabren Gulf breeze, FL 5,232. Tim Neeley Orlando, FL 5,233. Patricia Penley Amsterdam, Netherlands 5,234. Zeda Verheggen Amstelveen, Messios Netherlands 5,235. Lucia Ortega San Sebastián, Spain 5,236. Joanne Kilkelly Plymouth, United Just my love of animals Kingdom 5,237. Charity Colbert Santa Monica, CA 5,238. Evangelina Daniel Gentbrugge, Belgium 5,239. Merlynn Petito Anchorage, AK 5,240. Deborah Foster Mississauga, Canada 5,241. Susanne Eskilstuna, Sweden Andhager 5,242. Justine Kubica Hoffman Estates, IL 5,243. manuela grone oberpiesting, Austria 5,244. Sarah Tomer Edwardsville, IL 5,245. Della Lurusso Rothwell, United Kingdom 5,246. Tracey Stewart Bingie, Australia 5,247. Michael Bonacci Cliffside Park, NJ 5,248. Mary Metters Near looe, United Kingdom

Page 189 - Signatures 5,219 - 5,248 Name From Comments 5,249. Sussn Heller Silverado, CA 5,250. Crystal Smith Springtown, TX No animal should ever live on a chain 5,251. Emma Williams Falkville, AL 5,252. Dawn Chase Anchorage, AK 5,253. Jose De vries Leeuwarden, Netherlands 5,254. Lisa Burgess Teaneck, NJ 5,255. Lee Werner Elkhorn, WI 5,256. Inês Almeida Porto, Portugal 5,257. Larry Tamayo Downey, CA 5,258. Frances Brown Agat, Guam This is very important to all that loves animal! 5,259. Ann Doyle Mississauga, Canada 5,260. Stephen Yandina, Australia Penberthy 5,261. Donna War Budd Lake, NJ 5,262. Rose Thompson Amityville, NY 5,263. Franco Stefanoni Domodossola, Italy 5,264. Wyatt Kimberly Fenton, MI 5,265. Tracey Nouri Greenfield, MA How you are forcing them to life is a putrid existence and you should care that there is a quality of life It is neglect and forcing them to live unsocialized Please get them Off their heavy tow chain today 5,266. yolande gayte lyon, France 5,267. Christina Edwards Prenton, United Kingdom 5,268. Carolyn Counts Sedro Woolley, WA Humans are the worst species on earth to all other species! I'm shamed to be of the human species, they've gotten abusive and evil!! 5,269. Devona Jennings Spring, TX 5,270. Denise Bonet Segovia, Spain 5,271. daniele gautier cazeres, France 5,272. Donna Instrall Northampton, United Kingdom 5,273. Patricia Randolfi Montreal, Canada 5,274. Linda Forg Spring Creek, NV 5,275. Chantal Goupil Neuilly sur marne, France 5,276. LISA Maysonet Ocala, FL

Page 190 - Signatures 5,249 - 5,276 Name From Comments 5,277. NIKOLAOS ATHENS, Greece TSAKONAS 5,278. Alexandra Kirchdorf, Austria Juvancic 5,279. Elena Cretella New York, NY THERE A PRECIOUS LIFE 5,280. Karl Spence Blackburn, United Kingdom 5,281. Marty ann Ferro Mint Hill, NC smith 5,282. Alyce Wade Naples, FL 5,283. Susan Scott Reading, United Kingdom 5,284. Marzia Aiello Casteldaccia, Italy 5,285. Jeannine de BRUXELLES, Baenst Belgium 5,286. beatrice lippetal, Germany wassermann 5,287. Patti Mackie Featherstone, United Kingdom 5,288. Despo Matheou , Cyprus 5,289. Linda Mills Buford, GA 5,290. Veronika Widmer no, Germany 5,291. Lori Gwynn Jefferson, OH 5,292. Evelyn Döntgen Schramberg, Germany 5,293. Tracy Whitcomb CHEBANSE, IL This is just HORRIBLE!!!! These animals deserve to be set free and loved by their owners not left on a heavy chain and left outside!!!! PLEASE STOP THIS NOW!!! 5,294. Kathy Kammenga Mount Vernon, WA Dogs aren't lawn ornaments, they are living beings with feelings. Don't have one just to tie it outside. 5,295. Theresa Duncanville, TX Don't like seeing animals chained. Cummings 5,296. J Fox Orlando, FL Stop the insanity 5,297. georges brujan SAINT JEAN LA POTERIE, France 5,298. Maria Galatro New York, NY 5,299. Cheryl Lechtanski Middletown, NJ This is so cruel! 5,300. Adria Retos BROOKLYN, NY 5,301. Sherry Williams Daleville, AL 5,302. jane sandes fortaleza, Brazil

Page 191 - Signatures 5,277 - 5,302 Name From Comments 5,303. David Yacenick Chesterfield, MI And this, This is how an animal is supposed to be treated. I think not 5,304. Lee Ann Wilson Charleston, WV 5,305. annette moolman johannesburg, South Get rid of the chains now! Africa 5,306. Angie Augustine Mesa, AZ We have to stop treating our companions like "things"!!! Treat them for what they are...living feeling beings!! 5,307. Shannon Seymour Algonquin, IL 5,308. monika labudzka Αθήνα, Greece 5,309. Shari Landry Halifax, Canada It's time for the State of Hawaii to get involved and make it a criminal offence to have tethered dogs tied outside in the heat. I won't even go into using these animals to fight wild boars....City officials, get involved - for the animals who are living in unbearable conditions and the community who expects to be safe. Love all dogs. 5,310. sharon DiGenova toronto, Canada sanctioned abuse ha got to end. This is so unfathomably cruel and barbaric. It needs to end. 5,311. Jos Vautraversj Plaine, France 5,312. Rev Simpson Daytona, FL 5,313. Barbara Hinkle East Berlin, PA 5,314. Natalie Marconi Toronto, Canada 5,315. Joan Maynard Wokingham, United Kingdom 5,316. Lupit Akanke Roy, WA No animal deserve to live like that, or would the owner love Manassa to live like that daily 5,317. Celia Raia Palm Bay, FL This is abuse 5,318. Anjelica Moncada San Antonio, TX 5,319. Debra Roppolo Toronto, Canada 5,320. Kim Ford Windsor, Canada 5,321. Jennifer Manteno, IL Sosnowski 5,322. Heather Thomas Oshawa, Canada 5,323. Emily Tunstall Freedom, PA 5,324. Toni Hume Sandton, South Africa 5,325. Alexandra Chavez San Antonio, TX 5,326. Margaret Leat Essex, United Kingdom 5,327. Dominique De Prevessin, France backer 5,328. Cindy Johnson Dallas, TX 5,329. Sonja Thys Womlelgem, Belgium

Page 192 - Signatures 5,303 - 5,329 Name From Comments 5,330. maria harrington dracut, MA free the puppies 5,331. Alixte de Jaffinel Paris, France 5,332. Paula Harrington Las Vegad, NV 5,333. Nina Fischer München, Germany 5,334. Kobutsu Malone SEDGWICK, ME 5,335. elizabeth queen krakow, Poland 5,336. Roberta Wertman Waco, TX 5,337. Kumudini Kandy, Sri Lanka Thiranagamage 5,338. Beth Moore Elizabeth, PA 5,339. Chiqui Juris Katy, TX 5,340. Tamara Boico Antalya, Turkey 5,341. Rachel Walczyk West Valley, NY 5,342. heidi taylor NEWBURY PARK, CA 5,343. Annick Benavente Dededo, Guam Can we pass that here on Guam also, please, too many on chains no shelter from sun or rain, laying in their filth sad sad😤😭 5,344. Dianne Williams Chesapeake, VA 5,345. betty Pierre Flores PARIS, France 5,346. Cheong Zhen Ipoh, Malaysia 5,347. Catherine Forsling Casper, WY 5,348. Maria Arreola Del rio, TX 5,349. Traci Lopez Whitby, Canada 5,350. Deborah Sparaga West haven, CT 5,351. Bertha Nichols GILBERT, AZ 5,352. Diane Suppa White Plains, NY 5,353. Jesse Armaline Lakewood, OH 5,354. Andrea Hill Cary, NC 5,355. Deborah Perry Toronto, Canada This is horrible. Free the dogs. 5,356. Christy Noullet Columbus, GA 5,357. Beth Dwallibee White Bear Lake, MN 5,358. Jacqueline Genete Guilherand granges, France 5,359. Yadira Garay Edinburg, TX 5,360. Victoria Jenkins Thornton, CO 5,361. Sherryll Shaddock Nashotah, WI 5,362. maria Alchapar Ensival, Belgium Lopez Page 193 - Signatures 5,330 - 5,362 Name From Comments 5,363. Nosa Izekor Chigwell, United this is important to me I am an animal activist and I am Kingdom speaking for the animals that need a voice the animal that would like the voice heard properly and seriously they want to get their say and their say is said get dogs off 3 foot logging chains in Hawaii please remove all these horrible chains from the dogs they are hurting and suffocating please hear their feelings and their voice please I would also like everyone to sign this petition please for the sake of all the dogs out there in pain and hurting please sign this petition right now 5,364. Diana Szurgot Topsham, ME 5,365. Margo Watson Long Beach, CA 5,366. Leslie Davies Oceanside, CA 5,367. Helga Melgar Warwick, RI 5,368. Cesar Castro Zamora, Mexico 5,369. Carlos Sánchez Alicante, Spain Martín 5,370. Toni Benard Spring grove, IL No animal should live on a chain 5,371. Christine Cha Zuid Holland, Young Netherlands 5,372. sandra matsushita lages, Brazil 5,373. Grace Anne Los Angelis, CA I am their voice. If I need to fly to Hawaii to take it off I will. Pichay Who likes to be chained? No freedom. 5,374. Lesley Fetterman San Mateo, CA 5,375. Freddie Lussier El Dorado Hills, CA Because dogs were not meant to live on chains. They should be part of the family or don't have them. It is heartbreaking for them to live that way. And they can become neurotic. They are too sensitive to live like this. 5,376. Terry Spirer Wilmington, DE 5,377. kandi Collins Coldwater, MI 5,378. Ana Del Campo montlclair, NJ 5,379. Kathy King Ramona, CA 5,380. Sara Bellini Ficarolo, Italy 5,381. Denise Ignacio Upland, CA 5,382. Grete Bauer Gudensberg, Germany 5,383. Kelli Delaney Algona, WA 5,384. Elizabeth Juarez Montevideo, Uruguay 5,385. Kelli Harris Whitehouse Station, NJ 5,386. Denice Massengill PENN VALLEY, CA 5,387. Candi Dixon Lovettsville, VA Dogs deserve a better life then living on a chain. Page 194 - Signatures 5,363 - 5,387 Name From Comments 5,388. Talia Miller Fayetteville, NC 5,389. Sheryl Frianeza Cerritos, CA 5,390. Paola Villegas santiago, Chile Es una maldad, hacer tanto daño a un ser vivo que no puede defenderse, a un sin voz, que solo pide un pco de amor, son tan frágiles y fieles, que son capaces de dar la vida por uno... vamos a luchar por lo que le queda vida, sea feliz y digno de estar aquí con nosotros, muchas veces pienso que lo que debieran estar atado y encadenado tendríamos que ser los humanos que si tenemos raciocinio 5,391. Pamela Hryskiw Hamilton, Canada 5,392. Jacquelinenoone Methuen, MA Noone 5,393. Brooke Garnett Roswell, GA 5,394. Corinne White Voorhees, NJ 5,395. Sija Sur Zagreb, Croatia 5,396. Maria Borg Marsascala, Malta 5,397. Leonard Cates Northport, AL No dog should be on a chain 5,398. Sandra Richards Sulphur, LA 5,399. Dominique Overijse, Belgium Muyldermans 5,400. Minou Matute Panama, Panama 5,401. Larisa Long WOODSTOCK, IL 5,402. Tara Sears Cincinnati, OH 5,403. Mike Mihalow Robbinsville, NJ 5,404. Kevin Massey Louisville, KY 5,405. ANITA SAYERS PHOENIX, AZ The human race has proven itself to be the animals on this planet !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 5,406. B. Calzada Maastricht, Netherlands 5,407. Susan Cole North Shields, United Kingdom 5,408. h smith la, CA 5,409. Sandra Ferrand la richardais, France 5,410. Rebecca Reyes El Paso, TX 5,411. MaryAnn Ferraro Leland, NC 5,412. Jane Teruya Torrance, CA 5,413. Julia Mcenhill Sharpsburg, GA 5,414. Jenn Bulay Mesa, AZ

Page 195 - Signatures 5,388 - 5,414 Name From Comments 5,415. Suzanne Tooele, UT This is animal abuse/cruelty. No living being should be Edmundson subjected to a life of pain and suffering. It takes nothing away from a human to be kind to an animal. 5,416. Pamela Pothier Toulouse, France 5,417. Simone Martin Ajaccio, France 5,418. Lyndee Stark Grayling, MI 5,419. Diana Andersen South Jordan, UT 5,420. Sue wadland East Sussex, United Kingdom 5,421. Brenda Stone Kilkenny, Ireland 5,422. Eve Bonnick Glendale, CA Why do u even own a dog. Free the dog for better home and care. 5,423. Diane Walton Toronto, Canada All life needs to be treated better than this. This is animal cruelty! 5,424. Kelly Sherrer Goodwater, AL 5,425. Vikramaditya hyderabad, India Gidithuri 5,426. Tracey Keetley Nottingham, United Kingdom 5,427. Michelle Baldwin las vegas, NV 5,428. gloria Hanna Lisburn, United Kingdom 5,429. vlad panaitescu București, Romania 5,430. martine van malle, Belgium wijngaerden 5,431. Sharon Hawley London, United Kingdom 5,432. viviane broos Kapellen, Belgium 5,433. Juanita-Natalie Fulda, Germany Offord 5,434. sandra Thomas apopka, FL 5,435. Maia Lominadze Tbilisi, Georgia 5,436. theresa Coviello philadelphia, PA 5,437. Valerie Guidon Casablanca, Morocco 5,438. Linda Eidelberg Charlotte, NC 5,439. Michelle Berns San Diego, CA 5,440. CINDY normanton, United POULSON Kingdom 5,441. karen Mills luton, United Kingdom

Page 196 - Signatures 5,415 - 5,441 Name From Comments 5,442. Katharina , Germany Schreider 5,443. Chet Elfenbein MIAMI, FL 5,444. Tonya Lynn Vancleve, KY 5,445. Carolyn Wheeler Cypreds, CA Mcgrorge 5,446. Suzanne De sousa Strand, South Africa 5,447. Diane Miller Tooele, UT This is so sad! I hate that people abuse their animals like this. If people can't love and care for their animals they shouldn't be allowed to own one. 5,448. Ginny Siferd Findlay, OH 5,449. lene Henriksen arendal, Norway 5,450. Lisa Puleo LAS VEGAS, NV BOO Hawaii :( Don't be CRUEL! 5,451. maria huys antwerpen, Belgium 5,452. Donna Marino Boulder, CO 5,453. FRANCISCO DÜSSELDORF, CLIMENT Germany HERNANDEZ 5,454. muriel verstraete Assebroek, Belgium 5,455. michael mascioli san francisco, CA 5,456. Marie therese Avril sur loire, France Jolivot 5,457. Mary Fellman Las Vegas, NV 5,458. ana morris las vegas, NV 5,459. Pamela Kelly Warrington, United Kingdom 5,460. Jane Lloyd San Francisco, CA 5,461. becki anderson Chugiak, AK 5,462. Bridget Anderson BARRY, TX 5,463. Diana Rodriguez Briarwood, NY 5,464. Cuma Pineau Oxnard, CA Keep them off the big chains! 5,465. Cathy Flynn St John's, Canada try it see how u like it! dogs are sentient beings also! 5,466. Amanda D yorktown heights, NY 5,467. Diane Jasinski Newcastle, DE 5,468. Nicci Bailey London, United Kingdom 5,469. Leah Stratford Nth canterbury new It shouldnt be allowed and needs to be stopped Zealand, New Zealand

Page 197 - Signatures 5,442 - 5,469 Name From Comments 5,470. Deborah Pattinson Lytham St Annes, United Kingdom 5,471. Ilena Rabeau Loches, France 5,472. Samantha Lee Fairfield, CA 5,473. adriana boc Castiglione, Italy 5,474. Hedi Balk-Kühn Sanary-sur-Mer, France 5,475. Sheila Dunleavy Oakland, NJ 5,476. yıldız güney İstanbul, Turkey 5,477. Aavyusam Karthik Mumbai, India 5,478. Tanya Coyle Glasgow, United Kingdom 5,479. Evelien Mertens Denderleeuw, Belgium 5,480. Beth Williams Batavia, OH 5,481. Kathy Khamis RICHMOND, IN 5,482. Claudia Wieczorek Wilhermsdorf, Germany 5,483. Jamie Meyer Rochester, NY 5,484. Wendy Beyda Marlboro, NJ No dog deserves to live their life on a chain! 5,485. Bianca Ansink Eindhoven, Netherlands 5,486. Daisy Jeurissen Bilzen, Belgium 5,487. Tine Hertmans Destelbergen, Belgium 5,488. Marie Sosnowski Maspeth, NY 5,489. Elaine Kuehn Seminole, FL 5,490. debbie williams sun city, CA 5,491. Ada Brinker Rienzi, MS Animal cruelty ...No dog should be chained! 5,492. nasrin akbari firenze, Italy moghaddam 5,493. Sofie Van de reyd Meerhout, Belgium 5,494. Enza Di napoli Houten, Netherlands 5,495. Patricia Wasson Riverside, CA 5,496. nicoletta coiro civezzano, Italy 5,497. Debra Babirak Fayetteville, NC 5,498. Moreen Robinson Glasgow, United It is pure cruelty to loving dogs Kingdom 5,499. e e SØRUMSAND, Norway

Page 198 - Signatures 5,470 - 5,499 Name From Comments 5,500. Joy Bishop Spring, TX 5,501. nicola price carlisle, United Kingdom 5,502. Diana Higgins Beach, United Kingdom 5,503. Joanna Sale, United Kingdom AlveyWright 5,504. Mary Griffith Pittston, PA 5,505. Linda Shockley Wills Point, TX 5,506. Ka Ren Hope, RI Stop abusing animals !! 5,507. Adam Andrei Pistoia, Italy 5,508. Sue Hooper Southampton, United Kingdom 5,509. Nadine Brown Glasgow, United Kingdom 5,510. Nancy Erstad Poulsbo, WA 5,511. Kathryn Dalenberg Valley Head, AL Disgraceful! Best thing that can happen on the planet is the extinction of the parasite human. :-(( 5,512. Ashley Woods Pensacola, FL 5,513. Beth Knuth Roann, IN need a big time change in attitude there and I hear their are very arrogant humans! 5,514. Sara Cruz Surrey, Canada Hate abuse of animals 5,515. Deborsh Depiano Los amgeled, CA 5,516. Francis Acevedo TRACY, CA 5,517. Sara Arbogast Washington, DC 5,518. Charlene Minifie Vancouver, Canada There's no way this ISN'T important to me! Living in a Human Rights country means respecting ALL rights, damnit! 5,519. Edwina McNerney Cape Coral, FL 5,520. nazma zoetman haarlem, Netherlands 5,521. su shep whitchurch, United Kingdom 5,522. Rob Windsor Stoke, United Kingdom 5,523. Elke Thies Wrsseling, Germany Ich unterschreibe weil ich mitfühlen kann. 5,524. Dianna Martin Glasgow Barren County, KY 5,525. Marianne Mulmur, Canada McIntosh 5,526. Britta Fischer Bremerhaven, Germany

Page 199 - Signatures 5,500 - 5,526 Name From Comments 5,527. L OHARA Wilton, NH 5,528. Thomas LIvermore, CA 5,529. Susan Gentile port st lucie, FL no animal should be treated this way 5,530. Robin Kerns Buffalo, MN 5,531. Nancy Rodwell Lubbock, TX 5,532. Deborah Zatz Havertown, PA This is torture, must stop now. 5,533. Glen Darlow Sachigo Lake, Canada 5,534. Angelique Curran Laguna Niguel, CA 5,535. Deanna Sabourin Chilliwack, Canada 5,536. Tamara Ham Delta, PA 5,537. Suzanne Unthank Manchester, United Bennett Kingdom 5,538. Luz Quiroz Geyserville, CA Disgusting, cruel and inhumane. 5,539. Carla Poletti La Spezia, Italy 5,540. Karen Darosa Lake jackson, TX They have no voices to speak for themselves 5,541. Kay Mac Melrose, MA 5,542. Maryetta Brown Bealeton, VA 5,543. Tammy Slack Saint Petersburg, FL 5,544. Elena Burankova Moscow, Russian Federation 5,545. Mandy Riddle laurel, MT 5,546. Colleene Stever Lakela, FL 5,547. Estelle Lomuto East Patchogue, NY 5,548. Christine Jardine Kilmarnock, United Kingdom 5,549. katrin awad goodyear, AZ 5,550. Lisa Brown Houston, TX 5,551. Suzanne Cosner EL CAJON, CA 5,552. Carol Wyckoff Levittown, NY 5,553. Melanie Jenkins Huntsville, TX 5,554. Karina Alvarado Los Angeles, CA 5,555. Mia Vandeput Geel, Belgium 5,556. Clara Williams DUDLEY, NC 5,557. Kathy Berg Competa, Spain 5,558. Theresa Cooney Wexford, Ireland 5,559. Ace Gunner Hamilton, Canada

Page 200 - Signatures 5,527 - 5,559 Name From Comments 5,560. sophie leroy saint germain de coulamer, France 5,561. Susie Ronto Brisbane, Australia 5,562. Elizabeth Perth, United Robertson Kingdom 5,563. Lisa Gast Blanchester, OH This is just total b******* 5,564. Sherry Wigfield Fredricksburg, PA 5,565. Megan Gardner Healesville, Australia 5,566. Veronica Ramirez Mountain House, CA 5,567. Sharon Davies Leighton Buzzard, United Kingdom 5,568. Mariana Laub Eggenfelden, Germany 5,569. Marie Bernache Houston, TX Animals need to rism free. Csn you imsgine being restricted? How would you like that ti be your lufe? 5,570. sara reynolds sussex, United Kingdom 5,571. Linda Fleming CLEVELAND, OH This poor dog should be loved! No quality of life!!! Disgusting!! Poor baby! 5,572. Daniela Suntinger Klagenfurt, Austria 5,573. Gloria Robles Davenport, FL 5,574. Elisabeth Gutjahr Wien, Austria 5,575. BETTINA KIRBY Petaluma, CA 5,576. Mary Mathiasen WHEELING, WV 5,577. rebecca bruce TALLAHASSEE, FL Because dogs are sentient beings and deserve a better life. 5,578. Lori Donohue Julian, PA 5,579. wendy nolan durham, United Kingdom 5,580. Maria Saropoulos mitilini, Greece 5,581. Giulia Castriotta Manfredonia, Italy 5,582. Coralie Guidé Colfontaine, Belgium 5,583. Éléonore Brillon Longueuil, Canada 5,584. Kathy Swartz MASURY, OH Put the owners on the chains!!!!!!!! 5,585. lynda st saviour, Jersey please someone somewhere have compassion for these evan-williams poor dogs.. 5,586. CAROL MORRIS San Bernardino, CA 5,587. thomas osvald dtghdth, Belgium 5,588. Elena Stallings Menlo Park, CA 5,589. Rebecca Chalkley Bristol, United Kingdom

Page 201 - Signatures 5,560 - 5,589 Name From Comments 5,590. Lorraine Brazile Saint louis, MO 5,591. Danielle Pirotte Neupré, Belgium 5,592. Jessica Sanders Buffalo, NY 5,593. Melanie Reynolds London, United Kingdom 5,594. Lorraine Palmer Leicester, United Kingdom 5,596. mary rey Hallandale Beach, FL 5,597. Anja Goossens Schriek, Belgium 5,598. Tara Guinness Coburg, Australia This cruelty breaks my heart those beautiful creatures deserve a loving family and a real home with a warm bed to cuddle their humans. 5,599. MONTSE VILASSAR DE MAR, PEÑALVER Spain MARTINEZ 5,600. Elin Jenna Lillehammer, Norway Monsen 5,601. Diane Young South Rockwood, MI 5,602. Debra Cortez Portland, OR 5,603. Cindy Page PALM HARBOR, FL It’s HORRENDOUS, INHUMANE, BARBARIC, SICK & JUST PLAIN EVIL! Karma will come & give all those who exploit, eat, starve, torture, abuse, rape, neglect, hunt, kill &/or experiment on animals & mammals in any way, shape or form, &/or endanger species & their habitats, alter genetics &/or support archaic religious beliefs, bad or outdated laws &/or profit from animals, mammals & the animal kingdom in any way, shape or form for personal, religious, monetary gain or political reasons. I urge you to support & pass laws to protect all animals, pets, mammals & endangered species with great urgency & prosecute perpetrators to the fullest extent of the law. SHAME ON THEM! God Bless these animals! 5,604. Mary Sunderhauf Philadelphia, PA 5,605. Norbert Siepe Gummersbach, Germany 5,607. Mary Harris Pennfield, Canada 5,608. Rhonda Cook Oxford, MS 5,609. Steve Ayers Anderson, CA 5,610. muriel alleno plouay, France 5,611. Darla Tilley ANDERSON, CA 5,612. Luvic Slegers Maasmechelen, Belgium 5,613. Ann Schelkens mechelen, Belgium

Page 202 - Signatures 5,590 - 5,613 Name From Comments 5,614. Gerda Gaeters Hemiksem, Belgium I respect animals ! 5,615. Danielle Smith Apple Valley, CA Inhumane 5,616. edie drobny los altos, CA 5,617. Kathleen East Lincoln, United Kingdom 5,618. Christine Hutten North Tonawanda, NY 5,619. Ondine Angarola North Hollywood, CA 5,620. dagmar I angarola no. hollywood, CA I I call this animal cruelty 5,621. Talya Nevo Corona del marc, CA 5,622. Aimee Bertani Portland, OR Dogs deserve so much better. If their guardians cannot provide them humane living conditions, then they have business keeping a pet. 5,623. Shirley Swaim Warr Acres, OK 5,624. Charlotte Auckland, New Johansen Zealand 5,625. Pam Freeman Quinton, AL 5,626. carolyn howe SPANISH FORK, UT 5,627. Barbara Accetturo Marysville, WA 5,628. Pamela Ace Appleton, WI 5,629. Therieda Fink Mt. Pleasant, NC 5,630. Lizz Joffe Glen Lyon, PA 5,631. heshmat sajadi barrie, Canada 5,632. Catherine De la Benalmádena, Spain cruz 5,633. cynthia andrews hamilton, Canada 5,634. Sharon Gibbins Launceston, Australia 5,635. Uschi Ott terracina, Italy 5,636. Nicole Alessi Rochester, NY 5,637. [email protected], OH Richer 5,638. Michelle Lenz Aurora, IL 5,639. Toni Degirolamo Secaucus, NJ 5,640. chip macgill Baltimore, MD 5,641. shelva wood plano, TX 5,642. Ginger Mayfield Divide, CO This is animal abuse and not acceptable. No way to treat an innocent animal. 5,643. Lara Edelman Tucson, AZ 5,644. patsy van ternat, Belgium cleemput

Page 203 - Signatures 5,614 - 5,644 Name From Comments 5,645. Terry Huebert London, Canada 5,646. Jennifer Mills Salisbury, NC 5,647. Mar Angell LOS ANGELES, CA Cruelty to dogs is inportant to me 5,648. susanne La Orotava, Spain [email protected] 5,649. marie-claude lévis, Canada lessard 5,650. Darlene Johnson State college, PA This is in humane is how I feel. Not fair to this animal. Period. 5,651. Marcia McGuire Mira Loma, CA 5,652. Steffy Clayton Milwaukee, WI 5,653. Cecilia Tan Selangor, Malaysia 5,654. Kelly Wimsatt Houston, TX 5,655. Jessica Hollander BROOKLYN, NY 5,656. Alexander Kerr Columbus, OH 5,657. Raquel Medina Wellington, New Zealand 5,658. Jerri Gingrich Myrtle Beach, SC 5,659. Natalie King Playa del Rey, CA 5,660. Regina Milione PLYMOUTH Hawaii covers up well, a total disgrace! I will Never visit this MEETING, PA island! 5,661. Robin Martin Huntington Beach, CA 5,662. monica nancy cap fed, Argentina Basta de maltrato no sean herejes bondaruk 5,663. GLENDA QUEEN NEWTON, NC 5,664. J. Goodacre London, United Total misery Kingdom 5,665. Carol Forman W. Homestead, PA 5,666. Michael Samuels Linwood, PA 5,667. DEBRA 204 GAYLE ST., IA WARRENS 5,668. Bernice Welch Las vegas, NV I think this is abuse. Animal cruelty. What the hell is wrong with people. 5,669. Doraine Lew Groton, CT 5,670. Ryan Clark Kansas City, MO 5,671. Melissa Johnson Titusville, FL 5,672. jennifer townsley edinburgh, United No animal should suffer at the hand of sadistic humans Kingdom 5,673. Pamela V Niederwald, TX UNBELIEVABLE!!! Demons for ownets, NEED TO BE Campbell PROSECUTED!!! PUNISHMENT FITS THE CRIME!!!!

Page 204 - Signatures 5,645 - 5,673 Name From Comments 5,674. Renee Calpin Burrillvillr, RI No dog should ever be chained up on anything less than 10 ft and not for longer than a half hour to one hour weather permitting this is cruel barbaric and these people should not be allowed to have dogs if they're going to treat them this way animals do not belong on chains 5,675. Sharon Bamford Dorchester, MA 5,676. Gwen Jennier ALEXANDRIA, VA 5,677. Michelle Borowski Mesquite, TX 5,678. Aine O'Neill London, United Kingdom 5,679. Martha Barona Boynton Beach, FL 5,680. Iris DuCharme San Diego, CA Hawaii you can do better than this. Please take these chains off. So cruel, so much suffering! 5,681. The l Black Trenton, MO 5,682. Rebecca Trout Creek, Canada This is shameful treatment of any living thing. Ashworth 5,683. Sylvia Boronski Reading, PA 5,684. Roger Kann Pampanga, Philippines 5,685. Kathy Shoemaker Georgetown, SC 5,686. Rosanne Malpage London, Canada 5,687. Elizabeth Mole Elgin, IL Daren 5,688. Jean Horrall Del Mar, CA 5,689. Linda Steele Toronto, Canada 5,690. Daisy Wilcox Arlington, VA 5,691. Andrew Mundue Toronto, Canada 5,692. Jolene Gibson Rainier, WA 5,693. Robin VanOstrand London, Canada 5,694. Raymond Holder Cedar Rapids, IA 5,695. Lance Kammerud BLANCHARDVILLE, WI 5,696. Diane Sterner Chambersburg, PA 5,697. Denice Schaeffer Canton, MI 5,698. Marion Cavero Lima, Peru Blumenfeld 5,699. Marilyn Fox Northport, AL 5,700. Beth Wegner Pekin, IL 5,701. Green Mo Farley, MO 5,702. maria mlani rosario, Argentina

Page 205 - Signatures 5,674 - 5,702 Name From Comments 5,703. Mary Robles Torreón, Mexico 5,704. ANN ENGELEN Turnhout, Belgium 5,705. Dorien Schiffel Orihuela costa, Spain 5,706. Barbara Horton Quinque, VA 5,707. Cyn Matias Clifton park, NY 5,708. Sabine Fischer Idar-Oberstein, Germany 5,709. Mary Kershaw Mason, TN 5,710. Anne Portet Cruz bay, Virgin Islands, U.s. 5,711. Margaret Denison, TX This is cruelty at its worst! I think these dog owners should Hodgkins be tied outside on a 3-foot chain for a while to find out how bad it is. 5,712. Colleen Thompson Sandy, United Dogs should not be kept chained up! Kingdom 5,713. Ida On calgary, Canada 5,714. Valerie Neilson Delta, Canada 5,715. Lee Spitser San Diego, CA These dogs need to be cared for properly. 5,716. Lisa Lehman Hagerstown, MD 5,717. Diana Elliott Oregon, IL 5,718. Susan Sampson Federal Heights, CO 5,719. John Bonvicino Staten island, NY 5,720. Jason Anderson COLEMAN, MI 5,721. CYNDI SALINAS SCHAUMBURG, IL 5,722. Cari Beltane San Diego, CA 5,723. Hannah Marzec Paddington, Australia 5,724. Birthe Møller Skov Höör, Sweden 5,725. Dennis Kreiner Carpentersville, IL these dog s do not have a voice so we must speak for them 5,726. Penny Manchester Hiram, ME 5,727. Rhonda Dern Evergreen, CO 5,728. Jane Rhodus Ballwin, MO No animal should be shackled like this!!! Not in Hawaii, not ANYWHERE‼️‼️‼️ 5,729. Pat D Motreal, Canada 5,730. Andy Armstrong Burbank, CA 5,731. Lenka Praha 8, Czech Johanovská Republic 5,732. lisa garrison Colleyville, TX 5,733. Cecelia Halloran AUBURN, CA 5,734. R G Ukiah, CA

Page 206 - Signatures 5,703 - 5,734 Name From Comments 5,735. Neida Concepcion Chicago, IL 5,736. Marilyn Horton Bronxville, NY 5,737. Veronica Pattersonville, NY Fernandez 5,738. Rebecca Wilmington, DE Garagozzo 5,739. Eddie Plotts Mogadore, OH 5,740. Lesleigh Walsh Corinth, NY 5,741. Marjan Naderi Toronto, Canada 5,742. Vika Babakova Darwin, Australia 5,743. Denise Hodder Fairy Dell, Australia 5,744. Danijela Halt MARTENSVILLE, Canada 5,745. Diana Stivanson meadville, PA someone help him ,he deserves better 5,746. Donna Dunn sunrise beach,Tx, TX 5,747. Rupert Veitch Elsternwick Glen Eira City, Australia 5,748. Sandra Iseman Prescott, Canada 5,749. Robert English Syracuse, NY 5,750. ISA MORVAN plobannalec, France Ce genre de chose est horrible et indigne 5,751. Tachi G. De Salas Lima, Peru 5,752. glady malinoski Winnipeg, Canada 5,753. Juanita Leon Oakland, CA Bigger dogs need more space to run and play. Three foot is definitely abuse. 5,754. M Lam H.K., Hong Kong 5,755. diane clayton Danvers, MA 5,756. Judith Carr Palm Desert, CA This is pure cruelty. 5,757. Ruth Martin Courtenay, Canada 5,758. Barbara Preusser Pgh, PA 5,759. Judi Hurlock Highland, CA 5,760. Lita Ntovantzi Athens, Greece 5,761. theresa richmond, VA domhan-adams 5,762. suzanne slater los angeles, CA Disgusting cruelty. No animal deserves to live in such a horrid manner! 5,763. Darcy Drinkwine Jeffersonville, VT 5,764. Maurilia Silva Petrópolis / RJ, Brazil 5,765. Duart McLean London, United Kingdom

Page 207 - Signatures 5,735 - 5,765 Name From Comments 5,766. Stephanie Reisin Tucson, AZ 5,767. Julie Harris Biggs, CA Because animals have feelings just like we do and they deserve to be treated good. 5,768. Crystal Duncansville, PA Brumbaugh 5,769. Zdenka Coufalová Prague, Czech Please, do not torture living creatures. They feel fear and Republic pain in the same way as humans. 5,770. rita pissens buggenhout, Belgium 5,771. Anja Janssens Holsbeek, Belgium 5,772. Christy Cooley Van nuys, CA 5,773. Sheila Wright Castleberry, AL Animal abusers is horrible .The abusers should be punished just like the animal. 5,774. Mary Sherman Kernersville, NC 5,775. Marie Pascall West Vancouver, Canada 5,776. R Alexander Abiquiu, NM 5,777. Sabrina Klein , Germany 5,778. Eileen Lugo San Juan, PR 5,779. Irena Scavnicar Radenci, Slovenia 5,780. Elke Reuter Amsterdam, Netherlands 5,781. Jarrett Harris Biggs, CA 5,782. Isabel Maia Faro Algarve, Portugal 5,783. wanda martin PLEASUREVILLE, KY 5,784. Anne OLIVER Los Angeles, CA 5,785. Natasha Damien Los Cristianos. Tenerife, Spain 5,786. Anastasia Athens, Greece Chatzopoulou 5,787. Paul Hebert Lery, Canada 5,788. Kimberley Fenton ASHTABULA, OH 5,789. Tammy Booker North York, Canada 5,790. Alisha Saro Miri, Malaysia 5,791. MARIE-FRANCE ST-COLOMBAN, GUILHAUMA Canada 5,792. Olga Hernandez Miami, FL 5,793. petra kindt Aartrijke, Belgium 5,794. Marie Heymans Sint Amands, Belgium 5,795. Aicha Maraaoui Waardamme, Belgium

Page 208 - Signatures 5,766 - 5,795 Name From Comments 5,796. Susie Tallent Tampa, FL 5,797. Joanne Thompson El Cajon, CA 5,798. Ellen Dougherty Wimberley, TX 5,799. Wendy Pinconn8ng, MI Kryzanowicz 5,800. Anouk Van Gent, Belgium Damme 5,801. Veronica Ehrhardt Xghajra, Malta 5,802. Diane knowles Carpinteria, CA 5,803. Michael Sprung Grindsted, Denmark 5,804. Rosalina Dela Duarte, CA torre 5,805. Karen Sansbury Sultan, WA 5,806. Nicky Robbins Haenertsburg, South Africa 5,807. Lin Kristian Morton Grove, IL Please get dogs off of 3 foot logging chains forever. Dogs DO NOT BELONG ON CHAINS. All states need to make this a law! 5,808. Petra Stadtmueller Erlensee, Germany 5,809. Michele Todd Vancouver, Canada What is the point really? So sad and cruel.. 5,810. Lora Qaisi Vancouver, WA 5,811. Penny Anes Lansing, MI 5,812. Shirley Aldred Liverpool, United Kingdom 5,813. veronika anderson Rochester, United Kingdom 5,814. Gillian Cowell Bournemouth, United Kingdom 5,815. Paula Webster Bolton, United Kingdom 5,816. Erika Echegaray Arlington, VA 5,817. Stephanie Decker N Arlington, NJ 5,818. Stacey Boyd Denver, CO 5,819. Joann Clark Tucson, AZ 5,820. Jill Ryan Melbourne Australia, Australia 5,821. Julie Weiland Lurg, Australia 5,822. Joni Hujjbem Zeewolde, Netherlands 5,823. Antoinette Krikke Helmond, Netherlands

Page 209 - Signatures 5,796 - 5,823 Name From Comments 5,824. Pedro Lima Amadora, Portugal 5,825. Michelle Hoskins Coventry, United Kingdom 5,826. Ian Miller , Malta 5,827. Marilyn Wilson Chewelah, WA Stop this atrocity NOW! 5,828. Linda Andover, United Kingdom 5,829. Josiane LENOIR 33650 - LA BREDE, France 5,830. Carmen Mazon Long Beach, CA 5,831. Rikarda Daane Papendrecht, Netherlands 5,832. Sarah Addis Abergavenny, United Kingdom 5,833. Lisa Ramirez Barrie, Canada despicable, cruel, abusive, sick, mean, hateful, and what is the point in even having a beautiful, loving, loyal dog and then treat it worse than garbage!!! The dog owners need to go to jail asap 5,834. Klaus Weber Kelmscott, Australia 5,835. Zoe Thornley Manchester, United Kingdom 5,836. Karen Saliba Mtarfa, Malta 5,837. Leigh Jalland Essex, United Kingdom 5,838. Maria Acuna Hialeah, FL 5,839. May Cheng Kirkland, WA 5,840. Ann-Charlotte Strängnäs, Sweden Hintze 5,841. mariarosa torino, Italy castellano 5,842. Cathy Mason Toledo, OH 5,843. Ghania Hadda Bruxelles, Belgium 5,844. Judith Payne Clinton Twp., MI Know animal should be treated like this !! 😡 5,845. Paul Bird Stokesley road, United Kingdom 5,846. shaun figueiredo brisbane, Australia 5,847. Uta Jaklitsch Klagenfurt, Austria 5,848. elena arkhipova estela, Portugal 5,849. gerry griffiths London, United Kingdom 5,850. Marilyn Figueiredo Brisbane, Australia

Page 210 - Signatures 5,824 - 5,850 Name From Comments 5,851. R Hut Leek, Netherlands 5,852. Gun-Britt Barkma Ljugbyholm, Sweden 5,854. Wim Stockman Oudenaarde, Belgium 5,855. Chris Chernoski St Catharines, Canada 5,856. Katrin Esch Stuttgart, Germany 5,857. Gisela Lenski Wuppertal, Germany 5,858. Mary Hughes Brooksville, FL Dogs have feelings to and they should never be bound by a logging chain!!!!! 5,859. Laurie Miller Escondido, CA 5,860. Utsav Nayak Vapi, India 5,861. PATRICIA Cooper Bristol, United Kingdom 5,862. Travis Pishna Lincoln, NE 5,863. Ryah Schmidt Rockhampton, Australia 5,864. Linda Kruger Gauteng, South Africa 5,865. carol cleaver Birmingham, United Kingdom 5,866. Marisa RIbeiro Vila do Conde, Portugal 5,867. Victor Pater Grez-Doiceau, Belgium 5,868. Jackie Keeton Cape Town, South Stop cruelty to animals Africa 5,869. Don Hintan Elgin, IL 5,870. Misty Butcher Portland, OR 5,871. Valérie Paillard Savigny le Temple, France 5,872. edwige call toulon, France 5,873. Ronald Bach Zeewolde, Netherlands 5,874. Leanne Nijsten HEERLEN, Netherlands 5,875. Maria angela , Italy Cinardo 5,876. S Seiler Cleveland, OH 5,877. Maria Schultheiss Waldbronn, Germany 5,878. Terri Sengstock Port huron, MI 5,879. Agnes Boogaard Maarn, Netherlands

Page 211 - Signatures 5,851 - 5,879 Name From Comments 5,880. Giovanna milano, Italy Bonaccorsi 5,881. margarida sousa Vila Nova de Gaia, VERGONHA, ter um ser indefeso acorrentado com um colar Portugal desta grossura. Quem o devia usar é aquele que se intitula cuidador ...Besta quadrada!!! 5,882. Karen Hart Newcastle, OK 5,883. J,ackie LeBret Aberdeenshire, United Kingdom 5,884. Marie Beelen Ghislenghien, Belgium 5,885. Roswita Ritjens Dörverden, Germany 5,886. Jurema Conde Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Moreira 5,887. George DeLuca Wading River, NY 5,888. Valentina Genoa, Italy Gambino 5,889. Lincy La Heij Uithoorn, Netherlands 5,890. Christina Paul Berlin, Germany 5,891. Priscilla Leffelaar Amsterdam, Netherlands 5,892. Karen Bailey Bristol, United Kingdom 5,893. ELENI LARNACA, Cyprus DEMETRIOU 5,894. VICKY RETHYMNO, Greece ANASTOPOULOU 5,895. Robin Hamilton CYPRESS, CA 5,896. emilia petrovska zilina, Slovakia 5,897. Tammy Pratt Knoxville, TN 5,898. Debra Downey Newark, NY 5,899. Julie Cornell County durham, United Kingdom 5,900. Caroline Liverpool, United Lammond Kingdom 5,901. Eunice Sousa Queluz, Portugal 5,902. Katherine Rudd St Albans, United Kingdom 5,903. Sylvia Schmidt Mandeville, LA 5,904. Anna Maria La Campagna, Italy Torraca 5,905. John Antrobus Torquay, United Kingdom

Page 212 - Signatures 5,880 - 5,905 Name From Comments 5,906. helen smith Bongaree, Australia 5,907. stephane bonnières sur , morinaud France 5,908. Jamie Dimarsico Whitestone, NY 5,909. Gabi Apasa Bs as, Argentina 5,910. Dayvis Houstin Lisieux, France 5,911. Lia Asssa Ealing, United Kingdom 5,912. Natalia Bagashvili Tbilisi, Georgia 5,913. Irena Börner 39122 Magdeburg, Germany 5,914. Maria Fernanda Lisboa, Portugal Abreu Este Serra 5,915. Joanne Brooks Maldon, United Kingdom 5,916. Tegwin O'Connor Watford, United Kingdom 5,917. Maria Ostrander Saugerties, NY 5,918. Lori Spindler Wonder Lake, IL 5,919. Rachael Hamer Wakefield, United Kingdom 5,920. Candice Schuster Millbrae, CA 5,921. Wendy Vey So Plainfield, NJ 5,922. Inga Frauke Majer Bielefeld, Germany 5,923. Ann Kelly STRATFORD, NJ 5,924. Petra Piot , Belgium 5,925. Tina O'rourke Great yarmouth, United Kingdom 5,926. Kim Barlow Woonsocket, RI 5,927. Patricia Laurin Toronto, Canada 5,928. Kate Kenzie Exeter, United Kingdom 5,929. Melinda Holmes Pearcedale, Australia How many levels of wrong can there be? I can't believe people can be this disgusting & cruel , it is so so sad. And the poor babies get the blame! We have a lot to answer for! 5,930. Maria Berishaj Clinton Twp, MI 5,931. Deanna Frisbee Asheville, NC 5,932. Barry Frederick St helier, Jersey Baudains 5,933. Linda Reynaers Zichem, Belgium

Page 213 - Signatures 5,906 - 5,933 Name From Comments 5,934. Odile Harroch Casablanca, Morocco 5,935. jean-pierre jakobik jambville, France 5,936. Shelley Wyndham Chambersburg, PA 5,937. Gayla Fredrick Allen, TX 5,938. anna poggesi Firenze, Italy 5,939. Susan Wells Maidenhead, United Kingdom 5,940. Ailsa Glazebrook Frankston, Australia 5,941. Laura Pitagna Bronx, NY 5,942. Dennis Graham, NC To help protect our children from mistreated animals. Dogs Moneypenny only become aggressive when treated and trained to be so. 5,943. Rosemary Ward Nottingham, United Kingdom 5,944. Mark Ng Hk, Hong Kong 5,945. Debbie Fisher Coldstream, Canada 5,946. Veronica Crabtree Villamartin, Spain Hill 5,947. Bernie Timmins Brisbane, Australia 5,948. Gabriele Singleton Silvis, IL 5,949. Linda Alexander Orwell, OH 5,950. Lynne Miles Chesterfield, United Kingdom 5,951. Gina Swanson Nyc, NY 5,952. Paula Powers BOYNTON BEACH, FL 5,953. Karin Meeus Duffel, Belgium 5,954. Ren T Coquitlam, Canada 5,955. Tricia O'Brien Toronto, Canada 5,956. Damini Bhookhun Cbb, Mauritius 5,957. Laura Farrell cleveland, VA 5,958. Flavia del bello Milano, Italy 5,959. Ingrid Maria Steinkjer, Norway Waade 5,960. Pamela Tolson Woburn, MA 5,961. Bob Gunn Santa Barbara, CA 5,962. kaori kobayashi 札幌市, Japan 5,963. Bernd Willnauer Waghäusel, Germany 5,964. Anastacia SAN BENITO, TX Rodriguez

Page 214 - Signatures 5,934 - 5,964 Name From Comments 5,965. Aurore Caprilès Argenteuil, France 5,966. Susan Moore Greater manchester, These chains are barbaric put them on the evil owners see United Kingdom how they like it evil bsrbsric stupid people 5,967. Judy Sifers Granby, CO 5,968. hatsumi kouzono tokyo, Japan 5,969. Sallyann Davis Chesterfield, United FREE THESE DOGS IMMEDIATLY FGS I FEEL SICK . Kingdom 5,970. Emmanuelle STUNDWILLER, Mottin France 5,971. Richard Jenkins Bargoed, United Kingdom 5,972. ALLISON CANE CHESTERFIELD, These poor dogs need freedom to roam and play. How United Kingdom would you feel being chained up allday? Please stop this immediately 5,973. Kathy Fowler Warren, RI 5,974. junko kondo AICHI, Japan 5,975. monika tönges drolshagen, Germany 5,976. Anita Dobner München, Germany 5,977. Christine Monroeville, PA Senchesen 5,978. KArin Ball San Ramon, CA 5,979. Nelly Chesnel Les Chéris, France 5,980. Carl Lambert Fleet, United Kingdom 5,981. Taunna Davis Bonham, TX 5,983. Donita Eade Chandler, AZ 5,984. Natashia Yurkiw Mississauga, Canada 5,985. Susan Litchfield, OH Szente-Kish 5,986. Betty Morton Centerville, GA 5,987. Emy Schwaz PARIS, France 5,988. Linnea Lorenz Glendale, AZ 5,989. Vivienne Corfu, Greece Pittendrigh 5,990. Larry Grunspan Olathe, KS 5,991. Valerie Philebaum Dimondale, MI Smith 5,992. 新井 慶子 愛知県, Japan 5,993. vakhtang tbilisi, Georgia ushveridze 5,994. Gabi Boehme Köln, Germany

Page 215 - Signatures 5,965 - 5,994 Name From Comments 5,995. Taunja Schiffel Ontario, OH 5,996. Sandrine Michelle Gorinchem, Galatola Netherlands 5,997. Anna Stolecka Warszawa, Poland 5,999. janet whitehead cirencester, United it is like a millstone round their necks, those chains Kingdom must be so heavy and dogs need exercise. 6,000. kay mcgee naples, FL 6,001. Linda Simmons Wallis, TX 6,002. zelda DICKSON Durban, South Africa 6,003. Debbie Campbell Derby, United Heartbreaking :'( Kingdom 6,004. Lynda Denny Sandton, South Africa 6,005. carla renders heppen, Belgium 6,006. Ravin Driviz Singapore, Singapore 6,007. Diane Lang Seattle, WA 6,008. marleen vancoillie hooglede, Belgium 6,009. ANA ROSÁLIA RIO DE JANEIRO, TEIXEIRA Brazil CARNEIRO 6,010. severine sarda Pertuis, France 6,011. Carla Rotella Aprilia, Italy 6,012. M.B Fjellheim ---, Norway 6,013. Misty Oien Sioux Falls, SD 6,014. Veronika Karkova Sofia, Bulgaria 6,015. Brigitte de Marseille, France LANVERSIN 6,016. Luís Filipe Da Lisboa, Portugal Milheiro 6,017. Sheri Anderson Albany, OR 6,018. Marie Jacquemart Wavre, Belgium Je trouve ca cruel. Droit et respect aux animaux. Ces gens sont arrieres 6,019. Donella Duff Okehampton, United Kingdom 6,020. Marja Campbell Vantaa, Finland Stop hurting and Torturing the dogs 6,021. Andrea Angulo Buenos Aires, Argentina 6,022. patricia mccaskill santa rosa, CA 6,023. STEPHEN Chesterfield, MO JOHNSON

Page 216 - Signatures 5,995 - 6,023 Name From Comments 6,024. Lori Newland ann arbor, MI Animals deserve better than being left on a chain.. treat them with the love they deserve 6,025. Maja Trohar sv.nedelja, Croatia 6,026. helga apfelbaum san zenone po (pv), Italy 6,027. Shirley Andersch Saarburg, Germany OMG! What kind of monsters do this??? Shame on you!!!! 6,028. Regine ruelle Jávea, Spain 6,029. Mene Shioda Santa rosa, CA 6,030. veronique boidard houdan, France 6,031. hetty jager Duiven, Netherlands 6,032. Jesse Ross Conover, NC 6,033. kathleen Lentz willow grove, PA 6,034. Melanie Joseph Ragama, Sri Lanka 6,035. Monique Machado El Paso, TX 6,036. Katja Lövstrand laholm, Sweden This is wrong 6,037. Judy Obryan Wynnum, Australia Won't visit there😡😡😡😡😡 6,038. Denise Clifford Pieve a nievolr, Italy 6,039. Lina Barnes Niles, OH 6,040. Diane DeLong Lakewood, CO 6,041. Rodney Dick Cobble Hill, Canada 6,042. Barbara Wooten SAINT ALBANS, WV STOP THE SENSELESS CRUELTY NOW!!! 6,043. John Bobb Victoria, Canada 6,044. Dawn Dowling Baton Rouge, LA 6,045. Sandra Titusville, PA McElhaney 6,046. AF Costello North Chelmsford, MA DISGUSTING AND INHUMANE 6,047. Joyce Bannick Bay City, MI 6,048. Valerie Parr Alicante, Spain 6,049. Michelle Price dunkirk, MD 6,050. Glenda Myers Warne, NC Animal cruelty must stop and the only way that will ever happen is if laws are changed and abusers are held accountable and given MORE than a slap on the wrist for their crime.. 6,051. Joann Wittmier Maple Valley, WA 6,052. Ramona Constanta, Romania Stoicescu 6,053. Debbie Jenkins Thurmont, MD 6,054. nina schreuders Aalsmeer, Netherlands

Page 217 - Signatures 6,024 - 6,054 Name From Comments 6,055. Kasturi Saha Kolkata, India 6,056. Alison Jones Gwynedd, United Kingdom 6,057. Nyree Saunders Colchester, United Kingdom 6,058. Cherry M Kortrijk, Belgium 6,059. Amy Lai Dix hills, NY 6,060. Cassie Waz Mesa, AZ 6,061. Yvonne Almere, Netherlands Vancanegem 6,062. Susanne Hinnela Helsinki, Finland 6,063. Manny Eindhoven Rotterdam, Netherlands 6,064. O Duff Sheffield, United Kingdom 6,065. Tina Frier Odense, Denmark 6,066. Femke Kaspers Amsterdam, Netherlands 6,067. Myrna Schilling Calgary, Canada 6,068. Deanna Meunier Lafleche, Canada Would u people stop with putting logging chains around your dogs neck ,that is so cruel,,SHAME ON U HAWAII,,WHY HAVE A DOG IF YOUR GOING TO DO THAT TO HIM,,,ITS ABUSE U FOOLS,,, 6,069. Claudia DeAnna Geneva, OH 6,070. Kate Dushel Stewartstown, PA This is how we treat Man's Best Friends? You know what should be done here, so begging that you help too. Thank you 6,071. Colette Erickson Craig, CO When we visit Hawaii, I am horrified by the conditions in which I see so many dogs. No aloha for them...... :-( 6,072. Anna Espinoza Apple valley, CA 6,073. Pamela Columbus, OH McConehea 6,074. Ilene Orem Clementon, NJ 6,075. Patricia Anderson Cathlamet, WA 6,076. Joanne Clark Titusville, PA 6,077. Elena Anderson Cmox, Canada 6,078. Anne Falkenreck glendale, CO HAWAII DO NOT BE CRUEL TO YOUR DOGS; DO NOT CHAIN/TETHER THEM FOREVER IN YOUR YARD IN THE HEAT OF THE DAY. EVIL !!! Please sign/share/tweet ! 6,079. solange scherer St Pete, FL

Page 218 - Signatures 6,055 - 6,079 Name From Comments 6,080. danielle hamilton ELKTON, MD 6,081. Sarah Heath Newton ferrers, United Kingdom 6,082. Faye O'Shea No, United States Minor Outlying Islands 6,083. june Thomas Tonbridge, United What a brutal way to treat animals they need to make a few Kingdom tough laws to protect animals prove that they are civilised. 6,084. Denise Nordenhall Gunnislake Cornwall, United Kingdom 6,085. Elena Dorsey Bakersfield, CA 6,086. Darla Hill CANTON, OH agree! If you have to make this a law and enforce it,then these human defects don't deserve to have an animal in their care in the first place.If you have to allow these human defects have animals then these people are a huge big red flag and should be watched closely.All evil/twisted humans will always find loop holes to break the law,its the law makers to set in motion extra help to enforce the laws to protect the animals from these human defects! 6,087. jennifer pies euclid, OH 6,088. Norma Peet Houston, TX 6,089. Kathleen VICTORVILLE, CA Stephens 6,090. Sharryn Goodman Calivil, Australia 6,091. Marie-France GAP, France CONTI 6,092. Tracy Beaumont Gloucestershire, United Kingdom 6,093. Barbara Jordan North bellmore, NY 6,094. Tara Glasacb Dublin, Ireland 6,095. Brinezza Gutierrez Voorschoten, Netherlands 6,096. Heidemarie Hinze Bad Oldesloe, Germany 6,097. Mary More Paris, France 6,098. Stella Reina Victoria, Canada 6,099. Danielle Carole Hudson, Canada Comeau 6,100. Kirin Lee bellaire, OH 6,101. Karen Yateman Reading, United Kingdom 6,102. Monte Allen Portland, OR 6,103. Karen Rozo Coconut creek, FL

Page 219 - Signatures 6,080 - 6,103 Name From Comments 6,104. tina husfelt dover, DE 6,105. Linda Martin RDG, CA 6,106. Bogna Komar Wroclaw, Poland 6,107. Shan Bramley scunthorpe, United Kingdom 6,108. troy misener LAS VEGAS, NV 6,109. claire weatherill normanton, United Kingdom 6,110. Erika Barrote Sao paulo, Brazil 6,111. Dana Ray Akron, OH 6,112. Penni Norman Des Moines, IA 6,113. Joseph Finch Romford, United Kingdom 6,114. miriam pino santiago, Chile 6,115. zigomi , Italy 6,116. Maria de Fátima Rio Tinto - Gondomar, Cerqueir Rocha Portugal 6,117. Leslie Cronk Parham, Canada 6,118. francesca romano di lombardia gagliardi (berg, Italy 6,119. Any Monroe Concord, CA 6,120. Rose Cortez Arlington, TX 6,121. Mary Degon Gardner, MA 6,122. jane allen grimsby, United Kingdom 6,123. Jo Hewitt INDIANAPOLIS, IN 6,124. Sheila Kelly Elkridge, MD 6,125. Marja Meijer Kampen, Netherlands 6,126. Birgith Bäckman BURTRÄSK, Sweden 6,127. Маргарита Санкт-Петербург, Румянцева Russian Federation 6,128. lucy cord Brampton, Canada 6,129. Catherine George matlborough, United Kingdom 6,130. Sandy Disdale Reigate, United Kingdom 6,131. Cathy Peters Bremerton, WA 6,132. Perola Padovani São paulo, Brazil 6,133. Sema Richards COLORADO SPRINGS, CO

Page 220 - Signatures 6,104 - 6,133 Name From Comments 6,134. Daisy Estrella Bayamon, Puerto Rico 6,135. Malcolm Pannifer Newcastle upon tyne, United Kingdom 6,136. vicki burch Bastrop, TX 6,137. Fabienne Saint-Parres-aux-Tertres, Lagneaux France 6,138. Sarah Johnson Cleveland, OH 6,139. Dot Sager Sudbury, Canada 6,140. Carole Isola ronkonkoma, NY 6,141. Audrey Chartrand Montreal, Canada 6,142. Samantha Prosper, TX Underwood 6,143. Annette Ross Mississauga, Canada For the ethical treatment of animals 6,144. Barbara Joosten Witten, Germany 6,145. Patricia May Mentor, OH Cruelty pure and simple 6,146. Ewa Jasiniewska Nakło nad Not, Poland 6,147. Adrian Knight Stockton-on-Tees, United Kingdom 6,148. Janina Teodoro malate , manila, Philippines 6,149. Carolyn Longphrr Signal mtn, TN Look at these suffering, sad, pathetic live beings and feel their paain. Stop deplorable humans from doing this to dogs. 6,150. Melinda Klemas Woodland Pk, NJ 6,151. Gita Mehta OXFORD, CT 6,152. SUSAN Cupar, United DONNELLY Kingdom 6,153. Suzy Bailey Lehi, UT 6,154. Pat Smyklo Oakland, CA It is hot and every dog needs family to be with ,not stuck in a back lot with no contact except to throw food their way. 6,155. Gia Campola Willoughby, OH 6,156. Audra Demuth Coseley, United Kingdom 6,157. Janice Wilson Whitby, Canada 6,158. Catriona may Scotland, United Wilson Kingdom 6,159. Gabriela São paulo, Brazil archangela Enriquez 6,160. LAUREN Mandy Biloxi, MS

Page 221 - Signatures 6,134 - 6,160 Name From Comments 6,161. Diana Lynn Anaheim, CA 6,162. Sandra Snider RlTacoma, WA Chained dogs can be more aggressive -find other ways to keep dogs safe-no mre chaining 6,163. Paula Spier Paignton, United No dog should be subjected to this barbaric Kingdom Cruelty with such a lack of freedom , chaining A dog should be banned 6,164. marjorie Jongstra hillegom, Netherlands 6,165. Verona Petrou Patra, Greece 6,166. Mauna Sandin Pittsburgh, PA 6,167. Linda Staffulani South Lyon, MI 6,168. Ivonne Baes Copperascove, TX 6,169. Linda Gillespie Poulsbo, WA 6,170. Dragica Siedentop Maintal, Germany 6,171. jz houart lierde, Belgium 6,172. Karen Brown Chattanooga, TN This is so blatantly and egregiously abusive that the state ought to be sued as an accomplice to torture! 6,173. Lynn Hellmuth Madison, WI 6,174. Gia Thorsell Stockholm, Sweden 6,175. pilar Rodriguez valencia, Spain Pérez 6,176. Grace Beck Crestview, FL 6,177. Bianca Wohkittel Harsum, Germany 6,178. karen underwood aurora, CO 6,179. Reza Hoofddorp, leave them FREE Hemmatzadeh Netherlands 6,180. Babak London, United Sadegh-Zadeh Kingdom 6,181. jill hein Coupeville, WA Humans are disgusting - this is so cruel to any animal, get them off these short chains - they shouldn't be chained at all. 6,182. Marja Herfst Winkel, Netherlands 6,183. mesut Subaşı Beyoğlu, Turkey 6,184. Pamela Kramer Hometown, IL 6,185. Wendy Sugalski jacksonville, FL 6,186. Liv Lofink ORANGE, CA 6,187. May Milton Cardross, United Kingdom 6,188. dardonville marie angers, France france 6,189. sandra blanton st augustine, FL

Page 222 - Signatures 6,161 - 6,189 Name From Comments 6,190. Sue Clark Great Yarmouth, United Kingdom 6,191. Wendy Stiver SouthPasadena, CA 6,192. Darren Faraday Meeden, Netherlands Hawaii, to me conjurs up beautiful people in love with ALL nature. Please prove me right... 6,193. Courtney Bridge Peterborough, United Kingdom 6,194. Marie-Christine St-Hippolyte, Canada Champagne 6,195. Michelle Marechal Wavre, Belgium 6,196. jennifer goodwin mansfield woodhouse, United Kingdom 6,197. Roberta Mortimer Durweston, Blandford, United Kingdom 6,198. Nic Li Richardson, TX 6,199. Teresa Powers Orlando, FL 6,200. nada macak mittelbiberach, Germany 6,201. Russ Wray Doncaster, United Kingdom 6,202. Petro Twigge Boksburg, South Africa 6,203. Marie - Louise Basel, Switzerland Galliker 6,204. Annette ROQUEBRUNE sur CHOLOUX Argens, France 6,205. Lori Creasman Pompano Beach, FL 6,206. Chantal Viturtia Mössingen, Germany 6,207. Linda Buckley Banksia Beach, Australia 6,208. donna santella denver, CO 6,209. Kath Voss Pinneberg, Germany 6,210. Ann Smith Newbiggin by the sea, United Kingdom 6,211. Maria Furnari LEH, NJ 6,212. Cory Jubitz Portland, OR Dogs are living, breathing, thinking, feeling beings. They deserve to be part of a loving, caring family, not chained like objects. 6,213. bos claudine poligny, France 6,214. Miria Comandi Grosseto, Italy 6,215. sandra boumena Sucy-en-Brie, France

Page 223 - Signatures 6,190 - 6,215 Name From Comments 6,216. Andreas Roth Essen, Germany 6,217. Greg Orta Bethlehem, PA 6,218. philippe dorane waterloo, Belgium 6,219. Charmayne Cape Town, South There can never ever be any justification for the brutal Kempstet Africa treatment of man's best friend! 6,220. Patricia Gomez El Paso, TX 6,221. Donna Saunders Lutz, FL THIS IS SO WRONG! 6,222. Marie-louise Lloyd Cape town, South Africa 6,223. Julie Van Niekerk Ten acres, South Africa 6,224. Rachel Reich Grayslake, IL How cruel can you get! 6,225. Rita Tschaggelar Netstal, Switzerland 6,226. Amber Petri Den Haag, This is torture.The dog did nothing wrong and stil you keep Netherlands him like a prisoner.How would you feel?!! 6,227. Kathryn Moeller Highlands, TX Heater 6,228. tatiana mansilla merlo, Argentina 6,229. Petra Abrar Krefeld, Germany 6,230. Lourdes Hinnant Clearwater, FL 6,231. Paige Sautner Murrieta, CA 6,232. Leon Struck Boca Raton, FL This cruelty has to be totally eradicated. 6,233. 島津 智代 福津市, Japan 6,234. Annie Lefranc Autreches, France 6,235. Martina Krauss Fruedberg, Germany 6,236. Judith Vermaas Capelle aan den IJsel, Netherlands 6,237. micheline kirouac Québec, Canada 6,238. Raquel Rico-Arcos Vechta, Germany 6,239. Tracy Eland Tenerife, Spain 6,240. Leanne Goldsbury Ashington, United Kingdom 6,241. Nancy McGinn Salem, WV 6,242. Priscila Colangelo São Carlos.1530, Brazil 6,243. Johanna Fort Lauderdale, FL Kleuskens 6,244. Taylor Story NOBLE, OK 6,245. Tamara Trent Temple, TX

Page 224 - Signatures 6,216 - 6,245 Name From Comments 6,246. oscar cedeira santa fe, Argentina 6,247. Brenda Hart Bullard, TX 6,248. Dinah Frazier Apollo beach, FL Dogs do not belong chained up. 6,249. Alexis Outsider Patra, Greece 6,250. MARILYN UVALDE, TX FAWCETT 6,251. Deborah Lamb Man, United Kingdom 6,252. Anna maria Roghi La spezia, Italy 6,253. Heidi Alkan Grevenbroich, Germany 6,254. Sharon McCort Barnesville, OH If you want to chain something up- chain one of your kids. 6,255. Anita Biermans Halle, Belgium 6,256. Gayna Wills Northampton, United Kingdom 6,257. Andrea Sonntag Bremen, Germany 6,258. denise bourgin le malzieu ville, France 6,259. Sheri Nolen Duenweg, MO 6,260. Charmaine Walsh lansing, KS 6,261. Sandie Rosales Schertz, TX 6,262. Florence Berthault Roullet, France 6,263. Thea Ferreira London, United Kingdom 6,264. heike bremert deutschland, Sowas kann ich nicht akzeptieren ,es ist Tiermissbrauch Germany ....es gehört sofort verboten ! 6,265. Elizabeth Black Ventura, CA 6,266. Orlando Ribeiro Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Molinari 6,267. Kyriaki P Derynia, Cyprus 6,268. Deborah Ellison Kingston, Canada 6,269. Eve Delmonte Melbourne, Australia 6,270. Dee Epstein Bklyn, NY 6,271. Pia Lind Tureby, Denmark 😡😡 6,272. Lara Deveau Kingston, Canada 6,273. D Wassenaar Anersfoort, Netherlands 6,274. Anja Scheel Geesthacht, Germany 6,275. Alyne Dutra de Malta, Brazil Medeiros

Page 225 - Signatures 6,246 - 6,275 Name From Comments 6,276. Angelika Peter Altmünster, Austria 6,277. karine tremblay jonquiere, Canada 6,278. cintia gagliarducci cassina de pecchi, Italy 6,279. Val Hannah Scarborough, United Kingdom 6,280. Yana Todorova Catarroja, Spain Firmemod porfavor. 6,281. Angelique Parplies Waldfischbach-Burgalben, Germany 6,282. ileana roger HIALEAH, FL 6,283. Tracy Shaw Huddersfield, United Kingdom 6,284. Roxane Beis Ansouis, France 6,285. Jacqueline Leidschendam, Marlene Verheij Netherlands 6,286. Helmut Nicolay Hilchenbach, Germany 6,287. Christy Chaney Abilene, TX 6,288. Ines Nemiña Avellaneda, Argentina 6,289. Carl Mouer St Austell, United Kingdom 6,290. Jane Montonen Palm beach, FL 6,291. Patricia GUIRAN Draveil, France 6,292. Phyllis Mootz Conway, SC 6,293. Jean Lyle Auckland, New Cruel and disgusting. Save the dog and dont euthanise Zealand please 6,294. Isabelle Moreno Le Coudray montceaux, France 6,295. Ruth Richards York, United Kingdom its barbaric and has no place in our society. 6,296. Hendrika Pauley Versailles, KY 6,297. mary lou Howes Kingston, Canada 6,298. sheri christian Vancouver, WA 6,299. Cheryl Hawley Milwaukee, WI 6,300. Helena Smolica rijeka, Croatia 6,301. Jan Flieger Leipzig, Germany 6,302. Barbara Verheyen Zedelgem, Belgium 6,303. Louis Peluso Sellersville, PA 6,304. Erika Corrado Sommarøy, Norway 6,306. sandra sheehy Dublin, Ireland

Page 226 - Signatures 6,276 - 6,306 Name From Comments 6,307. ewa krawczyk nadarzyn, Poland 6,308. Myrle Horn Parkland, FL Because it is inhumane to treat dogs like this. 6,309. Daniella Verheire Wingene, Belgium 6,310. Kostas Korovilas Athens, Greece 6,311. Evan Loehrlein Evansville, IN 6,312. Patricia Krombach Krefeld, Germany 6,313. Laura Cave Augusta, GA 6,314. Lutz Schuemmer Würselen, Germany 6,315. Morales Maricela Huntington park, CA No animal deserves any abuse and keeping them like this is is abuse. 6,316. Candice Paulus Hanover, PA 6,317. Amy Hardwick Irthlingborough, United Kingdom 6,318. Uwe Wevers Ratingen, Germany 6,319. Diane Alpern BOULDER, CO 6,320. Lisa Mason Port Charlotte, United Arab Emirates 6,321. Henry Körver Kerkrade, Netherlands 6,322. Monika Saluter Amsterdam, Netherlands 6,323. IVY FAHRER Miami, FL freedom, sanctuary, humanity, try it...... feels good 6,324. Marci Bare Dresher, PA 6,325. Bob Slangen Kerkrade, Netherlands 6,326. Bev White Gloucester, United Kingdom 6,327. ben fuller tunbridge wells, United Kingdom 6,328. Karen Armlin Jackson, NJ 6,329. Cheryl McCanna Las Vegas, NV THIS IS BARBARIC 6,330. Conchita Roquebrune Cap Westerwoudt Martin, France 6,331. Velma Ellis Enid, OK This poor dog !! Hawaii needs to adopt felony animal abuse and put people who do this behind bars !! Of course an animal will become aggressive in these types of conditions and will do what they feel they have to do in an attempt to not be hurt anymore !!! People who do these things to animals do not deserve them. Dog fighting rings and dog and boar fights--how backward and barbaric !!! VOTE YES ON MOLLY B BILL !!! PLEASE

Page 227 - Signatures 6,307 - 6,331 Name From Comments 6,332. an co Montreal, Canada 6,333. Edia Lau Orlando, FL They deserve love and comfort more than the ones who think this is an acceptable way to live. 6,334. Brenda Toronto, Canada MacDougall 6,335. Anastasia Burkas Hoeselt, Belgium 6,336. Julia Rostron Manchester, United Kingdom 6,337. Julie Butche Newfoundland, PA 6,338. Katina Czyczelis Glenelg, Australia 6,339. Laura Fremont, NE Roddenberry 6,340. pina protino brindisi, Italy siete dei bastardi ma che male ti ha fatto animale 6,341. irene humphries stoke on trent, United please save these dogs..... Kingdom 6,342. Jennifer McKay Bradford, United Kingdom 6,343. Margaret Chicago, IL Vruelty Thompson 6,344. Judith Starkey Leeds, United Kingdom 6,345. Joanna Merida, Mexico Ciezkowski 6,346. jessica duff wyndham, Australia I cant believe you have to ask...why does anyone want to make another living creatures life a missery. We know better 6,347. Elizabeth Minor Edmond, OK This is terrible!!! Animal abuse can not continue!! This can not be allowed 6,348. Jayme Hess Morgantown, WV 6,349. Heather Butler Leewick, United Kingdom 6,350. Constantine Anoixi-Dionysos, Darmos Greece 6,351. Alicia Norris Pawleys Island, SC 6,352. Dana Palka RENO, NV Get with the program Hawaii...this is animal abuse! 6,353. Denise Liebmann DANA POINT, CA What are you thinking??!!! 6,354. Beate Hansmann Holzminden, Germany 6,355. Richard Mindrum Gainesville, FL 6,356. Ray Young ROCHESTER, NY 6,357. Jean Steel Kilbirnie, United Kingdom 6,358. kathy baker mayfield, NY

Page 228 - Signatures 6,332 - 6,358 Name From Comments 6,359. Olga Djurdjevic Kenosha, WI 6,360. Angela Derbyshire Stockport, United Kingdom 6,361. Hubert Garnich Monza, Italy 6,362. Regine Del Rio, TX McClammy 6,363. donna forde cork, Ireland 6,364. Cathy Canfield Santa Barbara, CA 6,365. Vianneu Vemtura Costa mesa, CA 6,366. Linda Jacobs West Palm Beach, FL 6,367. Jean Le Brun St Saviour, Jersey 6,368. Elizabeth Stadler Marietta, GA No excuse for animal cruelty 6,369. Cathy Bassett Portland, OR 6,370. MARIA PIEDAD rumoroso polanco, ECHEVERRY Spain 6,371. Melinda Finn Rochester, NY 6,372. Sherry Scott Castro Valley, CA 6,373. Sharon Dwvine EGV, IL How about we chain the owners and take the dogs into some protective custody!!! 6,374. Anca Popescu Bucharest, Romania 6,375. Linda Sobieski Elburn, IL 6,376. Jan Forehand Little River, SC 6,377. Judy Grastorf Le Roy, NY Breathtakingly cruel treatment of animals. One hopes that Hawaii is capable of better. 6,378. Julia Barsoum S Bound Brook, NJ 6,379. beckie wood washington, PA 6,380. LeeAnn McDonald Kennewick, WA 6,381. Doug Wiley Saint Charles, MO 6,382. Marnie Goodfellow Waltham, United Kingdom 6,383. marijke kap Mena Creek, Australia it breaks my heart, no animal should suffer on the hands of humans 6,384. Margaret Jean Milano, Italy Mould 6,385. Jeannine ANDRE Montfort sur Argens, France 6,386. Anne Romanow Schaumburg, IL 6,387. Teresa Silva Guimarães, Portugal 6,388. Suzanne Spencer Kintnersville, PA

Page 229 - Signatures 6,359 - 6,388 Name From Comments 6,389. Carrie White Loganville, GA 6,390. Afsaneh Rahmani WOODSTOCK, GA I literally become ill when I read stories like this.This is an Animal abuse and it needs to be taken seriously because it is a serious matter, and it has unfortunately become more and more common. Why support cruelty when you have a choice NOT TO? Dogs in Hawaii should not be thought of so poorly and disdainfully.STOP IT. 6,391. terry mcfadden allentown, PA 6,392. Marjorie Oss Schiller Park, IL 6,393. L Russell Troy, NY 6,394. Marjory Kephart Denver, CO 6,395. Kath Toupy Gent, Belgium 6,396. Amy Self Georgetown, SC 6,397. Jessica Thornton Lincoln city, OR 6,398. Lucimar Sanches Jundiai-SP, Brazil 6,399. Joan Berg Invercargill, New Zealand 6,400. Maria Letizia Basaluzzo, Italy Magri 6,401. Alice Hedden Stroudsburg, PA 6,402. Elizabeth Mesa, AZ This is animal cruelty and you can stop it! Greenwood 6,403. helen steel kilbirnie, United Kingdom 6,404. Eveline McLure Clackmannanshire, United Kingdom 6,405. tatiana galbiati milan, Italy 6,406. Lez Seges Barnet, United Kingdom 6,407. Tam Buonvicino Hallstead, PA 6,408. Patrycja Wydra Katowice, Poland 6,409. irene galicia arvada, CO What has happened to humanity? This is no way to leave these dogs chained up like this, I truly wish we could do the same for all of the bad people in this world. Please end this already, humans are the monsters of this world - not - the animals. 6,410. Kamelia London, United Kantcheva Kingdom 6,411. Marilyn O'Brien Madison, WI Horrifix 6,412. Elizabeth Walker Tucson, AZ 6,413. Denise Gonzalez Alliance, OH

Page 230 - Signatures 6,389 - 6,413 Name From Comments 6,414. saija toth Lund, Sweden 6,415. mike lodico crystal lake, IL 6,416. Sara Leonard FALMOUTH, ME 6,417. kendra courtney Whitanh, MA 6,418. Zach Strei Rockville, MD 6,419. Kristy Sanders Louisville, KY 6,420. Teresa Mynko Lake Elsinore, CA 6,421. Irasema Flores Coral Springs, FL Animals are better than humans 6,422. Janet Murphy Edison, NJ 6,423. C G Burnaby, Canada 6,424. Gloria Johnson Athens, AL 6,425. Sonja Roizen S.Lake Tahoe, CA 6,426. Jayne Schofield Liverpool, United Kingdom 6,427. necole cook SALEM, VA 6,428. Nicola Price Coventry, United Kingdom 6,429. William Bowes St Petesrburg, FL Why do you need to chain a dog! Let's chain the pet owners. 6,430. Luz Pusec MESA, AZ 6,431. Allison Duratz Lawrence, PA 6,432. Rosanne Fischer Beltsville, MD Dogs(who would do anything for us, including die to protect us) deserve far better conditions than being tethered by stinking 3 foot heavy chains. No dog deserves that kind of life. 6,433. BECKY TOPEKA, KS HOLLIDAY 6,434. Samantha Riggi Arlington Heights, IL 6,435. Beverly Lewis Dallas, TX 6,436. Michele Borland Zephyrhills, FL 6,437. Pauline APACHE JUNCTION, Adams-Bryant AZ 6,438. s m BRONX, NY 6,439. Amber Ybarra San antonio, TX 6,440. Darlene Bilyeu Vanceburg, KY 6,441. Maria Lá Salete Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Assacinos amaldiçoados dos Infernos ainda acorrentado Uchôa Rey cadeida pra esse demônio! 6,442. Lucy Amaro León, Mexico jimenez 6,443. Leti Korn DEEPHAVEN, MN

Page 231 - Signatures 6,414 - 6,443 Name From Comments 6,444. Shemirah Brachah Aurora, CO there need to be laws against this cruelty, punishment for those who inflict such cruelty, and better monitoring and reporting of animal cruelty! We are their only hope! 6,445. suan mayhugh COLUMBUS, OH 6,446. Anita Carter Morrow, GA 6,447. Maria Poyatos Longwood, FL 6,448. Jackie Kinnee Northwood, OH 6,449. Catherine Houed San Jose, Costa Rica 6,450. Deborah Metcalf London, United Kingdom 6,451. Cheryl Everson Bloomington, CA 6,452. Carol Jackson Eightmile, AL Well taking Hawaii off plases to vscation ,i wont support thid kind of behavior of their treatment to animals!!!!!!!!!!! 6,453. Tracy Skalitzky Brookeville, MD 6,454. Dawnita Lutz SIERRA VISTA, AZ 6,455. Randi Klein Los angeles, CA Animals do not have a voice. I want to be a voice for them. 6,456. Marjorie Anctil Conway, SC 6,457. Daniella Shaw Toronto, Canada 6,458. Jay'me Golden Lakeside, CA 6,459. Mel Jacobs Neptune, NJ 6,460. Donna DeMarco Frisco, TX 6,461. Karen Clayton Barnsley, United Kingdom 6,462. Art Slott Hewitt, NJ I want to prevent more suffering. 6,463. Mary Seni Dayton, OH 6,464. Lori Gannon Northbridge, MA 6,465. Colin Dendie Slough, United Kingdom 6,466. nancy norton west Burke, VT Protect the innocent. We need to be kind to those under our care. To those humans doing this crime, you will be feeling the weight of your sin around your necks someday. No mercy for you. Teach your children better than your horrid behavior. Do right, now, so they may know love and kindness. 6,467. eileen Stauder gelsenkirchen, Germany 6,468. Denise Wright Fayette, AL 6,469. Lovena Musette Port louis, Mauritius 6,470. Karine Elizabeth Brossard, Canada Curtis

Page 232 - Signatures 6,444 - 6,470 Name From Comments 6,471. esther vd hoeven naaldwijk, Netherlands 6,472. Tina Post Shelton, WA 6,473. Susan Higgins Wyoming, DE 6,474. Kanchan Christchurch, New Singh-mcauley Zealand 6,475. Nansi Shegem La, CA I hear horror stories ... people tell me ..."it's beautiful but dogs are treated so bad you won't like it .."so I don't go 6,476. Barbara Fritts Garland, TX 6,477. eronica martin woodbury, CT 6,478. Elizabeth Shepherdstown, WV Inhumane and inhuman. We can do better by them. We are Wisecarver stewards of this Earth. 6,479. ELIZABETH FISH CREEK, WI CIESAR 6,480. Reta Krukowski Tulsa, OK 6,481. Sattiya Muniandi Selangor, Malaysia 6,482. Vanessa Davis Jackson, MO 6,483. Marianne Harding Harrison, TN 6,485. Kristina Arsens Victoria, Canada Life is for living.....every living being deserves to be treated with respect...... living confined,chained and forgotten is torture for any life...... humans wake up!!! 6,486. Tatiana N Orlando, FL Quinones 6,487. Barbara TUJUNGA, CA Passerelle 6,488. charmen Rose Perth, Australia 6,489. Terry Loveless Hobart, IN That is no way for that baby to live pkease set them free 6,490. sue blaine mechanicsburg, OH Get the dog out of there 6,491. Lestat Marcel Marlton, NJ 6,492. Cherise Sawin Victoria, Canada 6,493. Rasha Didier Cedar park, TX 6,494. MARCY merrill, WI PEVERELL 6,495. Noemie Boulanger Montreal, Canada 6,496. Stephen Allison Durham, United Kingdom 6,497. Brenda young Georgetown, TX Cruelty is not acceptable. The humans who did this need to be killed. The state of Hawaii needs to be accountable for condoning this. 6,498. Tracy Aldea St clair shores, MI

Page 233 - Signatures 6,471 - 6,498 Name From Comments 6,499. NOELLE MOODY Mount Holly, NJ I LOVE ALL ANIMALS & WILL DO WHATEVER IS REQUIRED TO OBTAIN JUSTICE FOR THEM- THIS HORRIBLE PRACTICE OF CHAINING BELOVED DOGS IS REPREHENSIBLE ABUSE. NEGLECT & MISTREATMENT ALWAYS LEAD TO WORSE OUTCOMES. THE MORE ABUSE OCCURS IN ONE AREA THE MORE IT SPREADS LIKE THE DISEASE IT IS. STOP CHAINING & ABUSING THE PRIVILEDGE OF HAVING BEAUTIFUL ANIMALS. CLEAN UP YOUR ACT. THE MORE CARE YOU SHOW FOR YOUR ANIMALS-THE MORE IT WILL BLOSSOM WITHIN YOUR FAMILY UNIT. EVERY ANIMAL COUNTS. EVERY FAMILY COUNTS. CREATE A BETTER WORLD WITH SEEDS GROWN FROM COMPASSION- TAKE THESE BEAUTIFUL DOGS OFF THEIR CHAINS & SHOW THEM LOVE. THE DIFFERENCE IS A VITAL UPGRADE TO A QUALITY OF LIFE SHARED BY ALL- PLEASE SIGN THIS PETITION & HELP- 6,500. Karin Mahuna Chinle, AZ 6,501. shelley poirier Barrie, Canada 6,502. Ginger Davids Winslow, AZ 6,503. Marion Mlodynia Commack, NY This is an atrocity - please stop this; Be kind to innocent creatures. Search your hearts and do the right thing. 6,504. gillian lauder Ashburn, Canada 6,505. A Davis Thamesford, Canada 6,506. Marie Delagarza Tempe, AZ 6,507. kelly johnson courtice, Canada 6,508. Catharine Brown Cartersville, GA 6,509. Julianne Sunnyside, NY LAVALLEE 6,510. Dorothy Spies Edmonton, Canada 6,511. Anna Via Bekasi indonesia, Justice for dogs Indonesia 6,512. Kathleen Price Norcross, GA 6,513. Cordelia Walstijn Vedbæk, Denmark 6,514. Lise-Anne TORONTO, Canada Because I care Crawford 6,515. Lynn Brown Pasadena, TX So inhumane and cruel! 6,516. Sharon Milinazzo Key Biscayne, FL 6,517. Pirjo Ryyppö Espoo, Finland 6,518. Michelle Bean Yorkville, IL

Page 234 - Signatures 6,499 - 6,518 Name From Comments 6,519. christina pafitis narellan vale, Australia 6,520. Jessica Pozzi Lucerne, CA 6,521. Nathalie Djavady Barjols, France 6,522. Linda Hughes Louisville, KY 6,523. Walburga Hemer, Germany Wiegmann 6,524. Kaitlin Mcardle Melbourne, Australia 6,525. Indra Sinniah Singapore, Singapore 6,526. Erica G Denver, CO 6,527. Maya Silva Edmonton, Canada Get Dogs Off 3 foot Logging Chains in Hawaii 6,528. lynn jackson coral springs, FL 6,529. Henry Howe Baker city, OR 6,530. Floyd MARTINEZ, CA Quackenbush 6,531. Marcie Johnson Port orchard, WA 6,532. Lina Sorrentino Daly city, CA How cruel. Lets chain the owners up. Disgusting. Pure evil. Stop the abuse of animals now. 6,533. Marisel Perez Caguas, Puerto Rico 6,534. Stefanie Stief Playa Blanca, Spain 6,535. Sonja Meinhardt Himmelpfort, Germany 6,536. Nadsanan Glen Carbon, IL Watcharakan 6,537. Jennifer Delgadillo San Ramon, CA 6,538. Anita Verma Las Vegas, NV 6,539. Emilia Price Union City, IN 6,540. Miri Miron Kfar Saba, Israel 6,541. Fabian Koblenz, Germany Frankenberger 6,542. Angela DiAmicis Huntsville, TX This breaks my heart! Why are we so inhumane? This is so cruel and barbaric! 6,543. Marilyn Montreux St Paul, MN 6,544. Tanja Janker Regensburg, Germany 6,545. Debbie Borda San Francisco, CA 6,546. Manuela Schilling Herschbach, Germany Hört auf damit 6,547. Luisa Low Potts Point, Australia 6,548. Barbara Fayad Novi, MI

Page 235 - Signatures 6,519 - 6,548 Name From Comments 6,549. K P Cheshire, United Kingdom 6,550. Megan Pleasance Oakhurst, Australia 6,551. Nancy Ehlerange, Lehnen-Marso Luxembourg 6,552. Angela Rigley Bristol, United Kingdom 6,553. FLORA ROSAS LOS ANGELES, CA 6,554. Nathalie Neurath Van nuys, CA 6,555. sybille BOTTIN 4550, Belgium 6,556. Jet Higbie Parma, MI It is ridiculous we have to have a petition for law enforcement and the animal owners to have enough sense to see how cruel this is. 6,557. Anne Smith Liverpool, United Kingdom 6,558. Karen Vo Pasadena, CA 6,559. Jan Koger Augusta, GA 6,560. Kathie Brinks Clermont, FL train the dogs to be good dogs no fighting and they need no CHAINS maybe a leash to take a walk but not chains. stop the madness and be kind or is that above you 6,561. Helen Pedersen Macgregor, Australia 6,562. Roneal Ann Moreno Valley, CA 6,563. Aimy Vu Milpitas, CA 6,564. Sabine Hunger Frankfurt, Germany 6,565. Eva Paizs Harrow, United Kingdom 6,566. Margaret Badger Walla Walla, WA 6,567. sebnem andac bitez, Turkey 6,568. Kathleen Mullin Denver, CO 6,569. Jana Harth Telgte, Germany 6,570. Isabelle Nieuwpoort, Belgium Vanthournout 6,571. Thomas Carline Edinburgh, United Kingdom 6,572. Tina Langstrup Taastrup, Denmark 6,573. Kanani Kai Honolulu, HI I cannot stand for any animal to be abused, and this is abuse. 6,574. Dave Shelton Brentwood, United Kingdom 6,575. Joke Faassen Veldhoven, Netherlands

Page 236 - Signatures 6,549 - 6,575 Name From Comments 6,576. Robwrt Alaniz Sylmar, CA 6,577. Paula Haines Kent, United Kingdom 6,578. Sanjeev Sharma Karnal, India 6,579. Susan Clarke Melbourne, Australia 6,580. Colleen Dawber Auckland, New Zealand 6,581. Sabrina Bruske Darmstadt, Germany Wer gibt uns das recht?! 6,582. Judy Vernon Wanganui, New Zealand 6,583. Zoran Vukić Beograd, Serbia 6,584. debera jacobs HARARE, Zimbabwe 6,585. Ewa Niezgoda Krynica-Zdrój, Poland 6,586. yvonne Bouman Utrecht, Netherlands 6,587. Gunnar Dinter Oderberg, Germany 6,588. Alex Kravets Kiev, Ukraine 6,589. Pia Hanke Wurster Nordseeküste, Germany 6,590. AMBAR PEREZ milano italia, Italy 6,591. Ana Silva Lancsnshire Wigan, United Kingdom 6,592. barbara Kemp Gata de Gorgos, Spain 6,593. Suzette Hackl Hofheim, Germany 6,594. Tim Gilleland Hollywood, CA 6,595. Pursbi Das Guwahati, India 6,596. Mary Tarallo DeMotte, IN 6,597. 임 소정 서울, Korea, Republic Of 6,598. Lyndsey Newton Abbot, United Livingston Kingdom 6,599. G galvin ATLANTA, GA 6,600. sally higgs adelaide, Australia 6,601. Rachel Stansbury Christchurch, New Zealand 6,602. Linda Barlow Ormskirk, United Kingdom 6,603. Beryl Jones Leicester, United Kingdom

Page 237 - Signatures 6,576 - 6,603 Name From Comments 6,604. Marie-Louise Al Khor, Qatar Claringbould 6,605. Melanie Nielsen SHREVEPORT, LA 6,606. wendy wilson kieth ,, United Kingdom 6,607. Viviana Guadagno Roma, Italy 6,608. Philip Carline Manchester, United Kingdom 6,609. karen williams decatur, AL 6,610. Edwin Vargas Sevilla valle, Colombia 6,611. Beverly Schramm PLAINS, PA 6,612. Heena Pandya Vadodara, India Stoo p this cruality , n must for stringly low , save them ,give them jungle for live 6,613. Christine Tarn Paris, France 6,614. pauline gatenby hudds, United Kingdom 6,615. sally carnes saltash, United Kingdom 6,616. Heidi Cassar Abbey Wood, United Kingdom 6,617. Juliane Ottlik Zittau, Germany 6,618. tamara s maria cv, Italy PAKHOMOVA 6,619. Brigitte Maresch Hennigsdorf, Germany 6,620. Helena Sneddon Melbourne, Australia 6,621. Monica Lucchi Cesena, Italy SHAME HAWAII !!! STOP CRUELTY ON ANIMALS IMMEDIATELY !!! HAWAII IGNORANT AND BAD 6,622. Renee Pieterse Almere, Netherlands 6,623. Viktorya Ekinci Newport, United Kingdom 6,624. Jan Rose Hewitt, NJ 6,625. luciana biondi ferrara, Italy 6,626. BEATE Kressin Leopoldshöhe, Germany 6,627. Daniella Freiitas Newark, NJ 6,628. miranda parini magenta, Italy 6,629. Sue White Tiffin, IA 6,630. Apoorva Panda Bhubaneswar, India 6,631. Vince Verwey Brits, South Africa

Page 238 - Signatures 6,604 - 6,631 Name From Comments 6,632. Freya Misner Torbay, Canada 6,633. rosemarie alton, United Kingdom How cruel to keep dogs chained like this donaldson 6,634. Jan Toth Wyandotte, MI 6,635. Blanca Diaz Madrid, Spain 6,636. Michaela München, Germany Vakaresko 6,637. Ralf Riedel Zschopau, Germany 6,638. Gerda Gog Culemborg, Netherlands 6,639. Renaldo Salar Bonn, Germany Giansante 6,640. Iris anneliese Saarbrücken, Gugnon Germany 6,641. Linda Fay EUGENE, OR Sampson 6,642. Marion Vienna, Austria STOP THIS HORRIBLE TERRIBLE CRUELTY NOW AND Mitterhumer FOREVER!!! 6,643. Elaine Greenlee Bisbee, AZ 6,644. Karen Lueth Ocean Shores, Australia 6,645. carol hamilton glossop, United Kingdom 6,646. Cindy Fillmon Webster, FL 6,647. Tiffany Hoang SAN Antonio, TX 6,648. Devina Celeste Heatherbrae, Australia 6,649. Joni Lowther Palm Bay, FL 6,650. Margalida Palma, Spain Montserrat 6,651. Sam Olynyk Mermaid Waters, Australia 6,652. Elisabeth am See, Austria Schernthaner 6,653. Manfred Girod Berlin, Germany 6,654. Lori Mihelic Manteno, IL 6,655. Brigitte Brand Leonberg, Germany 6,656. Pia Everett STERLING, VA 6,657. Lisa B Kramer Cleveland Heights, OH 6,658. EDI DEI GALANTA, Slovakia

Page 239 - Signatures 6,632 - 6,658 Name From Comments 6,659. Mirjam Sorbi Utrecht, Netherlands totally unacceptable this abuse! 6,660. Monique Vetrano Altamonte Springs, FL 6,661. Manuela Lustadt, Germany Valendzik 6,662. Jose Castillo Ruskin, FL 6,663. Jan Crawford Earleville, MD 6,664. Claudia Kühm Schwetzingen, Germany 6,665. Helen Moreland Shoreview, MN 6,666. Donna Truesdale Brockport, PA 6,667. Marie Trejo Zolfosprings, FL 6,668. Paul Robinson Llanrwst, United Kingdom 6,669. Louis Lodyga Miami, FL 6,670. Paola Melotti Roma, Italy 6,671. tricia shawcross warrington, cheshire, United Kingdom 6,672. Cristina Romero Barcelona, Spain Villanueva 6,673. Magdal Rupf Niederrohrdorf, Switzerland 6,674. Kathleen Drude East Brunswick, NJ His face, his eyes tell the story! He is living a life that is full of pain, loneliness, and profound sadness! This life can be changed, please support them! They have to begin rescuing these dogs from these places 6,675. ana mateescu bucharest, Romania 6,676. Margret Wess Gloggnitz, Austria 6,677. ALLEN DAILEY CULLODEN, WV ASS WIPES THAT DO THIS NEED ASS BEAT 6,678. Vladislava Požarevac, Serbia Sermelwall 6,679. Marlene Feldman Agoura Hills, CA 6,680. Sirkka Mäkelä Jyväskylä, Finland 6,681. Gloria Ortner Winston-Salem, NC 6,682. Leslie Tyler Quanah, TX 6,683. Manfred Salzburg, Austria Obernosterer 6,684. anjo deenen venlo, Netherlands 6,685. Luca Ragusa Torino, Italy 6,686. Lynn Miyamoto Reno, NV 6,687. Elsa Schuermann elmshorn, Germany

Page 240 - Signatures 6,659 - 6,687 Name From Comments 6,688. Jane Horton Sheffield, United Kingdom 6,689. Elisabeth Rodda St Kilda, Australia 6,690. MIHARU HIRAKI KUMAMOTO, Japan 6,691. adrian brown TAUNTON, United Kingdom 6,692. I McC newry, United Please stop chaining dogs. Kingdom 6,693. Cheryl Macdonald calgary, Canada 6,694. Julie Weaver Oshawa, Canada 6,695. Marie-christine Burgthann, Germany Biehler 6,696. marianne mansour Raleigh, NC OMG!!! This is crazy!! 6,697. Daniel Hernandez Los Angeles, CA 6,698. vera felgemacher whitby, Canada STOP THE CRUELTY!!!! 6,699. Karen Esau Colorado Springs, CO How can anyone treat dogs this way? Are the in the dog fighting business? Someone needs to go to jail! 6,700. Johannes Tschirk Wiener Neustadt, Austria 6,701. MANUELA Soyen, Germany RIEDER 6,702. Gary Pierson Bokeelia, FL 6,703. Tonya Altemose Effort, PA 6,704. Susan Dunne KENTON, OH 6,705. Tracey Davidson London, United Kingdom 6,706. Hyunsook Ahn STATESBORO, GA 6,707. Kim Conner Biddeford, ME 6,708. liz schiavone Bethlehem, PA 6,709. Harvinder Kaur Owensboro, KY 6,710. Nancy Goin Ladysmith, WI It's a logging chain!!! Tie one around your neck for 48 hours and see how it feels. NO animal should ever be chained. A lot of people should be!!!!!! 6,711. Sherry Hawkins Monroe, MI 6,712. Linda Lynch Yonkers, NY 6,713. Mary Stacy Lubbock, TX 6,714. Julie Graham Virginia Beach, VA 6,715. Erin Coyle Califon, NJ 6,716. Jessica Hyatt Taneyville, MO 6,717. Erika Diaz Dallas, TX

Page 241 - Signatures 6,688 - 6,717 Name From Comments 6,718. Linda Marasco Ocala, FL 6,719. Bev Summers Fort Dodge, IA 6,720. Shelley Brockbank D, Jersey 6,721. Kelly Ritter Watertown, NY 6,722. Alice OConnor Grand Junction, CO 6,723. Kenneth towsom, MD Cramer-Cohen 6,724. Diane Salome, AZ Jones-Zakrajsek 6,725. Marlo Bayham Baton Rouge, LA, LA 6,726. Leslie Rowan Valparaiso, IN 6,727. Lee Sherrill SMYRNA, TN No animal should be treated like that. 6,728. Lindsay Hall Baton Rouge, LA 6,729. TANYA CINCINNATI, OH HAGAMAN 6,730. Marcela Valdes Laval, Canada 6,731. Sandra Silva Extrema, Brazil 6,732. Patricia Lefevre Montrottier, France 6,733. Lieselotte Köln, Germany Schneider 6,734. Dawn Orahood Columbus, OH 6,735. CLAUDIA DE MONTRÉAL, Canada WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH PEOPLE SANCTIS 6,736. LORE Mainardi Roma, Italy 6,737. christine giraudel vigoulet auzil, France 6,738. mauro calabrese fornacette, Italy 6,739. Wendy Chable Wakefield, United How disgusting and cruel is this???? This is animal abuse Kingdom and must be stopped - just look at his poor little face - such sadness!! 6,740. Pepe Iapesa Pacifica, CA 6,741. Christina Brich bucharest, Romania 6,742. joann zboyan NEW MARKET, MD THIS IS INHUMANE. PEOPLE SHOULD NOT ABUSE ANIMALS....GIVE THEM TO A GOOD HOME.. 6,743. Susanne Kösters Heek, Germany 6,744. Stacey Holliday CHATTANOOGA, TN No animal deserves to be put on a rope or chain.....don't get a dog if you can't give them lots of love & affection. ...PERIOD!!! 6,745. Courtney Hough Pocatello, ID 6,746. Amy Mroczkowski Barnesville, OH

Page 242 - Signatures 6,718 - 6,746 Name From Comments 6,747. Pat Bowers Polson, MT This is brutally cruel arrest owner and adopt out dog to loving home. 6,748. kim Staley Mill Creek, WA 6,749. Brian Mullin South Glens Falls, NY 6,750. ROBYN tulsa, OK this is horrific stop the cruelty and abuse WOODLEE 6,751. ann scott carlsbad, CA 6,752. Denise Dussle Waldachtal, Germany 6,753. Marcella lourenço Duque de caxias, dias Lourençodias Brazil 6,754. June Hale Sykkylven, Norway 6,755. Margaret Chester Norton, MI 6,756. Janis Rodman Lake Elsinore, CA 6,757. Robyn O'Neil Lexington park,, MD Thats just horrible why would you do that to those poor dogs thats just mean 6,758. tracey harris vernon, Canada please stop this atrocity 6,759. Cheryl Weiss Granite city, IL 6,760. Sharon Kennedy Etobicoke, Canada I cannot understand how people can live in a community and allow these crimes to happen...have all Christians, Muslims, lost their voice and their consciences? 6,761. Theresa Brown Bremen, KY 6,762. Sonia Checa Rota, Spain 6,763. Debra Milenk Kamloops, Canada This is not right at all!, This is utter Abuse , for Gods sake do not chain a dog! 6,764. Barbara Whittier, CA Cruel and inhumane 6,765. Cindie Jobe Kalispell, MT 6,766. Mariateresa Porlamar, Venezuela Jorquera Aranda 6,767. PATTY PEEK LAGUNA WOODS, CA 6,768. Mette Nordlie Kolbotn, Norway 6,769. Maureen Janis Barking, United Bunn Coelho Kingdom 6,770. Ellen Goodman EAST PROVIDENCE, RI 6,771. Pawel Gurdziel Weiden, Germany 6,772. patricia field gibsonville, NC 6,773. Kay Williams Jupiter, FL Cruelty to animals should be banned and highly punished 6,774. Alberto grassi roma, Italy 6,775. Troy Parrish Hagerstown, MD

Page 243 - Signatures 6,747 - 6,775 Name From Comments 6,776. Rowena Dupre Dublin, CA 6,777. Frances Santiago Los angales, CA Why would u do this stop putting dogs on these chains 6,778. Frances Jones Atenas, Costa Rica 6,779. Deborah Buhrke Wonder Lake, IL 6,780. Eileen Miller Corpus Christi, TX 6,781. BriAnna Brown New Philadelphia, OH 6,782. Tim Dean , CA This is inhumane 6,783. Tamar Shaddeau Grass Valley, CA 6,784. Maria Guido Roma, Italy 6,785. Yolanda Marsh Alconbury, United Kingdom 6,786. Joanne Aberdeen, United McCombie Kingdom 6,787. Lucretia Robbins Davenport, IA 6,789. Randy Saiani Simpsonville, SC 6,790. Anne Boul Carmarthen, United It's a living animal and shouldn't be living like this Kingdom 6,791. Lisa Bass Jacksonville, FL 6,792. sondra keena Concord, CA 6,793. Sylvia Wolford Apollo beach, FL Omg this is heartbreaking and cruel please save this sweet poor inocent Dog 😢 6,794. Audra Gednalske Aurora, CO 6,795. Susan Williams Ste maxime, France 6,796. T Crawford Amsterdam, Netherlands 6,797. Catherine Bennett Greenwood Lake, NY 6,798. Ines Nitsch Triefenstein, Germany 6,799. Elena De Fanis Vaprio d'adda, Italy 6,800. Sylvia Goff Henderson, TX Vile and wrong in every way. 6,801. Amy Hare Hook, United Kingdom 6,802. Julie Luckham kelowns, Canada This breaks my heart and should be stopped 6,803. ROSELYNE Labruguiere, France Ne faites plus souffrir nos chers animaux !!!!!! PETIT 6,804. Jackie Oliver Halesowen, United Kingdom 6,805. Antonia Davies Planet, Spain 6,806. Shirley Holman Kingston, Canada Get these dogs off these horrific chains PLEASE! They are sentient, intelligent beings who truly love humans given the chance. THEY DESERVE BETTER.

Page 244 - Signatures 6,776 - 6,806 Name From Comments 6,807. Cathrine Olsen Bergen, Norway 6,808. norma crichton clubview, South Africa 6,809. antoinette ibanès Saint-Santin Cantalès, France 6,810. Susan Fontanes New Hyde park, NY 6,811. Chip Pough NORRISTOWN, PA 6,812. Jayne Lake San Marcos, CA 6,813. Karen Co REYNOLDSVILLE, PA 6,814. taunaj brockway garland, TX 6,815. Bev Brown Welkom, South Africa 6,816. Sandra Hurtley White rock, Canada I've seen dogs chained in the Hawaiian heat - it is torture! 6,817. Marlène Quidouce Bologna, Italy 6,818. Dorottya Talos Nottingham, United Kingdom 6,819. Kelly Berks, United Saunders-Cross Kingdom 6,820. Sandra Bisogni Casole d'elsa, Italy 6,821. Linda Mcloughlin London, United Kingdom 6,822. Françoise Cunault la Mure, France 6,823. Lisa Murzin East Hartford, CT 6,824. Lisa Zalenski DEARBORN, MI 6,825. Shirley Fennell Morganville, NJ 6,826. Russ Ramirez Costa Mesa, CA 6,827. Eileen Tong Richmond, Canada 6,828. joan Rosenfeld Linwood, NJ Help these poor babies 6,829. Estela Piedade Portimao, Portugal 6,830. diane reason montreal, Canada poor babies should be happy and free 6,831. Linda Bonicelli Boise, ID 6,832. Christine Winnipeg, Canada Saranchuk 6,833. Stephanie GRANADA HILLS, Rosenberg CA 6,834. Hilary Moloney dublin, Ireland 6,835. Sugar Bouche Toronto, Canada 6,836. Michele Graves Arvada, CO 6,837. Margaret Touw Springfield, MA

Page 245 - Signatures 6,807 - 6,837 Name From Comments 6,838. Catherine Longchamp, France Dauvilaire 6,839. linda boyce cambridge, United OMG GETTING A DOG TO SUFFER TIED IN CHAINS Kingdom DISGUSTING AND WHAT FOR DOGS ARE PART OF FAMILY INTELIGENT PROTECTIVE AND SHOULD BE INDOORS 6,840. mireille carlotti toulon, France 6,841. Shawn Hux Jacksonville, NC Stop cruety to animals 6,842. Cheryl Freeman Glen burnie, MD It's inhuman to the animals. 6,843. wanda carthy frankfort, KY 6,844. SARA LEE morden, United Kingdom 6,845. Simone Reichelt Görlitz, Germany 6,846. linda boswell Dulzura, CA 6,847. Lia Carson Philadelphia, PA 6,848. Bärbel Anne Essen, Germany Stüber Pott 6,849. Fadem Bouhiana Ixelles, Belgium 6,850. ANGELA KIPRY siegen, Germany 6,851. Alice Weathington Pleasanton, CA Animals should not be treated this way 6,852. sonia tejeira lima, Peru 6,853. marjorie fleming BROOKSVILLE, FL 6,854. Carlos Otero Barcelona, Spain 6,855. Tiina Jauhiainen Lappeenranta, Finland 6,856. Alicia Thompson Tualatin, OR 6,857. Cecilia Banner Longmont, CO LOOK at these poor animals, look at their deplorable conditions!!! If you can't care for a being, DO NOT GET a goddamn being!!! Fix this!!! Please!!! 6,858. RAY ALVIN NEW YORK, NY 6,859. Sara Brown Acworth, GA 6,860. Joseph Barnett PENSACOLA, FL 6,861. Robert Lipsky Kensington, MD This is DISGUSTING. STOP IT NOW 6,862. Sharon Gay Belfast, Canada 6,863. Candis Miller Mason City, IA 6,864. Libby DiCaprio durham, United Kingdom 6,865. Karl Hammett Burgess Hill, United Kingdom 6,866. george maharis Washington, NC

Page 246 - Signatures 6,838 - 6,866 Name From Comments 6,867. Regina Kohl Praia /grande, Brazil Tavares 6,868. Tara Funderburg Conroe, TX 6,869. sylviane gressler saint-quentin, France 6,870. Robert Irving Dumfries, United Kingdom 6,871. Diane Boz Modesto, CA 6,872. Ana Cochran Las Vegas, NV 6,873. Cheryln Kurz Haverstraw, NY 6,874. ann gardner castleblayney, Ireland 6,875. Julie Goff Porland, ME 6,876. Kanelle Kanelle Marseille, France 6,877. Erika Schauland Braunschweig, Germany 6,878. Cindy Kliege Hannover, Germany 6,879. Maria Moncivais ARANSAS PASS, TX 6,880. mario echegaray Los Angeles, CA 6,881. Cheri MOrgan North Billerica, MA 6,882. Natalia Quiroga Whittier, CA 6,883. Donna Singh Margate, FL 6,884. Pacita Dimacali Alameda, CA 6,885. deborah rowell Livonia Wayne County, MI 6,886. Lilo Prinz Krummenau, Switzerland 6,887. Donna Anderson Bend, OR 6,888. Patricia Duffy Leverett, MA 6,889. Rain Eden Oregon City, OR 6,890. Claudine Sorbello Capalaba, Australia 6,891. Theresa Petrosky Fairfield, PA 6,892. Gail Magnon Elizabethtown, PA 6,893. Rosa Leipoldt Port Elizabeth, South Africa 6,894. viviane bruxelles, Belgium vanbuggenhout 6,895. Ellen Urrea Finestrat, Spain 6,896. VANDA FIELDS Kingsport, TN I'm From HONOLULU Hawaii,And You guys are a disgrace, GET them DOG'S OFF those 3foot Logging chains,WTF Are You Hawaiian IDIOT BOY'S TRYIN To Prove any Frickin Way, GET'EM,OFF.

Page 247 - Signatures 6,867 - 6,896 Name From Comments 6,897. Ruth Helfrich Fallbrook, CA 6,898. Gina Buntz lake park, FL 6,899. Michele Burke St. Elmo, IL 6,900. Barbara Drake Florence, IN Because it's cruel and I humane and probably a dog fighting operation. Logging chains belong on logs, not animals. 6,901. Opal Kennedy Port Saint Lucie, Turks And Caicos Islands 6,902. Jo Bacon POUGHKEEPSIE, NY 6,903. Ann Nguyen Alhambra, CA 6,904. Karin Davina Hengelo, Netherlands 6,905. Jackie Bragoli Wolverhampton, United Kingdom 6,906. Jean Dobizl Tigerton, WI 6,907. Marcia Mathias Santos/SP, Brazil Absurdo os maus-tratos. Demônios ordinários desgraçados. 👹 6,908. Nereyda Garcia Wellington, FL 6,909. Tsnia Roza Miami, FL 6,910. Elizabeth Garrett, IN Hendricks 6,911. Marilyn Berger Pasadena, CA 6,912. tamara burbridge richmond, CA 6,913. Carrie Tay Singapore, Singapore 6,914. Polya Galatinska London, United Kingdom 6,915. Dennis Fuller DEFIANCE, OH 6,916. Laila Plavins Toronto, Canada 6,917. Sandra McGee WINTHROP HARBOR, IL 6,918. Andrea Stewart Idabel, OK 6,919. Susan Martins Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 6,920. Patricia Toronto, Canada Echeverria 6,921. Pamela Buck Tacoma, WA 6,922. Saba Alemayehu Bellingham, WA 6,923. ROBERTO SILI Bormida, Italy 6,924. Marie-Jude Taunton, MA Rochester 6,925. Pat LaBuick Vaughan, Canada 6,926. Anahy Velasquez Broward, FL

Page 248 - Signatures 6,897 - 6,926 Name From Comments 6,927. Tina Doherty Stoneham, MA 6,928. Roberta Sangster Sandston, VA 6,929. Sonia Savage Oyaki, New Zealand 6,930. Clare Jones Dudley, United Kingdom 6,931. Sofia Love Las Vegas, NV 6,932. Angelica Martinez Culver city, CA 6,933. Athena Hogue Torrance, CA DON'T CHAIN ANY LIVING BEING ON THE END OF A 3 FT. CHAIN...UNLESS YOU'RE WILLING TO BE CHAINED RIGHT NEXT TO THEM... 6,934. Laura Siegel Scotch Plains, NJ 6,935. Kurt Meyer Elk Grove, IL No dog needs to ever carry the burden of a logging chain! 6,936. Suze Bujsaim MISSION VIEJO, CA 6,937. Wong Yoke Sin Ipoh, Malaysia 6,938. Dawn Goodman Durham, NC 6,939. bill beaudoin st alphonse rodriguez, Canada 6,940. Scott Dowdy Warner Robins, GA 6,941. Michelle St Paul, MN Schumack 6,942. Robyn Reichert Lake Worth, FL 6,943. Breiana Curry Miami, FL 6,944. Lane Smith Daly City, CA 6,945. Cassandra Okun Vienna, Austria 6,946. Maura Ivan Binbrook, Canada 6,947. P Price Scottsdale, AZ 6,948. Fulbright Fountain, CO 6,949. Susan Haynes GEORGETOWN, TX 6,950. Juliette Simser Peterborough, Canada 6,951. Brigitte Mariani Linz, Austria 6,952. Gloria Fernandez Roselle park, NJ 6,953. Celia Schroeder Watertown, SD Dont like animal a buse 6,954. Arlyn Marroquin Van nuys, CA 6,955. Marcia Costa Novo Hamburgo, Brazil 6,956. Ursula Temmel Untermeitingen, Germany 6,957. Donna Bellefeuille Leominster, MA

Page 249 - Signatures 6,927 - 6,957 Name From Comments 6,958. Connie Frey Silver springs, FL 6,959. Claudia Lippincott Hesperia, CA What kind of an ass would do this? Punish to the fullest extent of the law! 6,960. amanda kaplan Jacksonville, NC Animals are apart of the family and deserve to be treated as such. No one deserves to life their life on a chain. 6,961. Andrea Madruga Brentwood, CA 6,962. Ashley Grunzke Hastings, MN 6,963. kim wright elkhart, IN any idiot can look at this and see it is wrong! what is wrong with you people... this should be a crime everywhere... lucky i can't make laws... you all would never see the light of day again!!! 6,964. Stephanie Peck Jupiter, FL When I saw this I couldn't even believe this was happening in the U.S. Are we Iran or North Korea? 6,965. Denise Andrews London, United Kingdom 6,966. Nissrien Barakat Toronto, Canada 6,967. Molly Hamilton kingston, NY 6,968. Olivia Cutcher Kankakee, IL Sickening 6,969. Dona LaSchiava TUCSON, AZ FOR GOD'S SAKE WAKE UP HAWAII! This VILE SUB-HUMAN SAVAGERY is a clear indication of dog fighting! At the very least, in honor of Hawaii's reverence for nature, a full commitment to eradicating this horrifying animal cruelty should be implemented NOW! 6,970. Linda Crawley MANHATTAN, NY 6,971. Lugene Metzler Vandergrift, PA 6,972. Denise .bell London, United Kingdom 6,973. Elaine Briden Edmonton, Canada 6,974. Nicholas Marino Seaford, NY 6,975. Andrea Scott Sheffield, United Kingdom 6,976. Petra Hall Puyallup, WA This is cruelty 6,977. Janelle Brown Hermosa Beach, CA 6,978. Yoshioka Akemi OSAKA, Japan 6,979. Cathy Baynar Westminster, MD 6,980. Belinda Ciprés Oakland, CA 6,981. Robert Jenkins Salt Lake City, UT 6,982. pamela coleman new london, CT 6,983. Laurie Lansing, MI Hoopingarner 6,984. leonor PEK burnaby, Canada

Page 250 - Signatures 6,958 - 6,984 Name From Comments 6,985. Natalie Gray Pacific Grove, CA 6,986. Danielle Jupiter, FL Ohanesian 6,987. Lynda Okiver Pfds, Canada 6,988. jalayne lindberg toney, AL 6,989. Kerrie Lowry Winnipeg, Canada 6,990. Caty Camp LITTLETON, CO 6,991. Katherine Uy Toronto, Canada 6,992. marilyn Platt Brooklyn, NY 6,993. Carmen De Leon Carolina, Puerto Rico 6,994. Kathi Mann KV, MO 6,995. Mike Hornby Stittsville, Canada 6,996. Karen Conlon Hopewell Jct, NY 6,997. Rebecca Magnoni Santa Fe, NM 6,998. Marla Martin Waukesha, WI 6,999. Rene Cespedes Lima, Peru 7,000. Nancy Hickok Villa Park, IL 7,001. Ute Eagles Guelph, Canada 7,002. Drake Page Glasco, NY 7,003. pansy guffey odessa, MO 7,004. Martine Lacasse Gatineau, Canada 7,005. Julia Walters Hend, NV 7,006. Carolyn Jordan Anderson, SC 7,007. Kelly Fox Chicago, IL 7,008. Misti Reif San Francisco, CA 7,009. Winnetfred Mumbai, India Ballantyne 7,010. Natalie Kikel Highland, NY 7,012. Brett Palladino Sanford, ME 7,013. Vouli Dimkopoulos Melbourne, Australia 7,014. Arjun Athimurthi Butterworth, Malaysia 7,015. Terry Latschar Gettysburg, PA 7,016. Ishita Bundela Chhattisgarh, India 7,017. John Whelan CHICAGO, IL 7,018. Sally Sorensen Westerly, RI 7,019. Sandra Zambon Clifton Hill, Australia 7,020. Kristell Ward Huntington Beach, CA

Page 251 - Signatures 6,985 - 7,020 Name From Comments 7,021. Luisa Morrison Bayside, NY 7,022. d Schneider NEW WINDSOR, NY 7,023. Julie Ann Iloilo, Philippines Patriarca 7,024. Louise Forbes Capalaba, Australia 7,025. Teresa Fisher Edmonton, Canada 7,026. Cara Cornell Rosedale, Canada 7,027. Misha Cheema Tucson, AZ 7,028. George Sidoti East Northport, NY 7,029. Rocio Salazar Bogota, Colombia 7,030. Ometh Layton Bogota, Colombia 7,031. Nelly Lopez Bogota, Colombia 7,032. Tatiana Torres Bogota, Colombia 7,033. Yasmin Schirtzer New York City, NY 7,034. Ambreen Ahmed Khi, Pakistan 7,035. maria lucia Etobicoke, Canada Raffinatore 7,036. Carol Lyn West Warwick, RI Smarten up you ignorant people, it's 2017...dogs and cats Richards are treated like family where I come from!!!!!! Unchain your pets, they have feelings too!!!! 7,037. Nadine Teubner Berlin, Germany 7,038. sushma sachdev gurgaon, India 7,039. Thelma Mikulich Downey, CA 7,040. Michelle West valley city, UT Robertson 7,041. Nicole Walsh Lalitput, Nepal 7,042. Debbie Hitzfeld Round rock, TX 7,043. Honora Bowen Olympic Valley, CA 7,044. Gina Kirchert Lorton, VA 7,045. Malissa Walker heights, FL 7,046. VICKIE LOVE PARIS, KY I SAY PUT BUENAVENTURA AND NISHIMOTO ETC ON A DAMN 3 FT CHAIN AND TIE THEM TO THE CAPITOL! POS! ITS CRUELTY U IDIOTS! CANT U SEE U R SCABS ON THE ASS OF THE WORLD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 7,047. Patrícia Santacruz Barcelona, Spain 7,048. Lucy Harvey Frisco, TX 7,049. Linda Zitek Cedar Rapids, IA 7,050. Sarah Stratford-upon-Avon, Edwards-Johnston United Kingdom

Page 252 - Signatures 7,021 - 7,050 Name From Comments 7,051. Anna Lee Coos Bay, OR 7,052. Lesley Adamson Batemans Bay, This is cruel to dogs. They do not deserve to be on these Australia chains. 7,053. Lalsangpuii Aizawl, India Haokip 7,054. Nts Nts serre, Greece 7,055. Silvana Monti North Bay Village, FL No dog should be chained. If you are a decent owner they won't ever leave.Dogs are wonderful animals,better than some humans who chain them. 7,056. Janet Moskovitz Scranton, PA 7,057. Peta Campbell Cleveland, Australia SHOCKING ANIMAL CRUELTY Campbell 7,058. Janet Pillon Westland, MI 7,059. Ruth Dupre Fort Worth, TX 7,060. Simona Piccinini Reggio Emilia, Italy 7,061. Nicole Martin Howard, WI 7,062. Analisa Gomez Tacoma, WA No animal deserves cruelty and all animal abusers should be punished!!! 7,063. Shirley Scarlett Rochester, NY 7,064. Heather Hardin Flower mound, TX 7,065. Noémi Haszon Nagykanizsa, Hungary 7,066. carol mcgary cincinnati, OH 7,067. Linda Seglem Burns Flat, OK Anyone with any common sense can see how horribly cruel it is for any animal to be chained like this 24/7 and 12 months a year! I cannot believe our law makers in the state of Hawaii are too ignorant to realize this or they're too lazy or just don't care that animal cruelty is running rampant in their state! 7,068. Tucker Oswalt Madison, MS 7,069. Carina Lobel-West Ew Kensington, PA This is just horrific ! Stop it. 7,070. Michele Kelefas West Palm beach, FL 7,071. Monika Sohr Berlin, Germany 7,072. Bridget Mills Kenmore, Australia 7,073. Amber Leyburn, United Brocklehurst Kingdom 7,074. Debbie Knowles Madison heights, VA 7,075. Louise MacGregor CARRINGTON, Australia 7,076. CHRISTINE Fullerton, CA SCHAEFFER

Page 253 - Signatures 7,051 - 7,076 Name From Comments 7,077. María Luz Wilhelm Santiago, Chile 7,078. Lu Watson Cooma, New Zealand Poor darlings Some humans need chaining 7,079. Nuria Viles Barcelona, Spain 7,080. Shirley W P, Malaysia 7,081. Margaret Rizzo Sydney, Australia 7,082. Betty Kline North east, MD 7,083. Mary Sinacore Geneva, IL 7,084. pamela guyon w. henrietta, NY 7,085. Zsuzsanna Wallingford, CT Adorjan 7,086. Teresa Garcia Barcelona, Spain 7,087. Phil Saliba Kent, United Kingdom 7,088. Ana Frommhold Natal, Brazil 7,089. Lut Roelandt Antwerpen, Belgium 7,090. Aaron Austin Salt Lake City, UT All life is sacred. 7,091. Carrie Kopp Edwardsville, IL 7,092. Nancy Swan Corbett, OR 7,093. Récolet Sandrine castelnaudary, France 7,094. Lynda Smith Brandamore, PA 7,095. Maria Valianina ronse, Belgium 7,096. Dian Payne Paso robles, CA 7,097. Matthew Warta Bowling green, KY These are Gods children their here to be loved and cared for not chained like this. 7,098. Paloma Santana Brooklyn, NY 7,099. Brenda Wilson FWB, FL This is aweful and so cruel, people please sign this petition. Get these dogs off the chains, and used for cruel sports. 7,100. Jinnie Hostetler Raeford, NC 7,101. Julie Callahan Santa Cruz, CA 7,102. Elizabeth Reiss Aurora, IL 7,103. Oddrun Geitung Haugesund, Norway 7,104. Caterina Petrilli Guayaquil, Ecuador 7,105. Leighton York Southport, Australia 7,106. Donald Chambers NEW ORLEANS, LA 7,107. Chandra Kulupana Nugegoda, Sri Lanka 7,108. Vivien Gémesi Budapest, Hungary 7,109. Lisa Clark Wichita, KS 7,110. Julie Oca Vero Beach, AZ

Page 254 - Signatures 7,077 - 7,110 Name From Comments 7,111. vicki hood roseburg, OR I despise cruelty and will always fight it. 7,112. Laila Jönsson Bollstabruk, Sweden 7,113. Linda Epps Lakeland, FL 7,114. Terry Henson Eastbourne, United Kingdom 7,115. Carey Larsen Penticton, Canada 7,116. Marilyn Saunders Ridgefield Park, NJ 7,117. Lesley Tooten Lubbeek, Belgium 7,118. Danielle Bierwiler Billings, MT 7,119. christiane monty la louviere, Belgium 7,120. Vanessa Wollgast Trebur, Germany 7,121. Matthias Rüsselsheim, Scheuermann Germany 7,122. Sofia Jensen Copenhagen, Denmark 7,123. Pascale Moret Ménières, Switzerland I thought Hawaï was civilized ! 7,124. Khoa Nguyen Ho Chi Minh, Viet Nam 7,125. Lory Anello Union, NJ This cruelty has to stop!!! 7,126. Denise Moran Walsall, United Kingdom 7,127. Ashu Nahar Kingston, Canada 7,128. Annette Lloyd Batemans Bay, Australia 7,129. Mary Larrimore Panama city, FL 7,130. Lynne Gordon Cape Towm, South Africa 7,131. Essi Toivonen Lempäälä, Finland 7,132. Tresilla Wood Rustington, United Kingdom 7,133. ann Kasemsri Bangkok, Thailand 7,134. Rob Payne Near Brighton, United Kingdom 7,135. Elizabeth Kingsbridge, United Gerwinat Kingdom 7,136. Christina Lange Ulricehamn, Sweden 7,137. Per Millerseth Bromma, Sweden 7,138. Tanja Crljen Split, Croatia 7,139. Eleanor Hammel Bolton, United Kingdom

Page 255 - Signatures 7,111 - 7,139 Name From Comments 7,140. Jodie White Camberley, United Kingdom 7,141. Sylvie Counsell Perwang, Austria 7,142. Rosalind Britain Surfers paradise, Australia 7,143. Harold Stanley East Palestine, OH 7,144. Andrew Lee Birmingham, United Kingdom 7,145. Renate Graafhuis Almere, Netherlands 7,146. Nicola Francis Staffs, United Kingdom 7,147. Jan Smith Abbots langley, United Kingdom 7,148. Sandra Kempten, Germany Löchle-Suljic 7,149. rita placona torino, Italy 7,150. Jeremy Jones Birmingham, United Kingdom 7,151. Janet Brooker Peterborough, United Kingdom 7,152. Christine Chaffey Weymouth, United Kingdom 7,153. Kristine Thomas Ypsilanti, MI 7,154. Susanna Sironen Niittylahti, Finland 7,155. cheryll spencer birmingham, United Kingdom 7,156. Alma Dajlani Tirana, Albania 7,157. Dorothy Greenville, TX Pemberton 7,158. Slavica Ivancic Wien, Austria Stop animal cruelty 7,159. Anna Bucks , Malta 7,160. Andrea Jess Oldendorf, Germany 7,161. Sabine Pertgen Mainz, Germany 7,162. Mary Stewart LONGWOOD, FL 7,163. Elizabeth Lok Stadskanaal, Netherlands 7,164. Sedef Asla İzmir, Turkey 7,165. Bodil Ærøskøbing, Denmark Fabian-Lamijon 7,166. seraphine bad homburg, anzalone Germany

Page 256 - Signatures 7,140 - 7,166 Name From Comments 7,167. Ecaterina Megyes Ineu, Romania 7,168. Wayne Brummer Brisbane, Australia 7,169. Dijana Dellon München, Germany 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼❤️❤️❤️🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼 7,170. Eunice Neves Rio de Mouro, Portugal 7,171. SANDRA LAME hambach, France 7,172. Annbritt Karlsson Motala, Sweden 7,173. Lucy Eaton Providenciales, Turks And Caicos Islands 7,174. Adrianna West palm, FL Marignoli 7,175. yvonne hunter Ormskirk, United Kingdom 7,176. sandra bailey nottingham, United Kingdom 7,177. Shawn Lockwood Smithfield, UT 7,178. Gayle Hoare Oxfordshire, United Kingdom 7,179. Carol Warner Melbourne, Australia 7,180. Karen Ashley Kilmarnock, United Kingdom 7,181. Mara Gorlato Padova, Italy 7,182. francoise milleliri sotta, France 7,183. tania oliver Bilambil Heights, Get Dogs Off 3 foot Logging Chains in Hawaii Worldwide Australia Outrage! 7,184. Irene Pfister Unterkulm, Switzerland 7,185. Angi Beckett Withernsea, United Kingdom 7,186. Marilyn Winnipeg, Canada McCammon 7,187. Megane De EPONE, France Saint-Cyr 7,188. Dorte Bas Viborg, Denmark 7,189. Judy Carter Forest Glen, Australia 7,190. Nicki Stoneman Painesville, OH I hope God chains these POS in hell! 7,191. rachael bolt los abrigos, Spain 7,192. Mark Godbolt Ashford, United Kingdom 7,193. Majbritt kildegaard Vanlose, Denmark Hansen

Page 257 - Signatures 7,167 - 7,193 Name From Comments 7,194. Michele Rozelle, Australia McCamley 7,195. Pauline Nixon Dublin, Ireland Araujo 7,196. Donna Buelt Minneapolis, MN off 3 foot Logging Chains! Hawaii WTH? 7,197. Cristina Danila Zeebrugge, Belgium Ik heb zelf een hond 7,198. Nadia Fox Glenrothes, United This law is so needed. NOW.to help the population you need Kingdom to start with good animal welfare. Please.0 7,199. Denise Allen Devon, United Kingdom 7,200. Natan Rai Gaighat, Nepal 7,201. anne bernard fos sur mer, France 7,202. Carola Hollmann Telgte, Germany 7,203. Kathryn Jenkel Carbondale, IL Chaining and boar hunting dogs needs to be outlawed immediately. 7,204. Isabelke Kovari Bxl, Belgium 7,205. Bitten Østergård Kværndrup, Denmark 7,206. Filomena C Lisboa, Portugal 7,207. Rachel Bunt Madeira Park, Canada 7,208. Ursa Kljuce Bundoora, Australia 7,209. DENIS SEXTON PETERBOROUGH, United Kingdom 7,210. Claudia Koller Carrington, Australia 7,211. Suzanne Downie Swansea, United Kingdom 7,212. sharon illenye essex jct, VT 7,213. Milla Emporia Melbourne, Australia 7,214. Helle Darling Fredericia, Denmark tired of watching grown up acting like big children who wont listen while it's so much easier to make a small child listen to reason then we have adults who are sick and even adults who think this is okay. Well a real adult don't accept this at all they see the lie and the torture these sick people are doing dont be fooled by these evil to think this is normal. Even a child will understand if I say this is wrong please treat it like you want to be treated. Well the towards the animals will in the end mean nothing to this person who have used all their time to make hate agaisnt animals. Whats there to brag about nothing. I send love and hope 7,215. DeAne Vazquez Saugerties, NY 7,216. Rebecca Moore Bearsville, NY Heartbreaking and cruel. 7,217. Alberto Suvtik Sintra, Portugal Freedom

Page 258 - Signatures 7,194 - 7,217 Name From Comments 7,218. Mona Engström Västerås, Sweden 7,219. Debbie Macmillan Alexandria., United Kingdom 7,220. Ronnie Allard WADSWORTH, OH 7,221. Dianne Turner Wonthaggi, Australia 7,222. Julie Marshall FREEHOLD, NJ what the hell is wrong with people 7,223. Arlene Jones Draper, UT 7,224. Amanda Västerås, Sweden Ejnarsson 7,225. Shannon Adams Palm coat, FL 7,226. Maina Rangel RS, Brazil 7,227. Natasha McKay Sydney, Australia 7,228. elena edu iasi, Romania 7,229. Eva Schalin Overijse, Belgium 7,230. Haydee Pisa Cascais, Portugal 7,231. SANDRA COOK new castle, PA THIS IS VERY CRUEL-PLEASE GET THIS STOPPED 7,232. John Coleman Jr ft. lauderdale, FL 7,233. Angela Clinton Twp, MI SAVE THESE DOGS NOW ! Grammatico 7,234. Cristiane Emygdio Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Gomes 7,235. Christine Dudley Newport, NC 7,236. SHIRLEY NUNES LONDON, United Kingdom 7,237. viginia Randall CRANESVILLE, PA 7,238. Cindy Clark Douglasville, GA 7,239. Nikki Herrero Palm City, FL 7,240. Jessica Thomas Saratoga Springs, NY 7,241. Joan Bowkett Milton Keynes, United Kingdom 7,242. Dee Munro North Yorkshire, Its so bloody cruel!!! It should not happen. United Kingdom 7,243. Greg Stats Mermaid Beach, Australia 7,244. Vijaya Agarwal Mumbai, India 7,245. Laura Gomez Barcelona, Spain 7,246. RoseMarie Digilio N. Babylon, NY 7,247. Mary Dergance LaSalle, IL 7,248. marti blake springdale, PA

Page 259 - Signatures 7,218 - 7,248 Name From Comments 7,249. Nina Paul Boulder, CO Chaining these dogs is criminal animal abuse. 7,250. john brighton watford, United Kingdom 7,251. Shari Breitung Naperville, IL why has nobody taken any action, take these dogs away now they deserve a good home!!! 7,252. Alexandra Porto, Portugal Cordeiro 7,253. Christine Ritter Margate, FL 7,254. Mia Santos Faro, Portugal 7,255. Dallene Weaver Acworth, GA 7,256. Judith Notario Borrassa, Spain Calurano 7,257. Mary Briggs Carol Stream, IL 7,258. Michael Koeppen Florence, MT 7,259. Carmen Gibswil, Switzerland Harrassee 7,260. John Morgan Bedlington, United Kingdom 7,261. Mariette Young Rusternburg, South Africa 7,262. Bernardette Coventry, United Feehan Kingdom 7,263. Gail Frances Northampton, United Smith Kingdom 7,264. Charlene Muscat , Malta 7,265. Michael Inhauset Bad Tatzmannsdorf, Austria 7,266. Carolyn Mogavero San Diego, CA 7,267. Julie Martenson Austin, TX 7,268. Maria Bansfield Lynn, MA 7,269. C De Villiers Pretoria, South Africa 7,270. Martin Schmitz Magdeburg, Germany 7,271. Viktorija Trpceska Skopje, Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic Of 7,272. Jayne Loza Converse, TX 7,273. Petar Todorovic Smederevo, Serbia 7,274. Sergio Chueca Lima, Peru 7,275. Stephanie Ayan Hampstead, NH 7,276. Evelyn Roldan Newark, NJ

Page 260 - Signatures 7,249 - 7,276 Name From Comments 7,277. Bernie Doherty Wexford, Ireland 7,278. Martha Bailey Marydel, DE 7,279. Maxine Crook Pakenham, Australia 7,280. Lydia Chow Quincy, MA 7,281. Susan Grimmer London, United Kingdom 7,282. terry ripoli woodridge, IL 7,283. Victor Dumitras Köthen, Germany 7,284. Silvia Steinhilber Ste Anne, Canada 7,285. Jade Lapiere Niagara falls, Canada 7,286. Susan Sera Dandenong north, Victoria, Australia 7,287. Nikki Dee West jordan, UT 7,288. Lidice De Martinez Pembroke Pines, FL 7,289. Bibiana Korbova Presov, Slovakia 7,290. Hilda Rice birmingham, United Kingdom 7,291. Annie Willems SCHOTEN, Belgium 7,292. Riina Mikkonen Järvenpää, Finland 7,293. Jennifer Alexander Spring, TX 7,294. roz ransom london, United Kingdom 7,295. Delia Schulz Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires, Argentina 7,296. olga werniewicz Warsaw, Poland 7,297. julie Macmillan Bideford, United Kingdom 7,298. Dana Cox Mesa, AZ 7,299. Deanna Moncrief Antioch, IL 7,300. Wendy Linton Seattle, WA 7,301. Deborah Jones Meriden, CT OMG!! This has to stop now! 7,302. Diana Leblanc St.Leonard, Canada 7,303. Anne Presley Retford notts, United Kingdom 7,304. Rosa Villalva Corrientes, Argentina 7,305. Alejandra Garay corrientes, Argentina 7,306. Montse Alcaraz Barcelona, Spain 7,307. Valerie Capone Framingham, MA

Page 261 - Signatures 7,277 - 7,307 Name From Comments 7,308. Maria Bonnici Mellieha, Malta 7,309. Jane Peacock Hertfordshire, United Kingdom 7,310. Tulin Attila Hackney, United Disgusting inhuman cruelty Kingdom 7,311. Sylvia, Karlsruhe, Germany Hoerenberg 7,312. Norman Chevrier Athelstan, Canada 7,313. Paula Doyle Shepherdsville, KY Because this is a form of animal ABUSE ! 7,314. Sally Carter Adelaide, Australia 7,315. marikyn thompson craanbrook, Canada 7,316. Martine Cougul Ste rose, Guadeloupe 7,317. Nadja Kill Carmarthenshire, United Kingdom 7,318. Margaret Moore JOHNSTOWN, PA CRUELTY IS INHUMANE 7,319. marilyn rock carmel, NY 7,320. Shawna Erazo Reno, NV 7,321. Liana Roginsky Paris, France 7,322. Bonnie Watkins Medicine hat, Canada 7,323. Katherine Velo Cuyahoga Falls, OH 7,324. Louise Pritchett RYDE, United Kingdom 7,325. helen will Cheltenham, United Kingdom 7,326. Nancy Dunlap Bend, OR 7,327. Susan Johnson Keyport, NJ No animal should live on a chain 7,328. Mary Brown Bolton, MA 7,329. Susanne Kegel Birkenwerder, Germany 7,330. Sharon Wood Tacoma, WA 7,331. Joy Eva ANGLESEY, United Kingdom 7,332. Chantal Vergnault Dourdan , STOP !!! STOP !!! Loggin chains in Hawaii France 7,333. Michele Desgain Kill Devil Hills, NC 7,334. Marlyse Hanssens Lembeek, Belgium 7,335. Tamara McGinty Parma, OH Beyond abusive. Hideous. The owners who treat their Koncek animals like this should receive the same treatment back and worse. 7,336. Amanda Wallace Magnolia, TX

Page 262 - Signatures 7,308 - 7,336 Name From Comments 7,337. Hillegonda De Groningen, lange Netherlands 7,338. Geoff Simmons Cincinnati, OH 7,339. donna furano milford, CT 7,340. Annunziata Pisoni Alzano Lombardo, Italy 7,341. Donna Fisher Tucson, AZ 7,342. Melody Veylupek Canoga Park, CA Welcome to Hawaii?.....not that pretty to look at the helpless dogs of the heartless owners in Hawaii!!.....No sign necessary...just go there and get them out of the depression place NOW!!!...... if want to sign it..it will take forever to reach the 20,000 goal!!....go there and do it NOW!!!! 7,343. Ilean Brown Elliot Lake, Canada 7,344. Angela Miller EVANSVILLE, IN 7,345. Mary Conde Brooklyn, NY 7,346. Helle Norberg Frederiksberg, Denmark 7,347. Kris Jensen Lacey, WA Why do we need to be so cruel and abusive to our animals?? Di do want to be chained up on a tire all your life ?? Its horrific 7,348. Pireta Fiedler Konz, Germany 7,349. ophelia marçal porto, Portugal 7,350. Irish Cornaire Watertown, NY This is so wrong. 7,351. Kerstin Weiss Karlsruhe, Germany 7,352. Sandra Dixon , VA 7,353. Linda Stevenson Spring, TX 7,354. Terri Hoshell Warrenville, IL 7,355. Elizabeth Dryjas Glendale, NY Stop abusing animals, take away the chain from that poorly dog 7,356. laeticia demedts ronse, Belgium 7,357. jeanne aubert cortaillod, Switzerland 7,358. Laura Lucier Reno, NV 7,359. Margaret Turner Bury St Edmunds, United Kingdom 7,360. Lacy Dreis Austin, TX Are you kidding me? You still allow dogs to live chained??? How barbaric! Time to change your lame laws! 7,361. Josephine Skitt Willenhall, United Kingdom 7,362. Robyn Peterson Providence, RI 7,363. Phyllis Derfner Sunny Isles, FL

Page 263 - Signatures 7,337 - 7,363 Name From Comments 7,364. Erica Dominicus Alkmaar, Netherlands No chain ...pleace do you chain youre children .stop this . 7,365. Josephine Hoven Sparks, NV 7,366. Manu Roberts Tbilisi, Georgia 7,367. Haelie Shaw FORT COLLINS, CO 7,368. Ingrid COMIN WOIPPY, France 7,369. Anneli Jonsson skärholmen, Sweden 7,370. carlene ahern North Attleboro, MA 7,371. Laura Wolkofsky Tom river, NJ 7,372. DIANNE LONG BEACH, CA PORTANOVA 7,373. Federico Ramello Genova, Italy 7,374. Sandra OBER-MÖRLEN, Welter-Kalbhenn Germany 7,375. Star Jazuk Wrexham, United Kingdom 7,376. JEAN BRAMPTON, Canada MCCARTHY 7,377. Christina Sjöström Umeå, Sweden 7,378. Angel Dunning Portland, TN 7,379. Melodie Obrien Zephyrhills, FL 7,380. Elena Aponte Bronx, NY 7,381. Marlene Stokes Los Lunas, NM 7,382. Mandy Werner Dortmund, Germany 7,383. Linda Ramos Wichita Falls, TX 7,384. Brian Reynolds ATLANTIC CITY, NJ 7,385. Diane Tuohy Oradell, NJ 7,386. nedra comack lucerne, CA 7,387. Claudia Ferreira Myrtle Beach, SC 7,388. Ruth Ann Buck Plainfield, IL This should never happen and needs to be stopped!! 7,389. Vincent Ambroselli Ozone Park, NY 7,390. Vickie Dunlap Jewett, OH 7,392. Laurie Sumner Winterville, NC 7,393. Sonja Reiner Wien, Austria 7,394. Teresa Nicholls London england, United Kingdom 7,395. Davi Parrish Port Angeles, WA 7,396. Stasia Harris New York, NY 7,397. Adriana Rodriguez Miami, FL

Page 264 - Signatures 7,364 - 7,397 Name From Comments 7,398. Johan Strauven Nieuwerkerken, Belgium 7,399. Julia Doenham Sunderland, United Kingdom 7,400. Deborah Mercer Edwardsville, IL It's inhumane and must stop! 7,401. Nicole Ortiz STANDISH, ME 7,402. Sandra Collins Lake City, FL 7,403. Luree Dell-Bryan Shawnigan Lake, No animal deserves to be restricted from freedom! Canada 7,404. Mitzi Millikan Madisonville, KY 7,405. Susan Petersen Monterey, CA 7,406. Margarita Hazlet, NJ Cianchetta 7,407. Miia Watka Pukkila, Finland 7,408. Goffredo Gambini Milano, Italy 7,409. marian mcann London, United Kingdom 7,410. Tina Shrivastav Västra Frölunda, Sweden 7,411. Alan Rautenkranz Seattle, WA 7,412. Miriana Zaccaron Sondrio, Italy Condivido petizione 7,413. Ambassador Palm Desert, CA Karen Cantrell 7,414. valentina filip severin, Romania 7,415. Tamara Williams Norwalk, OH 7,416. Isabel Silva Penafiel, Portugal 7,417. Victoria Lange Aalborg, Denmark 7,418. jessie southan dudley, United cruel.. Kingdom 7,419. Joan Donachie Beith, United Kingdom 7,420. adolfo antolini Ghlin, Belgium Il faudrait attraper l'individu que maltraite ce chien et lui faire comprendre avec la même attitude à son égard qu'il doit respecter tous les êtres vivant y compris les animaux. 7,421. Rocky reuter Greensboro, NC 7,422. Laurent Baldovino Marseille, France 7,423. clare adams llansadwrn, United Kingdom 7,424. Robert ERIE, PA Schlaudecker 7,425. Birgitte Munding København, Denmark

Page 265 - Signatures 7,398 - 7,425 Name From Comments 7,426. Janice Chytra Toronto, Canada 7,427. barbara valdes ozzano della emilia, Italy 7,428. Anette Florstadt, Germany Gaede-merz 7,429. Zuzana Dijon, France Svantnerova 7,430. Kathleen Kastner San dieguito Drive Encinitas, CA 7,431. Kevin Newson Los Angeles, CA 7,432. k co la verne, CA 7,433. Tracey Spy Surrey, United Kingdom 7,434. Laura Perez Estado de Mexico, Ningun ser que fue creado para vivir en libertad merece Mexico pasar toda una vida encadenado, bajo ninguna circunstancia. 7,435. Heike Luckaßen Wesel, Germany 7,436. Claire Savino Chappaqua, NY 7,437. Karen Seifert Roseville, MI 7,438. Gloria Fiorini Casper, WY 7,439. Ursula Teahan Milltown, Co. Kerry, Ireland 7,440. lori funk helenville, WI 7,441. deb hayes harrow, Kenya 7,442. Josie Farinaccio Montreal, Canada 7,443. Cindy R Wagner Purlear, NC This is disgusting!! Can't Hawaii do better than this! 7,444. Marie Aldred Midhurst, Canada 7,445. Christi Remaly Smith's grove, KY 7,446. Erica Dahlberg Durango, CO 7,447. Dave Saunders Thornhill, Canada 7,448. Lizethe Proano Quito, Ecuador 7,449. Conny Vogel Mengen, Germany 7,450. Lisa Morrison Bunbury, Australia 7,451. Daniela Zega Constanta, Romania 7,452. Helen Thompson Montgomery, AL 7,453. Anne Fellenius Stockholm, Sweden 7,454. Dietmar Loibl Schöfweg, Germany 7,455. Wylmer Rivera Bogotá, Colombia 7,456. Audra OLeary Newbury, MA

Page 266 - Signatures 7,426 - 7,456 Name From Comments 7,457. Rose Davis Coudersport, PA 7,458. Maria Loredo Schertz, TX 7,459. Marlyn Johnston Barrie, Canada 7,460. Cynthia Gibbons Meridian, MS 7,461. Sabine Gohil Berlin, Germany 7,462. Jan Harvell Funtington, United Kingdom 7,463. ROBIN Deo Port Charlotte, FL 7,464. Cecilia Campbell Edmond, OK 7,465. Valérie RAYNAUD SAINTE-SUZANNE, 7,466. barbara braun nordenham, Germany 7,467. Kim Birch London, United Kingdom 7,468. Maria Morencio Lisboa, Portugal 7,469. jennifer hayward dannevirke, New Zealand 7,470. Catherine Schloss Livingston Holte-Stuckenbrock, Germany 7,471. Darrell McIvor Belfast, United Kingdom 7,472. Linda Jacobs University Park, IL 7,473. Bryan Coleman Santa Cruz, CA 7,474. Ankie Ellajdel Vendelsö, Sweden 7,475. Tina Ausbrooks Auburn, KY Dogs should have freedom to run not chained up!! 7,476. Jessica Chapman Deep Gap, NC 7,477. Judith Bergdorf WEST BROOKFIELD, MA 7,478. Carol Corbey Norwich, United Kingdom 7,479. Andreina Garbati La Seyne sur mer, France 7,480. Annette Wessberg Stockholm, Sweden 7,481. madeleine bühler rüschegg, Switzerland 7,482. Lotta Westman Tyresö, Sweden 7,483. Ellen Cather Montgomery, IL NO animal should be abused, suffer or live like that. Very cruel treatment. Inhumane. They deserve good treatment, love, good care, food, fresh water, medical care, and be able to run around.

Page 267 - Signatures 7,457 - 7,483 Name From Comments 7,484. Brenda Baxter Cody, WY 7,485. Celine Villax Belmont, NC 7,486. nobuyuki yonaha tyatan, Japan 7,487. Grace R Gorelick Los Angeles, CA This is cruel and inhumane 7,488. Sherry Nolan BLOOMINGTON, MN 7,489. Kelly Fourie Johannesburg, South Africa 7,490. Marion Jurchen Berlin, Germany 7,491. Donna Varty Kamloops, Canada Why are they allowing dog fighting which is illegal! That is such horrible animal cruelty using those ridiculous heavy chains! Hawaii - stop this abuse!! 7,492. Kerry Kirby Lisburn, Ireland 7,493. Esat acar Güngör Jantiant, Turkey 7,494. Christine Howard Gloucestershire, United Kingdom 7,495. Wendy Lee-Flavell Flesherton, Canada 7,496. Juan Garces Riobamba, Ecuador 7,497. Katarina Lee Whitianga, New Hawaii people are very progressive so they need to find Zealand humane alternative 7,498. Garnet Erdakos Penngrove, CA 7,499. Cheri Eberwein Waco, KY 7,500. beatrice felicia bucharest, Romania 7,501. Laura Burns Largs, United Kingdom 7,502. Doris Harder Mastic, NY 7,503. Darlene Baneky Lodi, NJ 7,504. Donna Hammonds Kannapolis, NC 7,505. Teresa Openshaw Essex, United Kingdom 7,506. Faze Myri Köln, Germany 7,507. Felice Smith Rockledge, PA 7,508. harry talmadge milford, PA 7,509. Justin Carr Ellesmere Port, United Kingdom 7,510. Wendy Wilkinson Gainsborough, United Kingdom 7,511. Vicky Pinheiro Framingham, MA 7,512. denise miceli phoenix, AZ 7,513. RICHERE DEZIEL Morin-Heights, Outrageous ! Canada

Page 268 - Signatures 7,484 - 7,513 Name From Comments 7,514. Daryl Conner Haines City, FL Who does this? Better think before you do this. 7,515. Zoya Krysteva Stara Zagora, Bulgaria 7,516. Dee Suarez Cypress, CA Plz stop animal abuse!! This aint right give these animals a chance to live a happy life!! 7,517. David Steed Stoke, United Kingdom 7,518. Angela Lentz Covington, GA This is torture!😡 7,519. Tina Austin Nottinghamshire, United Kingdom 7,520. Jade Stephens Wicklow, Ireland 7,521. Mary McKenzie El Paso, TX 7,522. Jadranka Tomic Beograd, Serbia 7,523. Ursula Lohmann Langenselbold, Germany 7,524. daniela montalto roma, Italy 7,525. Maria João de Vila Real, Portugal Sejam humanos e não monstros. Carvalho 7,526. Dawn Turner York, Canada 7,527. Lainey Simpson Gillingham, United Kingdom 7,528. Carol Shaw Wicklow, Ireland 7,529. Marisol Huijon Renton, WA 7,530. Kat Leslie White River Junction, VT 7,531. susan hilberer long beach, NY 7,532. Andrew and Landisville, NJ In civilized communities the awareness of continuously Jo-Ann tethered dogs is unacceptable and considered animal Sangataldo cruelty, please do the humane thing and pass anti-tethering legislation. 7,533. Silke Rodriguez Waynesville, MO Welfare of any dog 7,534. Anja Tieste Kassel, Germany 7,535. Cezary Krupa Miami, FL 7,536. Yolanda Wilson River Grove, IL 7,537. Anne-Marie Wetteren, Belgium Neckebroeck 7,538. Natalie Van Wilrijk, Belgium Damme 7,539. Dana Jenkins Kapolei, HI 7,540. GUY SWEENEY TROUPSBURG, NY How do "people' live with themselves? Its beyond comprehension!!!

Page 269 - Signatures 7,514 - 7,540 Name From Comments 7,541. gwenda mobsby brighton, United disgusting inhumane act to this dog Kingdom 7,542. Iris Somerton London, United jones Kingdom 7,543. Maria Dixon Union, NJ 7,544. kim labelle belleville, Canada 7,545. Marrtha Skinner Nsb, FL 7,546. Christine PIMONT France, France 7,547. Reto Rallen Itanagar, India 7,548. Herlé Quinquis Vidauban, France 7,549. Isabel Escalon Albuquerque, NM 7,550. V. Preston Regina, Canada 7,551. Rosalie DeVore Fernandina Beach, FL I have said it before, no being should live their life at the end of a chain, alone, neglected, and denied love. 7,552. Maria angela Torrance, United Obrien Kingdom 7,553. Valerie Amiot Pine Grove, PA 7,554. Josie Tuthill London, United Absolutely horrific barbaric cruelty this needs to be put a Kingdom stop to immediately 7,555. Lee Hamilton McAllen, TX 7,556. mary gardner ramseur, NC STOP THIS CRUELTY!!! 7,557. Heather Tillman Hampshire, United Kingdom 7,558. Cleici Alves neiva Curitiba, Brazil 7,559. Risa Matayoshi Yaese, Japan 7,560. Marina Zängler Schaafheim, Germany 7,561. Sue D'Andrea Cambridge, MN Life on a chain is no life for a dog! They are dependent on people and interactions with people! Learn to love dogs and treat them right! 7,562. Terri Mitro Fort wayne, IN 7,563. Michele Morris Nashville, TN 7,564. Christine Laughlin Victoria, Australia 7,565. Carol Courtney Mission Viejo, CA Look at the picture read the story. I'm sure you will sign to. 7,566. James Benko Woodbridge, NJ 7,567. Alexis Alberini Carpi, Italy 7,568. Fran Lowell Almont, MI 7,569. Janine Johnson Erlangen, Germany 7,570. Marly Wexler San Diego, CA this is wrong, that's all there is to it.. chaining anyone who can feel suffering, is cruel..

Page 270 - Signatures 7,541 - 7,570 Name From Comments 7,571. Sheri Rauch Northampton, MA 7,572. Laura Harper Christoval, TX 7,573. candi petersen glenview, IL 7,574. Kerry Roberts Easton, PA 7,575. Bonnie Sunday jacksonville, AR Extreme Cruelty to dogs. 7,576. Renata Murez PASADENA, CA 7,577. natasha salgado toronto, Canada 7,578. Honey Grodt Ankeny, IA 7,579. wanda stewart augusta, GA I hate this because your dog should be treated like family would u put a logging chain on ur family members !!😇 7,580. Karina Haldane Caroline springs, Australia 7,581. Niki French Brockton, MA 7,582. Ellen Klomp IJsselstein, Netherlands 7,583. Allison Kuhl Tincan bay, Australia 7,584. Patricia Orlando London, United Kingdom 7,585. Betty Tharp Louisville, KY 7,586. Lynne Roller Greeneville, TN 7,587. Ajla Dautovic Växjö, Sweden 7,588. Christine Saldana Alamo, TX Stop the torture of animals. 7,589. Betsy Sanders Lumberton, NJ 7,590. Teri Stewart Beeton, Canada 7,591. Daniella Garcia Brownsville, TX 7,592. Irene Kubosh Offutt afb, NE 7,593. Linda Fronk Douglasville, GA 7,594. Kent Templeton House Springs, MO 7,595. Cynthia Carson Danville, VA 7,596. Toni Lunac Fullerton, CA 7,597. Dr Susannah Telluride, CO Smith 7,598. Lorena Mcmurrin Hot springs, AR 7,599. Julie Smith Venice, FL 7,600. Fay Ray Brooklyn, NY 7,601. Anna Rita Leonetti Sant'Egidio alla Vibrata (TE), Italy 7,602. Denise Weingart Los Angeles, CA 7,603. Chantel Butler Greensboro, NC Page 271 - Signatures 7,571 - 7,603 Name From Comments 7,604. Mikaela Gray Tampa, FL All living things deserve kindness and respect 7,605. Margaret Widnes, United Bradburne Kingdom 7,606. Carrie Miller Mableton, GA 7,607. Amy Webb Montreal, Canada 7,608. Tania Zanini Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 7,609. Linda and Jack Oshawa, Canada Power 7,610. Patricia Midland, TX Flynn-Williams 7,611. Lydia Pyun Nyack, NY The ugly and barbaric side of Hawaii 7,612. Linda Ryan Burnsville, NC 7,613. Shirley Conley ROCK ISLAND, IL 7,614. Sharon Bradbury Barto, PA 7,615. Imola Baumann Denver, CO 7,616. Julia Szkiba Santa Clarita, CA 7,617. Kristy Leon Bronx, NY 7,618. Bonnie Kirk Cary, NC 7,619. Nicole Casper NEW ALBANY, OH 7,620. ANA ALEMAN Las Vegas, NV END ANIMAL ABUSE!!! 7,621. Eva DeRoche BEAUMONT, TX 7,622. Stephen Nealley Aurora, CO 7,623. He Alblas Gorssel, Netherlands Be nice to all animals! 7,624. Dina Dutta Sarkar Kolkata, India It has to end!!! It's Horrible... 7,625. Jody Weinman Shirley, NY 7,626. Nora Skinner Lake Charles, LA 7,627. Elisha Minsal Deerfield Beach, FL 7,628. June Vongsavanh Tampa, FL 7,629. Diane j Haye Batavia, OH 7,630. Melanie Matula Willow Springs, IL 7,631. Cheryl Anderson Mississauga, Canada 7,632. Margaret Johnson Toronto, Canada 7,633. Kelli McLeod St Paul, MN 7,634. julie gaines delafield, WI 7,635. Indora Toronto, Canada Nankoosingh 7,636. Andrea Gutiérrez México City, Mexico

Page 272 - Signatures 7,604 - 7,636 Name From Comments 7,637. Debbie Hebrard Sacramento, CA All chains should be outlawed!! If you don't have love for a dog or a brain don't get one!! 7,638. Deb Mcmanus Windsor, CA Disgusting to do to such loving souls omg 7,639. Jane Kusaka San Bernardino, CA 7,640. Rhiannon Young Whangarei, New Zealand 7,641. Melissa Duralia WELLINGTON, FL 7,642. Ashley Banesh Collegeville This is horrifying, these dogs also love my family medical collegeville, PA attention ASAP. Has anyone contacted the local SPCA in or near the town where these dogs live in to open an investigation? So sad! This is no way for any animal to live 7,643. Diana Echwald Næstved, Denmark 7,644. Sandra Siebert Sydney, Australia 7,645. Kim Hoshal Portland, OR 7,646. Nancy Velasco Glendale, AZ Dogs are our friends and companions. They are emotional beings, this horrible behavior should Not be tolerated, Chaining dogs is WRONG and Abuse!!! 7,647. Robyn Grogan San Diego, CA 7,648. Emilio Morales Caguas, Puerto Rico 7,649. Taz Butler GLOUCESTERSHIRE, United Kingdom 7,650. Ann Wilson Granger, IN This is HORRIFIC!!! 7,651. Melanie McCall ALABASTER, AL 7,652. Sherilyn Knoll Carmichael, CA 7,653. Maxine Morning Auburn, WA 7,654. Lily Silva Orange, CA 7,655. Denise Di sisto Wantirna South, Angola 7,656. Marie Negrete Anaheim, CA 7,657. Rose Miras Melbourne, Australia 7,658. joke jansen artemida, Greece I LIKE TO CHAINED THESE BLOODY BASTARDS SO THEY CAN FEEL THE TORTURE. AL GOVERNMENTS IT IS THERE DUTY TO HAVE A LAW AGAINST ANIMAL ABUSE. AN ABUSER MUST AT LEAST BEHIND BARS,AS WEL A PSYCHOPATH TEST. WHEN YOU ABUSE OR KILL ANIMALS YOU ARE ABLE TO DO THE SAME WITH HUMANS. 7,659. Carmen andrea PUNTA arenas, Chile Ollarzu 7,660. milly doe Madison, WI 7,661. Tammy Hanson Melbourne, Australia Page 273 - Signatures 7,637 - 7,661 Name From Comments 7,662. Celia Contreras Kearns, UT 7,663. Mindy Ramirez La Mirada, CA 7,664. Georgeanne PORT JEFFERSON Matranga STATION, NY 7,665. max franke perth, Australia this is cruel please free them 7,666. Evangeline San Diego, CA Miranda 7,667. Candace San Jose, CA Donaldson 7,668. BECKY DIGBY ilfracombe, United Kingdom 7,669. Marcel Verbelen londerzeel, Belgium 7,670. Iris Velasquez Surprise, AZ 7,671. Nellt Walczak Villebois, France 7,672. Leticia Gallegos Edinburg, TX Don't like dogs to suffer. 7,673. diane orefice East Northport, NY 7,674. Gerhard Rösner Altena, Germany STOP IT NOW ITS PERVERS 7,675. Helga Guillen Melbourne, Australia 7,676. Michèle Beckers Guilmécourt, France 7,677. Lisbeth Svensson Hono, Sweden 7,678. Alina Navrea Bucharest, Romania 7,679. Claudine Wakkerzeel, Belgium Goossens 7,680. Marlyse Culot Ervy le Châtel, France 7,681. Vera Nauwelaerts Westerlo, Belgium 7,682. Donna mitchell Plattsburgh, NY 7,683. Sue Poriazis Johannesburg, South Africa 7,684. Gehane Heshmat Giza, Egypt 7,685. Andrea Thiel Köngernheim, Germany 7,686. Isis Cortes Brooklyn, NY 7,687. Lynne Oldham Buckley, United Poor excuse for humans ....how could they treat these poor Kingdom dogs like this 7,688. ingrid portier bourg-fidele, France 7,689. Gillian Evans WAKEFIELD, United Kingdom 7,690. Rebecca Garrett Groveport, OH 7,691. Yip Ko yuen fairbanks, Hong Kong

Page 274 - Signatures 7,662 - 7,691 Name From Comments 7,692. nathalie le blévec sannois, France 7,693. Olesya Cheetham Millom, United Kingdom 7,694. Milagro Ocariz Mérida, Venezuela I´m against all kinds of animal cruelty 7,695. Martha Coulter Ocean View, NJ Would YOU like to be chained like this all day and all night? Then stop this abuse! Get them adopted by loving families who would never do this! 7,696. Gael Fraser-Tytler Westmount, Canada NO DOG SHOULD EVER BE TIED UP LIKE THIS!!!! EVER!!!! ITS HEINOUS CRUELTY!!!! 7,697. Petra Mitschrick Kerkrade, Netherlands 7,698. Lynne Grant Quorn, Australia 7,699. Ben Oscarsito My Hometown, Sweden 7,700. christine stripling CLACTON ON SEA, Totally wicked , how can you justify this awful wicked cruel United Kingdom behavior. Pleas stop this and let these poor dogs have a life. Thank you, UK 7,701. Tana M Las Vegas, NV Meriwether 7,702. Mary Sorrentino manchester, CT 7,703. danielle mascouche, Canada tourangeau 7,704. Christine Utzinger , Germany This is teribble animal abuse! Must end immediately! A COUNTRY CAN BE JUDGED BY THE WAY, IT'S ANIMALS ARE TREATED. MAHATMA GANDHI 7,705. Peter Jaho Nerja, Spain 7,706. Anne Wileman Tamworth, United This animal cruelty must be stopped worldwide. Why do they Kingdom have animals just to chain up? 7,707. marilyn basulgan riyadh, Saudi Arabia loving creature 7,708. Stephen Doughty Willenhall, United Kingdom 7,709. andreas zoglmeier münchen, Germany 7,710. Christine Dawson Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom 7,711. Francesca Milano, Italy Rebuscini 7,712. kathy oberther elmira, NY 7,713. britta rennwald kiel, Germany bestraft diese Tierquäler endlich und sperrt sie für immer weg 7,714. Alexandria Glasgow, United Why have dogs if this is how they are treated. . Stop this now Wessels Kingdom there is no good reason to be so cruel

Page 275 - Signatures 7,692 - 7,714 Name From Comments 7,715. Jenni Haughton Belmont, Australia 7,716. mitsi glynou athens, Greece 7,717. Marie BORDEAUX, France SALLABERRY 7,718. Israel Schwierz Wuerzburg, Germany 7,719. Bernice Bealy Boucherville, Canada 7,720. marilyse dumas Ottawa, Canada 7,721. david arnauld marsat, France 7,722. Teresa Hamilton Federal,Way, WA 7,723. Diana Eyres Liverpool, United Kingdom 7,724. Victoria Andreo TOLLAND, CT 7,725. Halina Drwecka Queens Park, Australia 7,726. Maria Ledezma Goodyear, AZ 7,727. Alex Richards Nevada city, CA 7,728. Sau tsang LAS VEGAS, NV 7,729. Françoise Cabries, France Baussan 7,730. Carmen Ermel Trier, Germany 7,731. Stacey Hewgill Barrie, Canada 7,732. Laura Cozma Vaslui, Romania 7,733. Eve Normand Fall River, Canada 7,734. marilyn heller kansas city, MO 7,735. Ngoc Nguyen Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam 7,736. Pheona Rossiter Haddington, United Kingdom 7,737. Helen Smith Cardiff, United Kingdom 7,738. Christine Weir Perth, Australia 7,739. françoise vannes, France Viallefond 7,740. Ute Brixius Pirmasens, Germany 7,741. Beatrice Lelievre Menton, France 7,742. manikandan t erode, India 7,743. JILL WATSON Slough, United Kingdom 7,744. Matei Cerasela Craiova, Romania

Page 276 - Signatures 7,715 - 7,744 Name From Comments 7,745. Lisa Bertrand Sulphur, LA 7,746. Iris Glarner-Frey Oberzissen, Germany 7,747. Synthia La louviere, Belgium Gianquinto 7,748. Denise Bennett Norfolk, United Kingdom 7,749. Donna Hedrick Ft Myers, FL 7,750. Monique Schreck Bischbrunn, Germany Ich gebe meine Stimme den Tieren 7,751. sharon ogrady worthing, United Kingdom 7,752. Jenica Lambert Brookfield, IL 7,753. margaret rose wolverhampton, United Kingdom 7,754. Audrey Noble Leicestershire, United Kingdom 7,755. Elizabeth Degante Sanra Ana, CA Its inhumane 7,756. Dixie Howard House Springs, MO 7,757. Amanda G Huntington, WV This is abuse and must be stopped now! Why are you so far behind the other states? 7,758. Kelly Hyde HAYWARD, CA 7,759. Ruth Dessemontet Saint Barthélemy, France 7,760. paula saraceno Denver, CO THIS IS INHUMANE. AS A TRAVEL AGENT I WILL QUIT SENDING PEOPLE TO HAWAII. 7,761. Theresa Chartrans Hanmer, Canada Animals deserve better then this, put end to chains for dogs!! 7,762. Wendy Buchanan Dartmouth, Canada 7,763. Maurizio Slanzi San Colombano al Lambro, Italy 7,764. clara sharp MARIETTA, GA This is no way for a dog to exist. It is barbaric and abusive. They become stressed, the know they are unloved, and no decent human would ever do such a thing. ANYWHERE! 7,765. Ian Kirby Lincoln, United Kingdom 7,766. Fiona Day Stockport, United Kingdom 7,767. Tatiana Ioannidou Thessaloniki, Greece 7,768. Brenda Lee Coffie Chandler, Canada 7,769. Marilyn Graziano Torino, Italy 7,770. Fran Petty Pebble Beach, CA 7,771. Michelle Brazda San Jose, CA

Page 277 - Signatures 7,745 - 7,771 Name From Comments 7,772. Nina Valery Montreal, Canada 7,773. Julia latchford Plymouth, United Kingdom 7,774. Patricia Smith Southend-on-sea, United Kingdom 7,775. Sarah TUCSON, AZ Friedman-St. John 7,776. Teresa Wehunt PORT CHARLOTTE, slavery is over for everyone, Please stop the cruelty FL 7,777. Catherine Dredge Waterford, Canada This is no life for ANY dog! 7,778. Marie Delepeleere bruxelles, Belgium 7,779. bruno tonetto burelles, France 7,780. Gwen Hoss Grand Junction, CO It is cruel and inhumane. 7,781. Guadalupe V San Antonio, TX Castaneda 7,782. Ortrun Merx Eislingen, Germany 7,783. Taylor Priest Andrew, IA 7,784. Suzi Mandic Scottsdale, AZ 7,785. Siw Monsteras, Sweden Tikkanen-Aldén 7,786. mary sheen nepean, Canada 7,787. Ann Johnson Eastbourne, United Kingdom 7,788. Vallee Rose JACONITA, NM 7,789. Sharon Clark East sussex, United Kingdom 7,790. Sharon Needham Rock hill, SC This is a disgrace to humanity 7,791. Lori Anne Stoneham, MA No animal should have to live like that! McPherson 7,792. Mary Reed Belding, MI 7,793. Nicole Troyan Randleman, NC 7,794. cheryl Casati Glendale, AZ 7,795. Riika Johansson herrljunga, Sweden 7,796. Michelle Mcgirr Port charlotte, FL 7,797. LARA VINBRET veracruz, Mexico 7,798. Andrea Crosta Neptune, NJ 7,799. Judith Taylor Dunmore, PA

Page 278 - Signatures 7,772 - 7,799 Name From Comments 7,800. Therese Powers N. Fort Myers, FL Chains are for trucks to haul cars. Chains are not to be put on animals necks to put pressure on their neck and spines. How would you feel with a 5-20lbs. chain around you neck day after day and years. a dog collar is just fine. It doesn't make them look like you own a mean dog. They are helpless and hurting for the pains they endure. STOP THIS ACTION. 7,801. Danny van Huizen Geldrop, Netherlands 7,802. Judith Treanor Exeter, United Kingdom 7,804. Elisabeth Schorr Thun, Switzerland 7,805. Vanessa Avanzini Sala Baganza, Italy 7,806. Paula Azar Whitehall, PA 7,807. Tara Mcghie Greytown, New Zealand 7,808. p bowlan Memphis, TN 7,809. Christeen CRESTVIEW, FL Anderson 7,810. Heather San Francisco, CA McPherson 7,811. Regina DeFalco Martinez, CA This is animal cruelty!!! Lippert 7,812. Michael Huntington Beach, CA Henderson 7,813. Francine Ramez LIEVIN, France 7,814. Shawna Howard TULSA, OK 7,815. Deborah Solario NAPA, CA 7,816. Lanette Norris Houston, TX 7,817. Desiree Contwig, Germany Börner-Jost 7,818. Joyce Bakker East Harwich, MA 7,819. bozena kordek kitchener, Canada 7,820. sheila griffin BG, KY if only the perpe t rators would be assured the exact same treatment !! 7,821. brian nielsen Brabrand, Denmark 7,822. Laura Larsem London, United Kingdom 7,823. Fitna Franzke Friesoythze, Germany 7,824. Gaëlle lopes blanzat, France 7,825. Somodi Tamásné Dunakeszi, Hungary 7,826. Lucy bargone tarpon springs, FL

Page 279 - Signatures 7,800 - 7,826 Name From Comments 7,827. SOva Maharana Grimsby, United Kingdom 7,828. Stacey Rame Tamarac, FL 7,829. Katja Silander Kaarina, Finland 7,830. carey winicki banning, CA 7,831. Wanda Gumm Los Angeles, CA 7,832. Gabriela Matias Altônia, Brazil Guerra 7,833. Taylor Ivy Kingsbury, TX 7,834. Deborah Houston, TX Vaquerano 7,835. Nicole Best CLEARFIELD, UT 7,836. Raquel Vogel Berlin, Germany 7,837. Marie Samuelsson Luleå, Sweden 7,838. Alyssa Wengel RICHBORO, PA 7,839. Renate Eisbacher Tittmoning, Germany 7,840. Sibylle käser Göppingen, Germany 7,841. richard isley toledo, OH 7,842. Anne Corbo Scottsdale, AZ Must be stopped immediately the purposeful abusemof these sweet and beautiful dogs. 7,843. Susan Wheeler Lawrence, KS 7,844. Martha Brown Lancaster, PA 7,845. Miranda Williams Armstrong, Canada Disgusting. Why have a dog if this is what you are going to do! 7,846. Inka Ingrid Eßer Köln, Germany 7,847. Louise Moore St Austell, United Kingdom 7,848. Michelle Leftwich Cabot, AR 7,849. Jill Osment Bristol, United Kingdom 7,850. Theresa Ogle Niceville, FL 7,851. andy T. Patra, Greece 7,852. Sam Baldwin Wokingham, United Kingdom 7,853. Lynn Storm Crownsville, MD 7,854. Diane Malpass Willenhall, United Kingdom 7,855. John Mulroy Hove, United Kingdom 7,856. Barbara Nielsen Waterloo, Canada

Page 280 - Signatures 7,827 - 7,856 Name From Comments 7,857. diane zuraski pt charlotte, FL 7,858. Dominique Fehn Whiting, NJ Will boycott any and all items from or processed from Hawaii. Disgusting practice! 7,859. Jessica Saxton Copiague, NY 7,860. Karen Kozlowski Lowestoft, United Kingdom 7,861. Pat Tomlinson Ryde, United Kingdom 7,862. Belinda Irving, TX No dog should be continually chained up. Please help by Compotaro signing and sharing this petition 7,863. Angry T lincoln, United I love dogs and this is WRONG. Kingdom 7,864. John Brewer MARIETTA, OH 7,865. Nicole Belardo North royalton, OH 7,866. Noelle Lapcevic Raleigh, NC 7,867. Dave Gralty Natick, MA 7,868. Elena Rogojkina Little River, SC 7,869. Peter Gentgen Merzenich, Germany 7,870. Sandra Newcomb Johnstown, CO 7,871. Vilma Salvador San Fernando, CA 7,872. Karen Douiglas Fresno, CA It's cruel!!! 7,873. Tricia Domono Metairie, LA Any abuse of animals is EVERYONE'S respondibility to bring to an end. 7,874. Toby Ann Reese Valley City, OH 7,875. Jason Gates Linden, MI These animals deserve better!!! 7,876. Lynda Roth Grand Prairie, TX 7,877. BetteAnn Grube Gurnee, IL 7,878. Andree Desjardins Longueuil, Canada 7,879. Sylvie Pelletier Laval, Canada 7,880. Gabriel Blanco New York, NY 7,881. Waltraud Tegernheim, Germany 3 foot long logging chain? Animal Abuse! Meierdierks 7,882. Eileen Sutley Apopka, FL 7,883. Mary Hines New Milford, CT 7,884. Vicky Yang Taipei, Taiwan 7,885. Lisa Sullivan Yazoo City, MS 7,886. Jeanie Casanova Opeloussas, LA Barbaric and cruel...... just because you CAN do this does not mean you have the right to do so...please stop this abuse 7,887. Sharon Chatwin Tooele, UT 7,888. Karen Lindsay Beech Island, SC

Page 281 - Signatures 7,857 - 7,888 Name From Comments 7,889. Gayle Klein Moreland Hills, OH Dogs are sociable creatures. They need attention and interaction. It is extreme cruelty to leave them out by themselves. Also, that heavy chain is painful and unhealthy. 7,890. Fran Young Hillsboro, OR This atrocity has to stop NOW 😡😢 7,891. Arnold Warners Rotterdam, Netherlands 7,892. Sonja Bohnsack Bridgetown, Barbados 7,893. Catherine Oak Lawn, IL This is DISGRACEFUL AND ANIMAL ABUSE! Please stop Dominici this horrible treatment of man's best friend. Dogs are better than most people and have feelings too. 7,894. Elizabeth Doyle Rochester, NY 7,895. Gia Alessandro East rockaway, NY 7,896. Marie-lyse Longueuil, Canada Brazeau 7,897. Charlene Chillicothe, MO Please do not put dogs on those chains. It changes their Thompson personalities. 7,898. Kimberly Gage Newburgh, NY Ugh. Over and over we have to remind humans that we are supposed to be the "human" in "humanity". When will our race figure this out. 7,899. Alla Maksimovich Perth, Australia 7,900. Josee Boudreau Lavaltrie, Canada 7,901. Anna Nelson Santa fe, NM 7,902. Jamie Patricia Peace River, Canada MISCH 7,903. Michael Gee Cowbridge, United Kingdom 7,904. Gloria Grotjan Aptos, CA 7,905. Heidi Rissanen Kellokoski, Finland 7,906. Mario Mendez Anchorage, AK Dogs should not have to endure this kind treatment if you must have chain this put it around your neck 7,907. Debbi Good Marleston, Australia 7,908. Marian Hussenbux Birkenhead, United Kingdom 7,909. Charlotte Nichols Kamarooka, Australia 7,910. Kathy Alvarado Hurt, VA 7,911. kerrin uytendaal St.Andrews Beach, Australia 7,912. Nicole Schwäbisch Hall, Scheffelmeier Germany 7,913. danielle robert HERSIN COUPIGNY, France

Page 282 - Signatures 7,889 - 7,913 Name From Comments 7,914. LORENZO Trujillo San Diego, CA Jr 7,915. andrew askew doncaster, United Kingdom 7,916. Paula Allen Fernwood, ID 7,917. Kathlee Hickson New Smyrna Beach, FL 7,918. dave perry wivenhoe, United Kingdom 7,919. Carol Martin Vancouver, Canada 7,920. Marcia Holdstock Redhill, United Kingdom 7,921. Julia Woods Taunton, United Kingdom 7,922. Patti Level San Antonio, TX 7,923. Roberta Elsley perth, Australia 7,924. maria Sharpe Lynn Haven, FL 7,925. Renate Keller Krefeld, Germany 7,926. Elaine Kent Christchurch, United Kingdom 7,927. Stuart Thomas TUCSON, AZ 7,928. Chris Manley Kingsbridge, United Kingdom 7,929. sandy primo wilmington, MA 7,930. Traci Richard Chapiin, SC 7,931. Celina Fiorino Philadelphia, PA 7,932. LORRAINE BROOKLLYN, NY CRIMANDO 7,933. Mark Sheppard Bridgend, United Kingdom 7,934. Angelina Ricketts Worcester, United Only bastsrds who chain there pets. They need to be thrown Kingdom to the lions den x 7,935. Judith Wilkings London, United Kingdom 7,936. Jennett Griffiths Leicester, United No animal should be chained ! Look at his face an unhappy Kingdom distressed dog 7,937. Ece Gürcan İstanbul, Turkey 7,938. Jayne Cassidy Briarcliff Manor, NY 7,939. nancy martin warren, RI 7,940. sue baxter bowdoinham, ME

Page 283 - Signatures 7,914 - 7,940 Name From Comments 7,941. Linda Mitchell Luton, United Kingdom 7,942. Laura Lanzi Milano, Italy 7,943. maggie janus brighton, United Kingdom 7,944. Nataliia Martyniuk Kharkiv, Ukraine 7,945. Margaret Maxwell Liverpool, United Kingdom 7,946. Janet Berg Alicante, Spain 7,947. Brandy Cherven BERLIN HEIGHTS, OH 7,948. Bruce Calder BOARDMAN, OH 7,949. Else Stellema Plucklet, United No dog should live on a chain! Kingdom 7,950. brigitte Bruxelles, Belgium vanbekbergen 7,951. Barbara Kohn San, CA 7,952. Sherry DeClercq Tucson, AZ 7,953. Js Angela Prague, Czech Republic 7,954. Maricel Briones Rizal, Philippines Please stop this. 7,955. renee dambron ostheim, France 7,956. Barbara and Matawan, NJ Robert Brucker 7,957. Susan Cooke Cornwall, United Kingdom 7,958. Marjolaine Plessisville, Canada SVP svp svp Gagnon 7,959. marie-louise sint niklaas, Belgium vercammen 7,960. Brigitte st jean Lincoln, Canada 7,961. Vi Saffer Leeming, Australia 7,962. Karla Walters El dorado, KS 7,963. Laure Cormier Paris, France 7,964. Beverly Scott KINGSPORT, TN The dog pictured says it all. No other words. 7,965. Karen Laffey Larkspur, CA 7,966. Jeannie Baker San Jacinto, CA 7,967. Stella Snyder Phoenix, AZ 7,968. Leann Harris Scranton, PA 7,969. sylvie Robinette vercheres, Canada

Page 284 - Signatures 7,941 - 7,969 Name From Comments 7,970. Guylaine Labonte St-Jerome, Canada 7,971. Malous Farhadi Toronto, Canada 7,972. greta toman ostrava, Czech Republic 7,973. ROBIN severn, MD WINDSOR 7,974. Laura Huikuri Jyvaskyla, Finland 7,975. france gagnon granby, Canada 7,976. ANGELA england, United BUTTERWORTH Kingdom 7,977. Silvia Schaefer San Rafael, CA Stop chaining up dogs! Help them not abuse animals! 😡 7,978. Pia Mittler Diez, Germany 7,979. France Poulin OUtremont, Canada 7,980. Linda Mcdonald Montreal, Canada 7,981. Shannon La quinta, CA Mcdonald 7,982. Fran Morgan Haatings, United Kingdom 7,983. Caterina Malden, MA Consider it "culture" to starve and chain dogs to hunt wild Moynihan boars. Dog-Boar fights Are even held now, where dogs are pitted against a particularly nasty boar. If you consider this YOUR culture then you are in the dark ages to see and support this animal abuse. Same on you and your culture. Wake UP it is 2017 7,984. Beverly Jacobs Bowling Green, VA Disgraceful and monstrous. Any decent government must abolish this practice. The innocent and helpless must be protected from the low, evil monsters who would torture and harm them. 7,985. Beatriz Zebadua Mexico city, Mexico 7,986. Pedro Giraud Puerto Vallarta, Mexico 7,987. Annie Choiniere Lawrenceville, Canada 7,988. Janet Madiello Plymouth, MA 7,989. Paula Santos Vila Nova De Gaia, AMIGOS ASSINEM E DIVULGUEM POR FAVOR! Portugal 7,990. Anna Cimino Liège, Belgium 7,991. suzanne nadeau montreal, Canada 7,992. Sunny Holmes NEVADA CITY, CA 7,993. Mike Bekiers Farmingdale, NY 7,994. Bonnie Wrenshall Unionville, Canada

Page 285 - Signatures 7,970 - 7,994 Name From Comments 7,995. Rebekah Amos Selby, United Kingdom 7,996. Lajeanne Leveton Fleming Island, FL 7,997. Penny-Ann Singer London, United Because quite simply this is downright cruel! Kingdom 7,998. luc labrie st jerome, Canada 7,999. Carolyn Butler Apache Junction, AZ 8,000. Yvonne-Marie Aberdeen, United Grace Kingdom 8,001. Christine Gravel Boucherville, Canada 8,002. Annie Parigi Draguignan, France 8,003. Irmgard Asperg, Germany Dogs are social, it is cruel and inhumane to keep them on a Gutersohn chain! 8,004. Bianca Piehl Münster, Germany Respekt und Rechte der Tiere fordern 8,005. veronika herrmann wainfleet, Canada 8,006. lenore taylor tanja, Australia WRONG 8,007. Judith Abbott SANBORNTON, NH Cruel, inhumane, a crime against God's creatures. 8,008. Roselee Florence, SC This is absolutely inhumane! Please stop it! Hershman 8,009. Judy Taylor Huddersfield, United Kingdom 8,010. roxie doring powder springs, GA 8,011. Claudia Lange GREENSBORO, NC Why does any dog need to be on a LOGGING CHAIN? This is horrible abuse! 8,012. Sheryl Stevenson Deltona, FL 8,013. Tina Fitch Madison, CT 8,014. Heather Riggs Albuquerque, NM 8,015. Terry Pratt Fayette, ME 8,016. Kt Hertfelder Ballwin, MO 8,017. Joanne Bunyan Buderim, Australia 8,018. Michael Arky Bronx, NY 8,019. Brian Belantan Bakersfield, CA 8,020. Ruthann McCoy Lexington, KY This is cruel. 8,021. maria de fátima Bh, Brazil ribeiro silva 8,022. Majid Abachi Richmond Hill, Canada 8,023. Brian Paulus Severn, MD 8,024. judy storkamp minneapolis, MN

Page 286 - Signatures 7,995 - 8,024 Name From Comments 8,025. MARYCECILIA DENVER, CO SEDILLO 8,026. Rita Weinreb Dana Point, CA 8,027. Lynn Farmer Brook Park, OH We need to learn to live compassionately if we want to see a better and safer world and it all begins with how we treat animals. 8,028. Beverly Singer Albuquerque, NM 8,029. SYLVIANE piton stleu, Reunion CODARBOX 8,030. Azar Asghari McLean, VA 8,031. Jill Walker Lyndhurst, OH 8,032. Pamela polhamus christiansburg, OH PASSIVE AND ACTIVE CRUELTY There are two kinds of animal cruelty inherent across the spectrum of animal abuse. ACTIVE CRUELTY, which is cruelty inflicted (with deliberate intent to harm an animal creating immediate pain and suffering), and PASSIVE CRUELTY (harm inflicted via willful neglect creating prolonged suffering). Regardless of the arguments that it may be the "custom" to ritually slaughter an animal for its fur or skin, or eat the animals we call our companions, cruelty is cruelty and cannot be disguised. All animals killed in these practices are "SENTIENT." They feel excruciating pain, fear and terror. This fact cannot be disregarded. While no regard is paid to this fact in many other countries, as a European and North American society we have a choice and must choose not to support and to condemn this absence of regard. Animal cruelty is no longer a simple issue and categorically cannot be ignored. Animal cruelty issues long considered a peripheral concern are no longer on the outskirts of our society. Clinicians, veterinarians and scientists are starting to see a shift in that mentality now. Animal cruelty is now recognized as signature pathology. Animal abusers are five times more likely to commit violent crimes against people. "To inflict cruelties on defenseless creatures, or condone such acts, is to abuse one of the cardinal tenets of a civilized society - reverence for life." There are a number of very important reasons that animal abuse should be considered a violent crime in our legal system. First, we know based on personal experience and countless scientific studies that animals are not things. They are nothing like other “property” such as tables and chairs. Animals are sentient beings with the ability to feel a range of emotions, and they are harmed both physically and psychologically by violent abuse, much as human beings are. They deserve to be treated under the law as the complex creatures that they are. classifying animal abuse as (continues on next page)

Page 287 - Signatures 8,025 - 8,032 Name From Comments 8,032. Pamela polhamus christiansburg, OH (continued from previous page) a violent crime and tracking and punishing it accordingly, we will protect both helpless animals and the people animal abusers are more likely to abuse. While it is incredibly important to appropriately punish animal abusers this change would play an even larger role in the way we regard animals in our society. When we consider the harm done to animals as equal to the harm done to members of our own species, we can begin to change cultural perceptions of animals and one day upgrade their status from being property to being individuals in their own right. It is only when this conscious change is made that we can hope to see a real change in the way that people treat and view animals. It’s not only an upgrade in the law, but an upgrade in our own values. 8,033. Isabel Schober Eagle, CO 8,034. Maricor Salvador Zamboanga, Philippines 8,035. manju robin kottayam, India 8,036. Anne Granholm Turku, Finland 8,037. Bj Craig Findlay, OH Put a log chain around their neck, about 5ft long, & made to wear it for 2 or 3 days, see how they like it. 8,038. Michaela Pilloni Sunnyvale, CA 8,039. eileen chenot irvine, CA 8,040. Kristin Wise Tallahasse, FL 8,041. Christine Basildon, United Millington Kingdom 8,042. Jeannette Frederiksberg, ANDERSEN Denmark 8,043. gillian sinclair Folkestone, United Kingdom 8,044. Debbie Edwards South Lismore, Australia 8,045. nimet kaynak İstanbul, Turkey 8,046. Ulrich Eczko Datteln, Germany Es treibt einen die Tränen in die Augen. Wer tut was??? 8,047. Takako M Chiba, Japan 8,048. Janet Tuttle Falls, ME 8,049. Sheila Gilbert Broadstairs, United Kingdom 8,050. l vincent roche saint julien en vercors, France 8,051. Jill O'Brien Gillingham, United Kingdom

Page 288 - Signatures 8,032 - 8,051 Name From Comments 8,052. Robyn Decatur, GA This is an abomination and beyond cruel. Pass a law making Spiegelman it illegal to tear her, chain up or restrain any animal! 8,053. Kelly Perrault Jacksonville, NC 8,054. Kiran Mand Maroubra, Australia 8,055. rhonda farrell Durham Androscoggin County, ME 8,056. jeanie elford worthing, United Kingdom 8,057. julia summerhill frederick, MD 8,058. LINDA GRASSO Maine, NY J 8,059. Alena Tchuřova Chropyně, Czech Republic 8,060. christiane page pals, Spain 8,061. Ivana Andulajevic Banja luka, Bosnia And Herzegovina 8,062. Lisa Koehl ORMOND BEACH, FL 8,063. Lisa Ricchetti Albuquerque, NM 8,064. Magalis Santiago Miami, FL 8,065. Stella Bowers San Diego, CA 8,066. Elizabeth Lancashire, United Harrington Kingdom 8,067. Cindee Fox Hollywood, FL 8,068. CHRISTINE GRENOBLE, France RAYMOND 8,069. Nora Choban Pasadena, CA 8,070. Anja Knorr Metzingen, Germany 8,071. Emek Felekoglu SANTA MONICA, CA 8,072. Linda Butler Warren, OH 8,073. Judith Loshaw Minneapolis, MN 8,074. georgette Murray West wildwood, NJ 8,075. Isabelle Lavenu SAINT-VALERIEN, France 8,076. GUY JOUVE Le Monteil, France 8,077. NANETTE RUTH Lakeport, CA 8,078. Carol Kerrison San Brunio, CA 8,079. d gauthier québec, Canada 8,080. Wanda Trotta Rockwall, TX 8,081. gabi scheuring hofheim, Germany

Page 289 - Signatures 8,052 - 8,081 Name From Comments 8,082. Ellen Gutfleisch SUSSEX, WI 8,083. Kristin Ryals New York, NY 8,084. Juliette Ebanks George Town, Cayman Islands 8,085. Chithral Sampath Seeduwa, Sri Lanka 8,086. Rosana Bello Sao paulo, Brazil 8,087. brigitte issot haguenau, France 8,088. Glenda Young Sultan, WA 8,089. Georgi Merrigan Cape coral, FL 8,090. YANINA BURBANK,, CA CARREON 8,091. enock ndou Johanesburg, South end terror against animals Africa 8,092. Sarah Spitler Kailua kona, HI 8,093. Irene Hutton Ayr, Australia 8,094. Madeline Kadle Peterborough, NH 8,095. Caroline Brennan Brantford, Canada 8,096. Marianne Danis Lac-des-Ecorces, Canada 8,097. Diane Meade Basye, VA Unconscienable!! Poor animal. 8,098. NICK ROBLEY manchester, United Kingdom 8,099. Linda Stumpf Colts neck, NJ 8,100. janet johnson Knoxville, TN 8,101. Karen Reem San Francisco, CA This is outrageously abusive. This law must end. 8,102. Bérénice Valliguieres, France SZAJNER 8,103. Kathleen Brower Npr, FL 8,104. Kelly Gaouette Sullivan, NH I am against any form of animal abuse 8,105. Maryanne Paul Calgary, Canada This practice is cruel and we know better as a society , time laws in USA change in all states about chaining !! 8,106. Sylvie Boisclair Laval, Canada 8,107. Phyllis Schultz Tinton Falls, NJ 8,108. Shirley Temple Torquay, United Kingdom 8,109. Petra Kristyan Ebreichsdorf, Austria 8,110. Kaitlin K Baltimore, MD 8,111. Andrea Hood Hartlepool, United Kingdom

Page 290 - Signatures 8,082 - 8,111 Name From Comments 8,112. Elaine Terlecky Berlin, CT Stop killing and abusing GOD'S CREATURES 8,113. kristina hållmats färnäs, Sweden 8,114. Carole Block Johnstown, PA 8,115. Sasha Kamahele Mililani, HI 8,116. Jacqueline greeneville, TN Roberts 8,117. Phyllis White El Dorado Hills, CA Inhumane! 8,118. Karen Hannan Asheboro, NC 8,119. Eila Immonen Helsinki, Finland 8,120. Hazel Jackson Midhurst, Canada 8,121. Marja Nurminen Hämeenlinna, Finland 8,122. Cindy Vines Baltimore, MD 8,123. Zohra Laakel Tetouan, Morocco 8,124. Ellyn Mattison Port St. Lucie, FL 8,125. Sally Madigan MEADOW VISTA, CA 8,126. Tarja Leino Pori, Finland 8,127. Linda Fitzgerald Mount Laurel, NJ 8,128. Susan Spencer London, Canada 8,129. Maureen Wills Charleston, WV Animal cruelty 8,130. Mary Ouderkirk Mississauga, Canada 8,131. Annette Carlin Altadena, CA 8,132. Peter Samuels San jose, CA 8,133. Debra Valente Zion Grove, PA 8,134. Melissa Wozniak Coconut Creek, FL 8,135. Marlana Schaefer Kapaa, HI 8,136. Victoria Hood West Linn, OR 8,137. Adrienne Kramer Hjfd, CA Cruelty must cease to bring about world peace. 8,138. Albert Osborn Columbia, SC 8,139. sherrie wilhite Sonora, CA 8,140. Kathleen Ryan Castle Rock, CO urrently Hawaii Law still allows for use of 3 foot long logging chains to permanently tie out dogs to tires, trees, other stationary objects. This causes decline of our communities as well as puts people at risk. It is also Animal Abuse and it is widespread on the islands. In 1997 the USDA ruled that people regulated by the Animal Welfare Act cannot keep dogs continuously chained. The American Veterinary Medical Association has also spoken out against chaining on BITE PREVENTION Week. Fighting dogs are all kept chained. (continues on next page)

Page 291 - Signatures 8,112 - 8,140 Name From Comments 8,140. Kathleen Ryan Castle Rock, CO (continued from previous page) At least 22 states and 45 counties and counting have adopted tethering provisions already for the safety of their communities. From a Public Health and community Safety standpoint, these officials are right on. We already lost a child in Kauai who was mauled to death by a chained dog. A chained, or once chained dog is 2.8 x more likely to bite, and that rises to 5.4 x for small children. Author's hand was mauled by a once chained dog that was also fed gunpowder to make him more aggressive. With the Highest "off the charts" kill rates in the shelters, Hawaii absolutely needs to adopt the USDA ruling on the Animal Welfare Act and we need to do it Now. Especially on the Outer Islands, visitors often comment on the disgraceful way people keep their animals. An estimated 100-150,000 dogs on Hawaii island alone are currently kept on heavy chains, with some residents having 7-8 dogs chained up to trees-trucks- tires-makeshift 'dog houses' somewhere along their yard or just out in jungle, In this Heat., rain etc. Consider it "culture" to starve and chain dogs to hunt wild boars. Dog-Boar fights Are even held now, where dogs are pitted against a particularly nasty boar. There are bumper stickers demanding we "respect the culture". However these "traditions and cultures" have been outlawed in the Civilized world to make it a safer more humane place for all including our keiki (Children) Where animal abuse proliferates, we have one of the lowest family prosperity index along with abundant Domestic Violence. 8,141. Diana St. Haiku, HI Gaudens 8,142. Wendy Harris Hungarton, United FGS send the missionaries, this is terrible. I don't suppose Kingdom Tourists see this??? 8,143. Crystal Gerovac Buffalo, NY 8,144. Kaushik Ranjan Guwahati, India Goswami 8,145. Tonya Monroe, WA Nooner-May 8,146. Jaana Rovanperä Vantaa, Finland 8,147. SHARON MACHESNEY PARK, GRAHAM-DOUGHTYIL 8,148. Sharon McDonald Big Spring, TX 8,149. Maria jose Orobitg Barcelona, Spain 8,150. Sarah Cockerill Durham,, United Kingdom 8,151. Chantelle Northcliff, South Africa Lombard

Page 292 - Signatures 8,140 - 8,151 Name From Comments 8,152. steve cowett presque isle, ME 8,153. Gudrun Magnea Reykjavík, Iceland Helgadóttir 8,154. Angela Tovey London, United Kingdom 8,155. maria scourta peiraeus, Greece 8,156. Agnieszka London, United Zbierska Kingdom 8,157. Michelle Critchell Portsmouth, United Kingdom 8,158. Roberto Suarez Las palmas, Spain 8,159. jill phipps abertillery, United Kingdom 8,160. John Bryant Tonbridge, United Kingdom 8,161. ALVARO NIÑO Bogotá, Colombia PEREZ 8,162. Lj Lyttle Somerset, United Kingdom 8,163. Sue North Chesterfield, United Kingdom 8,164. Shannon Nesbitt Kapaa, HI I am still amazed Hawaii's laws still allow this or any type of chaining PERIOD. Get with it and follow other states that are BANNING all chaining of dogs. It's inhumane and in my eyes ABUSE! 8,165. jacqueline Coventry, United southern Kingdom 8,166. Cherie Dull Lahaina, HI Animal cruelty is wrong Please everyone, be kind to animals & everyone else🙏 8,167. Vicki Becker La, CA Horrific! 8,168. Tracey Jech Guthrie, OK 8,169. Paula Tucker St albnans, United Kingdom 8,170. KIRSTI JÄRVENPÄÄ, Finland LEHTONEN 8,171. Kerry Barber Willenhall, United Kingdom 8,172. Danuta Kolcz DUBLIN, Ireland 8,173. Debora Baker Easton, PA It's called abuse. Have homeowners provide a safety fence and let the dog free to run. This is reduculous. 8,174. teresa dover, United mcmenamin Kingdom

Page 293 - Signatures 8,152 - 8,174 Name From Comments 8,175. rose ward Ipswich, United Kingdom 8,176. Lori LaMarr Kalaheo, HI 8,177. Renee Sherry Ft.pierce, FL 8,178. Tanya Oldridge Grimsby, United Kingdom 8,179. LINDSEY PLYMOUTH, United PARSONS Kingdom 8,180. Susan Daugherty Renton, WA These animals needs to run play and be free of chains.what is wrong with these people that chain these beautiful animals.how would they liked to be chained like that...... 8,181. Sara Gorton Wellesbourne, United Kingdom 8,182. Robert Hille Yau Ma Tei, Hong Kong 8,183. Bernardo Patino Skien, Norway 8,184. faye reese Kalaheo, HI 8,185. Beth Viano Northport, NY Simple question... How would YOU like to be on a 3 foot chain? 8,186. geoffrey ives nr valencia, Spain 8,187. Zsolt Komuves Budapest, Hungary 8,188. Kippy Dishman Middletown, OH 8,189. Maria Virgil Miami, FL 8,190. Beth Cook Janesville, WI 8,191. Barbara Savage Ledyard, CT How can anyone justify using that extreme restraint. Stop now PLEASE!!! 8,192. Marcela Ceballos Merida yucatan, Mexico 8,193. Susan Ehlert madison, WI 8,194. dondi cocola Veneta, OR 8,195. Jessica McKenzie Tavernier, FL 8,196. Renie Burch Charlotte Courthouse, VA 8,197. Angela Navarre Covington, KY 8,198. Andrew Vallender Leicester, United Kingdom 8,199. Melayne Mills Snowflake, AZ 8,200. Svetlana Babies Berlin, Germany 8,201. jackie dominguez pessac, France 8,202. Janina Markkula Hyvinkää, Finland

Page 294 - Signatures 8,175 - 8,202 Name From Comments 8,203. Alison Flanagan Fleet, United Kingdom 8,204. Lea Hirvikallio Lieksa, Finland 8,205. Sue Grainger Milton Keynes, United Kingdom 8,206. Hannele Kuoppala Harjavalta, Finland 8,207. Yvonne Wey 6002, Switzerland 8,208. Melisse Reynolds Bellingen, Australia 8,209. Barbara Rainbird Exeter, United Jones Kingdom 8,210. Teresa Sola Caldes de montbui, Spain 8,211. Florentina Dublin, Ireland Dumitras 8,212. irina salauyeva athens, Greece 8,213. Michelle Gohier Blyth, United Kingdom 8,214. Lisa Wise Morrisonville, NY 8,215. Conchita Vegan Ames, Spain Hawaii has been proved to be extremely backward time and time again. Tourists should not put their money in a state that abuses and tortures animals! 8,216. Olga Vdovenko Moskva, Russian Federation 8,217. josette reek geleen, Netherlands 8,218. Ky Ky Sydney, Australia 8,219. Atalanta Gourlay Cheltenham, United Show compassion and ket the poor dog have a descent life Kingdom 8,220. Theresa Rouse Denver, CO 8,221. Reyna Campbell Los Angeles,, CA 8,222. Marina Acton, MA Tarkhanova 8,223. Lisa Whiteman Wishaw, United Kingdom 8,224. Sarah Taylor Torquay, United Kingdom 8,225. Laurie Kase Markham, Canada 8,226. Sharyn Shubert Naples, FL 8,227. mandy cairns alloa, United Kingdom 8,228. laura hammock KANSAS CITY, KS 8,229. Martie Enfield Winter Park, FL 8,230. lidia mongelos prato, Italy 8,231. Daune Lyman EG, RI

Page 295 - Signatures 8,203 - 8,231 Name From Comments 8,232. Anita Phillips ELMIRA, NY 8,233. Mike Eskam Glendale az, AZ 8,234. Julie Smith Gering, NE Animals should NT BE TREATED LIKE THAT 8,235. Samantha Eskam Glendale, AZ 8,236. susan Mello Lakeville, MA 8,237. Kathy Laen BROOKLYN, NY 8,238. Sheila Williams Liberty, MO 8,239. Kymberly Young Charleston, WV 8,240. Denise Costello Assonet, MA 8,241. Nancy Semeniuk Sayreville, NJ Whoever did these deserves to rot in jail! 8,242. Kathy Pabst White city, OR 8,243. Linda Barbera Cupertino, CA This is inhumane! No animal deserves this kind of treatment or life - just sickening! 8,244. Maria Luiza Ferraz São Paulo, Brazil 8,245. k k orsk, Russian козлы. бедная собачка. Federation 8,246. Darlene Roepke Manitowoc, WI WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE? THIS IS PURE TORTURE, TO INNOCENT DOGS...WHAT HAVE THEY DONE TO DESERVE THIS? ANIMAL CRUELTY HAS TO END NOW!!! 8,247. rineke hoogerwerf doorn, Netherlands 8,248. Bonnie Gillings Sarnia, Canada 8,249. Eugene Chernova Vladivostok, Russian Federation 8,250. Yvonne Brassfield BAKERSFIELD, CA 8,251. Trisha Donnelly Sebastian, FL 8,252. Roxanne Rankin Rancho Cucamonga, CA 8,253. Paula Medaglia Leaburg, OR Dogs on chains live unnatural lives. This is inhumane and needs to stop. Get rid of the chains and fence the yards. 8,254. Kathy Stutler Walton, KY 8,255. pmw fotos toronto, Canada 8,256. Rita Pachitu Rio Rancho, NM Please stop this evil torture of these animals! Stop three if you cannot keep them by your side and in your house. This is horrifying! How are these people like to be chained up like this animals have feelings too! Don't get a dog and Leslie gave me part of your family! Stop the five-year of animals this is barbaric 8,257. Shannon Walker Clearwater, FL

Page 296 - Signatures 8,232 - 8,257 Name From Comments 8,258. Gloria Dalusung Munoz Science city Nueva Ecija, Philippines 8,259. Denise Melnick dayton, OH 8,260. Mari Serrano Santa Clarita, CA 8,261. yvette vernet Hobart, Australia 8,262. Elena Struk Brooklyn, NY 8,263. priscilla kinziger Wisconsin Rapids, WI This is cruel to keep any living creature chained up like this. Must end now!!! 8,264. Chris Coombes Sydney, Australia 8,265. Meloney Boutilier Strome, Canada 8,266. Claire Kenyon Middleburg, FL 8,267. liz spina caerphilly, United Kingdom 8,268. Amy Garofalo Goldsboro, NC 8,269. David lightfoot saxmundham, United Kingdom 8,270. Lynette Cavill Falmouth, United Kingdom 8,271. Lona Decasper Kiowa, CO 8,272. arlene orlando Bedford, OH 8,273. AnnMarie Barrie, Canada Hodgson 8,274. sylvie desbieys marseille, France 8,275. Linda Miller Roanoke, VA 8,276. Helena Thiels Beveren, Belgium 8,277. shirley stock budgewoi, Australia 8,278. Di Pugh Malvern, United Kingdom 8,279. Diane Occhionero Raleigh, NC 8,280. Debbie Elmer Kevil, KY 8,281. patricia napieray anizy le chateau, France 8,282. Cathy Knott Kitchener, Canada 8,283. Barbara Bellina Costa Mesa, CA 8,284. Tamara Johnson Valatie, NY Put the owners on the same damn chain! Monster! 8,285. Blanca Shannon Howell, NJ 8,286. Maureen Hodgson England, United Kingdom 8,287. Wieslaw Potempa Trollhättan, Sweden

Page 297 - Signatures 8,258 - 8,287 Name From Comments 8,288. Fran Sherwood charlotte, NC unconscionable! why have a dog if you are just gonna chain it up. Dogs are part of the family. Chaining dogs creates aggression but most obviously is extremely cruel. 8,289. annette edwards st. lawrence, Canada 8,290. Sandra Lumpkins Cannelton, IN 8,291. Liliana Elliot Los Gatos, CA 8,292. Tina Grey Miami, FL 8,293. Charlotte Rees Aberaeron, United Kingdom 8,294. Judit Toth N. Hollywood, CA 8,295. Maureen Belleville, NJ LoCascio 8,296. Michelle Montmorency, France Blessemaille 8,297. Shayne & Susan Rock Springs, WY Christensen 8,298. kelly boulter Albany, Australia 8,299. Amanda McVicar Brisbane, Australia 8,300. charlene klauck Elgin, IL 8,301. jonna sørensen nørresundby, The owner chould try this barbaby. MY GOD, how can any Denmark do this to a innocent soul ? :_( Look the eyes- thats no life, thats HELL. 8,302. Josiane Melchior wilsele, Belgium 8,303. Maureen Cross Murrumbeena, Australia 8,304. Carolyn Witmitz Mount Gambier, Australia 8,305. Brenda Johnson Wilmington, NC 8,306. susan mcquin Haverfordwest, United Kingdom 8,307. sharon hicks aberystwyth, United Kingdom 8,308. fred atkins borth, United Kingdom 8,309. dana krokaite haugesund, Norway 8,310. Richard Morwick Vancouver, Canada 8,311. Pilar Quesada Castellbell, Spain 8,312. Sara Paoluzzi Sacile, Italy 8,313. betty geddings sumter, SC 8,314. Angie Mason Edmontin, Canada 8,315. Veronica Lebron Coram, NY

Page 298 - Signatures 8,288 - 8,315 Name From Comments 8,316. Nadezhda Toteva Pleven, Bulgaria 8,317. Janice Pearson Chesterfield, United Kingdom 8,318. adrienne borszeki london, United Kingdom 8,319. Susi Price Pressignac, France Ridiculous. No dog should be chained at all. Cruel in the extreme 8,320. Saddie Al Jakarta, Indonesia 8,321. Mercia Perioli Durban, South Africa 8,322. michael shapiro goleta, CA stop the torture 8,323. Rhonda Ringer North Las Vegas, NV 8,324. Alexandra Tobin Gloucester, United Kingdom 8,325. Elise Phillips Livingston, NJ Margulis 8,326. Colette Murphy Toronto, Canada Because they are living bei fs thag need to bs treated witb care and respect. 8,327. Mark Mansfield Geneva, NY 8,328. Drinda Maxwell Honolulu, HI IT IS CRUEL! Dogs hate being chained, tied, staked out, etc. 8,329. Varsha Lala Singapore, Singapore 8,330. Patrick Mcintyre Los angrles, CA 8,331. Lorraine Kirkby stephen, Stephenson United Kingdom 8,332. marianne östlund Ytterby, Sweden 8,333. maija johansson malmö, Sweden 8,334. tony archer atherstone, United Kingdom 8,335. Corinne Evans Connahs Quay Flintshire, United Kingdom 8,336. Grace Hamlin Atlanta, GA This is unamerican! This is cruelty and against all life. 8,337. Jodie Graham AUGUSTA, GA 8,338. Rachel Meier Acworth, GA 8,339. Chris Portland, OR Schoonhoven 8,340. Lori Rourke Waynesville, NC 8,341. Cindy Miller Pittsburgh, PA 8,342. Evelyn Vancouver, Canada Holiday-Smith

Page 299 - Signatures 8,316 - 8,342 Name From Comments 8,343. Yana Yana , Russian Federation 8,344. Nicole Knupfer Konstanz, Germany 8,345. Monique Jacksonville, FL Henderson 8,346. mary ellen medway, MA alicandro 8,347. jade Alf blois. Loire et cher, France 8,348. Louise Cook Orange, CA this is abuse and should NEVER be allowed. For shame, Hawaii. 8,349. Jessica Fox Cape Town, South How in this day and age is it still Africa allowed to cruelly tie a dog up! 8,350. Joanne Daniels Becchboro, Australia 8,351. Evonne Steele Schuylerville, NY 8,352. Brigitte granieri meudon, France 8,353. LeAnne Neuens New Berlin, WI 8,354. Arline Amsterdam, NY Animals have right too Tarquinio-Kuhn 8,355. Lisa Gerhardt Brookeville, MD Theses dogs miss treated and that needs to stop!!!!! 8,356. Isabell Kuhl Zweibrűcken, Germany 8,357. Dee Clancy Dublin Ga, GA The hilt of cruelty! Horrid humans!!! 8,358. Sharon Iversen Lake Peekskill, NY 8,359. chelsea holliday havre de grace, MD 8,360. Luceil Lightfoot Detroit, MI 8,361. Sonja Belford Padstow, Australia 8,362. Reinilda Martes Chicopee, MA 8,363. Madasyn Carns Gilbert, AZ 8,364. Patricia Kelly Lakewood, WA It is wrong and it is crew I love animals 8,365. Stephanie Rea DDO, Canada 8,366. Colleen Bayer Wright, MO 8,367. Jackie Osborne Preston, United Kingdom 8,368. Christine Silva Nj, NJ Dogs are innocent cannot fend for themselves ! 8,369. Tammie Burnette Stanfield, NC 8,370. Angela kohrs calgary, Canada chaining a dog is cruel and speaks volumes about the ignorance of the owners. 8,371. Krista Tillman Stevensville, MI 8,372. Melodie Seltzer Greensboro, NC

Page 300 - Signatures 8,343 - 8,372 Name From Comments 8,373. Julie Dennison Bloomington, IL 8,374. Helene Blöchlinger Anières, Switzerland 8,375. Liz Leiva Yonkers, NY 8,376. Queade Di Ilio Ottawa, Canada 8,377. Denis Schneider Raleigh, NC Jr 8,378. Isabella De Luca Bern, Switzerland 8,379. Barbara Steele West Seneca, NY 3foot long chains are cruel and inhuman please stop this at once 8,380. Tori Hamann Reeseville, WI 8,381. Karolina Barahona Tegucigalpa, Honduras 8,382. Julie Spinks Ballwin, MO 8,383. Alysha Gagnon Calgary, Canada 8,384. Marina Pohlman Philip, SD 8,385. Tiffany gold Tacoma, WA 8,386. Elizabeth Farkas Rochester, NY 8,387. Debra Surrey, B.C, Canada Sommerfeld 8,388. HELENA KIELCE, Poland TROJAK 8,389. Malia Tomlinson Knoxville, TN 8,390. yoko natu kitaku, Japan 8,391. Sara Ward Rame, AL Animal abuse is wrong. Regardless of what it is. They owners need to go to jail. 8,392. Lea Pike Mahomet, IL We are the proud owners of rescued pitties.. Won't have another breed. 8,393. Cristine deRose Plainfield, IL 8,394. Stephanie Smith Cookeville, TN I am against animal cruelty 8,395. Jessica Mosca Atlanta, GA 8,396. Nabanita Banerjee Anand, India 8,397. Beth Rainbolt Okmulgee, OK 8,398. Susan Noland Jacksonville, FL 8,399. Dawn Smith Palm Coast, FL 8,400. Angie Torres Bronx, NY Please help these poor dogs. You can obviously see they are suffering. 8,401. Sandra Ellis Belle River, Canada It's very inhumane to treat the animals that way.Those poor dogs just want to be loved.It truly sickens me to see them tortured that way.Stop these disgusting acts now... 8,402. Isabelle To Ruskin, FL

Page 301 - Signatures 8,373 - 8,402 Name From Comments 8,403. Stephanie W HORSHAM, PA 8,404. lucia flores alice, TX I hate people abusing animals 8,405. Christy Porter Pickens, SC 8,406. Denise James Carrboro, NC 8,407. Nathan Clark Masontown, PA 8,408. A Young Kent, United Kingdom 8,409. Devin Donnelly Henderson, NV 8,410. Angela Smethwick Cincinnati, OH Dogs should not be tethered to chains!!! This is inhumane!!!! 8,411. Brenna Allan Kelowna, Canada Chain those pigs to 3 feet of chain and see how they feel. 8,412. Winnie Cape Town, South Shmaryahu Africa 8,413. Tenna Knox Monticello, IL This cruel and inhuman. Needs to stop. 8,414. AmyLynne Carlton Wake forest, NC 8,415. Deidra Gallagher Boston, MA 8,416. Anne Marie Montreal, Canada Bomben-Chagnon 8,417. Jennifer Pistola Old bridge, NJ 8,418. Delphine McIntosh L'étang la ville, France 8,419. Tamra Macaluso Banning, CA What personality will you humans have if you were chained to one area night and day for months and months , no one to talk to no comforts in the rain,wind,cold and oppressive heat no food or fresh water an being sick from all the cuts and abus. Well you will be an angry terrified person. Well any animal that goes thru this daily will be the same and if ha child comes near him of course the animal will react out of fear A human will become mentally disturbed and fight if some comes to help. Tortured. Humans and animals react the same way The powers that be in Hawaii need to stop allowing this practice and truly make this a paradise island and until all animals run free from chains this is a devil island run by evil people 8,420. Deborah Smith Mahtomedi, MN 8,421. oksana popovich London, United Kingdom 8,422. Conrad Michelsen Hvide sande, Denmark 8,423. Takahiro Fuefuki, Japan Kankawa 8,424. Emanuele milano, Italy Ciavarrella

Page 302 - Signatures 8,403 - 8,424 Name From Comments 8,425. Minako Nakajima Chiba, Japan 8,426. Nicolien Amstelveen, Leuverman Netherlands 8,427. Susan Johnson Climax, NC 8,428. Meagan Schlegel Indianapolis, IN 8,429. julio montes Santa Rosa, Argentina 8,430. Kathy Morrison Essex, VT 8,431. Priscilla Zizzo Phoenix, AZ This is just WRONG!!! 8,432. Anabela Duarte Amadora, Portugal 8,433. Shelly Stra sac, CA 8,434. Mirela Mona Cluj-Napoca, Prada Romania 8,435. Mary Quintana London, Canada 8,436. Rachel Fenwick Hartlepool, United Kingdom 8,437. Karen Liu Toronto, Canada 8,438. Donna Hickey Sydney, Canada I have a dog and cats myself, and find that any form of animal abuse is wrong and disgusting 8,439. Lesa Sumners Black Hawk, SD 8,440. Carolyn Pearson Wildomar, CA No one should ever be chained... 8,441. Amber Mccane Granite city, IL 8,442. Ruth Fehlman Traverse City, MI 8,443. Clint Fedler Kingshill, Virgin Islands, U.s. 8,444. Marla OBrien Wichita Falls, TX 8,445. Jennifer Jiron Fort Collins, CO Humane treatment of all animals is important 8,446. L Yanitski Red Deer, Canada 8,447. Cindy Hewitt Sarasota, FL 8,448. Lee Vannucci Jamestown, CA 8,449. Jane Kendall Summersville, WV 8,450. Tamara Watson Keaau, HI Dogs have feelings and have been domesticated to be social. Chaining them does not allow them the freedom to run, play and interact with others. 8,451. Sabrina Painter Chatsworth, GA 8,452. Cyd Woolf Salt lake city, UT 8,453. Janee Van Zile MILWAUKEE, WI 8,454. Joelle Badgley Universal City, TX 8,455. Dena Styskal Omaha, NE

Page 303 - Signatures 8,425 - 8,455 Name From Comments 8,456. Gabi Briese Cuxhaven, Germany 8,457. Pamela Welborn Opelika, AL 8,458. Katelyn Lanza Cooperstown, NY 8,459. Cindy Ashline Slingerlands, NY I love pit bulls and no dog should be treated this way! Hawaii needs to become a more humane state and make this illegal and punish people who do this! 8,460. Jane Campeau Wyoming, MI 8,461. Katie Herbold LAPORTE, IN 8,462. Ashley Barber Tarboro, NC Because animals should not live in chains 8,463. Renate Kunz Montegrotto Terme, Italy 8,464. Debra Chapman Junction City, CA 8,465. Ana Alves Livermore, CA 8,466. Gail Murphy Calgary, Canada 8,467. Irina Lamadrid Mar del Plata, Argentina 8,468. Patricia Rancho Palos Verdes, Nevimaguire CA 8,469. Sharon Miller Covington, LA 8,470. Diane Gilliam Rosamond, CA 8,471. Rhonda Jaramillo Bremerton, WA 8,472. Catherine Young Milwaukee, WI 8,473. Laura Cordova Concord, CA 8,474. Elizabeth Martin Albertville, AL 8,475. anne v d laar Waalwijk, Netherlands Stop this now! RESPECT Animals 8,476. Ralf Andermann Drakenburg, Germany 8,477. Yolanda Stadtler Bornheim, Germany 8,478. Lydie Duchet Les andelys, France 8,479. Kamilla Borzeta Belgrave Heights, Australia 8,480. Kylie Cambey Wangaratta, Australia 8,481. anna schatz st. Veit a.d.Glan, Austria 8,482. Thorsten Albold Hamburg, Germany 8,483. Ana Valencia , Chile 8,484. Paty Pizarro Santiago, Chile 8,485. Giuliana Gemetto Torino, Italy Basta maltrattamenti agli animali 8,486. claude laval, France demeulenaer

Page 304 - Signatures 8,456 - 8,486 Name From Comments 8,487. Yanneth Campo Tabasco, Mexico Amo los animales,respeto la vida 8,488. Kelly Walker Mayfield, NY Come on inhumame idiots wake up and smell the coffee for gods sake this is another life you are abusing they derserve kindness, love and compassion probably more then the rotten scum treating them like this 8,489. Nicole Carson Middletown, OH 8,490. Maria Urraca Madrid, Spain 8,491. Rena Henke Freiburg, Germany 8,492. Tammy Blandine Newton Falls, OH 8,493. Brittney Kistner Utica, NY 8,494. Mª Jose Muñoz Almaden, Spain 8,495. Susanne Findeiß Salzgitter, Germany 8,496. Margaret Day Weston-super-mare, United Kingdom 8,497. Heidrun Plöchl St. Michael, Austria 8,498. Sharon McGregor Blyth, United Kingdom 8,499. Vicky Haucke Berlin, Germany 8,500. Olaf Knuth Hamburg, Germany 8,501. Elfie Stumpf Surrey, Canada 8,502. Bonnie Shelley Maineville, OH 8,503. Jill Westwood Little Falls, NJ 8,504. Mary Wheatlry London, United Kingdom 8,505. Heike Schwertner Braunlage, Germany 8,506. Paquita Abarca Manresa, Spain 8,507. Mónika Szentendre, Hungary Hochhoffer 8,508. Meltem Demir Istanbul, Turkey 8,509. Stephanie Elbert, CO Wiedenhues 8,510. Peggy Skelton TEMPE, AZ 8,511. Sandi Akalewicz Carteret, NJ Dogs should not be chained outside for more than a few minutes, they belong in your house where they can protect you and your family 8,512. Karin Koop Harkstede, Netherlands 8,513. Veronica S Tucson, AZ Valencia 8,514. Joshua Friehling Congers, NY 8,515. Susannah Gelbart LAS VEGAS, NV

Page 305 - Signatures 8,487 - 8,515 Name From Comments 8,516. Clark Walden Georgetown, TX 8,517. Shanna Rosales Gsinesville, GA 8,518. Diana Morris Hephzibah, GA 8,519. Elizabeth Andrews Auburn, IN Chains period are wrong!!! This is sad!!! 8,520. Carlos Torrico Caba, Argentina 8,521. viv van den Leuven, Belgium Panhuyzen 8,522. Alf Alf Bruxelles, Belgium 8,523. CHANTAL SURESNES, France GERARD 8,524. Lotta Lindsjö Hjärup, Sweden 8,525. Shizuko Madsen Vancouver, WA Stop this cruelty to these gentle animals. They are harmless dogs that are being treat and raised wrong!!! 8,526. Alyson Maddox London, United Disgusting treatment of dogs... Kingdom Hawaii - you sell yourself as a beautiful island, but in truth you are a hell for animals... I would never visit. 8,527. caty cheneval chambery, France 8,528. Mireille Rummens Leuven, Belgium 8,529. claudine gouru st aignan, France 8,530. Nadine Schneider Faßberg, Germany 8,531. Karen Lambie Statesboro, GA This is an absolute atrocity. I implore you to do the right thing. You must stop this heinous abuse and cruelty immediately. 8,532. valerie bocourt saint-quentin, France 8,533. roger martinez oullins, France 8,534. Sandrine SAINT PIERRE LES HERVIEU ELBEUF, France 8,535. Josette von Dach Echallens, Switzerland 8,536. Jocelyne Meung sur loire, Thibaudeau France 8,537. Philippe Beghein Ampsin, Belgium 8,538. Yolanda Schultes Wittenbach, Switzerland 8,539. Hannelore Dolch Ruhla, Germany 8,540. marie breckpot OOSTENDE, Belgium 8,541. Claude Noel EPINAL, France 8,542. Véronique Chillet SAINT GENEST A quoi ça sert de prendre un chien pour l'attacher toute ça MALIFAUX, France pauvre vie c'est un creve coeur de voir se pauvre chien si triste !!! Les humains me dégoutent on devrait leur faire pareil !!!

Page 306 - Signatures 8,516 - 8,542 Name From Comments 8,543. melanie best l, Germany 8,544. wendy vicart bruxelles, Belgium 8,545. Bri Sofaru Paris, France 8,546. Maeva Orchidea Bruxelles, Belgium 8,547. Manuela Bodenwöhr, Germany Duschinger 8,548. Daisy Rorive Orchies, France 8,549. Carine Lang Saint dizant du gua, France 8,550. Liz Mahu Oaris, France 8,551. sylvie hubinet serezin du rhone, France 8,552. Marion Morcher FN, Germany 8,553. claire libert braine l'alleud, Belgium 8,554. stephanie richard Epeugney, France 8,555. Tatjana Schott Saarbrücken, Germany 8,556. Lourdes Marrero Arecibo, Puerto Rico 8,557. anne marie saint benigne, France benechet 8,558. Françoise Bourdin pont de labeaume, France 8,559. Michèle Legrand Antibes, France 8,560. CATHY CASALI SOUGY, France 8,561. Angelina Saint Etienne, France Bongiraud 8,562. caroline swart aiken, SC Unacceptable! 8,563. claudine echinard marseille, France 8,564. Rosemary Tate Waranga Shores, Australia 8,565. Kim Sutterby Greenwith, Australia 8,566. Kim Mueske Tigard, OR This is inhumane! Makes them aggressive! 8,567. Barbara Brindley Brisbane, Australia 8,568. Evelyn Carroll Adelaide, Australia 8,569. Kym Biddell Adelaide, Australia 8,570. D Corbin Rushworth, Australia 8,571. Gioia Price Glenbrook, Australia 8,572. Phil and Diane Seacliff Park, Cornelius Australia

Page 307 - Signatures 8,543 - 8,572 Name From Comments 8,573. Jaime Collura Mass pk, NY 8,574. Anne Prost Montalivet, France 8,575. christine josselin Vendays, France 8,576. helene prost pornic, France 8,577. Michaela Perez Denvee, CO 8,578. Anita Smit Stevensweert, Netherlands 8,579. Samantha PARKERSBURG, WV Kowalsky 8,580. Daniela Djuric Saint Ives, United Kingdom 8,581. Anna Krohn Tracy, CA 8,582. Michele DeVasto Medford, MA 8,583. Becky Scholze Humbird, WI 8,584. Donna Hanson Oceanside, CA 8,585. Karen Walton Huntington Beach, CA 8,586. Tiffany Leger Toronto, Canada 8,587. Regan Tabor Las vegas, NV We need to stop harming animals 8,588. Lucilla Strickland Madison, FL 8,589. Karen Sonne del rey oaks, CA 8,590. clark orman ottumwa, IA 8,591. Michael O'Malley Long Beach, CA 8,592. dawn snyder cave city, AR 8,593. letisia baltazar Burbank, CA 8,594. Daisy Garcia Sacramento, CA 8,595. Kate Rockwell Redondo Beach, CA 8,596. Brittany Vogen Taylorsville, UT 8,597. Ricky Thomas Stephens City, VA 3 feet is not long enough for a dog! 8,598. sandra emerson imperial beach, CA 8,599. Brenda Zuniga Salem, OR 8,600. Lisa Rice Hollywood, MD 8,601. Melody Welch Lake Jackson, TX 8,602. Penny Seiders Tucson, AZ This is a sick, disgusting way to treat a precious pup! Please outlaw this vile practice! 8,603. Xclan Martinez Compton, CA 8,604. Leslie Kilcullen Torrance, CA 8,605. Catalina Gardena, CA Dignadice

Page 308 - Signatures 8,573 - 8,605 Name From Comments 8,606. Cynthia Mann Beverly Hills, CA This cruel! 8,607. Amber Current Oconomowoc, WI 8,608. Sandra Welburn Viola, IL 8,609. Teresa Clouse Olympia, WA 8,610. kim martin princeton, WV This is cruel and barbaric. Why is God's name would these precious angel be on logging chains. These precious angel deserve loving homes. Punish the demons that do this. Put them on 3 foot logging chains. How demonic are these people 8,611. Cinthya Salas Encino, CA 8,612. Jane Livshin Canoga park, CA 8,613. Theresa Jones Tucson, AZ 8,614. Nancy Pirone Marysville, WA 8,615. Shannon Grimes Honolulu, HI This is disgusting 8,616. Linda Nerney Redondo beach, CA Hawaii doesn't let the tourists see what really go es on there. High crime rate and animal cruelty in paradise. 8,617. Renata Tavares Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 8,618. Linda Johnson La Habra, CA 8,619. Alexandra Steiert Las Vegas, NV 8,620. Bobbie Bacher Rockford, IL cruel..!! No need for this. 8,622. Jennifer Alexander Spring, TX 8,623. Pamela Byrne laguna beach, CA 8,624. Barbara Zekausky Pleasureville, KY Such an ugly law for the most beautiful state in the US. Make this illegal for the sake of all dogs in Hawaii. 8,625. Adriana Orozco PERRINE, FL 8,626. Feiga Mor Miami beach, FL 8,627. N Macchiusi Toronto, Canada 8,628. Claudis Herman CARL FISHER, FL 8,629. Allison Ballston Lake, NY Rasmussen 8,630. Mary Wells Sjc, CA 8,631. Patty Aiken Prescott Valley, AZ 8,632. Jaxson Myhill Adelaide, Australia No animal should be tied up with no chance of freedom .. this is animal cruelty and I hope those responsible are prosecuted and made an example of .. Absolute fuckn disgrace 8,633. Terry Maynez Apple valley, CA 8,634. Laura Keith Glendale, AZ 8,635. Shannon Griffiths Upland, CA 8,636. Joan Escobar Sacramento, CA

Page 309 - Signatures 8,606 - 8,636 Name From Comments 8,637. Usher Idkend Los Ángeles, CA 8,638. April Rath El Cajon, CA 8,639. Shanece Norco, CA Mccorkell 8,640. Suzanne Eger Redondo Beach, CA 8,641. Robin Gauthier Las Vegas, NV 8,642. Christine Chino Valley, AZ PITCHER 8,643. Valerie Gardner Aurora, CO 8,644. Alicejean Boness Menasha, WI 8,645. Alyson Cross Dublin, CA 8,646. JESSICA SHELBYVILLE, KY RUCKER 8,647. Anita James Pincher creek, Evolve already Canada 8,648. Viviana Diaz Miami, FL 8,649. J P Largo, FL 8,650. karen walvin nottinghamshire, United Kingdom 8,651. Stacey Wilks Costa Mesa, CA This is important to me because dogs FEEL!!! 8,652. Roxanne Daus BRONX, NY 8,653. Dawn Morgan Forestville, CT 8,654. CHERYL MYERS CANTON, IL 8,655. Ellie Kligman Van Nuys, CA This is animal cruelty. 8,656. Bernice Bowden King William, VA 8,657. Beverly Reaney Hillsboro, OR 8,658. Amber Thomas CALDWELL, ID 8,659. CHERYL Wilhite SOUTH JORDAN, UT 8,660. Terri Quick Easton, PA 8,661. maria twyman san francisco, CA 8,662. Marcey Reyes Chicago, IL 8,663. Suzanette Garden City, MO Hancock 8,664. tara smith burnsville, MN 8,665. GEORGE EAGLE, CO SQUYRES 8,666. Carol Seme TAVARES, FL 8,667. Nita Norman Dana Point, CA 8,668. Katherine Jeffries Quesnel, Canada

Page 310 - Signatures 8,637 - 8,668 Name From Comments 8,669. Karin Winter Kenmore, WA 8,670. Alexandra Nicole Santa Monica, CA 8,671. Lisa Taylor Sandersvillr, GA 8,672. Patricia Burgert Wake Forest, NC 8,673. Elena Wilson Burbank, CA 8,674. Andrea Geitner Schliersee, Germany 8,675. Nancy Emery San bruno, CA 8,676. Sharon Barrott Beaumont, CA 8,677. aj La Pan STATEN ISLAND, NY 8,678. Rachel Cohen Miami, FL 8,679. Kimberly Keller Santee, CA 8,680. Natascha Bock Buchdorf, Germany 8,681. Cindi Coker Yorba linda, CA 8,682. Isabella Albanese Chandler, AZ So sad!!! 8,683. Marilyn Ramos Springfield, MA 8,684. Molly Zbojniewicz Manhattan Beach, CA 8,685. casey crouch bernalillo, NM rescue dogs on chains, this is no way of life...and then put owners in jail on a leash so they can feel what they have done 8,686. Deborah Brown Beaverton, OR 8,687. Susanne Findeiß Salzgitter, Germany 8,688. Deborah Meyer Irvine, CA 8,689. Christine Borak Newport Beach, CA 8,690. Vanessa Russell FOREST, MS 8,691. JAN PAYNE Jackson, MI 8,692. Tracey Denney San clemente, CA 8,693. kathleen torres new york, NY 8,694. rebecca maydak washington, DC 8,695. Jeanne Eschmann Rockville Centre, NY 8,696. Wendy Carvill Greenwood lake, NY 8,697. Patricia MacIvr Holbroo, NY 8,698. Louann Smith McKinney, TX 8,699. Betty Geist Reading, MA 8,700. Pamela Hailey, ID Countryman 8,701. Lila Robin Brookhaven, MS 8,702. Darrie Stewart, TN Dovidauskas

Page 311 - Signatures 8,669 - 8,702 Name From Comments 8,703. susan ashley Coconut Creek, FL 8,704. Sterling Santa Monica, CA Long-Colbo 8,705. Kim Lin Appleton, WI 8,706. Kathy Burnett Jacksonville, FL 8,707. Gilbert Flores Phoenix, AZ 8,708. Evie Kettler LaGrange, GA No more chains I’m sick of it. 8,709. Thomas GREENSBORO, NC Cummings 8,710. Ali Parker Wirral, United Kingdom 8,711. Carol Smith Brentford, United Kingdom 8,712. Janitha Pallin Houston, TX 8,713. Nick Masson Alfreton, United Kingdom 8,714. Camille Cox Dryden, Canada 8,715. Cheryl Osborn NORWALK, OH 8,716. Tom Jankovic West Easton, PA 8,717. Susan Natale Ballston spa, NY 8,718. Lori Lindquist Spokane, WA 8,719. Dianne Racek Brunswick, MD This is barbaric and should be stopped immediately! 8,720. Jane Sampson Birmingham, United Kingdom 8,721. Winnie Paul Kaolei, HI No animal should live in such limited confinement. To be healthy of Mind and Spirit this must stop. Animals need physical and mental stimulation. Limiting severely their ability to move around is detrimental to the health of the dog. 8,722. Lori Lazzara Tampa, FL WHY are these poor dogs still chained?? WHY hasn't anything been done to help them?? Change the law NOW so NO dog ever has to suffer again!! 8,723. Lois Osbodn Whiting, NJ Stop this voilence 8,724. Margeaux LeVan Bethlehem, PA 8,725. Michael Hodge reston, VA 8,726. may ooi plantation, FL 8,727. Laura Skelton West Palm Beach, FL 8,728. Pamela Dugan NAPLES, FL 8,729. Gisel Leguizam Fort Lauderdale, FL 8,730. Virginia Oliva Dania, FL

Page 312 - Signatures 8,703 - 8,730 Name From Comments 8,731. Courtney Portland, CT McMahon 8,732. Tina Gilmore Cedar Hill, TX 8,733. P. A. Brandt PORT Orange, FL 8,734. Marie Rayho Poughkeepsie, NY Because we are their voice. 8,735. Lisa Machete Margate, FL 8,736. Pat Langhurst Marion, IA Chaining a dog is cruel andabusive. 8,737. Diane High Boca Raton, FL 8,738. Kristopher Dukes Walnut, CA 8,739. Laura Schmidt Melbourne, FL 8,740. Cathy Brackett Campobello, SC 8,741. Sarah Mash Carshalton, United Kingdom 8,742. Adrienne Smith Jefferson,, IA 8,743. Sandra HookhAm Midland, Canada 8,744. Jill Crosby Westfield, MA 8,745. DON ANDERSON Fort Lauderdale, FL 8,746. sara wragg new haven, CT 8,747. Maureen Corley Hackettstown, NJ 8,748. Susie Burns Ft Lauderdale, FL 8,749. Debra Ramirez Fridley, MN 8,750. melissa mortenson london, United Kingdom 8,751. Linda Mohr Marion, IA Because it is the right thing to do! 8,752. Mary Ellen Berry Elverson, PA 8,753. Diana Ackerman New franklin, OH This is a cruel and inhumane act to do this to those poor unfortunate dogs. 8,754. Pat Phillips Akron, OH This is a mean and cruel inhumane thing to do. These dogs don’t deserve this kind of life!!! 8,755. Lorette Campbell Sarasota, FL Because it is inhuman. 8,756. Jessica Monk Fort hood, TX 8,757. Alice Riley San Antonio, TX 8,758. Gail Blank Fresno, CA 8,759. gretchen peckham anza, CA 8,760. ADALGISA Grosseto, Italy GROTTI 8,761. Anna smith COLUMBIA, MD

Page 313 - Signatures 8,731 - 8,761 Name From Comments 8,762. RINA NORTH MIAMI WHY? SIMPLY I WISH THESE SAME HUMANS SHOULD ASSOULINE BEACH, FL BE CHAINED AND PLACED IN A TINY (RABBIT CAGE SIZE) WHERE THEY COULD NOT MOVE ONE SINGLE FINGER AND THERE, EXPERIENCE SLOW AND GRADUALLY PAIN IN THEIR JOINTS DISINTEGRATING LITTLE BY LITTLE....HOW ABOUT TRYING THIS? KARMA IS A BITCH. AS YE DO YE SHALL BE DONE. NO ESCAPE. 8,763. JANICE DORVAL TRYON, NC 8,764. Brenda Roy Manchester, NH 8,765. ashley baillargeon orlando, FL 8,766. alex lester toronto, Canada 8,767. Sue Shaw Voorhees, NJ One shouldn't need to explain this. It is cruel abuse to keep these dogs on 3 foot chains. And in horrible wooden boxes. They are being treated like trash. They are receiving no comfort, no care, no medical care. Please. They are being used and abused. Help them 8,768. Jennifer ellman TARZANA, CA 8,769. christy williams grove city, OH 8,770. Sheila Thiele Byhalia, MS 8,771. Pamela Davis Honolulu, HI 8,772. Jo Reints Tallahassee, FL Dogs dont belong on a log chain...they dont deserve it! As a result they become unsocial & neglected dogs; leading to attacks on humans. "Speak for those that cannot speak for themselves- Ensure justice for those being crushed" proverbs 31.8 Another translation reads "Open your mouth for the mute, for the rights of all who are destitute" 8,773. Carol Hoke CONOVER, NC 8,774. Monica Kelly BIGFORK, MT 8,775. Deborah Murphy Bigfork, MT 8,776. John Falletti Chester, CA 8,777. Michelle Hopper Englewood, OH 8,778. JOANNA TWIGG GERMANTOWN, MD 8,779. Elisa Norris Waianae, HI Because it is so wrong to treat any animal like that. Get this outlawed 8,780. Paul-Denis Montreal, Canada Clermont 8,781. Larie Kent Hilo, HI 8,782. Terrica Tarpy Northwood, OH 8,783. Emily Moyer FREMONT, OH

Page 314 - Signatures 8,762 - 8,783 Name From Comments 8,784. Reverend James Hilo, HI Dogs need to be treated as our friends, not as our prisoners. Borden 8,785. Madison Smith LENEXA, KS 8,786. Joann Henderson PALM COAST, FL 8,787. Anna Jozefowicz Fountain Valley, CA 8,788. Eva Tervala Espoo, Finland 8,789. Dolores Comeau Haute Aboujagane, Dogs and cats are God's great gifts to humans..they deserve Canada to live to give love and receive love..please change the law to no kill and let these precious animals live 8,790. anan fawzi cario, Egypt 8,791. Mira Gamal Cairo, Egypt 8,792. Robert Earthman Santa Barbara, CA 8,793. Gabrielle Connery Mtn view, HI 8,794. Sheila Stutz Lansing, MI 8,795. Evelyn Hill Pearblossom, CA 8,796. Doug Haferkamp Ottawa, Canada 8,797. Juan Roggero Montgomery village, MD 8,798. Katherine Ehlers Keaau, HI People should be arrested for the cruely towards animals here on the big island. I’ve seen cruelty here and that’s outrages. 8,799. Nika Kuznetsova Honolulu, HI 8,800. Manuela Schultz Neumünster, Germany 8,801. Maria van Geel Zdroisko, Poland Getekend 8,802. nan newall bg, Canada 8,803. Margarida Pires Angouleme, France 8,804. Cecilia Ojeda Lima, Peru 8,805. Manfred Kroboth Zurndorf, Austria 8,806. Sandra Morales Sinaloa, Mexico 8,807. Miro Krajnc Podvelka, Slovenia 8,808. paula bdiwi lynn, MA 8,809. Annette Knödler Kraichtal, Germany 8,810. Caroline Cottrell Bristol, United Kingdom 8,811. Tanya Burt San Jose, CA 8,812. Anthony Murphy London, United Kingdom 8,813. Igor Kvichansky Flushing, NY

Page 315 - Signatures 8,784 - 8,813 Name From Comments 8,814. Jessica Garcia Pasadena, TX 8,815. Brenda Gladfelter York, PA 8,816. Crystal Rochester, NY Khammaniving 8,817. Ginette Québec, Canada Deschenes 8,818. Sae Magata Hiroshima-shi, Japan 8,819. Maria Tovar Neiva, Colombia Perdomo 8,820. Michael Wehlan Saarbrücken, Germany 8,821. Helene Schlierbach, Austria Schliesselberger 8,822. Peggy Meißner Dresden, Germany 8,823. Corinna Leonberg, Germany Wieczorkowski 8,824. Alexandra Marktgraitz, Germany Brunsch 8,825. Marie Achenbach Stahnsdorf, Germany Help him!!!!! 8,826. Monika Kurdic Schönwalde, Germany 8,827. Monika Epperlein , Germany 8,828. Rainer Wotke Berndorf, Austria 8,829. Petra Klein Bocholt, Germany Langenhoff 8,830. kiyoko Nakajima Naeki, Japan 8,831. Izabela Gierlata Essen, Germany 8,832. Sandra Riemer Moers, Germany Weil Tiere keine Stimme haben! 8,833. Susan Melzer Chemnitz, Germany 8,834. Juliane W Wien, Austria 8,835. Elisabeth Steyr, Austria Leingang 8,836. Ursula Jakobs Bad Oldesloe, Germany 8,837. Susanne van der Berlin, Germany Velden 8,838. Petra Jungblut Bad Kreuznach, Germany 8,839. Bianca Ziegs Meissen, Germany 8,840. Sabine Sommerein, Austria Zinngiesser

Page 316 - Signatures 8,814 - 8,840 Name From Comments 8,841. Dragica siedentop Maintal, Germany 8,842. peter treasure grand junction, CO 8,843. Sascha Christens Tangstedt, Germany 8,844. Esther Sutter Langenthak, Switzerland 8,845. shigenori tanaka jeasey for, NJ 8,846. M. Lies Enger, Germany 8,847. Nicole Schauer Hochwolkersdorf, Austria 8,848. Felix Schinkitz Rosenbach, Germany 8,849. Gerharde Schulz Schliengen, Germany 8,850. Mariya Dubrova Bielefeld, Germany 8,851. Cindy Burger Weißenburg, Germany 8,852. Katrin Riedel Gößnitz, Germany Ich hoffe und bete dafür das auch in Hawaii geholfen wird den Tieren ein gutes und liebes sauberes leben geschenkt wird 8,853. Simone Fey Dietikon, Switzerland 8,854. Jana Sigmund Adetswil, Switzerland 8,855. Sabine Hermstein Rotenburg, Germany 8,856. Sacha Schranz Adelboden, Switzerland 8,857. Silvia Laser Perchtoldsdorf, Austria 8,858. Nicole Bajramovic Flensburg, Germany 8,859. Kerstin Schneider Berlin, Germany Ich liebe Hunde und finde es unerträglich wenn ihnen Leid angetan wird. 8,860. Christian Weber Zürich, Switzerland 8,861. Désirée Velden, Austria Strohmayer 8,862. Sabine Matthes Reichshof, Germany 8,863. Carina Jörg Andermatt, Switzerland 8,864. Margitta Berlin, Germany Hunde , Tiere allgemein sollten nicht angekettet sein. Das ist Leuschner gegen die Natur. 8,865. Vivian Reufels Solingen, Germany 8,866. Martina Kempe Reifenberg, Germany Sie sind keine Mörder und Schwerverbrecher!! 8,867. Birgit Schleinitz Berlin, Germany 8,868. Susan Stange Regenbogenland, Germany

Page 317 - Signatures 8,841 - 8,868 Name From Comments 8,869. Marianne Christen Aarburg, Switzerland 8,870. Angelique von Berlin, Germany Grzegorzewsky 8,871. Anna Haul Kröppelshagen, Sowas soll nkcjt passieren!!!!! Germany 8,872. Lena Sohnle Hohenlohe, Germany 8,873. Michelle Toretto Aachen, Germany 8,874. Julia Lang Parndorf, Austria 8,875. Corina Schmalz Bad Vöslau, Austria 8,876. Margarete Lindhorst, Germany Hülsemann 8,877. Rosi Lüft Mainz, Germany 8,878. Dagmar Brohl Diemelstadt, Germany 8,879. Gertrude Challet Vendlincourt, Switzerland 8,880. Sabine Schur Weissenburg, Germany 8,881. Jasmin Castens Hamburg, Germany 8,882. r g Aesch, Switzerland 8,883. Yumiko Rörvig Henån, Sweden 8,884. Ulrike Patricelli Alezio, Italy 8,885. mandy kriebel meerane, Germany 8,886. Riko Tosa funabashi, Japan 8,887. Hattori Takako Osaka city, Japan 8,888. Marion Pichler 877w, Austria 8,889. Linda Gießbach Erkelenz, Germany 8,890. Dagmar Sommer Krumbach, Germany 8,891. sarah vadien Essen, Germany Weil ich Tiere liebe 8,892. Chris Hepperle Schelklingen, Germany 8,893. 飯住 早苗 大阪市, Japan 8,894. Micaela Linde Hohen Neuendorf, Germany 8,895. Carmen Wendt Erfurt, Germany 8,896. Kornelia Schmuck Doren, Austria 8,897. Grejs Grejs Landser, France Aide c’est malheureux svp. 8,898. tim kobayshi köln, Germany 8,899. Mlkl Klfushi Chikuma, Japan 8,900. 加藤 ヨウコ 鴻巣市, Japan

Page 318 - Signatures 8,869 - 8,900 Name From Comments 8,901. Sina Clerici St. Gallen, Switzerland 8,902. Sabine Kühne Berlin, Germany 8,903. Doris Angermund Düsseldorf, Germany 8,904. Gudrun Wilhelm Fhh, Germany 8,905. Viola Priebe Remscheid, Germany 8,906. Vera Samhaber Leonding, Austria 8,907. Nils Böhnke Duisburg, Germany 8,908. Matthias Berlin, Germany Schneider 8,909. mireille cordonnier namur, Belgium 8,910. Enrico Beiler Ellrich, Germany 8,911. Karin Jacobs Moers, Germany 8,912. Kim Behner Braunschweig, Germany 8,913. Nelly Nyffeler Derendingen, Switzerland 8,914. Michael Schmitt 71384 Weinstadt, Germany 8,915. Marion Richter Bernburg, Germany 8,916. Maria München, Germany Eissenberger 8,917. Daniela Waldner Berlin, Germany 8,918. Rabea Preuss Hagen, Germany 8,919. Jutta Lütticke Olpe, Germany 8,920. Sarah List privacy, Austria 8,921. Christine Scholz Berlin, Germany Sehr sehr traurig! 8,922. Stephanie Kerres Amberg, Germany 8,923. Heide Eich Bad Homburg, Germany 8,924. sonja hafner weisslingen, Switzerland 8,925. Claudia Schlimper Reinheim, Germany 8,926. Melanie Roos Kleve, Germany 8,927. Anja Ledderhos Unkeroda, Germany 8,928. Sandra Kottisch Köln, Germany 8,929. hildi machler altendorf, Switzerland 8,930. Sandra Kerang Traunstein, Germany 8,931. Petra Stadtmueller Hanau, Germany

Page 319 - Signatures 8,901 - 8,931 Name From Comments 8,932. Cordula Brauer Vennesla, Norway 8,933. Willi Lukaschow Eißel, Germany 8,934. Hannelore Weidenbach, Wittmann Germany 8,935. janine keck merzen, Germany 8,936. Renate Graf Andernach, Denmark 8,937. Isabell Rasch Dormagen, Germany 8,938. Marion Hannover, Germany Tempelmann 8,939. Franziska Greiner Bad saarow, Germany 8,940. Sandra Breitenau, Austria Doppelreitwr 8,941. Patrizia Kirchberg an der Wackernell Raab, Austria 8,942. Larena Gronewold Großefehn, Germany 8,943. Ingo Szobries Eygelshoven, Netherlands 8,944. junichi taki niwagun, Japan 8,945. Stefanie Brugger Vomp, Austria 8,946. Shion reira tokyo, Japan 8,947. Leona Nowok Herne, Germany 8,948. Ruth Sambor Davie, FL 8,949. Subesten Mehra Manama, Bahrain 8,950. Reinhard Klagenfurt, Austria Pessentheiner 8,951. Ann Reichel Wismar, Germany 8,952. Camilla Hermann 1100, Austria 8,953. Almut Bubendorfer St.johann, Austria 8,954. Sonja Reinecke Braunschweig, Germany 8,955. Rita Keller Benken, Switzerland 8,956. Guelsen Aytan Berlin, Germany Tierschândler bestrafen ! 8,957. Mika Tatuchi gifushi Gifuken, Japan 8,958. Heike Messemer Illingen, Germany 8,959. Vera David Singen, Germany 8,960. Gail Lezak Brookpark, OH 8,961. angela harris Wiesbaden, Germany 8,962. Christel Weber Hamburg, Germany 8,963. Maggy Fettweis Simmerath, Germany

Page 320 - Signatures 8,932 - 8,963 Name From Comments 8,964. Mike Mohs Berlin, Germany 8,965. Karin Schönlieb Elsbethen, Austria 8,966. Franziska Welzien Leipzig, Germany 8,967. Sandra Dondorf Aachen, Germany 8,968. Martina Stomberg , Germany 8,969. Ralf Probst Lippstadt, Germany 8,970. Svenja Kalweit Köhn, Germany 8,971. gerlinde lipke mönchengladbach, Germany 8,972. Mariko Watanabe Tokyo, Japan 8,973. Bianca Müller Gladbeck, Germany 8,974. Ulrike Berg Rotenburg an der Fulda, Germany 8,975. Katrin Köhler Tangermünde, Germany 8,976. Matthias Häß Lahr, Germany 8,977. Melanie Mracina Hohentengen a.h, Germany 8,978. Claudia Schott 82110, Germany 8,979. Christine Triller Altdorf, Germany 8,980. Julie Hansen Freeman, SD 8,981. Helene Zeller 93083 obertraubling, Germany 8,982. Annerose Salzgitter, Germany Wohlgemuth 8,983. Sabrina Kuhaupt Vellmar, Germany 8,984. Viacheslav Kibets Kamenskoe, Ukraine 8,985. Ingrid Bochum, Germany Manderscheid 8,986. Nathalie Quesnel Calais, France 8,987. hans- joachim geislingen, Germany holm 8,988. Manuela Strobl Hüttendorf, Austria 8,989. Sabine Hamburg, Germany Stöhlmacher 8,990. Claudia Hübner Speyer, Germany 8,991. Angelika Ruhrberg Remscheid, Germany 8,992. Nicole Jäschke Thedinghausen, Germany

Page 321 - Signatures 8,964 - 8,992 Name From Comments 8,993. Miriam Langenfeld, Germany Obst-Yavuzyasar 8,994. Margrit Hildmann Solingen, Germany 8,995. Heidi Kirchner Potsdam, Germany 8,996. Sabine Wiesbaden, Germany Schiebofski 8,997. mel stampe Berlin, Germany 8,998. Tamara Althoff Monguzo, Italy 8,999. Nino Rosic Turnisce, Slovenia 9,000. Sabine Lippisch Hinwil, Switzerland I love animals 9,001. Isabelle Sablotny Gelsenkirchen, Germany 9,002. Judith Meienberg Rorschacherberg, Switzerland 9,003. Lena Naujoks Wolfsburg, Germany 9,004. yoko natu osaka, Japan 9,005. Katja Wojahn Berlin, Germany 9,006. Monica Via Cochabamba, Bolivia 9,007. Marina Kushnir Oldenburg, Germany 9,008. Steffi Hermann Leverkusen, Germany 9,009. Britta Trovato Kempten, Germany 9,010. connie martin humansville, MO 9,011. Sophie Menzel Leipzig, Germany 9,012. Kim Hellbach Wunsiedel, Germany 9,013. Laurence Lumes Menton, France 9,014. VIVIAN Thomas Raubach, Germany 9,015. otto berger benningen, Germany 9,016. natalie gardi niederhasli, Switzerland 9,017. Sandra Gamböck Wiener Neudorf, Austria 9,018. Kathrin Koob Freiburg, Germany 9,019. Heinz Fischer Bludenz, Austria 9,020. Simone Kraiss Böblingen, Germany 9,021. Nadja Hübschen Friedrichsthal, Germany 9,022. Yvonne Bremen, Germany Ouedraogo 9,023. Christiane Neser Speyer, Germany

Page 322 - Signatures 8,993 - 9,023 Name From Comments 9,024. Bettina Borensky Höberdbrunn, Austria 9,025. Cindy Maier Mobridge, SD 9,026. Anna Stein Kassel, Germany 9,027. Ivanovic Cvetka Bad Rappenau, Strafe für alle die Tiere misshandeln egal auf welche Art Germany 9,028. Heike Thutewohl Potsdam, Germany 9,029. Janina Bernhard Zarpen, Germany 9,030. Laetitia Pinkafeld, Austria Kaltenhofer 9,031. Marie-José saint jean de braye, CHOBERT France 9,032. Birgit Müller Herborn, Germany 9,033. Pamela Kahder Berlin, Germany 9,034. Renate Pracher Wien, Austria 9,035. Carmen Blume Puerto de La Cruz, Spain 9,036. Nicole Basel, Switzerland Aeschbacher 9,037. Simone Pfetzing Iserlohn, Germany 9,038. Richard Sebicht Sangerhausen, Germany 9,039. Martina Räther Eberswalde, Germany 9,040. Ivo Thery Stekene, Belgium 9,041. Patricia Galindo Barcelona, Spain Rooney 9,042. Jan Haubold Velden, Germany 9,043. Patricia Hudson Northwich, United Kingdom 9,044. Melissa Unger Bremen, Germany 9,045. Marlen Zemke Ludwigsfelde, Die armen! Germany 9,046. Marion Szagun Mendig, Germany 9,047. Sofia Traeva Stockholm, Sweden 9,048. Colleen Wysser - Laupen, Switzerland Martin 9,049. Janine Wustrau Brandenburg an der havel, Germany 9,050. karin schneider Frauenfeld, Switzerland

Page 323 - Signatures 9,024 - 9,050 Name From Comments 9,051. anna ritter bad krozingen, Germany 9,052. Ivone Kleinhappel Kirchberg, Austria ! 9,053. Zahida Delic Osnabrück, Germany 9,054. Stefan Probst Voitsberg, Austria ! 9,055. Regina Wegsada Gross-Siegharts, Austria 9,056. Rüdiger 53881 Euskirchen, Schmeling Germany 9,057. Harriet Bilinski Winterthur, Switzerland 9,058. Nicole Kleinhans Witten, Germany 9,059. Pina Hodes Düsseldorf, Germany 9,060. Nina Bolten Ober-Ramstadt, Germany 9,061. Sima Aziz Karimi Stuttgart, Germany 9,062. Claudia Villach, Austria Wertschnig 9,063. micky rively dania, FL what a damn shame what damn people 9,064. Vincenza Ferlisi Wuppertal, Germany 9,065. Silvio Krichel Gangelt, Germany 9,066. Effie Seanlarnold 彰化, Taiwan 9,067. Zaher Naoum haifa, Israel 9,068. Willy Gross Münsingen, Germany 9,069. Janina Kaiser Berlin, Germany 9,070. Karolina Düsseldorf, Germany Grzybowski 9,071. Brigitte Kamp Krefeld, Germany 😡😡😡😡😡 9,072. Linda Lins Beulenstraat, Belgium 9,073. Sabine Vögeli Speyer, Germany 9,074. Elfriede Moore Washington, DC It is abusive and people who treat their dog this way should be ashamed. 9,075. Fuencisla A Coruña, Spain Vazquez 9,076. Bettina Lazzel Salzgitter, Germany 9,077. Melissa Erfurt, Germany Bachmann 9,078. Robert Larcher Feldkirchen bei Graz, Austria 9,079. mariage st pierre, Reunion

Page 324 - Signatures 9,051 - 9,079 Name From Comments 9,080. Yolanda Basel, Switzerland Schneider 9,081. andrea bassett london, United My heart bleeds: Get Dogs off 3 Foot Chains in Hawaii, Kingdom please. 9,082. Carola Shockley Frankfurt am Main, Germany 9,083. Lola Salas Garcia Barcelona, Spain 9,084. Muriel Lovenfosse Flémalle, Belgium 9,085. Hermine Jevsevar Buchbach, Austria 9,086. Georgette Oudit Seraing, Belgium 9,087. Ashley Yanez Mount vernon, IL 9,088. Setuko Nagano Ogakishi, Japan 9,089. Janis King RENO, NV 9,090. Brigitte Lassalle 21224 Rosengarten, Germany 9,091. Beatrix Schmelz Rödermark, Germany ❤🐾😭 9,092. Kiyomi Nakahara hyogo, Japan 9,093. renata reeg mannheim, Germany Ich bin gegen Tierqalerei. Die Tierqualer bestraft sollten werden 9,094. Beata Uba Sosnowiec, Poland 9,095. Giselle Takishima Tokyo, Japan 9,096. Fabienne Voreppe, France Paternoster 9,097. Barbara Wörgl, Austria Werlberger 9,098. Sandy Waldrop Rotthalmunster, Germany 9,099. helma Goebel Großkrotzenburg, Germany 9,100. Friederike Schöler Steinbach, Germany 9,101. eric archambault paris, France 9,102. Kesang Thonpa Wädenswil, need to chance now bros & sisters Switzerland 9,103. Nadja Philippi Pirmasens, Germany 9,104. Giovanna Urbino, Italy Perini-Folesani 9,105. richelle mcdonald green river, WY 9,106. Dorota Wis Szczecin, Poland 9,107. Elena Samoylova Tuchkovo, Russian Federation

Page 325 - Signatures 9,080 - 9,107 Name From Comments 9,108. Giovanna Leggio Neuenhof, Switzerland 9,109. Beate Freyberger Georgensgmünd, Germany 9,110. Julie Port Slough, United Kingdom 9,111. Manuela Sypli Berlin, Germany 9,112. Hanna Sehmisch Berlin, Germany 9,113. Petra Klaus Herne, Germany 9,114. Beatrix Brändli Wilchingen, Switzerland 9,115. Roberto Dell'onze Lecce, Italy 9,116. Anne Élise Vertou, France Grégoire 9,117. Nicole Holler St. Peter, Germany 9,118. Monika Köberl Bad Ischl, Austria Den wirtschaftlichen Erfolg und moralischen Fortschritt einer Nation erkennt mann daran wie es seine Tiere behandelt. 9,119. Maria González Barcelona, Spain Herrero 9,120. Friedrich Dirner Inke, Hungary 9,121. Caroline Debaille Braine-le-comte, Belgium 9,122. Natalia Wieser Domat/Ems, Switzerland 9,123. Birgit Plein Köln, Germany Helfen und den armen Tiere ihre Traurigkeit nehmen mit viel Liebe 9,124. Solar W 彰化, Taiwan 9,125. Elisabetta Ferrara, Italy Colombani 9,126. Maziarz Maziarz Fussen, Germany 9,127. Elizabeth Auckland, New Whiteside Zealand 9,128. Tanja Giger Langenthal, Switzerland 9,129. Sabine Kerber Wuppertal, Germany 9,130. Rosa Köln, Germany Wieschemann 9,131. Araceli lopez Haro, Spain 9,132. Zaira De Bonis Arzignano, Italy 9,133. Peggy Harper North Wales, PA 9,134. Liane Luxs Schöneiche, Germany

Page 326 - Signatures 9,108 - 9,134 Name From Comments 9,135. maria moynes hoofddorp, Netherlands 9,136. Brenda Heise Topeka, KS 9,137. naganuma hatsue nagoya, Japan 9,138. Birgit Bosch Edesheim, Germany 9,139. Stéphane Aumont-Aubrac, GARCIA France 9,140. Marina Cremona Roma, Italy 9,141. TAKAKO SAPPORO, Japan TANAKA 9,142. Katrin Wolter Berlin, Germany 9,143. Ken H 彰化, Taiwan 9,144. Leidy Arteaga Pasto, Colombia 9,145. Carmen Filzmoos, Austria Kirchgasser 9,146. Sonia Ranieri Morón, Argentina 9,147. Maria Naves Belo Horizonte, Brazil 9,148. Manfred Fischer Hennef, Germany Tiere sind Lebewesen 9,149. Claudia Frosch Enzersfeld, Austria 9,150. Stefania Person Żydow, Poland 9,151. Kerstin Scharf Bokholt-Hanredder, Germany 9,152. GABRIELA Maiersdorf, Austria Wagner 9,153. Mira McMullen London, United Kingdom 9,154. Krzysztof Kozak Lublin, Poland 9,155. Karin Ehnes Dietschwil, Switzerland 9,156. Daniel Zurlinden Feldkirch, Austria 9,157. Sandra Larch Mühlbach, Italy 9,158. Manuela Allera Siglistorf, Switzerland Widerliche Menschen 9,159. Regine Knoblich Baldham, Germany 9,160. MARISA BRAVO cordoba, Argentina 9,161. Cecile Walker Neuheim, Switzerland Klein 9,162. Gulcan Altınkaya Çorlu, Turkey 9,163. Barb Beronski Chicago, IL 9,164. fran morgan Dunkirk, MD

Page 327 - Signatures 9,135 - 9,164 Name From Comments 9,165. Michelle North Shields, United Stephenson Kingdom 9,166. Alexa Thirel Xanthi, Greece 9,167. Maggie Ft Myers, FL McLaughlin 9,168. Stefanie Michel Köln, Germany They're looking so sad! They need someone how loves 9,169. Melissa Bourgeois Captain Cook, HI 9,170. Rinu Antony Chimur, India Is this how we treat our 'man's best friend? Please don't misuse their faith and loyalty on us! Have empathy! For once put yourself in their shoes. 9,171. Stephanie Lusa Recklinghausen, Germany 9,172. Caroline Segalla Pahoa, HI 9,173. Connie Cauchon Camano Island, WA 9,174. Marlene Capson Houma, LA 9,175. Claire Back Esch/Alzette, Luxembourg 9,176. Valérie von Oberengstringen, Gunten Switzerland 9,177. Taylor Bentley Captain Cook, HI 9,178. Lisa Sheridan Asheboro, NC 9,179. Randyl Rupar Honaunau, HI 9,180. Amanda Pusch Kailua Kona, HI It's animal cruelty. If we can't tie up people in the same manner, then animals should not be as well. If you have ever witnessed an animal being tied up on a short chain, eating and sleeping in its own feces for hours and hours into days, it's horrific, and cruel. 9,181. Natalia María Comodoro Rivadavia, Fernández Argentina 9,182. nathalie warest bussy saint georges, France 9,183. Nicole Rettke Filderstadt, Germany 9,184. Lena Porsch Kiel, Germany Help this innocent dog 9,185. Paula O'Connor Reading, United Kingdom 9,186. Jean Michel , Germany Friedrich 9,187. Michaela Gihl nußdorf, Austria 9,188. Robyn Hayde Dunedin, New Zealand 9,189. Lisa Strand Carbondale, CO

Page 328 - Signatures 9,165 - 9,189 Name From Comments 9,190. Robert Forbes woodstock, NY 9,191. kaye mohammadi Atlanta, GA because its cruel thought better of Hawaii 9,192. Lois Mallare Singapore, Singapore 9,193. Jasmin Bjeske Berlin, Germany 9,194. Giovanna Cassano d'Adda, Italy Ioannidou 9,195. Evelyn Betancourt Madrid, Spain 9,196. Gill Whitty Oxford, United Kingdom 9,197. Ann Wagemaker AUSTIN, TX 9,198. Tina Lautenbach Bochum, Germany 9,199. Allie Lindsay Bozeman, MT Because dogs should have the freedom to run, even if that means within limits. They were not born to be tied to a chain. You are a coward to own an animal that you are unable to care for and excercise 9,200. Holger Schrörs Schwerte, Germany 9,201. Janelle Pollock La Boisse, France 9,202. Eline van der Captain Cook, HI Kloos 9,203. mary Potter Alpharetta, GA Cruelty to animals is no longer acceptable in a civilized society... 9,204. Gilda Mazza Rosario, Argentina 9,205. Sarah Colwell Bristol, United Kingdom 9,206. Lorraine Heil Midhurst, United Kingdom 9,207. Rick Caldis Pahoa, HI 9,208. AYUMI KOTANI O-TAKU, Japan 9,209. Eva Guibert Kihei, HI Needs to be illegal to chain up a family member. 9,210. Barbara Preusser Pgh, PA 9,211. Mary Cristina C.A.B.A., Argentina Garcia Larrosa 9,212. Jody Weaver Grygla, MN It is in humane... 9,213. Avril Delaney Waratah, Australia 9,214. Lucinda Smyth Port MacDonnell, Australia 9,215. Keely Herod Kailua-Kona, HI 9,216. Daniel Steele Chelmsford, United Kingdom

Page 329 - Signatures 9,190 - 9,216 Name From Comments 9,217. Susan Yeagley Pahoa, HI This is 100% not acceptable, nor in any way, shape or form a reflection of aloha. Hawaii needs to convey the spirit of aloha to ALL sentient beings. If not, it loses all credibility and meaning in my eyes. 9,218. Lynn French Las Vegas, NV 9,219. Kathie Mudge Mesa, AZ 9,220. Velimir Džaković Zagreb, Croatia 9,221. Andrea Diekmann Herne, Germany 9,222. rhonda narellan, Australia PATTRRICK 9,223. simone molinari nice, France 9,224. Connir Poe Alexandria, OH 9,225. Janet Elliott Holt, United Kingdom 9,226. Lola Christen Belgrade, Serbia 9,227. Shell P Fontana, CA 9,228. КАРОЛИНА Подем, Bulgaria Кралева 9,229. April Blades Honolulu, HI 9,230. TAMMY BERNE, IN HUMMEL 9,231. Rachel Burton Oakman, AL 9,232. Fe Camila Calamba,Laguna, Azupardo Philippines 9,233. Zoe Vernon Manchester, United Kingdom 9,234. Lyn Leeuw Marianna, FL Inhumane!!! 9,235. Manuela Nestler Erfurt, Germany 9,236. Doris Kiss Groß-Enzersdorf, Austria 9,237. Angela Adams Panama city, FL 9,238. David Gross Chattanooga, TN Because its not fair to the dog 9,239. Elena Samoilova Tuchkovo, Russian Federation 9,240. Barbara Keen Ashland, OR 9,241. brice madho BONDY, France MA FAMILLE ET MOI AIMONS LES ANIMAUX ALORS NOUS SIGNONS 9,242. Antonio Velasco CORDOBA, Spain 9,243. Marlies Jakob Kerkrade, Netherlands

Page 330 - Signatures 9,217 - 9,243 Name From Comments 9,244. Lisa Ashland, OR I have known about this hortible treatment of canines for CATRANIDES many years and I will never visit Hawaii, or allow my family to vacation there until this law is changed. 9,245. Michelle Burnley, Lancashire, Rawsthorne United Kingdom 9,246. Marta Szweda Warszawa, Poland 9,247. Melanie Zappe Greimeltshofen, Germany 9,248. Megan Hessel Portland, OR Please be humane, this is an awful practice and way to treat any animal. 9,249. petra gaubinger 2130 mistelbach, Austria 9,250. Almudena Garcia Madrid, Spain 9,251. Gwen Winterflood Jedburgh, United Kingdom 9,252. Kathleen Eales Chelsea, MI 9,253. jorgina B Pahoa, HI This is worst thing you can do as a pet owner, they have feelings, don't have a pet if you don't know how to take care of them with LOVE!!! 9,254. Alison McCalla Kailua-Kona, HI The who lives next door to me has been on a chain for many years. He just took itʻs second victim, a small, sweet dog who got too close. I was the first victim, where I had my leg mauled trying to save my dogs. These dogs need to have a safe and loving environment or not be in Hawaii! Get pit bullls and all dogs off the chain. Thank you! 9,255. Estelle Cruse Kamuela, HI I love dogs. They deserve good lives inside homes! 9,256. Margit Fuchs Vienna, Austria 9,257. Joan Ord Sunderland, United Kingdom 9,258. marie-anna ultsch ludwigshafen, Germany 9,259. Hannah Cooper Kailua kona, HI Dogs are smart, they know what being neglected feels like. They know what love feels like. It is a horrible thing that people do this to "their" dogs. Standards should be higher. People should be held accountable for mis treating and neglecting their dogs. They are mans best friend and should be treated as such. 9,260. justin kysor kona, Uganda 9,261. Susi Oettli Bettwiesen, Switzerland 9,262. Gretchen Watson Holualoa, HI It’s cruel — dogs are like family and should be treated as Kabei such 9,263. Bob Robertson Kailua-Kona, HI

Page 331 - Signatures 9,244 - 9,263 Name From Comments 9,264. Claudia Gries Remscheid, Germany 9,265. Lori Mattos Hilo, HI 9,266. Meghan Volcano, HI Jerolaman 9,267. Linda Ugalde Volcano, HI No animal should be chained up, it’s crule 9,268. Kimberly Smith Tucson, AZ 9,269. alison whitelaw dalkeith, United Kingdom 9,270. Sara Krosch Volcano, HI 9,271. Rina Rocker Kamulea, HI 9,272. Liz Naughton Kailua kona, HI 9,273. Kristine Wendling Kailua Kina, HI Because I am pit bull mom, and chaining up dogs kills me, they don’t deserve a life like that! My dog has never been chained up, she has been tethered at the beach, but home is her free space 9,274. Abril Monafo Mendoza, Argentina lucero 9,275. Sue Thompson Johnsburg, IL No animal should be abused and I think this treatment is abusive! 9,276. Shirley Doctor Pahoa, HI They should have more room to move around. 9,277. Susanne Koppo Grevenbroich, Germany 9,278. Brenna Gorresen Kona, HI No living creature should live chained like this! 9,279. Stephanie Kailua Kona, HI This is absolutely horrid! So cruel and inhumane! Please, Smedes please, please pass laws to stop this kind of abuse! 9,280. Tara Bartolome Parker, CO 9,281. Bertha Garcia Toluca estado de mex, Mexico 9,282. kathleen goodman evergreen, CO dogs deserve better! this should be a punishable crime! 9,283. Lana Canuteson Captain Cook, HI I love dogs 9,284. Mary wheeler Bedford, TX 9,285. Nicola Stepanek Kailua kona, HI This is animal cruelty and it is our moral duty to update old laws that have lead to such common canine pet abuses in the Hawaiian islands. Take a walk around any heavily populated neighborhood and you will see dogs chained and miserable - lets change it today. 9,286. Elaine Leste Kailua kona, HI Cruel and barbaric! 9,287. Tara Allen Holualoa, HI 9,288. afrodti chaka karditsa, Greece 9,289. Krisztina Ligetvari Várpalota, Hungary

Page 332 - Signatures 9,264 - 9,289 Name From Comments 9,290. Candi Hololio KEAAU, HI I see dogs all over Puna Diatrict in East Hawai'i chained full time. These dogs are neurotic and some appear psychotic from years of abuse and neglect. 9,291. František Labanič Senec, Slovakia 9,292. Cherylann Brown Seattle, WA 9,293. Daniela Schwanenstadt, Hausberger Austria 9,294. Mandy Steiger Berlin, Germany 9,295. Danii Paolucci Perugia, Italy 9,296. Antonia Fanaro Collegeville, PA 9,297. Carola Kailua-Kona, HI Any breathing life, animal or human, deserves protection Soder-Johnson and a life worth living!! 9,298. Joseph Edgerton North Kingstown, RI 9,299. Karin Stoll Erbach, Germany 9,300. Fanny Collart Éghezée, Belgium 9,301. Ashley Cole Eastham, MA 9,302. eva obst Wenzenbach, Germany 9,303. Debora Lampreia Lisboa, Portugal 9,304. Kathy Jensen Ocean View, HI I moved here from the mainland. The mountain of paperwork I had to fill out to bring my three dogs here was daunting, not to mention the enormous expense. I assumed, because of this, dogs were treated like family here. They are not. I am unable to walk my dogs, on a leash, in my own neighborhood for fear of being attacked by roaming dogs. I am unable to let my dogs outside in my fenced yard because of the roaming dogs. These are not ferals, they have collars (and sometimes tags). Ive seen them dragging chains and ropes behind them that they've broken free from. 2 dogs killed my neighbors baby goat, who was penned up. There are so many small children in my neighborhood and I fear for their safety. It's not just about the welfare of the chained dogs, it's about the welfare of whole communities. 9,305. Juli Steenhuis Kailua kona, HI It’s cruel and inhuman. This must stop 9,306. Judith Friedman Hallandale Bch, FL 9,307. Tania Leslie Kealakekua, HI 9,308. Emily Boyd Winter spring ka, FL 9,309. Suzanne Levy Evergreen, CO 9,310. Barbara Hussey Reno, NV Having lived on the Big Island of Hawaii, I know first hand, the horrible chaining abuse dogs suffer. I pray this legislative session will actually Do Something about this terrible chaining and tethering of dogs in “paradise”. 9,311. Carola Chueca Lima, Peru

Page 333 - Signatures 9,290 - 9,311 Name From Comments 9,312. Rosanne Azarian Marblehead, MA No living creature should’ve treated so cruelly. 9,313. jean daglish logan, Australia 9,314. Susan Mitnik Kapaau, HI 9,315. Alissa Betz Aalen, Germany 9,316. Lisa Smith Keaau, HI I oppose cruelty 9,317. Sarah Firman Wyverstone, United Kingdom 9,318. Lahela Kealakekua, HI Because I love animals, and doing Demello-Richard 9,319. Parsla Meiere , Malta 9,320. Monika Gropp Berlin, Germany 9,321. Julie McGovern Ewa Beach, HI We need to end this form of animal abuse and torture. 9,322. Gisele Cassarotti Pahoa, HI Prescott 9,323. Mariana Aguirre Hialeah, FL 9,324. Kalena Blakemore Hawai‘i Volcanoes Dogs should not be chained! They should be loved not used National Park, HI as faux security systems 💔 9,325. Joy Moir Perth, Australia It’s not right to chain up a dog 🙁 9,326. Annelies Craig Nambour, Australia 9,327. Fallon Dickson Pahoa, HI It's disgusting and needs to change. 9,328. William Drazer mountain home, AR 9,329. Christian Young DuPont, WA This is barbaric, inhumane and evil. No excuses for this behavior whatsoever. 9,330. Joan Kelly Salamander Bay, Chaining any animal up is barbaric and cruel Australia 9,331. Eryn Joyce Medford, OR 9,332. Jill Horvath P.S., CA 9,333. Riesa Larson New Castle, DE 9,334. Katya Noronha Hilo, HI 9,335. Haley Bell Kona, HI 9,336. sandra goldthorpe brisbane, Australia 9,337. Sherida Ribordy Black Hawk, SD 9,338. RaLinda Santa Rosa, CA Life is so short for animals, let's treat them with love and Ginocchio kindness as we would want. 9,339. Barbara Gallager DUSON, LA 9,340. christopher taylor shelby township, MI WTF? sick and wrong... 9,341. Amanda Pollotta Honolulu, HI 9,342. JoAnne Fraser Sarnia, Canada 9,343. Roger morman Mt.pleasant, TX

Page 334 - Signatures 9,312 - 9,343 Name From Comments 9,344. Nicky East Sheffield, United Kingdom 9,345. karen McCartney oshawa, Canada 9,346. Dianne Bird Waterdown, Canada How heavy would that chain be. I'm sure after time the dog's neck would be deformed. Also any dog that is tied up will be aggressive and attack, why?, because it has know place to get away and is afraid. di 9,347. Mellisa Carpenter Ohkay owingeh, NM 9,348. Patricia Rosario, Argentina Arribalzaga 9,349. Teresa Prater Rocky Mount, NC 9,350. Patricia Saccento Port Saint Lucie, FL 9,351. Chrissie Roberts Supply, NC Nothing should ever have to live like that !! Please save these baby's ! 9,352. Jolene Morato Salisbury, United Kingdom 9,353. Carmen Gray Captain Cook, HI Any cruelty leads to more cruelty. Allowing cruelty to be normalized and accepted will inevitably lead to greater and more serious abuse. 9,354. Tim Long Hagerstown, MD 9,355. Jana Malicher Calgary, Canada 9,356. kelly smith pembroke, Canada Animals are not property. 9,357. Wanda Clarke Philadelphia, PA 9,358. Judith Spell Brooksville, FL 9,359. linda bradley rochester, NY 9,360. Rosa Cabrerizo L'Hospitalet, Spain 9,361. Corinne Red Deer, Canada 9,362. Grace Suazo Madrid, Spain 9,363. Aisea Sol Cantabria, Spain 9,364. Darlene Okey Indianapolis, IN I'm having a hard time trying to figure out why these animals are chained with a logging chain or any chain take the chains off if you want something chained change yourself or your children leave the dogs alone you evil pieces of s*** 9,365. Meli Folgar Pontevedra, Spain 9,366. Billijo Ruvolo Lansford, PA This cruel and wrong please set them free 9,367. Ananya Bangkok, Thailand Boonyarattaphun 9,368. Traci Hackney Merkel, TX 9,369. larry philllips escondido, CA 9,370. Tammy Schrock Accident, MD I am a dog lover and no dog should have to live on a chain

Page 335 - Signatures 9,344 - 9,370 Name From Comments 9,371. Tina Fletcher Lafayette, IN 9,372. anne jacques bruxelles, Benin 9,373. Sandy A Waterville, OH 9,374. Donna funk Leesburg, OH 9,375. Josephine Mayville, MI Spaulding 9,376. Shontelle Taylor Christchurch, New I love dogs and no dog should ever be on a chain Zealand 9,377. Holly Gigantino Chester, AR NO animal should ever live life on a chain. 9,378. Sami Goodman Carmichael, CA 9,379. Marcel Stratford, CT Provenzano 9,380. Rick Santiago Rockford, IL Not the way to treat a dog 9,381. Meghan Long Burleson, TX 9,382. Stephanie Mancini Pittsburgh, PA 9,383. Jean Morris Cwmbran, United It's so unfair to any dog what's the point in having a dog just Kingdom to keep it chained up 9,384. ROnnie Rodriguez Sf, CA 9,385. Ingeborg Hellwig Obererbach, Germany 9,386. Gwen Casey Valencia, ca, CA 9,387. Pamela Conway Southold, NY 9,388. Cristie Carter Yucca Valley, CA 9,389. David Slayton Cumberland, WI Dogs do not need to be treated this way. It is animal cruelty 9,390. Christine Fadrilan Batangas, Philippines 9,391. J H LIBERTY TOWNSHIP, OH 9,392. Talya Honor Cape Town, South Africa 9,393. W. J. Lent Phoenix, AZ This is cruel and dangerous both for the dogs and people. Violence incites violence! 9,394. Estrellita Burley Pahoa, HI 9,395. Artem Vyzhenko Zaporizhzhya, Ukraine 9,396. Danielle Grace Caloocan City, Dacuan Philippines 9,397. Nina-Maria London, United TERRORISM isn't just a people's problem. The WALKER Kingdom TERRORISED VICTIMS come in all forms of SPECIES. The TERRORISTS come in one SPECIES - HUMAN. The most DANGEROUS DERANGED SPECIES of ALL! When will people make the CONNECTION? You only have to research The Psychology of Abusing / (continues on next page)

Page 336 - Signatures 9,371 - 9,397 Name From Comments 9,397. Nina-Maria London, United (continued from previous page) WALKER Kingdom Killing Animals for Profit & Pleasure - its not Rocket science! What a MALFUNCTIONED UNHINGED DISFUNCTINAL SUB-HUMAN Race of PSYCHOPATHS TYRANTS & TERRORISTS the HUMAN'UN'KIND TRULY ARE! !!!!!! 9,398. Carmen Casanova New Haven, CT This is abuse 9,399. Stormi LaCombe Humane, CO 9,400. Paul Brooks Charmhaven, It's just wrong. It's cruel Australia 9,401. Hannah Climax, NC Brookbank 9,402. Paula Devine Belfast, United This is so cruel ..we must stand together and save these poir Kingdom neglected puos 😢😢😢 9,403. Lucinda Tyler Chillicothe, OH 9,404. Kim Burgess Sittingbourne, United Kingdom 9,405. Stephanie Sullivan Wichita, KS To say these dogs have been abused and vilified is an understatement. The cruelty is disgusting and has to stop 9,406. lisa wragg sheffield, United Kingdom 9,407. Kim Spector Scottsdale, AZ No way to live 9,408. Belinda Webber Redruth, United This is cruelty if you as a human wouldnt want to be treated Kingdom this way why should a animal 9,409. dianne mazzo palm coast, FL 9,410. April Perry Penscacola, FL 9,411. Cari Vestal Clearlake, CA Pro animal! 9,412. Marilyn Jones Sarasota, FL 9,413. Sharon Miller Middletown, OH 9,414. Joann Mizutani Sacramento, CA PITIFUL. THIS MISTAKE STOP!!! 9,415. Louise Lucey Johannesburg, South Africa 9,416. Marie-Josée Rafol de Almunia, AS GANDHI SAID "THE GREATNESS OF A NATION AND Fässler Spain ITS MORAL PROGRESS CAN BE JUDGED BY THE WAY THEY TREAT THEIR ANIMALS" 9,417. Margie Bennett Lawton, OK They havr feelings to. Pluse they need longer smallwr chains 9,418. Katrena Smead Carlsbad, NM 9,419. Marsha Schelsky Buffalo Grove, IL 9,420. Kerri Cossa Cottonwood, CA 9,421. Christina Davis Spanaway, WA 9,422. Liane Copeland Haslingden, United Kingdom

Page 337 - Signatures 9,397 - 9,422 Name From Comments 9,423. Karina Velasquez Madelia, MN 9,424. Barbara Garcia Wildomar, CA They’re family never should be abused 9,425. Jeanne Bernhard Boyertown, PA 9,426. Deborah Spence Hilo, HI Unchain their hearts ! 9,427. cindy Liepold alamogordo, NM 9,428. Keaau, HI There are too many neglectful owners of dogs. It’s animal abuse to leave your dog tied up to a chain all day with little to no human interaction day after day! Particularly in Hawaii on the Big Island where there are fire ants that bite animals that have no way to get away from them. It’s painful to the dog and causes blindness. It’s cruel! If you think a chained dog is going to deter people from robbing you.. think again. Dogs need to be protected and cared for versus tied up, ignored, and exposed to weather and the elements. This IS animal abuse!!!! 9,429. Laura Stanford Portland, OR Inhumane, needs to stop. I lived in Hawaii for 32 years and have seen this inhumane treatment time and time again We must treat dogs better, they do not deserve this awful treatment. 9,430. Vicky Dallenger Blandford, United Kingdom 9,431. Catalina Hammond, IN No animal should live their life on a chain, let alone one so Vila-Pereira short and inhumane! Enough is enough when it comes to treating animals as property and not as living beings! Animals don’t have a voice so we have to stand up for them! Please put an end to this now! 9,432. Lisa Barr Welwyn garden city, Why keep dogs like this, it's no life for them and is cruel and United Kingdom unnecessary 9,433. carl mcevoy runcorn, United Kingdom 9,434. Lyndsey Hall Moffat, United Kingdom 9,435. Veronica Derry, United Mcmonagle Kingdom 9,436. Danielle Levin Denver, NC 9,437. Ellona Vinnitskiy Tarzana, CA 9,439. debra olsson EUGENE, OR 9,440. Ans Weevers Vorden, Netherlands 9,441. Page Olson Keaau, Turks And Caicos Islands 9,442. Nicole Francombe Quartzhill, CA 9,443. Aubrey Barlow Glasgow, MT

Page 338 - Signatures 9,423 - 9,443 Name From Comments 9,444. Valerie Bell Northfleet, United Kingdom 9,445. Kim Wright Birmingham, United Kingdom 9,446. Diana Khmeleva Magadan, Russian Federation 9,447. Ellie Leach Walton on Naze, United Kingdom 9,448. Mila Mattice Harkers Island, NC 9,449. Miriam Rangel Osterville, MA 9,450. Diane Kilgour Wivenhoe, United Kingdom 9,451. M. Browne Keaau, HI 9,452. Stacey Krenelka Kihei, HI I hate thos. Our neighbors have their dog on a chain and it is horribly cruel. 9,453. Constance Gibout Jonesboro, GA Stop this madness 9,454. Marina Moscow, Russian Kotelnikova Federation 9,455. Anna Jozefowicz Fountain Valley, CA 9,456. Chad Bergantz Kaneohe, HI I am a HUGE animal lover and they need to be loved and treated well, NOT ABUSED and let the government sit by and let it happen! 9,457. Michelle Ramos BURBANK, CA 9,458. Baron Von Wailuku, HI Treat animals as you wish to be treated yourself. Wolfsheild 9,459. Nicole Stevens Sault Ste Marie, MI 9,460. Lee Farrell St. Joseph, MO It's cruel and if someone has to explain that there is something seriously wrong 9,461. Stacia Miller Captian Cook, HI 9,462. Sharon Caplener Hilo, HI Dogs deserve better 9,463. Kathryn Neumann Rocky point, NY 9,464. julie stitz hilo, HI People do what they think is normal. Things need to change with tethering dogs. Its not only not good for the health and mental state of the dogs, it also puts humans at risk for being attacked. Its time we change this, so others start changing as well. 9,465. Rhonda Olafson Prince Albert, Canada 9,466. BEVERLEY LEICESTER, United MORRIS Kingdom 9,467. Chris Hufana Portland, OR I support Fences for Fido

Page 339 - Signatures 9,444 - 9,467 Name From Comments 9,468. Susan Honaunau, HI It’s torture to see a dog chained up like this. They need love Rosenbaum and adventure like you! They have feelings and need human contact and socialization for a start to become a healthy minded well behaved and happy dog. 9,469. Janette Behrsing Sunderland, United Kingdom 9,470. LAURIE DENARO Shaftsbury, VT 9,471. Billie Jo Schultz Jacksonville, NC What kind if question is that, Why is this important to me? Because animals are beings just like you and me. They have feelings, they get cold, they get hot, they bleed, they feel pain mental physical and emotional pain. They deserve to be treated as we do. 9,472. Saudina Torres Kihei, HI Freedom 9,473. Brenda Nelson Kailua-Kona, HI It is cruelty to animals. It's inhumane. Needs to stop. If you can't afford a fence then don't get a dog. Most people who chain their dogs want the dogs to be aggressive to keep people out of their yard. Please pass this law. 9,474. Denise Deeringer Liverpool, United Kingdom 9,475. Marianne Ray Ontario, CA 9,476. Marie Hastings Port Moody, Canada It’s absolutely inhumane! 9,477. Lynette Bates Leicestershire, United Kingdom 9,478. Alice Dawson Lowell, MA Terrible abuse! Chain the owners! 9,479. Arleene Ceiba, Puerto Rico Betancourt 9,480. Claudia Veronica Bs As, Argentina Garcia 9,481. Amanda Celis Fusagasuga, Gutierrez Colombia 9,482. Angelica Silva Santiago, Chile Los animales son Sres vivos que merecen respecto. 9,483. Maria Jorge Mdp, Argentina 9,484. IRIS GONZALEZ avelaneda, Argentina 9,485. Monika Radl Capital Federar, Argentina 9,486. sheila williams graham, NC This barbaric treatment of companion animals needs to stop!!!! LIKE NOW!!! 9,487. FulviaAway Torre Annunziata, Marino Italy 9,488. Magdalena Torun, Poland Szydlowska 9,489. HAnnah Smith Kamuela, HI

Page 340 - Signatures 9,468 - 9,489 Name From Comments 9,490. Philippe Chatelain Montigny-le-Gannelon, France 9,491. Claudia Gaballo Antwerpen, Belgium 9,492. Chadwick Smith Kona, HI Animal lives worth more than human lives 9,493. Randee Jennings Kailua Kona, HI Because this is inhumane and unnecessary. 9,494. Alexis Thomas Haleiwa, HI 9,495. Ruth Robison HILO, HI 9,496. D Collins LAFAYETTE SQUARE, LA 9,497. Tamiko Murai Monterey Park, CA “The greatness of a nation can be judged by the way its animals are treated” - Gandhi

Page 341 - Signatures 9,490 - 9,497

Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)