God, Fate, and Enemies of Reason: the Self Respect Movement in South India

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

God, Fate, and Enemies of Reason: the Self Respect Movement in South India The Dissertation Committee for Cary E. Sockwell Curtiss Certifies that this is the approved version of the following Dissertation: God, Fate, and Enemies of Reason: The Self Respect Movement in South India Committee: Martha A. Selby, Supervisor Lisa Mitchell Sumit Guha Donald R. Davis Jr. Oliver Freiberger God, Fate, and Enemies of Reason: The Self Respect Movement in South India by Cary E. Sockwell Curtiss Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin May 2020 Dedication For my family, who share their love and support so fully. AcknowledGements It is overwhelming to attempt to put in to words how deeply others have been a part of this process. I want to begin by thanking my graduate school community. My experience at the University of Texas at Austin was tremendous, and this is largely due to the exceptional people with whom I was surrounded. My fellow graduate students played a major role in my academic development. I thank all of them, and especially want to name Amber Abbas and Dean Accardi for many, many conversations which pushed me and furthered my interaction with my studies. Additionally, friends outside of my specific academic context played critical roles in helping me relate my academic pursuits to wider contexts, and in providing friendship, fellowship, and support. Many friends have meant so much to this journey through various roles such as our regular dinner group, to starting new phases for our families together, to showing up and seeing me through some of the toughest times I have had. In these contexts, I want to especially thank both Amber and Dean mentioned above, and also Robyn Heeks and Erin Gentry. The second group of people who have been generous and formative to this process are the faculty with whom I studied at the University of Texas at Austin – and also those with whom I studied earlier in life. I want to start by thanking, wholeheartedly, my Ph.D. advisor Martha Selby. Martha has been supportive beyond what I could ever have expected. She has read this dissertation more times than I would wish on anyone! I cannot say enough as to how important she has been to this process. I would not have managed to see this through if it were not for her. At the University of Texas at Austin, I also benefited and grew due to opportunities to study with Gail Minault, Sankaran Radhakrishnan, Janice Leoshko, Thomas Tweed, Wm. Roger Louis, Antony Hopkins, iv Kamala Visweswaran, and Syed Akbar Hyder, among others. Additionally, I am grateful for Jennifer Tipton's repeated help navigating processes at the University of Texas. I came to the University of Texas at Austin with so much to learn, and I am incredibly grateful for the opportunity. I would also like to thank other professors and teachers I have had, especially Bill Helf, Kelly Dean Jolley, Mary Cameron, Kelly Alley, and Jody Graham. All of these teachers have been part of my love of learning, and that is a gift I carry always. Finally, I want to close by thanking my family. I am thankful to extended family such as Peggy Sockwell, Louise Stump, and Ashley Curtiss; they have been there for me so many times. For the past twenty-five years, Susan Cloud has been my almost-family, and I am immensely grateful to have her friendship to lean on. My parents Anne and Sam had a marathon dissertation-reading weekend with me, and provided me so much helpful and thoughtful feedback. Alongside them, my sisters Emily and Rebecca, and their families, have given me endless encouragement, patience, support, and love. I would not be here without my family. My deepest heartfelt thank you goes to my son Jackson and my partner Matthew; they are the two who got me to the finish line, day by day. Jackson, through his easygoing nature, has been consistently supportive and a constant source of joy and humor. Matthew has believed in me so fully, and has given me much-needed perspective in addition to unquestioning energy and help. From the moment Matthew said “What do we need to do to make this happen?” we three did it, together. v Abstract God, Fate, and Enemies of Reason: The Self Respect Movement in South India Cary E. Sockwell Curtiss, Ph.D. The University of Texas at Austin, 2020 Supervisor: Martha A. Selby With this dissertation, I investigate the question of how the Self Respect Movement, with its rejection of religion and seeming promotion of atheism, fit into the religious landscape of India in the early twentieth century. I argue that history has failed to appreciate the non-religious dynamics of this movement and the complex role of non- religion in India. South Indian social identities went through many changes in the early twentieth century and are commonly explored through influences such as caste, regionalism, language, politics, religion, and gender. This dissertation calls attention to the lack of study of non-religion, which I consider here as a field of tangible and specific phenomena. I begin by reviewing the conceptual framework for the study of non-religion, followed by historiographical approaches to the study of Indian history and nationalism. This provides context for a discussion of the political reform milieu in which the Self Respect Movement arose. I also review the historiography of the study of religion, secularism, and rationalism as a foundation for the study to follow. I turn to individuals’ published writings in varieties of early twentieth century south Indian journals to vi investigate the ways that individual authors champion reason and critique the religious culture around them. Considering perspectives that non-religion offers as alternatives to religious lifestyles offers a richer, more contextualized approach to evaluating the status of religion in India, both historically and into the current day. Here, I show that the Self Respect Movement contributed to identity formation through the exposition of specific values and establishment of new normative practices. I argue that to consider the non- religious aspects of the Self Respect Movement as merely reactionary, inflammatory, or as derivative of western Enlightenment values is reductive and misses the compelling meaning and formative nature that non-religion played for its members. vii Table of Contents Chapter 1: ““Every Human Being is Rational” An introduction to Non-Religion and Early Twentieth Century South India ............................................................................1 Constitutive Boundaries, Aims, and Organization .....................................................2 Conceptual Non-Religion ...........................................................................................6 Historiographical Contextualization ...........................................................................9 Nationalism ...................................................................................................12 Religion in India, Historically ......................................................................15 Caste .........................................................................................................................22 History and Caste ..........................................................................................23 Caste in South India ......................................................................................27 Nationalism and Language on Center Stage .............................................................30 India, Language, and Historical Context ......................................................33 South Indian Tamil Language Context .........................................................34 Differences between Tamil and Telugu Speaking Areas ..............................37 Political Changes and the Emergence of the Self Respect Movement .....................41 Tamil “Nationalism” .....................................................................................46 E.V.R. ...........................................................................................................49 Reflections ................................................................................................................51 Chapter 2: “Rationalists, Humanists, and Atheists” The Study of Religion and the Emergence of Rationalism ...........................................................................................53 The Study of Religion ...............................................................................................55 Historical Trajectory of the Study of Religion .............................................55 Contemporary Debate in the Study of Religion............................................ 58 viii Secularity ..................................................................................................................60 Historical Development of the Concept of “the Secular” .............................62 Contemporary Debate over Secularity ..........................................................66 Historical Emergence of the Term “Rationalism” ........................................70 Atheism and Secularism in India ..............................................................................72 Short History of Atheism in India ................................................................73 Secularism in India .......................................................................................77 Chapter 3: “If Religion
Recommended publications
  • 3.029 Peer Reviewed & Indexed Journal IJMSRR E- ISSN
    Research Paper IJMSRR Impact Factor: 3.029 E- ISSN - 2349-6746 Peer Reviewed & Indexed Journal ISSN -2349-6738 DALITS IN TRADITIONAL TAMIL SOCIETY K. Manikandan Sadakathullah Appa College, Tirunelveli. Introduction ‘Dalits in Traditional Tamil Society’, highlights the classification of dalits, their numerical strength, the different names of the dalits in various regions, explanation of the concept of the dalit, origin of the dalits and the practice of untouchabilty, the application of distinguished criteria for the dalits and caste-Hindus, identification of sub-divisions amongst the dalits, namely, Chakkiliyas, Kuravas, Nayadis, Pallars, Paraiahs and Valluvas, and the major dalit communities in the Tamil Country, namely, Paraiahs, Pallas, Valluvas, Chakkilias or Arundathiyars, the usage of the word ‘depressed classes’ by the British officials to denote all the dalits, the usage of the word ‘Scheduled Castes’ to denote 86 low caste communities as per the Indian Council Act of 1935, Gandhi’s usage of the word ‘Harijan’ to denote the dalits, M.C. Rajah’s opposition of the usage of the word ‘Harijan’, the usage of the term ‘Adi-Darvida’ to denote the dalits of the Tamil Country, the distribution of the four major dalit communities in the Tamil Country, the strength of the dalits in the 1921 Census, a brief sketch about the condition of the dalits in the past, the touch of the Christian missionaries on the dalits of the Tamil Country, the agrestic slavery of the dalits in the modern Tamil Country, the patterns of land control, the issue of agrestic servitude of dalits, the link of economic and social developments with the changing agrarian structure and the subsequent profound impact on the lives of the Dalits and the constructed ideas of native super-ordination and subordination which placed the dalits at the mercy of the dominant communities in Tamil Society’.
    [Show full text]
  • “Lost in Translation”: a Study of the History of Sri Lankan Literature
    Karunakaran / Lost in Translation “Lost in Translation”: A Study of the History of Sri Lankan Literature Shamila Karunakaran Abstract This paper provides an overview of the history of Sri Lankan literature from the ancient texts of the precolonial era to the English translations of postcolonial literature in the modern era. Sri Lanka’s book history is a cultural record of texts that contains “cultural heritage and incorporates everything that has survived” (Chodorow, 2006); however, Tamil language works are written with specifc words, ideas, and concepts that are unique to Sri Lankan culture and are “lost in translation” when conveyed in English. Keywords book history, translation iJournal - Journal Vol. 4 No. 1, Fall 2018 22 Karunakaran / Lost in Translation INTRODUCTION The phrase “lost in translation” refers to when the translation of a word or phrase does not convey its true or complete meaning due to various factors. This is a common problem when translating non-Western texts for North American and British readership, especially those written in non-Roman scripts. Literature and texts are tangible symbols, containing signifed cultural meaning, and they represent varying aspects of an existing international ethnic, social, or linguistic culture or group. Chodorow (2006) likens it to a cultural record of sorts, which he defnes as an object that “contains cultural heritage and incorporates everything that has survived” (pg. 373). In particular, those written in South Asian indigenous languages such as Tamil, Sanskrit, Urdu, Sinhalese are written with specifc words, ideas, and concepts that are unique to specifc culture[s] and cannot be properly conveyed in English translations.
    [Show full text]
  • The Fault Lines in Tamil Nadu That the DMK Now Has to Confront
    TIF - The Fault Lines in Tamil Nadu that the DMK Now Has to Confront KALAIYARASAN A June 4, 2021 M. VIJAYABASKAR Is modernisation of occupations in Tamil Nadu possible? A young worker at a brick factory near Chennai | brianindia/Alamy The DMK faces new challenges in expanding social justice alongside economic modernisation: internal fault lines have emerged in the form of cracks in the Dravidian coalition of lower castes and there are external ones such as reduced autonomy for states. As anticipated, the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK)-led alliance has come to power in Tamil Nadu after winning 159 out of the 234 seats in the state assembly. Many within the party had expected it to repeat its 2019 sweep in the Lok Sabha elections. The All-India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (AIADMK), despite having been in power for a decade and losing its long-time leader J. Jayalalithaa, managed to retain a good share of its vote base. The AIADMK government was often seen to compromise the interests of the state because of pressure from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), with which it had allied. The DMK’s election campaign had, therefore, emphasised the loss of the state’s dignity and autonomy because of the AIADMK-BJP alliance and promised a return to the Page 1 www.TheIndiaForum.in June 4, 2021 Dravidian ethos that had earlier informed the state’s development. Apart from welfare, the DMK’s election manifesto emphasised reforms in governance of service delivery, and growth across sectors, agriculture in particular. The DMK’s victory has come at a time when Tamil Nadu is faced with a series of challenges.
    [Show full text]
  • Top 300 Masters 2020
    TOP 300 MASTERS 2020 2020 Top 300 MASTERS 1 About Broadcom MASTERS Broadcom MASTERS® (Math, Applied Science, Technology and Engineering for Rising Stars), a program of Society for Science & the Public, is the premier middle school science and engineering fair competition, inspiring the next generation of scientists, engineers and innovators who will solve the grand challenges of the 21st century and beyond. We believe middle school is a critical time when young people identify their personal passion, and if they discover an interest in STEM, they can be inspired to follow their passion by taking STEM courses in high school. Broadcom MASTERS is the only middle school STEM competition that leverages Society- affiliated science fairs as a critical component of the STEM talent pipeline. In 2020, all 6th, 7th, and 8th grade students around the country who were registered for their local or state Broadcom MASTERS affiliated fair were eligible to compete. After submitting the online application, the Top 300 MASTERS are selected by a panel of scientists, engineers, and educators from around the nation. The Top 300 MASTERS are honored for their work with a $125 cash prize, through the Society’s partnership with the U.S. Department of Defense as a member of the Defense STEM education Consortium (DSEC). Top 300 MASTERS also receive a prize package that includes an award ribbon, a Top 300 MASTERS certificate of accomplishment, a Broadcom MASTERS backpack, a Broadcom MASTERS decal, a one-year family digital subscription to Science News magazine, an Inventor's Notebook, courtesy of The Lemelson Foundation, a one-year subscription to Wolfram Mathematica software, courtesy of Wolfram Research, and a special prize from Jeff Glassman, CEO of Covington Capital Management.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Personality Politics Died with Amma'
    'Personality politics died with Amma' 'I don't think after Amma, the cult of personality will endure.' 'I think there will be a shift back to the politics of ideology and principles rather than a cult of personality.' P T R Palanivel Thiagarajan is the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam MLA from the Madurai ​ ​ Central constituency. A former America-based merchant banker, he returned to Tamil Nadu to contest a seat his father P T R Palanivel Rajan had represented in the state assembly. His observations during the discussions on the budget in the assembly were acknowledged by then chief minister J Jayalalithaa. P T R Palanivel Thiagarajan draws the trajectory of Tamil Nadu politics after Jayalalithaa's death. It will be difficult for All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam members to find a common cause. They had a towering personality for a leader and filling that vacuum will not be possible. I don't see another leader taking her place in the near future. There is nobody of her stature. It is a generational shift and in her case the successor is not obvious. It is a inter generational transfer. It started with Perarignar Anna (the late Tamil Nadu CM C N ​ Annadurai, founder of the DMK and the inspiration for the AIADMK) and then MGR (the late ​ ​ Tamil Nadu CM M G Ramachandran). ​ With Anna, the politics was based on ideology which was different from the earlier Congress government in Tamil Nadu. During MGR's time, it was a big shift from ideology governance to a personality cult. With the DMK and the Congress, there was a marked difference in ideology.
    [Show full text]
  • GRAMMAR of OLD TAMIL for STUDENTS 1 St Edition Eva Wilden
    GRAMMAR OF OLD TAMIL FOR STUDENTS 1 st Edition Eva Wilden To cite this version: Eva Wilden. GRAMMAR OF OLD TAMIL FOR STUDENTS 1 st Edition. Eva Wilden. Institut français de Pondichéry; École française d’Extrême-Orient, 137, 2018, Collection Indologie. halshs- 01892342v2 HAL Id: halshs-01892342 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-01892342v2 Submitted on 24 Jan 2020 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. GRAMMAR OF OLD TAMIL FOR STUDENTS 1st Edition L’Institut Français de Pondichéry (IFP), UMIFRE 21 CNRS-MAE, est un établissement à autonomie financière sous la double tutelle du Ministère des Affaires Etrangères (MAE) et du Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS). Il est partie intégrante du réseau des 27 centres de recherche de ce Ministère. Avec le Centre de Sciences Humaines (CSH) à New Delhi, il forme l’USR 3330 du CNRS « Savoirs et Mondes Indiens ». Il remplit des missions de recherche, d’expertise et de formation en Sciences Humaines et Sociales et en Écologie dans le Sud et le Sud- est asiatiques. Il s’intéresse particulièrement aux savoirs et patrimoines culturels indiens (langue et littérature sanskrites, histoire des religions, études tamoules…), aux dynamiques sociales contemporaines, et aux ecosystèmes naturels de l’Inde du Sud.
    [Show full text]
  • Agastya International Foundation Synopsys
    In Partnership with Student Projects Technical Record Released on the occasion of Science & Engineering Fair of Selected Projects at Shikshakara Sadana, K G Road Bangalore on th th th 26 , 27 & 28 February 2018 Organised by Agastya International Foundation In support with Synopsys Anveshana 2017-18- BANGALORE - Abstract Book Page 1 of 209 CONTENTS 1. FOREWORD 2. ABOUT AGASTYA INTERNATIONAL FOUNDATION 3. ABOUT SYNOPSYS 4. ABOUT ANVESHANA 5. PROJECT SCREENING COMMITTEE 6. COPY OF INVITATION 7. PROGRAM CHART 8. LIST OF PROJECTS EXHIBITED IN THE FAIR 9. PROJECT DESCRIPTION Anveshana 2017-18- BANGALORE - Abstract Book Page 2 of 209 FOREWORD In a world where recent events suggest that we may be entering a period of greater uncertainties, it is disturbing that India's educational system is not (in general) internationally competitive. In an age where the state of the economy is driven more and more by knowledge and skill, it is clear that the future of our country will depend crucially on education at all levels – from elementary schools to research universities. It is equally clear that the question is not one of talent or innate abilities of our country men, as more and more Indians begin to win top jobs in US business and industry, government and academia. Indian talent is almost universally acknowledged, as demonstrated by the multiplying number of R&D centres being set up in India by an increasing number of multinational companies. So what is the real problem? There are many problems ranging from poor talent management to an inadequate teaching system in most schools and colleges where there is little effort to make contact with the real world in general rather than only prescribed text books.
    [Show full text]
  • Periyar 1000 Pages
    Compiled by : Dr. K.Veeramani A Publication of DRAVIDAR KAZHAGAM Periyar Thidal, Vepery, Chennai - 600 007. PERIYAR 1000 QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS (All about Periyar E.V.Ramasamy) Compiled by: Dr. K.Veeramani Translated by: Prof. S.F.N. Chelliah Pages : 240 (1/8 Demmy) Donation (Minimum) : Rs.50/- Rs.60/- Rs.70/- Rs.80/- Rs.90/- Rs.100/- First Edition : 2013 Published by Dravidar Kazhagam ‘Periyar Thidal’. No. 84/1(50), E.V.K. Sampath Road, Vepery, Chennai - 600 007, Tamil Nadu - India Tel: 91-44-26618161 Fax: 91-44-26618866 Printed by ‘Viduthalai’ Offset Printers, 84/1(50), E.V.K. Sampath Salai, Chennai - 7 Available at Periyar Book House 84/1(50), E.V.K. Sampath Salai, Vepery, CHENNAI - 7. : 91-44-26618162 Periyar Maligai, Puthur, TRICHY - 17. : 91-431-2771815 Website: www.dravidianbookhouse.com ISBN : 978-93-80972-96-1 nlike world's other thinkers, Th anthai Periyar was an original thinker. Th e enrichment of his thoughts is the seed of social development and Ua weapon for social revolution. In addition to this; his rationalistic thoughts are totally based on scientifi c thinking. Th at is why we feel proud of calling him a 'rare social scientist'. What is Science? And who is a Scientist? What is scientifi c temperament? Even the teachers of science, do not seem to know the real meaning of science. Th ey only know science as 'a subject', 'a study', nothing more. We are puzzled why they are not interested to know or to understand the real meaning of science and to teach the students.
    [Show full text]
  • Fuzzy and Neutrosophic Analysis of Periyar's Views
    FUZZY AND NEUTROSOPHIC ANALYSIS OF PERIYAR’S VIEWS ON UNTOUCHABILITY W. B. Vasantha Kandasamy Florentin Smarandache K. Kandasamy Translation of the speeches and writings of Periyar from Tamil by Meena Kandasamy November 2005 FUZZY AND NEUTROSOPHIC ANALYSIS OF PERIYAR’S VIEWS ON UNTOUCHABILITY W. B. Vasantha Kandasamy e-mail: [email protected] web: http://mat.iitm.ac.in/~wbv Florentin Smarandache e-mail: [email protected] K. Kandasamy e-mail: [email protected] Translation of the speeches and writings of Periyar from Tamil by Meena Kandasamy November 2005 2 Dedicated to Periyar CONTENTS Preface 5 Chapter One BASIC NOTION OF FCMs, FRMs, NCMs AND NRMS 1.1 Definition of Fuzzy Cognitive Maps 9 1.2 Fuzzy Cognitive Maps – Properties and Models 13 1.3 Fuzzy Relational Maps 18 1.4 An Introduction to Neutrosophy and some Neutrosophic algebraic structures 22 1.5 Neutrosophic Cognitive Maps 27 1.6 Neutrosophic Relational Maps — Definition with Examples 31 Chapter Two UNTOUCHABILITY: PERIYAR’S VIEW AND PRESENT DAY SITUATION A FUZZY AND NEUTROSOPHIC ANALYSIS 2.1 Analysis of untouchability due to Hindu religion using FCMs and NCMs 43 2.2 Analysis of discrimination faced by Dalits/ Sudras in the field of education as untouchables using FCMs and NCMs 58 2.3 Social inequality faced by Dalits and some of the most backward classes - an analysis using FCM and NCM 66 4 2.4 Problems faced by Dalits in the political arena due to discrimination – a FCM and NCM analysis 75 2.5 Study of Economic Status of Dalits due to untouchability using fuzzy and neutrosophic
    [Show full text]
  • Police Matters: the Everyday State and Caste Politics in South India, 19001975 by Radha Kumar
    PolICe atter P olice M a tte rs T he v eryday tate and aste Politics in South India, 1900–1975 • R a dha Kumar Cornell unIerIt Pre IthaCa an lonon Copyright 2021 by Cornell University The text of this book is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License: https:creativecommons.orglicensesby-nc-nd4.0. To use this book, or parts of this book, in any way not covered by the license, please contact Cornell University Press, Sage House, 512 East State Street, Ithaca, New ork 14850. Visit our website at cornellpress.cornell.edu. First published 2021 by Cornell University Press Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Kumar, Radha, 1981 author. Title: Police matters: the everyday state and caste politics in south India, 19001975 by Radha Kumar. Description: Ithaca New ork: Cornell University Press, 2021 Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2021005664 (print) LCCN 2021005665 (ebook) ISBN 9781501761065 (paperback) ISBN 9781501760860 (pdf) ISBN 9781501760877 (epub) Subjects: LCSH: Police—India—Tamil Nadu—History—20th century. Law enforcement—India—Tamil Nadu—History—20th century. Caste— Political aspects—India—Tamil Nadu—History. Police-community relations—India—Tamil Nadu—History—20th century. Caste-based discrimination—India—Tamil Nadu—History—20th century. Classification: LCC HV8249.T3 K86 2021 (print) LCC HV8249.T3 (ebook) DDC 363.20954820904—dc23 LC record available at https:lccn.loc.gov2021005664 LC ebook record available at https:lccn.loc.gov2021005665 Cover image: The Car en Route, Srivilliputtur, c. 1935. The British Library Board, Carleston Collection: Album of Snapshot Views in South India, Photo 6281 (40).
    [Show full text]
  • The Political Aco3mxddati0n of Primqpjdial Parties
    THE POLITICAL ACO3MXDDATI0N OF PRIMQPJDIAL PARTIES DMK (India) and PAS (Malaysia) , by Y. Mansoor Marican M.Soc.Sci. (S'pore), 1971 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FL^iDlMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES (Department of. Political Science) We accept this thesis as conforniing to the required standard THE IJNT^RSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA November. 1976 ® Y. Mansoor Marican, 1976. In presenting this thesis in partial fulfilment of the requirements for an advanced degree at the University of British Columbia, I agree that the Library shall make it freely available for reference and study. I further agree that permission for extensive copying of this thesis for scholarly purposes may be granted by the Head of my Department or by his representatives. It is understood that copying or publication of this thesis for financial gain shall not be allowed without my written permission. Department of POLITICAL SCIENCE The University of British Columbia 2075 Wesbrook Place Vancouver, Canada V6T 1W5 ABSTRACT This study is rooted in a theoretical interest in the development of parties that appeal mainly to primordial ties. The claims of social relationships based on tribe, race, language or religion have the capacity to rival the civil order of the state for the loyalty of its citizens, thus threatening to undermine its political authority. This phenomenon is endemic to most Asian and African states. Most previous research has argued that political competition in such contexts encourages the formation of primordially based parties whose activities threaten the integrity of these states.
    [Show full text]
  • Economic and Political Change and Caste Relations in Tamil Nadu Early in the 21St Century
    Privilege in Dispute: Economic and Political Change and Caste Relations in Tamil Nadu Early in the 21st Century John Harriss Simons Papers in Security and Development No. 44/2014 | September 2015 Simons Papers in Security and Development No. 44/2015 2 The Simons Papers in Security and Development are edited and published at the School for International Studies, Simon Fraser University. The papers serve to disseminate research work in progress by the School’s faculty and associated and visiting scholars. Our aim is to encourage the exchange of ideas and academic debate. Inclusion of a paper in the series should not limit subsequent publication in any other venue. All papers can be downloaded free of charge from our website, www.sfu.ca/internationalstudies. The series is supported by the Simons Foundation. Series editor: Jeffrey T. Checkel Managing editor: Martha Snodgrass Harriss, John, Privilege in Dispute: Economic and Political Change and Caste Relations in Tamil Nadu Early in the 21st Century, Simons Papers in Security and Development, No. 44/2015, School for International Studies, Simon Fraser University, Vancouver, September 2015. ISSN 1922-5725 Copyright remains with the author. Reproduction for other purposes than personal research, whether in hard copy or electronically, requires the consent of the author(s). If cited or quoted, reference should be made to the full name of the author(s), the title, the working paper number and year, and the publisher. Copyright for this issue: John Harriss, jharriss(at)sfu.ca. School for International Studies Simon Fraser University Suite 7200 - 515 West Hastings Street Vancouver, BC Canada V6B 5K3 Privilege in Dispute: Caste Relations in Tamil Nadu 3 Privilege in Dispute: Economic and Political Change and Caste Relations in Tamil Nadu Early in the 21st Century Simons Papers in Security and Development No.
    [Show full text]