Hotshot Executives Are Fleeing the Scrutiny of Public Companies for The

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Hotshot Executives Are Fleeing the Scrutiny of Public Companies for The CLASS DIVIDE AT AMHERST (P. 64 ) lA DIFFERENT DIET PILL (P. 74 ) FEBRUARY 27, 2006 www.businessweek.com GoingPrivate Hotshot executives are fleeing the scrutiny of public companies for the mad money of the private-equity boom BY EMILY THORNTON (P. 52 ) February 27, 2006 52 FOLLOW THE MONEY Cover Story WIth so much private-equity 52 Going Private cash sloshing around, no Money and freedom. That’s wonder top talent is kissing what’s driving hotshot off public companies managers, midcareer folks, and newly minted MBAs alike to private equity, a world where investors buy slumping companies, turn them around, then sell or take them public. Pay is high even at the entry level—and can be spectacular for stars like ex-ibm chief Lou Gerstner. As for freedom, ceos can build for the long term without shareholders second-guessing every move. Not to mention that pesky Sarbanes-Oxley... 58 Buyout Mania’s Mountain of Debt By 2008 there may be a wave of defaults 62 A Chat With Lou Gerstner Why he doesn’t miss the quarterly grind The Business Week 26 News You Need To Know Retail sales; oil production; Merrill and 84 BlackRock; Warner Music; and more a; BAND WIDTH News: Analysis Your own kind & Commentary of music, online 28 How the IPO Market Got Its Buzz Back Investor appetites have returned, but this time they’re drawn to—mostly— saner offerings BusinessWeek (ISSN 0007-7135) Issue number 3973, published weekly, except for one week in January and one in August, by The 44 McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Executive, Editorial, Circulation, and Advertising Offices: 1221 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NON GRATA N.Y. 10020. Periodicals postage paid at New York, N.Y., and at additional mailing offices. Canada Post Publication Mail Icahn’s frosty Agreement Number 40012501. Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to: DPGM Ltd., 2-7496 Bath Road, Mississauga, ON L4T 1L2. Email: bwkcustserv@cdsfulfillment.com reception in Korea Postmaster: Send address changes to BusinessWeek. P.O. Box 8418, Red Oak, IA. 51591-1418. john kuczal by cover photo illustration (bottom left) rick maiman/bloomberg news 2 | BusinessWeek | February 27, 2006 31 Class Actions’ Great Divide More plaintiffs opt out of settlements—a headache for companies being sued 64 32 Commentary: Housing BIG PLAN ON CAMPUS Falling prices will bring on the pain. Even with financial aid, Who’ll get blamed if the roof caves in? most low-income kids 34 The Rising Stock of Black Directors can’t afford college. Companies seek to broaden their boards Amherst President 36 Wanna Buy a Money Manager? Tony Marx wants Banks and brokerages are selling to change that 38 Tesco’s California Dream A British supermarket heads for the U.S. Government 41 Washington Outlook A congressman’s guilty plea shines light Science & Technology 90 Your Very Own Hit Factory on Capitol Hill’s “black budget” A digital home recording studio requires 74 Girth of a Nation the right software and a lot of patience Many doctors may decide obesity is best fought with a pill nearing fda approval 92 Tuning Up a New Generation Global Business Teaching computer-savvy kids to compose 42 Electrolux Cleans Up ceo 94 Singing Beyond the Shower Straberg reverses a slide by Marketing Web sites to expand your audience jettisoning old ways and boosting r&d 76 Video Games: The New Ad Game 44 Icahn: Foreign Raiders in Korea Why they’re becoming the hot spots for His kt&g fight may be the first of many product placements Columnists 45 India’s Generic-Drug Wars 18 Wildstrom: Technology & You pc Suddenly, Dr. Reddy’s and Ranbaxy are Finance New security services for the home up against a fresh crop of competitors 20 Fine: Media Centric Golden West’s Golden Strategy What the U.S. Can Learn from Sasol 78 And the competition is...teen consumers 46 How it’s able to ride a housing bubble The South African company makes 23 Cooper: Business Outlook liquid fuels from coal, not Mideast oil An increasingly global economy will Entrepreneurs hamstring Bernanke’s domestic efforts Currencies: The case for a dollar decline Managing 80 Steering Patients Through the System 96 Marcial: Inside Wall Street 48 The Org Chart That Really Counts Quantum Health points people to the How mapping unofficial job links pays off best care and saves employers big bucks 102 Jack and Suzy Welch: The Welch Way Weighing worklife trade-offs The Corporation Information 50 Dot-Com Fever, Again Technology Ideas Small sites are pursued by Big Media 82 A New Chapter for Digital Books 100 Books In 2006 they may become best-sellers, Spar: The Baby Business thanks to big tech advances 104 Outside Shot: Barney Frank Special Report The free market is producing more 64 Amherst’s Campus Revolutionary inequality than is socially healthy President Tony Marx is developing a Personal Tech/Music radical plan to get more poor kids into 84 Boot Up the Band top colleges, starting with his own school Technology makes it easier to compose, Features record, and promote your own music 7 UpFront People 85 Plug ’n’ Play Pianos 14 Readers Report There’s a digital keyboard for everyone 16 Corrections & Clarifications 72 Death, Dying, and the CEO kpmg’s Eugene O’Kelly and his wife 88 Go, Go, Go Johnny B. Digital 98 Figures of the Week collaborated on a remarkable chronicle Bringing guitars into the 21st century 99 Index of Companies February 27, 2006 | BusinessWeek | 3 It’s about money. Earning it. WWW.BUSINESSWEEK.COM Updated every business day. BusinessWeek magazine is available online free to subscribers: Investing it. Go to www.businessweek.com and follow instructions to register. Spending it. Mourning the closing Check out this weekend’s of Chicago’s landmark show February 18 and 19: eatery Overlooked deductions: Tips to help lower your tax Keeping it bill and boost your refund. Teaching tunes: Kids review All in the Family software that teaches them As baby boomers gray, hundreds of how to compose and play music. thousands of family-owned businesses are facing a major decision: What will Destination CEO: Meet Barbie’s they do with the business? Options maker. Mattel CEO Bob Eckert abound: selling to investors, giving the a talks about his rise to the business to children, bringing in corner office. outside management. In this Online Special Report, we take a look at what Barking for bucks: families need to consider as they Dog-related products and decide whether and how to pass their services are making big businesses on. Meet Chicago’s Berghoff bucks for business owners. Family, who after three generations has decided to close the 108 year-old restaurant that bears their name. Visit Execs Craigie and Debbie Zildjian keep with the 14th generation of Zildjians to the cymbal maker marching on find out how they’ve managed to keep the family’s cymbal business running for nearly 400 years. Our report also examines Airs Saturday/Sunday nationwide. the generation ready to take control and offers a gallery of family- Check your local listings owned businesses that have stood the test of time. You’ll find all or view segments at this and more at www.businessweek.com/go/familybusiness (top to bottom) jeff roberson/ap/wide world; asia kepk www.businessweekweekend.com 4 | BusinessWeek | February 27, 2006 “I am stunned that he would be out speechifying the first week he was off the job.” –Donald Straszheim of Straszheim Global Advisors on Alan Greenspan possibly upstaging successor Ben Bernanke with his public appearances and planned memoir, to USA Today EDITED BY DAN BEUCKE MOTHER INDIA romance, politics, hatred, all creating high drama,” says AS THE Shristi Behl Arya, who is the show’s producer. CALL CENTER Indeed, the customer TURNS service scene in India is any- thing but boring. Centers can MAYBE IT SEEMS like you be a hotbed of hormones; spend half your life on the some average a marriage a phone with a call center in month, often outside tradi- India. But in India itself, call tional bounds of caste and centers actually are seeping economic status. The Call into everyday life, appearing Center, a show coming soon to in a wave of popular sitcoms channel NDTV, takes potshots and books. India Calling, a at Americans venting their hot Indian tv show (below) angst about losing jobs to the on Rupert Indians on the Murdoch’s other end of HAPPIER DAYS Eisner and Jobs STAR channel, the wire. A after A Bug’s depicts a best-selling Life premiere small-town book, One girl who Night @ The lands in Call Center, SHOW BIZ Bombay in touches on search of her love, bad boss- absconding es, even God Eisner: Let’s sister. She finds a job in a call (appearing, naturally, in a center instead. Viewers phone call). Then there are follow the highs and lows of the jokes making the rounds: Break a Deal the work, which attracts When a man complains to a thousands of young Indians. doctor about insomnia, the MICHAEL EISNER now knows they can put your name on the “Call center jobs are now part doctor suggests working at a building, but that doesn’t guarantee a warm welcome back. of India’s social fabric, call center as the remedy. Eisner, who left Walt Disney as ceo on Sept. 30, was honored offering immense scope for –Nandini Lakshman on Jan. 23 when Disney named its Burbank headquarters building after him. But later that day, the board turned down Eisner’s last pitch: a plea to pull out of talks to buy Steve Jobs’ Pixar Animation Studios.
Recommended publications
  • 8364 Licensed Charities As of 3/10/2020 MICS 24404 MICS 52720 T
    8364 Licensed Charities as of 3/10/2020 MICS 24404 MICS 52720 T. Rowe Price Program for Charitable Giving, Inc. The David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust USA, Inc. 100 E. Pratt St 25283 Cabot Road, Ste. 101 Baltimore MD 21202 Laguna Hills CA 92653 Phone: (410)345-3457 Phone: (949)305-3785 Expiration Date: 10/31/2020 Expiration Date: 10/31/2020 MICS 52752 MICS 60851 1 For 2 Education Foundation 1 Michigan for the Global Majority 4337 E. Grand River, Ste. 198 1920 Scotten St. Howell MI 48843 Detroit MI 48209 Phone: (425)299-4484 Phone: (313)338-9397 Expiration Date: 07/31/2020 Expiration Date: 07/31/2020 MICS 46501 MICS 60769 1 Voice Can Help 10 Thousand Windows, Inc. 3290 Palm Aire Drive 348 N Canyons Pkwy Rochester Hills MI 48309 Livermore CA 94551 Phone: (248)703-3088 Phone: (571)263-2035 Expiration Date: 07/31/2021 Expiration Date: 03/31/2020 MICS 56240 MICS 10978 10/40 Connections, Inc. 100 Black Men of Greater Detroit, Inc 2120 Northgate Park Lane Suite 400 Attn: Donald Ferguson Chattanooga TN 37415 1432 Oakmont Ct. Phone: (423)468-4871 Lake Orion MI 48362 Expiration Date: 07/31/2020 Phone: (313)874-4811 Expiration Date: 07/31/2020 MICS 25388 MICS 43928 100 Club of Saginaw County 100 Women Strong, Inc. 5195 Hampton Place 2807 S. State Street Saginaw MI 48604 Saint Joseph MI 49085 Phone: (989)790-3900 Phone: (888)982-1400 Expiration Date: 07/31/2020 Expiration Date: 07/31/2020 MICS 58897 MICS 60079 1888 Message Study Committee, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Behind Janus: Documents Reveal Decade-Long Plot to Kill Public-Sector Unions
    Behind Janus: Documents Reveal Decade-Long Plot to Kill Public-Sector Unions The Supreme Court case Janus v. AFSCME is poised to decimate public-sector unions—and it’s been made possible by a network of right-wing billionaires, think tanks and corporations. MARY BOTTARI FEBRUARY 22, 2018 | MARCH ISSUE In These Times THE ROMAN GOD JANUS WAS KNOWN FOR HAVING TWO FACES. It is a fitting name for the U.S. Supreme Court case scheduled for oral arguments February 26, Janus v. American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, Council 31, that could deal a devastating blow to public-sector unions and workers nationwide. In the past decade, a small group of people working for deep-pocketed corporate interests, conservative think tanks and right-wing foundations have bankrolled a series of lawsuits to end what they call “forced unionization.” They say they fight in the name of “free speech,” “worker rights” and “workplace freedom.” In briefs before the court, they present their public face: carefully selected and appealing plaintiffs like Illinois child-support worker Mark Janus and California schoolteacher Rebecca Friedrichs. The language they use is relentlessly pro-worker. Behind closed doors, a different face is revealed. Those same people cheer “defunding” and “bankrupting” unions to deal a “mortal blow” to progressive politics in America. A key director of this charade is the State Policy Network (SPN), whose game plan is revealed in a union-busting toolkit uncovered by the Center for Media and Democracy. The first rule of the national network of right-wing think tanks that are pushing to dismantle unions? “Rule #1: Be pro-worker, not anti-union.
    [Show full text]
  • No Shortcuts: the Case for Organizing
    City University of New York (CUNY) CUNY Academic Works All Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects 5-2015 No Shortcuts: The Case for Organizing Jane Frances McAlevey Graduate Center, City University of New York How does access to this work benefit ou?y Let us know! More information about this work at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu/gc_etds/1043 Discover additional works at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu This work is made publicly available by the City University of New York (CUNY). Contact: [email protected] i No Shortcuts: The Case for Organizing by Jane F. McAlevey A dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty in Sociology in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, The City University of New York 2015 ii COPYRIGHT © 2015 JANE F. MCALEVEY All Rights Reserved iii APPROVAL PAGE, NO SHORTCUTS: THE CASE FOR ORGANIZING This manuscript has been read and accepted for the Graduate Faculty in Sociology to satisfy the dissertation requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Approved by: Date Chair of Examining Committee ______________________ _________________________________________ Frances Fox Piven, Professor Date Executive Officer, Sociology ______________________ __________________________________________ Philip Kasinitz, Professor Supervisory Committee Members James Jasper, Professor William Kornblum, Professor Dan Clawson, Professor, UMASS Amherst THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK iv ABSTRACT Abstract No Shortcuts: The Case for Organizing By Jane McAlevey Advisor: Frances Fox Piven This dissertation will explore how ordinary workers in the new economy create and sustain power from below. In workplace and community movements, individuals acting collectively have been shown to win victories using a variety of different approaches.
    [Show full text]
  • Policy Brief Six Common Myths About the Minimum Wage Erin Shannon Director, Center for Small Business and Labor Reform December 2017
    Policy Brief Six common myths about the minimum wage Erin Shannon Director, Center for Small Business and Labor Reform December 2017 Key Findings 1. The buying power of the federal minimum wage, and state minimum wages that are higher, have kept pace with inflation. 2. Minimum wage workers are not worse off economically than they were in the past. In 1968 minimum wage workers could buy more with their money, but there were three times as many workers earning minimum wage and they were paying much higher taxes than today’s minimum wage workers. 3. Increasing the minimum wage does not reduce poverty. Low wages are not the cause of poverty; it is lack of a job. Of working age adults living in poverty, nearly two-thirds do not work. Of the close to one-third who do work, only 10 percent work full time. 4. Very few people are “trying to survive” on minimum wage earnings. The majority of minimum wage earners are young and many are still in school. Most minimum wage workers are not poor, are not working full-time, and do not rely on their wages as the sole source of income to support a family. 5. A family that relies solely on minimum wage earnings is rare. The vast majority of adult minimum wage earners, with or without children, are supplementing the income of a higher- earning spouse. 6. The value of the minimum wage has more than kept pace with gains in worker productivity in the jobs that typically pay minimum wage. 7. Economic studies show raising the minimum wage comes with significant harmful effects, making it harder for young people, immigrants and minorities, and workers with less on-the-job experience to find employment.
    [Show full text]
  • Gedung Putih, Hari Pertama Obama
    Untuk Rachel Corrie gadis muda Amerika, aktivis perdamaian yang tubuhnya hancur digilas buldozer Israel Ucapan terimakasih untuk... Suamiku, yang tanpa dukungannya buku ini takkan pernah selesai. Anak-anakku, yang bersabar membiarkanku melewati puluhan hari untuk menulis buku ini. Orangtuaku, teman-temanku, dan semua orang yang mendorongku untuk terus menulis. QR Aliya Publishing, yang telah bersedia menerbitkan buku ini Prolog Obama: Tutankhamon Baru Dunia (?) The United States played a role in the overthrow of a democratically elected Iranian government. (Pidato Obama di Kairo) 4 Juni 2009 Kairo, yang biasanya padat dan bising, pagi itu sangat sepi dan teratur. Ada tamu besar yang akan datang hari itu: Presiden AS ke-44, Barack Husein Obama. Beberapa jalanan utama yang akan dilalui Sang Presiden ditutup untuk umum dan dikawal polisi berseragam putih. Sebagian besar dari 18 juta penduduk kota itu memilih tinggal di rumah daripada berpergian di tengah jalanan yang diblokir di sana-sini. Bahkan terminal bus di dekat Mesjid Sultan dipindahkan supaya tak ada keramaian di mesjid kuno yang akan dikunjungi Obama itu. Tak heran bila Al Dastour, koran independen terbitan Kairo menulis headline, “Hari Ini Obama Datang Ke Mesir Setelah Mengevakuasi Warga Mesir”. Di pasar Khan Al Khalili, Kairo, toko-toko souvenir menjual plakat metal bergambar wajah Pharaoh (Firaun)1 dengan tulisan “Obama, Tutankhamon Baru Dunia”. Tutankhamon adalah Firaun terakhir Dinasti Kedelapanbelas Mesir, hidup pada tahun 1333-1324 sebelum Masehi. Konon dia raja yang berhasil memimpin Mesir melewati masa krisis. Dan agaknya, menurut versi pembuat souvenir itu, Obama adalah Tutankhamon baru yang memimpin dunia yang saat ini sangat dipenuhi oleh krisis, konflik, dan pertumpahan darah.
    [Show full text]
  • Board Special Meeting
    Board Special Meeting Work Sessions: Student Assignment Transition Plan and Boundaries; Student and Community Workforce Agreement Task Force Recommendations June 17, 2020, 4:30 – 7:30 p.m. Meeting to be held remotely By Microsoft Teams By Teleconference: 206-800-4125 (Conference ID: 365 554 104#) Agenda Call to Order 4:30pm Work Session: Student Assignment Transition Plan and Boundaries 4:30pm Work Session: Student and Community Workforce Agreement 6:00pm* Task Force Recommendations Adjourn 7:30pm* IMPORTANT NOTE: This meeting will be held remotely without an in-person location per the Governor’s Proclamation 20-28.4, which currently prohibits public agencies from conducting meetings subject to the Open Public Meetings Act in-person to curtail the spread of COVID-19, and consistent with School Board Resolution 2019/20-29. The public is being provided remote access through Microsoft Teams and teleconference as noted above. Special meetings of the Board, including work sessions and retreats, may contain discussion and/or action related to the items listed on the agenda. Executive sessions are closed to the public per RCW 42.30. *Times given are estimated. WORK SESSION Student Assignment Transition Plan & School Boundary Changes for 2021-22 Enrollment Planning June 17, 2020 Agenda • Boundary Changes • Identifying and Addressing Capacity Issues • Boundary Change Process and Timeline • Community Engagement • Potential Boundary Changes for 2021-22 SY • Student Assignment Transition Plan • Overview • Dual Language Immersion 2 Boundary Changes 3 Identifying and Addressing Capacity Issues In order to identify capacity issues we: • Develop and monitor 5-year enrollment projections. • Monitor and review new housing and construction across the city.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the Original Report Here
    CONTRIBUTORS AARON YELOWITZ, University of Kentucky MARK PERRY, American Enterprise Institute and the University of Michigan-Flint DAVID NEUMARK, University of California-Irvine DAVID MACPHERSON, Trinity University JAMES SHERK, Former Research Fellow, Heritage Foundation WILLIAM EVEN, Miami University ANDY PUZDER, Former CEO, CKE RICHARD BERMAN, Center for Union Facts LLOYD CORDER, CorCom, Inc., Carnegie Mellon University and University of Pittsburgh JOSEPH SABIA, San Diego State University and University of New Hampshire With an Introduction by MICHAEL SALTSMAN Edited by LIAM SIGAUD and MICHAEL SALTSMAN EMPLOYMENT POLICIES INSTITUTE 5 INTRODUCTION: A CASE FOR CAUTION MICHAEL SALTSMAN EMPLOYMENT POLICIES INSTITUTE In his 2013 State of the Union, President Obama These consequences shouldn’t come as a surprise, called for a 25 percent increase in the federal minimum given the lack of precedent for a minimum wage as high wage, to $9 an hour. Five years later, the Democratic as $15 an hour. The first federal minimum in 1938 was Party promised a minimum wage increase of more than $0.25 an hour, or $4.20 in 2015 dollars. It began primarily 100 percent, to $15 an hour. as a skilled minimum wage, applied to industries such as This radical evolution in what constitutes an mining, manufacturing and transportation. As it expanded acceptable minimum wage can be credited to the to include jobs in the service industry, the minimum Service Employees International Union (SEIU), which wage in effect became a wage floor for unskilled labor. starting in 2012 invested more than $100 million to Adjusted for inflation, the federal minimum wage has normalize the concept of a $15 minimum wage.
    [Show full text]
  • ALT-Labor, Secondary Boycotts, and Toward a Labor Organization Bargain
    University of Wyoming College of Law Law Archive of Wyoming Scholarship Faculty Articles UW College of Law Faculty Scholarship 2-12-2014 ALT-Labor, Secondary Boycotts, and Toward a Labor Organization Bargain Michael C. Duff University of Wyoming College of Law, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.uwyo.edu/faculty_articles Recommended Citation Duff, Michael C., "ALT-Labor, Secondary Boycotts, and Toward a Labor Organization Bargain" (2014). Faculty Articles. 68. https://scholarship.law.uwyo.edu/faculty_articles/68 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the UW College of Law Faculty Scholarship at Law Archive of Wyoming Scholarship. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Articles by an authorized administrator of Law Archive of Wyoming Scholarship. ALT-LABOR, SECONDARY BOYCOTTS, AND TOWARD A LABOR ORGANIZATION BARGAIN Michael C. Duff INTRODUCTION In recent times, low wage non-union workers have staged noteworthy protests and job actions against alleged inferior working conditions. Protests against Walmart, strikes against fast food restaurants, and immigration rallies by unauthorized workers offer ready examples. In these protests and job actions various non-union labor advocacy groups, sometimes collectively denoted as “ALT-Labor,” have often led the involved workers.1 This article addresses legal problems that might arise from ALT-Labor coordination2: when one ALT-Labor group protests on behalf of or assists another such group.3 Imagine, for example, a situation in which Professor of Law, University of Wyoming College of Law. B.A. 1991, West Chester University of Pennsylvania; J.D. 1995, Harvard Law School.
    [Show full text]
  • The Impact of Teacher Collective Bargaining Laws on Student Achievement: Evidence from a New Mexico Natural Experiment Abstract
    Doc1 benjamin A. lindy The Impact of Teacher Collective Bargaining Laws on Student Achievement: Evidence from a New Mexico Natural Experiment abstract. This Note uses the 1999 sunset and 2003 reauthorization of New Mexico’s public employee collective bargaining law to estimate the causal effect of teacher collective bargaining on student achievement. This Note finds that mandatory teacher bargaining laws increase the performance of high-achieving students while simultaneously lowering the performance of poorly achieving students. After establishing this core empirical result, the Note explores its implications for current trends in American education policy and for normative arguments about the role of teachers’ unions in public schools. author. Yale Law School, J.D. 2010; Yale College, B.A. 2003. Many thanks to Ian Ayres, John Donohue, Christine Jolls, Jens Ludwig, Barbara Schone, and Chris Griffin for research guidance and excellent teaching; to Paige Elisha, Jonathan Justl, and my family for support and encouragement; to Kenneth Jamison for help preparing this Note for publication; and to my former students and colleagues for a topic that matters. 1130 the impact of teacher collective bargaining note contents introduction 1132 i. teacher collective bargaining laws 1136 ii. the nonempirical literature on teacher bargaining 1139 A. The “Teachers’ Unions Are Terrible” Arguments 1140 B. The “Teachers’ Unions Are Vital” Arguments 1143 iii. the empirical literature on teacher bargaining 1144 A. Cross-Sectional Comparisons and Endogeneity Problems 1144 B. Panel Data and Instrumental Variable Approaches 1147 iv. new mexico’s natural experiment 1149 A. Natural Experiment Studies 1151 B. Data 1152 C. Econometric Models 1158 D.
    [Show full text]
  • Enabling Employee Choice: a Structural Approach to the Rules of Union Organizing
    ENABLING EMPLOYEE CHOICE: A STRUCTURAL APPROACH TO THE RULES OF UNION ORGANIZING Benjamin I. Sachs TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 656 II. UNION ORGANIZING UNDER THREE LEGAL REGIMES ............................................ 664 A. The Current NLRA Procedure ........................................................................................ 664 B. Rapid Elections ................................................................................................................. 667 C. Card Check ......................................................................................................................... 668 III. LABOR LAW’S ALTERING RULE ....................................................................................... 672 A. Default and Altering Rules .............................................................................................. 672 1. Preference-Eliciting Default Theory ......................................................................... 673 2. Reversible Default Theory ......................................................................................... 677 B. Default and Altering Rules To Maximize Employee Choice ....................................... 680 1. Impediments to Unionization: Collective Action Problems and Direct Managerial Intervention ......................................................................... 680 2. Managerial Intervention and Employee Free
    [Show full text]
  • 3 Bargaining Units Settle Contracts at Portland Schools by DON Mcintosh Some Portland Business Leaders
    See Inside MEETING NOTICES Page 6 Volume 107 Number 13 July 7, 2006 Portland 3 bargaining units settle contracts at Portland Schools By DON McINTOSH some Portland business leaders. The Associate Editor three voting against the contract were Oregon’s largest school district ap- Dan Ryan, Sonja Henning, and Board pears to be backing away from open co-chair Bobbi Regan. For Ryan and warfare with its unions. Henning to take that stance surprised Portland Public Schools (PPS) has PAT President Ann Nice, given that different management this year than it PAT had backed them in the 2005 had during earlier rounds of contract election. talks, and seems to have adopted a less The district’s 210 cafeteria workers, hard-line stance. Still, the district’s represented by Service Employees Lo- three contract settlements in June look cal 503, also ratified a new contract in less like declarations of love than tem- June. The contract sets up a two-tier porary truces between adversaries. benefit system: Newly-hired part-time The district’s 47,000 students are workers, if any, will get no health ben- taught by 3,800 teachers, who are rep- efits, while current part-timers get pro- resented by the Portland Association rated benefits as before. of Teachers, an affiliate of the Oregon “It was rammed down our throats,” Education Association. Their new con- SEIU negotiator Lane Toensmeier said tract basically keeps the status quo for of the two-tier benefits proposal. the next two years. Ratified June 14, it “Loss of part timers’ health insurance gives them two 2.5 percent cost-of-liv- is huge, and our members know that.” ing raises.
    [Show full text]
  • One Person, One Vote, One Time? Re-Election Votes Hold Unions Accountable to Their Members by James Sherk
    Policy Report - September 5, 2016 One Person, One Vote, One Time? Re-election Votes Hold Unions Accountable to Their Members By James Sherk Executive Summary Unions exercise considerable power in the workplace. As the sole collective bargaining representative for a unionized workforce, unions negotiate wages, benefits, and working conditions. Yet the vast majority of union members had no say in selecting their union representatives. As a general rule, unions do not periodically stand for re-election. After being certified they remain workers’ representatives indefinitely. Most major Ohio unions have represented the same workplaces for decades. The Columbus Education Association, for example, has bargained for Columbus Public School teachers since 1968. Virtually all of the teachers currently in the district have been hired since then. They – like most Ohio union members – inherited union representation that a previous generation of employees once thought was a good idea. In theory, unionized workers can vote to decertify an unwanted union. In practice, however, navigating the decertification process is difficult. The Ohio State Employment Relations Board received just 14 validly submitted decertification petitions in the past three years. Very few Ohio unions face electoral accountability to the workers they represent. Consequently, unions do not have to cultivate workers’ support to remain their representatives. Polling shows considerable dissatisfaction among union members with the quality of their union representation. Almost three-quarters of union members say they want their unions held more accountable to the rank-and-file, and 82 percent of union members support holding union votes where members can maintain or replace their union. The Ohio General Assembly has little authority over private sector unions under federal law, but it can provide for a greater degree of accountability for state and local government unions by requiring them to periodically stand for re-election and give workers voting rights.
    [Show full text]