DOCSLIB.ORG

Max Stirner: Hanging out with One’S Own

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Max Stirner: Hanging out with One’S Own CHAPTER EIGHT MAX STIRNER: HANGING OUT WITH ONE’S OWN The ideas of Max Stirner (1806–1856), which derive almost completely from his principal work, The Ego and Its Own (1844), have been compared with those of Nietzsche, existentialism, and anarchism, and were criti- cized in the author’s time by thinkers of no less stature than Feuerbach and Marx. In this chapter, it is suggested that perhaps the discussion might more fruitfully focus on less metaphysical issues than those which have preoccupied many of the interpreters of Stirner, and rather treat the value of his writings today as being, in accordance with the goal of the present volume, to provide some inspiration for contemporary political concerns. This would appear to be how Benjamin Tucker, the subject of Chapter One, saw Stirner’s work, and, as was noted there, the influence of Stirner upon Tucker was considerable: it caused Tucker to reorient his own philosophy. Stirner’s real name was Johann Caspar (or Kaspar) Schmidt. Eltzbacher (1958), Martin ([1962] 2005), and Schiereck (1981) spell his middle name with a “K.” Basch (1904), Carroll (1974b), Carus (1914), Mackay ([1898] 1914a), Paterson (1971), and Welsh (2010) prefer a “C.” As a boy, he had a long forehead, the size of which tended to be embellished by his hairstyle, causing some of his classmates to coin the nickname, “Stirner”; “Stirn” means “forehead” in German. Stirner, who was not offended by this appel- lation eventually came to accept it as his name, and that is how he is almost always known today (Dematteis 1976, 55; Mackay [1898] 1914a, 85; Paterson 1971, 3; Welsh 2010, 6). Carroll (1974b, 18) comments that “with his individualist fancy tickled and his romantic ambitions stirred by the allusion to the stars (… Gestirn = star), the plebeian name of Schmidt was abandoned.” Stirner was born in Bayreuth in Bavaria, where his family had lived for several generations, in a house located in the center of town, on October 25, 1806. He went on to study at the universities of Erlangen and Königsberg, as well as Berlin, where Hegel was a professor, and Feuerbach was another student, and it is likely that both Stirner and Feuerbach attended Hegel’s classes on religion and philosophy at the University of Berlin during 1827. Although Stirner and Feuerbach also attended the PG3298 PG3298 208 chapter eight University of Erlangen at the same time, in the fall of 1828, it does not appear that they ever met. From 1839 to 1844, Stirner enjoyed a successful teaching career, employed at a private girls’ school called the “Institute for the Instruction and Cultivation of Superior Girls,” which was managed by a Madame Gropius. Stirner’s first marriage was brief, spanning just 1837–1838, as his wife, Agnes Clara Kunigunde Burtz, soon died in childbirth (Basch 1904, 2; Carroll 1974b, 19; Carus 1914, 54, 55; Dematteis 1976, 9, 57; Paterson 1971, 6; Stepelevich 1974, 326, 1978, 451–452, 1985, 602–603; Welsh 2010, 8). Stirner was one of Die Freien (which has been translated variously as “the Free,” “the Free Men,” and “the Free Ones”), a group of Young Hegelians that included Friedrich Engels – who thought Stirner to be the most talented among his cohorts – which met at Hippel’s Weinstube, a restaurant in Berlin (Carus 1914, 55; Mackay [1898] 1914a, 57–59; Martin [1962] 2005, ix; Paterson 1971, 7–8; Stepelevich 1985, 602). A spin-off from the earlier Doctors’ Club, to which Marx had belonged and at whose meet- ings he had been temporarily influenced by the discussions, Die Freien was an assemblage known for its partying prowess as well as for its continua- tion of intellectual position-taking. Hippel’s appears to be where Stirner met his second wife, Marie Wilhelmine Dähnhardt, the daughter of a druggist who possessed a significant financial nest egg; she smoked cigars, and had come to the big city to escape the social limitations of small town life, reveling in the bawdy atmosphere, sometimes dressing as a man, even accompanying some of the men when they visited a brothel (Carroll 1974b, 21; Carus 1914, 57; Dematteis 1976, 57; Mackay [1898] 1914a, 115; McLellan 1980, 50, 52, 91; Paterson 1971, 9; Welsh 2010, 10). Max and Marie were married on October 21, 1843 in a mocking, avant- garde quasi-religious ceremony. The wedding rings, obtained at the last minute, were copper fasteners purloined from fellow Young Hegelian Bruno Bauer’s purse. The relationship lasted three years, until Marie’s money was lost in an enterprise designed to sell milk, much of which the couple were unable to dispose of. Dähnhardt moved to England and became a teacher before emigrating to Melbourne, Australia, and eventu- ally returning to London where as an old lady she would respond in writing to some questions sent to her by the German poet, John Henry Mackay; she characterized Stirner as self-absorbed and “sly,” saying that she had never loved him (Basch 1904, 5–6; Carroll 1974b, 22–24; Carus 1914, 55, 57; Mackay [1898] 1914a, 12, 117; Paterson 1971, 10). Not much is known about Stirner’s life after he published his book and responded to its inevitable critics; he worked as a translator, and spent two short periods in jail for debt, before dying following an insect bite in 1856 (Carus 1914, 58; Eltzbacher 1958, 62). PG3298 PG3298.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Anarchists: a Picture of Civilization at the Close of the Nineteenth Century
    John Henry Mackay The Anarchists: A Picture of Civilization at the Close of the Nineteenth Century 1891 The Anarchist Library Contents Translator’s Preface ......................... 3 Introduction.............................. 4 1 In the Heart of the World-Metropolis .............. 6 2 The Eleventh Hour.......................... 21 3 The Unemployed ........................... 35 4 Carrard Auban ............................ 51 5 The Champions of Liberty ..................... 65 6 The Empire of Hunger........................ 87 “Revenge! Revenge! Workingmen, to arms! . 112 “Your Brothers.” ...........................112 7 The Propaganda of Communism..................127 8 Trafalgar Square ...........................143 9 Anarchy.................................153 Appendix................................164 2 Translator’s Preface A large share of whatever of merit this translation may possess is due to Miss Sarah E. Holmes, who kindly gave me her assistance, which I wish to grate- fully acknowledge here. My thanks are also due to Mr. Tucker for valuable suggestions. G. S. 3 Introduction The work of art must speak for the artist who created it; the labor of the thoughtful student who stands back of it permits him to say what impelled him to give his thought voice. The subject of the work just finished requires me to accompany it with a few words. *** First of all, this: Let him who does not know me and who would, perhaps, in the following pages, look for such sensational disclosures as we see in those mendacious speculations upon the gullibility of the public from which the latter derives its sole knowledge of the Anarchistic movement, not take the trouble to read beyond the first page. In no other field of social life does there exist to-day a more lamentable confusion, a more naïve superficiality, a more portentous ignorance than in that of Anarchism.
    [Show full text]
  • X Max Stirner
    X MAX STIRNER In 1888 John Henry Mackay, the Scottish-German poet, while at the British Museum reading Lange's History of Materialism, encoimtered the name of Max Stirner and a brief criticism of his forgotten book, Der Einzige und sein Eigenthum (The Only One and His Property; in French translated L'Unique et sa Propri^te, and in the first English translation more aptly and euphoniously entitled The Ego and His Own). His curiosity excited, Mackay, who is an anarchist, procured after some difficulty a copy of the work, and so greatly was he stirred that for ten years he gave himself up to the study of Stimer and his teachings, and after incredible painstaking published in 1898 the story of his life. (Max Stimer: Sein Leben und sein Werk: John Henry Mackay.) To Mackay's labours we owe all we know of a man who was as absolutely swallowed up by the years as if he had never existed. But some advanced spirits had read Stirner's book, the most revolutionary ever written, and had felt its influence. Let us name two: Henrik Ibsen and Frederick Nietzsche. Though the name of Stirner is not quoted by Nietzsche, he nevertheless recommended Stirner to a favourite pupil of his, Professor Baumgartner at Basel University. This was in 1874. One hot August afternoon in the year 1896 at Bayreuth, I was standing in the Marktplatz when a member of the Wagner Theatre pointed out to me a house opposite, at the corner of the Maximilianstrasse, and said: "Do you see that house with the double gables? A man was born there whose name will be green when Jean Paul and Richard Wagner are forgotten." It was too large a draught upon my credulity, so I asked the name.
    [Show full text]
  • Music Manuscripts and Books Checklist
    THE MORGAN LIBRARY & MUSEUM MASTERWORKS FROM THE MORGAN: MUSIC MANUSCRIPTS AND BOOKS The Morgan Library & Museum’s collection of autograph music manuscripts is unequaled in diversity and quality in this country. The Morgan’s most recent collection, it is founded on two major gifts: the collection of Mary Flagler Cary in 1968 and that of Dannie and Hettie Heineman in 1977. The manuscripts are strongest in music of the eighteenth, nineteenth, and early twentieth centuries. Also, the Morgan has recently agreed to purchase the James Fuld collection, by all accounts the finest private collection of printed music in the world. The collection comprises thousands of first editions of works— American and European, classical, popular, and folk—from the eighteenth century to the present. The composers represented in this exhibition range from Johann Sebastian Bach to John Cage. The manuscripts were chosen to show the diversity and depth of the Morgan’s music collection, with a special emphasis on several genres: opera, orchestral music and concerti, chamber music, keyboard music, and songs and choral music. Recordings of selected works can be heard at music listening stations. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756–1791) Der Schauspieldirektor, K. 486. Autograph manuscript of the full score (1786). Cary 331. The Mary Flagler Cary Music Collection. Mozart composed this delightful one-act Singspiel—a German opera with spoken dialogue—for a royal evening of entertainment presented by Emperor Joseph II at Schönbrunn, the royal summer residence just outside Vienna. It took the composer a little over two weeks to complete Der Schauspieldirektor (The Impresario). The slender plot concerns an impresario’s frustrated attempts to assemble the cast for an opera.
    [Show full text]
  • Rescuing the Individual from Neoliberalism: Education, Anarchism, and Subjectivity
    Georgia State University ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University Educational Policy Studies Dissertations Department of Educational Policy Studies Spring 5-11-2018 Rescuing the Individual from Neoliberalism: Education, Anarchism, and Subjectivity Gabriel Keehn Georgia State University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/eps_diss Recommended Citation Keehn, Gabriel, "Rescuing the Individual from Neoliberalism: Education, Anarchism, and Subjectivity." Dissertation, Georgia State University, 2018. https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/eps_diss/178 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of Educational Policy Studies at ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Educational Policy Studies Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. ACCEPTANCE This dissertation, RESCUING THE INDIVIDUAL FROM NEOLIBERALISM: EDUCATION, ANARCHISM, AND SUBJECTIVITY, by GABRIEL T. KEEHN, was prepared under the direction of the candidate’s Dissertation Advisory Committee. It is accepted by the committee members in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree, Doctor of Philosophy, in the College of Education and Human Development, Georgia State University. The Dissertation Advisory Committee and the student’s Department Chairperson, as representatives of the faculty certify that this dissertation has met all standards of excellence and scholarship as determined by the faculty. __________________________ Deron Boyles, Ph.D. Committee Chair __________________________ __________________________ Kristen Buras, Ph.D. Chara Bohan, Ph.D. Committee Member Committee Member __________________________ __________________________ Judith Suissa, Ph.D. Michael Bruner, Ph.D. Committee Member Committee Member __________________________ Date __________________________ William Curlette, Ph.D. Chair, Department of Educational Policy Studies __________________________ Paul A.
    [Show full text]
  • Anarchist of Love
    Hubert Kennedy Anarchist of Love The Secret Life of John Henry Mackay Revised and Expanded Edition Peremptory Publications San Francisco 2002 © 1996 by Hubert Kennedy This 2002 edition is a revised and greatly expanded version of Anarchist of Love: The Secret Life of John Henry Mackay (New York: Mackay Society, 1983). It was published by the North American Man/Boy Love Association, New York, in 1996 (and appeared simultaneously as NAMBLA Topics #3). A revised German edition, translated by Almuth Carstens, was published as Anarchist der Liebe: John Henry Mackay als Sagitta (Berlin: Jochen Knoblauch Verlag, 1988). This ebook edition differs from the 1996 edition in format and illustrations. It may be freely distributed, but no changes may be made in it. The caricature on the title page is by Bruno Paul (1874–1968). In: Martin Möbius [pseudonym of Otto Julius Bierbaum], Steckbriefe erlassen hinter dreißig literari- schen Uebelthätern gemeingefährlicher Natur, Berlin: Verlag Schuster & Löffler, 1900, p. 98. 2 3 1 “I was SAGITTA” I am the arrow that springs from the string, Whirring through the night of time I ring— To all healing, here courage, there comfort, bring: If healing, not death—“Your health!” I sing. I am SAGITTA! —Know: the arrow am I Which cures or kills . Stay!—or—away fly! On 6 October 1909, after nineteen months of legal proceedings, the power of the German state moved to crush the first deliberate and self-aware campaign in modern times to gain public understanding of man-boy love. In spite of having one of the best defense lawyers in Germany, and in spite of expert witnesses of the first rank (including M.
    [Show full text]
  • Hubert Kennedy Reading John Henry Mackay
    Hubert Kennedy Reading John Henry Mackay Selected Essays Peremptory Publications San Francisco 2002 1 © 2002 by Hubert Kennedy Reading John Henry Mackay: Selected Essays is a Peremptory Publications ebook. It may be freely distributed, but no changes may be made in it. The caricature on the title page is by Bruno Paul (1874–1968). In: Martin Möbius [pseu- donym of Otto Julius Bierbaum], Steckbriefe erlassen hinter dreißig literarischen Ue- belthätern gemeingefährlicher Natur (Berlin: Verlag Schuster & Löffler, 1900), p. 98. Comments and suggestions are welcome. Please write to [email protected]. 2 Contents Introduction 4 Knabenliebe in den Schriften des Anarchisten John Henry Mackay 9 Boy-love in the Writings of the Anarchist John Henry Mackay 15 No Good Deed Goes Unpunished: John Henry Mackay’s Helene 23 Hiding in the Open: John Henry Mackay’s “A Farewell” 31 Twilight of the Gods: John Henry Mackay’s Der Unschuldige 46 Götterdämmerung: John Henry Mackays Der Unschuldige 71 Anarchist Angst: John Henry Mackay’s “The Adoption” 95 John Henry Mackay, ein Berliner Original 105 John Henry Mackay’s The Anarchists 127 John Henry Mackays Der Schwimmer: Reaktionen auf einen Roman 138 3 Introduction Since 1981 I have published a number of articles about the German writer John Henry Mackay and have translated several of his works. Here is a selection of those arti- cles. The first article I wrote, a biographical sketch of Mackay, “Anarchist of Love,” pub- lished in Alternate, a gay magazine in San Francisco, is not included here; it has been ex- panded several times and will appear as a separate ebook.
    [Show full text]
  • Drawing First Blood
    Library.Anarhija.Net Drawing First Blood Meme, Myself and I 2011 I have no ancestors! For me the creation of the world dates from the day of my birth; for me the end of the world will be accomplished on the day when I shall re- store to the elementary mass the apparatus and the af- flatus which constitute my individuality. I am thefirst man, I shall be the last. My history is the complete re- sult of humanity; I know no other, I care to know no other. When I suffer, what good do I get from another’s enjoyment? When I enjoy, in what do those who suf- Meme, Myself and I fer detract from my pleasures? Of what consequence to Drawing First Blood me is that which happened before me? How am I con- 2011 cerned in what will happen after me? It is not for me to serve as a sacrifice to respect for extinct generations, Retrieved on January 19, 2018 from writerror.com. or as an example to posterity. I confine myself within Meme, Myself and I. ”Drawing First Blood”. In Enemies of Society: the circle of my existence, and the only problem that I An Anthology of Individualist & Egoist Thought. Ardent Press. 2011. have to solve is that of my welfare. I have but one doc- trine, that doctrine has but one formula, that formula lib.anarhija.net has but one word: ENJOY! Sincere is he who confesses it; an imposter is he who denies it. This is bare individualism, native egoism; I do notdeny sibly can, relying on their own psychic resources and experienc- it, I confess it, I verify it, I boast of it.
    [Show full text]
  • Benjamin Tucker and His Periodical, Liberty
    Jaurnolo/Li&~~wionStudla, Vol. I.No.4, pp. 301-318. Pn8amon Prnr 1977. Printdin Grcal Britain BENJAMIN TUCKER AND HIS PERIODICAL, LIBERTY CARL WATNER Baltimore, Maryland In a letter to the New York Tribune on Avrich, Liberty was simply "the best Anarchist December 4, 1898, Benjamin Tucker (1854- paper in the English language". 1939) described himself as an Anarchist. "I was The 403 issues of Liberty which appeared the first American - I may say the first have been reprinted and made available by the Anglo-Saxon - to start (in 1881) an avowedly Greenwood Reprint Corporation. They are a Anarchistic newspaper printed in the English great source of information both to the historian language. I am still the editor, publisher, and and the philosopher. Here we can analyze the proprietor of that paper. It is everywhere history of the individualist Anarchist move- regarded as the pioneer and principal organ of ment, its reaction to contemporary events of the modern individualist Anarchism. I either am, or late 19th and early 20th Centuries, as well as have been, the publisher of the chief Anarchistic view the actual ideological content and doctrinal works in the English language. I am the author changes occurring in the movement. To study of the most widely-accepted English text-book Liberfy is to touch practically every social of Anarchism. I have enjoyed the friendship, question. (132-5) " . Liberty carried had the benefit of the instruction, and. have translations and articles from many of the most carefully studied the works, of those Americans seminal thinkers of both Europe and from whom the Anarchists have largely derived America."[z' While its subscription list probably their beliefs - Josiah Warren, Stephen Pearl never exceeded 1000, it had a world-wide Andrews, Lysander Spooner, and Colonel circulation and impact, considering that it William B.
    [Show full text]
  • John Henry Mackay Summing Up
    John Henry Mackay Summing Up Marginal Notes to Life and Work Edited and Translated by Hubert Kennedy Peremptory Publications San Francisco 2002 © 2002 by Hubert Kennedy Summing Up: Marginal Notes to Life and Work is a Peremptory Publications ebook. It may be freely distributed, but no changes may be made in it. Summing Up: Marginal Notes to Life and Work and Dear Tucker: The Letters and Postcards of John Henry Mackay to Benjamin R. Tucker have been combined in a print edition, which may be obtained from: Xlibris Corporation 1-888-7-XLIBRIS www.Xlibris.com [email protected] NB. The print edition is not identical with this ebook. For example, the illustrations included here are not in the print edition. Please send any comments and suggestions to: [email protected]. 2 3 Contents Preface 5 Summing Up 7 References 126 4 Preface In his last published book Summing Up: Marginal Notes to Life and Work (Abrechnung: Randbemerkungen zu Leben und Arbeit; 1932), the Scotch-German John Henry Mackay (1864–1933) claimed that it was neither an autobiography nor memoirs. Nevertheless it is the closest to either that he wrote, so that I included it along with Dear Tucker: The Letters from John Henry Mackay to Benjamin R. Tucker in a print edition in 2000 under the general title Autobiographical Writings. After referring to the book as “marginal notes,” Mackay added: “If they appear to you to be a confused mix—well, just order them otherwise; put them together as it pleases you.” With this permission, I have taken the liberty of adding numerous annotations, all of which are in a different print font and inside brackets [thus].
    [Show full text]
  • K.H.Z. Solneman John Henry Mackay
    K.H.Z. SOLNEMAN JOHN HENRY MACK AY - THE UNIQUE UnionOfEgoists.com K. H. Z. Solneman JOHN HENRY MACKAY- THE UNIQUE UnionOfEgoists.com . 1978 « © MACKAY-GESELLSCHAFT , Freiburg/Br. Druckerei Sonnenschein , Lauf ISBN 3-921388-25-2 UnionOfEgoists.com : JOHN HENRY MAC KAY - THE UNIQUE "A thousand days come and go: Sometimes someone comes to you and me and awakens us. But to so many others no-one comes in many thousands of days Boldly interrupting the course of their lives. I cannot make you other than you are But I can awaken you From the dulness of your heart and mind. That is my triumph!" JOHN HENRY MACKAY It was not only in the sense in which Stimer used the expression that his rediscoverer was unique, but John Henry Mackay was unique in three respects - as a Poet, in his prose as well as in his verse; as a Thinker, especially as a social critic; and, above all, as a Personality. "Because 1 want what others do not want, I see what only few can", he said in one of his poems. And . "I want to live in Freedom!", I said. Then, with a strength which was greater Than that of my youth, 1 drove myself a path through the gossiping crowd. Friends left my side, As blossom flies before the storm . My gaze was set on the far distance, They watched me go, doubting. The strong wings of my purpose Bore me through the night towards the dawn; When, finally, they brought me to my goal I looked around in the silence and found 1 stood alone.
    [Show full text]
  • Benjamin Tucker, Liberty, and Individualist Anarchism
    SUBSCRIBE NOW AND RECEIVE CRISIS AND LEVIATHAN* FREE! “The Independent Review does not accept “The Independent Review is pronouncements of government officials nor the excellent.” conventional wisdom at face value.” —GARY BECKER, Noble Laureate —JOHN R. MACARTHUR, Publisher, Harper’s in Economic Sciences Subscribe to The Independent Review and receive a free book of your choice* such as the 25th Anniversary Edition of Crisis and Leviathan: Critical Episodes in the Growth of American Government, by Founding Editor Robert Higgs. This quarterly journal, guided by co-editors Christopher J. Coyne, and Michael C. Munger, and Robert M. Whaples offers leading-edge insights on today’s most critical issues in economics, healthcare, education, law, history, political science, philosophy, and sociology. Thought-provoking and educational, The Independent Review is blazing the way toward informed debate! Student? Educator? Journalist? Business or civic leader? Engaged citizen? This journal is for YOU! *Order today for more FREE book options Perfect for students or anyone on the go! The Independent Review is available on mobile devices or tablets: iOS devices, Amazon Kindle Fire, or Android through Magzter. INDEPENDENT INSTITUTE, 100 SWAN WAY, OAKLAND, CA 94621 • 800-927-8733 • [email protected] PROMO CODE IRA1703 Benjamin Tucker, Liberty, and Individualist Anarchism —————— ✦ —————— WENDY MCELROY iberty, Equality, Fraternity, these three; but the greatest of these is Lib- erty. Formerly the price of Liberty was eternal vigilance, but now it can be had for fifty cents a year.” So wrote Benjamin Ricketson Tucker “L 1 (1854–1939) on the first page of the first issue of Liberty. The American periodical Liberty,2 edited and published by Tucker from August 1881 to April 1908, is widely considered to be the finest individualist-anarchist peri- odical ever published in the English language.
    [Show full text]
  • John Henry Mackay Dear Tucker
    John Henry Mackay Dear Tucker The Letters from John Henry Mackay to Benjamin R. Tucker Edited and Translated by Hubert Kennedy Peremptory Publications San Francisco 2002 © 2002 by Hubert Kennedy Dear Tucker: The Letters from John Henry Mackay to Benjamin R. Tucker is a Peremp- tory Publications ebook. It may be freely distributed, but no changes may be made in it. Summing Up: Marginal Notes to Life and Work and Dear Tucker: The Letters and Post- cards of John Henry Mackay to Benjamin R. Tucker have been combined in a print edi- tion under the title John Henry Mackay: Autobiographical Writings (2000), which may be obtained from: Xlibris Corporation 1-888-7-XLIBRIS www.Xlibris.com [email protected] NB. The print edition is not identical with this ebook. For example, the illustrations in- cluded here are not in the print edition. Please send any comments and suggestions to: [email protected]. 2 3 Contents Introduction 5 List of letters and postcards 11 The letters from John Henry Mackay to Benjamin R. Tucker 17 “John Henry Mackay” by Hermann Bahr 279 Index of Names 284 4 Introduction The nearly 200 letters and postcards from John Henry Mackay to Benjamin R. Tucker, which are preserved in the New York Public Library, demonstrate the depth and extent of the friendship between the foremost representatives of individualist anarchism in Germany and the United States, respectively. They clearly show the warmth and devo- tion felt by Mackay toward Tucker; alas, the letters from Tucker to Mackay were all de- stroyed1 so that Tucker’s feelings cannot be directly seen, but Mackay’s letters furnish ample evidence of their mutual regard.
    [Show full text]