Search, Characterization, and Properties of Brown Dwarfs
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Central Florida STARS Electronic Theses and Dissertations, 2004-2019 2009 Search, Characterization, And Properties Of Brown Dwarfs Ramarao Tata University of Central Florida Part of the Physics Commons Find similar works at: https://stars.library.ucf.edu/etd University of Central Florida Libraries http://library.ucf.edu This Doctoral Dissertation (Open Access) is brought to you for free and open access by STARS. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations, 2004-2019 by an authorized administrator of STARS. For more information, please contact [email protected]. STARS Citation Tata, Ramarao, "Search, Characterization, And Properties Of Brown Dwarfs" (2009). Electronic Theses and Dissertations, 2004-2019. 3944. https://stars.library.ucf.edu/etd/3944 Search, Characterization, and Properties of Brown Dwarfs by Ramarao Tata M.S. University of Central Florida, 2005 B.Tech. Sri Venkateshwara University, 2002 A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Physics in the College of Sciences at the University of Central Florida Orlando, Florida Fall Term 2009 Major Professor: Eduardo L. Mart´ın ABSTRACT Brown dwarfs (BD) were mere theoretical astrophysical objects for more than three decades (Kumar (1962)) till their first observational detection in 1995 (Rebolo et al. (1995), Nakajima et al. (1995)). These objects are intermediate in mass between stars and planets. Since their observational discovery these objects have been studied thoroughly and holisti- cally. Various methods for searching and characterizing these objects in different regions of the sky have been put forward and tested with great success. Theoretical models describing their physical, atmospheric and chemical processes and properties have been proposed and have been validated with a large number of observational results. The work presented in this dissertation is a compilation of synoptic studies of ultracool dwarfs(UDs)1. A search for wide binaries around solar type stars in upper scorpio OB association • (Upper Sco) do indicate (the survey is not yet complete) a deficit of BD binaries at these large separations (< 5AU). Twenty six new UDs were discovered at low galactic latitudes in our survey from • archival data and a novel technique using reduced proper motion. 1 We use the term “ultracool dwarfs” as the mass of most of the objects mentioned is unknown, which is required to classify an object as a brown dwarf. We define objects later than M7 as ultra cool dwarfs iii Six field UDs were discovered by spectroscopic follow-up of the candidates selected • from a deep survey. Optical interferometry was used to independently determine the orbit of the compan- • ion of HD33636 which was initially determined using Hubble Space Telescope(HST) astrometry and radial velocity found. Some inconsistency in the HST determined orbit and mass. Optical linear polarization in UDs was used to investigate the dust properties in their • atmospheres. A trend in polarization as predicted by theoretical models was validated, and atmospheric dust grain sizes and projected rotational velocities for these objects were estimated Comprehensive studies of UDs are proving to be crucial not only in our understanding of UDs but also for star and planet formation as brown dwarfs represent their lower and upper mass boundaries, respectively. iv To my beloved wife, Nicole Tata, for her support and motivation. v Acknowledgments I would like to acknowledge the support of all my collaborators in each of the projects. 1. Chapter2: Jerome Guilet and Rohit Deshpande have contributed in this project with data reduction and analysis. 2. Chapter3: CTIO facility was utilized for some of the observations. NOAO travel funding is also appreciated. This project was a collaborative effort led by Phan-Bao Ngoc. 3. Chapter4: I thank the VLTI staff for granting us the opportunity to test our new idea. Carla Gil and Eder Martioli’s collaboration is acknowledged. 4. Chapter5: I thank the WHT staff for making these observations possible. This project is a collaboration between, Eduardo Martin, Sujan Sengupta, Maria Rosa Zapatero, Phan-Bao Ngoc, and Herve Buoy and was led by me. I also acknowledge the extensive use of publicly available astronomy resources such as NOAO-IRAF, Simbad, Vizier, Aladin and STARALT. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES . viii LIST OF TABLES . ix CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION . 1 CHAPTER 2 A SEARCH FOR BROWN DWARF COMPANIONS OF SOLAR- TYPE STARS IN UPPER SCO . 6 2.1 BACKGROUND . 6 2.2 METHOD . 7 2.3 RESULTS . 19 CHAPTER 3 DISCOVERY OF NEW NEARBY L AND LATE-M DWARFS AT LOW GALACTIC LATITUDE FROM THE DENIS DATABASE . 27 3.1 BACKGROUND . 27 3.2 METHOD . 28 3.3 RESULTS . 39 vii CHAPTER 4 USING VLTI OPTICAL INTERFEROMETRY TO VERIFY HST-ASTROMETRY DERIVED MASS AND ORBITAL PARAMETERS OF THE COMPANION OF HD33636 . 47 4.1 BACKGROUND . 47 4.2 METHOD . 49 4.3 RESULTS . 55 CHAPTER 5 OPTICAL LINEAR POLARIZATION IN ULTRA COOL DWARFS: A TOOL TO PROBE DUST IN ULTRA COOL DWARF ATMOSPHERES 64 5.1 BACKGROUND . 64 5.2 METHOD . 65 5.3 RESULTS . 75 CHAPTER 6 DISCUSSION . 82 LIST OF REFERENCES 87 viii LIST OF FIGURES 2.1 Reduced and stacked I band image of one of the sources V1121Oph . 9 2.2 Reduced and stacked H band image of one of the sources V1121Oph . 10 2.3 DENIS catalog magnitude vs I band instrumental magnitude for sources in the field of view of one of the targets . 11 2.4 2MASS catalog magnitude vs H band instrumental magnitude for sources in the field of view of one of the targets . 12 2.5 I band magnitude distribution of all the sources in the area of interest (1.5 arcmin box) around all of the targets . 13 2.6 H band magnitude distribution of all the sources in the area of interest (1.5 arcmin box) around all of the targets . 14 2.7 Separation distribution of all the sources in the area of interest (1.5 arcmin box) around all of the targets . 15 2.8 Initial selection Color-Magnitude Diagram . 16 2.9 Optical spectra of Upper Sco BD candidates . 21 2.10 Color-Magnitude Diagram of our candidates and current status of the project 23 ix 2.11 Color-Magnitude diagrams showing all the candidates . 25 2.12 Color-Magnitude diagrams showing all the candidates . 26 3.1 (MJ , I - J) color-magnitude diagram for late-M and L dwarfs with known trigonometric parallaxes . 29 3.2 (I - J, J - K) color-color diagram for our 29 late-M and L dwarf candidates . 31 3.3 I-band reduced proper motions versus I - J . 38 3.4 Spectra of the 26 M8-L5.5 ultracool dwarfs are plotted by increasing spectral type . 41 3.5 Number of ultracool dwarfs per 2.5 pc spectrophotometric distance bin over 4,800 square degrees . 45 4.1 A schematic representation of a 2-element interferometer. 51 4.2 AMBER data reduction work flow . 53 4.3 One of the averaged frame of HD33636 . 54 4.4 Squared visibility vs wavelength plot . 58 4.5 Flux vs wavelength plot . 59 4.6 Closure phase vs wavelength plot . 60 4.7 Model fit for the visibility measurements . 61 4.8 Apparent orbit of HD33636 and its companion. 62 x 4.9 Angular separation vs Orbital inclination . 63 5.1 Reduced data frame . 67 5.2 Best model fit of the observed data . 77 5.3 Spectral energy distribution of 2MASS J17312974+2721233 . 78 xi LIST OF TABLES 2.1 Ultracool dwarf candidates . 17 2.1 Ultracool dwarf candidates . 18 2.1 Ultracool dwarf candidates . 19 3.1 DENIS ultracool dwarf candidates . 33 3.1 DENIS ultracool dwarf candidates . 34 3.2 DENIS ultracool dwarf candidates measured proper motions . 35 3.2 DENIS ultracool dwarf candidates measured proper motions . 36 3.3 26 nearby L, and late-M dwarfs . 42 3.3 26 nearby L, and late-M dwarfs . 44 5.1 Target list . 74 5.2 Polarization measurements . 76 5.3 Model fit . 79 5.4 IRAC photometry of 2MASS J17312974+2721233 . 79 xii CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION Brown dwarfs are sub-stellar objects with masses less than what is required to maintain hydrogen nuclear fusion in their cores. There is still some debate on how to differentiate Brown dwarfs from massive planets.The most commonly used mass range for brown dwarfs is between 13M 78M , which represents the deuterium burning limit and the hydrogen J − J burning limit, respectively. Brown dwarfs’ mere existence from theory (Kumar (1962)) to their discovery took more than three decades. In the last fifteen years a lot of progress has been made in our under- standing of these objects. Ultra cool dwarfs (later than spectral type M7) search criteria could vary on parameters such as age, distance, metallicity etc., but most of the common methods involve multi-color imaging surveys. Once a UD candidate is identified based on multi-color imaging (color-color and/or color-magnitude diagrams), its temperature or mass needs to be estimated. It turns out that in most cases the temperature estimation is rela- tively easy to make based on the spectral types. Two new spectral types, the L type and the T type, were proposed (Mart´ın et al. (1999) & Kirkpatrick et al. (1999)) after the discovery of the first brown dwarfs. The L type is defined in the red optical region by strengthening metal hydride bands (FeH, MgH, CrH, CaH), prominent alkali lines (K I - 7655/7699A˚, Rb 1 I - 7800/7948A˚, Cs I - 8521/8943A˚), and weakening metal-oxide bands (VO, TiO). The T dwarfs are characterized by the presence of methane bands, weakening metal hydrides, and broad alkali metal absorption features.