The Figure of Mary in Italian Opera Theological Foundations and Technical Analysis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INTERNATIONAL MARIAN RESEARCH INSTITUTE UNIVERSITY OF DAYTON, OHIO In affiliation with the PONTIFICAL THEOLOGICAL FACULTY MARIANUM ROME ITALY By: Richard Eugene Lenar The Figure of Mary in Italian Opera Theological Foundations and Technical Analysis A Thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Licentiate of Sacred Theology with specialization in Marian Studies Director: Father Thomas Thompson Marian Library/International Marian Research Institute University of Dayton 300 College Park Dayton, OH 45469-1390 2018 Vidimus et approbamus: Thomas A. Thompson, S.M., Ph.D. – Director Johann G. Roten, S.M., S.T.D. – Revisore 1 Daytonesis (USA), ex aedibus International Marian Research Institute, et Romae, ex aedibus Pontificiae Facultatis Theologicae Marianum, die 4 Ianuarii 2019. 2 Table of Contents Chapter 1: Background and Methodological Considerations ........................................................ 5 Introduction: The Presence of Mary in Italian Opera ................................................................. 5 The Importance of Popular Marian Devotion ............................................................................. 5 The Experience of Listening to Music ........................................................................................ 8 The Connection between Music and Theology - Music as a Language.................................... 10 The Connection between Music and Theology through Divine Revelation ............................. 13 Summary of Chapter 1 .............................................................................................................. 14 Chapter 2: The Title “Aiuto dei Cristiani” as an Expression of Italian Popular Devotion .......... 15 The Historical Development of the Marian Presence in Italian Opera ..................................... 15 Don Bosco as an Exemplar of Italian Marian Devotion .......................................................... 19 Don Bosco’s Place in the Historical Development of the Title Aiuto dei Cristiani.................. 21 Conclusion of Chapter 2 - Essential Characteristics of Don Bosco’s Formulation of the Title Aiuto dei Cristiani with Excerpts from his Writings................................................................. 24 Chapter 3: The Marian Operatic Presence during the 19th Century ............................................ 29 Terminology Associated with Marian Operatic References ..................................................... 29 Analysis of Operas with Marian References ............................................................................. 30 Verdi: I Lombardi alla prima crociata ..................................................................................... 30 Ricci: La Festa di Piedigrotta ................................................................................................... 34 Verdi: La Forza del Destino ..................................................................................................... 36 Boito: Mefistofele ...................................................................................................................... 38 Ponchielli: La Gioconda........................................................................................................... 41 Verdi: Otello .............................................................................................................................. 44 Summary of Chapter 3 .............................................................................................................. 47 Chapter 4: The Marian Operatic Presence during the Verismo Period ........................................ 48 Mascagni: Cavalleria Rusticana ............................................................................................... 48 Leoncavallo: Pagliacci .............................................................................................................. 49 Puccini: La Bohème ................................................................................................................... 51 Puccini: Tosca ........................................................................................................................... 52 Wolf-Ferrari: I Gioielli della Madonna ................................................................................... 54 Giacomo Puccini: Suor Angelica .............................................................................................. 61 Summary of Chapter 4 .............................................................................................................. 65 Chapter 5: Reflections and Conclusions ...................................................................................... 66 3 The Place of Music in Theological Method .............................................................................. 66 Correlation of Operatic Content with Mary as Aiuto dei Cristiani ........................................... 66 The Depiction of Marian Devotion: Praxis ............................................................................... 67 Theological Accuracy ............................................................................................................... 69 Exemplary Value ....................................................................................................................... 70 Summary ................................................................................................................................... 72 Bibliography ................................................................................................................................. 73 4 Chapter 1: Background and Methodological Considerations Introduction: The Presence of Mary in Italian Opera Although the Blessed Virgin Mary is not ordinarily associated with operas, these works contain numerous and varied references to her. Italian operas written during the last half of the 19th century and the first decades of the 20th provide the richest and most extensive examples of this Marian operatic presence. The presentation of Marian content by librettists in operatic narratives is deeply influenced by the practices of piety which were prevalent in the devotional praxis of the common Italian people. The primary dramatic reason that operas have Marian content is characters turn to her for help. The Marian presence in opera results from cultural and artistic considerations. The deeply Catholic aspects of 19th century Italian culture influenced daily life and conversation. Mary was frequently invoked as la Madonna (“the Lady”). Operas would naturally include Catholic images and language which refer to the la Madonna in diverse ways. The combination of music, text and visual arts can produce Marian content under each aspect: the music may be a setting of a Marian prayer or antiphon, the libretto may refer to Mary, or the scenery may contain Marian imagery or iconography. In a few cases, Mary is even a member of the opera’s cast. To examine this Marian operatic content, the present study will consider the music, text and stagecraft of Italian operas from a perspective that is cognizant of both the theological and the devotional. For this purpose, a series of operatic examples have been taken from famous operas as well as from lesser-known works. The timeframe encompasses the years 1840 to 1920, because in this period Italian operatic works exhibit the most extensive Marian content. The year 1890 will serve as an important milepost, since a shift to the so-called Verismo style occurred at that time. The Marian presence in opera has not been a common topic for scholarly research. The only extended study is Maria in der Musik by Gero Vehlow.1 This text is impressive for a comprehensive scope, which embraces all types of art music since the medieval period. Vehlow’s work is primarily musicological and does not treat theological issues at length. The present study will differ from Vehlow’s by considering the specifically theological significance of operatic episodes in which Marian devotion is portrayed or a character invokes Mary’s intercession and assistance. This study is organized in the following manner. Chapter 1 examines popular Marian devotion as well as the experience of listening to music and then develops theoretical considerations regarding the connection between music and theological method. Chapter 2 first provides a summary of the historical context of 19th century Italian opera. St. Don Bosco’s understanding of the Marian title “Aiuto dei Cristiani/Help of Christians” is then developed as a representative, but not exclusive, example of popular Italian Marian devotion. Chapter 3 will examine a series of Italian operas up to the year 1890. Chapter 4 will commence with the onset of the Verismo style and then examine operas until about 1920. Chapter 5 will provide a concluding synthesis by identifying and summarizing important theological and devotional themes. The Importance of Popular Marian Devotion 1 Gero Vehlow, Maria in der Musik (Köln: Verlag Christoph Dohr, 2007). 5 An important element of the Marian operatic presence is the depiction of popular devotion. In the present study, popular Marian devotion will be understood exclusively in terms of certain practices of piety associated with Mary. These practices include common Marian prayers, such as the Ave Maria, Salve Regina, and the rosary; the use of Marian images and statues; Marian processions; Marian figures of speech in daily conversation; and, most importantly,