“Peace on Earth”? Catholic Moralities of Warfare and Their Shifts After 1945
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Interdisciplinary Journal for Religion and Transformation (2018), Heft 6, doi.org/10.14220/jrat.2018.4.issue-1 HowtoBring About “Peace on Earth”? Catholic Moralities of Warfare and Their Shifts after 1945 DanielGerster Thepaper explores how and why Catholic thinking and teachingabout war changed during the second half of the 20th century. To do so,Iwill examinethe ways in whichthe two world wars and the atomic bomb shaped the Catholic perception of modern warfare, outline how declarations of the Roman Catholic Church shifted the official Catholic position, and examine the impact of those changes with regard to West Germany and the United States.Iconclude that, while the fundaments of Catholic moralitiesofwarfare, such as the just war concept,remained unchangedeven after 1945, there were essential shifts in what can be said and whatcan be doneabout war and peace.These shifts exceeded general Catholic ambiguity on the topic,which had existed for many centuries. Thepaper will discuss how these shifts were linked to other fundamental developments of recent decades,such as the globalisation of the Catholic Church, the pluralisation of the religious field,and the individualisation of life style in Western countries. Catholics,Roman Catholic Church,peace, war, modernwarfare,atomic bomb, peace movement, world war, Second Vatican Council, (West) Germany,USA, contemporary history Daniel Gerster is Research Assistant (Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter) at the Center for Religion and Modernity (CRM)atthe Westfälische Wilhelms-University Münster (WWU). He holds aPhD in history and studied in Mainz, Berlin, Warsaw,and Florence. RecentPublications:GodsOwn Gender?Masculinities in World Religions (co-edited, Würzburg 2018, forthcoming); Religionspolitik heute.Problemfelderund Perspektiven in Deutschland (co-edited, Freiburg im Breisgau 2018);Ordnungen religiöser Pluralität. Wirklichkeit Wahrnehmung Gestaltung (co-edited, FrankfurtamMain /New York À À 2016);Friedensdialoge im Kalten Krieg.Eine Geschichte der Katholiken in der Bun- desrepublik, 1957–1983 (FrankfurtamMain/NewYork 2012). Introduction When Pope Francis addressed an international conference held at the Vatican in April 2016 to reevaluate the Roman Catholic teaching on just war,hestrongly encouraged the participantsto“strengthen the role of active non-violence in the face of aggression or conflict”1.The papal plea seems to speak to awide-spread 1JoshuaJ.McElwee,“Francis Encourages Vatican Just WarConference to Re- 164 Open-Access-Publikation im Sinne der CC-Lizenz BY-NC-ND 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) Downloaded from Brill.com09/28/2021 06:23:53PM via free access Interdisciplinary Journal for Religion and Transformation (2018), Heft 6, doi.org/10.14220/jrat.2018.4.issue-1 How to Bring About “Peace on Earth”? impression that the Roman Catholic Church is one of the major international supporters of peace and non-violence,apparently exploiting acentury-old, gen- uine Christianmessageofpeace keeping and human rights.When we look back in history,however, it becomes apparentthat Christianity in general, in particular the RomanCatholic Church, has not alwaysbeen as peaceful and peace-loving as it seemstobetoday,orasmany of the gospelspassagesmight suggestitwas.2 To come to this conclusion, one does not need to take examples from the Middle Ages,such as the crusadesagainst Muslims or thefight against heretics.Itis sufficient to cast abrief glance at the last century:itbegan withthe war of 1914 to 1918 –inwhich millions lost their lives –that enjoyedbroad support even among Christians.3 Evenafter the devastating experienceofthe Second World War, the Catholic Church did not immediatelyturn into the internationalsupporter of peace and non-violence as which it is perceived today.What then,wemight ask, has happened in the decades after the 1950s which brought on majorshifts in what we can call Catholic moralitiesofwarfare? In this article,Iwill explore how and why Catholic thinking and teachingabout war changed during the second half of the 20th century.Todoso, Iwill first examine the ways in whichthe two world wars and the atomic bombshape the Catholic perception of modern warfare, first resultinginCatholicgrassroots movements for peace,and then leading to major shifts in Catholic debates more broadly (1.).Iwill then outline how declarations of the RomanCatholic Church such as John XXIIIsencyclical letter Pacem in Terris (1963) and the Second Vatican Councilsapostolic constitution Gaudium et Spes (1965) shifted the of- ficial Catholic positioning by adoptingnew perceptions of war and peace (2.).In the third section, Iwill look at West Germany and the United States and examine the impact that changes in official Catholicteaching had on discussions of war and peace during the 1970s and 1980s.Iwill especially emphasise the remaining im- portance of national political culture as wellasthe growing influence of the media (3.). In my concluding remarks (4.), Iwill elaborate my claim that, while the fundaments of Catholic moralitiesofwarfare,such as the just war concept, remained unchangedeven after 1945, there were essential shifts in what can be vitalize Tools of Non-Violence”, in:National Catholic Reporter, 12th April 2016, avail- able at:https://www.ncronline.org/blogs/ncr-today/francis-encourages-vatican-just-war- conference-revitalize-tools-non-violence [12.06. 2017]. 2Cf. e. g. ArnoldAngenendt, Toleranzund Gewalt. Das Christentum zwischen Bibel und Schwert, Münster 2007 and Andreas Holzem (ed.), Krieg und Christentum. Religiöse Gewalttheorien in der Kriegserfahrung des Westens,Paderborn 2009. 3Cf. e. g. Martin Greschat, Der Erste Weltkrieg und die Christenheit. Ein globaler Überblick,Stuttgart 2014;Michael Fischer, Religion,Nation, Krieg. Der Lutherchoral Ein feste Burg ist unserGott zwischenBefreiungskriegen und ErstemWeltkrieg, Münster /New York 2014;Martin Lätzel, Die Katholische Kirche im ErstenWeltkrieg. Zwischen Nationalismus und Friedenswillen, Regensburg 2014. 165 Open-Access-Publikation im Sinne der CC-Lizenz BY-NC-ND 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) Downloaded from Brill.com09/28/2021 06:23:53PM via free access Interdisciplinary Journal for Religion and Transformation (2018), Heft 6, doi.org/10.14220/jrat.2018.4.issue-1 Daniel Gerster said and what can be done about war and peace.4 These shifts exceeded general Catholic ambiguity on the topic, which had existed for many centuries.ThusIwill also discuss how the shifts in Catholic moralities of warfare were linked to other fundamental developments of recent decades,such as the globalisation of the Catholic Church, the pluralisation of the religious field, and the individualisation of life style in Western countries. Yet, before we start examining in what way Catholic moralitiesofwarfare changed in the decades immediately after the Second World War, we have to clarify who and what exactlyweare talking about. Speaking of the the Roman Catholic Church tempts us to ignore the multiple levels and actorswithinit. Franz-XaverKaufmannonce distinguished four mainsociological phenomena: the church of clergymen (Klerikerkirche), the Catholic milieu, Catholic (sub-)culture,and political Catholicism.5 Based on his model, Iwill focuson leadingactors of the Catholic milieu like the Zentralkomitee der deutschen Ka- tholiken (ZdK), the umbrella organisation for the various lay groups in Germany, and organisations relatedtothe topic, such as the peace group Pax Christi.6 In addition, Iwill examine the church hierarchy and its key figures such as bishops, the pope in Rome, and the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965).7 Thechurch hierarchysglobalnature makesatransnational perspectiveinevitable so that, when necessary,Iwill also look at Catholic communities of other countries such as the United States and their discussions on moralitiesofwarfare.8 But what do we mean by Catholic moralities of warfare?Asoutlined by the editors in their introduction, analysing moralities of warfare involves first and foremost the “reconstruction of the formation, fixation and also the disintegration 4Cf. Willibald Steinmetz, Das Sagbare und das Machbare. Zum Wandel politischer Handlungsspielräume.England 1780–1867, Stuttgart 1993. 5Franz-Xaver Kaufmann, “Zur Einführung:Problemeund Wege einer historischen Einschätzung des II. VatikanischenKonzils”, in:ibid. /Arnold Zingerle (eds), Vatikanum II und Modernisierung. Historische,theologische und soziologische Perspektiven, Pa- derborn 1996, 9–34, 16. 6Onthe general development of the Catholic milieu in Germany,see KarlGabriel, “Die Katholiken in den 50er Jahren:Restauration, Modernisierung und beginnende Auflösung eines konfessionellen Milieus”, in:Axel Schildt /Arnold Sywottek (eds), Modernisierung im Wiederaufbau. Die westdeutsche Gesellschaft der 50er Jahre,Bonn 1998, 418–430 and ibid.,“Zwischen Aufbruch und Absturz in die Moderne.Die Ka- tholische Kirche in den 60er Jahren”, in:Axel Schildt et al (eds), Dynamische Zeiten. Die 60er Jahre in den beiden deutschen Gesellschaften 2000, 528–543. 7Cf. e. g. John Pollard, The Papacy in the Age of Totalitarism, 1914–1958,Oxford 2014. 8For acomparison, see AntoniusLiedhegener, Macht, Moral und Mehrheiten. Der politische Katholizismusinder Bundesrepublik Deutschland und den USA seit 1960, Baden-Baden 2006, esp.39–44. 166 Open-Access-Publikation im Sinne der CC-Lizenz BY-NC-ND 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) Downloaded from Brill.com09/28/2021 06:23:53PM via free access Interdisciplinary Journal for Religion and