NSA Petition 8.2.13
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
August 2, 2013 General Keith B. Alexander Director, National Security Agency 9800 Savage Road Fort Meade, MD 20755 Secretary Chuck Hagel Department of Defense 1400 Defense Pentagon Washington, DC 20301 Re: Petition for NSA to Conduct a Public Rulemaking on its Monitoring and Collection of Communications Traffic within the United States Dear General Alexander and Secretary Hagel: The undersigned individuals and organizations, concerned about the rule of law and the protection of Constitutional freedoms, hereby petition the National Security Agency to conduct a public rulemaking on the agency's monitoring and collection of communications traffic within the United States. 5 U.S.C. § 553(e). We believe that the NSA’s collection of domestic communications contravenes the First and Fourth Amendments to the United States Constitution, and violates several federal privacy laws, including the Privacy Act of 1974, and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 as amended. The NSA’s collection of solely domestic communications, which has been acknowledged by the President, the Director of National Intelligence, and the Chair and Ranking Member of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, also constitutes a legislative rule that “substantively affects the public to a degree sufficient to implicate the policy interests animating notice-and- comment rulemaking” under the Administrative Procedure Act. EPIC v. DHS, 653 F.3d 1, 6 (D.C. Cir. 2011). Accordingly, the NSA's collection of domestic communications, absent the opportunity for public comment, is unlawful. We hereby petition the National Security Agency, a component of the Department of Defense, for relief. We ask the NSA to immediately suspend collection of solely domestic communications pending the completion of a public rulemaking as required by law. We intend to renew our request each week until we receive your response. Sincerely, Marc Rotenberg Dr. Alessandro Acquisti James Bamford Grayson Barber Professor Ann Bartow EPIC Petition 1 August 2, 2013 to National Security Agency NSA Surveillance of Domestic Communications Professor Colin Bennett Professor Christine Borgman Professor Julie E. Cohen Dr. Danah Boyd Simon Davies Dr. Whitfield Diffie Dr. Cynthia Dwork Professor David Farber Addison Fischer Professor David Flaherty Professor Michael Froomkin Professor Urs Gasser Deborah Hurley Professor Jerry Kang Sheila Kaplan Professor Ian Kerr Rebecca MacKinnon Mary Minow Dr. Pablo Molina Dr. Peter G. Neumann Professor Helen Nissenbaum Ray Ozzie Deborah C. Peel, MD Chip Pitts Professor Anita Ramasastry Professor Ronald Rivest Professor Pam Samuelson Bruce Schneier Dr. Barbara Simons Edward G. Viltz EPIC Petition 2 August 2, 2013 to National Security Agency NSA Surveillance of Domestic Communications Tom Abate - San Leandro, CA Christopher Ammerman - Hales Corners, zed abbadi - ashburn, VA WI Linda Abbott - New York, NY Anne Anderson - Acton, MA Yusuf Abdi - Alexandria, VA Axel Anderson - wausau , WI Luther Abel - Alameda, CA Ben Anderson - Marion, IA Lorii Abella - Chicago, IL Brandon Anderson - Falls church, VA Peter Abeln - Saint Louis, MO Dave Anderson - Waltham, MA James Able - San Rafael, CA David Anderson - Belmont, MA Roger Abrams - Franklinton, NC Geoffrey Anderson - Bordentown, NJ Carl Adams - Albany, CA Lee Anderson - Livermore, CA Chris Adams - Oklahoma City, OK Matt Anderson - Boston, MA Douglas Adams - Mountain View, CA Michael Anderson - Nevada City, CA Jonathan Adams - San Francisco, CA Patricia Anderson - Anchorage, AK Thomas Adams - Boise, ID Peter Anderson - New York, NY Eric Aderhold - Seattle, WA Ted Anderson - Austin, TX Sam Agnew - Anchorage, AK Valerie Anderson - Vancouver, WA Norman C Ahlquist - Seattle, WA William Anderson - Rohnert Park, CA marina ahmed - sheffield, William Anderson - Glendale, CA Thomas Aiken - New York, NY Dimitrios Andrakakis - New York, NY Patrick Ainge - New York, NY Lloyd Andrew - Arnold, MD Robert Aitken - San Jose, CA Alan Andrews - Kemah, TX Mykhailo Aizatskyi - Santa Clara, CA Carl Angoli - Ashburn, VA Jeff Akerlund - Richmond, CA Emily Anicich - San Francisco, CA Frankie Albin - Utica, NY Jason Anicich - Florence, AZ isaac alcala - gilbert, AZ Anon Annanon - Baltimore, Raven Alder - Seattle, WA Jacob Ansari - Racine, WI Michael Alderete - San Francisco, CA James Anthony - San Francisco, CA Jacqueline Aldridge - Concord, CA Lyle Antieau - Grosse Ile, MI David Alexander - Baltimore, MD Mark Antonson - Lincoln, NE Mark Alexander - Fredericksburg, VA Lauren Araya - Memphis, TN Jerry Alexandratos - Frederick, MD sebastian araya - memphis, TN Sean Alexandre - Durham, NC Joseph Arceneaux - San Francisco, CA Eric Aley - Jackson, WY Etienne Ardant - new York, NY Levi Aliposa - Chicago, IL Daniel Arendt - Albany, OR Joseph Allard - Portland, OR Jason Armstrong - Meze, Charles Allen - Buckeye Lake, OH Michael Arrow - Brentwood, CA David Allen - Los Angeles, Luis Arruda - Wrentham, MA Gregory Allen - Olympia, WA Matthew Arthur - Collinsville, IL John Allen - Madison, WI John Arwe - Poughkeepsie, NY Kathryn Allen - Madison, WI Richard Ashford - Round Rock, TX randall allen - los angeles, CA Scott Askew - San Francisco, CA Terry Allen - Pittsburg, KS Michael Askren - Polk City, IA John Allison - Niceville, FL Michael Atkinson - Mundelein, IL Joseph Allred - Arlington, TX Miles Atkinson - Seneca, SC Evan Allrich - Hiawatha, IA Rebecca Atkinson - Mundelein, IL Kris Alman - Portland, OR Matthew Atwood - Brooklyn, NY Shfaheen Alnuaimi - Calpine, CA Pat Augustine - Uhland, TX Jeremy Amaismeier - State College, PA Philip Auld - Hudson, MA Kiyoshi Aman - Tulsa, OK Mat Auricchio - Scotia, NY Theresa Amato - Oak Park, IL Kevin Austin - Minneapolis, MN Thomas Auzinger - Hillsborough, NJ EPIC Petition 3 August 2, 2013 to National Security Agency NSA Surveillance of Domestic Communications Jeffrey Avallone - Carlisle, PA Mike Bauer - North Hollywood, Jonathan Avery - New York, NY Julia Baumberg - Ottawa Ontario, CA Kelly Avery - Fort Collins, CO Nancy Baumeister - Corvallis, OR Ibrahim Ayoub - Sierra Vista, AZ Dan Baxter - Atoka, TN Gary Baalman - San Jose, CA David Baxter - Acton, MA Laura Baalman - San Jose, CA Joseph Bayly - Indianapolis, IN Meagan Baalman - broomfield, CO Sarita Beach - Raleigh, NC David Baasch - Portland, OR Todd Beal - Blissfield, MI Karen Babich - Madison, WI Sun-Li Beatteay - Seattle, WA Peter Bachman - Swarthmore, PA Mike Beaty - Mannington, WV Derrick Bacon - Lynn Haven, FL Todd Beaver - Davidson, NC Maksym Badrak - Brookline, MA Michael Bechard - Cordova, TN L. Bagley - Albuquerque, NM Dan Becker - Seattle, WA Barbara Bahr - Belleville, IL Douglas Becker - Holland, MI Luigi Bai - Houston, TX Kenneth Becker - Metuchen, NJ Craig Bailey - Columbia, MO Russ Beckham - Newton, KS Jeff Bailey - Sylmar, CA Mel Beckman - Oxnard, CA Alan Baker - San Jose, CA Thomas Beckmann - North Platte, NE Chris Baker - Peachtree , GA Kim Beckner - Land O Lakes, FL Christopher Baker - Mobile, AL Robert F. Bedel - Pittsburgh, PA Eric Baker - Orem, UT Matt Beelman - Sacranento, CA Paschall Baker - Richmond, VA Simon Behr - Medford, MA Jeffrey Bales - Tucson, AZ Caleb Bell - Myrtle Beach, SC Mr.Dannert A. Balfanz - Victoria, TX eric bell - seattle, WA Charles Ball - Cape Coral, FL Michael Bell - Tacoma, WA Jonathan Bame - Fayetteville, AR Jason Bellew - Charlotte, NC John Bane - Bowie, MD Frank Bellino - Glendale, CA John R Bane - Bowie, MD Ron Bellisario - NULL, NULL tee bane - fdsd, AK Bill Bellomy - Fort Worth, TX Robert Banfich - Durham,, NC Steve Belongie - Sheboygan, WI Mark Bannan - Owosso, MI Lyndon Belt - Eufaula, OK Daryl Banttari - Burnsville, MN Dr. Benjamin Belton - Fort Myers, FL Ricardo Barahona - Stratford, CT David Benfell - Sebastopol, CA RG Bargy - Phoenixville, PA John Benjamin - Paducah, KY David Barnes - Warwick, RI Alfred Bennard - portland, OR Mike Barnes - Gates, OR Christopher Bennett - Villas, NJ Phil Barnett - Apopka, FL Gabriel Bennett - Central Point, OR Lyle Barrere - Orinda, CA Benjamin Berendes - Cashton, WI Jonathan Barrett - Bethesda, MD Dirk Bergemann - Berlin, HI Michael Barrett - Red Bank, NJ James Bergstrom - Chicago, IL Leslie Barron - sandown, NH M Berk - Mountain View, CA David Barrow - Tavernier, FL Jason Berlinsky - Morristown, NJ Brandon Barry - Arlington, MA Douglas Bernal - Silver Spring, MD Duncan Barth - Eugene, OR James Bernard - Richmond, VA Will Barton - Red Hook, NY Eric Berry - Cedar Rapids, IA Stephen Bash - Waltham, MA Kathy Berry - Lancaster, CA David Basri - Matthews, NC Jean-Denis Bertron - Castle Rock, CO Steven Bass - Sharon, MA Burton Betchart - Rochester, NY Alan Batie - Corvallis, OR Adam Bettencourt - New York, NY Forrest Batson - San Diego, CA Bradley Beyenhof - San Diego, CA Philip Baudoin - New York, NY Rakesh Bharania - San Jose, CA EPIC Petition 4 August 2, 2013 to National Security Agency NSA Surveillance of Domestic Communications Nathan Bidwell - Germantown, MD David Borgendale - Montpelier, VT Helene Biernacki - Chicago, IL Jack Borninski - Wilmer, TX Carr Biggerstaff - Newberg, OR Laura Borst - Houston, TX William Billingsley - Seattle, WA William Bortko - Streetman, TX Roiberd Billson - Westfield, NJ TOM Bosserman - Miami Beach, FL Roger Bingham - Tucson, AZ Jonah Bossewitch - New York City, NY Nathan Binkert - Redwood City, CA Robin Bostwick - Akron, OH Gary Binner - McLean, VA David Boswell - Georgetown, TX Steve Birchall - Monona, WI Jason Boudi - Franklin, IN Edward Bishop - San Diego, CA Michael Bourgon - Ft. Worth, TX John Bishop - White Plains, NY Diane E Boush